trading ambiguity: a tale of two heterogeneities
|
|
- Mitchell Carson
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 trading ambiguity: a tale of two heterogeneities Sujoy Mukerji, Queen Mary, University of London Han Ozsoylev, Koç University and University of Oxford Jean-Marc Tallon, Paris School of Economics, CNRS ICEF Moscow, 28 October 2017
2 introduction: general research question What does ambiguity and ambiguity aversion, on top of risk and risk aversion, add to our understanding of financial and economic arrangements? 2
3 introduction: ambiguity Risk can be expressed using a single probability distribution. For instance, x N(θ, σ), θ and σ known Ambiguity cannot be expressed using a single probability distribution. Agents are uncertain about the true probability. For instance, x N(θ, σ), θ and/or σ unknown (e.g., θ N(µ, ζ), or θ [0, 2]...) Experimental evidence dating back to Ellsberg (1961) documents that a majority of subjects exhibit aversion to ambiguity. 3
4 introduction: related literature Ambiguity models have had some success in explaining (aggregate) asset pricing puzzles Epstein & Wang (1994), Cao, Wang & Zhang (2005), Ju & Miao (2012), Epstein & Schneider (2008), Hansen & Sargent (2015), Collard et al. (2016)... Regarding quantities: Zero position / No trade / Liquidity Dow & Werlang (1992), Mukerji & Tallon (2001), Easley & O Hara (2009), Ozsoylev & Werner (2010), Illeditsch et al. (2015)... Portfolio efficiency Wang (2005), Hara and Honda (2016),... Risk sharing Dana et al. (2000), Rigotti et al. (2008), Strzalecki & Werner (2011),... Home Bias/ Diversification Epstein & Miao (2003), Dimmock et al. (2016),... Speculative trade Werner (2015),... 4
5 introduction: what we do Our focus is on portfolio choice, asset pricing and trade at equilibrium in a model with two kinds of heterogeneities: differently ambiguous assets, differently ambiguity averse agents. Core mechanism: portfolio rebalancing due to heterogeneity in ambiguity and ambiguity aversion. 5
6 introduction: a loose empirical background/motivation 1. Asset allocation puzzle (Canner, Mankiw and Weil, 1997): Why is it that financial advisors propose different funds depending on how conservative/agressive clients are? 2. Documented departures from CAPM (e.g., Fama and French, 1992, 1993): firms of small market cap, or with high book-to-market ratio tend to earn higher returns. 3. Trade following earnings announcements (Kandel and Pearson, 1995): Observe large volume of trade after public announcements (even without any significant price change). difficult to reconcile with usual risk modelling we provide a simple departure from expected utility that provides a theoretical framework that helps thinking about/providing possible explanations for these different problems simultaneously. 6
7 static setting: asset structure - one risk-free asset, two uncertain assets - R: return vector for uncertain assets - M represents model a model can be thought of as fixing the means of uncertain asset returns - R M N(M, Σ R Σ M ): distribution of R conditional on model M. Model uncertainty only affects the conditional mean of the return, not its variance. Model and asset returns are jointly distributed according to: ( ) (( ) ( )) M µ Σ M Σ M N, R µ Σ M Σ R where Σ M = ( (σ1 M)2 σ12 M σ12 M (σ2 M)2 ) and Σ R = ( (σ 1 ) 2 σ 12 σ 12 (σ 2 ) 2 ) 7
8 static setting: preferences - CARA: u(x) = exp( θx) - Overall utility given by smooth ambiguity model of Klibanoff, Marinacci and Mukerji (2005): U(Z) = E [Φ (Eu(Z) M)] with Φ(z) = ( z) γ/θ - Denote η γ θ 1, the coefficient of relative ambiguity aversion of the decision maker. 8
9 maximization problem - a i : monetary holding of asset i = f, 1, 2, equal to q i p i - normalize p f = 1 - Notation a i,n when deal with several agents, n = 1,..., N. Maximization problem Max af,a 1,a 2 U(a f R f + a 1 R 1 + a 2 R 2 ) subject to a f + a 1 + a 2 W. Let a = (a 1, a 2 ). Maximization of U(.) is equivalent to maximization of (see Maccheroni, Marinacci, Ruffino (2013) as well) : Max af,av (a f, a) = a f R f + µ a θ 2 a Σ X a γ θ a Σ M a 2 Note: when γ = θ, i.e., η = 0, then model variance Σ M is not relevant for asset demand and we are back to the standard mean-variance preference. 9
10 portfolio choice Ratio of demand for the two uncertain assets: a i = (µ ( i R f ) σ 2 j + η(σj M ) 2) (µ j R f ) ( σ 12 + ησ12) M a j (µ j R f ) ( σi 2 + η(σi M ) 2) (µ i R f ) ( ) σ 12 + ησ12 M does not depend on risk aversion. Ambiguity aversion, η, affects demand, via the weight put on model variance. Under ambiguity neutrality (η = 0) or homogenous ambiguity aversion (i.e., same η for all), we have the mutual fund theorem. 10
11 comparative statics Theorem 1: Assume µ 1 Rf µ 2 R f σm 1 σ M 2 σ 1 σ 2 σm 1 σ M 2, and If agent n is more ambiguity averse than agent n, i.e., η n > η n, then. a 1,n < a1,n a 2,n a 2,n and q 1,n < q1,n. q 2,n q 2,n 11
12 comparative ambiguity Asset 1 is more ambiguous (I) than asset 2 in the sense of Jewitt-Mukerji (2017) if all ambiguity neutral preferences are indifferent between the two assets and all ambiguity averse preferences in the class (here KMM) prefer 2 to 1. Asset 1 is more ambiguous (I) than asset 2 if µ 1 = µ 2, σ 1 = σ 2 and σ M 1 > σm 2 > 0 Theorem 1 says that if asset 1 is more ambiguous (I) than asset 2, a more ambiguity averse investor will hold proportionally less of it. 12
13 comparative ambiguity Notion of more ambiguous (I) rather restrictive (fixes mean and variance of the unconditional distribution). Jewitt-Mukerji (2017) develop another notion that amounts here to saying that asset 1 is more ambiguous (II) than asset 2 if σ M 1 > σm 2 Theorem 1 says that if asset 1 is sufficiently more ambiguous (II) than asset 2, a more ambiguity averse investor will hold proportionally less of it. 13
14 asset allocation puzzle: canner, mankiw, weil (1997) Table I - Asset Allocations Recommended By Financial Advisors Percent of portfolio Advisor and investor type Cash Bonds Stocks Ratio of bonds to stocks A. Fidelity Conservative Moderate Aggressive B. Merrill Lynch Conservative Moderate Aggressive C. Jane Bryant Quinn Conservative Moderate Aggressive D. New York Times Conservative Moderate Aggressive
15 asset allocation puzzle: a possible resolution? Table II - The Distribution of Annual Real Returns Arithmetic Standard Correlation Correlation Asset mean return (%) deviation (%) w/ bonds w/ stocks Treasury bills Long-term government bonds Common stock If interpret all uncertainty as mere risk, cannot explain financial advice that depends on risk aversion in simple ways. If think that there is also model uncertainty, and it is more accentuated for equity, then room for explaining this advice. 15
16 equilibrium asset pricing - Move now to equilibrium analysis. Assets are in fixed aggregate supply (e 1, e 2 ). Take safe asset to be inside asset. - Let p1e1r1+p2e2r2 p 1e 1+p 2e 2 R Market be the market portfolio return. Theorem 2: Assume a continuum of investors with ambiguity aversion distributed according to some continuous distribution function on [η, η], then there exists an η m [η, η] such that where E[R i ] r f = β i (η m ) (E[R Market ] r f ) β i (η m ) = cov(r Market, R i ) + η m cov M (R Market, R i ) var(r Market ) + η m var M. (R Market ) 16
17 ambiguous capm Under ambiguity neutrality, usual CAPM formula. Ruffino (2014) derives a similar CAPM-like formula but with homogeneously ambiguity averse agents. As shown earlier, the mutual fund theorem holds with homogeneity in ambiguity aversion. Here, we derive a CAPM-like formula with heterogeneity of ambiguity aversion, i.e., without the mutual fund theorem. Different agents still hold different portfolios, and yet, a CAPM-like single-factor pricing model holds. 17
18 link with documented departures from capm Let us now define βi Risk (η m ) = cov(r Market, R i ) var(r Market ) }{{} OLS coefficient estimate and β Amb i (η m ) = cov M (R Market, R i ) var M. (R Market ) Then, where α i E[R i ] r f = α i + β Risk i (η m ) (E[R Market ] r f ) η mvar M (R Market ) var(r Market )+η mvar M (R Market ) ( β Amb i (η m ) βi Risk (η m ) ) (E[R Market ] r f ). could be exploited to address empirical puzzles (e.g., Fama-French factors beyond the market risk premium) 18
19 why? Small firms are followed by fewer equity analysts. So, less information about them, i.e., more ambiguity. Also, small firms are more dependent on bank financing and therefore more likely to default compared to firms which can rely on equity financing. Hence, more susceptible financial distress, associated with heightened uncertainty. High book-to-market ratio is often a sign of financial distress (Fama-French interpretation). Therefore, overall, small caps and high book-to-market firms are more sensitive to macro uncertainty shocks, hence they carry higher systematic ambiguity. 19
20 dynamic extension: modeling earnings announcements - Simple extension of previous model: two trading periods. - Two long-term uncertain assets (in fixed equal supply) and a short-term risk-free asset. - No intermediate consumption. - Trade at t = 0. - At t = 1 get a signal, update beliefs, get the return on risk free-asset, and re-trade while prices of uncertain assets adjust. - At time t = 2, get the exogenous returns on the two uncertain assets, return on the risk-free asset and consume. 20
21 dynamic extension: signal structure and asset returns - Signal structure: M R N S µ µ µ, Σ M Σ M Σ M Σ M Σ R 0 Σ M 0 Σ R - Conditional on a model, R and S are i.i.d. The signal informs about the underlying model, but does not provide direct evidence about the realization of the payoff in the last period. ( R M S M ) N (( M M ), ( Σ R Σ M 0 0 Σ R Σ M )) - Let M S be the posterior for M after observing S. Then M S N (µ S, Σ S ) where µ S is a linear function of S, and Σ S does not depend on realization S. 21
22 trivial vs non-trivial trading the equilibrium entails trivial trading at signal realization S if the composition of the uncertain portfolio stays the same across periods 0 and 1 for all agents, but the split between the uncertain portfolio and the risk-free asset changes for at least one agent the equilibrium entails non-trivial trading at signal realization S if the composition of the uncertain portfolio changes period 0 to 1 for some agent the equilibrium entails no trade at signal realization S if it entails neither trivial nor non-trivial trading 22
23 a trade result Theorem 3: The equilibrium entails non-trivial trading at almost all signal realizations if agents are heterogenous in ambiguity aversion. If agents are homogenous in ambiguity aversion, then the equilibrium entails no trade at any signal realization. If agents are homogeneous in ambiguity aversion, then they do not change their uncertain portfolio composition after receipt of a public signal: they hold the market portfolio as their uncertain portfolio in both periods. If agents are heterogeneous in ambiguity aversion and interim, assets bear different ambiguity then they change their uncertain portfolio composition after receipt of the signal. 23
24 numerical illustration σ1 2 =.04 σ2 2 =.04 risk correlation=.5 µ 1 = 1.12 µ 2 = 1.12 r f = 1.05 (5%) ambiguity correlation =.5 Different scenarios used for the asset ambiguity (model variance): scenario 1 σ1 M =.0007 σm 2 =.0007 scenario 2 σ1 M =.0006 σm 2 =.0008 scenario 3 σ1 M =.0008 σm 2 =.0016 scenario 4 σ1 M =.0006 σm 2 =
25 trade without price movements 8 % 10 % 6 % Trading Volume 4 % Trading Volume 5 % 2 % 0 % 0 % Agent 2's Ambiguity Aversion Agent 2's Ambiguity Aversion Trading volumes for assets 1 & 2: These graphs depict trading volume for asset 1 (left panel) and 2 (right panel) in the four scenarios, for a particular signal realization that leads to no change in prices. The ambiguity aversion of agent 1 is fixed at η 1 = 9. 25
26 likelihood of trade 0 % 5 % 10 % 15 % Trading Volume 0 % 5 % 10 % 15 % Trading Volume Histogram of trading volumes for assets 1 & 2: These graphs depict the histogram of trading volume in asset 1 (left panel) and 2 (right panel) for scenarios 2 (pale grey), 3 (grey) and 4 (black) for the asset ambiguity for a thousand realizations of the signals. The ambiguity aversions are fixed as η 1 = 9 and η 2 = 2. 26
27 discussion All investors start with same (second order) beliefs. Updating upon arrival of interim information. All investors have the same (second order) revised beliefs, that depend on the public information received. change in the mean of second order distribution this depends on realization of S change in ambiguity that is, variance of second order distribution state independent (does not depend on realization of S) How does this lead to trade? Prices could adapt to state dependent change in the mean so that demand remains the same (this is what happens under risk). But change in ambiguity together with heterogeneous ambiguity aversion leads to agent-specific change in the asset demand functions. Prices therefore cannot fully adjust, and trade follows. 27
28 uncertainty shocks Model with only 3 interim states. Signals indicate (H)igh, (I)ntermediate or (L)ow ambiguity. Assume the mean of M, µ, to be independent of S. For each realization S = H, I, L, the posterior M S satisfies: M S N(µ, Σ S ) and X M S N(M S, Σ X Σ S ) where one can think of the following specification: Σ L = λ L Σ, Σ I = λ I Σ, and Σ H = λ H Σ where Σ is some positive definite matrix and λ H > λ I > λ L (in numerical example below take λ H = 2, λ I = 1 and λ L = 1/2). 28
29 trading under uncertainty shocks In this setup, agents hold the market portfolio ex ante. Interim, after the realisation of S = L, I, H, we are as in the static framework and, under heterogeneity of ambiguity aversion will hold different portfolio. trade & portfolio choice implications: (i) The volume of trade is higher, the larger the uncertainty, i.e., it is higher when H is realized, than when I is realized, which is in turn higher than when L is realized. (ii) The distance from the market portfolio is higher, the larger the uncertainty. 29
30 numerical simulation: trading volume 10 % 30 % Trading Volume 5 % Trading Volume 20 % 10 % 0 % 0 % Agent 2's Ambiguity Aversion Agent 2's Ambiguity Aversion Trading volume in assets 1 & 2 with uncertainty shocks: This graph depicts the trading volume in assets 1 (left panel) & 2 (right panel) following an uncertainty shock (H,I,L). The ambiguity aversion of agent 1 is fixed at η 1 = 9. 30
31 numerical simulation: distance from the market portfolio 10 % Distance from Market Portfolio 5 % 0 % Agent 2's Ambiguity Aversion Distance of the equilibrium portfolio to the market portfolio: This graph depicts the distance of agent 1 portfolio from the market portfolio following an uncertainty shock (H,I,L). The ambiguity aversion of agent 1 is fixed at η 1 = 9. 31
32 conclusion Under heterogeneous ambiguity aversion: different investors will optimally hold different uncertain portfolios. There is an ambiguity premium: an asset, whose ambiguity beta is higher than its risk beta, carries a premium compared to its CAPM-predicted return. Provide a derivation of a CAPM-like formula under ambiguity aversion, which holds promises to provide some intuitive explanation to cross-sectional asset pricing anomalies. Trade upon receiving public information whenever investors have different ambiguity aversion. Can generate trade even without (large) price movements. All this with, we hope, an intuitive underlying mechanism based on heterogeneity among uncertain assets and across agents. 32
Risk and Ambiguity in Asset Returns
Risk and Ambiguity in Asset Returns Cross-Sectional Differences Chiaki Hara and Toshiki Honda KIER, Kyoto University and ICS, Hitotsubashi University KIER, Kyoto University April 6, 2017 Hara and Honda
More informationAmbiguous Information and Trading Volume in stock market
Ambiguous Information and Trading Volume in stock market Meng-Wei Chen Department of Economics, Indiana University at Bloomington April 21, 2011 Abstract This paper studies the information transmission
More informationLiquidity and Asset Prices in Rational Expectations Equilibrium with Ambiguous Information
Liquidity and Asset Prices in Rational Expectations Equilibrium with Ambiguous Information Han Ozsoylev SBS, University of Oxford Jan Werner University of Minnesota September 006, revised March 007 Abstract:
More informationParticipation in Risk Sharing under Ambiguity
Participation in Risk Sharing under Ambiguity Jan Werner December 2013, revised August 2014. Abstract: This paper is about (non) participation in efficient risk sharing in an economy where agents have
More informationInformation Inertia. June 6, Abstract
Information Inertia Scott Condie Jayant Ganguli Philipp Karl Illeditsch June 6, 2012 Abstract We study how information about an asset affects optimal portfolios and equilibrium asset prices when investors
More informationInformation Inertia. ScholarlyCommons. University of Pennsylvania. Scott Condie. Jayant Ganguli. Philipp Karl Illeditsch University of Pennsylvania
University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Finance Papers Wharton Faculty Research 1-28-2013 Information Inertia Scott Condie Jayant Ganguli Philipp Karl Illeditsch University of Pennsylvania Follow this
More informationSpeculative Trade under Ambiguity
Speculative Trade under Ambiguity Jan Werner March 2014. Abstract: Ambiguous beliefs may lead to speculative trade and speculative bubbles. We demonstrate this by showing that the classical Harrison and
More informationThe Capital Asset Pricing Model CAPM: benchmark model of the cost of capital
70391 - Finance The Capital Asset Pricing Model CAPM: benchmark model of the cost of capital 70391 Finance Fall 2016 Tepper School of Business Carnegie Mellon University c 2016 Chris Telmer. Some content
More informationWorkshop on the pricing and hedging of environmental and energy-related financial derivatives
Socially efficient discounting under ambiguity aversion Workshop on the pricing and hedging of environmental and energy-related financial derivatives National University of Singapore, December 7-9, 2009
More informationFinal Exam Suggested Solutions
University of Washington Fall 003 Department of Economics Eric Zivot Economics 483 Final Exam Suggested Solutions This is a closed book and closed note exam. However, you are allowed one page of handwritten
More informationSpeculative Trade under Ambiguity
Speculative Trade under Ambiguity Jan Werner November 2014, revised March 2017 Abstract: Ambiguous beliefs may lead to speculative trade and speculative bubbles. We demonstrate this by showing that the
More informationAmbiguous Information, Risk Aversion, and Asset Pricing
Ambiguous Information, Risk Aversion, and Asset Pricing Philipp Karl ILLEDITSCH February 14, 2009 Abstract I study the effects of aversion to risk and ambiguity (uncertainty in the sense of Knight (1921))
More informationConsumption and Portfolio Decisions When Expected Returns A
Consumption and Portfolio Decisions When Expected Returns Are Time Varying September 10, 2007 Introduction In the recent literature of empirical asset pricing there has been considerable evidence of time-varying
More informationSignal or noise? Uncertainty and learning whether other traders are informed
Signal or noise? Uncertainty and learning whether other traders are informed Snehal Banerjee (Northwestern) Brett Green (UC-Berkeley) AFA 2014 Meetings July 2013 Learning about other traders Trade motives
More informationApplied Macro Finance
Master in Money and Finance Goethe University Frankfurt Week 8: From factor models to asset pricing Fall 2012/2013 Please note the disclaimer on the last page Announcements Solution to exercise 1 of problem
More informationOne-Period Valuation Theory
One-Period Valuation Theory Part 2: Chris Telmer March, 2013 1 / 44 1. Pricing kernel and financial risk 2. Linking state prices to portfolio choice Euler equation 3. Application: Corporate financial leverage
More informationLECTURE NOTES 3 ARIEL M. VIALE
LECTURE NOTES 3 ARIEL M VIALE I Markowitz-Tobin Mean-Variance Portfolio Analysis Assumption Mean-Variance preferences Markowitz 95 Quadratic utility function E [ w b w ] { = E [ w] b V ar w + E [ w] }
More informationAmbiguous Information, Risk Aversion, and Asset Pricing
Ambiguous Information, Risk Aversion, and Asset Pricing Philipp Karl ILLEDITSCH May 7, 2009 Abstract I study the effects of aversion to risk and ambiguity (uncertainty in the sense of Knight (1921)) on
More informationSpeculative Trade under Ambiguity
Speculative Trade under Ambiguity Jan Werner March 2014. Abstract: Ambiguous beliefs may lead to speculative trade and speculative bubbles. We demonstrate this by showing that the classical Harrison and
More informationSDMR Finance (2) Olivier Brandouy. University of Paris 1, Panthéon-Sorbonne, IAE (Sorbonne Graduate Business School)
SDMR Finance (2) Olivier Brandouy University of Paris 1, Panthéon-Sorbonne, IAE (Sorbonne Graduate Business School) Outline 1 Formal Approach to QAM : concepts and notations 2 3 Portfolio risk and return
More informationReading the Tea Leaves: Model Uncertainty, Robust Foreca. Forecasts, and the Autocorrelation of Analysts Forecast Errors
Reading the Tea Leaves: Model Uncertainty, Robust Forecasts, and the Autocorrelation of Analysts Forecast Errors December 1, 2016 Table of Contents Introduction Autocorrelation Puzzle Hansen-Sargent Autocorrelation
More informationMacroeconomics Sequence, Block I. Introduction to Consumption Asset Pricing
Macroeconomics Sequence, Block I Introduction to Consumption Asset Pricing Nicola Pavoni October 21, 2016 The Lucas Tree Model This is a general equilibrium model where instead of deriving properties of
More informationFinancial Economics 4: Portfolio Theory
Financial Economics 4: Portfolio Theory Stefano Lovo HEC, Paris What is a portfolio? Definition A portfolio is an amount of money invested in a number of financial assets. Example Portfolio A is worth
More informationLiquidity and Asset Prices in Rational Expectations Equilibrium with Ambiguous Information
Liquidity and Asset Prices in Rational Expectations Equilibrium with Ambiguous Information Han Ozsoylev University of Oxford Jan Werner University of Minnesota Abstract: The quality of information in financial
More informationConsumption- Savings, Portfolio Choice, and Asset Pricing
Finance 400 A. Penati - G. Pennacchi Consumption- Savings, Portfolio Choice, and Asset Pricing I. The Consumption - Portfolio Choice Problem We have studied the portfolio choice problem of an individual
More informationSpeculative Trade under Ambiguity
Speculative Trade under Ambiguity Jan Werner November 2014, revised November 2015 Abstract: Ambiguous beliefs may lead to speculative trade and speculative bubbles. We demonstrate this by showing that
More informationPh.D. Preliminary Examination MICROECONOMIC THEORY Applied Economics Graduate Program June 2017
Ph.D. Preliminary Examination MICROECONOMIC THEORY Applied Economics Graduate Program June 2017 The time limit for this exam is four hours. The exam has four sections. Each section includes two questions.
More informationFIN 6160 Investment Theory. Lecture 7-10
FIN 6160 Investment Theory Lecture 7-10 Optimal Asset Allocation Minimum Variance Portfolio is the portfolio with lowest possible variance. To find the optimal asset allocation for the efficient frontier
More informationDelegated Portfolio Management and Asset Pricing in the Era of Big Data
Delegated Portfolio Management and Asset Pricing in the Era of Big Data Ye Li Chen Wang June 30, 2018 Abstract Big data creates a division of knowledge asset managers use big data and professional techniques
More informationSpeculative Betas. Harrison Hong and David Sraer Princeton University. September 30, 2012
Speculative Betas Harrison Hong and David Sraer Princeton University September 30, 2012 Introduction Model 1 factor static Shorting OLG Exenstion Calibration High Risk, Low Return Puzzle Cumulative Returns
More informationConsumption and Asset Pricing
Consumption and Asset Pricing Yin-Chi Wang The Chinese University of Hong Kong November, 2012 References: Williamson s lecture notes (2006) ch5 and ch 6 Further references: Stochastic dynamic programming:
More informationCharacterization of the Optimum
ECO 317 Economics of Uncertainty Fall Term 2009 Notes for lectures 5. Portfolio Allocation with One Riskless, One Risky Asset Characterization of the Optimum Consider a risk-averse, expected-utility-maximizing
More informationMoral Hazard: Dynamic Models. Preliminary Lecture Notes
Moral Hazard: Dynamic Models Preliminary Lecture Notes Hongbin Cai and Xi Weng Department of Applied Economics, Guanghua School of Management Peking University November 2014 Contents 1 Static Moral Hazard
More informationApplied Macro Finance
Master in Money and Finance Goethe University Frankfurt Week 8: An Investment Process for Stock Selection Fall 2011/2012 Please note the disclaimer on the last page Announcements December, 20 th, 17h-20h:
More informationAsset Pricing with Heterogeneous Consumers
, JPE 1996 Presented by: Rustom Irani, NYU Stern November 16, 2009 Outline Introduction 1 Introduction Motivation Contribution 2 Assumptions Equilibrium 3 Mechanism Empirical Implications of Idiosyncratic
More informationResolution of a Financial Puzzle
Resolution of a Financial Puzzle M.J. Brennan and Y. Xia September, 1998 revised November, 1998 Abstract The apparent inconsistency between the Tobin Separation Theorem and the advice of popular investment
More informationQuantitative Risk Management
Quantitative Risk Management Asset Allocation and Risk Management Martin B. Haugh Department of Industrial Engineering and Operations Research Columbia University Outline Review of Mean-Variance Analysis
More informationPortfolio models - Podgorica
Outline Holding period return Suppose you invest in a stock-index fund over the next period (e.g. 1 year). The current price is 100$ per share. At the end of the period you receive a dividend of 5$; the
More informationRisks for the Long Run: A Potential Resolution of Asset Pricing Puzzles
: A Potential Resolution of Asset Pricing Puzzles, JF (2004) Presented by: Esben Hedegaard NYUStern October 12, 2009 Outline 1 Introduction 2 The Long-Run Risk Solving the 3 Data and Calibration Results
More informationWhat is Cyclical in Credit Cycles?
What is Cyclical in Credit Cycles? Rui Cui May 31, 2014 Introduction Credit cycles are growth cycles Cyclicality in the amount of new credit Explanations: collateral constraints, equity constraints, leverage
More informationAsset Pricing Implications of Social Networks. Han N. Ozsoylev University of Oxford
Asset Pricing Implications of Social Networks Han N. Ozsoylev University of Oxford 1 Motivation - Communication in financial markets in financial markets, agents communicate and learn from each other this
More informationLog-Robust Portfolio Management
Log-Robust Portfolio Management Dr. Aurélie Thiele Lehigh University Joint work with Elcin Cetinkaya and Ban Kawas Research partially supported by the National Science Foundation Grant CMMI-0757983 Dr.
More informationOptimizing Portfolios
Optimizing Portfolios An Undergraduate Introduction to Financial Mathematics J. Robert Buchanan 2010 Introduction Investors may wish to adjust the allocation of financial resources including a mixture
More informationLecture 2: Stochastic Discount Factor
Lecture 2: Stochastic Discount Factor Simon Gilchrist Boston Univerity and NBER EC 745 Fall, 2013 Stochastic Discount Factor (SDF) A stochastic discount factor is a stochastic process {M t,t+s } such that
More informationBeta Ambiguity and Security Return Characteristics
Beta Ambiguity and Security Return Characteristics Zhe Geng and Tan Wang November, 018 Abstract We develop a model to study the cross-sectional properties of asset returns in the presence of ambiguity
More informationLECTURE NOTES 10 ARIEL M. VIALE
LECTURE NOTES 10 ARIEL M VIALE 1 Behavioral Asset Pricing 11 Prospect theory based asset pricing model Barberis, Huang, and Santos (2001) assume a Lucas pure-exchange economy with three types of assets:
More informationApplied Macro Finance
Master in Money and Finance Goethe University Frankfurt Week 2: Factor models and the cross-section of stock returns Fall 2012/2013 Please note the disclaimer on the last page Announcements Next week (30
More informationBasics of Asset Pricing. Ali Nejadmalayeri
Basics of Asset Pricing Ali Nejadmalayeri January 2009 No-Arbitrage and Equilibrium Pricing in Complete Markets: Imagine a finite state space with s {1,..., S} where there exist n traded assets with a
More informationu (x) < 0. and if you believe in diminishing return of the wealth, then you would require
Chapter 8 Markowitz Portfolio Theory 8.7 Investor Utility Functions People are always asked the question: would more money make you happier? The answer is usually yes. The next question is how much more
More informationAmbiguity, Learning, and Asset Returns
Ambiguity, Learning, and Asset Returns Nengjiu Ju and Jianjun Miao June 2011 Abstract We propose a novel generalized recursive smooth ambiguity model which permits a threeway separation among risk aversion,
More informationMean Variance Analysis and CAPM
Mean Variance Analysis and CAPM Yan Zeng Version 1.0.2, last revised on 2012-05-30. Abstract A summary of mean variance analysis in portfolio management and capital asset pricing model. 1. Mean-Variance
More informationWhy Do Agency Theorists Misinterpret Market Monitoring?
Why Do Agency Theorists Misinterpret Market Monitoring? Peter L. Swan ACE Conference, July 13, 2018, Canberra UNSW Business School, Sydney Australia July 13, 2018 UNSW Australia, Sydney, Australia 1 /
More informationLiquidity Creation as Volatility Risk
Liquidity Creation as Volatility Risk Itamar Drechsler Alan Moreira Alexi Savov Wharton Rochester NYU Chicago November 2018 1 Liquidity and Volatility 1. Liquidity creation - makes it cheaper to pledge
More informationINTERTEMPORAL ASSET ALLOCATION: THEORY
INTERTEMPORAL ASSET ALLOCATION: THEORY Multi-Period Model The agent acts as a price-taker in asset markets and then chooses today s consumption and asset shares to maximise lifetime utility. This multi-period
More informationDynamic Asset Allocation with Ambiguous Return Predictability
Dynamic Asset Allocation with Ambiguous Return Predictability Hui Chen Nengjiu Ju Jianjun Miao March 9, 23 Abstract We study an investor s optimal consumption and portfolio choice problem when he is confronted
More informationAppendix to: AMoreElaborateModel
Appendix to: Why Do Demand Curves for Stocks Slope Down? AMoreElaborateModel Antti Petajisto Yale School of Management February 2004 1 A More Elaborate Model 1.1 Motivation Our earlier model provides a
More informationCONSUMPTION-BASED MACROECONOMIC MODELS OF ASSET PRICING THEORY
ECONOMIC ANNALS, Volume LXI, No. 211 / October December 2016 UDC: 3.33 ISSN: 0013-3264 DOI:10.2298/EKA1611007D Marija Đorđević* CONSUMPTION-BASED MACROECONOMIC MODELS OF ASSET PRICING THEORY ABSTRACT:
More informationOPTIMAL RISKY PORTFOLIOS- ASSET ALLOCATIONS. BKM Ch 7
OPTIMAL RISKY PORTFOLIOS- ASSET ALLOCATIONS BKM Ch 7 ASSET ALLOCATION Idea from bank account to diversified portfolio Discussion principles are the same for any number of stocks A. bonds and stocks B.
More informationEquilibrium Yield Curve, Phillips Correlation, and Monetary Policy
Equilibrium Yield Curve, Phillips Correlation, and Monetary Policy Mitsuru Katagiri International Monetary Fund October 24, 2017 @Keio University 1 / 42 Disclaimer The views expressed here are those of
More informationEcon 424/CFRM 462 Portfolio Risk Budgeting
Econ 424/CFRM 462 Portfolio Risk Budgeting Eric Zivot August 14, 2014 Portfolio Risk Budgeting Idea: Additively decompose a measure of portfolio risk into contributions from the individual assets in the
More informationIndexing and Price Informativeness
Indexing and Price Informativeness Hong Liu Washington University in St. Louis Yajun Wang University of Maryland IFS SWUFE August 3, 2017 Liu and Wang Indexing and Price Informativeness 1/25 Motivation
More informationMarket Timing Does Work: Evidence from the NYSE 1
Market Timing Does Work: Evidence from the NYSE 1 Devraj Basu Alexander Stremme Warwick Business School, University of Warwick November 2005 address for correspondence: Alexander Stremme Warwick Business
More informationChapter 8: CAPM. 1. Single Index Model. 2. Adding a Riskless Asset. 3. The Capital Market Line 4. CAPM. 5. The One-Fund Theorem
Chapter 8: CAPM 1. Single Index Model 2. Adding a Riskless Asset 3. The Capital Market Line 4. CAPM 5. The One-Fund Theorem 6. The Characteristic Line 7. The Pricing Model Single Index Model 1 1. Covariance
More informationLiquidity and Valuation in an Uncertain Market with Multiple Risky Assets and Difference of Opinions
Liquidity and Valuation in an Uncertain Market with Multiple Risky Assets and Difference of Opinions Qi Nan Zhai FDG School of Finance and Economics, UTS Business School University of Technology, Sydney
More informationCHAPTER 9: THE CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL
CHAPTER 9: THE CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL 1. E(r P ) = r f + β P [E(r M ) r f ] 18 = 6 + β P(14 6) β P = 12/8 = 1.5 2. If the security s correlation coefficient with the market portfolio doubles (with
More informationWITH SKETCH ANSWERS. Postgraduate Certificate in Finance Postgraduate Certificate in Economics and Finance
WITH SKETCH ANSWERS BIRKBECK COLLEGE (University of London) BIRKBECK COLLEGE (University of London) Postgraduate Certificate in Finance Postgraduate Certificate in Economics and Finance SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS,
More informationFinancial Economics: Capital Asset Pricing Model
Financial Economics: Capital Asset Pricing Model Shuoxun Hellen Zhang WISE & SOE XIAMEN UNIVERSITY April, 2015 1 / 66 Outline Outline MPT and the CAPM Deriving the CAPM Application of CAPM Strengths and
More informationBirkbeck MSc/Phd Economics. Advanced Macroeconomics, Spring Lecture 2: The Consumption CAPM and the Equity Premium Puzzle
Birkbeck MSc/Phd Economics Advanced Macroeconomics, Spring 2006 Lecture 2: The Consumption CAPM and the Equity Premium Puzzle 1 Overview This lecture derives the consumption-based capital asset pricing
More informationLiquidity Creation as Volatility Risk
Liquidity Creation as Volatility Risk Itamar Drechsler, NYU and NBER Alan Moreira, Rochester Alexi Savov, NYU and NBER JHU Carey Finance Conference June, 2018 1 Liquidity and Volatility 1. Liquidity creation
More informationBlack-Litterman Model
Institute of Financial and Actuarial Mathematics at Vienna University of Technology Seminar paper Black-Litterman Model by: Tetyana Polovenko Supervisor: Associate Prof. Dipl.-Ing. Dr.techn. Stefan Gerhold
More informationTwo hours. To be supplied by the Examinations Office: Mathematical Formula Tables and Statistical Tables THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
Two hours MATH20802 To be supplied by the Examinations Office: Mathematical Formula Tables and Statistical Tables THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER STATISTICAL METHODS Answer any FOUR of the SIX questions.
More informationFinancial Economics Field Exam January 2008
Financial Economics Field Exam January 2008 There are two questions on the exam, representing Asset Pricing (236D = 234A) and Corporate Finance (234C). Please answer both questions to the best of your
More informationCredit and hiring. Vincenzo Quadrini University of Southern California, visiting EIEF Qi Sun University of Southern California.
Credit and hiring Vincenzo Quadrini University of Southern California, visiting EIEF Qi Sun University of Southern California November 14, 2013 CREDIT AND EMPLOYMENT LINKS When credit is tight, employers
More informationOUT OF ORDER Bolton and Scharfstein
OUT OF ORDER Bolton and Scharfstein Borrowers are disciplined by the threat of losing access to further credit. Generates Investment cash flow correlation Suppose there is a one period model where an entrepreneur
More informationIncorporating Managerial Cash-Flow Estimates and Risk Aversion to Value Real Options Projects. The Fields Institute for Mathematical Sciences
Incorporating Managerial Cash-Flow Estimates and Risk Aversion to Value Real Options Projects The Fields Institute for Mathematical Sciences Sebastian Jaimungal sebastian.jaimungal@utoronto.ca Yuri Lawryshyn
More informationThe Asymmetric Conditional Beta-Return Relations of REITs
The Asymmetric Conditional Beta-Return Relations of REITs John L. Glascock 1 University of Connecticut Ran Lu-Andrews 2 California Lutheran University (This version: August 2016) Abstract The traditional
More informationTrinity College and Darwin College. University of Cambridge. Taking the Art out of Smart Beta. Ed Fishwick, Cherry Muijsson and Steve Satchell
Trinity College and Darwin College University of Cambridge 1 / 32 Problem Definition We revisit last year s smart beta work of Ed Fishwick. The CAPM predicts that higher risk portfolios earn a higher return
More informationMarket Liquidity and Performance Monitoring The main idea The sequence of events: Technology and information
Market Liquidity and Performance Monitoring Holmstrom and Tirole (JPE, 1993) The main idea A firm would like to issue shares in the capital market because once these shares are publicly traded, speculators
More informationLabor Economics Field Exam Spring 2011
Labor Economics Field Exam Spring 2011 Instructions You have 4 hours to complete this exam. This is a closed book examination. No written materials are allowed. You can use a calculator. THE EXAM IS COMPOSED
More informationPortfolio Risk Management and Linear Factor Models
Chapter 9 Portfolio Risk Management and Linear Factor Models 9.1 Portfolio Risk Measures There are many quantities introduced over the years to measure the level of risk that a portfolio carries, and each
More informationThe University of Nottingham
The University of Nottingham BUSINESS SCHOOL A LEVEL 2 MODULE, SPRING SEMESTER 2010 2011 COMPUTATIONAL FINANCE Time allowed TWO hours Candidates may complete the front cover of their answer book and sign
More informationCOMM 324 INVESTMENTS AND PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ASSIGNMENT 2 Due: October 20
COMM 34 INVESTMENTS ND PORTFOLIO MNGEMENT SSIGNMENT Due: October 0 1. In 1998 the rate of return on short term government securities (perceived to be risk-free) was about 4.5%. Suppose the expected rate
More informationThe Estimation of Expected Stock Returns on the Basis of Analysts' Forecasts
The Estimation of Expected Stock Returns on the Basis of Analysts' Forecasts by Wolfgang Breuer and Marc Gürtler RWTH Aachen TU Braunschweig October 28th, 2009 University of Hannover TU Braunschweig, Institute
More informationA Theory of Asset Prices based on Heterogeneous Information and Limits to Arbitrage
A Theory of Asset Prices based on Heterogeneous Information and Limits to Arbitrage Elias Albagli USC Marhsall Christian Hellwig Toulouse School of Economics Aleh Tsyvinski Yale University September 20,
More informationImperfect Competition, Information Asymmetry, and Cost of Capital
Imperfect Competition, Information Asymmetry, and Cost of Capital Judson Caskey, UT Austin John Hughes, UCLA Jun Liu, UCSD Institute of Financial Studies Southwestern University of Economics and Finance
More informationDynamic Asset Allocation with Ambiguous Return Predictability
Dynamic Asset Allocation with Ambiguous Return Predictability Hui Chen Nengjiu Ju Jianjun Miao First draft: September 2008. This draft: February 2009 Abstract We study an investor s optimal consumption
More informationAmbiguous Information, Portfolio Inertia, and Excess Volatility
University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Finance Papers Wharton Faculty Research 2011 Ambiguous Information, Portfolio Inertia, and Excess Volatility Philipp Karl Illeditsch University of Pennsylvania
More informationThe Econometrics of Financial Returns
The Econometrics of Financial Returns Carlo Favero December 2017 Favero () The Econometrics of Financial Returns December 2017 1 / 55 The Econometrics of Financial Returns Predicting the distribution of
More informationMATH 4512 Fundamentals of Mathematical Finance
MATH 451 Fundamentals of Mathematical Finance Solution to Homework Three Course Instructor: Prof. Y.K. Kwok 1. The market portfolio consists of n uncorrelated assets with weight vector (x 1 x n T. Since
More informationLow Risk Anomalies? Discussion
Low Risk Anomalies? by Schneider, Wagners, and Zechner Discussion Pietro Veronesi The University of Chicago Booth School of Business Main Contribution and Outline of Discussion Main contribution of the
More informationAdverse Selection and Switching Costs in Health Insurance Markets. by Benjamin Handel
Adverse Selection and Switching Costs in Health Insurance Markets: When Nudging Hurts by Benjamin Handel Ramiro de Elejalde Department of Economics Universidad Carlos III de Madrid February 9, 2010. Motivation
More informationAmbiguity, ambiguity aversion and stores of value: The case of Argentina
LETTER Ambiguity, ambiguity aversion and stores of value: The case of Argentina Eduardo Ariel Corso Cogent Economics & Finance (2014), 2: 947001 Page 1 of 13 LETTER Ambiguity, ambiguity aversion and stores
More informationInternational Asset Pricing and Risk Sharing with Recursive Preferences
p. 1/3 International Asset Pricing and Risk Sharing with Recursive Preferences Riccardo Colacito Prepared for Tom Sargent s PhD class (Part 1) Roadmap p. 2/3 Today International asset pricing (exchange
More informationRisk, Uncertainty, and Option Exercise
Risk, Uncertainty, and Option Exercise Jianjun Miao and Neng Wang September 9, 2010 Abstract Many economic decisions can be described as an option exercise or optimal stopping problem under uncertainty.
More informationAsymmetric Information: Walrasian Equilibria, and Rational Expectations Equilibria
Asymmetric Information: Walrasian Equilibria and Rational Expectations Equilibria 1 Basic Setup Two periods: 0 and 1 One riskless asset with interest rate r One risky asset which pays a normally distributed
More informationSolutions to questions in Chapter 8 except those in PS4. The minimum-variance portfolio is found by applying the formula:
Solutions to questions in Chapter 8 except those in PS4 1. The parameters of the opportunity set are: E(r S ) = 20%, E(r B ) = 12%, σ S = 30%, σ B = 15%, ρ =.10 From the standard deviations and the correlation
More informationEcon 422 Eric Zivot Summer 2004 Final Exam Solutions
Econ 422 Eric Zivot Summer 2004 Final Exam Solutions This is a closed book exam. However, you are allowed one page of notes (double-sided). Answer all questions. For the numerical problems, if you make
More informationDynamic asset allocation with ambiguous return predictability
Dynamic asset allocation with ambiguous return predictability The MIT Faculty has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters. Citation As Published
More informationProblem set 5. Asset pricing. Markus Roth. Chair for Macroeconomics Johannes Gutenberg Universität Mainz. Juli 5, 2010
Problem set 5 Asset pricing Markus Roth Chair for Macroeconomics Johannes Gutenberg Universität Mainz Juli 5, 200 Markus Roth (Macroeconomics 2) Problem set 5 Juli 5, 200 / 40 Contents Problem 5 of problem
More informationA. Huang Date of Exam December 20, 2011 Duration of Exam. Instructor. 2.5 hours Exam Type. Special Materials Additional Materials Allowed
Instructor A. Huang Date of Exam December 20, 2011 Duration of Exam 2.5 hours Exam Type Special Materials Additional Materials Allowed Calculator Marking Scheme: Question Score Question Score 1 /20 5 /9
More information