U.S. Supreme Court Considering Fiduciary Responsibility For 401(k) Plan Company Stock Funds and Other Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOP)
|
|
- Claribel Rich
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Fiduciary Responsibility For Funds and Other Employee Andrew Irving Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel
2 The Supreme Court of the United States is poised to enter the debate over the standards of prudence and loyalty that an ERISA plan fiduciary must satisfy when a defined contribution plan offers participants a fund dedicated to company stock as one of the plan s investment options. The Court heard oral argument on April 2, 2014 in a case brought by participants in Fifth Third Bank s 401(k) plan alleging that the bank and its officials who were the plan s fiduciaries breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA by maintaining the plan s company stock fund even as the Bank s stock declined by 74% in the aftermath of poor financial results stemming from the Bank s expansion of its subprime lending and other high-risk businesses. The plan s company stock fund lost tens of millions of dollars as a result, according to the plaintiffs. The name of the case is Fifth Third Bank v. Dudenhoeffer and a decision is expected by the end of June. Summary and Overview Company stock funds pose unique challenges and risks to plan fiduciaries who must decide what, if anything, to do when the company and its stock face serious challenges, putting participant investments in the stock fund in jeopardy. The Supreme Court is expected to provide at least some clarification as to the nature of those fiduciary responsibilities and the fiduciary breach claims that stock fund participants can bring when plans lose millions of dollars on company stock. The Supreme Court may address how appointing an independent fiduciary can alleviate some of the inherent conflicts, and resulting risks, associated with putting company insiders with access to material nonpublic information in fiduciary positions. What s at Stake According to the briefs filed with the Supreme Court, thousands of companies offer some kind of employer stock investment opportunity to their employees. Company stock funds can take the form of standalone Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) that exist side by side with an ordinary 401(k) plan, or as one of the several investment options offered within the 401(k) plan (so-called KSOPs ). AARP, citing a study by Vanguard, reports that nearly 60% of participants enrolled in plans covering at least 5,000 participants were offered employer stock as an investment option, and that retirement plans held $240 billion in employer stock as of Congress has indicated its support for the concept of employee ownership, and has facilitated the offering of employer stock funds in 401(k) plans by explicitly providing that such funds are exempt from the diversification element of ERISA s demanding fiduciary standards. Because employer stock funds are, by definition, undiversified, plan participants who choose to invest in the stock fund can suffer significant losses if the stock price drops dramatically. Perhaps not surprisingly in our litigious society, those losses have given rise to lawsuits. A nonparty friend INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 2
3 of the court brief filed by Delta Airlines listed 235 so-called stock drop litigation cases under ERISA filed between July 1997 and August While plaintiffs have yet to win a case that has gone to trial, the friend of court brief filed by the Chamber of Commerce and other employer organizations reported that such lawsuits often settle for tens of millions of dollars. Gallagher s institutional investment and fiduciary services practice has reviewed and approved ERISA stock-drop settlements for as much as $57 million. The Issues The U.S. Department of Labor and attorneys representing plan participants have very different views from attorneys representing plan fiduciaries on how a fiduciary should manage an employer stock fund. ERISA and the fiduciary dilemma created by employer stock funds ERISA imposes a fiduciary duty on fiduciaries managing ESOP and KSOP company stock funds consisting of three components: Loyalty: A duty to act solely in the interests of the participants and beneficiaries and for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and their beneficiaries and defraying the plan s reasonable administrative expenses; Prudence: A duty to act with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use in the conduct of an enterprise of a like character and with like aims, but without the duty to diversify investments that applies to other ERISA plan assets; and Conformity with plan documents: A duty to act in accordance with the plan s governing documents to the extent consistent with specified provisions of ERISA, including the provisions outlining the other elements of fiduciary duty. In contrast to other fund investment options, company stock funds invest in only a single security. Despite the risk associated with such an undiversified investment, Congress has expressed its support for giving employees an opportunity to become owners of a stake in their employers by exempting ESOPs and KSOPs from the investment diversification element of fiduciary duties that applies to all other plan investments. Another distinguishing feature of company stock funds is that the plan s governing documents, typically drafted by the employer establishing the plan (a function trust law refers to as a settlor function ), often mandate that the employer stock fund be offered and do not authorize the fiduciaries to eliminate the fund the way they can eliminate or replace the plan s other investment options. In addition, the company officials assigned to provide fiduciary oversight of the plan s investments often have access to negative nonpublic information about the company but (1) are barred by the securities laws from relying on that information to sell the plan s holdings of company stock before the INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 3
4 news becomes public and drives down the stock price, and (2) would be defying the plan document if they were to sell the plan s stock holdings or bar participants from investing in it. The question facing not only the Supreme Court but also the fiduciaries responsible for making decisions about employer stock funds is how, if at all, ERISA s fiduciary s duties of loyalty, prudence and plan document conformity are different when a company stock fund is involved, as compared to the plan s other investments. A fiduciary needs to know what circumstances give rise to a duty to override the plan s direction and either limit or bar new investments into the stock fund, or even to sell the fund s holdings of the employer stock. And fiduciaries and their insurers need to know how expensive litigation will be and how likely they are to be held liable if, on the one hand, the fiduciaries maintain the stock fund and the company s stock declines or even becomes worthless in a bankruptcy, or they decide to sell the stock when it is under pressure and a declining company recovers and the stock price rallies. The Moench Presumption of Prudence Most courts have adopted what has come to be known as the Moench presumption, named for a participant in an ESOP sponsored by a New Jersey bank that went bankrupt. Mr. Moench sued the ESOP fiduciaries for breach of fiduciary duty for continuing to purchase the bank s stock for the ESOP even as they became aware of the bank s deteriorating condition. The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit decided in that 1995 case that when it comes to employer stock, as opposed to other investments, fiduciaries are entitled to a presumption of prudence in light of the special nature of employer stock funds described above. According to the Moench presumption, plaintiffs who suffer losses on their employer stock investments must meet a higher burden of proof to establish that fiduciaries breached their duties, versus the burden of proof required to establish breaches of fiduciary duties pertaining to other investments. Since then, virtually all of the Courts of Appeal around the country have agreed that such a presumption is appropriate and applies to ESOPs and KSOPs alike. However, the courts have been unable to agree on a formulation of exactly what circumstances overcome the presumption and give rise to a fiduciary duty to respond to negative developments about the company by taking action to close or liquidate a stock fund or make disclosures to participants outside the requirements of the securities laws. In the Moench case itself, the court said that employer stock fiduciary decisions are presumed prudent unless they amount to an abuse of discretion in that the fiduciary could not have believed reasonably that continued adherence to the [plan provisions calling for an employer stock fund] was in keeping with the settlor s expectations of how a prudent trustee would operate. While agreeing that a decline in the stock s price was not by itself enough to require fiduciary action, courts have used phrases like extreme risk, dire situation, [doubts as to] viability as a going concern, serious INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 4
5 mismanagement and impending collapse to attempt to characterize the additional circumstances that must be present to render a fiduciary dutybound to stop investing the plan s assets in the employer s stock. Fiduciary defendants support a strong statement of the presumption, arguing that without it employers will become reluctant to establish employer stock funds notwithstanding public policy encouraging them, and that plan participants can use the securities laws to recover if their losses result from fraud-like conduct. Meanwhile, attorneys for plan participants continue to argue that, aside from the exemption from diversification, ERISA does not provide for a separate fiduciary standard applicable to employer stock. The Department of Labor has consistently taken that same position, asserting that employer stock fiduciaries are not entitled to the special deference or protection a presumption of prudence creates. Under this view, plan participants who suffer losses on employer stock investments need only show that a trustee adhering to ERISA s prudence and loyalty standards should have taken action to close or eliminate the stock fund, or taken other steps such as making disclosures to participants or limiting investments in the fund. Further, the inside information dilemma can be addressed by appointing an independent fiduciary untainted by such information to make decisions about the fund. A separate but related issue concerns the stage of the proceedings at which plan participants must present specific facts other than the decline in the price of the stock sufficient to overcome a presumption of prudence (however it is formulated). Most courts have agreed with fiduciary defendants that the complaint filed at the beginning of the case must meet that standard or the case will be dismissed. Dismissal of a case at that early stage prevents lengthy, expensive litigation involving extensive document production, depositions, motions and the associated legal fees. And the prospect of dismissal can discourage attorneys from pursuing stock drop claims. Plan participants, on the other hand, again supported by the Department of Labor, urge that if there is to be a presumption of prudence it should only apply after a full record has been developed through pre-trial discovery, since participants do not have access to all the facts concerning the company and the fiduciaries conduct when a case begins. They say that requiring participants to allege facts needed to overcome a prudence presumption places an effectively insurmountable barrier to recovery of employer stock losses. What Will the Supreme Court Do? The Supreme Court received a total of 12 briefs in the case. Delta Airlines and Key Bank, who are facing similar stock drop litigation, filed friend of the court briefs supporting Fifth Third Bank s arguments in favor of a strong presumption of prudence. Similar briefs were filed by the ESOP Association, a coalition of organizations representing plan sponsors such as the Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers, INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 5
6 and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association. On the other side, the Solicitor General of the United States (on behalf of the Department of Labor), the AFL-CIO, AARP and a group of law professors supported the plan participants in arguing that ERISA does not permit a presumption of prudence and if it does, it should not apply at the outset of the case. The briefs appeared to agree on one point only: that a stock price drop by itself is insufficient proof of a breach of fiduciary duty. Otherwise, the briefs presented disagreements even among those arguing on the same side as to what renders continued maintenance of an employer stock fund imprudent and a violation of the duty of loyalty, both with and without a presumption of prudence. At oral argument an engaged Court pressed all the lawyers on the practical issues facing employer stock fund fiduciaries, but the focus was limited almost exclusively on the situation in which fiduciaries are insiders who come to possess materially adverse information about the company. There was acknowledgment that fiduciary action to liquidate the company stock fund, before the adverse information was disclosed, would not only violate the securities laws but itself drive down the price of the stock to the detriment of the participants. The Justices also asked the lawyers how a fiduciary could be expected to outguess the market as to whether the company stock was overvalued other than by reference to inside information. But several Justices asked whether insider fiduciaries with negative nonpublic information need the protection of the Moench presumption if compliance with the securities laws means they cannot sell stock before the public disclosure of the information drives down the stock price. The back and forth on those issues led some Justices to seem to suggest that if ordinary standards of prudence did not require fiduciaries to violate the securities laws by selling on non-public information or to outguess the market, then no special prudence rule for employer stock funds was even necessary. Justices also observed that replacing insiders with an independent fiduciary to assume responsibility for the company stock fund would resolve the inside information dilemma. With the focus on the inside information problem, little was said during the argument about the dilemma of fiduciaries at risk for dismantling a company stock fund too early rather than too late. And the Justices gave scant attention to the question of whether a presumption of prudence, if sustained, applies at the beginning of a case or should only be considered after a full record has been developed. This omission was surprising since it was the different views in the lower courts on this particular point that was central to the Court s decision to hear the case in the first place. The ebb and flow of oral argument does not always provide a reliable indicator as to how the Court will rule in a particular case. It may be that the Justices avoidance of discussion about when the presumption should apply indicates an inclination to reject the presumption itself. The Court may accept the suggestion of the United States Solicitor General to limit its opinion to situations where a failure to disclose material inside information known to the responsible fiduciaries has artificially inflated the stock s value. INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 6
7 Such an outcome would leave unaddressed the fiduciary obligations in other situations such as a company facing serious but fully disclosed financial or business problems driving down its stock price. The Court likewise could focus on the availability of independent fiduciaries to resolve some elements of the dilemma corporate insiders face when they choose to serve also as plan fiduciaries. And the Court may not address at all whether it matters how definitively plan language mandates that an employer stock fund be offered. One thing is clear after 20 years of debate in the lower courts, the companies who create employer stock funds, the in-house and independent fiduciaries who manage them and the plan participants who invest in them are hoping for clarification of the fiduciary rules of the road. We will know by the end of June if the Court will deliver that clarification. Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. s Institutional Investment and Fiduciary Services Practice has served as independent fiduciary for numerous employer stock funds in a variety of industries. INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 7
8 Andrew Irving About the Author Andrew Irving, Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel of the Institutional Investment & Fiduciary Services group of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., leads the fiduciary decision-making practice, which focuses on providing independent, conflict-free, discretionary decisions regarding particular transactions or plan assets. As Area Counsel, he also provides guidance on legal issues that arise in the course of client engagements and manages the services of outside legal counsel when particular assignments require their assistance. Andrew Irving Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel Institutional Investment & Fiduciary Services Investment advisory services and named and independent fiduciary services are offered through Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Adviser. This document contains proprietary information that belongs to Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC and is protected by copyright, trade secret and other State and Federal laws. Any copying, redistribution, or retransmission of any of the contents without the written consent of Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC is expressly prohibited. Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC is a single-member, limited-liability company, with Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc. as its single member. Neither Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC nor their affiliates provide accounting, legal or tax advice 2014 Gallagher Fiduciary Advisors, LLC INSTITUTIONAL INVESTMENT & FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO. MAY 2014 :: 8 14GBS25521A
Stakes Are High For ERISA Fiduciaries
Portfolio Media. Inc. 860 Broadway, 6th Floor New York, NY 10003 www.law360.com Phone: +1 646 783 7100 Fax: +1 646 783 7161 customerservice@law360.com Stakes Are High For ERISA Fiduciaries Law360, New
More informationAugust 14, Winston & Strawn LLP
The Supreme Court s Decision in Dudenhoeffer: If You Offer a Company Stock Fund Investment Option in Your 401(k) Plan or ESOP, You Will be Sued, Eventually August 14, 2014 Today s elunch Presenters Mike
More informationThe Impact of Dudenhoeffer on Lower Court Stock-Drop Cases
The Impact of Dudenhoeffer on Lower Court Stock-Drop Cases ALYSSA OHANIAN The Supreme Court recently held in Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer, 134 S. Ct. 2459 (2014), that employer stock ownership plan
More informationESOP FIDUCIARY LIABILITY: AN OVERVIEW OF THE OBLIGATIONS AND EXPOSURES OF ESOP FIDUCIARIES. Prepared by Stephen D. Rosenberg, The Wagner Law Group 1
ESOP FIDUCIARY LIABILITY: AN OVERVIEW OF THE OBLIGATIONS AND EXPOSURES OF ESOP FIDUCIARIES Prepared by Stephen D. Rosenberg, The Wagner Law Group 1 Table of Contents Important Note... 1 Executive Summary...
More informationRecent trends in ERISA litigation
RETIREMENT INSIGHTS SERIES A valuable resource for advisors looking to grow their retirement business. Recent trends in ERISA litigation At Groom Law Group, where he currently serves as the firm s Chairman,
More informationFollow this and additional works at:
2008 Decisions Opinions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit 11-13-2008 Ward v. Avaya Inc Precedential or Non-Precedential: Non-Precedential Docket No. 07-3246 Follow this and additional
More information9/22/ IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE AGENDA. ESOP Transactions: Fiduciary Duty & New Guidance from the DOL
Southwest Chapter of the ESOP Association Fall Conference Houston, Texas September 19, 2014 ESOP Transactions: Fiduciary Duty & New Guidance from the DOL Allison Wilkerson Allison.wilkerson@klgates.com
More informationJanuary 2005 Bulletin Labor Department Issues Guidance on Fiduciary Responsibilities of Directed Trustees
January 2005 Bulletin 05-01 Labor Department Issues Guidance on Fiduciary Responsibilities of Directed Trustees If you have questions or would like additional information on the material covered in this
More informationThird Circuit Affirms Dismissal of 401(k) Stock-Drop Case
ERISA Litigation Advisory September 27, 2007 Third Circuit Affirms Dismissal of 401(k) Stock-Drop Case Introduction The United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has affirmed the dismissal of
More informationWho Are the Fiduciaries and What Are Their Key Responsibilities?
Who Are the Fiduciaries and Presented by: Thomas H. Mug Greensfelder, Hemker & Gale, P.C. 10 South Broadway, Suite 2000 St. Louis, Missouri 63102 (314) 345-4732 thm@greensfelder.com 1 Section 3(21) of
More informationAVOIDING FIDUCIARY DUTY FOR DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS. Brian T. Ortelere Charles C. Jackson
AVOIDING FIDUCIARY DUTY FOR DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS I. INTRODUCTION Brian T. Ortelere Charles C. Jackson Recent highly publicized corporate reversals have spawned numerous class action lawsuits raising
More informationRegulatory Update Retirement Plans
DiMeo Schneider & Associates, L.L.C. VOLUME 4, NO. 2 Regulatory Update Retirement Plans DOL Outlook for 2014 IN THIS ISSUE: DOL Outlook for 2014 Stock Drop Case Update District Court Decision Affirms Importance
More informationThe United States Supreme Court held in Tibble et al. v. Edison
Employee Relations L A W J O U R N A L Employee Benefits Electronically reprinted from Spring 2016 The Trouble Caused by Tibble: Supreme Court Case Requires Enhanced Monitoring of Plan Investments Mark
More information401(k) Fee Litigation Update
October 6, 2008 401(k) Fee Litigation Update Courts Divide on Fiduciary Status of 401(k) Service Providers Introduction As the 401(k) fee lawsuits progress, the federal district courts continue to grapple
More informationTrustees: Independent vs. Internal and Directed vs. Non-Directed Legal Aspects
Trustees: Independent vs. Internal and Directed vs. Non-Directed Legal Aspects The 19 th Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference Akron/Fairlawn Hilton Akron, Ohio Friday, April 15, 2005 Carl J. Grassi,
More informationInsights for fiduciaries
Insights for fiduciaries Hiring an investment fiduciary issues and considerations for plan sponsors The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 ( ERISA ), the federal law that governs privately
More informationJACKSONVILLE POLICE AND FIRE PENSION FUND Standard Procedures Manual
15 (b) 1 of 6 to be determined I. Principles 1. The Board of Trustees manages the assets entrusted to it in accordance with the prudent expert principle which requires that the Board act with the care,
More informationPensions Strike Back A New Dawn. Nick Davies Area President. Andrew Irving Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel
A New Dawn Nick Davies Area President Andrew Irving Area Senior Vice President and Area Counsel It is a well known premise that sequels are rarely as good as the original when it comes to blockbuster feature
More informationCase 2:16-cv BSJ Document 2 Filed 11/14/16 Page 1 of 9
Case 2:16-cv-01159-BSJ Document 2 Filed 11/14/16 Page 1 of 9 JOHN W. HUBER, United States Attorney (#7226) JARED C. BENNETT, Assistant United States Attorney (#9097) 111 South Main Street, #1800 Salt Lake
More informationBENEFITS LAW BRIEFING:
BENEFITS LAW BRIEFING: Eliminating the Company Stock Fund From Your Public Company's 401(k) Plan Navigating the Securities and ERISA Fiduciary Issues May 21, 2015 Jan Jacobson Senior Counsel, Retirement
More informationBAILEY CAVALIERI LLC ATTORNEYS AT LAW
BAILEY CAVALIERI LLC ATTORNEYS AT LAW One Columbus 10 West Broad Street, Suite 2100 Columbus, Ohio 43215-3422 telephone 614.221.3155 facsimile 614.221.0479 www.baileycavalieri.com ERISA TAGALONG LITIGATION
More informationCITY OF HOLLYWOOD POLICE OFFICERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM SECURITIES LITIGATION POLICY
CITY OF HOLLYWOOD POLICE OFFICERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM SECURITIES LITIGATION POLICY I. Principles 1. The Board of Trustees manages the assets entrusted to it in accordance with the prudent expert principle
More informationINDEPENDENT FIDUCIARIES IN THE POST- DUDENHOEFFER WORLD
HEALTH WEALTH CAREER INDEPENDENT FIDUCIARIES IN THE POST- DUDENHOEFFER WORLD As a result of a June 2014 US Supreme Court ruling, Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) fiduciaries face new considerations
More informationTrack Two: The Roles of Boards of Directors and Trustees in ESOP Companies
Track Two: The Roles of Boards of Directors and Trustees in ESOP Companies The California/Western States Chapter of The ESOP Association: The 2018 Chapter Conference Thursday, October 4, 2018 3:15 p.m.
More informationYOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT?
YOU ARE AN ERISA FIDUCIARY, NOW WHAT? November 18, 2015 Rebecca E. Greene 414-298-8244 rgreene@reinhartlaw.com 1000 North Water Street, Suite 1700, Milwaukee, WI 53202 www.reinhartlaw.com Webinar Housekeeping
More informationERISA Fiduciary Responsibilities for 403(b) Plans: Keys to Implementation
ERISA Fiduciary Responsibilities for 403(b) Plans: Keys to Implementation ERISA Fiduciary Responsibilities for 403(b) Plans: Issues and Implementation Table of Contents Description Page I. Introduction...1
More informationPRUDENT ADMINISTRATION OF EMPLOYEE STOCK OWNERSHIP PLANS
PRUDENT ADMINISTRATION OF EMPLOYEE STOCK OWNERSHIP PLANS Ronald J. Mann Columbia Law School A pervasive element of the landscape of employee stock ownership plans has been the unexamined assumption that
More informationUnderstanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans
Understanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans An overview of the fiduciary s role and frequently asked questions about it When you are a trustee or serve on an investment committee
More informationERISA: THOU SHALL NOT PAY EXCESSIVE FEES! By: José M. Jara, Esq.
ERISA: THOU SHALL NOT PAY EXCESSIVE FEES! By: José M. Jara, Esq. Partner Employment, ERISA, and Employee Benefits Practice Group Leader About 12 years ago in 2006, there was a wave of class action lawsuits
More informationRetirement Plan Fiduciary Best Practices Houston Compensation and Benefits Total Rewards Summit
Retirement Plan Fiduciary Best Practices Houston Compensation and Benefits Total Rewards Summit Edward A. Razim, Partner September 13, 2018 Fiduciary Status Who is a fiduciary? Any individual or entity
More informationERISA Stock Drop Litigation Against Financial Institutions
ERISA Stock Drop Litigation Against Financial Institutions Sheila Finnegan, Mayer Brown LLP Reginald Goeke, Mayer Brown LLP Mayer Brown is a global legal services organization comprising legal practices
More informationEXCESSIVE OR HIDDEN FEES ERISA LITIGATION
EXCESSIVE OR HIDDEN FEES ERISA LITIGATION April 17, 2007 What it s s all about: In a nutshell, an alleged breach of ERISA s fiduciary duties and/or prohibited transactions provisions by defined contribution
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN MILWAUKEE DIVISION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN MILWAUKEE DIVISION ) THOMAS E. PEREZ, ) Civil Action No. Secretary of the United States ) Department of Labor, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. )
More informationTarget Date Funds Platform Investment Options
Target Date Funds Platform Investment Options The Evolving Tension Between Property Rights and Union Access Rights The California Experience By: Ted Scott and Sara B. Kalis, Littler Mendelson Kim Zeldin,
More informationDIRECTORS AND OFFICERS LIABILITY ERISA ENTERS THE SPOTLIGHT
DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS LIABILITY ERISA ENTERS THE SPOTLIGHT JOSEPH M. MCLAUGHLIN * SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP DECEMBER 9, 2004 Directors of public companies and their advisers have long understood
More informationUnderstanding Your Fiduciary Liability: 3(21) vs. 3(38) Services
Understanding Your Fiduciary Liability: 3(21) vs. 3(38) Services Mark J. Grushkin Employee Benefits Shareholder Littler Mendelson, P.C. (Littler) There is considerable confusion in the marketplace regarding
More informationThe Investment Lawyer
The Investment Lawyer Covering Legal and Regulatory Issues of Asset Management VOL. 24, NO. 6 JUNE 2017 Business Development Company Update: Excessive Fees Lawsuit Against Adviser Dismissed By Kenneth
More informationDEPARTMENT OF LABOR (DOL) FIDUCIARY RULE IMPLICATIONS FOR CORPORATE FIDUCIARIES
James Marion DEPARTMENT OF LABOR (DOL) FIDUCIARY RULE IMPLICATIONS FOR CORPORATE FIDUCIARIES NEW YORK BANKER S ASSOCIATION (NYBA) TRUST & INVESTMENT CONFERENCE SEPTEMBER 22, 2016 National Fiduciary Executive,
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS. No.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS ROY E. RINARD and STEVE LACEY, Plaintiffs, No. v. CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT ENRON CORP. and THE NORTHERN TRUST COMPANY, Defendants. Plaintiffs, by their
More informationBenefits Briefing: Company Stock as a Retirement Plan Investment. Friday, September 21, p.m. to 3 p.m. ET
Benefits Briefing: Company Stock as a Retirement Plan Investment Friday, September 21, 2018 2 p.m. to 3 p.m. ET Today s Speakers Moderator: Guest Speakers: Jan Jacobson Senior Counsel, Retirement Policy
More informationWill The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone
DR. GREGORY W. KASTEN UNIFIED TRUST COMPANY, NA Will The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone Many plan sponsors are aware they need help with the
More informationModel Ethics and Conflict-of- Interest Policy for Texas Public Retirement Systems PENSION REVIEW BOARD
Model Ethics and Conflict-of- Interest Policy for Texas Public Retirement Systems PENSION REVIEW BOARD 12/19/2013 Table of Contents BACKGROUND... 1 I. Overview... 3 II. Code of Ethics... 3 III. General
More informationDIRECTORS & OFFICERS AND FIDUCIARY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR ESOPS: The Exposure, the Solutions, the Marketplace
DIRECTORS & OFFICERS AND FIDUCIARY LIABILITY INSURANCE FOR ESOPS: The Exposure, the Solutions, the Marketplace ESOP MIDWEST REGIONAL CONFERENCE Bloomington, Minnesota September 11, 2015 TED BECKER Drinker
More informationCase 1:08-cv Document 1 Filed 10/21/2008 Page 1 of 19 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
Case 1:08-cv-06029 Document 1 Filed 10/21/2008 Page 1 of 19 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. SAVINGS PLAN INVESTMENT OVERSIGHT
More informationManaging Fiduciary Risk Under ERISA: A Primer for Employers, HR Directors, and Plan Administrators. Copyright
Managing Fiduciary Risk Under ERISA: A Primer for Employers, HR Directors, and Plan Administrators Copyright 2011 1 Presenters Gregory L. Ash, JD Partner gash@spencerfane.com 913.327.5115 Julia M. Vander
More informationWho is the Plan Fiduciary? Employment Law Briefing June 25, 2018 CUPA HR Conference 2
Who is the Plan Fiduciary? June 25, 2018 Jacksonville Presented by: Robert S. Ellerbrock Paul Owen (CAPTRUST Advisors) Employment Law Briefing June 25, 2018 CUPA HR Conference 1 Who is a Fiduciary? Basically,
More informationJuly 26, Unwarranted and Harmful ERISA Breach of Fiduciary Duty Litigation
July 26, 2017 Mr. Nicholas C. Geale Acting Solicitor of Labor U.S. Department of Labor Office of the Solicitor of Labor 200 Constitution Ave., NW Washington, DC 20210 RE: Unwarranted and Harmful ERISA
More informationFiduciary Best Practices Helped NYU Win ERISA Class Action
Portfolio Media. Inc. 111 West 19 th Street, 5th Floor New York, NY 10011 www.law360.com Phone: +1 646 783 7100 Fax: +1 646 783 7161 customerservice@law360.com Fiduciary Best Practices Helped NYU Win ERISA
More informationRETIREMENT PLAN INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT TRINITY PORTFOLIO ADVISORS LLC
vs.4 RETIREMENT PLAN INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT TRINITY PORTFOLIO ADVISORS LLC Name of Plan: Name of Employer: Effective Date: This Retirement Plan Investment Management Agreement ( Agreement ) is
More informationLearning the True Meaning of Fiduciary, the Hard Way Sub: As 401(k) values plummet, pensioners look to employers and question their performances
Learning the True Meaning of Fiduciary, the Hard Way Sub: As 401(k) values plummet, pensioners look to employers and question their performances By Evan Miller and Alison Cera National Law Journal Although
More informationSupreme Court of the United States
Supreme Court of the United States WILSON-EPES PRINTING CO., INC. (202) 789-0096 WASHINGTON, D. C. 20002 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF AUTHORITIES... ii SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS... 1 I. OTHER
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO
Case 4:16-cv-00325-CWD Document 50 Filed 11/15/17 Page 1 of 9 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO PENSION BENEFIT GUARANTY CORPORATION, vs. Plaintiff IDAHO HYPERBARICS, INC., as Plan
More informationUnited States Court of Appeals For the Eighth Circuit
United States Court of Appeals For the Eighth Circuit No. 17-2397 John Meiners, on behalf of a class of all persons similarly situated, and on behalf of the Wells Fargo & Company 401(k) Plan lllllllllllllllllllllplaintiff
More informationERISA Compliance and Monitoring 401(k) Investments: Safe Harbor Rules and Appointing Advisers
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A ERISA Compliance and Monitoring 401(k) Investments: Safe Harbor Rules and Appointing Advisers TUESDAY, APRIL 3, 2018 1pm Eastern 12pm Central 11am
More informationWildman vs. American Century Process Saved the Day
Wildman vs. American Century Process Saved the Day Philip Chao, Principal & CIO, pchao@chaoco.com January 28, 2019 On June 30, 2016, a class action complaint 1 was filed by Steve Wadman, et al (Plaintiffs),
More informationFiduciary Liability Insurance
14 th National Forum on ERISA Litigation March 1-2, 2017 Fiduciary Liability Insurance Alison L. Martin Fiduciary Product Manager Chubb Brian Smith Chief Operating Officer Segal Select Insuring Services
More informationJanus Henderson Labs DEFINED CONTRIBUTION. Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures. Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process
Janus Henderson Labs Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process DEFINED CONTRIBUTION Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Agenda + Overview
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA LYNCHBURG DIVISION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA LYNCHBURG DIVISION THOMAS E. PEREZ, ) SECRETARY OF LABOR, ) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) ) ADAM VINOSKEY,
More informationFIDUCIARY ISSUES AND HOW TO AVOID BEING A DEFENDANT
FIDUCIARY ISSUES AND HOW TO AVOID BEING A DEFENDANT Mid-Sized Retirement and Healthcare Plan Management Conference October 17, 2012 Sherwin Kaplan AGENDA Who is an ERISA Fiduciary? What are an ERISA Fiduciary
More informationFIDUCIARY ISSUES AND HOW TO AVOID BEING A DEFENDANT. Mid-Sized Retirement and Healthcare Plan Management Conference September 12, 2012 Sherwin Kaplan
FIDUCIARY ISSUES AND HOW TO AVOID BEING A DEFENDANT Mid-Sized Retirement and Healthcare Plan Management Conference September 12, 2012 Sherwin Kaplan AGENDA Who is an ERISA Fiduciary? What are an ERISA
More informationFIDUCIARY TUNE-UP 25TH ANNUAL BENEFITS COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE SOUTHWEST BENEFITS ASSOCIATION NOVEMBER 13-14, 2014
FIDUCIARY TUNE-UP 25TH ANNUAL BENEFITS COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE SOUTHWEST BENEFITS ASSOCIATION NOVEMBER 13-14, 2014 Dallas DoubleTree Galleria Dallas, Texas By: John L. Utz, Esq. UTZ & LATTAN, LLC 7285 W.
More informationRecent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures
Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Why Plan Sponsors are Being Sued and the Importance of Process Recent Case Studies in Fiduciary Failures Agenda + Overview of Recent Class-Action Lawsuits + What
More information"3(38) Manager" Program Services Agreement
"3(38) Manager" Program Services Agreement Wilshire Associates Incorporated ("Wilshire") is pleased to have the opportunity to provide our "3(38) Manager" Program Services (the "Services") to your Plan.
More informationINTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO, CLC PENSION ASSISTANCE AND LITIGATION POLICY ADOPTED 2011
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO, CLC PENSION ASSISTANCE AND LITIGATION POLICY ADOPTED 2011 I. General Policy Statement on Retirement: The retirement benefits earned by firefighters are
More informationPLAN DISTRIBUTION AND ROLLOVER GUIDANCE AFTER CHAMBER OF COMMERCE V. US DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
PLAN DISTRIBUTION AND ROLLOVER GUIDANCE AFTER CHAMBER OF COMMERCE V. US DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AN ANALYSIS OF THE DESERET LETTER September 2018 www.morganlewis.com This White Paper is provided for your convenience
More informationUnder ERISA, the role of fiduciary
Prudent fiduciary decision making is critical to the goal of achieving successful retirement outcomes and delivering meaningful benefits to plan participants. However, fiduciary responsibility under the
More informationWill The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone
Will The Real Fiduciary Please Stand Up: In Most Court Cases The Plan Sponsor is Left Standing Alone Today many plan sponsors are aware they need help with the sections of ERISA dealing with fiduciary
More informationBest Practices in Fiduciary Liability
Best Practices in Fiduciary Liability Laverne Wingfield, Ullico Casualty Group James Martinez, Arthur J Gallagher Timothy Bowen, Mesirow Financial Fiduciary Liability Insurance Protect the board and the
More informationROCK N ROLL DUTIES: Fiduciary Duty Issues for Employee Stock Ownership Plans
ROCK N ROLL DUTIES: Fiduciary Duty Issues for Employee Stock Ownership Plans New South Chapter of the ESOP Association Fall Conference - September 19, 2013 Gordon Earle Nichols Eileen Wyatt babc.com ALABAMA
More informationCORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION: DO THE TWO COINCIDE IN THE POST- ENRON ENVIRONMENT? Dana M. Muir * and Cindy A.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND FIDUCIARY OBLIGATION: DO THE TWO COINCIDE IN THE POST- ENRON ENVIRONMENT? I. Introduction by Dana M. Muir * and Cindy A. Schipani ** The corporate scandals of the past few years
More informationUnderstanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans
Understanding your fiduciary responsibilities for retirement plans An overview of the fiduciary s role and frequently asked questions about it What is a fiduciary? A fiduciary is a person or entity who:
More informationPLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY. In further support of their Opposition to Defendants Motion to Dismiss the Consolidated
Case 1:09-md-02017-LAK Document 216 Filed 01/20/2010 Page 1 of 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK IN RE LEHMAN BROTHERS SECURITIES AND ERISA LITIGATION C.A. No. 09 MD 2017 This
More informationFiduciary Training: ERISA Duties & Obligations Seyfarth Shaw LLP
Fiduciary Training: ERISA Duties & Obligations Seyfarth Shaw LLP Seyfarth Shaw refers to Seyfarth Shaw LLP (an Illinois limited liability partnership). Why Do We Care? Fiduciary status creates litigation
More informationCase 1:13-cv DJC Document 1 Filed 03/07/13 Page 1 of 19 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
Case 1:13-cv-10524-DJC Document 1 Filed 03/07/13 Page 1 of 19 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS Patricia Boudreau, Alex Gray, ) And Bobby Negron ) On Behalf of Themselves and
More informationChapter 2 The Duty of Care
Chapter 2 The Duty of Care By stipulating three Qualified Default Investment Alternatives (QDIAs), the Pension Protection Act of 2006 has established certain forms of safe harbors, but the substance, i.e.,
More informationQ UPDATE EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS CASES OF INTEREST D&O FILINGS, SETTLEMENTS AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS Q1 2018 UPDATE CASES OF INTEREST U.S. SUPREME COURT FINDS STATE COURTS RETAIN JURISDICTION OVER 1933 ACT CLAIMS STATUTORY DAMAGES FOR VIOLATION OF TCPA FOUND TO BE PENALTIES AND
More information401(K) AND 403(B) PLAN SPONSORS AND THEIR FIDUCIARY DUTIES FOR REVENUE SHARING
401(K) AND 403(B) PLAN SPONSORS AND THEIR FIDUCIARY DUTIES FOR REVENUE SHARING JUNE 2017 A WHITE PAPER BY FRED REISH TABLE OF CONTENTS JUNE 2017 401(k) Plan Sponsors and Their Fiduciary Duties for Revenue
More informationBluesphere Advisors LLC. Form ADV Part 2A Disclosure Brochure
Form ADV Part 2A Disclosure Brochure Effective: April 27, 2017 This Form ADV 2A ( Disclosure Brochure ) provides information about the qualifications and business practices of ( Bluesphere or the Advisor
More informationT he US Supreme Court s recent decision in Janus Capital Group, Inc. v. First Derivative
The Supreme Court s Janus decision: no secondary liability, but many secondary questions Arthur Delibert and Gregory Wright Arthur Delibert and Gregory Wright are both Partners at K&L Gates LLP, Washington,
More information401(k) Fees and Fiduciary Responsibility
T. ROWE PRICE 401(k) Fees and Fiduciary Responsibility What Plan Sponsors Need to Know Retirement Insights EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In recent years, market events have made many 401(k) participants more sensitive
More informationPERSONAL CUSTODIAL ACCOUNT AGREEMENT
PERSONAL CUSTODIAL ACCOUNT AGREEMENT Terms and conditions of this Self-Directed Account are listed below. The Customer and New Direction IRA Inc., agent for the Custodian, Mainstar Trust Company, make
More informationPUBLIC COMPANY PERSPECTIVES APRIL 2011
PUBLIC COMPANY PERSPECTIVES APRIL 2011 Dates to Remember: April 22, 2011 Good Friday SEC Open; U.S. markets closed. May 2, 2011 Deadline to file a proxy statement for companies that incorporate into Part
More informationFiduciary Education. Jared Martin, CFP Vice President, Consultant. October 19, 2016
Fiduciary Education Jared Martin, CFP Vice President, Consultant October 19, 2016 FIDUCIARY EXPERTISE Professional certifications which include fiduciary standards: AICPA, AIFA, AIF, ASPPA, CFA, & CIMA
More informationThe DOL and ESOPs. Best Practices for a DOL Audit
The DOL and ESOPs Best Practices for a DOL Audit 61152401 1 Patti J. Hedgpeth, Esq. Shareholder Polsinelli 2950 N Harwood Street Suite 2100 Dallas, TX 75201 Phone: (214) 661-5556 Mobile: (214) 923-0251
More informationFiduciary Insurance Understanding Your Exposure. All programs Administered by Lockton Affinity, LLC
Fiduciary Insurance Understanding Your Exposure All programs Administered by Lockton Affinity, LLC First Party vs. Third Party ERISA Plan First Party Named plan fiduciaries or anyone acting in the capacity
More informationTrusts & Equity Law 463 Fall Term 2018 LECTURE NOTES NO. 1
Trusts & Equity Law 463 Fall Term 2018 LECTURE NOTES NO. 1 THE FIDUCIARY PRINCIPLE Fiduciary duties are a special category of obligations that sound in equity rather than common law. Breaching such a duty
More informationRECENT ERISA LITIGATION WHERE FIDUCIARY AND PREEMPTION ISSUES ARE HEADED IN 2008
THE WAGNER LAW GROUP A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION 99 SUMMER STREET, 13 TH FLOOR BOSTON, MA 02110 (617) 357-5200 FACSIMILE E-MAIL WEBSITE (617) 357-5250 marcia@wagnerlawgroup.com www.erisa-iawyers.com www.wagnerlawgroup.com
More informationCase 3:11-cv WGY Document 168 Filed 01/10/13 Page 1 of 53 IN THE UNTIED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT
Case 3:11-cv-00282-WGY Document 168 Filed 01/10/13 Page 1 of 53 IN THE UNTIED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT HEALTHCARE STRATEGIES, INC., Plan Administrator of the Healthcare Strategies,
More informationCase 1:16-cv UU Document 38 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2016 Page 1 of 14
Case 1:16-cv-20245-UU Document 38 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2016 Page 1 of 14 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA MIAMI DIVISION THOMAS E. PEREZ, ) Secretary of Labor,
More informationFIDUCIARY DEVELOPMENTS, PLAN FEES AND VENDOR SEARCHES. General Fiduciary Guidelines Regarding Fees. Controlling Law
FIDUCIARY DEVELOPMENTS, PLAN FEES AND VENDOR SEARCHES May 21, 2014 General Fiduciary Guidelines Regarding Fees Controlling Law ERISA imposes procedural and substantive duties on fiduciaries of employee
More informationREAL ESTATE COUNCIL OF ONTARIO DISCIPLINE DECISION
REAL ESTATE COUNCIL OF ONTARIO DISCIPLINE DECISION IN THE MATTER OF A DISCIPLINE HEARING HELD PURSUANT TO BY-LAW NO. 10 OF THE REAL ESTATE COUNCIL OF ONTARIO John Van Dyk Respondent This document also
More informationRedefining. A plan sponsor s guide. roles and responsibilities. for saving time and managing risk
Redefining roles and responsibilities A plan sponsor s guide for saving time and managing risk Employer-sponsored retirement plans serve two important goals: attracting and retaining skilled employees;
More informationUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA. This action involves the Wells Fargo & Company 401(k) Plan (the 401(k) Plan ), which
Case 0:08-cv-04546-PAM-FLN Document 91 Filed 09/22/09 Page 1 of 30 Robin E. Figas, and all others similarly situated, UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA Plaintiffs, v. Wells Fargo
More informationCorporate Must Reads. Making sense of it all.
e-book March 2014 Corporate Must Reads. Making sense of it all. Table of contents U.S. Supreme Court extends whistleblower protection to employees of a public company s private contractors...3 SEC issues
More informationOverview of ERISA s Fiduciary Requirements: Retirement Plan Sponsor Considerations
Overview of ERISA s Fiduciary Requirements: Retirement Plan Sponsor Considerations R. Randall Tracht, Esq. Claudia L. Hinsch, Esq. Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP www.morganlewis.com June 2011 Introduction
More information14 - Court Determines Damages for Willfully Filing a Fraudulent Information Return
14 - Court Determines Damages for Willfully Filing a Fraudulent Information Return Angelopoulo v. Keystone Orthopedic Specialists, S.C., et al., (DC IL 7/9/2018) 122 AFTR 2d 2018-5028 A district court
More informationPegram v. Herdrich, 90 days later By Jeffrey Isaac Ehrlich
Pegram v. Herdrich, 90 days later By Jeffrey Isaac Ehrlich More than a third of all Americans receive their healthcare through employersponsored managed care plans; that is, through plans subject to ERISA.
More informationPART 8 DUTIES AND POWERS OF TRUSTEE General Comment
PART 8 DUTIES AND POWERS OF TRUSTEE General Comment This article states the fundamental duties of a trustee and lists the trustee s powers. The duties listed are not new, but how the particular duties
More informationUnderstanding the Roles and Responsibilities of a Fiduciary
Understanding the Roles and Responsibilities of a Fiduciary The retirement plan fiduciary has significant responsibilities. This paper outlines a fiduciary s responsibilities and offers strategies that
More informationNOTICE OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT in WAWA ESOP LITIGATION Pfeifer v. Wawa, Inc. et al, Case No (E.D. Pa.)
NOTICE OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT in WAWA ESOP LITIGATION Pfeifer v. Wawa, Inc. et al, Case No. 16-0497 (E.D. Pa.) Please read this notice carefully and completely. If you are a member of the Class, the
More information