What is CBA and why you need it
|
|
- Tracy Kelly
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Flood Hazard Research Centre Middlesex University, London What is CBA and why you need it Edmund Penning-Rowsell Professor of Geography Oxford London FLOODCBA2 Seville May 2017 Distinguished Research Associate
2 The FHRC is an interdisciplinary research centre, based in the School of Science and Technology at Middlesex University. Risk governance Investment appraisal Equity and social acceptability Environmental
3 1 2 3 Rivers and towns Coastal hazards Standards and safety Three knowledge assembly and transfer projects across 8 EU countries Directorate General for the Humanitarian Aid and Civil Protection
4 Three knowledge assembly and transfer projects How to make wise 100% completed (proactive) investment decisions based on 100% completed systematic appraisal methods (principally using a Cost:Benefit c. 60% completed Analysis framework) Directorate General for the Humanitarian Aid and Civil Protection
5 1 2 3 Rivers and towns Coastal hazards Standards and safety Three knowledge assembly and transfer projects 1. A Common framework of terms and ideas 2. Guidelines for using investment appraisal techniques 3. Awareness raising and training 4. A legacy of a toolkit on a knowledge platform All systematically stakeholder validated Directorate General for the Humanitarian Aid and Civil Protection
6 3 SIGMA Consultants Ltd (GR) Lead Partner Greece Middlesex University Higher Education Corporation, Flood Hazard Research Centre (UK) UK University Pablo de Olavide (ES) Interdisciplinary Centre for Social Sciences, CICS.NOVA, University Nova de Lisboa (PT) Environmental Agency of Andalusia Region, REDIAM (ES) Region of East Macedonia and Thrace (GR) Municipality of Amadora (PT) Spain Portugal Spain Greece Portugal Regional/Urban authorities
7 Costs Benefits??
8 The basic CBA process Do Nothing ( Baseline ) Assess the current state of flood damages Convert to annual average damages Convert to present value of damages (by discounting) Do something to reduce risk ( Measures ) Assess the resulting (lower) state of flood damages Convert to annual average resulting damages Convert to present value of resulting damages (by discounting) BCA (Compares Measures against the Baseline ) Compare the two results ( Baseline minus Measures ) and compare with the cost of the Measures
9 Cost: benefit analysis (CBA, or BCA) is designed to make you THINK! Vera, Spain
10 article gallery Cost: benefit analysis (CBA, or BCA) is designed to make you THINK! Andalusia and Murcia
11 f Is flood protection the best use of our money? What are the alternative approaches. Who is paying, anyway? Mallorca, Spain
12 Who is suffering? What if we cannot pay? What can be done at really low cost? Bobadilla, Spain
13 Types of flood risk reduction measures Dams, reservoirs, retarding basins Structural measures Channel modifications Levee banks Water control measures Non-structural measures Flood-proofing Catchment modifications Schemes of drainage and flood protection Flood forecasting, flood warning & emergency planning Planning controls Acquisition & relocation Land use control measures Financial relief & loss reduction Flood insurance Public information & education
14 The Middlesex FHRC* Manuals: From 1977 to 2013/4 Blue Manual Red Manual FLAIR Yellow Manual 2005 Multi- Coloured Manual Centre founded Direct damages Indirect losses Coastal added 2010 All Update topics 2013/14 Why? To seek sensible decisions on where and when to invest our hard-pressed taxpayers money on reducing the risks of flooding and erosion.. * Flood Hazard Research Centre, Middlesex University Routledge, November
15 Flood risk management budget for England: 2005 to 2015 (c. 0.6bn or Euros 0.7bn per annum) Tax payers Defra Environment Agency
16 Why CBA? To seek sensible decisions on where and when to invest our hard-pressed taxpayers money on reducing the risks of flooding and erosion.. It is all about the merits of reducing flood risk
17 Why CBA? To seek sensible decisions on where and when to invest our hard-pressed taxpayers money on reducing the risks of flooding and erosion.. It is all about the merits of reducing flood risk
18 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data Tangible Measurement Intangible Form of loss Direct Indirect Damage to building and contents: houses and shops Loss of industrial production/ retail trade Loss of an archaeological site Inconvenience of post-flood recovery
19 Impact 1 We know a great deal about the economic damage caused by floods. 44,000 38,000 22,000 31,000 5,000
20 Plus: Impact 2 Evacuation: 50% of those with flood water > 30cm are not back in their homes inside 30 days But the economic damage caused by floods is only part of the story.
21 Impact 3: Health and floods: The time line of impacts Flood Up to 80% < 60% Psychological impacts Physical impacts?? years
22 Assessing the benefits of flood alleviation Lower flood stage Lower flood damage With and without criterion
23 What did we need? A flood extent map
24 44,000 38,000 22,000 31,000 5,000
25 Metres Metres Metres Metres Depth Metres Method application, for high street shop stock component Figure 3: Depth damage curves for high street shops Sub-category 211 (High Street Shop) Scenario: River flood, no warning and duration less than 12 hours Depth Damage Curve ,000 1,250 1,500 Damage /m2 High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility Building structure, fabric and services Moveable equipment Indicative value 739 per m2 Indicative value 63 per m % 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100 Percent % High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility % 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100 Percent % High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility Fixture and fittings Stock Indicative value 340 per m2 Indicative value 372 per m % 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100 Percent % High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility % 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100 Percent % High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility
26 Depth Metres Method application, for high street shop: depth/damage relationship Depth Damage Curve ,000 1,250 1,500 High Susceptibility Band Low Susceptibility Band Indicative Susceptibility Damage /m2 26
27 What is the extra value (benefit) you might obtain from spending more? Cost : Euros 25,000 The answer : We compare the marginal increase in benefit with the marginal increase in costs: that should be exactly the same with spending on flood hazard mitigation: extra protection costs extra money! Ford Focus Cost : Euros 45,000 Mercedes E class
28 What is the extra value (benefit) you might obtain from spending more? Cost : Euros 5,000 The answer : Ford Focus Extra protection costs extra money! Cost : Euros 6bn Mercedes E class
29 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data: benefits and costs of interventions Question: To what standard should this community be defended: what is the most efficient use of resources? Intervention Design standard A 12 B 20 C 50 D 100 E 125 Yalding, Kent, 2000 The return period (in years) of the largest flood that is protected against
30 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data: benefits and costs of interventions Question: To what standard should this community be defended: what is the most efficient use of resources? Intervention Benefits ( m) Costs ( m) A B C D E Yalding, Kent, 2000
31 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data: benefits and costs of interventions Intervention Benefits ( m) Costs ( m) A B C D E
32 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data: benefits and costs of interventions Intervention Intervention Benefits ( m) Benefit/ cost ratio Costs ( m) A B C D E Benefit minus cost A B C D E
33 The impacts of floods, and flood damage data: benefits and costs of interventions Intervention Benefits ( m) Costs ( m) A B C D E Efficiency = Outputs minus inputs C is the efficient choice
34 Confidence that an intervention is desirable Confidence >>> Benefit-cost ratio >> Dead Ducks Marginal Certain projects Incredulity
35 CBA for Flood Risk Management: Merits and problems Merits: Transparent Interrogable Leads to suggested expenditure Problems: May not include those aspects which are most important (the socalled intangibles ) Somerset, FLOODCBA2 UK Seville Winter May
36 ?? Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2016
37 The flood in 2007 The situation in Oxford: Circa 2,000 homes, and Circa 200 businesses affected Nursing homes evacuated Oxfordshire clean-up 34 million Schools costs 632,000 Tourism bookings 40% down (John Kelly, ) Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2016
38 The flood in 2007 The situation in Oxford: Circa 2,000 homes, and Circa 200 businesses affected Nursing homes evacuated Oxfordshire clean-up 34 million Schools costs 632,000 Tourism bookings 40% down (John Kelly, ) Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2016
39 Where are the properties that could be flooded in the future?
40 Euros 140m Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2017
41 The proposed bypass channel Euros 140m 50% central government grant 50% local contributions Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2017
42 All millions What this means Walk away : No maintenance at all of existing FRM Continued existing maintenanc e ( Option 2 ) Option 2 plus interim measures ( Option 12 ) Medium sized bypass channel
43 The proposed bypass channel Euros 140m So: 1:8 benefits vs costs 1:1.2 benefits compared to next best alternative Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2017
44 Fin! Oxford Flood Alleviation Scheme: Demonstration Case Study The results as of mid-2016
Damages caused by Flash Floods
Damages caused by Flash Floods Damages caused as a result of flash flood are enormous both on human lives and loss of property. It is reported that flood disasters account for about a third of all natural
More informationExploring the economic benefits of coast protection at Torbay, UK
Exploring the economic benefits of coast protection at Torbay, UK Locations around the coast. 1 Towyn 2 Blackpool 3 Morecambe 4 Uphill 5 Porlock 6 Hunstanton 7 Scarborough 8 Filey 9 Bridlington 10 Spurn
More informationThis project has been funded with the contribution of the Civil Protection Financial Instrument of the European Union. The sole responsibility of
This project has been funded with the contribution of the Civil Protection Financial Instrument of the European Union. The sole responsibility of this communication lies with the author. The Commission
More informationA guide to how we fund and deliver Flood Risk Management Schemes
A guide to how we fund and deliver Flood Risk Management s We are currently in the appraisal stages of many projects investigating whether schemes to manage flood risk can be provided throughout Cumbria.
More information2018 PREPARING FOR A CHANGING CLIMATE AND MANAGING THE RISING FLOOD RISK
Ireland Water 2018 PREPARING FOR A CHANGING CLIMATE AND MANAGING THE RISING FLOOD RISK Mark Adamson Office of Public Works 25 th April, 2018 FLOOD RISK IN IRELAND NATIONAL RISK ASSESSMENT, OEP 2012 & 2017
More informationFLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT IN IRELAND
National Flood Management Conference 2018 FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT IN IRELAND Mark Adamson Office of Public Works 15 th March, 2018 FLOOD RISK IN IRELAND NATIONAL RISK ASSESSMENT, OEP 2012 Flooding: Joint
More informationA tool for the assessment and visualisation of flood vulnerability and risk
A tool for the assessment and visualisation of flood vulnerability and risk Alexander, M., Viavattene, C., Faulkner, H. and Priest, S. Contents Flooding in context Flood emergency management in the UK
More informationPaschali Stauroula Karanika Chrisoula Kokovinos Konstantinos Koujianos Ioannis Vatistas Panagiotis
Evros River Flood Lavara Case Study Chouvardas Konstantinos (Coordinator) Papapostolou Christos Chamitidou Maria Partsias Christos Doulgeraki Chrisoula Paschali Stauroula Paschali Stauroula Karanika Chrisoula
More informationFlood Risk Management in Ireland. The National CFRAM Programme & overview of the Capital Works Programme. Click to add text
Flood Risk Management in Ireland The National CFRAM Programme & overview of the Capital Works Programme Click to add text Dr. John Martin Office of Public Works Engineers Ireland's Local Government Seminar
More informationFILEY CASE STUDY: A GUIDE TO BENEFIT APPRAISAL
FILEY CASE STUDY: A GUIDE TO BENEFIT APPRAISAL Introduction This case study provides the user with a walkthrough of the costbenefit appraisal process. Cost-benefit appraisal (CBA) is used by authorities
More informationNational Infrastructure Assessment Technical Annex. Technical annex: Flood modelling
Technical annex: Flood modelling July 2018 1 This annex provides supplementary detail on modelling of flood management for the National Infrastructure Assessment. Assessing cost and benefits of different
More informationAction Items for Flood Risk Management on Wildcat Creek Interagency success with floodplain management plans and flood forecast inundation maps
Presentation to USACE 2012 Flood Risk Management and Silver Jackets Joint Workshop, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Action Items for Flood Risk Management on Wildcat Creek Interagency success with floodplain
More informationMapping flood risk its role in improving flood resilience in England
Mapping flood risk its role in improving flood resilience in England Catherine Wright Director of Digital and Skills Flood and Coastal Risk Management Environment Agency 6 October 2017 The Environment
More informationNational Flood Risk Management Plan. CFRAM Programme
National Flood Risk Management Plan AND THE CFRAM Programme Gerard O Connell, Engineer-in-Charge, Regional Projects & Flood Advisory Office Environmental SPC, 27 th June, 2018 HISTORIC & POLICY CONTEXT
More informationA COMMON FRAMEWORK OF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS FEATURES
A COMMON FRAMEWORK OF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS FEATURES Knowledge Platform for assessing the costs and benefits of flood prevention measures Deliverable number C.1 Delivery date 24/10/2013
More informationStrategic Flood Risk Management
Strategic Management Duncan McLuckie (NSW Department of Infrastructure and Natural Resources) Introduction This paper discusses what is meant by strategic flood risk management, who is responsible in New
More informationImpacts and Economic Costs of River Floods in the EU and Costs of Adaptation
Impacts and Economic Costs of River Floods in the EU and Costs of Adaptation Luc Feyen Getty Images Joint Research Centre European Commission Water and Adaptation to Climate Change in Transboundary Basins:
More informationBritannia Village Flood Control Project
Britannia Village Flood Control Project Summary of Background Information February 2011 Contents 1) Flood Risks in the Village 2) Alternative Flood Risk Management Approaches Status Quo The Proposed Remedial
More informationDEFINING BEST PRACTICE IN FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT
DEFINING BEST PRACTICE IN FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT M Babister 1 M Retallick 1 1 WMAwater, Level 2,160 Clarence Street Sydney Abstract With the upcoming release of the national best practice manual, Managing
More informationRisk Assessment for Floods Due to Precipitation Exceeding Drainage Capacity
Risk Assessment for Floods Due to Precipitation Exceeding Drainage Capacity November 2006 Umut Karamahmut Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences i i. Abstract Studies on flood risk modeling were
More informationThe 2004 Gilbert F. White National Flood Policy Forum September 21-22, 2004 FLOOD STANDARDS IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES
The 2004 Gilbert F. White National Flood Policy Forum September 21-22, 2004 FLOOD STANDARDS IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES Firas Makarem, Dewberry, International Committee Chair, Association of State Floodplain
More informationStrategic flood risk management
Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs and Environment Agency Strategic flood risk management HC 780 SESSION 2014-15 5 NOVEMBER 2014 4 Key facts
More informationCYNGOR SIR POWYS COUNTY COUNCIL. CABINET EXECUTIVE 18 th September Flood Risk Management Plan (FRMP)
CYNGOR SIR POWYS COUNTY COUNCIL. CABINET EXECUTIVE 18 th September 2018 REPORT AUTHOR: SUBJECT: County Councillor Phyl Davies Portfolio Holder for Highways, Recycling and Assets Flood Risk Management Plan
More informationFindings and Recommendations the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia
Findings and Recommendations the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia Glossary... 1 1. Legal and Institutional Framework for Flood Risk Management... 2 2. Units of Management... 3 3. International River
More informationGood Practice Guide. GPG 101 Document Owner: Steve Cook. Page 1 of 7.
Good Practice Guide Producing flood risk hydraulic models and flood consequence assessments for development planning purposes Date Published: September 2015 GPG 101 Document Owner: Steve Cook Page 1 of
More informationThe AIR Inland Flood Model for Great Britian
The AIR Inland Flood Model for Great Britian The year 212 was the UK s second wettest since recordkeeping began only 6.6 mm shy of the record set in 2. In 27, the UK experienced its wettest summer, which
More informationIntegrating intangible values in economic analyses of flood mitigation: a case study of the Brown Hill and Keswick creeks catchment in Adelaide
ABSTRACT This study undertakes an economic analysis of flood mitigation options for a high flood-risk catchment in Adelaide. To date, economic analyses have focused primarily on estimating the tangible
More informationHelping communities weather the storm. Shawna Peddle Adaptation Canada 2016 April 13, 2016
Helping communities weather the storm Shawna Peddle Adaptation Canada 2016 April 13, 2016 FLOOD HAPPENS Our climate is changing Increasing precipitation, snow and ice melt Our communities are changing
More informationFlood Plain Management Services (FPMS) Program
Flood Plain Management Services (FPMS) Program 2016 Winter Stakeholder Partnering Forum March 2016 Mario Beddingfield, P.E., CFM Hydraulic Engineer/FPMS Program Manager H&H/Water Control Branch U.S. Army
More informationLower Lee (Cork City) Flood Relief Scheme (Including Blackpool and Ballyvolane)
STUDY AREA MAP N LEGEND: Study Area (for which flood alleviation measures are to be identified) Additional Environmental Study Area (assessment area of environmental affects from proposed flood alleviation
More informationMethodology for the calculation of industrial flood damage and its application to an industry in Vereeniging
Methodology for the calculation of industrial flood damage and its application to an industry in Vereeniging HJ Booysen 1 *, MF Viljoen 2 and GduT de Villiers 1 1 Department of Geography, the University
More informationA Flood Mitigation Plan for the Non-Tidal N.J. Section of the Delaware River Basin. Warren County Planning Workshop (2 nd Meeting) March 7, 2007
A Flood Mitigation Plan for the Non-Tidal N.J. Section of the Delaware River Basin Warren County Planning Workshop (2 nd Meeting) March 7, 2007 Study Area Participation: Hunterdon: 16 Eligible Municipalities
More informationDANUBE FLOODRISK PROJECT
FLOOD CBA MEETING, Oxford, 20-21 May, 2013 Strategic Project DANUBE FLOODRISK PROJECT Cooperation for Hazard and Risk Maps Atlas production along the Danube and its continuation in RO by FLOOD CBA Project
More informationCRS State Profile: Connecticut
CRS State Profile: Connecticut This is a profile for communities in your state that are participating in the Community Rating System (CRS). This profile is intended to provide information to the State
More informationCommunity Rating System. National Flood Insurance Program
National Flood Insurance Program Community Rating System A Local Official s Guide to Saving Lives Preventing Property Damage Reducing the Cost of Flood Insurance FEMA B-573 / May 2015 How the Community
More informationFlood directive implementation in Finland
Flood directive implementation in Finland 1 Content Legislation Implementing the flood directive Preliminary flood risk assessment Flood hazard maps and flood risk mapping Flood risk management plans Competent
More informationAssessing future flood risk and opportunities for adaptation at UK scale
Assessing future flood risk and opportunities for adaptation at UK scale Paul Sayers Sayers and Partners (SPL), Associate Advisor WWF and Research Fellow, University of Oxford. Co-authors Matt Horritt,
More informationARUN DISTRICT COUNCIL POLICY STATEMENT ON FLOOD AND COASTAL DEFENCE. 12 January 2004
ARUN DISTRICT COUNCIL POLICY STATEMENT ON FLOOD AND COASTAL DEFENCE 12 January 2004 1.0 INTRODUCTION This is an update to the existing policy statement which was prepared by Arun District Council to provide
More informationFlood Risk Management Planning in Scotland: Arrangements for February 2012
Flood Risk Management Planning in Scotland: Arrangements for 2012 2016 February 2012 Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009 1 Contents Forewords 1. Introduction to this document... 5 2. Sustainable
More informationThis survey is expected to take approximately 20 minutes and must be completed in one session.
State Flood Assessment Survey 1 Introduction Thank you for your willingness to participate in this online survey as part of the State Flood Assessment effort. This first step toward developing comprehensive
More informationDerry City & Strabane District Council 17th July 2015, 3pm.
Derry City & Strabane District Council 17th July 2015, 3pm Malcolm Calvert, (Principal Engineer, Mapping & Modelling Unit) Sean O Neill, (Regional Engineer - Western) Flood Hazard & Risk Mapping www.riversagencyni.gov.uk
More informationEngineers Ireland Annual Conference
Engineers Ireland Annual Conference MANAGING FLOOD RISK AND BUILDING SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES Mark Adamson Office of Public Works 15 th May, 2015 FLOOD RISK IN IRELAND RECENT FLOODS November 2009: >1,600
More informationDavid A. Stroud, CFM AMEC Earth & Environmental Raleigh, NC
David A. Stroud, CFM AMEC Earth & Environmental Raleigh, NC Objectives Risk MAP background North Carolina s Risk MAP role Role of communication in Risk MAP Effective risk communication two examples Multi-hazard
More informationThis survey is expected to take approximately 20 minutes and must be completed in one session.
Introduction Thank you for your willingness to participate in this online survey as part of the State Flood Assessment effort. This first step toward developing comprehensive flood planning for Texas does
More informationFlood and Coastal Risk Management - A Risk Based. David Rooke Head of Flood & Coastal Risk Management 20 March 2009
Flood and Coastal Risk Management - A Risk Based Approach David Rooke Head of Flood & Coastal Risk Management 20 March 2009 Risk Significant risks to the delivery of Defra s outcomes in this area Consequence
More informationDRAFT STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT SCREENING REPORT. Climate Change Sectoral Adaptation Plan for Flood Risk Management ( )
Office of Public Works DRAFT STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT SCREENING REPORT Climate Change Sectoral Adaptation Plan for Flood Risk Management (2014-2019) Determination of the need for strategic environmental
More informationKarlstad, Sweden. Local progress report on the implementation of the 10 Essentials for Making Cities Resilient ( )
Karlstad, Sweden Local progress report on the implementation of the 10 Essentials for Making Cities Resilient (2013-2014) Mayor: Ulf Nyqvist Name of focal point: -Anna -Sjödin Organization: -Karlstad Municipality
More informationMAY Carbon taxation and fiscal consolidation: the potential of carbon pricing to reduce Europe s fiscal deficits
MAY 2012 Carbon taxation and fiscal consolidation: the potential of carbon pricing to reduce Europe s fiscal deficits An appropriate citation for this report is: Vivid Economics, Carbon taxation and fiscal
More informationCRS State Profile: Wyoming
CRS State Profile: Wyoming This is a profile for communities in your state that are participating in the Community Rating System (CRS). This profile is intended to provide information to the State NFIP
More informationABI GUIDE TO RESISTANT AND RESILIENT REPAIR AFTER A FLOOD
ABI GUIDE TO RESISTANT AND RESILIENT REPAIR AFTER A FLOOD @BritishInsurers abi.org.uk @BritishInsurers 1 2 abi.org.uk Introduction If you have suffered a flood you will know how devastating and distressing
More informationRAINGAIN. Torbay Flood Risk Management. Dave Stewart. 16 th April 2013
RAINGAIN Torbay Flood Risk Management Dave Stewart 16 th April 2013 Overview Catchment Description and Drainage Responsibilities Historic Flooding Problems Drainage Legislation Affecting Local Authorities
More informationFlood risk modelling: a crisis of confidence?
Proceedings of ICE Civil Engineering 150 May 2002 Pages 30 35 Paper 12768 Keywords design methods & aids; floods & floodworks; statistical analysis Flood risk modelling: a crisis of confidence? B. A. Hamer
More informationLOW. Overall Flood risk. Flood considerations. Specimen Address, Specimen Town. Rivers and the Sea Low page 4. Historic Flood.
Specimen Address, Specimen Town Overall Flood risk LOW Crown copyright and database rights 2018. Ordnance Survey licence 100035207 Groundsure Floodview complies with relevant Law Society practice notes
More informationReport on. Stakeholders Views
Report on Stakeholders Views Deliverable number 2.3.3 Delivery date Status Author 31 st /July/2013 Final Version Pablo de Olavide University CONTENTS 1. Introduction...2 2. Overview of the use of CBA in
More informationOptions for North Wagga
Options for North Wagga As a direct result of community feedback received during the exhibition of the levee upgrade concept designs, a number of alternatives for protecting North Wagga during a flood
More informationC o p e r n i c u s E m e r g e n c y M a n a g e m e n t S e r v i c e f o r R i s k p l a n n i n g a n d R e c o v e r y
C o p e r n i c u s E m e r g e n c y M a n a g e m e n t S e r v i c e f o r R i s k p l a n n i n g a n d R e c o v e r y Copernicus Service Copernicus EU Copernicus EU Copernicus EU www.copernicus.eu
More informationSecond workshop on Transboundary Flood Risk Management, Geneva, March 2015
Second workshop on Transboundary Flood Risk Management, Geneva, 19-20 March 2015 PILOT CASE STUDY OF THE PRELIMINARY FLOOD RISK ASSESSMENT, MAPPING AND INVENTORY OF THE FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT PLANNING FOR
More informationFLOOD HAZARD AND RISK MANAGEMENT UTILIZING HYDRAULIC MODELING AND GIS TECHNOLOGIES IN URBAN ENVIRONMENT
Proceedings of the 14 th International Conference on Environmental Science and Technology Rhodes, Greece, 3-5 September 2015 FLOOD HAZARD AND RISK MANAGEMENT UTILIZING HYDRAULIC MODELING AND GIS TECHNOLOGIES
More informationPresent and future flood vulnerability, risk and disadvantage A UK assessment
Present and future flood vulnerability, risk and disadvantage A UK assessment Assessment Methodology Prepared for Joseph Rowntree Foundation, Climate Change and Communities Programme June 2017 i Contents
More informationSkardu, Pakistan. Local progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action (First Cycle)
Skardu, Pakistan Local progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action (First Cycle) Name of focal point: Habib Mughal Organization: UN-HABITAT - Pakistan Title/Position: Manager
More informationCRS State Profile: Alaska
CRS State Profile: Alaska This is a profile for communities in your state that are participating in the Community Rating System (CRS). This profile is intended to provide information to the State NFIP
More informationMUNICIPAL LAND USE STRATEGIES for Improving Flood Resilience
MUNICIPAL LAND USE STRATEGIES for Improving Flood Resilience Strategy for a Flood Resistant Southern Tier Central Region (LWRP project) This presentation was prepared by Southern Tier Central Regional
More informationStrategic Flood Risk Assessment
Strategic Flood Risk Assessment Draft Claremorris Local Area Plan 2012 2018 Prepared by Forward Planning Section Mayo County Council 1 Table of Contents Section 1: Overview of the Guidelines... 4 1.1 Introduction...
More informationFlood Risk Management Strategy. Shetland
Flood Risk Management Strategy Shetland Publication date: 14 December 2015 Terms and conditions Ownership: All intellectual property rights for Flood Risk Management Strategies are owned by SEPA or its
More informationSocial vulnerability and climate change in Flood Risk Management in Scotland
Social vulnerability and climate change in Flood Risk Management in Scotland Leigh Fraser leigh.fraser@sepa.org.uk Senior Policy Officer, Flood Risk Management Planning and Policy Scottish Environment
More informationIntroduction. Purpose
Table of Contents Introduction... 1 Purpose... 1 Related Projects and Programs 3 Vision... 3 Legislation and Policy Framework... 3 Target Audience... 4 Guiding Principles... 5 Governance... 6 Roles and
More informationSolway Local Plan District 1 Flood risk management in Scotland 1.1 What is a Flood Risk Management Strategy? Flood Risk Management Strategies have bee
Flood Risk Management Strategy Solway Local Plan District Section 1: Flood Risk Management in Scotland 1.1 What is a Flood Risk Management Strategy?... 1 1.2 How to read this Strategy... 1 1.3 Managing
More informationNational and regional levee systems analysis in the UK and relevance to USA
National and regional levee systems analysis in the UK and relevance to USA Jonathan Simm Presentation for ASFPM Conference, Grand Rapids MI Overview UK background Overview of method and description of
More information7. Understand effect of multiple annual exposures e.g., 30-yr period and multiple independent locations yr event over 30 years 3%
I. FLOOD HAZARD A. Definition 1. Hazard: probability of water height 2. At a Specific XY floodplain location; 3. Z can be expressed as elevation (NAVD88); gauge height; height above ground (depth). 4.
More informationVision to Action: Creating and Using a Flood Risk Assessment for Identifying Mitigation Options
Vision to Action: Creating and Using a Flood Risk Assessment for Identifying Mitigation Options Lisa Graff, CFM, GISP Clayton Ballerine, CFM Brad McVay, CFM, GISP University of Illinois Prairie Research
More informationConsider the risks to your own business as well as to your operations
Hayley Bowman Flood and Coastal Risk Management Mapping, Modelling and Data 07919 544 551 Hayley.bowman@environment-agency.gov.uk DataInfo@environment-agency.gov.uk EA covers England only. Wales covered
More informationQUANTITATIVE COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS
3.7.0 SERIES 3 Building Resilience QUANTITATIVE COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS Contents of Set 3.7.0: Guide 3.7.1: Activity This training set is designed for teams that need to implement a quantitative cost-benefit
More informationFlood and Coastal Defence Project Appraisal Guidance Economic Appraisal
Flood and Coastal Defence Project Appraisal Guidance Economic Appraisal FCDPAG3 A PROCEDURAL GUIDE FOR OPERATING AUTHORITIES Foreword This is one of a series of guidance documents designed to provide advice
More informationTS18 Mitigation Grant Application and Benefit Cost Analysis Development - Support Documentation - Governor s Hurricane Conference 2017
TS18 Mitigation Grant Application and Benefit Cost Analysis Development - Support Documentation - Governor s Hurricane Conference 2017 Name Entity Your role with mitigation projects Your expectations /
More informationCzech Republic. National progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action ( )
Czech Republic National progress report on the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action (2011-2013) Name of focal point: Organization: Title/Position: E-mail address: Marie Adamkova/Matyas Doul
More informationEnvironment Agency pre-application advice incorporating Local Flood Risk Standing Advice from East Lindsey District Council
Environment Agency pre-application advice incorporating Local Flood Risk Standing Advice from East Lindsey District Council Version 1 UNCLASSIFIED We are the Environment Agency. We protect and improve
More informationEvidence for Environmental Audit Committee Enquiry on Sustainable Housing Submission by Association of British Insurers, May 2004
Evidence for Environmental Audit Committee Enquiry on Sustainable Housing Submission by Association of British Insurers, May 2004 The Government s plans to tackle the country s profound housing shortage
More informationDevelopment and Flood Risk - the Environment Agency s approach to PPS25. scrutinised before planning decisions are made
Development and Flood Risk - the Environment Agency s approach to PPS25 Steve Cook Flood Risk Policy Advisor Stephen.cook@environment-agency.gov.uk Our role in PPS25 h Providing advice and information
More informationAPPENDIX B: CITIZEN SURVEY
APPENDIX B: CITIZEN SURVEY B1 CONVERSE COUNTY HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN SURVEY March 30, 2011 Prepared for: Converse County Emergency Management Agency Prepared by: Ken Markert, AICP MMI Planning Cody, WY.
More informationGuildford Borough Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment Summary Report. January 2016
Guildford Borough Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment Summary Report January 2016 What is this document? This document provides a summary of Guildford Borough Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA,
More informationFlood Risk Outreach Tools for Georgia Communities. GAFM 10 th Annual Conference Presented By: Jarrett Mattli
Flood Risk Outreach Tools for Georgia Communities GAFM 10 th Annual Conference Presented By: Jarrett Mattli April 13, 2016 Presentation Overview Guidebooks Toolkits Templates Educational Videos Resource
More informationIRISH FLOOD PREVENTION PROGRAMME Example of integrating climate change adaptation into projects
IRISH FLOOD PREVENTION PROGRAMME Example of integrating climate change adaptation into projects JASPERS Networking Platform Event Climate Change Adaptation: Vulnerability and Risk Assessment and the Resilience
More informationEffective Disaster Risk Management for Sustainable Development
Effective Disaster Risk Management for Sustainable Development Catastrophe Risk Insurance: Key Challenges and Opportunities - Project Dissemination Workshop Sofia, Bulgaria, May 27, 2008 Margaret Arnold,
More informationinclude cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA), multi-criteria analysis (MCA) and robust decision-making approaches (RDMA).
Risk Nexus Making communities : the role of cost-benefit analysis and other decision-support tools Many issues need to be considered when deciding how best to help protect a community from floods. In this
More informationHazard Mitigation Grants. Technical Assistance Session Middlesex County, NJ December 7, 2011
Hazard Mitigation Grants Technical Assistance Session Middlesex County, NJ December 7, 2011 Outline Purpose of Hazard Mitigation Hazard Mitigation Projects Hazard Mitigation Assistance Grant Programs Using
More informationShannon Flood Risk State Agency Co-ordination Working Group - Open Days on Work Programme
Shannon Flood Risk State Agency Co-ordination Working Group - Open Days on Work Programme Questions and Answers What is the purpose of the Shannon Flood Risk State Agency Co-ordination Working Group? The
More informationPassaic River Basin Flood Advisory Commission Report/Status of Recommendations. October 2014 Update
Passaic River Basin Flood Advisory Commission Report/Status of Recommendations October 2014 Update Passaic River Basin Flood Advisory Commission April 2010: By Executive Order, Governor Christie created
More informationCDBG-DR, BW-12, CRS and Dauphin County, PA: What do they have in common? 2015 FMA Annual Conference
CDBG-DR, BW-12, CRS and Dauphin County, PA: What do they have in common? 2015 FMA Annual Conference September 9, 2015 Today's Speaker Kristen Gelino Hazard Mitigation Planner, Tetra Tech, Inc. 2 years
More informationHRPP 313. Developing a performance - based management system for flood and coastal defence assets
HRPP 313 Developing a performance - based management system for flood and coastal defence assets Paul Sayers, Jonathan Simm, Michael Wallis, Foekje Buijs, Jaap Flikweert & Ben Hamer Reproduced from a paper
More informationDRAFT APPROPRIATE ASSESSMENT SCREENING REPORT
DRAFT APPROPRIATE ASSESSMENT SCREENING REPORT Climate Change Sectoral Adaptation Plan for Flood Risk Management (2014-2019) 2538_RP/003/C FRAM Section Office of Public Works 2538_RP/003/D CONTENTS 1.0
More informationChapter 8: Lifecycle Planning
Chapter 8: Lifecycle Planning Objectives of lifecycle planning Identify long-term investment for highway infrastructure assets and develop an appropriate maintenance strategy Predict future performance
More informationMournag, Tunisia. Local progress report on the implementation of the 10 Essentials for Making Cities Resilient ( )
Mournag, Tunisia Local progress report on the implementation of the 10 Essentials for Making Cities Resilient (2013-2014) Name of focal point: Kamal Alelwy Organization: La ville de Mournag Title/Position:
More informationDO WE NEED TO CONSIDER FLOODS RARER THAN 1% AEP?
DO WE NEED TO CONSIDER FLOODS RARER THAN 1% AEP? Drew Bewsher and John Maddocks Bewsher Consulting Pty Ltd Abstract Everyone is aware that floods rarer than the 1% AEP event occur. Australia-wide, over
More informationReview of preliminary flood risk assessments (Flood Risk Regulations 2009): guidance for lead local flood authorities in England
Review of preliminary flood risk assessments (Flood Risk Regulations 2009): guidance for lead local flood authorities in England 25 January 2017 We are the Environment Agency. We protect and improve the
More informationQuantitative Cost-Benefit Analysis
SERIES 3: Building Resilience Quantitative Cost-Benefit Analysis Guide 3.10.0 Contents 3.10.0: Guide 3.10.1: Activity This training set is designed for teams that need to implement a quantitative cost-benefit
More informationPLANNING FOR SAFE AND SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES
Flood Risk Management Protecting and Planning for our Communities PLANNING FOR SAFE AND SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES Mark Adamson Office of Public Works 12 th February, 2014 A WET START TO THE YEAR! STORM CHRISTINE
More informationENGINEERING AND CONSTRUCTION BULLETIN
ENGINEERING AND CONSTRUCTION BULLETIN No. 2016-8 Issuing Office: CECW-CE Issued: 22 Feb 16 Expires: 22 Feb 18 SUBJECT: Interim Risk Reduction Measures (IRRMs) for Levee Safety CATEGORY: Directive and Policy
More informationRESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE June 1 4, 2016
RESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE June 1 4, 2016 MUNICIPAL RISK ASSESSMENT TOOL (MRAT) Scott Praill Dillon Consulting Limited, Canada ABSTRACT MRAT is a made-in-canada tool that overlays municipal data sets and
More informationAspiration and reality: flood policy, economic. damages and the appraisal process
Area (2007) 39.2, 214 223 Aspiration and reality: flood policy, economic Blackwell Publishing Ltd damages and the appraisal process Clare Johnson, Edmund Penning-Rowsell and Sue Tapsell Flood Hazard Research
More informationFlooding in Brisbane. Challenges and implications. Kerry Doss Manager City Planning & Economic Development
Flooding in Brisbane Challenges and implications Kerry Doss Manager City Planning & Economic Development Brisbane, the River City In January 2011, the River City was reminded just what that meant Over
More information