IMPLEMENTATION OF BUS RAPID TRANSIT SYSTEM IN HUBBALLI DHARWAD RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN FOR IMPACTS WITH DHARWAD BUS TERMINAL (MITRA SAMAJ)

Transcription

1 IMPLEMENTATION OF Public Disclosure Authorized BUS RAPID TRANSIT SYSTEM IN HUBBALLI DHARWAD SFG1653 V2 RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN FOR IMPACTS WITH DHARWAD BUS TERMINAL (MITRA SAMAJ) Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized HUBLI-DHARWAD BRTS COMPANY LIMITED September-2016

2 Contents Executive Summary 1 Introduction Extent of land to be acquired Magnitude of Impacts Impact on Land and Structures Project Affected Persons Tenants Squatters & Kiosks Budget for RAP: Public Consultation meeting with Dharwad city PAPs Socio-Economic Survey Social Assessment of PAPs Caste wise distribution of PAPs in % Age wise distribution of PAPs Size of the family Occupations wise distribution of the PAPs Income level wise distribution PAPs of families Rehabilitation and Resettlement Grievance Redress Committee Time table for key activities Annexure Annexure I: PAPs list Annexure II: Photo documentation Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 2

3 Executive Summary The proposed bus terminal at Mitra Samaj is exclusively for BRTS buses and as this terminal right in middle of the city, the terminal design is unique and aesthetic. It is located 1.5km from the Jubilee Circle. The area of proposed site is 36Gunte and 10Annas. As per the land use patterns, the entire stretch i.e. from Jubilee Circle to Anjuman Circle and from Anjuman Circle to Jubilee Circle surrounded by commercial, Government land and only few residential buildings. As per JMC three properties will be affected, One title holder is private person. Out of the two remaining properties one belongs to HDMC and the other is Government property. In addition to existing approved RAP of Hubli Dharwad BRTS project, The Resettlement Action Plan for the Hubli-Dharwad BRTS at Mitra Samaj was prepared to address and mitigate the impacts arising out of the Project. Socio-economic surveys were conducted, as per the census survey it is found that among total PAPs, 03 are THs, out of which 1 belongs to government, 1 lease holder and another one is private property. Two (2) title holders and 33 NTHs are having business in the existing buildings, out of which 3 are Kiosks, 5 commercial Squatters 25 commercial Tenants. Those structures which are located in private and government land will be compensated as per the provisions of the Entitlement matrix. The private owner will have choice for consent award for 2.5 times of guidance value, if he won t agree for consent award, the general award will be passed as per New Act provisions. The total land requirement estimated for the project is 35 gunte and 10 annas, out of which 1.07 Gunte of private land and Gunte Government land and 6 Gunta belongs to Hubli Dharwad Municipal Corporation (HDMC). Public consultations were held on and The outcomes of the consultations are incorporated in the Social Impact Assessment of the project. The outcomes will be incorporated in the designing of infrastructure and as inputs for the resettlement plan preparation and implementation. This RAP is also prepared in accordance with the stipulations and guidelines provided in the project specific Entitlement Matrix for the BRTS Project, GEF SUTP s ESMF (Environmental and Social Management Framework), the project authority proposes to acquire land through consent award following the Karnataka Highways Act, 1964 and LA (Karnataka Extension and Amendment) Act, It is expected that land acquisition under this Act will help the PAPs to receive the market price/replacement cost of land as compensation. There will be Negotiation Committee and the role of the committee will be to negotiate the price of land with the entitled persons. The guidance value of land in respective area will be considered as the base for negotiation. Entitlements include payment of cash compensation for land preferably through consent award as per the provisions of the Karnataka Highways Act. The owner/tenant will be given the right to salvage material from the affected structure and will be given adequate notice for Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 3

4 removal of structure and shifting. Shifting allowance of Rs.6655/- will be given to all major impact categories and Livelihood Restoration allowance of Rs.19965/- will be given for Loss of Livelihood. Rental allowance for a period of six months at the rate Rs.2396/- for commercial categories of tenants will be given. Hubli - Dharwad Municipal Corporation will be requested to provide preferential allocations of alternate commercial space for the licensed Kiosks which are located in the land to be acquired. For those who are losing livelihood, one family member (male or female) of the affected family will be provided necessary training for development of entrepreneurship skills by co-ordinating with HDMC or other Government Departments to take up self-employment projects. Additional support to vulnerable groups would be given through pension schemes, if eligible as per the criteria prescribed in respective schemes. RAP will be implemented by the Environment and Social Development Cell. The land acquisition will be done by competent authority as per the applicable act and ESDC will be responsible for all the activities related to Resettlement and Rehabilitation. All grievances will be settled through existing grievance redress committee. The grievance redress process specifies procedures for registering and addressing complaints including appeal mechanisms. The estimated total budget for the implementation of RAP is Rs Crore. The RAP Executive Summary along with Entitlement Matrix will be disclosed through public consultations and in the website of Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Company limited. Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 4

5 1 Introduction The Resettlement Action Plan for the Hubli-Dharwad BRTS at Mitra Samaj was prepared to address and mitigate the impacts arising out of the Project. The RAP was prepared based on the socio-economic survey conducted on The Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Company Limited has completed the Joint Measurement Certificate (JMC) survey on The JMC report has been finalised. The social impact of the project are detailed in the succeeding paras. 2 Extent of land to be acquired guntas of land is being acquired for the BRTS at Mitra Samaj, Dharwad. The extent of land to be acquired and the details of land ownership are indicated below: Table 2-1: Extent of land to be acquired (Area in Gunta- Ani) Village/ City Extent as per notification 15(1) Extent as per JMC- (Agri/ NA) Govt Land/ Dept HDMC Private Land Dharwad Magnitude of Impacts 3.1 Impact on Land and Structures Three (03) properties will be affected as per JMC. One title holder is private land owner. Out of the two remaining, one property belongs to HDMC and other one belongs to Government. The Government has given the land to Mitra Samaj Trust on a 99 years lease. The lease period of land had expired. Some structures were constructed by lease holders, and they are eligible for ex-gratia compensation for loss of structures as per the entitlement matrix approved for the project. Table 3-1: Impact on Land, Structure and Trees Town Structure Trees Dharwad Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 5

6 3.2 Project Affected Persons The total number of project affected persons is 35. The classification of PAPs by category is indicated in the following table. The details of the PAPs are enclosed in Annexure I. Table 3-2: Classification of PAPs-BRTS Category No of PAPs A) Owner 03 Private 01 Government/ HDMC 02 B) Tenant 25 C) Squatter 05 D) Kiosks 03 Total 35 Sl No 01 Town Dharwad city Table 3-3: Distribution of Major Impact by Category Total Major Impact Structures Residential Commercial Res. and com. Total Minor Impact Rehabilitation and resettlement assistance is as per the approved entitlement matrix of Hubballi-Dharwad BRTS project. In case of major impacted titleholders, R&R assistance for shifting, subsistence allowance will be discussed during finalization of the land acquisition compensation rate and accordingly agreed as needed based on the severity of the impacts. 3.3 Tenants The number of tenants require to be shifted are 25, and all belong to out of which all are commercial category. The details are as follows: Particular Tenants under major impact category Table 3-4: Major and Minor Impact under Tenant Category Major Impacts Residential Commercial Residential and Commercial Total Minor Impacts Total Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 6

7 3.4 Squatters & Kiosks The number of squatters identified during the socio-economic survey is 05, and Kiosks are 03, the details of types of squatters and kiosks are as below: Table 3-5: Impact on Squatters and Kiosks Particular Residential Commercial Residential and Commercial Squatter Kiosks Total The Hubli-Dharwad Company Limited is working with HDMC to get alternative locations for the licensed KIOSK with substantial efforts. 4 Budget for RAP: Table 4-1: Revised Budget for RAP (Amount in Rs.) Sl. No. Category Amount 1 Compensation for Land 1,25,00, Compensation for Structure 1,50,00, R&R Assistance (Squatters, Tenants and Encroachers) 17,10, A) Total (1+2+3) 2,92,10, B) Contingency (@10%) 29,21, GRAND TOTAL (A+B) 3,21,31, Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 7

8 5 Public Consultation meeting with Dharwad city PAPs Consultation, participation and disclosure will ensure that information provided and feedback obtained on proposed project of Hubballi- Dharwad BRTS terminal, be adequately considered in the project design. It will also provide adequate opportunities for consultation/participation of PAPs in the project process. The consultation process was carried out with the following objectives: To promote awareness among the PAPs and to public about the proposed project. To familiarize the people with technical, social and economic issue of the project for better understanding; To stimulate community self-evaluation and analysis; To identify the environmental issues relating to project components; To secure people s input in respect of project design, selection of mitigation measures and monitoring strategies viz. incorporating the suggestions made during consultations into project design as found feasible; To assess the views of the beneficiary community; A) Public Consultation meetings Public consultation has been considered to be an extremely important process and the RAP is prepared on the basis of people s perceptions about the project impacts and felt needs. It is ensured that results of public consultation whichever deemed feasible have been incorporated in the final design. Date: Venue: HDMC meeting hall Major discussions were as follows: Questions raised by participants Bus terminal can be done in new bus stand why in the old bus stand. What is the proposed road width? Group of vendors asked in which place the rehabilitation will be done When the road work will start The government library building is affected? If so what is rehabilitation plan for that, Commercial shop owners requested for alternative shop from Govt side Explanation given by Hubli- Dharwad BRTS Company Limited Buses are running between twin cities. New bus stand is for long tour buses. BRTS buses are running between Hubli and Dharwad. Clarified by the Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Company Ltd. Rehabilitation assistance will be provided as per the approved entitlement matrix. Will be started shortly. Library building will be constructed in the terminal. Rehabilitation assistance will be provided as per the approved entitlement matrix. Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 8

9 B) Public consultation meeting with Tenants Date: Venue: HDBRTS Company Negotiation meeting was conducted by Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Company Lt. with tenants of Mitra Samaj premises and Mitra Samaj committee. The members present in the meeting expressed their demands which are as follows: Demands of the Tenants The compensation of the structures should be paid to the tenants. The tenants insisted to increase the assistance. The tenants demanded for alternate shops before demolishing the building and to provide proper rehabilitation assistance. Explanation given by Hubli- Dharwad BRTS Company Limited. The structures compensation will be paid to the lease holder. The tenants will gets interior works valuation amounts apart from R&R assistance. Rehabilitation and resettlement assistance will be paid as per approved entitlement matrix. Project authority will try to explore the possibility of facilitating assistance to eligible PAP s in link with various Government schemes. The following notified Government Schemes are being considered for the vulnerable groups and linking them to respective PAPs category. Eligible PAP category Women All backward classes under Chaitanya All minority community under Swavalambana. Any individual above 18 years of age Self Employment Programme for SC/ST and International study Programme (ISP) Proposed Govt. Scheme (State / Central) Udyogini Chaitanya & Swavalambana Schemes of BC & MD Corporation Prime Minister s Employment Generation Programme Schemes of Karnataka SC/ST Dev. Corporation Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 9

10 C) The Negotiation Committee Meetings held with property owner on and In the negotiation committee meeting two proposals were finalised i.e. o o The negotiated price approved by the Government for Dharwad city limit i.e., For Non agriculture commercial category- Rs.6750/- per sq feet For Non agriculture Residential category Rs.4500/- per sq. feet The affected library building will be constructed in the proposed BRTS. Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 10

11 6 Socio-Economic Survey The socio economic survey was done to identify project affected people, families and to develop their socio-economic profile by conducting survey and collecting information related to various aspects such as demography, occupational and income details. The objectives of the study are: To assess the socio-economic impacts of Project Affected Persons/ Families. To assess the number of house structures that will be affected. To arrive at a rehabilitation package for PAPs. 6.1 Social Assessment of PAPs Social Assessment has been made on the basis of data collected. It is observed that more than 50% belongs to vulnerable groups, more than 75% of the PAPs are under working age groups and have a monthly income above Rs.4000/- per month. The social profile of the PAPs is indicated in the following tables Caste wise distribution of PAPs in % Caste category No. % SC/ ST Minority OBC Others Total Age wise distribution of PAPs. Age group No. Average age of head of the family (%) 20 to to to Above Total Size of the family Size of the family No. % > to Occupations wise distribution of the PAPs. Occupation No. % Bag repairer s Kiosks Hotels Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 11

12 Occupation No. % Medical shop Pan shop Others Total Occupational Distribution of PAPs brings out the fact that most of the PAPs are working as labourers on daily basis. 50% PAPs are daily earners (Bag repairers and Kiosks) among PAPs. About 06 percent workers are medical shop and about 20% workers are also having small business. Other 30 % workers are professionals doing different businesses Income level wise distribution PAPs of families Level of Income Nos. % 4000 to % 5000 to % 6000 above 06 14% Total % Data has shown that 56 % PAP families are having monthly income between Rs.4000 to Rs About 30 % families are able to earn between Rs.5000 to Rs.6000 and 14% of families have income of more than Rs Rehabilitation and Resettlement Rehabilitation will be done in accordance with approved R&R policy frame work and approved RAP of Hubli-Dharwad BRTS project. The entitlement matrix as approved for the Hubli-Dharwad BRTS project is as follows. The Entitlement Matrix: The Entitlement Matrix addresses three broad categories of social and economic impacts, which require mitigation in this project. Loss of assets, including land and house; Loss of livelihood or income opportunities; and Collective impacts on groups, such as loss of common property resources The first two categories represent direct project impacts on an identified population. The affected people will be surveyed and registered, and project monitoring and evaluation will compare long term impact against baseline socio-economic data. The third category represents an indirect impact, where group members need not be individually registered. Gains and losses of a group-oriented nature are not quantifiable in terms of impact on the individual. Mitigation and support mechanisms will be collectively oriented, and the Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 12

13 monitoring of these development efforts will be the impact and benefits for the groups involved. Table 7-1:Entitlement Matrix proposed for the Project Impact category Entitlements Remarks I. Title Holders Loss of land 1. Compensation through negotiation as per Land Acquisition Act / Karnataka Highway Act, Stamp duty and registration charges on compensation amount. 3. Crop/ tree damage compensation as assessed by concerned Departments. Loss Residential structures Loss commercial structures of of 1. Compensation at current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. 2. Stamp duty and registration charges on compensation amount; 3. Additional 25% compensation for partially affected structures towards reconstruction 4. Shifting assistance of Rs.6,655 for major impact structures. 1. Compensation at current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. 2. Stamp duty and registration charges on compensation amount. 3. Additional 25% compensation for partially affected structures. 4. Shifting assistance of Rs. 6, Livelihood Restoration allowance equivalent to 3 The minimum negotiated price will be 1.5 times of the Guidance Value. Stamp Duty and Registration Charges on compensation amount will be exempted/ factored into the compensation and assistance (this is applicable for those who avail compensation through consent award). One family member (male/female) of the affected family, if interested, may be provided necessary training for skill development and income generation. Training for selfemployment will be based on aptitude / assessment of skill sets of affected family and will be dovetailed with programs implemented by other departments. The shifting allowance, livelihood restoration allowance and other allowances specified in Entitlement column will be shared and discussed with the PAPs during consent award negotiations. A notice period of 3 months will be given for the removal of structures and shifting where Applicable. The owner/tenant (in cases where a tenant occupies the structure) will be given the right to salvage material from the structures. Stamp Duty and Registration Charges on compensation amount will be exempted/ factored into the compensation and assistance (this is applicable for those who avail compensation through consent award). The shifting allowance, livelihood restoration allowance and other allowances specified in Entitlement column will be shared and discussed with the PAPs during consent award negotiations. A notice period of 3 months will be given for the removal of structures and shifting where Applicable. Stamp Duty and Registration Charges on compensation amount will be exempted/ factored into the compensation and assistance (this is applicable for those who avail compensation through consent award). One family member (male/female) of the affected family, if interested, may be provided necessary training for skill development and Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 13

14 Impact category Entitlements Remarks months of minimum industrial income generation. Training for selfemployment wages of Karnataka (calculated for 25 days in a month) or Rs.19,965 whichever is higher of for major. will be based on aptitude / assessment of skill sets of affected family and will be dovetailed with programs implemented by other departments. The owner/tenant (in cases where a tenant occupies the structure) will be given the right to salvage material from the structures. The shifting allowance, livelihood restoration Loss of residential cum commercial structures II. Tenants: Loss of residential / commercial / residential cum commercial structures 1. Compensation at current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. 2. Stamp duty and registration charges on compensation amount 3. Additional 25% compensation for partially affected structures. 4. Shifting allowance of Rs 6, Livelihood Restoration allowance equivalent to 3 months of minimum industrial wages of Karnataka (calculated for 25 days in a month) or Rs.19,965 whichever is higher for major impacts. 1. Rental allowance for 6 Rs 1,597 per month for residential and Rs for commercial categories 2. Livelihood restoration allowance equivalent to 3 months of minimum industrial wages of Karnataka (calculated for 25 days in a month) or. Rs.19,965 whichever is higher for major 3. Shifting assistance of Rs. 6, Tenants will get interior valuation amount III. Non-Title holders: Encroachers Ex-gratia for affected structure based on current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. Licensed kiosks Assistance for loss of Kiosks. 1.Livelihood Restoration allowance equivalent to 3 months allowance and other allowance A notice period of 3 months will be given for the removal of structures and shifting where applicable. Stamp Duty and Registration Charges on compensation amount will be exempted/ factored into the compensation and assistance (this is applicable for those who avail compensation through consent award). The owner/tenant (in cases where a tenant occupies the structure) will be given the right to salvage material from the structures. One family member (male/female) of the affected family, if interested, may be provided necessary training for skill development and income generation. Training for selfemployment will be based on aptitude / assessment of skill sets of affected family and will be dovetailed with programs implemented by other departments. A notice period of 3 months will be given for the removal of structures and shifting where applicable. The tenant will be given the interior valuation amount. One family member (male/female) of the affected family, if interested, may be provided necessary training for skill development and income generation. Training for self-employment will be based on aptitude / assessment of skill sets of affected family and will be dovetailed with programs Implemented by other departments. Ex-gratia for affected structure based on current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. Encroachers will be notified a time in which to remove their assets. For those kiosks which are licensed for fixed locations, a reference will be made to HDMC for relocation of kiosks or allotment of Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 14

15 Impact category Entitlements Remarks of minimum industrial wages of Karnataka (calculated for 25 days alternate shops in the complexes belonging to it. HDMC will be requested to provide in a month) or Rs. Rs.19,965 preferential allocations of alternate 2. Shifting allowance of Rs.6,655 commercial space to the licensed shop keepers whose shop fall in the land to be acquired, OR, Employment opportunities for affected persons as per skills in the BRT operations, Commercial / Residential squatters Livelihood Restoration allowance equivalent to 3 months of minimum industrial wages of Karnataka (calculated for 25 days in a month) or Rs.19, Shifting allowance of Rs. 6,655. IV. Vulnerable People Additional support 1. Assistance to include in to Vulnerable government pension schemes if groups: SC, ST, not included, if eligible as per Women headed Government criteria family Widows 2. Livelihood Restoration Physically challenged and allowance equivalent to 3 months of minimum industrial wages of those aged above Karnataka (calculated for 25 days 60 years in a month) or Rs.19,965 whichever is higher for major impacts. V. Community Assets: Community Assets Conservation, protection, compensatory replacement VI. Unidentified Impacts: Unidentified Impacts housekeeping etc. Squatters will be notified a time in which to remove their assets. An appropriate ex-gratia amount for affected structures, if any (excluding ambulatory structures) would be given as per evaluation done by the Hubli Dharwad BRTS Company Ltd. Government pension schemes if not included, if eligible as per the criteria prescribed in the schemes. The common property resources and the Community infrastructure (bus shelters, community ponds and other assets, if any) will be relocated in consultation with the community. The Religious structures, if any, on private lands will be entitled for compensation at current PWD schedule of rates without depreciation. Religious structures constructed by encroaching on Government lands i.e., parks, roads and public spaces etc will be relocated in consultation with the community. 1. Mitigation measures Unforeseen impacts shall be documented and mitigated based on the principles provided in this policy. Note: 1) All amounts in this entitlement matrix are fixed as of April 01, These will be 10% p.a on first day of April every year. Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 15

16 2) As part of consent award negotiations, the additional compensation for resettlement (subsistence allowance, shifting allowance etc) will be fully factored into and reflected in the consent award as a separate line item in the compensation negotiated under consent award. 8 Grievance Redress Committee Already Grievance Redress Committee has been formed with Deputy Commissioner of the Dharwad district as head, Representative of reputed NGO, Representative from social sector/retired government officer and a Representative of SPV as Convener (Manager R&R and HR). GRC will hear complaints and facilitate solutions; and the process, as a whole, will promote dispute settlement through mediation to reduce litigation. The following existing GRC committee members will continue for this purpose also. Deputy Commissioner - Dharwad Chairman Tel: Representative from social sector/retired government officer (to be selected by DC) - Member, Sri. A G Gadag ( Retired Tahashlidar) Revenue Colony, Rani Channamma Nagar Representative of reputed NGO working in Hubballi Dharwad. Member, Sri Subhasa Kumar 27X7 Safe hands Kusalam Akareddy Building Lokappa Hakkalu Road, Near Laxmi temple, Vijaya Nagar Hubli-22 Tel: Executive Engineer of KRDCL Member, Division Office Dolor s colony, near New Bustand Hubli Tel: Representative of Social Welfare Department as selected by the Deputy Commissioner Member, Sri. Ashok Chalawadi District Social Welfare Officer, Dharwad. Tel: Representative of SPV Member Convener Manager R&R Hubli- Dharwad BRTS Company Limited. Tel: The main functions of GRC To provide support to PAPs on problems arising out of eligibility for RAP-provided entitlements and assistance provided; Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 16

17 To record the grievances of the PAPs, and categorize, prioritize and resolve them within one month; To inform ESDC of serious cases within one week; and To report to the aggrieved parties about the developments regarding their grievances and decisions of the ESDC, within one month. 9 Time table for key activities Sl. No. Key Activities Time- schedule 01 Completion of private land acquisition 3 rd week of October Transfer of Govt. land End of September Issue of identity card 3 rd week of September Preparation of including entitlement details (Micro plan) 3 rd week of July Payment of R&R assistance End of September Assistance to livelihood support including assistance to vulnerable families End of September Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 17

18 Annexure I PAPs List pertaining to Mitra Samaj Area of Dharwad city Title holder: Sl. No Name of the Owner Sl. No Name of the lease holder 1. Ajit Gaonkar and others 1. Mitra Samaja Committee Tenants: Sl. No Name of tenants Sl. No Name of Tenants 1. Narayana Shetty 2. Eranna Shetty 3. Nazeer Ahmed 4. Pruthviraj Shetty 5. Mane (Scrap Material) 6. Mane (Scrap Material) 7. Mahadevappa Medical Shop 8. Shrikanth Shetty 9. Patresh Ingaladal DTDC Courier 10. Venkatesh Medical Shop 11. Dr. Suvarna, Suvina Clinic 12. Dr. Suvarna, Suvina Clinic 13. Dr. Suvarna, Suvina Clinic 14. Dr. Mahantesh S. Dental Clinic 15. Dr. Ashwinin Kulkarni, General 16. Panduranga Shetty, Sarwswate Surgeon General Store 17. Shrikanth-Builders and contractors 18. Tigadi (Dr. Vaidya Bande) 19. Lokade 20. Dr. Suresh Patil 21. Iliyas Ahmed 22. Ramesh-Star Automobiles 23. Shivanand Ajit 24. Basappa Khanavali 25. Panduranga Sheety Squatters:- Sl. No Name of Squatters Sl. No Name of Squatters Kiosks: 1. Arun S Mangodi 2. Riyaz Ahemad Suravangi 3. Hajarathabilal Soudhagar 4. Hajarthaali Soudhagar 5. Abdul Mutavali Soudhagar Sl. No Name of Kiosks Sl. No Name of Kiosks 1. Radha Yuvaraj Honakhande 2. Pundalika Kuberappa Savadatti 3. Parashuram Sambrani Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 18

19 Squatters (Near Azad Park, Dharwad City) Annexure II Figure 1: Sri. Arun Siddappa Mangoli Figure 3:Sri. Abdul Mutavali Saudagar Figure 2: Sri. Riyaz Ahmed Suravanagi Panshop Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 19

20 KIOSK (Near Azad Park, Dharwad City) Figure 4: Sri. Sheenu Sambrani Figure 5: Sri. Pundaleek Karibasappa Figure 6: Sri. Radha Yuvaraj Honakhonde Savadatti Hubli-Dharwad BRTS Co. Ltd. Page 20