AZ Local Government Scorecard -- By District, with Cumulative Scores for FYs 08-15

Transcription

1 AZ Local Government Scorecard -- By District, with Cumulative Scores for s Updated April Scoring Rubric on Pages Full Spreadsheet: tjenney@afphq.org (Sub-Scores for 2015 are posted at AVG. Cumulative Designation Apache County Supervisor Shirley, Joe Not Bad Apache County Supervisor Weller, Barry Friend of the Taxpayer Apache County Supervisor White, Tom Not Bad Apache Junction City City Council Barker, Robin Needs Improvement Apache Junction City City Council Wilson, Chip Needs Improvement Apache Junction City City Council Evans, Gail Needs Improvement Apache Junction City City Council Rizzi, Christa Ally of Big Government Apache Junction City City Council Serdy, Jeff Needs Improvement Apache Junction City City Council Waldron, David Needs Improvement Apache Junction City City Council Insalaco, John Needs Improvement Avondale City City Council Iwanski, David -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Avondale City City Council Karlin, Stephanie Needs Improvement Avondale City City Council Kilgore, Bryan -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Avondale City City Council McDonald, Jim Not Bad Avondale City City Council Scott, Frank Needs Much Improvement Avondale City City Council Vierhout, Charles Not Bad Avondale City City Council Weise, Kenneth Needs Improvement

2 Benson City City Council Brooks, Ron Ally of the Taxpayer Benson City City Council King, Toney Needs Much Improvement Benson City City Council Boyle, Pat 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Benson City City Council Peter Wagness 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Benson City City Council Jeff Cook 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Benson City City Council Moncada, Chris Ally of the Taxpayer Benson City City Council Sacco, Al Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Badal, Adriana Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Budge, Ken Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Cline, Anna Ally of Big Government Bisbee City City Council Connors, Eugene Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Doughty, Shirley Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Dunn, Douglas Needs Much Improvement Bisbee City City Council Von Gundlach, Peter 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Buckeye City City Council Garza, Robert Ally of Big Government Buckeye City City Council Hess, Michelle Not Bad Buckeye City City Council Heustis, Craig Needs Much Improvement Buckeye City City Council McAchran, Brian Needs Much Improvement Buckeye City City Council Meck, Jackie Needs Much Improvement Buckeye City City Council Orsborn, Eric Needs Much Improvement Buckeye City City Council Strauss, Ray Needs Improvement Bullhead City City City Council Bruck, Kathy 4 NA Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Clark, Mark Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Duvall, Jerry Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Hakim, Jack 4 NA Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Medrano, Sam 4 NA Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Ring, Tami Not Bad Bullhead City City City Council Shutts, Sheila Not Bad Camp Verde City City Council Baker, Jackie Ally of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council George, Bruce Friend of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council German, Carol Ally of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council German, Charles NA Friend of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council Gordon, Brad Ally of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council Jones, Jessie Ally of Big Government Camp Verde City City Council Whatley, Robin Needs Much Improvement

3 Carefree City City Council Crane, John Friend of Big Government Carefree City City Council Farrar, Mike Ally of Big Government Carefree City City Council Miller, Glenn Needs Improvement Carefree City City Council Peterson, Les Friend of Big Government Carefree City City Council Price, Melissa Ally of Big Government Carefree City City Council Saltzman, Marty Ally of Big Government Carefree City City Council Schwan, David Needs Improvement Casa Grande City City Council Fitzgibbons, Lisa N Needs Improvement Casa Grande City City Council Herman, Matt Ally of Big Government Casa Grande City City Council Jackson, Robert Friend of Big Government Casa Grande City City Council Kortsen, Mary Friend of Big Government Casa Grande City City Council Montoya, Karl Friend of Big Government Casa Grande City City Council Powell, Dick Friend of Big Government Casa Grande City City Council Varela, Ralph Friend of Big Government Cave Creek City City Council Bunch III, Ernest Ally of the Taxpayer Cave Creek City City Council Durkin, Mike Not Bad Cave Creek City City Council Francia, Vincent Ally of the Taxpayer Cave Creek City City Council McGuire, Thomas Not Bad Cave Creek City City Council Monachino, Reg Not Bad Cave Creek City City Council Spitzer, Charlie Not Bad Cave Creek City City Council Trenk, Adam Ally of the Taxpayer Central AZ Proj. Water Director Atkins, Lisa Needs Improvement Central AZ Proj. Water Director Burns, Gayle Friend of the Taxpayer Central AZ Proj. Water Director Carpenter, Guy Friend of Big Government Central AZ Proj. Water Director Fairbanks, Frank Needs Improvement Central AZ Proj. Water Director Goddard, Terry Friend of Big Government Central AZ Proj. Water Director Hartdegen, Jim Needs Much Improvement Central AZ Proj. Water Director Holway, Jim Needs Improvement Central AZ Proj. Water Director Jacobs, Pat Not Bad Central AZ Proj. Water Director Lewis, Mark Ally of the Taxpayer Central AZ Proj. Water Director Macre, Heather Friend of Big Government Central AZ Proj. Water Director Megdal, Sharon Not Bad Central AZ Proj. Water Director Moulton, Cynthia Needs Improvement Central AZ Proj. Water Director Pickard, Pam Ally of the Taxpayer Central AZ Proj. Water Director Tenney, Warren Not Bad Central AZ Proj. Water Director Zimmerman, Carol Needs Improvement

4 Chandler City City Council Donovan, Trinity Needs Improvement Chandler City City Council Hartke, Kevin Needs Improvement Chandler City City Council Ellen, Nora Friend of the Taxpayer Chandler City City Council Heumann, Rick Ally of the Taxpayer Chandler City City Council Sellers, Jack Ally of the Taxpayer Chandler City City Council Tibshraeny, Jay Not Bad Chandler City City Council Weninger, Jeff Needs Improvement Chino Valley City City Council Best, Mike Ally of Big Government Chino Valley City City Council Croft, Darryl Ally of Big Government Chino Valley City City Council Hatch, Linda Needs Much Improvement Chino Valley City City Council Marley, Chris Ally of Big Government Chino Valley City City Council Mckee, Pat Friend of Big Government Chino Valley City City Council Turner, Lon Ally of Big Government Chino Valley City City Council Wojcik, Don Friend of Big Government Clarkdale City City Council Bohall, Curtis 3 NA Not Bad Clarkdale City City Council Dehnert, Richard NA Needs Improvement Clarkdale City City Council Radoccia, Reynold Friend of the Taxpayer Clarkdale City City Council Regner, Bill Ally of the Taxpayer Clarkdale City City Council Von Gausig, Doug 3 NA Not Bad Cochise County Supervisor Call, Pat Needs Much Improvement Cochise County Supervisor English, Ann Not Bad Cochise County Supervisor Searle, Richard Needs Much Improvement Coconino County Supervisor Archuleta, Elizabeth Friend of Big Government Coconino County Supervisor Babbott, Art Ally of Big Government Coconino County Supervisor Fowler, Lena Friend of Big Government Coconino County Supervisor Metzger, Mandy Friend of Big Government Coconino County Supervisor Ryan, Matt Friend of Big Government Coolidge City City Council Hendrie-Henry, Jacque Ally of the Taxpayer Coolidge City City Council Hudson, Steve Not Bad Coolidge City City Council Lister, Richard Not Bad Coolidge City City Council Lopez, Gilbert (Cldg) Not Bad Coolidge City City Council Rotz-Lopez, Judy Needs Improvement Coolidge City City Council Shope, Thomas Not Bad Coolidge City City Council Thompson, Jon Ally of the Taxpayer

5 Cottonwood City City Council Dowling, Jesse Needs Much Improvement Cottonwood City City Council Elinski, Tim Friend of Big Government Cottonwood City City Council Garrison, Randy Ally of Big Government Cottonwood City City Council Jauregui, Ruben Needs Much Improvement Cottonwood City City Council Joens, Diane Friend of Big Government Cottonwood City City Council Pfeifer, Karen Friend of Big Government Cottonwood City City Council Pratt, Terence Friend of Big Government Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Alen, Arlene Ally of the Taxpayer Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Hamilton, Jack Ally of the Taxpayer Dewey-Humboldt City City Council McBrady, Mark Not Bad Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Nolan, Terry Not Bad Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Repan, Dennis Not Bad Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Williams-Rowe, Sonya Ally of the Taxpayer Dewey-Humboldt City City Council Wright, Nancy Not Bad Douglas City City Council Greer, Luis Not Bad Douglas City City Council La Forge, Ben Not Bad Douglas City City Council Nelson, Ken 1 1 Not Bad Douglas City City Council Morales, Margaret NA Ally of the Taxpayer Douglas City City Council Ortega, Danny Not Bad Douglas City City Council Betancourt, Fernanda 1 1 Not Bad Douglas City City Council Lopez, Patricia 1 1 Not Bad Duncan City City Council Failed to Post F F F F F FTP Failed to Post Eagar City City Council Browning, Allen Friend of the Taxpayer Eagar City City Council Erhart, Steve Needs Improvement Eagar City City Council Hamblin, Bryce Friend of the Taxpayer Eagar City City Council McNeill, Winslow Friend of the Taxpayer Eagar City City Council Nelson, James Ally of Big Government Eagar City City Council Phelps, John O Not Bad Eagar City City Council Smith, Byron Needs Improvement El Mirage City City Council Delgado, Roy Needs Much Improvement El Mirage City City Council McPhetres, James Champion of the Taxpayer El Mirage City City Council Mook, Lana Needs Improvement El Mirage City City Council Palladino, Jack Needs Improvement El Mirage City City Council Ramirez, Joe Needs Improvement El Mirage City City Council Selby, Lynn Needs Improvement El Mirage City City Council Shapera, David Needs Improvement Eloy City City Council Akes, Belinda Not Bad Eloy City City Council Amerson, Etta Ruth Needs Improvement Eloy City City Council Belloc, Joel Needs Improvement Eloy City City Council Nagy, J.R Not Bad Eloy City City Council Powell, Micah Needs Improvement Eloy City City Council Sauceda, Augustine Not Bad Eloy City City Council Tidwell, J.W Not Bad

6 Flagstaff City City Council Barotz, Celia Not Bad Flagstaff City City Council Brewster, Karla Needs Improvement Flagstaff City City Council Evans, Coral Needs Improvement Flagstaff City City Council Nabours, Jerry Friend of the Taxpayer Flagstaff City City Council Oravits, Jeff Friend of the Taxpayer Flagstaff City City Council Overton, Scott Needs Much Improvement Flagstaff City City Council Putzova, Eva 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer Florence City City Council Celaya, Tom Friend of Big Government Florence City City Council Hawkins, Bill Ally of Big Government Florence City City Council Montano, Ruben Ally of Big Government Florence City City Council Rankin, Tom Friend of Big Government Florence City City Council Smith, Tom Friend of Big Government Florence City City Council Walter, Tara Friend of Big Government Florence City City Council Woolridge, Vallarie Friend of Big Government Fountain Hills City City Council Brown, Dennis Ally of Big Government Fountain Hills City City Council Dickey, Ginny Ally of Big Government Fountain Hills City City Council Elkie, Tait Needs Much Improvement Fountain Hills City City Council Hansen, Cassie Needs Much Improvement Fountain Hills City City Council Kavanagh, Linda Needs Much Improvement Fountain Hills City City Council Leger, Henry Ally of Big Government Fountain Hills City City Council Yates, Cecil Needs Much Improvement Fredonia City City Council Johnson, Alvin? F 0 0 F F FTP Failed to Post Fredonia City City Council Lukus, Jennifer? F 0 0 F F FTP Failed to Post Fredonia City City Council Riddle, Dustin? F 0 0 F F FTP Failed to Post Fredonia City City Council Waters, Mike? F 0 0 F F FTP Failed to Post Fredonia City City Council Zaccaria, Tony? F 0 0 F F FTP Failed to Post Gila County Supervisor Marcanti, John Friend of the Taxpayer Gila County Supervisor Martin, Tommie Not Bad Gila County Supervisor Pastor, Michael Ally of the Taxpayer Gila Bend City City Council Fernandez, Fernando F Needs Much Improvement Gila Bend City City Council Gonzalez, Amida 1 NA 0 F Needs Improvement Gila Bend City City Council Henry, Ron 1 NA 0 F Not Bad Gila Bend City City Council Holt, Steve 1 NA 0 F Needs Improvement Gila Bend City City Council Sikes, Tommy Lee Needs Much Improvement Gila Bend City City Council Turner, Chuck 1 NA 0 F Needs Improvement Gila Bend City City Council Turner, James Ally of Big Government

7 Gilbert City City Council Cook, Eddie Needs Improvement Gilbert City City Council Cooper, Ben Not Bad Gilbert City City Council Daniels, Jean Ally of the Taxpayer Gilbert City City Council Lewis, John Ally of the Taxpayer Gilbert City City Council Petersen, Victor Champion of the Taxpayer Gilbert City City Council Ray, Jordan Needs Improvement Gilbert City City Council Taylor, Jared Champion of the Taxpayer Glendale City City Council Alvarez, Norma Not Bad Glendale City City Council Chavira, Sammy Ally of Big Government Glendale City City Council Hugh, Ian Needs Much Improvement Glendale City City Council Knaack, Yvonne Not Bad Glendale City City Council Martinez, Manuel Not Bad Glendale City City Council Sherwood, Gary Ally of Big Government Glendale City City Council Weiers, Jerry Ally of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Alderman, Lerry Ally of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Haley, James 0 NA Ally of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Humphrey, Mike Friend of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Johnson, Roberta Friend of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Mariscal, Eric Friend of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Stapelton, Mike Friend of the Taxpayer Globe City City Council Wheeler, Terence Ally of the Taxpayer Goodyear City City Council Campbell, Wally Ally of the Taxpayer Goodyear City City Council Hohman, Sharolyn Ally of Big Government Goodyear City City Council Lauritano, Sheri Ally of the Taxpayer Goodyear City City Council Lord, Georgia Ally of the Taxpayer Goodyear City City Council Osborne, Joanne Not Bad Goodyear City City Council Pizzillo, Joe Ally of the Taxpayer Goodyear City City Council Stipp, Bill Not Bad Graham County Supervisor Drew, John Needs Much Improvement Graham County Supervisor Palmer, Jim Needs Much Improvement Graham County Supervisor Smith, Danny Not Bad Greenlee County Supervisor Campbell, Ron Friend of Big Government Greenlee County Supervisor Gomez, David Ally of Big Government Greenlee County Supervisor Corbell, Robert -4-4 Friend of Big Government

8 Guadalupe City City Council Cota, Gloria Ally of Big Government Guadalupe City City Council Flores, Saturnino Ally of Big Government Guadalupe City City Council Perez, Angie Ally of Big Government Guadalupe City City Council Sanchez, Andres Ally of Big Government Guadalupe City City Council Sanchez, Joe NA Ally of Big Government Guadalupe City City Council Jimenez, Rebecca -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Guadalupe City City Council Valenzuela, Faustino Cruz -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Hayden City City Council Badillo, Monica F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Cooper, Rhonda F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Cruz, Kathy F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Lagunas, Thomas F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Lopez, Enrique F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Munoz, Maria F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Hayden City City Council Quesada, Annette F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Holbrook City City Council Carlisle, Wade Not Bad Holbrook City City Council Cobb, Phillip Not Bad Holbrook City City Council Haussmann, Charles Not Bad Holbrook City City Council Hill, Jeff Not Bad Holbrook City City Council Maxwell, Myron Not Bad Holbrook City City Council Peterson, Richard Needs Improvement Holbrook City City Council Tyler, Bobby Needs Improvement Huachuca City City City Council Perry, David A 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council Johnson, Donna -3 NA F 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council McCullough, Gene -3 NA F 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council Taylor, Ken F 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council Van Slyke, Mary F 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council Wallace, Laura 2 F 5 FTP Failed to Post Huachuca City City City Council Welsch, Walter F 5 FTP Failed to Post Jerome City City Council Bassett, Ann Ally of the Taxpayer Jerome City City Council Check, Nichole Ally of the Taxpayer Jerome City City Council Currier, Lew Ally of the Taxpayer Jerome City City Council Hunt, Randall Ally of the Taxpayer Jerome City City Council Phinney, William Ally of the Taxpayer

9 Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kearny City City Council Failed to Post F 0 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Kingman City City Council Anderson, Richard Ally of the Taxpayer Kingman City City Council Carver, Larry Ally of the Taxpayer Kingman City City Council Cochran, Erin Ally of the Taxpayer Kingman City City Council Miles, Jen Ally of the Taxpayer Kingman City City Council Watson, Janet Needs Improvement Kingman City City Council Wimpee, Mark Ally of the Taxpayer Kingman City City Council Young, Carole Not Bad La Paz County Supervisor Clapperton, King Friend of Big Government La Paz County Supervisor Irwin, Holly Needs Improvement La Paz County Supervisor Wilson, DL Friend of Big Government Lake Havasu City City City Council Alger, Crystal Needs Improvement Lake Havasu City City City Council Barlow, Dean Not Bad Lake Havasu City City City Council Brister, Donna Ally of Big Government Lake Havasu City City City Council Callahan, Don Not Bad Lake Havasu City City City Council Coke, Jeni Needs Improvement Lake Havasu City City City Council McAtlin, David Not Bad Lake Havasu City City City Council Nexsen, Mark Not Bad Litchfield Park City City Council Blake, Tim Ally of Big Government Litchfield Park City City Council Faith, Paul Ally of Big Government Litchfield Park City City Council Landis, Diane Ally of Big Government Litchfield Park City City Council Mahoney, Peter Ally of Big Government Litchfield Park City City Council Romack, John Needs Much Improvement Litchfield Park City City Council Schoaf, Tom Ally of Big Government Litchfield Park City City Council Stucky, Paul Needs Much Improvement

10 Mammoth City City Council Barcelo, Alvaro F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Brewer, Joseph F F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Medina, Rogina F F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Romero, Erik F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Vacant (Mammoth) F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Wickham, Frances F 0 F F F FTP Failed to Post Mammoth City City Council Barcelo, Juan F FTP Failed to Post Marana City City Council Bowen, Dave Not Bad Marana City City Council Comerford, Patti Needs Improvement Marana City City Council Honea, Ed Needs Improvement Marana City City Council Kai, Herb Needs Improvement Marana City City Council McGorray, Carol Needs Improvement Marana City City Council Post, Jon Needs Improvement Marana City City Council Ziegler, Roxanne Needs Improvement Maricopa City City Council Brown, Marvin Ally of Big Government Maricopa City City Council Chapados, Peggy Needs Much Improvement Maricopa City City Council Farrell, Edward Friend of Big Government Maricopa City City Council Gusse, Julia Needs Much Improvement Maricopa City City Council Kimball, Bridger Needs Much Improvement Maricopa City City Council Frank, Dan 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer Maricopa City City Council Price, Christian Needs Much Improvement Maricopa County Supervisor Barney, Denny Ally of the Taxpayer Maricopa County Supervisor Chucri, Steve Ally of the Taxpayer Maricopa County Supervisor Hickman, Clint Ally of the Taxpayer Maricopa County Supervisor Kunasek, Andy Not Bad Maricopa County Supervisor Lopez Rogers, Marie 0 0 Needs Improvement Maricopa Comm. College Board Member Burke, Doyle Needs Much Improvement Maricopa Comm. College Board Member Gutierrez, Alfredo Needs Improvement Maricopa Comm. College Board Member Lumm, Randolph Needs Much Improvement Maricopa Comm. College Board Member Pearson, Debra Needs Improvement Maricopa Comm. College Board Member Saar, Dana Needs Much Improvement Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Bicknell, Elbert Needs Improvement Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Dewane, Mark Friend of Big Government Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Gerard, Susan Ally of Big Government Maricopa IHS Health Board Member Harden, Mary Friend of Big Government Maricopa IHS Health Board Member McMahon, Terence Friend of Big Government

11 Mesa City City Council Finter, Alex Needs Much Improvement Mesa City City Council Glover, Christopher Ally of Big Government Mesa City City Council Kavanaugh, Dennis Needs Much Improvement Mesa City City Council Luna, David Friend of Big Government Mesa City City Council Richins, Dave Needs Much Improvement Mesa City City Council Smith, Scott Needs Much Improvement Mesa City City Council Somers, Scott Ally of Big Government Miami City City Council Baeza, Robert 0 NA 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Black, Mike 0 F -6 1 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Castaneda, Rosemary 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Dalley, Darryl 0 F -6 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Gonzales, Sammy 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Hanson, Susan 0 F -6 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Miami City City Council Reiman, Don 5 F F FTP Failed to Post Mohave County Supervisor Anguis, Hildy Friend of the Taxpayer Mohave County Supervisor Bishop, Jean Friend of the Taxpayer Mohave County Supervisor Johnson, Buster Friend of the Taxpayer Mohave County Supervisor Moss, Steven Friend of the Taxpayer Mohave County Supervisor Watson, Gary Friend of the Taxpayer Navajo County Supervisor Allen, Sylvia Ally of the Taxpayer Navajo County Supervisor Nez, Jonathan Not Bad Navajo County Supervisor Tenney, David Needs Much Improvement Navajo County Supervisor Thompson, Jesse Needs Much Improvement Navajo County Supervisor Whitesinger, Dawnafe Ally of the Taxpayer Nogales City City Council Acosta, Joe Ally of the Taxpayer Nogales City City Council Diaz, Jose Not Bad Nogales City City Council Doyle, John Ally of the Taxpayer Nogales City City Council Garino, Arturo 0 NA Not Bad Nogales City City Council Hanessian, Nubar 0 NA Not Bad Nogales City City Council Melendez-Lopez, Esther Not Bad Nogales City City Council Parada, Cesar N Not Bad

12 Oro Valley City City Council Burns, Brendan Friend of the Taxpayer Oro Valley City City Council Garner, William Ally of the Taxpayer Oro Valley City City Council Hiremath, Satish Needs Improvement Oro Valley City City Council Hornat, Joe Needs Improvement Oro Valley City City Council Snider, Mary Needs Improvement Oro Valley City City Council Waters, Lou Needs Improvement Oro Valley City City Council Zinkin, Mike Friend of the Taxpayer Page City City Council Bryan, Michael Ally of the Taxpayer Page City City Council Diak, Bill Not Bad Page City City Council Kocjan, John Needs Much Improvement Page City City Council Sadler, Scott Not Bad Page City City Council Tappan, Levi Ally of the Taxpayer Page City City Council Tennis, David Not Bad Page City City Council Warner, Dennis Ally of the Taxpayer Paradise Valley City City Council Collins, Michael Friend of Big Government Paradise Valley City City Council Dembow, Paul Friend of Big Government Paradise Valley City City Council Vacant (PV) Needs Much Improvement Paradise Valley City City Council LeMarr, Scott Needs Much Improvement Paradise Valley City City Council Schweiker, Dan Ally of Big Government Paradise Valley City City Council Sherf, David Needs Much Improvement Paradise Valley City City Council Trueblood, Lisa Ally of Big Government Parker City City Council Beaver, Dan NA Ally of Big Government Parker City City Council Hartless, Vivian -5-5 Champ. of Big Government Parker City City Council Collett, Hal -5-5 Champ. of Big Government Parker City City Council Hooper, Jerry Needs Improvement Parker City City Council Savino, Frank 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Parker City City Council Shontz, Marion 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Parker City City Council Yackley, Frank Ally of Big Government Patagonia City City Council Coleman, James F F -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Patagonia City City Council Gilbert, Meg F F -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Patagonia City City Council Isakson, R.E. F F -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Patagonia City City Council Quiroga, Gilbert F F -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Patagonia City City Council Wood, Andrea F F -1-1 Needs Much Improvement

13 Payson City City Council Blair, Ed Needs Improvement Payson City City Council Carpenter, Fred Needs Improvement Payson City City Council Connell, Su Not Bad Payson City City Council Croy, Rick Needs Improvement Payson City City Council Evans, Kenny Needs Improvement Payson City City Council Hughes, Michael Needs Improvement Payson City City Council Wilson, John Needs Improvement Peoria City City Council Aames, Ron Ally of the Taxpayer Peoria City City Council Barrett, Bob Ally of the Taxpayer Peoria City City Council Toma, Ben 0 0 Vacant Peoria City City Council Edwards, Jon Ally of the Taxpayer Peoria City City Council Leone, Carlo Ally of the Taxpayer Peoria City City Council Patena, Bill Ally of the Taxpayer Peoria City City Council Rivero, Tony Ally of the Taxpayer Phoenix City City Council DiCiccio, Sal Champion of the Taxpayer Phoenix City City Council Gates, Bill Champion of the Taxpayer Phoenix City City Council Pastor, Laura 0 0 Needs Improvement Phoenix City City Council Nowakowski, Michael Not Bad Phoenix City City Council Gallego, Kate 0 0 Needs Improvement Phoenix City City Council Stanton, Greg Needs Much Improvement Phoenix City City Council Valenzuela, Daniel Friend of the Taxpayer Phoenix City City Council Waring, Jim Hero of the Taxpayer Phoenix City City Council Williams, Thelda Ally of the Taxpayer Pima City City Council Carter, Don F 2 FTP Failed to Post Pima City City Council Claridge, Thomas F F 2 FTP Failed to Post Pima City City Council Lemen, George F F 2 FTP Failed to Post Pima City City Council Rogers, Dale F 2 FTP Failed to Post Pima City City Council Woods, Russell F F 2 FTP Failed to Post Pima County Supervisor Bronson, Sharon Needs Improvement Pima County Supervisor Carroll, Ray Friend of the Taxpayer Pima County Supervisor Elias, Richard Needs Improvement Pima County Supervisor Miller, Ally Friend of the Taxpayer Pima County Supervisor Valadez, Ramon Needs Improvement

14 AVG. Cumulative Designation Pima Community College Board Member Cortez, Marty Not Bad Pima Community College Board Member Even, Brenda Not Bad Pima Community College Board Member Lee, Sylvia Friend of the Taxpayer Pima Community College Board Member Longoria, David Not Bad Pima Community College Board Member Stewart, Scott (PCC) Ally of the Taxpayer Pinal County Supervisor Chase, Cheryl Not Bad Pinal County Supervisor House, Todd Not Bad Pinal County Supervisor Miller, Stephen Not Bad Pinal County Supervisor Rios, Pete Not Bad Pinal County Supervisor Smith, Anthony Not Bad Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Vacant (Pinetop) 0 0 Needs Improvement Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Irwin, Stephanie Needs Improvement Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Place, Patrick Friend of Big Government Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Cannon, Chris 0 0 Needs Improvement Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Vanesian, Dara Ally of Big Government Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Wessel, Leslee Needs Much Improvement Pinetop-Lakeside City City Council Williams, Roger Friend of Big Government Prescott City City Council Arnold, Charlie Not Bad Prescott City City Council Blair, Steve Not Bad Prescott City City Council Lazzell, Greg 1 1 Not Bad Prescott City City Council Kuknyo, Chirs Not Bad Prescott City City Council Kuykendall, Marlin Ally of the Taxpayer Prescott City City Council Lamerson, Jim Not Bad Prescott City City Council Wilcox, Jean 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Prescott Valley City City Council Anderson, Rick Not Bad Prescott Valley City City Council Grossman, Martin Needs Much Improvement Prescott Valley City City Council Mallory, Mary Needs Improvement Prescott Valley City City Council Marshall, Stephen Needs Much Improvement Prescott Valley City City Council Nye, Lora Lee Not Bad Prescott Valley City City Council Skoog, Harvey Not Bad Prescott Valley City City Council Whiting, Michael Needs Improvement

15 Quartzsite City City Council Crooks, Norma NA Not Bad Quartzsite City City Council Foster, Ed NA Friend of the Taxpayer Quartzsite City City Council Jewitt, Mike NA Needs Much Improvement Quartzsite City City Council Kelley, Carol NA Not Bad Quartzsite City City Council Orgeron, Mark NA Not Bad Quartzsite City City Council Scott, Mary NA Friend of the Taxpayer Quartzsite City City Council Timberlake, Monica NA Friend of the Taxpayer Queen Creek City City Council Barnes, Craig Ally of the Taxpayer Queen Creek City City Council Barney, Gail Needs Improvement Queen Creek City City Council Benning, Robin Ally of the Taxpayer Queen Creek City City Council Brown, Jeff Ally of the Taxpayer Queen Creek City City Council Gad, Jason Needs Improvement Queen Creek City City Council Oliphant, Dawn Ally of the Taxpayer Queen Creek City City Council Wheatley, Julia Ally of the Taxpayer Safford City City Council Bingham, Mary Ally of Big Government Safford City City Council Gibbs, Wyn "Chris" Ally of Big Government Safford City City Council Howes, James Ally of Big Government Safford City City Council Lopez, Arnold Ally of Big Government Safford City City Council Malloque, Kenneth Ally of Big Government Safford City City Council Ortega, Richard Needs Much Improvement Safford City City Council Seale, Gene Ally of Big Government Sahuarita City City Council Blumberg, Duane Not Bad Sahuarita City City Council Bracco, Bill Needs Improvement Sahuarita City City Council Egbert, Kara Not Bad Sahuarita City City Council Lusk, Gil Needs Improvement Sahuarita City City Council Murphy, Tom Needs Improvement Sahuarita City City Council Skelton, Lynne Needs Improvement Sahuarita City City Council Smith, Melissa Needs Improvement San Luis City City Council Harper, Joe Needs Improvement San Luis City City Council Luna-Carrasco, Africa Ally of Big Government San Luis City City Council Pinzon, Marco A Needs Improvement San Luis City City Council Rosales, Matias Needs Improvement San Luis City City Council Ramos, Maria Needs Improvement San Luis City City Council Sanchez, Gerry NA Needs Much Improvement San Luis City City Council Torres, Gloria Needs Improvement

16 Santa Cruz County Supervisor Maynard, John Needs Improvement Santa Cruz County Supervisor Molera, Rudy Needs Improvement Santa Cruz County Supervisor Ruiz, Manuel Needs Improvement Scottsdale City City Council Klapp, Suzanne Needs Improvement Scottsdale City City Council Korte, Virginia Friend of the Taxpayer Scottsdale City City Council Lane, Jim Not Bad Scottsdale City City Council Littlefield, Robert Not Bad Scottsdale City City Council Milhaven, Linda Ally of the Taxpayer Scottsdale City City Council Philips, Guy Friend of the Taxpayer Scottsdale City City Council Robbins, Dennis Ally of the Taxpayer Sedona City City Council Adams, Rob Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council DiNunzio, Mark Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council Litrell, Barbara Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council Martinez, John Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council McIlroy, Dan Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council Ward, Mike Needs Improvement Sedona City City Council Williamson, Jessica Needs Improvement Show Low City City Council Allsop, Mike Needs Improvement Show Low City City Council Crittenden, Rennie Needs Much Improvement Show Low City City Council Hatch, Brent Ally of the Taxpayer Show Low City City Council Kakavas, Connie Needs Improvement Show Low City City Council Kelley, Gene Needs Improvement Show Low City City Council Leech Jr., John Needs Improvement Show Low City City Council Seymore, Daryl Needs Improvement Sierra Vista City City Council Blanchard, Bob Not Bad Sierra Vista City City Council Calhoun, Gwen Not Bad Sierra Vista City City Council Crosby, Tom Ally of the Taxpayer Sierra Vista City City Council Gray, Rachel Friend of the Taxpayer Sierra Vista City City Council Huisking, Henrietta Needs Improvement Sierra Vista City City Council Mueller, Rick Not Bad Sierra Vista City City Council Reardon, Tom Not Bad

17 Snowflake City City Council Ballard, Kerry 0 NA Needs Improvement Snowflake City City Council Hensley, Stuart Needs Much Improvement Snowflake City City Council Johnson, Lynn Needs Much Improvement Snowflake City City Council Kay, Bev Needs Much Improvement Snowflake City City Council Poscharsky, Tom Needs Much Improvement Snowflake City City Council Whiting, Jason Needs Much Improvement Snowflake City City Council Willis, Kelly 0 NA Needs Improvement Somerton City City Council Anaya, Gerardo Needs Much Improvement Somerton City City Council Galindo, Luis 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Somerton City City Council Gonzales, Carlos Friend of Big Government Somerton City City Council Porchas, Martin 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Somerton City City Council Ramirez, Laura 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Somerton City City Council Villalpando, Miguel 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Somerton City City Council Yepez, Jose 0 NA Needs Much Improvement South Tucson City City Council Diaz, Paul Ally of the Taxpayer South Tucson City City Council Rojas, Miguel Ally of the Taxpayer South Tucson City City Council Mendoza, Vanessa Needs Improvement South Tucson City City Council Romero, Anita Friend of the Taxpayer South Tucson City City Council Patino, Oscsar Friend of the Taxpayer South Tucson City City Council Soltero, Mary Needs Improvement South Tucson City City Council Green, Ildefonso Ally of the Taxpayer Springerville City City Council Nedrow, Mary 0 NA Not Bad Springerville City City Council MacKenzie, Robert 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Springerville City City Council Davis, Richard 3 3 Friend of the Taxpayer Springerville City City Council Silva, Susan F Ally of the Taxpayer Springerville City City Council Wilkins, Phelps NA Friend of the Taxpayer St. Johns City City Council Raykovitz, Tony 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer St. Johns City City Council Cirivello, Mike F 2 0 Needs Improvement St. Johns City City Council Hancock, Pete F 2 0 Needs Improvement St. Johns City City Council Hauser, Kay F 2 1 Not Bad St. Johns City City Council Richardson, John 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer St. Johns City City Council Patterson, Ryan 0 1 F 2 1 Not Bad St. Johns City City Council Udall, Spence 0 1 F 2 1 Not Bad

18 Star Valley City City Council Binney, George F Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council Coon, Gary F Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council Hartwell, Barbara F Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council Henderson, Paty F Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council Leis, Vern F Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council McDaniel, Ronnie Needs Much Improvement Star Valley City City Council Newland, Del F Needs Much Improvement Superior City City Council Cooper, Steve -5-5 Champ. of Big Government Superior City City Council Alonzo, Michael Ally of Big Government Superior City City Council Estatico, Steve Ally of Big Government Superior City City Council Lopez, Olga Needs Improvement Superior City City Council Besich-Lira, Mila -5-5 Champ. of Big Government Superior City City Council Tameron, John Not Bad Superior City City Council Valenzuela, Jayme Not Bad Surprise City City Council Tande, Todd -5-5 Champ. of Big Government Surprise City City Council Biundo, Jim Friend of Big Government Surprise City City Council Hall, Skip Needs Improvement Surprise City City Council Villanueva, Rachel Hero of Big Government Surprise City City Council Williams, John Needs Improvement Surprise City City Council Wolcott, Sharon Needs Much Improvement Surprise City City Council Winters, Roland Needs Much Improvement Taylor City City Council Brubaker, Jason Not Bad Taylor City City Council Cosper, Carl Not Bad Taylor City City Council DeWitt, Lynn Not Bad Taylor City City Council Hatch, Fay Needs Much Improvement Taylor City City Council Palmer, Shawn Needs Much Improvement Taylor City City Council Smith, David Not Bad Taylor City City Council Solomon, Gary Needs Much Improvement Tempe City City Council Arredondo-Savage, Robin Needs Much Improvement Tempe City City Council Ellis, Shana Needs Much Improvement Tempe City City Council Granville, Kolby Not Bad Tempe City City Council Mitchell, Mark Needs Much Improvement Tempe City City Council Navarro, Joel Needs Improvement Tempe City City Council Shekerjian, Onnie Not Bad Tempe City City Council Woods, Corey Needs Improvement

19 Thatcher City City Council Allen, Aaron Needs Much Improvement Thatcher City City Council Griffin, D. Wayne Needs Improvement Thatcher City City Council Innes, Donald 0 NA Needs Improvement Thatcher City City Council Larson, Kenneth 0 NA Needs Improvement Thatcher City City Council Martin, Joy Needs Much Improvement Thatcher City City Council Mulleneaux, Bill 0 NA Needs Improvement Thatcher City City Council Rivera, Bob 0 NA Needs Improvement Tolleson City City Council Erives, Clorinda Not Bad Tolleson City City Council Vacant (Tolleson) 0 0 Needs Improvement Tolleson City City Council Farr, Kathie -1 NA Needs Improvement Tolleson City City Council Gamez, Adolfo -1 NA Not Bad Tolleson City City Council Laborin, Linda 0 NA Needs Improvement Tolleson City City Council Mendoza, Albert 0 NA Needs Improvement Tolleson City City Council Rodriguez, Juan 0 NA Needs Improvement Tombstone City City Council Aiton, Don 2 2 Ally of the Taxpayer Tombstone City City Council Korbeck-Reeder, Stacey F -1 F F 2 FTP Failed to Post Tombstone City City Council Schmidt, Stephen F F 2 FTP Failed to Post Tombstone City City Council Taylor, Don F 2 FTP Failed to Post Tombstone City City Council Villa, Armando F 2 FTP Failed to Post Tucson City City Council Cunningham, Paul Needs Improvement Tucson City City Council Fimbres, Richard Needs Improvement Tucson City City Council Kozachik, Steve Ally of the Taxpayer Tucson City City Council Romero, Regina Needs Improvement Tucson City City Council Rothschild, Jonathan Not Bad Tucson City City Council Scott, Shirley C Needs Much Improvement Tucson City City Council Uhlich, Karin Needs Much Improvement Tusayan City City Council Bryan, Greg Friend of Big Government Tusayan City City Council Fitzgerald, Bill Ally of Big Government Tusayan City City Council Montoya, Al Friend of Big Government Tusayan City City Council Rueter, John Friend of Big Government Tusayan City City Council Sanderson, Craig Ally of Big Government Wellton City City Council Bejarano, Alejandro F 0 F F 5 FTP Failed to Post Wellton City City Council Bornt, Vickie F 5 FTP Failed to Post Wellton City City Council Deermer, James F 0 F F 5 FTP Failed to Post Wellton City City Council Jameson, Lisa M. F F 5 FTP Failed to Post Wellton City City Council McCollough, Cecilia F 0 F F 5 FTP Failed to Post

20 Wickenburg City City Council Band, Chris -1 NA Needs Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Blunt, Kelly Needs Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Cook, John -1 NA Needs Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Crissman, Sam Needs Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Kardinal, Royce Needs Much Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Madrid, Ruben Needs Much Improvement Wickenburg City City Council Stewart, Scott (W) -1 NA Needs Improvement Willcox City City Council Cronberg, Monika 3 NA Not Bad Willcox City City Council Goolsby, Earl B Friend of the Taxpayer Willcox City City Council Holloway, William Ally of the Taxpayer Willcox City City Council Irvin, Robert Friend of the Taxpayer Willcox City City Council Johnson, Elwood 3 NA Friend of the Taxpayer Willcox City City Council Lindsey, Gerald NA Not Bad Willcox City City Council Nigh, William Friend of the Taxpayer Williams City City Council Dent, Don F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council Fritsinger, Craig F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council Hiemenz, Bernie F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council McNelly, Frank F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council Moore, John F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council Payne, Lee F Needs Much Improvement Williams City City Council Wurgler, Jim F Needs Much Improvement Winkelman City City Council Failed to Post F FTP Failed to Post Winkelman City City Council Failed to Post F FTP Failed to Post Winkelman City City Council Failed to Post F FTP Failed to Post Winkelman City City Council Failed to Post F FTP Failed to Post Winkelman City City Council Failed to Post F FTP Failed to Post Winslow City City Council Boyd, Robin -5 NA Not Bad Winslow City City Council Cake, Peter -5 NA Not Bad Winslow City City Council Hardy, Curtis Ally of the Taxpayer Winslow City City Council Chacon, Thomas R. NA Ally of the Taxpayer Winslow City City Council Losey, Marshall NA Ally of the Taxpayer Winslow City City Council Schlesinger, Bob Ally of the Taxpayer Winslow City City Council Soehner, Harold -5 NA Not Bad

21 AVG. Cumulative Designation Yavapai County Supervisor Brown, Craig Not Bad Yavapai County Supervisor Davis, Chip Needs Improvement Yavapai County Supervisor Smith, Jack Not Bad Yavapai County Supervisor Simmons, Rowle Not Bad Yavapai County Supervisor Thurman, Thomas Needs Improvement Youngtown City City Council Chittenden, Margaret 0 NA Ally of Big Government Youngtown City City Council Duran, Jacob "Jack" 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Youngtown City City Council Johnson, Judy Ally of Big Government Youngtown City City Council Miller, June Not Bad Youngtown City City Council LeVault, Michael 0 NA Ally of Big Government Youngtown City City Council Mello, Dorena 0 NA Needs Much Improvement Youngtown City City Council Oglesby Gustafson, Shirley 0 NA Ally of Big Government Yuma City City Council Beeson, Cody Not Bad Yuma City City Council Craft, William -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Yuma City City Council Knight, Gary -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Yuma City City Council Nicholls, Douglas Not Bad Yuma City City Council McClendon, Leslie Needs Improvement Yuma City City Council Wright, Gary -1-1 Needs Much Improvement Yuma City City Council Thomas, Edward Ally of the Taxpayer Yuma County Supervisor Clark, Russ Ally of the Taxpayer Yuma County Supervisor Ferguson, Greg Needs Improvement Yuma County Supervisor McCloud, Russell Needs Improvement Yuma County Supervisor Reyes, Marco "Tony" Needs Improvement Yuma County Supervisor Stuart, Lenore Loroña Needs Improvement