ر ر دور ٤ ر ٦ ٦ #"!ت-'& $&* U\! 4 (5 2\!.2. :^m I4AE!

Transcription

1 ر ر دور ٤ ر ٦ ٦ #"!ت'&!"# 3* 2 1 $ 456%!"# $%&' () $* +,./012! (4>$* 4.) ;<=. ($* 8*9) 4! " H. 4>@(EF0 G5> 145 4B%,./0 $(* A PAQM.4> 4ENO % 1388 $! I. "% UV W S(4AT *O S( P R. $* \! YB Z4 W. *O `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ () I4! PAQM.G* $%&' () (d.\. P UE FOe6%!"# Q $%&' f% () Z;> $* WNO ]! $%&' (). I4! ;E `a!"# ]! E $ABE g>$. ^<_!"# $%&' () ;<= I4! PE.&.4A5$ [% 456% 4A ^<_!"# $%&' () gg* FOe6% d.\.g! FOe6% `a bvc.;<= I4! I4!!"# $%&' ():' %# 96/7/4:@V_ GE ie% 96/9/4:@V_ WEF0 ie% :^m I4AE! jfakhri12@gmail.com * "% $(\" 4"> U\! 4 E(*.1 $&* U\! 4 (5 2\!.2 "% ^M> "% 4. "% $a U\! 4 4>A>5.3

2 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 2 (). $V ;LM $V GB+. I Y&' WNO $V Y= $L= 34 @ g(1393 ;M. W.!) G* $V UE4;E ol( 2% 4. Y&' 4Aa $V Y= Y&'. UE *.4AA5 q% $))=. 42A* p( XMp% * XL 4V%. G\0 G" 1r $;E ;%Z $=. $ABE gg* (( $Vr4(* PAT N! Z_( Z5. Lc Ep% >$ $V Y&' E 4AA5 s\ 4A!(.(2004;M. NA%) ae GB. $<(. $\$O N 4AA5^(A5 5.* E $* 4AE 1 2A *. 4$,EN $V Y= $V UE 2 4. b 4 u<'.,en. $V ;LM. GB+. (" FO@E*. PE. ZV@ b%%pe4.4> 4Aa 2% 4. EF03cB! PE >$ ) O4AA5[(*. $* P $'<% Z0 $* WNO M>@ d $%&' w<a E. 4> $A. X"Z O4AA5[(* 4E 4E WNO 4!( $ABE g4> $%&' () 4E $* WNO UE Y<!(V) FO e6% 1"* GM. $<( FO@E* OXMp%.(2007;M 456%!"# $%&' () $*,./0 @% WNO$%&' ()@5 Ga* \!'a 4E.4>$ ;<=. 4! 4!%$ O4!OXMp%. G5> W e6%. $!*. Y! E $* GM U\./0. FO@E* G5> " H. FO4!(* w OXMp% 4AE Z"% b PAT $O E g4> a 456%!"# $%&' () PE ZV ;<=. 4! 1. Signaling Theory 2. Positive Accounting Theory (PAT)

3 3... 4! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* *#+,! GLc Z_(!"# G4a PE%W. PE%X" GEE4 4>"# $V G* $V Y= G<!!"# Y= PE $* R_ GVm UE *.G* $<(5. fe=!"# Z> 4E WNO.(1393 ;M. W.!) $* 4> Z= xe(! 4E A PE4.4> $V Y= I PE.4 $* $V Y= I!"# A< 4>b5 uc $V ^_B $!AM' b5 1NL( N 4>$ $V E Z> $* G* 4 4!(* Z>) 4>ZE4B% WNO. (^<_ WNO Z>) 4\!ZE4B% WNO :(1393 $B) G*.(. WNO.!"#14 WNO d.\ WNO E P\0 (! G* $%&' () $& 2E z ;E. PAT.4A5 y)v a XMp%.. > $_ca FO@E* WNO ie%.(1394 ;M. $!") >$ FO@E* OXMp% Y.[% G& E G* $V Y= 8n ie% M $* XMp%. a `a 1"[. 40 $(& PAT.4$ \! G5> $LB X_% ) %, : I4!.FO$ e6% $V Y= [=. E 4 A G* $E@*9 4B% "A% 3&(a. 4AA5$ O4! S( PE ^ 8*9 10 E 8 6 4) 4![E (1981) L2! (2002) ;M. ^.5 R*% %$.5 >(2003) 4AVE. (2009) E.}! (2000) ;M. * G[5 sa> I4!,./0 2! * EG5> * >$ A,0 G* 4> [(* * EG5> %, % T5 @%. UE 3'.4> %{N $* %r G[5 4E6% $A< $a,./0 xe(! $* $* G[5 @(O! %r G<! ($* * 4A!)

4 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 4!"# $%&' () I4! e6% +,./0 ZV PM G* 4_(B (1981) $* %, 4A@& E g4! %G[5 $* 8n % NU! (\ G* U! G* E E(\ 4!. G*@ E(\ 4!5 "# PAT (1993) m!. *4E..4A(! Y= oe)% o\5 * w%.pe g4! %{N {N $\e (2005) X5 $V.G* T5@*9 %, * ;(* " I4!" S( O4! $La ol(,./0 *. T5 $*@*9 I E $M* $* {N I%,G4. A55 E4B% ZV@ $* ]! $M* UE " "@<% $*@*9 :4!>$ ;[% $*8*9. (1392). $\ R*% 4>12!,./0 xe(! $* %{N (1389) $La,./0 UE G* $V PE.4! 12! %G[5 `a GBA= E sp% PAQM. $* (*0*. 4> E4 %$ ^ ) G* 4> [(* " I4!" S( 8<*) G" (1395) ;M. $. (1394) $)V=. >a$!me (1391) $!5$M#!. $E (" Y4a bl PAT.(5 > $E5 8E! 2!.(2005 Aƒ) G<! 4>$ $%&' () X(@ R*% 4>\ Y&' %G[5 * R*% NU!,*0 o\5 G* 4$ \! a ^* G* PE $U!UT $O a $V Y= O4AA5[(* E*. FO@E* 1"* ( I4! T $[L( O4E ) WNO FOe6%!"# 4A!4 % 4A(4A@& $V Y&' ;M. ie\) G* $%&' () %

5 5... 4! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* ]! $%&' () I4! ]+ PE +.aefo$ e6%!"#!" $%&' $UAE! %, \ ZV@ 4> %{N 2% 4. $E4. PAT 4"* UE g. %X5 OXMp% }E% a P0 YrM( 4A!%$ (" % T5 2% PME. }%. ;M. $!") 4AA5 &=. y)v $4 W0 ' 8+@* Z> 4 N! G5> I4! 8+ *.4>$ ^M( 4> %, Z E* Ge %, 4AA5 Z_(A I. 4>WNO $E@E. (!.4A5$ (!. $** 4B 8+.G* P;M E g> G5> r.* G* P;M $"% PAT.4A5 G5> r.* G* $=a Y_ E 4E4 YV. > 4G**,A5. b G* P;M.(1394;M. $!") 4EM! ZM)% G5> *#+, 0./, % 1995 $! I.. "U!> " H. (2000) ;M. PT. GM ($* $)+% 4A M) d.>. d.\ WNO e6% $E. 5F WNO 1"* PE G<!,A5. P PAQM.. AB. ;B 8c.4!. AB Y.[% WNO 1. The Bonus Plan Hypothesis 2. The Debt Contract Hypothesis 3. The Political Cost Hypothesis

6 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 6 $* WNO $%&' () $\./0 (2000) $!cl* \! 8<*) G" UV " H. AB. $[A $* WNO \(! EN! $%&' () N! 1. ^* $* d.\ WNO ;%.. $%&' () V(* " H. N! (2003) ;M. Z. ("A "`a bvc 456%" 4A 4A!) $+ 4A $* $EG5> \! O4AA5[(* GM XMp%. E X" $\_! 5F 4A E. 4A(> $V ).G*@(>4! G5> FO@E* d.\ WNO * (2004) ;M. NA% $* d.\ 4!4*@)(! $* $*.4! $%&' W O4AA5[(* d.\ WNO $%&' () $E 34 (2007) ;M. Y<!(V 1"* GM $* d.\ WNO e6% " H. $*. 1"* GM d.\ WNO e6% <! $* $* $\./0 N! (2012) Pƒ!(E $M_( e6% $* $5. u_)% xe(!.ga0. $*!"# $%&' () (2016) AEMˆ*. }5A% ]!. @2(! \E.4! $V GB+.. ;<= I4! I4! X_( e PAT. $U( G5> '23 *#+,. 1"* GM *!"# e6% $\./0 (1378) $M%a. A<> $* d.\ WNO e6% $E G"!.4A(a0 $V Y= ZL)% $5 $* " * 8<*) G" UV 1"* GM PAQM. 1"* GM. $* WNO d> P 8c.

7 7... 4! 456%!"# $%&' a $V OXMp% $* d.\ WNO $* d.\ WNO $%&' () N! (1389) 14_..4" P AB Y.[%. <! U!! $* A(* UE $* ^<_. d.\ WNO \(! Z= G<! $* d.\ WNO 5 %$ N.G! %, $%&' () ^<_ X2 $*!"# ]! e6% X (1392) 5W_!E4. 1"* \! \E u_)% 1"* Y&B 4 % NEM% PE > Zn Y.[% $*!"# G* P;M $L5 '.O 1"* Y&B X2 S% G! YS% e.!"# <" X (1395) $M. " PAQM.!"# ]! 4$ \! u_)% xe(!.4a(a0 1"* Y&B X2. GM. G5> 1"* Y&B X2. GM $M_( 8c!"# <" () $* G* U! PE.& $*!"# S%. a OXMp% FO@E*. G* $%&'.4!@% *#+, (45 $!< :4!4> PE.4% E Y=@.G* $%&' ()!"#:(1) $L=8+(oV.G* $%&' () ^<_!"#:(11) $8+ () `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# :(12) $ 8+.G* $%&'.G* $%&' () d.\!"#:(13) $8+ 8c!"# $%&' (). I4! P :(2) $L= 8+ (.. AB

8 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 8 ^<_!"# $%&' (). I4! P :(21) $ 8+.. AB 8c ^<_!"# $%&' (). I4! P :(22) $ 8+.. AB 8c `a bvc 456% 4A d.\!"# $%&' (). I4! P :(23) $ 8+.. AB 8c 8c!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4! P :(3) $L= 8+ (.. AB ^<_!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4! P :(31) $ 8+.. AB 8c ^<_!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4! P :(32) $ 8+.. AB 8c `a bvc 456% 4A d.\!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4! P :(33) $ 8+.. AB 8c *#+, 6# # 7.G* $U(<M$[=% G y)v y)v,./0 PE *#+, 89 (1) UV ^. $L= 8+ +,./0 8+ (2) UV 1. $L= 8+ G* 4> \! E,./0 UV.G* 4> [(* (3) UV 1* $L=.G* 4>.1 ^.4,./0 S( PAQM R i,t = C(1)*EARN i,t + C(2)* EARN i,t + C(3)* AuditOpinion i,t + C(4)*EARN i,t * AuditOpinion i,t + C(5)*LEV i,t + C(6)*GROWTH i,t + C(7)* AuditOpinion i,t * LEV + C(8)*UNQOP i,t *GROWTH i,t + e i,t ( 1) R i,t = C(1)*EARN i,t + C(2)* EARN i,t + C(3)* AuditOpinion i,t + C(4)*EARN i,t * AuditOpinion i,t + C(5)*LEV i,t + C(6)*GROWTH i,t + C(7)* AuditOpinion i,t * LEV + C(8)*UNQOP i,t *GROWTH i,t + e i,t ( 2)

9 9... 4! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* R i,t = C(1)*EARN i,t + C(2)* EARN i,t + C(3)* AuditOpinion i,t + C(4)*SIZE i,t + C(5)* AuditOpinion i,t *SIZE i,t + C(6)*GROWTH i,t + C(7)*LEV i,t + C(8)* AuditOpinion i,t *LEV + C(9)* AuditOpinion i,t *GROWTH i,t + e i,t ( 3) :1 1"* X"* GM X"* * X"* GM X"* * YS% ^<_!"# `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# d.\!"# I4! ;<= I4! 4>! $V S( Z_( S( Z_( S( OZE4B% S( OZE4B% S( OZE4B% S( OZE4B% S( OZE4B% S( $V(A5 S( $V(A5 S( R EARN EARN UNQOP UNQEXP QOP AUDITOR SIZE GROWTH LEV <= ; #*#+, : (# S( "A% 4>$B :(R) 1"*.4> \! 1"*. GM Y&' d<%! $!<,.G* 1"* O4! Z_( $%&' () 1"* [(* $M_% *.&@ 1"* GM YS% 1"* 2AE.>$.G* >) : X"* GM X"* * X_% Y< :(EARN) X"* GM X"* * $U(<M ]! E 2E 4= S( PE.4>PB% $! I. 4( G5>.G* 1"*

10 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 10 X"* *" YS% G* Y< :( EARN) X"* GM X"* * G* 4> W&% S( PE oeb%.@(>fo G<! $LB I. "X"* GM.> s\ %, 1"* $O4Af+% N 1. 0$V.) }E. (* ^4 [(* S( G* 1r 4> PAT N! $\./0 UV.G* 4> (* (1393 ;M.G*@(. Z_( S(. ;>?@ : :4>$ E (AuditOpinion)! "# ]! 4>PB% I. ;<= $* WNO O :(UNQOP) ^<_!"#.G* [= Y= PE. E S( PE 4_ 4> ^<_!"# $* WNO O :(UNQEXP) `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4_ 4> `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4>PB% I. ;<=.G* [= Y= PE. E S( PE 4>PB% I. ;<= $* WNO O :(QOP) d.\!"#.g* [= Y= PE. E S( PE 4_ 4> d.\!"# $M* :(AUDITOR) I4! P(> $* *. ( T5 T5 * %$ ^.4!@(O {N * I %, G4. E A55 (1393) a$a. ;>N0. (1392) ;M. $V4< R*% 4>12!,./0 Y">. <(.{N 8*9 PE.5 > 4 8B $* Y*9) $* Y*9 E* Z_. r Y*9 G* % T5 $* G<! ($M* $%=.G* PE0 Y">. <( I4! 2 S( 4_ G* $* *,./0 I. $' [= 4_ Y=PE. E $* 1. Easton and Harris

11 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* 1"* W X(EUV ;<= I4! O4! :(SIZE) ;<= I4! %, 4>PB% I. ;<= 1"* W X(EUV O.G* 4> [(* G5> PE. E S( PE 4_ 4> G5> 1"* W PU! X(EUV.G* [= Y= 9. : I. ;<= 1"* <= H_ W G* Y< :(GROWTH) 4>! ;M..). M ;<= 1"* <= H_ ( W X_% 4>PB%.(2011 I. ;<= ($4 Z5) Y44AL $4 G* Y< :(LEV) $V 1.(2009 }A. V). M ;<= $E Z5 X_% 4>PB% = 0@1 % 1388 $! I.!. 4AM4 O@!M! W.,./0 PE Z> G5> 145 4B% X A 3F W. [(*..O ^* :4!4> (! E B *G5> ^* 1015@ d $V ^* Y&' EF0@E_ 34. $(<*A. $Lp e $"(A G5> 1386 ^* Z< G5> u_)% 4ENO G5> $V Y= (a*. YLM G Y.[% G5> E FO@E* G5>. 4A!) $V "!.4A><! $V Z5 G5> $V Y&'.4> (* u_)% I. u_)% I. $' 4ENO G5> Y&' EF0@E_ $O/E. Œ[ $V ^* S%.,@[. PAT u_)% I. $' 4ENO G5> $%&B o% Y=.(1393 A0. [=) 4><!

12 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 12 *#+, (5? A"= 2 ^.4,./0 S( $[=% $%4_ PU! PE%X5. d,./0 S( P PU! PE%,.G*.G* X"* GM X"* * d (, 55/945 2/ / /019 0 /28 ( "+ 134 /939 1 / / / /97 " #$ %& :2 * 0 0 /134 0/ /048 2 /4 () 2 /668 0 /134 0/901 0 /116 0 /348 0 /534 0 /372 0 /209 0 /47 0 /086 4 /087 #$ '%& 1"* X"* GM X"* * X"* GM X"* * YS% ^<_!"# `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# d.\!"# $V ) ]. ^M( I4! ;<= I4! $V 1 4>!!. = BC <= # C9 F<= PM% G* 1r FV.4> $ $<5% @%.G* 4> [(* MV F A PE.O s\ ($EL% E $_[L%). >$ [(* $_[L% W. 4> %5 %, $%4\ [(* $EL% W. ^4 PM% G* %5 %X5 $%4\ 4!%$ " Ge Ye". " $p% Ye" ^4. [(* a $EL% W..>$.G* 4EO [(* PM* > [(* ^4 PB%.O 12!

13 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* *8 7+ (5 H 56 F 23& 4 1$/0 :3 23& *> ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye ($LA0) $EL% $p% Ye %7:; <= 0/812 0/594 0/841 0/796 0/255 0/397 0/772 0/603 0/919 :73& *%: '%& %79 1/723 4/470 1/652 6/471 1/671 4/169 1/702 5/414 1/690 11/300 1/698 9/422 1/673 5/672 1/645 7/322 1/662 3/870 23& MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* MV F PM* 23& 11? 18 12? 18 13? 18 21? 18 22? 18 23? 18 31? 18 32? 18 33? 18 (1) '"045<= (!.G* 4> [(* Ge Ye *O F Ge Ye $EL% UV. $<5% *O UV W. P gg* 1M% 5 > (! $<5% W. MV F O.>$ [(* MV 12! N! PM* % G* 1r > (! Ge Ye $EL% W. O $p% Ye UV Z_ Ge Ye UVO5@ PB% PM*.>.(1389G<;!. $!'&) >$ [(* G* $p% Ye W. 4E6% 4A\! 3 ^.4 4A xe(! (G* %5 %X5 ^M( E gg* $<5% $EL% 4E6% EO 4 ^.4 (11) $ 8+ $M. 42@_).G* 4> \!

14 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 14 (11)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :4 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 30/402 1/722 UV 4< 1/133 0/624 0/489 0/111 X"* GM X"* * 1/001 0/004 2/871 0/007 X"* GM X"* * YS% 6/137 0/017 2/39 0/374 ^<_!"# 3/596 0/029 2/181 1/710!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 1/162 7/848 1/777 $V 1 1/026 4/729 0/006 4>! 2/007 0/119 1/558 1/397 ^<_!"# Ž $V 1 2/488 0/278 1/084 0/014 ^<_!"# 4>! 0/08 PB% be+ 0/06 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/741 %.P. I 5/23 \ I UV AB 10 %X5 }!E. 1% Z @% AB $* PAQM.4!4! $cax UE4;E,./0 S( G* @5 4> [(* 4= 5 ca fc* F $!*O UV 4= 95 AM' %$ () AB fc* PAQM. (5/23) 4>@<*) t be+ AB $* PM+.G* AB Z5 UV 5 S( I be+ (11) $ 8+.G* 4> [(* 4= 5 ca fc* S( PE be+ 4 ^.4 u<'.g* 4> $A,0 AB ^<_!"# 4AA5ZE4B% 8+ b%%pe4.g* AB 4= 95 AM' fc* G* 1/710.G* $%&' () ^<_!"#. 4> 4E6% (11) $ 4> [(* (1) PE :(12) $ 8+.G* ^.4 a

15 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* (12)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :5 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 40/45 1/989 UV 4< 1/724 0/254 1/141 0/333 X"* GM X"* * 1/005 0/186 1/322 0/004 X"* GM X"* * YS% 2/598 7/002 0/579 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 2/313 4/637 1/117!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 1/563 6/794 1/184 $V 1 2/292 0/004 2/837 0/005 4>! 2/1 4/14 1/755 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"#$V 1 2/455 0/275 1/092 0/002 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4>! 0/13 PB% be+ 0/12 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/779 %.P. I 9/296 \ I UV AB fc* 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (12) $ 8+ gg* 1/117 S( PE be+ 6 ^.4 u<'.g* 4> $A,0 AB `a AB 4= 95 AM' 5 %$ y)v $ABE () `a bvc 4<5% 4A ^<_!"#. 4> 4E6% 8+.G* $%&' $A,0 AB d.\!"# 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (13) $ 8+ %$ y)v $ABE gg* 1/213 S( PE be+ 6 ^.4 u<'.g* 4>!"#. 4> 4E6% AB 4= 95 AM' 5 6 ^.4 Z= xe(!.g* $%&' () d.\.g* 4> \! fc* (13). (12) (11) @% Ga* \!'a 4E *O 4E6% 4= 95 AM' F I AB fc* (1) $L= d G* PE

16 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 16 Ž P.I 4A! E* PAQM.G* UV 4=5%X5 I P(> 2/5. 1/5 P) 4! $Lc fc* N! }!E. 1% Z. %. (1) $L= 5 PAT P..G* 4> 4E6%!"# (13)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :6 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 16/376 1/37 UV 4< 3/140 0/255 4/502 0/821 X"* GM X"* * 1/006 1/138 0/003 X"* GM X"* * YS% 2/559 7/678 0/627 d.\!"# 3/465 5/721 1/213!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 3/916 8/111 2/68 $V 1 1/842 3/481 0/007 4>! 5/056 4/097 1/798 d.\!"#$v 1 1/963 0/631 0/479 0/001 d.\!"# 4>! 0/12 PB% be+ 0/11 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/751 %.P. I 8/832 \ I UV AB fc* (2) '"045<= ^<_!"# $%&' () 8c AB (2) $L= 8+.G* $* d.\. `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ ^<_!"#. I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (21) $ 8+ g>$m! 4E6% (21) $ G* 4\! $A,0 AB. AB 8c ^<_!"# $%&' (). I4! P UE.G* 4> \! 7^.4 Z= xe(!.4!

17 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* (21)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :7 G%7 % H? 1/111 1/004 3/812 1/093 1/263 1/164 1/027 2/009 2/541 5F7 0/422 0/007 0/912 0/249 0/086 0/273 0/019 0/08 0/07 1/758 5/131 te%& 21/422 0/767 2/705 0/110 1/152 1/719 10/610 4/488 1/095 2/347 D78 1/658 0/167 0/007 0/009 0/123 0/702 1/926 0/006 1/210 0/017 UV 4< X"* GM X"* * X"* GM X"* * YS% ^<_!"# I4! I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( $V 1 4>! ^<_!"#$V 1 ^<_!"# 4>! PB% be+ 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ %.P. I \ I UV AB fc*.g* 4> [(* (2) PE :(22) $8+ ^<_!"#. I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( I be+ (22) $ \! $A,0 AB `a blc 456% `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# $%&' (). I4!P.G* 4> \! 8 ^.4 5F 8+ Z= xe(!.4!. AB 8c (22)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :8 G%7 % H? 1/156 1/008 1/988 1/698 2/083 1/487 2/296 2/056 5F7 0/362 0/006 0/418 0/367 0/010 0/019 te%& 49/593 0/911 2/718 4/238 0/808 0/901 5/017 2/574 2/336 D78 1/787 0/183 0/007 0/366 0/061 0/089 1/419 0/005 1/434 UV 4< X"* GM X"* * X"* GM X"* * YS% `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# I4! I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( $V 1 4>! `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"#$V 1

18 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 18 2/453 0/340 0/10 0/09 1/765 6/498 0/953 0/002 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4>! PB% be+ 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ %.P. I \ I UV AB fc* Z= xe(!.g* 4> [(* (2) PE :(23) $ 8+.G* 4> \! 9^.4 (23)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :9 G%7 % H? 1/160 1/009 1/960 2/100 2/345 3/944 1/839 4/940 1/961 5F7 0/286 0/004 0/821 0/806 0/013 0/011 0/669 0/10 0/09 1/741 6/408 t'%& 15/096 1/066 2/895 5/862 0/226 0/244 6/039 2/485 2/541 0/426 D78 1/497 0/213 0/006 0/397 0/018 0/039 2/545 0/006 1/501 0/001 ^4 4<. 4( 1"* GM X"* *. 4( 1"* GM X"* * YS% d.\!"# I4! I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( $V 1 4>! d.\!"#$v 1 d.\!"# 4>! PB% be+ 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ %.P. I \ I UV AB fc* d.\!"#. I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( I be+ (23) $ 8+ g>$m! 4E6% (23) $ 4\! $A,0 AB. AB 8c d.\!"# $%&' (). I4!P UE.4!

19 ! 456%!"# (! 3&a (2) $L= 8+ Z= xe(! 95 AM' fc* (23). (22) (21) $E@(E!"# (2) $L= 4E6% 4=!"# $%&' 5 %$ 4= 95 AM'.4\! 4E6% 8c I4! d.\. `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ ^<_.4!. AB (3) '"045<= ^<_!"# $%&' () 8c AB (3) $L= 8+.G* ;<= I4! $* d.\. `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ xe(!.g* 4> [(* (1) PE :(31) $ 8+.G* 4> \! 10^.4 Z= (31)? 18 23& * *$/0 :10 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 23/284 1/828 UV 4< 1/113 0/543 0/608 0/15 X"* GM X"* * 0/01 0/014 2/458 0/006 X"* GM X"* * YS% 7/474 0/002 3/104 1/04 ^<_!"# 1/14 4/574 0/221 ;<= I4! 3/839 4/743 1/288 ;<= I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 1/161 8/874 1/76 $V 1 1/031 4/075 0/007 4>! 2/155 4/39 3/393 ^<_!"#$V 1 3/419 0/007 2/7 0/148 ^<_!"# 4>! 0/17 PB% be+ 0/16 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/777 %.P. I 11/260 \ I UV AB fc*

20 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 20 ^<_!"#. ;<= I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (31) $ 8+ P UE G* 4> $A,0 AB.. AB 8c ^<_!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4!.G* 4> [(* (3) PE :(32)$ 8+ ^<_!"#. ;<= I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (32) $ 8+ 4\! $A,0 AB `a bvc 456% 4A 456% 4A ^<_!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4! P UE g> 11 ^.4 Z= xe(!.4!. AB 8c `a bvc.g* 4> \! (32)? 18 23& * *$/0 :11 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 37/548 1/929 UV 4< 1/149 0/605 0/517 0/126 X"* GM X"* * 1/014 0/011 2/553 0/006 X"* GM X"* * YS% 2/484 4/115 0/457 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 1/575 5/050 0/177 ;<= I4! 2/197 0/430 0/788 0/099 ;<= I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 1/486 5/051 0/503 $V 1 2/300 3/534 0/007 4>! 2/069 0/074 1/790 1/321 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"#$V 1 2/473 0/515 0/650 0/001 `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# 4>! 0/13 PB% be+ 0/11 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/723 %.P. 7/935 \ I UV AB fc*.g*4> [(*(3) PE :(33) $8+

21 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* d.\!"#. ;<= I4! 4AA5ZE4B% S( be+ (33) $ 8+ P UE 4> $A,0 AB.. AB 8c d.\!"# $%&' (). ;<= I4!.G* 4> \! 12^.4 Z=xE(! (33)? 18 23& * 1$/0 :12 G%7 % H? 5F7 te%& D78 12/025 1/492 ^4 4< 1/157 0/539 0/614 0/142. 4( 1"* GM X"* * 1/015 0/008 2/646 0/005. 4( 1"* GM X"* * YS% 2/581 7/452 0/608 d.\!"# 2/257 0/637 0/471 0/050 ;<= I4! 3/234 4/114 0/434 I4!.!"# ]! 4AA5ZE4B% S( 3/965 3/821 2/362 $V 1 1/879 3/549 0/007 4>! 4/976 0/118 1/564 0/908 d.\!"#$v 1 1/980 0/820 0/227 d.\!"# 4>! 0/31 PB% be+ 0/30 4>ZE4B% PB% be+ 1/722 %.P. I 23/984 \ I UV AB fc* AM' fc* (33). (31) @% (3) $L= 4E6% (32) $ 8+. 4!4> 4E6% 4= 95 ^<_!"#) ]! E. 4> 4E6% (d.\. ^<_)!"# ]!..4\! 4E6% (`a bvc 456% 4A 3./, #;(I Z. $%&' () $* 34 +,./0 xe(!.4>$ ;<= I4!. I4! $ABE O4AA5[(* OXMp% X"

22 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 22 WNO $%&' (). $A<,./0 ^. $L= 8+ W Z= $V OZL)% O4A<( G* ]+ PE I4A\! Z_( y4>@"% WNO 4>$* $V Y&' O4AA5[(* ]! E PE $_e w<a $* * R*% }0 G* $O4AEM! 8AEN AM'Z $%&' w<a E 4> 4> $M* R*% a Z= xe(!.g* 4> 4E6% N! R*% >$ $_L% \E.G* O* N! (2000) $!cl*,./0 Z= xe(! ^. $L= 8+ u_)% xe(!. " H. $* WNO $%&' () $* WNO \(! EN! ]+ PE U! N! 1. ^* $* d.\ WNO ;% PAQM.. AB. $[A xe(! ^. $L= 8+ Z= xe(! PM+.G* $%&' () a@bvc \E.G* O* X(1395) $M. ",./0. G5> 1"* GM. Y&B X2 AB. X_( 8c!"# Y&B X2. GM AB. X_( 8c!"# <" PAQM. 1"* P $A<,./0 1. $L= 8+ W Z= G* I4A\! I4!. Z_( WNO ]! $%&' e6% $* WNO $%&' () ($* 8*9) $ABE.4A5$ [% ;E `a!"# ]! UE Y< 4A5 d.\!"# $(5> 5 %$ $L5' ;E 4> 4> $* $M* 8*9 R*% $(V 8c!"# ]! $%&' (). I4! P PEA.G*,./0 Z= xe(! 1. $L= 8+ Z= xe(!.4!. a,./0 \E E gg* O*! (2016) AEMˆ*. }5A%.G*FOe6%!"# $%&' () I4!@5 4!4* P AB 8c. $A<,./0 1* $L= 8+ W gg* $5 ;<= I4!. WNO ]! $%&' ()

23 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$*!"# $%&' () $V g. AB 8c ;<= I4! d.\. ^<_ ;<= I4! `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# $%&' () $%&' () 4A> AB 8c $%&' () ;<= I4! 8c 8+ PEA G* %, N!!"#. 4> 4E6% d.\. ^<_!"# `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# $%&' () bvc 456% 4A ^<_. ^<_!"# 5 [% PAT %$. Z {N G5> E g4! $!4AT Y.[% {N G5> `a $)+% 4A E G* P;M $!. p( 4a 4!%$M! `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# PEA.> WNO $(M $%&' UE O4E $*!"# o' *. d.\. PE UE $%&' () 4A( "% " H. 4>@(EF0 G5> $)+% 4A E.. G* $L5 GV {N G5> Y= O4AA5[(* @ 4!%$M! {N G5>. @% 4>$* $V AEMˆ*. }5A%,./0 Z= xe(! uc d.\. ^<_!"# bvc 456% 4A ^<_!"# <! UE *.G* (2016) (2016) AEMˆ*. }5A%,./0 Z= xe(! ;<= I4! `a.g* O*! /#+, (5?.! 3 3./, PEA g4a( $%&' a OXMp% $* $EWNO 4A Y&',0, >$. _V FO@E*. OZL)% O4!O FV.4AA5 [(* WNO OXMp% 1UA >$ "A\0 "% " H. ZB[V

24 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 24 ]! P d<%. $* WNO 4A $%&' ()..4!U! $%&' (). $* WNO!"# $%&' (). I4! * RE> $%4"M% 4\E4! FO! % >$ "A\0 FV 4!. AB 8c $* $(V. d $* 5]p)!4>@(;> $M* ue'pe4 % 4!. X Y*9 P $( $c) PM+. \! 2E $* * @*9 PE $!;E G= $M* U(a,! >$ z = *#+,?3./, () $M* ]!. 1.4% e6% $*. d.\. `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ ^<_@!O@*!"#$%&' 456% 4A $O4A<T P 8c $*.>$ ;%!"#]! $!. d.\. `a bvc 456% 4A ^<_ GEE4 $E!% P 8c $*. d.\. `a bvc J. 1L. $V GEE4 4 Y )% $2A*p( 5.(1389).^ G<;!..] $!'&.@% Y\(! "% ^. sp%. $* G5> I4! e6% $*.(1394).].1 $)V=.. >a$!me }![A5 P.. $L }![A5 P"T * GEE4 $* G[5 sa> A.GEE4. 4 $LLMVP 4"B% 1& GEE4. GBA= sp%.(1391).1 $!5$M#!..].1 $E.174(46) 12 $*,!. (a

25 ! 456%!"# $* WNO 4A* $LL)% $*.(1391). 4M$L.. 4"$A.2913 (6) 2 GEE4 $*. 4,! G[5 4p% Y4 8c $*.(1393).1. a$a..]. ;>N (67) 174,!. $*.G\ULO Y\(! "% ^. T 4 `a $*.(1393). $B. 1"* Y&B X2. GM YS% Ye.!"# <".(1395)..1 $M.. ".8261 (8) 30 $*. $V $ML Y\(! "% ^. @ALp.. $* 8*9 I4!. $* G[5 P 8c.(1389).v (61) 17 $*. 4 $*. $* WNO > Eaq 5 $%&' ().(1384).1 (42) 4 $*. 4 $*!) O4A<( OXMp% Z_( WNO e6%.(1383)..1. (6) 2 4 (E ^&_(*. $* 4p% I.GBA= sp% e6%.(1395).1 $M%aM).. G5AT. $ (32) 8 $*. $V 1"* GM WNE $V Y= ZL)%. 1"* GM $* d.>e6%.(1378).].1 $M%a.. A<>.5023 (1) 11 GEE4. "% " H. NO5. $'> 5@ $O4A<T e6%.(1393). A A[=.6039(14) 44 $2%,./0 Y= 8n 4E42% $O/E. e6%.(1392). %0..] $^B..1$V4<.10085(20) 3$*. 4 $*. $V T 8 E. [(* (E Z!0 5 $2A*p(.(1394).` $M..] 42@_.XL! Y\(!"% ^. 1" 456% * GEE4.!"#.(1393).1.!..1 V= (21) 2$*. 4 GVB 1.4%

26 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 26 ol( RE> 1"* Y!*! G5> I4! 8c.(1390). PM3.. ie\.8669(11) 3$*. 4 4>@(EF0 G5> d.\ WNO $%&' () $*.(1389).] 14_...4".8568 (6) 2 $*. 4 Y "% " H..,! U! Y\(! "% ^. 4L 4 m%.(1394).1. $A4*... "% ^. T 1. 4L 4 m%.(1395).1 $"..1. $A4*.. $5.. $!" $5. $!".,! U! Y\(! H. 1"* Y&B X2!"# ]! e6%.(1392)..1 5W_!E4. GV (18) 4 $*. 4 Y "% " Y\! "% 1. T $V 4 w..(1393).1... $5..$!".. W.!.,! U! 1* T.] 4 $%<e m%.(1392).^.$ PME..^. }%..@% Y\(! "% d (a \ fc* e6% $*.(1393). 4M..H!bV'. 0$V. 4. "% " H. 4>@(EF0 G5> 4 Y&' W.8171(21) 7Y )%. 1L 4. $&* * Y\(! "% 113 IM> 8E\! E $V U>NO. 4! $!<.(1376) 4 4!(* PE.4% Gm G[5. $* 8*9 I4! P 8c $*.(1392).v..] $\.5223 (17) 5$*. 4Y )% AlThuneibat, A.A., Khamees, B.A. and AlFayoumi, N.A. (2007). The Effect of Qualified Auditors' Opinions on Share Prices: Evidence from Jordan. Managerial Auditing Journal, 23 (1): Bessell, M., Anandarajan, A. and Umar, A. (2003). Information Content, Audit Reports and Goingconcern: An Australian Study. Accounting and Finance, 43 (3):

27 ! 456%!"# $%&' ()$* Chen, C.J., Su, X. and Zhao, R. (2000). An Emerging Market's Reaction to Initial Modified Audit Opinions: Evidence from the Shanghai Stock Exchange. Contemporary Accounting Research, 17 (3): Craswell, A., Stokes D.J. and Laughton, J. (2002). Auditor Independence and Fee Dependence. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 33 (2): Davidson, R.A. and Neu, D. (1993). A Note on Association between Audit Firm Size and Audit Quality. Contemporary Accounting Research, 9 (2): DeAngelo, L.E. (1981). Auditor Size and Audit Quality. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 3 (3): Defond, M., Francis, J.R. and Wong, T.J. (2000). Auditor Industry Specialization and Market Segmentation: Evidence from Hong Kong. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 19 (1): Francis, J.R. and Yu, M.D. (2009). Big 4 Office Size and Audit Quality. The Accounting Review, 84 (5): Hao, S., Jin, Q. and Zhang, G. (2011). Investment Growth and the Relation between Equity Value, Earnings, and Equity Book Value. Accounting Review, 86 (2): Henock, L. (2005). Acquirers Abnormal Returns, Audit Firm Size and the Small Auditor Clientele Effect. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 40 (13): Herbohn, K., Ragunathan, V. and Garsden, R. (2007). The Horse Has Bolted: Revisiting the Market Reaction to Going Concern Modifications of Audit Reports. Accounting and Finance, 47 (3): Ireland, J.C. (2003). An Empirical Investigation of Determinants of Audit Reports in the UK. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 30 (78): Ittonen, K. (2012). Market Reactions to Qualified Audit Reports: Research Approaches. Accounting Research Journal, 25 (1): 824. Kim, J. (2005). Accounting Transparency of Korean Firms: Measurement and Determinant Analysis. The Journal of American Academy of Business, Cambridge, (2):

28 1396Nn016 M> 4. 4 $* 28 Ljubic, D. and Mance, D. (2009). A Model of Accounts Receivable Risk Management for Bosnia And Herzegovina s Business Environment. Rijeka: University of Rijeka, Faculty of Economics. Martínez, M.C.P., Martínez, V.A. and Benau, M.A.G. (2004). Reactions of the Spanish Capital Market to Qualified Audit Reports. European Accounting Review, 13 (4): Soltani, B. (2000). Some Empirical Evidence to Support the Relationship between Audit Reports and Stock Prices the French Case. International Journal of Auditing, 4 (3): Tahinakis, P. and Samarinas, M. (2016). The Incremental Information Content of Audit Opinion. Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 17 (2):