E-Merge Process Table (Version 1)

Transcription

1 E-Merge Proess Tle (Version 1) I 1 Indiies Trgets Stte Energy Environmentl ESTABLISHING GOALS & BASELINES Identify gols from stte energy offie perspetive Identify stte puli helth nd welfre gols ffeted y energy-relted emissions Apply federl requirements, or go eyond them to redue risk of future nonttinment nd/or hieve more-protetive puli helth gols? Speify trget levels y pollutnt Identify stte energy gols for eletri system stte indiies for: Reliility? Reserve mrgins? (Lest) Cost? Speify trgets for eh gol Stkeholder Pln for stkeholder involvement, whih will e neessry in tion (see Step 6) if not sooner. Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here. Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here to diminish onflit lter. Inititing geny needs ddress how est to engge the other genies. Estlish timefrmes jointly, euse plnning must inlude wht nd when. Stkeholder involvement should our s erly s possile, even if informl t first. Cn PUC gols for utility IRP proesses e pplied here, llowing E-Merge to leverge existing stte efforts? Consider how impts of power setor trnsformtion (PST) will ply out. My wnt to pply options or rnge insted of single point vlues s initil trgets. Metris my e diffiult for some gols. Consider utilizing performne-sed regultion pprohes.

2 Other Info 2 Metris, Sttus 3 Gols Met? On-the- Books? Devition Stte Energy seline levels for stte energy offie gols Identify metris nd existing levels for eh gol identified Compre seline levels to gols Does eh metri meet the gol? If not, re there on the ooks poliies tht will use eh gol to e met? wht dditionl work is needed to hieve eh gol Environmentl Consider: Wht shre of AQ issues relte to EGU emissions tody? Wht if ny future EGU tions re plnned? Impts? Wht if ny good neighor oligtions exist? seline levels for ir qulity gols Identify mient ir qulity (AQ) levels (or EPA design vlues) for eh pollutnt Compre mient AQ levels (or EPA design vlues) for eh pollutnt to gols Does mient AQ level meet the gol (or EPA design vlue) for eh pollutnt? If not, re there on the ooks poliies tht will use the gol for eh pollutnt to e met? wht dditionl mient AQ improvement is needed for eh pollutnt seline levels for eletri system gols Identify metris nd existing levels for eh gol Compre seline levels to gols identified Does eh metri meet the gol? If not, re there on the ooks poliies tht will use eh gol to e met? wht dditionl work is needed to hieve eh gol Stkeholder Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here. Hving identified gols in Step 1, identify metris for ssessing urrent nd future sttus. Some levels (nd/or metris) my not e known (or onsensus my not exist); need to determine pth forwrd in these ses. 2

3 4 II 5 Review Supply Curve Stte Energy If neessry, ondut pproprite help determine wys to meet energy gols Environmentl If neessry, ondut AQ determine the mount of emission redutions needed to hieve mient AQ improvement IDENTIFY AND RANK MEASURES/OPTIONS urve of mesures to help hieve gols urve of mesures to help hieve neessry emission redutions If neessry, ondut energy system determine wht resoure mix(es) n hieve lestost plnning nd reliility gols urve of mesures to help hieve gols Collortively review supply urve to determine energy svings nd o-enefits performne hievle through ost-effetive energy effiieny (EE), demnd response (DR), renewle energy (RE), nd other mesures Stkeholder Stkeholder involvement my e espeilly helpful in identifying options nd mesures Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here. If desired, ondut eonomi modeling refleting optionlity. Note tht hoie of models is importnt, s dt nd resouress to support modeling efforts re often signifint. A supply urve lists options, their mgnitude, nd ost, sorted lest-ost to highest-ost. When ville, run this proess through system dynmis optimiztion model ginst dtse of potentil emission redution mesures until trget emission redutions nd energy gols re rehed t lest ost. Consider whether other setors ould help hieve gols (e.g., trnsporttion) Consider impts of poliies to oost enefiil eletrifition in other setors (e.g., trnsporttion, spe nd wter heting, et.) 3

4 Trnslte Into Metris Compre To Gols d Model & Iterte III 6 Stte Energy Trnslte options into performne metris ginst energy offie gols Agree on preferred options nd ompre overll performne to gol levels Condut eonomi onfirm gol hievement; iterte if neessry. IMPLEMENTATION Environmentl Trnslte options energy svings into emission redutions Agree on preferred options nd ompre their totl emissions redutions to trget levels Condut ir qulity onfirm gol hievement nd to stisfy EPA; iterte if neessry. Trnslte options into performne metris ginst gols (reliility, ost, et.) Agree on preferred options nd ompre overll performne to gol levels Condut energy system (dispth) onfirm gol hievement; iterte if neessry. Condut stkeholder proess(es) to onsider wht mesures should e dopted, wht revisions my e neessry, et. 7 Implement reommended mesures. EPA Approvl Adopt Regs Condut proeedings nd/or outreh neessry to mesures ssoited with energy gols. Ensure pprovility y EPA under the Clen Air At, et. Condut regultory proeedings neessry to mesures ssoited with ir qulity. Condut regultory proeedings neessry to mesures ssoited with the eletri system. Stkeholder Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here. If stkeholders were not involved previously, they should e now. If only limited numer of stkeholders were involved previously, expnd to e fully inlusive. Note tht modeling often rries signifint osts; there my e wys to estimte itertive results. If stkeholders were fully engged in the proess up to this point, this step my e unneessry. Suggest inviting EPA to prtiipte in the full proess nd provide feedk throughout. 4

5 IV 8 Stte Energy EVALUATION Identify proess stremlining tht E-Merge my hve enled Estimte svings (or osts) from E-Merge proess regultory stremlining Environmentl Identify regultory stremlining tht E-Merge my hve enled Estimte svings (or osts) from E-Merge proess regultory stremlining Identify regultory stremlining tht E-Merge my hve enled Estimte svings (or osts) from E-Merge proess regultory stremlining Stkeholder Stkeholder involvement my e vlule here. Exmple: Integrted proess my e more diffiult nd ostly thn for ny single geny or ny single pollutnt lone, ut less so thn for eh geny to hndle eh gol nd eh pollutnt individully. Sum net svings nd osts ross genies to provide estimted totl enefits or osts. 5