August 14, Winston & Strawn LLP
|
|
- Verity Jackson
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 The Supreme Court s Decision in Dudenhoeffer: If You Offer a Company Stock Fund Investment Option in Your 401(k) Plan or ESOP, You Will be Sued, Eventually August 14, 2014
2 Today s elunch Presenters Mike Melbinger Partner, Chair Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation Chicago mmelbinger@winston.com Joe Torres Partner, Hiring Committee Chair Labor & Employment Chicago jtorres@winston.com 2
3 Overview Stock drop litigation origins Consequences and pre-dudenhoeffer strategies for proactive fiduciaries Stock drop litigation Part II Dudenhoeffer Key holdings and takeaways What s likely to happen next? Post-Dudenhoeffer strategies 3
4 Stock Drop Litigation Origins Historically, company stock price drop = lawsuits against company, officers, and directors Around 2002, federal securities law claims repackaged as ERISA violations Plan fiduciaries likely included officers and directors Plan participants were/are a ready-made class Bad facts made bad law (see Enron) Statutory attorneys fees Typical claim - Fiduciaries knew/should have known stock was overvalued, or about to decline in value Given fiduciary s duty to act solely in the interests of plan participants, information should have been shared or acted upon (even if it was material non-public information) Fiduciary breached ERISA s duties of prudence and loyalty by failing to act Or, fiduciary failed to monitor activities of others charged with plan oversight 4
5 Stock Drop Litigation Origins (cont d) Common fiduciary responses: The Board member, officer, etc., was not a fiduciary Disclosure of material non-public information would violate federal securities laws ERISA creates fiduciary exception for Company stock funds Decision to offer a Company stock fund was settlor, not fiduciary, function Many courts adopt Moench presumption Is Company stock fund mandated by the plan documents? If so, plan fiduciaries continuing purchases of [or failure to divest] company stock was presumed to be prudent Procedural prudence may also provide some protection Fiduciaries need not be clairvoyant However, they must carefully follow all proper procedures (akin to business judgment rule) 5
6 Who is at Risk in a Stock Drop Suit? ERISA broadly defines fiduciary to include any person who: Exercises discretionary authority over plan or its assets Controls or oversees plan administration, or management of plan assets Covers individuals designated in plan Named fiduciary Plan trustees Plan administrator Investment managers Also can cover de facto fiduciary, regardless of plan terms Key to finding fiduciary status is function, not job title 6
7 What is at Risk in a Stock Drop Litigation? Either participants or the DOL may sue DOL can seek forfeiture of fiduciary plan account balance or benefit Fiduciaries can be personally liable for violations Personal really means personal your house, your assets Check D&O coverage Civil and criminal penalties also may apply May also carry significant tax implications Personal liability may exist even if claim is failure to monitor, versus failure to directly act 7
8 What s a Fiduciary To Do? Understand the basics of ERISA and fiduciary statutory obligations Operate under well-drafted and thorough governing documents Plan or trust SPD Board or fiduciary committee charter Adhere to well-designed and well-documented practices and procedures Participate in periodic fiduciary training Other protective measures Proper, accurate, and well-documented fiduciary actions and delegations ERISA 404(c) Prompt and accurate participant communications 8
9 Other Stock Drop Proactive Strategies Appoint an independent fiduciary for the plan s Company stock investment Still valid post-dudenhoeffer Plaintiffs bar has sued in-house plan fiduciaries nonetheless and announced its intention to continue doing so Insert protective language into plan documents At a minimum, hard-wire in the requirement that the plan offer a Company stock fund investment option Closely review plan, policies, and procedures to: Ensure proper governance documentation and compliance Correct any inconsistencies or operational deficiencies Update plan practices Review and update operating charters of relevant BOD committees Clarify employee communications, if necessary 9
10 Stock Drop Litigation Part II More bad facts made more bad law The financial crisis and the resulting market crash = more suits Unanticipated corporate crisis (e.g., BP oil rig) = even more suits Nature of triggering events makes it likely that history will repeat itself Bad things, unfortunately, will inevitably happen to some good companies 10
11 Dudenhoeffer Background and Allegations Followed the financial crisis Fiduciaries should have known, based on public and inside information, that Fifth Third stock was overpriced and excessively risky Public information = e.g., discussions regarding risks of subprime lending Non-public information = inside information that Fifth Third officers had deceived market by making material misstatements about the company s financial prospects A prudent fiduciary would have responded to this information by: Selling off the plan s holdings of Fifth Third stock, Refraining from purchasing more Fifth Third stock, or Disclosing the inside information so market could correct the stock s price downward 11
12 Dudenhoeffer Lower Court Holdings Trial court dismissed the complaint for failure to state a claim Applies Moench presumption Appellate court found trial court s dismissal was erroneous Agreed that ESOP fiduciaries are entitled to a presumption of prudence However, presumption cannot bar suit from proceeding at all Presumption only applies at trial as evidentiary presumption At the pleading stage, only question is whether suit reasonably identifies claimed harm Supreme Court agrees to consider nature of the presumption of prudence applicable to ESOP fiduciaries 12
13 Dudenhoeffer Supreme Court s Holding ERISA contains no special presumption in favor of ESOP fiduciaries Same prudence standard applies to all fiduciaries Only difference is that ESOP fiduciaries have no duty to diversify Hence, plaintiffs need not allege employer was on brink of collapse, under extraordinary circumstances, etc., to state a claim Presumption is also not supported by the common law trust rule that a settlor can reduce or waive the prudent man standard in plan document Unlike common law, ERISA does not permit plan documents to excuse fiduciaries from their statutory duties 13
14 Dudenhoeffer Supreme Court s Holding (cont d) Special purpose served by ESOP does not allow for atextual presumption ERISA duty of prudence refers generally to trustees management of investments ERISA does not set a separate standard for ESOP management Fiduciaries can only follow plan terms if they are consistent with ERISA Rule would make no sense if the duty of prudence was defined by plan (because duty of prudence would never conflict with plan document) ESOP statutory exemption for diversification would be unnecessary if the duty of prudence was altered by purposes underlying ESOP Congress promotion of ESOPs does not mean it allowed addition of an atextual presumption 14
15 Dudenhoeffer Supreme Court s Holding (cont d) Concern of conflict between duty of prudence and prohibition on insider training is legitimate concern However, ESOP-specific presumption is an ill-fitting means of addressing concern Non-ESOP fiduciaries face this same potential conflict with securities law ESOP fiduciaries face this conflict whether or not they need to address a financial emergency Concern litigation threat will deter offering ESOPs cannot bar all such claims Presumption is not proper way to weed out meritless claims Presumption makes it impossible for plaintiff to state a claim, no matter how meritorious, unless company is in dire economic circumstances Presumption does not allow courts to discern plausible claims from meritless cases Better approach is to review complaint allegations carefully, and in context Court offers guidance to lower court for assessing claims at pleading stage 15
16 Dudenhoeffer Guidance for Evaluating Claims Claims based on public information Allegations a fiduciary should have recognized from public information alone that the market was overvaluing or undervaluing stock are implausible as a general rule At least in the absence of special circumstances Thus, fiduciary is usually not imprudent in assuming a major stock market provides estimate of the value of the stocks traded on it Plaintiffs allegations that fiduciaries should have known of risks due to participation in subprime lending market do not constitute special circumstances Claims based on non-public information Plaintiffs must plausibly allege alternative action that defendants could have taken that: Would have been consistent with securities laws; and That prudent fiduciary in same circumstances would not have viewed as more likely to harm the fund than to help it 17
17 Dudenhoeffer Guidance for Evaluating Claims Three additional points: Duty of prudence does not require a fiduciary to break the law Therefore, alleging fiduciaries should have divested stock based on insider information cannot state a claim If plaintiff alleges fiduciary should have refrained from additional stock purchases or disclosing information to the public, court should consider extent to which obligation to disclose or refrain would conflict with insider trading and corporate disclosure requirements Court invites SEC s views on this point Courts should also consider whether complaint has plausibly alleged that prudent fiduciary could have taken above actions without doing more harm than good by causing a drop in stock price and stock value 18
18 Key Takeaways ERISA means what it says, nothing more Courts should not bolt on atextual presumptions to Congress carefully crafted statute Courts also should reject attempt to degrade standards based on Congress general statements of policy Fiduciaries cannot hide behind plan language that purports to diminish the obligations imposed by ERISA s statutory language No tolerance for the tail wagging the dog However, do not forsake this language yet 19
19 Key Takeaways (cont d) Companies and fiduciaries retain the ability to secure dismissal of some claims at pleading stage Allegations based on publicly available information will fail, absent special circumstances that reasonably challenge reliability of market price, in light of all publicly available information Allegations that Fifth Third engaged in lending practices that were equivalent to participation in the subprime lending market, that Defendants were aware of the risks of such investments by the start of the class period, and that such risks made Fifth Third stock an imprudent investment, are not sufficient to constitute special circumstances. Allegations based on inside information need to contend with: (a) applicable securities and corporate disclosure law; and (b) do no more harm guidance 20
20 What s Next? Fiduciaries may not avoid litigation beyond pleading stage based on: Presumptions Plan documentation purporting to codify presumption of fiduciaries actions Getting beyond pleading stage still remains a challenge for plaintiffs: Claims based on public information Must overcome special circumstances hurdle Claims based on non-public information Must overcome insider trading prohibitions and do no greater harm standard Courts may revive previously dismissed claims E.g., in the wake of Dudenhoeffer, Fifth Circuit revives stock drop claim against BP 21
21 What s Next? (cont d) Many stock drop lawsuits will still falter at the pleading However, such claims will persist and some will get to discovery: Plaintiffs bar will argue that duty to disclose/refrain can exist regardless of insider trading concerns Class action lawsuits remain attractive, given the leverage points noted above It will take time for all courts have to weighed in on application of the pleading standard Some are sure to be more lenient than others DOL remains aggressive in its views: The position that we have taken in a number of briefs is that an SEC communication in and of itself is not an ERISA communication. But when they are incorporated into plan documents like an SPD and a statement is made telling participants to look at the plan documents, that incorporation is a fiduciary act and the duty to be truthful to participants applies to the documents included by reference as much as it does to the SPD 22
22 What s Next? (cont d) Securities Law Requirements File Form 11-K annually Ensure that the number of shares registered for sale under the plan on Form S-8 is sufficient Prepare and deliver the 10(a) Prospectus Consider monitoring selling by company insiders 23
23 Steps in Light of Dudenhoeffer Assess the risk and the benefit of maintaining a Company stock fund option If you keep option, consider appointing independent fiduciary and delegate the duty to monitor the plan s investment in Company stock Does not eliminate risk to other potential fiduciaries Brings additional costs/administrative considerations Consider use of investment manager Evaluate composition of fiduciary committee Consider removing Section 16 officers and other individuals with significant or too much inside information from any fiduciary committee or roles 24
24 Steps in Light of Dudenhoeffer (cont d) Audit/confirm your design, drafting, and administration strategies Hard-wire requirements that Company offer stock fund option Ensure that governance, oversight and practices: Are consistent with intended/actual practices Vest and/or delegate authority in/to the intended entities/individuals Do not inadvertently vest responsibility in unintended entities/individuals Work with counsel to consider stock fund guidelines unique to your organization Procedures for evaluating adverse public and non-public information E.g., government investigation, public scandal, product or safety recall, financial calamity What might constitute special circumstances, given the possible scenarios How/when inside information might come to fiduciaries attention How to evaluate inside information and public disclosure obligations, given your company s individual circumstances 25
25 Questions?
26 Thank You. Mike Melbinger Partner, Chair Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation Chicago Joe Torres Partner, Hiring Committee Chair Labor & Employment Chicago 28
U.S. Supreme Court Considering Fiduciary Responsibility For 401(k) Plan Company Stock Funds and Other Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOP)
Fiduciary Responsibility For Funds and Other Employee Andrew Irving Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel The Supreme Court of the United States is poised to enter the debate over the standards of
More informationThe Impact of Dudenhoeffer on Lower Court Stock-Drop Cases
The Impact of Dudenhoeffer on Lower Court Stock-Drop Cases ALYSSA OHANIAN The Supreme Court recently held in Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer, 134 S. Ct. 2459 (2014), that employer stock ownership plan
More informationStakes Are High For ERISA Fiduciaries
Portfolio Media. Inc. 860 Broadway, 6th Floor New York, NY 10003 www.law360.com Phone: +1 646 783 7100 Fax: +1 646 783 7161 customerservice@law360.com Stakes Are High For ERISA Fiduciaries Law360, New
More informationBENEFITS LAW BRIEFING:
BENEFITS LAW BRIEFING: Eliminating the Company Stock Fund From Your Public Company's 401(k) Plan Navigating the Securities and ERISA Fiduciary Issues May 21, 2015 Jan Jacobson Senior Counsel, Retirement
More informationPRUDENT ADMINISTRATION OF EMPLOYEE STOCK OWNERSHIP PLANS
PRUDENT ADMINISTRATION OF EMPLOYEE STOCK OWNERSHIP PLANS Ronald J. Mann Columbia Law School A pervasive element of the landscape of employee stock ownership plans has been the unexamined assumption that
More informationESOP FIDUCIARY LIABILITY: AN OVERVIEW OF THE OBLIGATIONS AND EXPOSURES OF ESOP FIDUCIARIES. Prepared by Stephen D. Rosenberg, The Wagner Law Group 1
ESOP FIDUCIARY LIABILITY: AN OVERVIEW OF THE OBLIGATIONS AND EXPOSURES OF ESOP FIDUCIARIES Prepared by Stephen D. Rosenberg, The Wagner Law Group 1 Table of Contents Important Note... 1 Executive Summary...
More information9/22/ IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE AGENDA. ESOP Transactions: Fiduciary Duty & New Guidance from the DOL
Southwest Chapter of the ESOP Association Fall Conference Houston, Texas September 19, 2014 ESOP Transactions: Fiduciary Duty & New Guidance from the DOL Allison Wilkerson Allison.wilkerson@klgates.com
More informationBAILEY CAVALIERI LLC ATTORNEYS AT LAW
BAILEY CAVALIERI LLC ATTORNEYS AT LAW One Columbus 10 West Broad Street, Suite 2100 Columbus, Ohio 43215-3422 telephone 614.221.3155 facsimile 614.221.0479 www.baileycavalieri.com ERISA TAGALONG LITIGATION
More informationRegulatory Update Retirement Plans
DiMeo Schneider & Associates, L.L.C. VOLUME 4, NO. 2 Regulatory Update Retirement Plans DOL Outlook for 2014 IN THIS ISSUE: DOL Outlook for 2014 Stock Drop Case Update District Court Decision Affirms Importance
More informationYOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT?
YOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT? November 18, 2015 Rebecca E. Greene 414-298-8244 rgreene@reinhartlaw.com 1000 North Water Street, Suite 1700, Milwaukee, WI 53202 www.reinhartlaw.com Webinar Housekeeping
More informationDIRECTORS AND OFFICERS LIABILITY ERISA ENTERS THE SPOTLIGHT
DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS LIABILITY ERISA ENTERS THE SPOTLIGHT JOSEPH M. MCLAUGHLIN * SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP DECEMBER 9, 2004 Directors of public companies and their advisers have long understood
More informationERISA Stock Drop Litigation Against Financial Institutions
ERISA Stock Drop Litigation Against Financial Institutions Sheila Finnegan, Mayer Brown LLP Reginald Goeke, Mayer Brown LLP Mayer Brown is a global legal services organization comprising legal practices
More informationWho Are the Fiduciaries and What Are Their Key Responsibilities?
Who Are the Fiduciaries and Presented by: Thomas H. Mug Greensfelder, Hemker & Gale, P.C. 10 South Broadway, Suite 2000 St. Louis, Missouri 63102 (314) 345-4732 thm@greensfelder.com 1 Section 3(21) of
More informationBenefits Briefing: Company Stock as a Retirement Plan Investment. Friday, September 21, p.m. to 3 p.m. ET
Benefits Briefing: Company Stock as a Retirement Plan Investment Friday, September 21, 2018 2 p.m. to 3 p.m. ET Today s Speakers Moderator: Guest Speakers: Jan Jacobson Senior Counsel, Retirement Policy
More informationFollow this and additional works at:
2008 Decisions Opinions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit 11-13-2008 Ward v. Avaya Inc Precedential or Non-Precedential: Non-Precedential Docket No. 07-3246 Follow this and additional
More informationAVOIDING FIDUCIARY DUTY FOR DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS. Brian T. Ortelere Charles C. Jackson
AVOIDING FIDUCIARY DUTY FOR DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS I. INTRODUCTION Brian T. Ortelere Charles C. Jackson Recent highly publicized corporate reversals have spawned numerous class action lawsuits raising
More informationFiduciary Training: ERISA Duties & Obligations Seyfarth Shaw LLP
Fiduciary Training: ERISA Duties & Obligations Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seyfarth Shaw refers to Seyfarth Shaw LLP (an Illinois limited liability partnership). Why Do We Care? Fiduciary status creates litigation
More informationRecent trends in ERISA litigation
RETIREMENT INSIGHTS SERIES A valuable resource for advisors looking to grow their retirement business. Recent trends in ERISA litigation At Groom Law Group, where he currently serves as the firm s Chairman,
More informationFiduciary Governance: Lessons from ERISA Litigation
Fiduciary Governance: Lessons from ERISA Litigation Philadelphia Tuesday, June 20, 2017 Los Angeles Tuesday, June 27, 2017 Chicago Wednesday, June 28, 2017 Lawsuits Against Plan Fiduciaries Lawsuits alleging
More informationDIRECTORS & OFFICERS AND FIDUCIARY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR ESOPS: The Exposure, the Solutions, the Marketplace
DIRECTORS & OFFICERS AND FIDUCIARY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR ESOPS: The Exposure, the Solutions, the Marketplace ESOP MIDWEST REGIONAL CONFERENCE Bloomington, Minnesota September 11, 2015 TED BECKER Drinker
More information401(k) Fee Litigation Update
October 6, 2008 401(k) Fee Litigation Update Courts Divide on Fiduciary Status of 401(k) Service Providers Introduction As the 401(k) fee lawsuits progress, the federal district courts continue to grapple
More informationUnder ERISA, the role of fiduciary
Prudent fiduciary decision making is critical to the goal of achieving successful retirement outcomes and delivering meaningful benefits to plan participants. However, fiduciary responsibility under the
More informationERISA: THOU SHALL NOT PAY EXCESSIVE FEES! By: José M. Jara, Esq.
ERISA: THOU SHALL NOT PAY EXCESSIVE FEES! By: José M. Jara, Esq. Partner Employment, ERISA, and Employee Benefits Practice Group Leader About 12 years ago in 2006, there was a wave of class action lawsuits
More informationThird Circuit Affirms Dismissal of 401(k) Stock-Drop Case
ERISA Litigation Advisory September 27, 2007 Third Circuit Affirms Dismissal of 401(k) Stock-Drop Case Introduction The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has affirmed the dismissal of
More informationWill The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone
DR. GREGORY W. KASTEN UNIFIED TRUST COMPANY, NA Will The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone Many plan sponsors are aware they need help with the
More informationCommunity Action Program Legal Services (CAPLAW) Navigating Retirement Plan Fiduciary Rules and Correcting Plan Errors
Community Action Program Legal Services (CAPLAW) Navigating Retirement Plan Fiduciary Rules and Correcting Plan Errors March 1, 2017 Michele Berman Golkow golkow@ballardspahr.com 215.864.8403 Retirement
More informationFiduciary Tool Kit for Compliance: Common Errors in Qualified and Nonqualified Retirement Plan Administration
Journal of Collective Bargaining in the Academy Volume 0 National Center Proceedings 2014 Article 19 April 2014 Fiduciary Tool Kit for Compliance: Common Errors in Qualified and Nonqualified Retirement
More informationJuly 26, Unwarranted and Harmful ERISA Breach of Fiduciary Duty Litigation
July 26, 2017 Mr. Nicholas C. Geale Acting Solicitor of Labor U.S. Department of Labor Office of the Solicitor of Labor 200 Constitution Ave., NW Washington, DC 20210 RE: Unwarranted and Harmful ERISA
More informationJanuary 2005 Bulletin Labor Department Issues Guidance on Fiduciary Responsibilities of Directed Trustees
January 2005 Bulletin 05-01 Labor Department Issues Guidance on Fiduciary Responsibilities of Directed Trustees If you have questions or would like additional information on the material covered in this
More informationFIDUCIARY LIABILITY Risk review performed for: Date:
ForeFront Portfolio SM Risk Analyzer for Privately Held Companies FIDUCIARY LIABILITY Risk review performed for: Date: The Purpose of the Risk Analyzer When it comes to insuring your company, you can
More informationLegal Risks of ESOPS:
Legal Risks of ESOPS: Strategies To Avoid ERISA Violations and Liability November 1, 2007 Randall C. McGeorge White & Case New York, NY rmcgeorge@ny.whitecase.com Craig C. Martin Jenner & Block Chicago,
More informationUnderstanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans
Understanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans An overview of the fiduciary s role and frequently asked questions about it When you are a trustee or serve on an investment committee
More informationUnderstanding the Roles and Responsibilities of a Fiduciary
Understanding the Roles and Responsibilities of a Fiduciary The retirement plan fiduciary has significant responsibilities. This paper outlines a fiduciary s responsibilities and offers strategies that
More informationSupreme Court of the United States
No. 15-1199 IN THE Supreme Court of the United States RAYMOND PFEIL, MICHAEL KAMMER, ANDREW GENOVA, RICHARD WILMOT, JR. AND DONALD SECEN (ON BEHALF OF THEMSELVES AND ALL OTHERS SIMILARLY SITUATED), v.
More informationThe United States Supreme Court held in Tibble et al. v. Edison
Employee Relations L A W J O U R N A L Employee Benefits Electronically reprinted from Spring 2016 The Trouble Caused by Tibble: Supreme Court Case Requires Enhanced Monitoring of Plan Investments Mark
More informationThe DOL and ESOPs. Best Practices for a DOL Audit
The DOL and ESOPs Best Practices for a DOL Audit 61152401 1 Patti J. Hedgpeth, Esq. Shareholder Polsinelli 2950 N Harwood Street Suite 2100 Dallas, TX 75201 Phone: (214) 661-5556 Mobile: (214) 923-0251
More informationRetirement Plans: Challenges, Litigation and Trends
Public Retirement Plans: Challenges, Litigation and Trends Jon Willhite, CIMA Senior Institutional Consultant Senior Retirement Plan Consultant UBS Institutional Consulting Group 10001 Woodloch Forest
More informationTrustees: Independent vs. Internal and Directed vs. Non-Directed Legal Aspects
Trustees: Independent vs. Internal and Directed vs. Non-Directed Legal Aspects The 19 th Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference Akron/Fairlawn Hilton Akron, Ohio Friday, April 15, 2005 Carl J. Grassi,
More informationWill The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone
Will The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone Today many plan sponsors are aware they need help with the sections of ERISA dealing with fiduciary
More informationA guide to the fiduciary role in a retirement plan
Retirement Plan Solutions Content provided by: Compliments of TD Ameritrade Institutional A guide to the fiduciary role in a retirement plan Understanding your status, supporting plan sponsors as fiduciaries,
More informationManaging investment responsibilities. WEIGHING THE OPTIONS IS AN INVESTMENT POLICY STATEMENT RIGHT FOR YOUR PLAN?
PRICE POINT July 2017 Timely intelligence and analysis for our clients. Managing investment responsibilities. WEIGHING THE OPTIONS IS AN INVESTMENT POLICY STATEMENT RIGHT FOR YOUR PLAN? EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
More informationDealing with ERISA Fiduciary Responsibility & Liability
Qualified and Non Qualified Retirement Plans Pitfalls for the Practitioner Representing the Small Business Owner Dealing with ERISA Fiduciary Responsibility & Liability Irwin N. Rubin, Esq. 19 th Annual
More informationT he US Supreme Court s recent decision in Janus Capital Group, Inc. v. First Derivative
The Supreme Court s Janus decision: no secondary liability, but many secondary questions Arthur Delibert and Gregory Wright Arthur Delibert and Gregory Wright are both Partners at K&L Gates LLP, Washington,
More informationFIDUCIARY DEVELOPMENTS, PLAN FEES AND VENDOR SEARCHES. General Fiduciary Guidelines Regarding Fees. Controlling Law
FIDUCIARY DEVELOPMENTS, PLAN FEES AND VENDOR SEARCHES May 21, 2014 General Fiduciary Guidelines Regarding Fees Controlling Law ERISA imposes procedural and substantive duties on fiduciaries of employee
More informationRecent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures
Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Agenda + Overview of Recent Class-Action Lawsuits + What
More informationInsights for fiduciaries
Insights for fiduciaries Hiring an investment fiduciary issues and considerations for plan sponsors The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 ( ERISA ), the federal law that governs privately
More informationERISA FIDUCIARY BASICS AND BEST PRACTICES
Presents ERISA FIDUCIARY BASICS AND BEST PRACTICES November 5, 2015 Misty A. Leon mleon@wifilawgroup.com COMPLIANCE 101 General Roles and Responsibilities Who's Involved? Plan Administrator Responsibilities
More informationOutsourcing Fiduciary Responsibility Craig A. Bitman Donald J. Myers D. Ward Kallstrom
September 16, 2010 Outsourcing Fiduciary Responsibility Craig A. Bitman Donald J. Myers D. Ward Kallstrom Today s Topics I. Fiduciary Overview II. Spectrum of Outsourcing A. Effective Delegation vs. Ineffective
More informationFiduciary Education. Jared Martin, CFP Vice President, Consultant. October 19, 2016
Fiduciary Education Jared Martin, CFP Vice President, Consultant October 19, 2016 FIDUCIARY EXPERTISE Professional certifications which include fiduciary standards: AICPA, AIFA, AIF, ASPPA, CFA, & CIMA
More informationManaging Fiduciary Risk Under ERISA: A Primer for Employers, HR Directors, and Plan Administrators. Copyright
Managing Fiduciary Risk Under ERISA: A Primer for Employers, HR Directors, and Plan Administrators Copyright 2011 1 Presenters Gregory L. Ash, JD Partner gash@spencerfane.com 913.327.5115 Julia M. Vander
More informationERISA Fiduciary Obligations: How to Protect Yourself, Your Boss and the Company
June 26-29, 2011 Las Vegas, Nevada Sheldon J. Blumling June 27, 2011 SHRM 2011 Annual Conference & Exposition Introduction Fiduciary > An individual in whom another has placed the utmost t trust t and
More informationFiduciary Responsibilities and Oversight for Deferred Compensation Retirement Plans
Fiduciary Responsibilities and Oversight for Deferred Compensation Retirement Plans Denise Fortune- Regional Sales Director May 10, 2017 FOR INSTITUTIONAL USE ONLY. Not for public distribution. Discussion
More informationFIDUCIARY TUNE-UP 25TH ANNUAL BENEFITS COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE SOUTHWEST BENEFITS ASSOCIATION NOVEMBER 13-14, 2014
FIDUCIARY TUNE-UP 25TH ANNUAL BENEFITS COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE SOUTHWEST BENEFITS ASSOCIATION NOVEMBER 13-14, 2014 Dallas DoubleTree Galleria Dallas, Texas By: John L. Utz, Esq. UTZ & LATTAN, LLC 7285 W.
More informationBank of America Merrill Lynch Legislative and Regulatory Brief
RETIREMENT & BENEFIT PLAN SERVICES Bank of America Merrill Lynch Legislative and Regulatory Brief July 2014 www.baml.com/publicpolicyinsights DOL Regulatory Project Plan Revised Status On May 27, 2014,
More informationThe FCPA and Insurance Coverage: Five Strategies for Protecting Against the Financial Costs of an FCPA Claim
The FCPA and Insurance Coverage: Five Strategies for Protecting Against the Financial Costs of an FCPA Claim Jonathan M. Cohen and Katrina F. Johnson i In an era of high profile Wall Street prosecutions
More information401(k) Fees and Fiduciary Responsibility
T. ROWE PRICE 401(k) Fees and Fiduciary Responsibility What Plan Sponsors Need to Know Retirement Insights EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In recent years, market events have made many 401(k) participants more sensitive
More informationQ UPDATE EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS CASES OF INTEREST D&O FILINGS, SETTLEMENTS AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS Q1 2018 UPDATE CASES OF INTEREST U.S. SUPREME COURT FINDS STATE COURTS RETAIN JURISDICTION OVER 1933 ACT CLAIMS STATUTORY DAMAGES FOR VIOLATION OF TCPA FOUND TO BE PENALTIES AND
More informationFiduciary Update and Best Practices for Retirement Plan Committee Members April 7, 2017
Fiduciary Update and Best Practices for Retirement Plan Committee Members April 7, 2017 Presented by: Nicole Berlowski ProHealth Care, Inc. 725 American Drive 191 N. Wacker Drive POB Suite 305 Suite 3700
More informationFiduciary Duty in Retirement Plans The facts to combat the fiction when assessing fiduciary risk
Fiduciary Duty in Retirement Plans The facts to combat the fiction when assessing fiduciary risk 2003 2014 Multnomah Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Agenda Fiduciary Responsibility ERISA s Standards Determining
More informationAsk the Expert Panel Retirement Plans
Ask the Expert Panel Retirement Plans 2017 Maryland Health Care & Retirement Plan Summit October 24, 2017 Benjamin L. Grosz (202) 393-7600 BGrosz@ipbtax.com 2017 Q & A October 24, 2017 2 Potential Agenda
More informationDefined Contribution Legal and Regulatory Update
Defined Contribution Legal and Regulatory Update JULY 2015 We are committed to providing you with the information and tools you need to help meet your fiduciary responsibilities as a plan sponsor and to
More informationFiduciary Education Fiduciary Basics. Pension Consultants, Inc. is registered with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as an investment adviser.
Fiduciary Education Fiduciary Basics Pension Consultants, Inc. is registered with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as an investment adviser. Part 1 Origin of fiduciary status Fiduciary definitions
More informationcorporate advisor Hale and Dorr LLP Directors of Financially Troubled Companies Face Special Duties and Risks
Hale and Dorr LLP March 2002 Directors of Financially Troubled Companies Face Special Duties and Risks In today s difficult economic environment, many companies, both public and private, are encountering
More informationERISA FIDUCIARY INSURANCE: COMMON EXCLUSIONS AND OTHER CONSIDERATIONS. Allison Madan, Esq. SLEVIN & HART, P.C. WASHINGTON, D.C.
ERISA FIDUCIARY INSURANCE: COMMON EXCLUSIONS AND OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Allison Madan, Esq. SLEVIN & HART, P.C. WASHINGTON, D.C. 20036 I. Why Do Plan Fiduciaries Need Fiduciary Insurance? A. Personal Liability
More informationYOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT?
YOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT? November 16, 2016 Rebecca E. Greene 414-298-8244 rgreene@reinhartlaw.com 1000 North Water Street, Suite 1700, Milwaukee, WI 53202 www.reinhartlaw.com Rebecca E. Greene
More informationOverview of ERISA s Fiduciary Requirements: Retirement Plan Sponsor Considerations
Overview of ERISA s Fiduciary Requirements: Retirement Plan Sponsor Considerations R. Randall Tracht, Esq. Claudia L. Hinsch, Esq. Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP www.morganlewis.com June 2011 Introduction
More informationRECENT ERISA LITIGATION WHERE FIDUCIARY AND PREEMPTION ISSUES ARE HEADED IN 2008
THE WAGNER LAW GROUP A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 99 SUMMER STREET, 13 TH FLOOR BOSTON, MA 02110 (617) 357-5200 FACSIMILE E-MAIL WEBSITE (617) 357-5250 marcia@wagnerlawgroup.com www.erisa-iawyers.com www.wagnerlawgroup.com
More informationDeveloping an Investment Policy Statement Under ERISA
online report consulting group Developing an Investment Policy Statement Under ERISA summary a template for prudent investment decisions The creation and implementation of a written investment policy statement
More informationJanus Henderson Labs DEFINED CONTRIBUTION. Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures. Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process
Janus Henderson Labs Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process DEFINED CONTRIBUTION Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Agenda + Overview
More informationFiduciary Liability Insurance
14 th National Forum on ERISA Litigation March 1-2, 2017 Fiduciary Liability Insurance Alison L. Martin Fiduciary Product Manager Chubb Brian Smith Chief Operating Officer Segal Select Insuring Services
More informationRetirement Plan Fiduciary Best Practices Houston Compensation and Benefits Total Rewards Summit
Retirement Plan Fiduciary Best Practices Houston Compensation and Benefits Total Rewards Summit Edward A. Razim, Partner September 13, 2018 Fiduciary Status Who is a fiduciary? Any individual or entity
More informationUnderstanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans
Understanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans An overview of the fiduciary s role and frequently asked questions about it What is a fiduciary? A fiduciary is a person or entity who:
More informationProtecting your ESOP Company from legal problems can be broken down into two main areas:
Presented by: Christopher McLean Kaufman & Canoles, P.C. McLean, VA Todd Denison Phelps Dunbar, Mobile, AL Protecting your ESOP Company from legal problems can be broken down into two main areas: Plan
More informationBest Practices for Retirement Plan Fiduciaries
Best Practices for Retirement Plan Fiduciaries Presented by: Christina Anstett Director, Advanced Markets, 401(k) AXA Equitable IU-84238 (4/13) AXA Equitable Life Insurance Company (NY, NY) Contact Information
More informationTrack Two: The Roles of Boards of Directors and Trustees in ESOP Companies
Track Two: The Roles of Boards of Directors and Trustees in ESOP Companies The California/Western States Chapter of The ESOP Association: The 2018 Chapter Conference Thursday, October 4, 2018 3:15 p.m.
More informationFiduciary Responsibility, Delegation & Oversight Multnomah Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2003 2015 Multnomah Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. About the Presenter Amy Barber is the Chief Compliance Officer and Director of Technical Services for Multnomah Group. She is responsible for the development,
More informationProcess & Decision Making of the ESOP Administration Committee
Process & Decision Making of the ESOP Administration Committee The ESOP Association Las Vegas Conference & Tradeshow November 10-11, 2016 Todd L. Denison Phelps Dunbar, LLP Todd.denison@phelps.com www.phelpsdunbar.com
More informationCORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION: DO THE TWO COINCIDE IN THE POST- ENRON ENVIRONMENT? Dana M. Muir * and Cindy A.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION: DO THE TWO COINCIDE IN THE POST- ENRON ENVIRONMENT? I. Introduction by Dana M. Muir * and Cindy A. Schipani ** The corporate scandals of the past few years
More informationCase 1:08-cv Document 1 Filed 10/21/2008 Page 1 of 19 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
Case 1:08-cv-06029 Document 1 Filed 10/21/2008 Page 1 of 19 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. SAVINGS PLAN INVESTMENT OVERSIGHT
More informationFiduciary Duty 201 The next step in understanding fiduciary duty
Fiduciary Duty 201 The next step in understanding fiduciary duty September 13, 2013 Jeanna M. Cullins, Partner Fiduciary Duty Refresher The Basics General Trust Principles Fiduciary law stems from the
More informationProcess & Decision Making of the ESOP Administration Committee
Process & Decision Making of the ESOP Administration Committee The ESOP Association Mid-Atlantic Chapter, Spring Conference March 10, 2017 Nona K. Massengill Williams Mullen nmassengill@williamsmullen.com
More informationSeptember 30, 2003 Ruling on Defendants Motions to Dismiss
September 30, 2003 Ruling on Motions to Dismiss Members of Enron s Board of Directors Compensation Committee (who appointed members to the administrative committees) Count I Surviving Breach of Fiduciary
More informationEXCESSIVE OR HIDDEN FEES ERISA LITIGATION
EXCESSIVE OR HIDDEN FEES ERISA LITIGATION April 17, 2007 What it s s all about: In a nutshell, an alleged breach of ERISA s fiduciary duties and/or prohibited transactions provisions by defined contribution
More informationStock Drop Litigation: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends
Stock Drop Litigation: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends Rayman Mathoda, Entrepreneur and Investor Reginald Goeke, Mayer Brown LLP John Nadolenco, Mayer Brown LLP Fabio Bertoni, Incisive Media Mayer
More informationThis Webcast Will Begin Shortly
This Webcast Will Begin Shortly If you have any technical problems with the Webcast or the streaming audio, please contact us via email at: webcast@acc.com Thank You! Severance Plan Design: Legal and Practical
More informationB. Co-Defendant Coverage. This alternative grants coverage for any claim against the company provided that the claim is also made against D&Os.
GLOSSARY I. INSURANCE COVERAGE TERMS Allocation refers to the process of determining the amount of defense costs and any settlement or judgment which is properly attributable or allocated to covered claims
More informationFiduciary Case Studies
Fiduciary Case Studies 2015 ASPPA Annual Conference R. Bradford Huss Trucker Huss Alex Brucker Brucker & Morra 1 Recent Developments Supreme Court decision in Tibble Scope of equitable relief post-amara
More informationSupreme Court of the United States
NO. 12-751 In the Supreme Court of the United States FIFTH THIRD BANCORP, ET AL., v. Petitioners, JOHN DUDENHOEFFER, ET AL., Respondents. On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for
More informationEmployee benefit plan large filers: Meeting your compliance and fiduciary requirements. April 20, 2016
Employee benefit plan large filers: Meeting your compliance and fiduciary requirements April 20, 2016 1 Your presenters Rose Ann Abraham, CPA Partner Baker Tilly 312 729 8086 roseann.abraham@bakertilly.com
More informationProtecting Yourself from ERISA Fiduciary Liability
Protecting Yourself from ERISA Fiduciary Liability Tax Executives Institute Cincinnati-Columbus Chapter February 9-10, 2015 Jodi H. Epstein (202) 662-3468 JEpstein@ipbtax.com Benjamin L. Grosz (202) 662-3422
More informationLessons from the Newest Benefits Lawsuits. 19 th Annual Conference on Employee Benefits and Retirement Plans Jim Griffin
Lessons from the Newest Benefits Lawsuits 19 th Annual Conference on Employee Benefits and Retirement Plans Jim Griffin jgriffin@jw.com Issue Reasonableness of 401(k) Fees Case Name Damberg v. LaMettry
More informationSecurities, Financial and Directors & Officers Litigation. Practice Overview
Securities, Financial and Directors & Officers Litigation Practice Overview Seyfarth Shaw LLP Capabilities Our Securities, Financial and Directors & Officers Litigation Practice Group attorneys help companies
More informationSO YOU RE A RETIREMENT PLAN FIDUCIARY NOW WHAT? GE (2/17) (Exp. 2/19)
SO YOU RE A RETIREMENT PLAN FIDUCIARY NOW WHAT? GE-123340 (2/17) (Exp. 2/19) AGENDA The Framework Defining the Fiduciary The Big 5 - Basic Fiduciary Duties Plan Governance Limiting Liability When Mistakes
More informationSTATE UNIVERSITIES RETIREMENT SYSTEM OF ILLINOIS SELF-MANAGED PLAN INVESTMENT POLICY
STATE UNIVERSITIES RETIREMENT SYSTEM OF ILLINOIS SELF-MANAGED PLAN INVESTMENT POLICY Adopted by the Board of Trustees September 11, 2015 SELF-MANAGED PLAN INVESTMENT POLICY Table of Contents Section /
More informationFiduciary Responsibilities under ERISA Alabama SHRM State Conference
Fiduciary Responsibilities under ERISA 2017 Alabama SHRM State Conference May 17, 2017 B. David Joffe Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP Fiduciary Responsibility Rules Employee
More informationCase 5:12-cv R-DTB Document Filed 06/02/14 Page 1 of 24 Page ID #:3449 EXHIBIT 1
Case 5:12-cv-01648-R-DTB Document 166-1 Filed 06/02/14 Page 1 of 24 Page ID #:3449 EXHIBIT 1 Case 5:12-cv-01648-R-DTB Document 166-1 Filed 06/02/14 Page 2 of 24 Page ID #:3450 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
More informationERISA Causes of Action *
1 ERISA Causes of Action * ERISA authorizes a variety of causes of action to remedy violations of the statute, to enforce the terms of a benefit plan, or to provide other relief to a plan, its participants
More informationRisky Business: Protecting the Personal Assets of Ds&Os. Steven Cohen, Marsh Inc. Jay Dubow, Pepper Hamilton LLP Bob Hickok, Pepper Hamilton LLP
Risky Business: Protecting the Personal Assets of Ds&Os Steven Cohen, Marsh Inc. Jay Dubow, Pepper Hamilton LLP Bob Hickok, Pepper Hamilton LLP Thursday, January 28, 2016 Topics Nuts and Bolts - D&O Liability,
More informationCITY OF HOLLYWOOD POLICE OFFICERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM SECURITIES LITIGATION POLICY
CITY OF HOLLYWOOD POLICE OFFICERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM SECURITIES LITIGATION POLICY I. Principles 1. The Board of Trustees manages the assets entrusted to it in accordance with the prudent expert principle
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS. No.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS ROY E. RINARD and STEVE LACEY, Plaintiffs, No. v. CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT ENRON CORP. and THE NORTHERN TRUST COMPANY, Defendants. Plaintiffs, by their
More information