"#$%&'%(!)*+*! &,-.%&,-/01! 0,2032,-#(!4,4%(!

Transcription

1 "#$%&'%()*+* &,-.%&,-/01 0,2032,-#(4,4%( ",&%DDDD E:FGBHF:AIHBH7J8J7FK8F7LA99M M:AFK89KA98B:F 1

2 1 3 S5P7@BH8B s "( t # u) RL5@< 2 T5U s;h7@tvw8@<uv+) T55U 1:9P7BH77OA8B5:@C ZxV[x\T+*\xU x x # " x 2 " x " u;h7@sv+***8@<tvx 2 N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y Z > Z Z Z )

3 3 ]] ;F5B7 Q:Y > )GaJV+*` ]] 4AJJMV]] ) Z - Specialists in Science and Maths Education

4 -#-,2 (:;+)WcZ+VXWWVZ*cZ*dd+c+ (:;))XcZ)VXW`VZ*cZ*dd)c) (:;Z)[cZZVXW+VZ*cZ*ddZcZ (:;>)`cz>vxx>vz*cz*dd>c> (:;?D EH5KHF:;;599H8P78B:B89:LXZ`e EH8B5CBH7B:B89:LF:;)*e -%,&1 )Z>? &,-0.%1 A vs B A vs B A vs B A vs B A vs C A vs C A vs C B vs C A vs D A vs D B vs C A vs E B vs D C vs D B vs C B vs D B vs E C vs D C vs E D vs E -#-,2 + Z ` +* %8KHB:B895C:QB85@7<QMK:A@B5@IBH7@A6Q7F:L68BKH7C5@8978IA7] EH8B5CBH7-#-,2@A6Q7F:L978IA768BKH7CL:F[-%,&1e EH8B@A6Q7F:L-%,&1;:A9<BH7F7Q75@8978IA7;5BH8-#-,2:LW+ 68BKH7Ce N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y ) ) ) ) ) 4

5 ;F5B7, Q8I +* C;5gg97CR[ B:LL77C X I:QdCB:JJ7FC]/ C797KB 8 5@BH5C C;77BLF:6BH7Q8I] Q:Y T8U EH8B5CBH7JF:Q8Q595BMBH8B6MC;77B5C@:B8C;5gg97eDDDD + TQU EH8B5CBH7JF:Q8Q595BMBH8B6MC;77B5C8KH:K:98B7J78@ABeDDDD + /78BBH7L5FCBC;77B]/@:;C797KB8C7K:@<C;77B] TKU /L 6M L5FCB C;77B ;8C 8 B:LL77 ;H8B 5C BH7 JF:Q8Q595BM BH8B 6M C7K:@< C;77B5C8@:BH7FB:LL77e ) DDDDD T<U /L 6M L5FCB C;77B ;8C 8 B:LL77 ;H8B 5C BH7 JF:Q8Q595BM BH8B 6M C7K:@< C;77B5C8I:QdCB:JJ7Fe ) DDDDD -H7P89A7:L8I:9<5@I:B8BBH77@<:L7P7FMM78F5C+*h6:F7BH8@5B;8C8BBH7 CB8FB:LBH7M78F]/@i8@A8FM)**W8I:9<5@I:B;8C;:FBH_X***] T5U T55U.:;6AKH;8C5B;:FBH5@i8@A8FM)*+*e.:;6AKH;5995BQ7;:FBH5@i8@A8FM)*+?e,BBH7CB8FB:L;H5KHM78F;599BH7P89A7:LBH75@I:BL5FCBQ76:F7BH8@_)****e %"N#^%j,&/",-/#" /^k#3.,$%-/&%0.%0bk#3(e#(b ) Z Z 5

6 "#$%&'%()*+* &,-.%&,-/01 "#"0,2032,-#(4,4%( ",&%DDDD E:FGBHF:AIHBH7J8J7FK8F7LA99M 6

7 7 48I7+ )*++awwwv )*++\WWWV )*++c++v ;F5B7 Q:Y C7M:AFJF7P5:AC 8@C;7FB:L5@< )*]++c+]+v EH8B5C)>cWe 3C7M:AFJF7P5:AC 8@C;7FB:;F5B7<:;@ BH78@C;7FB:)>**cW* )*]++a*]*wv )*]++a*]wv )*]++awv S5P7@BH8B )?c+wv>[? 3C7BH5C8@C;7FB:L5@< >[?$+WV 8@< >[?**$+WV 8@< T>[?a>[?U$+WV S5P7@BH8B?`[$)[V)+ 3C7BH5C8@C;7FB: L5@<?`[$)+V 8@<?`][$)][V EH8B5C>***$>* DDDDDDD] 3C7M:AF8@C;7FB: ;F5B7<:;@BH78@C;7FC B: >***$)* DDDDDDD] >***$X* DDDDDDD] Specialists in Science and Maths Education

8 EF5B7BH7C7BHF77 C68997CBL5FCB] 5 R *]XR Wh 6 ]] 1:9P7BH7C77OA8B5:@C 3x # 4 " 2(13 # x) ]] x % 5 1 " 4 2 ]]] ^5@<BH7@7YB)B7F6C5@ BH7C7OA7@K7= )R?R[R+)R+WRZ+RD DD DD] 48I7) 1 EH8B5C 7 h:l_>** 2 DDDDDDDDD] & % ]] ' 4 2 ( 1 ) # * $ , 2 ] EH8B5C8C=,<7K5689e ]],J7FK7@B8I7e ]] ^5@<L5P775IHBHC:L >*XJ DDDDDDDDD]] EF5B7<:;@8LF8KB5:@ Q7B;77@*]+`8@<*]+[ ddddddddd EF5B7<:;@8<7K5689 Q7B;77@ 1 3 8@<30% ddddddddd,l8bh7fch8f7:ab_z? J:KG7B6:@7M5@BH7 F8B5::LZ=?=`].:; 6AKH<:7C78KHKH59< I7Be dddddddr dddddddr ddddddd NF8;@Q79:;5C8FH:6QAC8@<5BC<58I:@89C]^5@<BH7P89A7:Lx] [) : x. N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y ) ) ) Z Z Z Z + + ) + + > Z 8

9 "#$%&'()&*+$%,)-.&)'./&$ 0/1+-2+($34$ $ 5678%5679:;$ $ 7.-+$)<</=+>?$@A$-.&B'+C$ $ $ 065%DDDD$ $ E/(F$'G(/BHG$'G+$I)I+($*)(+JB<<K$ L/B$>/$&/'$G)1+$'/$J.&.CG$+1+(K'G.&H$ M/$&/'$CI+&>$'//$-B*G$'.-+$/&$)&K$C.&H<+$NB+C'./&$ ;G/=$)&K$=/(F.&H$.&$'G+$CI)*+C$I(/1.>+>$ OC+$'G+$2<)&F$<+J'$G)&>$I)H+C$J/($(/BHG$=/(F$ 9

10 1 3 S5P7@BH8B s "( t # u) RL5@< 2 T555U s;h7@tvw8@<uv+) T5PU 1:9P7BH77OA8B5:@C ZxV[x\T+*\xU x x # " x 2 " x " u;h7@sv+***8@<tvx 10 N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y Z > Z Z Z )

11 11 ]] ;F5B7 Q:Y > ZHa<V)Z NAKGV]] ) Z - Specialists in Science and Maths Education

12 -#-,2 (:;*+)c+)v+>>v+)c+)dd*c* (:;+++c+zv+>zv+)c+)dd+c+ (:;)+*c+>v+>*v+)c+)dd)c) (:;ZWc+?V+Z?V+)c+)ddZcZ (:;>D EH5KHF:;;599H8P78B:B89:LW?e EH8B5CBH7B:B89:LF:;+Ze -%,&1 )Z>? &,-0.%1 A vs B A vs B A vs B A vs B A vs C A vs C A vs C B vs C A vs D A vs D B vs C A vs E B vs D C vs D B vs C B vs D B vs E C vs D C vs E D vs E -#-,2 + Z ` +* %8KHB:B895C:QB85@7<QMK:A@B5@IBH7@A6Q7F:L68BKH7C5@8978IA7] EH8B5CBH7-#-,2@A6Q7F:L978IA768BKH7CL:FX-%,&1e EH8B@A6Q7F:L-%,&1;:A9<BH7F7Q75@8978IA7;5BH8-#-,2:L+*> 68BKH7Ce N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y ) ) ) ) ) 12

13 Q:Y T7U + TLU EH8B5CBH7JF:Q8Q595BMBH8B6MKH77C75C808676Q7FBeDDDD + /78BBH7L5FCBKH77C7]/@:;C797KB8C7K:@<KH77C7] TIU /L6ML5FCBKH77C7;8C80H7<<8F;H8B5CBH7JF:Q8Q595BMBH8B6MC7K:@< C;77B5C8@:BH7F0H7<<8Fe ) DDDDD THU /L 6M L5FCB KH77C7;8C 8 1B59B:@;H8B 5C BH7 JF:Q8Q595BM BH8B 6M C7K:@< C;77B5C8(7<275K7CB7Fe ) DDDDD /B5C7CB568B7<BH8BBH7J:JA98B5:@:LB5I7FCI:7C<:;@QM+*h7P7FMM78F]/@ i8@a8fm)*+*bh7f7;7f78@7cb568b7<)***b5i7fc] T555U %"N#^%j,&/",-/#" /^k#3.,$%-/&%0.%0bk#3(e#(b 13 ) Z Z

14 "#$%&'()&*+$%,)-.&)'./&$ 0/1+-2+($34$ $ 5678%5679:;$ $ 7.-+$)<</=+>?$34$-.&B'+C$ $ $ 065%DDDD$ $ E/(F$'G(/BHG$'G+$I)I+($*)(+JB<<K$ L/B$>/$&/'$G)1+$'/$J.&.CG$+1+(K'G.&H$ M/$&/'$CI+&>$'//$-B*G$'.-+$/&$)&K$C.&H<+$NB+C'./&$ ;G/=$)&K$=/(F.&H$.&$'G+$CI)*+C$I(/1.>+>$ OC+$'G+$2<)&F$<+J'$G)&>$I)H+C$J/($(/BHG$=/(F$ $ P6Q%$ $ 3$ "$ 7R76S$ 56TU$ V$ 3@$ V$ W4$ 56TU$ $ $ $ $ 14

15 "#$% "&'($)"**+,$'-./&'.&-0$'"1$')/2.3$34'0/(.&#"&5 &$1$''")5(/)6.&#' 7887BP 7887"S; P:P VP:P9P:P9P:PWU %SC 7887< :::; 78R87B%RP 7887" S8; 7887" S88; 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 15

16 @A?=FQ>J]FA?>MO S8_8RXP *>J]FA?; '^>QQFA?; "OO?H]F?=FJ H\7Z H\T8 >MO H\%P %4Z4Y4%T4%:4eeRR >MO %4%474T4P4Y4eRR >MO "#$7 % a 7 _H\ `X88C,AFGHIJ>MANFJA?H \@MO%S % a 7 _H\`X88 )@[=>JO@A%7GF>JA HQOR "O>^@A?N@[F>AHQO >A)@[=>JOR (@QQ@A H\"O>^cA >]FR (=>?@A?=F@J?H?>Q >]FC I??=FAFOF[@^>QA@M HJOFJ4A?>J?@M]N@?=?=FQ>J]FA?R 8R%8%48R8%%48R%% b@mohmfm@m?=h\tx8,afghij>manfj?h \@MO\HIJM@M?=AH\TX8 (J@?FOHNM>OF[@^>Q df?nffmsp_>moy8_ (J@?FOHNM>\J>[?@HM df?nffmx8_>mos8_ (=>?\J>[?@HMH\?=@A \Q>]@AA=>OFOC 0HN^>MG^HJF JF[?>M]QFAMFFO?HdF A=>OFO?H\@QQ H\?=F \Q>]C 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 7 7 % % % 16

17 (HJfHI? 9 (=>?@A?=Fd@]]FA? MI^dFJ?=>?O@L@OFA FB>[?QG@M?H X84S7>MOYZC (=>?@A8RSNJ@??FM>A >\J>[?@HMC (=>?@A8R8SNJ@??FM >A>\J>[?@HMC (=>?@A8RS8SNJ@??FM >A>\J>[?@HMC (HJfHI? "#$T < (=>?@A?=FA^>QQFA? MI^dFJ?=>? 74T4>MOY >QQO@L@OF@M?HC (=>?@A NJ@??FM>A> OF[@^>QC (=>?@A >OF[@^>QC (=>?@A >OF[@^>QC NJ@??FM>A NJ@??FM>A "OO?H]F?=FJ?=F \HQQHN@M]4]@L@M]GHIJ >MANFJ>A>3$1.g"* XP_48RP8S>MO b@mo?nhmi^dfja?=>?=>lf>o@\\fjfm[f H\P>MO>OOIK?H%: &>^F?=FA=>KFA dfqhn 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 17

18 &HLF^dFJ78%7 g"-0$g"-.1' &"g$eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee (HJf?=JHI]=?=FK>KFJ[>JF\IQQG 18

19 19 TPU TP5U ;F5B7 Q:Y Z > 1:9P7BH77OA8B5:@C?xV[x\T+)\xU Z Z Z ) - Specialists in Science and Maths Education

20 20 7OA89B:BH78F78:LBH7K5FKA98FQ8C76A9B5J957< DDDDDDDDD]] ;F5B7 Q:Y > >8aIV`X* S8g7997V]] ) Z - Specialists in Science and Maths Education

21 -#-,2 (:;*)?c)?v`)?v)?c)? *c* (:;+)>c)`v`)>v)?c)? +c+ (:;))Zc)[V`)+V)?c)? )c) (:;Z))c)XV`+`V)?c)? ZcZ (:;>D EH5KHF:;;599H8P78B:B89:L?[`e -%,&1 )>` &,-0.%1 A1 vs B1 A1 vs B1 A1 vs B1 A1 vs B2 A1 vs B2 A2 vs B1 A2 vs B2 A1 vs B3 A2 vs B1 A2 vs B2 A2 vs B3 A3 vs B1 A3 vs B2 A3 vs B3 -#-,2 + > W %8KHB:B895C:QB85@7<QMK:A@B5@IBH7@A6Q7F:L68BKH7C] EH8B5CBH7-#-,2@A6Q7F:L978IA768BKH7CL:FX-%,&1e EH8B@A6Q7F:L-%,&1;:A9<BH7F7Q75@8978IA7;5BH8-#-,2:L>** 68BKH7Ce N:@:B ;F5B7 5@BH5C Q:Y ) ) ) ) ) 21

22 T5U TlU EH8B5CBH7JF:Q8Q595BMBH8B6MC;77B5C825OA:F5K7eDDDD TGU /L 6M L5FCB C;77B;8C DDDDD T9U C;77B5C808F8679e DDDDD BH73b] TPU TP5U %"N#^%j,&/",-/#" /^k#3.,$%-/&%0.%0bk#3(e#(b 22 ;F5B7 Q:Y + + ) ) ) Z Z

23 &HLF^dFJ78%7 g"-0$g"-.1' &"g$eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee (HJf?=JHI]=?=FK>KFJ[>JF\IQQG "#$ % 7 T -/-"* g")6 %Y 7Z %Y X8 g")6 23

24 "#$% "&'($)"**+,$'-./&'.&-0$'"1$')/2.3$34'0/(.&#"&5 &$1$''")5(/)6.&#' 78%7BP8 78%7":; Z:X VZ:X9Z:XWUYC 78%7< Z::; 78R%7B%RP 78%7" :8; 78%7" :88; 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 24

25 @A?=FQ>J]FA?>MO Y_8R% *>J]FA?; '^>QQFA?; "OO?H]F?=FJ H\78 H\TT >MO H\: T4%74ZY4%:74eeRR >MO %4T4Z4S4%%4%Y4eRR >MO "#$7 `Z888C % a 7 _H\ `Z888C,AFGHIJ>MANFJA?H \@MO7S % a 7 _H\`Z888 )@[=>JO@A%PGF>JA HQOR "O>^@A\HIJ?@^FA>A HQO>A)@[=>JOR (@QQ@A H\"O>^cA >]FR (=>?@A?=F@J?H?>Q >]FC I??=FAFOF[@^>QA@M HJOFJ4A?>J?@M]N@?=?=FQ>J]FA?R 8R8S748RX:48RS b@mohmfaflfm?=h\ PX8,AFGHIJ>MANFJ?H \@MO\@LFAFLFM?=AH\ PX8 (J@?FOHNM>OF[@^>Q df?nffm:p_>mo:x_ (J@?FOHNM>\J>[?@HM df?nffm78_>mo7p_ (=>?\J>[?@HMH\?=@A \Q>]@AA=>OFOC 0HN^>MG^HJF JF[?>M]QFAMFFO?HdF A=>OFO?H\@QQ H\?=F \Q>]C 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 7 7 % % % 25

26 (HJfHI? 9 (=>?@A?=Fd@]]FA? MI^dFJ?=>?O@L@OFA FB>[?QG@M?H T84Z7>MOPZC (=>?@A8R%TNJ@??FM >A>\J>[?@HMC (=>?@A8R88%T NJ@??FM>A>\J>[?@HMC (=>?@A8R%T%T NJ@??FM>A>\J>[?@HMC (HJfHI? "#$T < (=>?@A?=FA^>QQFA? MI^dFJ?=>? Z4P4>MOX >QQO@L@OF@M?HC (=>?@A NJ@??FM>A> OF[@^>QC (=>?@A >A>OF[@^>QC (=>?@A >A>OF[@^>QC NJ@??FM NJ@??FM "OO?H]F?=FJ?=F \HQQHN@M]4]@L@M]GHIJ >MANFJ>A>3$1.g"* ZX_48R7PY>MO b@mo?nhmi^dfja?=>?=>lf>o@\\fjfm[f H\%%>MO>OOIK?H7T &>^F?=FA=>KFA dfqhn 3/ &/- ().-$.& -0.' D/E % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 26

27 27