APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting For Transmission Planning

Transcription

1 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting For Transmission Planning FERC Order 890 SRP Attachment K APS Attachment E SRP Facility Scottsdale, AZ December 15 th, :00 11:00 A.M.

2 Agenda 1. Welcome, Introductions, and Stakeholder Meeting Overview 2. Status of Action Items June 22, 2017 Joint APS/SRP 2 nd Quarter Public Planning Meeting 3. Purpose of Today s Meeting SRP Planning 4. Purpose of Today s Meeting APS Planning 5. Stakeholder Questions/Comments 6. Action Items Review 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 2

3 2. Status of Action Items There were no Action Items from the Joint APS/SRP 2 nd Quarter Public Planning Meeting held on 6/22/ /15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 3

4 3. Purpose of Today s Meeting Per SRP s OATT, SRP conducts the 4 th quarter public planning meeting to: A) Review its current transmission study plan provide an opportunity for transmission customers to update their loads, resources and other data review any stakeholder proposals previously submitted to SRP for study plan alternatives B) Present a draft of its Ten Year Plan for the following calendar year 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 4

5 3. Purpose of Today s Meeting Continued C) Provide updates on the generation study requests D) Provide updates on the transmission study requests E) Provide updates on the economic study requests F) Invite stakeholders to submit additional study proposals 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 5

6 3.A. SRP s Study Plan SRP has two distinct, but related, transmission study plans NERC Compliance SRP s budgetary planning The difference between the two plans: NERC Compliance studies based on new TPL Standard: 2 seasons/scenarios, 3 discrete years (near and long term) SRP s annual planning: 1 season, 10 consecutive years (first 6 years are for budget, remaining 4 for compliance purposes) The similarities between the two plans: Similar load forecasts, demand response They are reliability studies 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 6

7 3.A NERC Compliance Study Methodology Coordinated Base Cases (Seed Cases) 2018 AZ coordinated case used to build AZ coordinated case used to build AZ coordinated case used to build 2026 The intermediate cases are APS/SRP coordinated 69kV transmission models incorporated Most up-to-date forecasts for peak summer loads 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 7

8 3.A NERC Compliance Study Methodology NERC Compliance Study Cases: 2018 Summer Peak & Sensitivity 2021 Off-peak & Sensitivity 2022 Summer Peak Case & Sensitivity 2026 Summer Peak Case Following analyses conducted: Thermal Analysis Transient Stability Short Circuit 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 8

9 3.A. NERC Compliance Studies NERC STANDARD Type of Studies Completed TPL P0 Thermal Transient Stability Short Circuit 2018 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2021 Off-peak, Sensitivity X X 2022 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2026 Peak X X TPL P1, P2 Thermal Transient Stability Short Circuit 2018 Peak, Sensitivity X X X 2021 Off-peak, Sensitivity X X X 2022 Peak, Sensitivity X X X 2026 Peak X X X 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 9

10 3.A. NERC Compliance Studies NERC STANDARD Type of Studies Completed TPL P3-P7 Thermal Transient Stability 2018 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2021 Off-peak, Sensitivity X X 2022 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2026 Peak X X TPL Extreme Events Thermal Transient Stability 2018 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2021 Off-peak, Sensitivity X X 2022 Peak, Sensitivity X X 2026 Peak X X 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 10

11 3.A. NERC Compliance Results 2017 Results 2017 NERC Compliance Studies were finalized by the end of October of /15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 11

12 3.A. Customer Load/Resource Updates SRP received no stakeholder proposals in 2017 prior to this meeting. If you like to provide information for the future SRP planning cycles, please see critical dates on the next slide 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 12

13 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 13

14 3.B. SRP Ten Year Plan Draft - Still subject to change until January 31 st filing 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 14

15 3.B Ten Year Plan Methodology Coordinated Base Cases See NERC Compliance Methodology slide #6 69kV transmission models incorporated Most up-to-date forecasts for peak summer loads TPL P0 & P1 events studied for all ten years 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 15

16 ARIZONA EHV SYSTEM (AS OF FEBRUARY 2, 2017) Crystal Glen Canyon Navajo Four Corners San Juan LEGEND Coal Generation Nuclear Generation Gas Generation Hydro Generation Wind Generation Solar Generation 345kV Transmission 500kV Transmission Mead El Dorado Colorado River Palo Verde Hassaympa Hoodoo Wash North Gila Cedar Mountain Liberty Westwing Phoenix Area Rudd Kyrene Gila River Pinal Central Pinal West Moenkopi Flagstaff Pinnacle Peak Silver King Browning Saguaro / Tortolita Cholla Sugarloaf Coronado McKinley Springerville Greenlee Vail South Bicknell Winchester 16

17 230kV System West /15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 17

18 230kV System East TBD 2024 Q Positions 41 and /15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 18

19 Eastern Mining Area 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 19

20 3.B. SRP changes since 2017 Plan Completed Projects None Revised In-Service Dates Price Road Corridor, updated to 2021 Copper Crossing Abel 230kV updated to /15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 20

21 3.B. SRP changes since 2017 Plan New Projects Browning Corbell reconfiguration (2019) Removed Projects None 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 21

22 3.B. SRP th BTA Requirement B Reactive Devices Ohm Series Reactors on Palo Verde Hassayampa 500kV Ties Transformers 2022 Rudd 230/69kV Transformer 2024 Browning 230/69kV Transformer Re-Conductor None 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 22

23 3.C. 3.E. Transmission Planning Study Process SRP evaluates plan submittals or alternatives according to the following flowchart. Exhibit 1 SRP Attachment K * Transmission Planning Process Economic What Type of Study? 1 Reliability Regional Transmission Provider Evaluation High priority Local 2 Transmission Provider Economic Study Not high priority Does Transmission Provider s system meet NERC/WECC criteria? No Transmission Provider determines facilities needed with Stakeholder input Study results documented in a report and reviewed by Customer and Transmission Provider Yes TEPPC evaluates with Stakeholder input Customer Choice of Study at Customer s expense Does Transmission Provider s system meet local reliability criteria? No Transmission Provider determines facilities needed with Stakeholder input TEPPC determines high priority, performs study TEPPC determines not high priority Yes Transmission Provider coordinates with Sub- Regional Planning Group 1. Generator Interconnection Request studies are performed pursuant to the Large Generator Interconnection Procedure contained in the Transmission Provider s Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT). Transmission Service Requests are also performed pursuant to OATT procedures. 2. All requests for economic planning studies received by the Transmission Provider are forwarded to TEPPC for inclusion in the TEPPC Master List. TEPPC will evaluate only those requests that have regional impacts. * Note WECC organizational changes discontinued TEPPC 12/12/2016 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 23

24 3.C.-E. SRP Planning - Study Requests Generation Interconnection Requests Transmission Interconnection Requests Transmission Service Requests Economic Study Requests 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 24

25 3.C. SRP Planning Interconnection Requests (Transmission) One Transmission Interconnection Request under study (Palo Verde Pinal Central Q06) 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 25

26 3.C. Interconnection Requests (Generation) A. EAST VALLEY 2- Solar Projects 98MW 1- Battery Storage 10MW 2- Natural Gas 1557MW B. EMA 115kV AREA 1- Solar Project 9MW A B Generation Interconnection Requests listed on this slide are for SRP solely owned transmission 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 26

27 3.D.-E. SRP - Transmission Service and Economic Study Requests SRP received one Transmission Service Requests under study There are no Economic Study Requests 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 27

28 3.F. Submittal of Additional Study Plan Proposals If you have study ideas for SRP to consider, please send a detailed message to: SRP.TransmissionPlanning@srpnet.com Please include (at a minimum): Your Name/Company/contact info ( /phone #) What the purpose of the study request is? And how will the results be used? What year(s) and season(s) is of interest? What type of study reliability (power flow only?), economic? 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 28

29 3.G. SRP Planning Comments & Questions Stakeholder comments/questions on 2017 Study Results 12/15/2017 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 29

30 APS 4th Quarter Stakeholder FERC Order 890 APS Attachment E

31 4.A. APS s Study Plan APS has two distinct, but related, transmission study processes NERC Compliance APS s Annual Planning The difference between the two processes: NERC Compliance: Minimum 2 seasons, 3 discrete years (near and long term); all cases examine P0-P7 (formerly Category A D) APS s annual planning: 1 season, 10 consecutive years; N-0 and N-1 31

32 4.A. NERC Compliance Results? 2016 Results? APS is fully compliant with NERC Transmission Planning Standards 2017 Progress? Case building complete DYD files complete Study work being finalized Report writing being finalized 32

33 4.A Ten-Year Plan Methodology Coordinated Base Cases 2019HS AZ coordinated case used to build heavy summer HS AZ coordinated case used to build heavy summer HS AZ coordinated case The intermediate cases are only APS/SRP coordinated 69kV transmission models incorporated Most up-to-date forecasts for peak summer loads N-0 and N-1 analysis conducted for all ten years Note: AZ coordinated cases also included IID 33

34 4.A NERC Compliance Study Methodology NERC Compliance Studies Cases 2019 peak case 2022 peak and off-peak cases 2027 peak case Data from various IRP filings are incorporated (ex. generator retirements are accounted for) IRP Following analyses are conducted: Thermal and voltage Short-Circuit Transient Stability 34

35 4.B. Customer Load/Resource Updates APS has all load/resource data from Network Customers and has incorporated them into the base cases APS received no stakeholder proposals in 2016 or prior to this meeting Should you like to provide information for the future APS planning cycles, please see critical dates on the next slide 35

36 Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep. Oct. Nov. Dec. Planning Calendar for Ten-Year Planning Cycle APS Transmission Planning 10 Yr Plan 10yr Plan Filed with ACC by Jan. 31 APS Corporate Load Forecast Develop 10yr base cases from AZ seed cases 10yr Plan study effort Determination of projects, timings, and scope APS Corporate Load Forecast Post Summer 10yr Plan New load forecast sensitivity Stakeholder Input 10yr. Plans filed by others Arizona Utilities coordinated seed case development 2 nd Quarter Stakeholder Meeting Stakeholder input on studies, request study alternatives, updates on current projects Sep. 1 st Network Transmission Customers and all other Transmission Customers Load & Resource Forecast Oct. 31 st Deadline to submit Economic Study Requests for 4 th Quarter Meeting review 4 th Quarter Stakeholder Meeting Review draft of current 10yr plan, discuss Economic Study requests, receive stakeholder input 36 Other Coordination Activities Throughout the Year APS/SRP Coordination Meeting APS/WAPA Coordination Meeting WestConnect Meetings SWAT Meetings o AZTS o New Mexico o Eldorado Valley o Transmission Corridor o Short-circuit

37 4.B. Feedback on the Plan? Feedback on the Plan or methodologies NERC Reliability Ten Year Plan See next slide to see how APS would evaluate plan submittals or alternatives. 37

38 Exhibit 1 APS Attachment E Transmission Planning Process Economic What Type of Study? 1 Reliability Regional Transmission Provider Evaluation High priority Local 2 Transmission Provider Economic Study Not high priority Does Transmission Provider s system meet NERC/WECC criteria? No Transmission Provider determines facilities needed with Stakeholder input Study results documented in a report and reviewed by Customer and Transmission Provider Yes TEPPC evaluates with Stakeholder input Customer Choice of Study at Customer s expense Does Transmission Provider s system meet local reliability criteria? No Transmission Provider determines facilities needed with Stakeholder input TEPPC determines high priority, performs study TEPPC determines not high priority Yes Transmission Provider coordinates with Sub- Regional Planning Group 1. Generator Interconnection Request studies are performed pursuant to the Large Generator Interconnection Procedure contained in the Transmission Provider s Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT). Transmission Service Requests are also performed pursuant to OATT procedures. 2. All requests for economic planning studies received by the Transmission Provider are forwarded to TEPPC for inclusion in the TEPPC Master List. TEPPC will evaluate only those requests that have regional impacts. 38

39 4.B. APS Ten-Year Plan Projects Transmission Plan Filed on Jan. 31,

40 In-Service: Delaney-Palo Verde 500kV Line Delaney-Sun Valley 500kV Line 2018: Mazatzal 345/69kV Substation Morgan-Sun Valley 500kV Line Ocotillo Modernization Project Interconnection Facilities 40

41 41 In-service: Palm Valley-Trilby Wash 230kV Line Sun Valley-Trilby Wash 230kV Line 2018: Ocotillo Modernization Project Interconnection Facilities

42 2021: North Gila-Orchard 230kV Line 42

43 4.B. Changes since 2016 Plan was filed Projects completed Palo Verde-Delaney-Sun Valley 500kV Energized May, 2016 Sun Valley-Trilby Wash 230kV Energized May, 2016 Actively under construction Mazatzal 345/69kV Substation Sun Valley-Morgan 500kV Line 43

44 Bulk Transformer Additions/Replacements Description Year Sun Valley 500/230kV Transformer (in-service) 2016 Delaney 500/69kV Transformer (in-service) 2016 Four Corners 500/345kV #2 Transformer (in-service) 2017 Mazatzal 345/69kV Transformer 2018 North Gila 500/230kV Transformer 2021 Orchard 230/69kV Transformer 2021 Orchard 230/69kV Transformer # Scatter Wash 230/69kV Transformer

45 4.C-E. APS Planning - Study Requests Interconnection Requests Transmission Interconnection Requests Generation Interconnection Requests Transmission Service Requests Economic Study Requests 45

46 4.C. Interconnection Requests 2 Active Wires-to-Wires Interconnection requests Active Generation Interconnection requests APS OASIS contains Generation Interconnection Queue 19 Solar projects 5535 MW 1 Wind/Solar project 101 MW wind/60 MW solar 5 Natural Gas projects 3390 MW 1 Battery Storage 50 MW Note: Generator Queue information as of 11/30/17 46

47 H I C D A Hoodoo Wash 5 projects 1370 MW B - Gila Bend/Buckeye 1 project 20 MW C Metro Phx 3 projects 1545 MW D Saguaro Area 8 projects 2688 MW E Four Corners 1 project 500 MW F - Moenkopi 2 project 2161 MW G - Cholla 3 projects 305 MW H Yuma Area 1 project 70 MW I Delaney 2 projects 477 MW Note 1: Generator Queue information as of 11/30/17 Note 2: Figures displayed may not represent complete queue 47

48 4.D-E Transmission Service Requests and Economic Study Requests 36 Transmission Service Requests that may require a SIS Currently no Economic Study Requests 48

49 4.F. Submittal of additional study plan proposals If you have study ideas for APS to consider, please send a detailed message to: apstransmission@aps.com Please include (at a minimum) Your Name/Company/contact info ( /phone #) What the purpose of the study request is? And how will the results be used? What year(s) and season(s) is of interest? What type of study reliability (power flow only?) economic? 49

50 5. Stakeholder Questions & Comments Open discussion Reference Material WestConnect APS OASIS SRP OASIS 12/12/2016 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 50

51 6. Action Items Review any action items, assignments, and due dates 12/12/2016 APS/SRP Stakeholder Meeting for Transmission Planning 51