Exhibit 4 Page 1 of 8

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Exhibit 4 Page 1 of 8"

Meredith Hood
5 years ago
Views:

Page 1 of 8 Price Analysis Summary Bid #C2113975C1, Construction of Davie Road Extension Agency: Highway Construction and Engineering Division Bid Submittals: 4 Purchasing Agent: Cara M. Leisy, J.D. Declinations: 0 HCED/Engineer's Cost Estimate General Asphalt Co Inc Weekley Asphalt Paving Inc.

1 Page 1 of 8 Price Analysis Summary Bid #C C1, Construction of Davie Road Extension Agency: Highway Construction and Engineering Division Bid Submittals: 4 Purchasing Agent: Cara M. Leisy, J.D. Declinations: 0 HCED/Engineer's Cost Estimate General Asphalt Co Inc Weekley Asphalt Paving Inc. JVA Engineering Contractor Inc. Community Asphalt Corp % Difference Comparison Recommended Bid vs. Engineer's Estimate 1 (B/A) Group # Group Description Total Price Price Price Price Price 1 General Construction Operations $ 715, $ 617, $ 528, $ 909, $ 1,419, % 2 Roadway $ 2,581, $ 2,320, $ 2,609, $ 2,762, $ 3,101, % 3 Signing and Pavement Marking $ 201, $ 185, $ 206, $ 213, $ 202, % 4 Signalization $ 137, $ 138, $ 124, $ 137, $ 149, % 5 Landscaping $ 330, $ 452, $ 343, $ 368, $ 388, % 6 Payment and Performance Bond $ 30, $ 20, $ 45, $ 61, $ 37, % 7 Insurance $ 8, $ 5, $ 3, $ 15, $ 10, % Total* $ 4,005, $ 3,738, $ 3,860, $ 4,467, $ 5,309, % Note: The lowest bid received was compared against the engineer's cost estimate that uses the overall area costs based on historical industry prices for similar items of work being performed. Fluctuations in costs between the average costs and the bid costs may be present due to availability of materials and labor forces, market demand, economic activity, and overall bidding preferences of the contractor. * Bid Totals listed above do not include the $25,000 bid allowance for permit fees.

2 Page 2 of 8 Lot: General Construction Operations C C FDOT PAY Mobilization 1 lump sum $ 290, $ 290, $ 100, $ 100, $ 90, $ 90, $ 390, $ 390, $ 486, $ 486, C C FDOT PAY Maintenance of Traffic 1 lump sum $ 330, $ 330, $ 446, $ 446, $ 395, $ 395, $ 410, $ 410, $ 832, $ 832, C C FDOT PAY SEDIMENT BARRIER linear foot $ 2.35 $ 31, $ 1.71 $ 22, $ 1.00 $ 13, $ 2.00 $ 26, $ 1.63 $ 21, C C FDOT PAY INLET PROTECTION SYSTEM 5 each $ $ 1, $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ 9, C C FDOT PAY LITTER REMOVAL acre $ $ 5, $ 1.00 $ $ 1.00 $ $ $ 11, $ $ 9, C C FDOT PAY MOWING acre $ $ 3, $ 1.00 $ $ 1.00 $ $ $ 14, $ $ 12, C C FDOT PAY INSPECTION & SETTLEMENT MONITORING 1 lump sum $ 6, $ 6, $ 9, $ 9, $ 11, $ 11, $ 15, $ 15, $ 2, $ 2, C C FDOT PAY FIELD OFFICE 900 SQUARE FEET 270 day $ $ 43, $ $ 36, $ $ 15, $ $ 32, $ $ 42, lump sum $ 3, $ 3, $ 2, $ 2, $ 2, $ 2, $ 8, $ 8, $ 2, $ 2, C C FDOT PAY Audio Visual Pre Construction and Post Construction Records Total $715, $617, $528, $909, $1,419,405.71

3 Page 3 of 8 Lot: Roadway C C FDOT PAY CLEARING & GRUBBING acre $ 16, $ 180, $ 10, $ 116, $ 26, $ 283, $ 19, $ 203, $ 14, $ 160, C C FDOT PAY REGULAR EXCAVATION 7230 cubic yard $ 8.49 $ 61, $ 5.50 $ 39, $ $ 132, $ $ 86, $ $ 99, C C FDOT PAY EMBANKMENT 727 cubic yard $ $ 10, $ 4.40 $ 3, $ $ 9, $ $ 23, $ $ 16, C C FDOT PAY TYPE B STABILIZATION 9297 square yard $ 5.60 $ 52, $ 3.80 $ 35, $ 3.45 $ 32, $ 3.50 $ 32, $ 6.22 $ 57, C C FDOT PAY OPTIONAL BASE BASE GROUP 09 (B 12.5 ONLY) 8819 square yard $ $ 325, $ $ 361, $ $ 326, $ $ 370, $ $ 943, C C FDOT PAY TURNOUT CONSTRUCTION ASPHALT 714 ton $ $ 143, $ $ 107, $ $ 121, $ $ 97, $ $ 97, C C FDOT PAY MILLING EXIST ASPH PAVT 1 inch AVG DEPTH square yard $ 2.95 $ 92, $ 2.00 $ 62, $ 2.25 $ 70, $ 2.40 $ 75, $ 2.54 $ 79, C C FDOT PAY SUPERPAVE ASPHALTIC CONC TRAFFIC C 8322 ton $ $ 846, $ $ 790, $ $ 912, $ $ 957, $ $ 822, C C FDOT PAY ASPHALT CONCRETE FRICTION COURSETRAFFIC C FC 9.5 PG 76 to 2986 ton $ $ 407, $ $ 358, $ $ 375, $ $ 406, $ $ 402, C C FDOT PAY MANHOLE ADJUST 1 each $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ 1, $ $ C C FDOT PAY INLETS DT BOT TYPE C PARTIAL 1 each $ 6, $ 6, $ 5, $ 5, $ 1, $ 1, $ 2, $ 2, $ 4, $ 4, C C FDOT PAY MANHOLES P to 8 PARTIAL 1 each $ 4, $ 4, $ 5, $ 5, $ 2, $ 2, $ 5, $ 5, $ 6, $ 6, C C FDOT PAY DESILTING PIPE 0 to 24 inch 338 linear foot $ $ 3, $ 6.60 $ 2, $ 8.25 $ 2, $ $ 6, $ $ 3, C C FDOT PAY PIPE CULVERT OPTIONAL MATERIAL ROUND 12 inch SD 45 linear foot $ $ 6, $ $ 4, $ $ 3, $ $ 4, $ $ 7, C C FDOT PAY CONCRETE CURB & GUTTER TYPE F 1303 linear foot $ $ 40, $ $ 36, $ $ 30, $ $ 44, $ $ 55, C C FDOT PAY CONCRETE SIDEWALK AND DRIVEWAYS 6 inch THICK 4241 square yard $ $ 221, $ $ 256, $ $ 179, $ $ 176, $ $ 181, C C FDOT PAY BUS SHELTER PAD REINFORCED CONCRETE 22 square yard $ $ 2, $ $ 1, $ $ 3, $ $ 2, $ $ 9, C C FDOT PAY DETECTABLE WARNINGS 961 square foot $ $ 34, $ $ 29, $ $ 24, $ $ 27, $ $ 45, C C FDOT PAY GUARDRAIL REMOVAL 93 linear foot $ 3.70 $ $ $ 2, $ 5.00 $ $ 4.00 $ $ $ 1, C C FDOT PAY PERFORMANCE TURF SOD PASPALUM NOTATUM BAHIA GRASS square yard $ 4.09 $ 135, $ 3.00 $ 99, $ 2.87 $ 95, $ 7.00 $ 232, $ 3.08 $ 102, C C FDOT PAY BUS SHELTER RELOCATE 1 each $ 2, $ 2, $ 1, $ 1, $ $ $ 3, $ 3, $ $ C C FDOT PAY BICYCLE RACK RELOCATE 1 each $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 2, $ 2, each $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ 1, C C FDOT PAY TRASH RECEPTACLE RELOCATE Total $2,581, $2,320, $2,609, $2,762, $3,101,719.01

4 Page 4 of 8 Lot: Signing and Pavement Marking C C FDOT PAY PATTERNED PAVEMENT GREEN BIKE LANE square yard $ $ 77, $ $ 81, $ $ 72, $ $ 78, $ $ 82, C C FDOT PAY CONDUIT FURNISH & INSTALL OPEN TRENCH 20 linear foot $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY PULL & SPLICE BOX RELOCATE 2 each $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ 1, $ 3, $ 1, $ 3, C C FDOT PAY ALUMINUM SIGNALS POLE RELOCATE 2 each $ $ 1, $ 1, $ 2, $ 1, $ 2, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, C C FDOT PAY SINGLE POST SIGN (F&I) LESS THAN 12 SF 37 assembly $ $ 17, $ $ 13, $ $ 25, $ $ 25, $ $ 16, C C FDOT PAY SINGLE POST SIGN (F&I) 12 to 20 SF 15 assembly $ 1, $ 19, $ 1, $ 17, $ $ 14, $ $ 14, $ $ 9, C C FDOT PAY SINGLE POST SIGN RELOCATE 23 assembly $ $ 3, $ $ 7, $ $ 9, $ $ 9, $ $ 3, C C FDOT PAY SINGLE POST SIGN REMOVE 36 assembly $ $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 3, C C FDOT PAY RETRO REFLECTIVE PAVEMENT MARKER 587 each $ 4.70 $ 2, $ 3.30 $ 1, $ 3.50 $ 2, $ 4.00 $ 2, $ 3.49 $ 2, C C FDOT PAY PAINTED PAVEMENT MARKINGS FINAL SURFACE 1 lump sum $ 22, $ 22, $ 10, $ 10, $ 15, $ 15, $ 15, $ 15, $ 14, $ 14, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE SOLID 12 inch 606 linear foot $ 2.69 $ 1, $ 2.20 $ 1, $ 1.30 $ $ 1.50 $ $ 1.43 $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE SOLID 18 inch 110 linear foot $ 3.53 $ $ 2.75 $ $ 2.00 $ $ 2.00 $ $ 2.31 $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE SOLID 24 inch 661 linear foot $ 4.82 $ 3, $ 3.50 $ 2, $ 3.00 $ 1, $ 3.00 $ 1, $ 3.15 $ 2, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE 2 to 4 DOTTED GUIDELINE/ 6 to gross mile $ 2, $ 2, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE MESSAGE 3 each $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. WHITE ARROW 43 each $ $ 4, $ $ 2, $ $ 3, $ $ 3, $ $ 3, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. YELLOW SOLID 18 inch 491 linear foot $ 3.36 $ 1, $ 2.75 $ 1, $ 2.00 $ $ 2.00 $ $ 2.31 $ 1, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. YELLOW 2 to 4 DOTTED/GUIDELINE/6 to gross mile $ 2, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ C C FDOT PAY PREFORMED TAPE BIKE MESSAGE 21 each $ $ 5, $ $ 4, $ $ 18, $ $ 18, $ $ 15, C C FDOT PAY PREFORMED TAPE BIKE ARROW 21 each $ $ 3, $ $ 2, $ $ 7, $ $ 7, $ $ 15, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. OTHER SURFACES WHITE SOLID 6 inch 4.01 gross mile $ 4, $ 17, $ 4, $ 18, $ 3, $ 14, $ 3, $ 14, $ 3, $ 14, C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. OTHER SURFACES WHITE SOLID 8 inch 0.05 gross mile $ 5, $ $ 5, $ $ 4, $ $ 4, $ $ 4, $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. OTHER SURFACES YELLOW SOLID 6 inch 2.99 gross mile $ 4, $ 12, $ 4, $ 13, $ 3, $ 10, $ 3, $ 10, $ 3, $ 11, gross mile $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 2, $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY THERMOPLASTIC STD. OTHER SURFACES YELLOW SKIP 6 inch Total $201, $185, $206, $213, $202,462.93

5 Page 5 of 8 Lot: Signalization C C FDOT PAY CONDUIT (F& I) OPEN TRENCH 60 linear foot $ 8.96 $ $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ $ 9.56 $ C C FDOT PAY CONDUIT (F& I) DIRECTIONAL BORE 242 linear foot $ $ 5, $ $ 7, $ $ 7, $ $ 4, $ $ 4, C C FDOT PAY SIGNAL CABLE NEW OR RECONSTRUCTED INTERSECTION FURNISH & INS 1 per intersection $ 5, $ 5, $ 6, $ 6, $ 5, $ 5, $ 3, $ 3, $ 4, $ 4, C C FDOT PAY PULL & SPLICE BOX (F&I) 13 inch x 24 inch 23 each $ $ 12, $ $ 14, $ $ 12, $ $ 17, $ $ 14, C C FDOT PAY PULL & SPLICE BOX (F&I) 24 inch X 36 inch 1 each $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, C C FDOT PAY ELECTRICAL POWER SRV(F&I) UGPURNOT REQ 1 assembly $ 2, $ 2, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, C C FDOT PAY ELECTRICAL SERVICE WIRE (F&I) 320 linear foot $ 2.80 $ $ 3.00 $ $ 1.90 $ $ 5.00 $ 1, $ 5.06 $ 1, C C FDOT PAY ELECTRICAL POWER SERVICE REMOVE OVERHEAD 1 assembly $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY STRAIN POLE WOOD REMOVE 2 each $ $ 1, $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ 3, $ 2, $ 4, C C FDOT PAY ALUMINUM SIGNALS POLE PEDESTAL 2 each $ 1, $ 2, $ 1, $ 3, $ 1, $ 3, $ $ 1, $ 1, $ 2, C C FDOT PAY M/ARMF&I WS 150SING ARMWITH LUM 60 1 each $ 44, $ 44, $ 50, $ 50, $ 44, $ 44, $ 44, $ 44, $ 50, $ 50, C C FDOT PAY TRAFFIC SIGNAL(F&I) ALUMINUM 3 S 1 W 4 assembly $ 1, $ 4, $ $ 3, $ $ 3, $ $ 3, $ 1, $ 4, C C FDOT PAY TRAFFIC SIGNAL RELOCATE INCLUDES REMOVAL AND REINSTALLATION 4 assembly $ $ 2, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 2, $ $ 2, C C FDOT PAY PEDESTRIAN SIGNAL (F&I) LED COUNT 1 WAY 2 assembly $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, C C FDOT PAY PEDESTRIAN DETECTOR (F&I) ACCESSIBLE 2 each $ 1, $ 3, $ 2, $ 4, $ 2, $ 4, $ $ 1, $ $ 1, C C FDOT PAY TRAFFIC CONTROLLER ASSEMBLY (F&I) MODEL assembly $ 31, $ 31, $ 33, $ 33, $ 30, $ 30, $ 31, $ 31, $ 35, $ 35, C C FDOT PAY TRAFFIC CONTROLLER ASSEMBLY REMOVE CONTROLLER WITH CABINET 1 assembly $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY MANAGED FIELD ETHERNET SWITCH ADJUST / MODIFY 1 each $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ C C FDOT PAY LIGHTING CONDUCTORS (F&I) INSULATED NO.8 to linear foot $ 2.80 $ $ 3.00 $ 1, $ 1.90 $ $ 2.00 $ $ 1.52 $ C C FDOT PAY LOAD CENTER (F&I) SECONDARY VOLTAGE 1 each $ 12, $ 12, $ 3, $ 3, $ 3, $ 3, $ 12, $ 12, $ 14, $ 14, each $ 1, $ 1, $ $ $ $ $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, $ 1, C C FDOT PAY LUMINAIRE (F&I) ROADWAY COBRA HEAD Total $137, $138, $124, $137, $149,034.28

6 Page 6 of 8 Lot: Landscaping C C TREE REMOVAL CANOPY TREES LESS THAN 20 FOOT IN HT 7 each $ $ 1, $ $ 3, $ $ 1, $ $ 4, $ $ 3, C C TREE REMOVAL CANOPY TREES MORE THAN 20 FOOT IN HT 49 each $ 1, $ 49, $ 2, $ 98, $ $ 25, $ $ 44, $ $ 27, C C TREE REMOVAL PALM TREES 15 each $ $ 4, $ $ 7, $ $ 3, $ $ 9, $ $ 6, C C ROOT BARRIER 18 INCH PANEL 705 linear foot $ $ 17, $ $ 11, $ $ 11, $ $ 10, $ $ 11, C C ACER RUBRUM RED MAPLE 14 FOOT to 16 FOOT x 8 FOOT SPR. 45 G 9 each $ $ 4, $ $ 6, $ $ 6, $ $ 6, $ $ 6, C C BURSERA SIMARUBA GUMBO LIMBO 14 FOOT to 16 FOOT x 8 FOOT SPR. 65 G 27 each $ $ 18, $ $ 17, $ $ 15, $ $ 15, $ $ 17, C C CONOCARPUS ERECTUS GREEN BUTTONWOOD 12 FT to 14 FT x 6 FT SPR. 3 INCH CAL. 13 each $ $ 8, $ $ 8, $ $ 8, $ $ 8, $ $ 9, C C CONOCARPUS ERECTUS SERICEUS SILVER BUTTONWOOD 10 FOOT to 12 FOOT x 6 FOOT SPR. 29 each $ $ 14, $ $ 13, $ $ 12, $ $ 12, $ $ 13, C C JACARANDA MIMOSIFOLIA JACARANDA 12 FOOT to 14 FOOT x 6 FOOT SPR. FG 11 each $ $ 7, $ $ 7, $ $ 6, $ $ 6, $ $ 7, C C QUERCUS VIRGINIANA LIVE OAK 14 FOOT to 18 FOOT x 8 FOOT FG 89 each $ $ 74, $ 1, $ 112, $ 1, $ 102, $ 1, $ 102, $ 1, $ 115, C C PERSEA BORBONIA FLORIDA RED BAY 10 FOOT to 12 FOOT x 6 FOOT SPR. 45 G 11 each $ $ 6, $ $ 8, $ $ 7, $ $ 7, $ $ 8, C C TAXODIUM DISTICHUM BALD CYPRESS 14 FOOT to 18 FOOT x 8 FOOT FG 18 each $ $ 9, $ $ 10, $ $ 9, $ $ 9, $ $ 10, C C BISMARCKIA NOBILIS SILVER BISMARCK PALM 10 FOOT CT SINGLE TRUNK 26 each $ 1, $ 45, $ 1, $ 45, $ 1, $ 41, $ 1, $ 41, $ 1, $ 46, C C ROYSTONEA REGIA FLORIDA ROYAL PALM 10 FOOT GRAY WOOD MATCHED 25 each $ 1, $ 33, $ 1, $ 35, $ 1, $ 32, $ 1, $ 32, $ 1, $ 36, each $ $ 34, $ $ 64, $ $ 58, $ $ 58, $ $ 65, C C SABAL PALMETTO SABAL PALM 14 FOOT to 22 FOOT STAGGERED HTS. BOOTED Total $330, $452, $343, $368, $388,416.12

7 Page 7 of 8 Lot: Payment and Performance Bond C C Payment and Performance Bond Premium 1 lump sum $ 30, $ 30, $ 20, $ 20, $ 45, $ 45, $ 61, $ 61, $ 37, $ 37,164.03

8 Page 8 of 8 Lot: Insurance C C Insurance Bond Premium 1 lump sum $ 8, $ 8, $ 5, $ 5, $ 3, $ 3, $ 15, $ 15, $ 10, $ 10,984.77

ALVAREZ ENGINEERS, INC. July 27, 2017 a) Evaluation Criteria PROJECT: ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS TO DOLPHIN MALL OUTER RING ROAD for BEACON TRADEPORT COMMUN

ALVAREZ ENGINEERS, INC. July 27, 2017 a) Evaluation Criteria PROJECT: ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS TO DOLPHIN MALL OUTER RING ROAD for BEACON TRADEPORT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT CITY OF SWEETWATER, FLORIDA