Integrating Economic Capital, Regulatory Capital and Regulatory Stress Testing in Decision Making
|
|
- Morris Sanders
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Complimentary Webinar: Integrating Economic Capital, Regulatory Capital and Regulatory Stress Testing in Decision Making Amnon Levy, Managing Director, Head of Portfolio Research Co-Sponsored by: Originally presented and recorded as a Moody s Analytics webinar August, 2013
2 2 Complimentary Webinar: Integrating Economic Capital, Regulatory Capital and Regulatory Stress Testing in Decision Making Presented by Dr. Amnon Levy, Head of Portfolio Research at Moody s Analytics Dr. Amnon Levy heads the Portfolio Research Group that is responsible for research and model development for Moody s Analytics portfolio and balance sheet models. Dr. Levy holds a B.A. in Economics from the University of California at Berkeley and a Ph.D. in Finance from the Kellogg Graduate School of Management, Northwestern University. Prior to joining MKMV, Dr. Levy was a visiting assistant professor at the Stern School of Business, New York University, and the Haas School of Business, University of California at Berkeley. He has also taught Corporate Finance at the Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University and worked at the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. He is currently teaching a course on credit risk at the Haas School of Business MFE program. Dr. Levy has been published in the Journal of Financial Economics, Journal of Monetary Economics, Encyclopedia of Quantitative Finance, Risk, Journal of Banking and Finance, and Journal of Risk Model Validation. His current research interests include modeling credit portfolio risk, integrated models for balance sheet management, as well as liquidity risk.
3 Agenda 3 1. Context 2. Current State of Portfolio Management 3. Unified Measures 4. Stress Testing in an Economic Capital Framework 5. Recap 2010 Moody's Analytics, Inc., its licensors and affiliates. All rights reserved. All trademarks, unless otherwise noted, are owned by MIS Quality Management Corp. and used under license.
4 1 Context
5 Economic Capital (EC), Regulatory Capital (RegC) and Regulatory Stress Tests (RST) EC is a measure of economic risk associated with a portfolio» Accounts for diversification and concentration risks» Provides insights allowing optimized risk-return profiles, facilitate strategic planning and limit setting, as well as define risk appetite» Provides a foundation for return-to-risk measures such as RORAC, Sharpe Ratio and Vasicek Ratio to rank instruments RegC and RST, when binding, results in tangible costs» Additional capital is needed for new investments» Changes in portfolio composition can require drastic action» Sale of business units» Access capital markets at unfavorable terms 5
6 Strategic Questions 6 Should RegC replace EC in asset selection?» With the advent of Basel III, financial institutions face RegC constraints that are increasingly impacting investment plans» In such environments should an institution replace EC with RegC in RORAC style decision rules? How should RST enter into decision making? Is there a need for unified measures?» RegC and RST are risk measures» do not account for concentration or diversification effects» Are associated with tangible costs» EC does account for diversification, concentration effects, and other economic risks EC, RegC and RST should all influence decision making
7 2 Current State of Credit Portfolio Management
8 8 Traditional Measures for Asset Selection Using traditional measures that accounts for EC but not RegC, The asset should be purchased as long as: SR jt, ES = RC ES jt, Pt, σ jt, Pt,, or VR jt, ES ES = CR CR jt, Pt, jt, Pt,, or ES ES RORAC = + r + r jt, Pt, jt, Dt, Dt, CRjt, CRPt,
9 9 Motivation Behind Asset Selection Based on Traditional Measures A financial institution maximizes the utility function of its stakeholders max ( ) U C E t C bc st.. t 2 ( ) = 0 γ ( t t ) C = P + CF N D (1 + r ) P N + D t jt, jt, it, 1 t 1 Dt, it, it, t j j C can be thought of as the dividend policy Overarching structure is same as that which underpins» CAPM in portfolio selection» Black-Scholes style pricing» NPV capital budgeting using a project s β
10 3 Unified Measures
11 11 Introducing the Regulatory Capital Constraint When RegC is binding, an institution faces a tangible cost, which can be considered as an additional constraint in the optimization problem: max ( ) U C E t C bc st.. t 2 ( ) = 0 γ ( t t ) C = P + CF N D (1 + r ) P N + D, and t jt, jt, it, 1 t 1 Dt, it, it, t j j Book Equity and = N D N RWC t jt, t jt, jt, j j
12 12 Introducing the Stress Testing Constraint When binding, an institution faces a tangible cost, which can be considered as an additional constraint in the optimization problem: max Equity U C E t C bc st.. t 2 ( ) = 0 γ ( t t ) ( ) C = P + CF N D (1 + r ) P N + D, and t jt, jt, it, 1 t 1 Dt, it, it, t j j and = N + N EL N EL N D t stress j, t Liquid, t stress j, t stress j, t Liquid, t stress Liquid, t t stress j j N j, trwc j, t stress + NLiquid, t stress RWCLiquid, t stress j
13 13 Asset Selection with RegC or RST Constraint The agent should purchase assets as long as: SR ES jt SR Pt RC where ES = r r f ES σ, Pt, jt., jt,.,, jt, jt j t D t adjustment p Only the numerator is affected by the RegC constraint RegC-adjusted ES is similar to traditional ES but the cost of debt is multiplied by an adjustment factor.
14 Impact of the RegC Constraint on ES % Difference Between ES and RegC Adjusted ES 0.10% 0.08% 0.06% 0.04% 0.02% 0.00% RegC The impact on ES as a function of RegC varies, in part, because of the role of price in the adjustment
15 Impact of the RegC Constraint on RORAC % 30.00% Correlation = % RegC Adjusted RORAC 20.00% 15.00% 10.00% Impact on RORAC can exceed 50% 5.00% 5.00% 10.00% 15.00% 20.00% 25.00% 30.00% 35.00% Traditional RORAC
16 4 Stress testing in an EC framework
17 Moody s Analytics RiskFrontier framework with our Global Correlation (GCorr ) Macro model Draws of borrower specific credit risk factors 1-RSQ Draws of asset returns (credit quality changes) PD, LGD, EAD, Credit Migration Credit portfolio loss distribution on a horizon EL given a macroeconomic shock Draws of systematic credit risk factors φ CR1, φ CR2, Joint distribution with correlation matrix Σ RSQ Correlations of GCorr systematic factors and standard normal macroeconomic factors (φ MV ): φ CR φ CR Σ GCorr φ MV Mapping between φ MV and macroeconomic variables (MV) Range of losses given a macroeconomic shock Scenario for macroeconomic variables (MV) conditional loss distribution. φ MV GCorr Macro Model
18 What is the impact of an oil price drop on a credit portfolio loss distribution? A large credit portfolio of homogenous exposures to the U.S. Oil, Gas, and Coal Expl/Prod industry» Input parameters: PD=1%, RSQ=20%, LGD=100%, EAD=1. Conditional distribution of φ US,Oil, given φ OilPrice Conditional loss distribution, given φ OilPrice Unconditional distr. Unconditional distr. E[L]=1% Oil Price drops by 2 standard deviations Oil Price drops by 2 standard deviations
19 What is the impact of an oil price drop on a credit portfolio loss distribution? A large credit portfolio of homogenous exposures to the U.S. Oil, Gas, and Coal Expl/Prod industry» Input parameters: PD=1%, RSQ=20%, LGD=100%, EAD=1. Conditional distribution of φ US,Oil, given φ OilPrice Conditional loss distribution, given φ OilPrice Unconditional distr. Conditional distr. E[L φ OilPrice ] =2.3% Conditional distr. Mean= 0.82 Std=0.91 Unconditional distr. E[L]=1% Oil Price drops by 2 standard deviations Oil Price drops by 2 standard deviations Conditional expected loss: Terminology: conditional expected loss, given a macroeconomic scenario, will be also called stressed expected loss. 1 N (PD) ρ RSQ φ OilPr ice φ OilPr ice = N 2 [ ] E L 1ρ RSQ
20 20 Two ways of using the GCorr Macro model within the RiskFrontier framework: Analytical method Calculating stressed expected loss using formulas, which can be evaluated analytically, without a Monte Carlo simulation. The formulas are based on the GCorr Macro model. The formulas account only for losses due to defaults, not due to deteriorating credit quality of counterparties. The method is simpler and the calculation faster than in the case of the simulation approach. The method allows for a CCAR-style analysis. Simulation approach Running the Monte Carlo simulation in RiskFrontier with the GCorr Macro model. Using the Monte Carlo simulation output for various analyses of credit portfolio losses. In addition to calculation of the stressed expected loss, the method allows for: further insights into relationships between losses and macroeconomic variables. determining the full conditional loss distribution. reverse stress testing. Accounting not only for defaults, but also for losses due to credit quality deterioration. The method takes advantage of the RiskFrontier capability to value various credit risk exposures.
21 Running RiskFrontier, including the simulation, with the GCorr Macro model Expanded covariance matrix r C and r I φ MV Mapping between standard normal macroeconomic factors φ MV and macroeconomic variables MV. Inputs r C and r I GCorr Matrix φmv Output Trial Simulated macroeconomic factors Output of Monte Carlo simulation RiskFrontier Monte Carlo simulation engine Simulated GCorr systematic credit risk factors Portfolio Loss 1 φ MV1, φ MV2, φ 1, φ 2, L Trial 1 2 φ MV1, φ MV2, φ 1, φ 2, L Trial 2 Conversion to observable macroeconomic variables MV 1, MV 2, using mappings Losses can account for credit quality deterioration. Analysis of relationships between portfolio losses and macroeconomic variables across trials
22 22 How do correlations vary across U.S. industries?» Box plots characterizing distribution of correlations between the 61 U.S. custom indexes and select macroeconomic variables 'STEEL & METAL PRODUCTS' 'CHEMICALS' 'MINING' 'BUSINESS PRODUCTS WHSL' 'FURNITURE & APPLIANCES' 'CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS 'REAL ESTATE' 'OIL, GAS & COAL EXPL/PROD' 'MINING' 'STEEL & METAL PRODUCTS' 'COMPUTER HARDWARE' 'SEMICONDUCTORS' 'COMPUTER SOFTWARE' 'TELEPHONE' Correlations scaled by -1 Correlations scaled by -1 'UTILITIES, ELECTRIC' 'INSURANCE - PROP/CAS/HEALTH' 'INSURANCE - LIFE' 'BANKS AND S&LS Patterns resulting from a strong interest rate component in asset returns, attributable to financial leverage
23 How credit portfolio losses depend on various macroeconomic variables» IACPM portfolio 3000 reference entities distributed across 7 developed countries and 60 industries.» Running simulation engine, which generates draws of systematic factors as well as macroeconomic standard normal shocks (φ MV ). Each trial credit portfolio loss and a macroeconomic shock.» Example: impact of two macroeconomic variables on the portfolio One trial portfolio loss versus a draw of the macroeconomic standard normal shock φ S&P500. Conditional expected loss given the macroeconomic standard normal shock φ S&P500. Conversion to observable stock market returns using a mapping Losses more strongly associated with macroeconomic shocks φ S&P500 than φ OilPrice.
24 CCAR: stressed expected losses over multiple periods in the future» Stressed expected losses over future periods: Analysis date Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Scenario Scenario Scenario k,1 k,1 = k,1 PD LGD EL Scenario Scenario Scenario k,2 k,2 = k,2 PD LGD EL Scenario Scenario Scenario k,3 k,3 = k,3 PD LGD EL Scenario Scenario Scenario k,4 k,4 = k,4 PD LGD EL Stressed Expected Loss Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
25 Quarterly FDIC C&I loan performance indicator for all FDIC-insured institutions Net Charge - offs 4 Avg Outstanding Two periods of high losses: Dot-com bust recession Financial crisis Time series pattern: Does GCorr Macro imply higher than average losses during recessions and lower than average losses during periods of economic growth?
26 Historical time series patterns in losses produced by the GCorr Macro model» Variables used in the scenario: unemployment rate, Baa yield, Stock market return, VIX. 9 quarter cumulative stressed expected losses. Why 9 quarters? CCAR time horizon GCorr Macro Stressed expected loss over the 9 quarter horizon t t+9. Both PD and LGD are stressed. Unconditional expected loss over the 9 quarter horizon t t+9 Stressed expected losses increase above the unconditional expected losses during the dotcom recession and the financial crisis. Why are losses higher during the financial crisis? The financial crisis saw larger quarterly shocks to the stock market and unemployment rate than the dot-com recession.
27 5 Recap
28 Recap» EC, RegC and RST should all influence decision making» We design decision making variables that bring the three together using a broadly accepted economic framework Accounts for risks related to concentration and diversification Accounts for tangible costs related to RegC and RST» Link stress testing and EC under a single model Introduce GCorr Macro which unifies credit factors and macroeconomic variables Allows for CCAR/DFAST-style stress testing Provides insights on the extent to which scenarios span portfolio risk Reverse stress testing Risk integration
29 6 Thank You Q&A
30 2012 Moody s Analytics, Inc. and/or its licensors and affiliates (collectively, MOODY S ). All rights reserved. ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS PROTECTED BY COPYRIGHT LAW AND NONE OF SUCH INFORMATION MAY BE COPIED OR OTHERWISE REPRODUCED, REPACKAGED, FURTHER TRANSMITTED, TRANSFERRED, DISSEMINATED, REDISTRIBUTED OR RESOLD, OR STORED FOR SUBSEQUENT USE FOR ANY SUCH PURPOSE, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, IN ANY FORM OR MANNER OR BY ANY MEANS WHATSOEVER, BY ANY PERSON WITHOUT MOODY S PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT. All information contained herein is obtained by MOODY S from sources believed by it to be accurate and reliable. Because of the possibility of human or mechanical error as well as other factors, however, all information contained herein is provided AS IS without warranty of any kind. Under no circumstances shall MOODY S have any liability to any person or entity for (a) any loss or damage in whole or in part caused by, resulting from, or relating to, any error (negligent or otherwise) or other circumstance or contingency within or outside the control of MOODY S or any of its directors, officers, employees or agents in connection with the procurement, collection, compilation, analysis, interpretation, communication, publication or delivery of any such information, or (b) any direct, indirect, special, consequential, compensatory or incidental damages whatsoever (including without limitation, lost profits), even if MOODY S is advised in advance of the possibility of such damages, resulting from the use of or inability to use, any such information. The credit ratings, financial reporting analysis, projections, and other observations, if any, constituting part of the information contained herein are, and must be construed solely as, statements of opinion and not statements of fact or recommendations to purchase, sell or hold any securities. NO WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS TO THE ACCURACY, TIMELINESS, COMPLETENESS, MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OF ANY SUCH RATING OR OTHER OPINION OR INFORMATION IS GIVEN OR MADE BY MOODY S IN ANY FORM OR MANNER WHATSOEVER. Each rating or other opinion must be weighed solely as one factor in any investment decision made by or on behalf of any user of the information contained herein, and each such user must accordingly make its own study and evaluation of each security and of each issuer and guarantor of, and each provider of credit support for, each security that it may consider purchasing, holding, or selling.
Modeling Credit Correlations Using Macroeconomic Variables. Nihil Patel, Director
Modeling Credit Correlations Using Macroeconomic Variables Nihil Patel, Director October 2012 Agenda 1. Introduction 2. Challenges of working with macroeconomic variables 3. Relationships between risk
More informationLinking Stress Testing and Portfolio Credit Risk. Nihil Patel, Senior Director
Linking Stress Testing and Portfolio Credit Risk Nihil Patel, Senior Director October 2013 Agenda 1. Stress testing and portfolio credit risk are related 2. Estimating portfolio loss distribution under
More informationA Unified Approach to Accounting for Regulatory and Economic Capital
AUGUST 2013 WHITEPAPER A Unified Approach to Accounting for Regulatory and Economic Capital About This whitepaper was derived from a Moody s Analytics Modeling Methodology Whitepaper entitled, A Unified
More informationStress Testing Challenges:
Stress Testing Challenges: Forecasting Consistent Credit & Market Risk Losses JOSE CANALS-CERDA, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia JUAN M. LICARI, Senior Director, Moody s Analytics OCTOBER 2015 Agenda
More informationThe Next Challenge in Portfolio Management: Accounting for Liquidity in Pricing and Risk. Amnon Levy, Managing Director, Head of Portfolio Research
The Next Challenge in Portfolio Management: Accounting for Liquidity in Pricing and Risk Amnon Levy, Managing Director, Head of Portfolio Research November 2010 2 Bank Funding Costs Continue to be a Maor
More informationMeasuring and Managing the Impact of IFRS 9/CECL on Earnings Volatility and Capital
Measuring and Managing the Impact of IFRS 9/CECL on Earnings Volatility and Capital Yashan Wang, Senior Director, Head of Valuation, Accounting, and ALM Research Jing Zhang, Global Head of Quantitative
More informationRetail Risk Modeling Framework in the Current Environment. BRAD BRADLEY, SunTrust JUAN M. LICARI, Moody s Analytics
Retail Risk Modeling Framework in the Current Environment BRAD BRADLEY, SunTrust JUAN M. LICARI, Moody s Analytics OCTOBER 2015 Retail Risk Modeling Framework in the Current Environment Brad Bradley, SunTrust
More informationQuantitative Modeling Beyond CCAR and other Regulatory Compliance
Quantitative Modeling Beyond CCAR and other Regulatory Compliance Gordon Liu, EVP, HSBC Chris Mann, MD, BTMU Jing Zhang, MD, MA Facilitated by David Little, MD, MA October 2015 Agenda 1. Setting the Context
More informationLearn the Fundamentals of Managing Liquidity Under U.S. Basel III
Learn the Fundamentals of Managing Liquidity Under U.S. Basel III Originally presented as a part of a Moody s Analytics recorded webinar on May 1, 2014 Agenda» Key Aspects of the Planned U.S. Basel III
More informationApplications of GCorr Macro within the RiskFrontier Software: Stress Testing, Reverse Stress Testing, and Risk Integration
AUGUST 2014 QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH GROUP MODELING METHODOLOGY Applications of GCorr Macro within the RiskFrontier Software: Stress Testing, Reverse Stress Testing, and Risk Integration Authors Mariano Lanfranconi
More informationImprove liquidity management under a regulation framework. Nicolas Kunghehian
Improve liquidity management under a regulation framework Nicolas Kunghehian 24 th May 2011 From Basel II to Basel III» Too much leverage» Excessive credit growth» Insufficient liquidity buffers» Weaknesses
More informationPotential Bumps Ahead for U.S. Financial Markets RYAN SWEET, DIRECTOR OF REAL-TIME ECONOMICS SOHINI CHOWDHURY, DIRECTOR
Potential Bumps Ahead for U.S. Financial Markets RYAN SWEET, DIRECTOR OF REAL-TIME ECONOMICS SOHINI CHOWDHURY, DIRECTOR May 2017 Financial Drag Can Be Significant Real GDP response to one std deviation
More informationApplications of GCorr Macro: Risk Integration, Stress Testing, and Reverse Stress Testing
5 APRIL 013 MODELING METHODOLOGY Authors Libor Pospisil Andrew Kaplin Amnon Levy Nihil Patel Contact Us Americas +1-1-553-1653 clientservices@moodys.com Europe +44.0.777.5454 clientservices.emea@moodys.com
More informationPractical Considerations When Unifying Regulatory and Economic Capital in Investment Decisions
JULY 2015 QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH GROUP MODELING METHODOLOGY Practical Considerations When Unifying Regulatory and Economic Capital in Investment Decisions Authors Pierre Xu Amnon Levy Qiang Meng Andrew
More informationMoody s Analytics. Jacek Nowak, Associate Director. Nikola Bakić, Credit Product Specialist. Essential Insight Serving Global Financial Markets
Moody s Analytics Essential Insight Serving Global Financial Markets Jacek Nowak, Associate Director Nikola Bakić, Credit Product Specialist November 2012 Agenda 1. Who are we? 2. Why should you care?
More informationOptimizing performance and profitability in the Basel III environment. Nicolas Kunghehian, Business Development Director
Optimizing performance and profitability in the Basel III environment Nicolas Kunghehian, Business Development Director June 2011 Higher costs for a better risk control performance Risk Operation al reports
More informationModern Techniques for Analyzing CLOs. A Workshop
Modern Techniques for Analyzing CLOs A Workshop June 2013 Agenda» Introduction» Basic Fundamental and Market Valuation Techniques» Data-driven Valuation Enhancements» Comparables» Manager Style» Single
More informationReverse Stress Testing:
Reverse Stress Testing: Challenges & Benefits Presented by: Dr. Christian Thun, Senior Director Dr. Juan M. Licari, Senior Director Dr. Mark Zandi, Chief Economist November 23 rd, 2010 Reverse Stress Testing:
More informationPreparing for Defaults in China s Corporate Credit Market
Preparing for Defaults in China s Corporate Credit Market David Hamilton, PhD Managing Director, Singapore Glenn Levine Senior Economic Research Analyst, New York Irina Baron Quantitative Credit Risk,
More informationStress Testing Handling low default portfolios under stress. Thanks for joining today s webinar. It will begin shortly.
Stress Testing Handling low default portfolios under stress Part of the Moody s Analytics Stress Testing Webinar Series Thanks for joining today s webinar. It will begin shortly. Dial-in details: Call-in
More informationStrategic Risk Management and Balance Sheet Management under the new regulatory environment
Strategic Risk Management and Balance Sheet Management under the new regulatory environment Vishal Kapoor Regional Practice Lead (APAC) Balance Sheet Management, Moody s Analytics 1 Introduction to Moody
More informationCCAR Stress Testing Basics. By: Michael Fadil October 17, 2012 Chicago
CCAR Stress Testing Basics By: Michael Fadil October 17, 2012 Chicago Risk Practitioner Conference - 2012 Stress Testing What is It?? Stress testing is a useful method for determining how a portfolio will
More informationMoody s Approach to Assessing Credit Risk for Oil & Gas Companies. Gretchen French Vice President and Senior Credit Officer Moody s Investors Service
Moody s Approach to Assessing Credit Risk for Oil & Gas Companies Gretchen French Vice President and Senior Credit Officer Moody s Investors Service Agenda 1. Overview of Moody s Ratings 2. Rating Methodologies
More informationCredit Risk Scoring - Basics
Credit Risk Scoring - Basics Charles Dafler, Credit Risk Solutions Specialists, Moody s Analytics Mehna Raissi, Credit Risk Product Management, Moody s Analytics NCCA Conference February 2016 Setting the
More informationA.M. Best s Updated Credit Rating Methodology and Capital Model. Robert Raber Senior Financial Analyst A.M. Best Company
A.M. Best s Updated Credit Rating Methodology and Capital Model Robert Raber Senior Financial Analyst A.M. Best Company 1 Contents A.M. Best Company Overview Updated Best s Credit Rating Methodology (BCRM)
More informationU.S. Macroeconomic Outlook DAN WHITE, ECONOMIST
U.S. Macroeconomic Outlook DAN WHITE, ECONOMIST FTA Annual Conference June 10, 2013 Businesses Have Never Been as Profitable After-tax corporate profit margin, % 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 45 50 55 60 65 70 75
More informationEffective Risk Management in CRE Lending
Effective Risk Management in CRE Lending CHRISTIAN HENKEL, SENIOR DIRECTOR, MOODY S ANALYTICS SUMIT GROVER, ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR, MOODY S ANALYTICS August 6, 2015 Speakers Sumit Grover is an Associate Director
More informationPerformance Forecasting and Stress Testing: Selecting the Right Tool for the Job MICHAEL FADIL, CITIZENS BANK CRISTIAN DERITIS, MOODY S ANALYTICS
Performance Forecasting and Stress Testing: Selecting the Right Tool for the Job MICHAEL FADIL, CITIZENS BANK CRISTIAN DERITIS, MOODY S ANALYTICS The Great Duel: Banker vs. Economist 2 The Questions 1.
More informationCECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success. Glenn Levine, Associate Director David Fieldhouse, Director
CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success Glenn Levine, Associate Director David Fieldhouse, Director September 6, 2017 Moody s Analytics CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success TODAY Lifetime Expected
More informationThe Regional Outlook MARISA DI NATALE, DIRECTOR
The Regional Outlook MARISA DI NATALE, DIRECTOR Expansion Is Spreading Total employment, % of previous business cycle peak, 2013Q2 U.S.=98% Sources: BLS, Moody s Analytics New peaks: 25% by count 35% by
More informationProxy Function Fitting: Some Implementation Topics
OCTOBER 2013 ENTERPRISE RISK SOLUTIONS RESEARCH OCTOBER 2013 Proxy Function Fitting: Some Implementation Topics Gavin Conn FFA Moody's Analytics Research Contact Us Americas +1.212.553.1658 clientservices@moodys.com
More informationMeasuring Required Economic Capital and Parameterizing the Loss Reference Point
MARCH 2016 MODELING METHODOLOGY Authors Peter Bozsoki Amnon Levy Thomas Tosstorff Mark Wells Acknowledgements We would like thank Pierre Xu and Christopher Crossen for their comments and review. Contact
More informationIntegrating The Macroeconomy Into Consumer Loan Loss Forecasting. Juan M. Licari, Ph.D. Economics & Credit Analytics EMEA Moody s Analytics
Integrating The Macroeconomy Into Consumer Loan Loss Forecasting Juan M. Licari, Ph.D. Economics & Credit Analytics EMEA Moody s Analytics 2 Integrating The Macroeconomy Into Consumer Loan Loss Forecasting
More informationMethodology Review Seminar
etc.venues St.Paul s, London Methodology Review Seminar 16 November 2016 Methodology Review Seminar Welcome and Introduction Overview of the Structural Changes to Best's Credit Rating Methodology Greg
More informationBank Failure Case Study: Bank of Cyprus PLC
NOVEMBER 2013 QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH GROUP CASE STUDY Bank Failure Case Study: Bank of Cyprus PLC Authors Yanruo Wang Associate Director 1.415.874.6232 Yanruo.wang@moodys.com Clara Bernard Research Data
More informationMulti-Period Capital Planning
APRIL 2016 MODELING METHODOLOGY Multi-Period Capital Planning Authors Andy Kaplin Xuan Liang Acknowledgements We would like thank Amnon Levy, Libor Pospisil, and Christopher Crossen for their valuable
More informationasset classes? Natixis European Infrastructure Day - Paris, 17 October 2013 ANDREW DAVISON, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT
How is Infrastructure different from other asset classes? Natixis European Infrastructure Day - Paris, 17 October 2013 ANDREW DAVISON, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT Contents 1. What is Infrastructure? 2. Risk
More informationManaging IFRS 9 expected credit losses variance and forecast uncertainty
WHITEPAPER MAY 2016 Managing IFRS 9 expected credit losses variance and forecast uncertainty Author Pierre Gaudin Senior Director, Enterprise Risk Solutions Tel: +65.6511.4486 pierre.gaudin@moodys.com
More informationCanadian Life Insurance Industry
A.M. Best Company s 11 th Annual Insurance Market Briefing Canada Canadian Life Insurance Industry Edward Kohlberg, CPA, FLMI, CLU Associate Director Anthony McSwieney Senior Financial Analyst Toronto,
More informationProperty / Casualty State of the Market. Greg Williams Vice President
IASA Fall Meeting Property / Casualty State of the Market Greg Williams Vice President Agenda State of the Market Market Forces Financial Indicators & Underwriting Details Outlooks In the News Cyber Security
More informationCanadian Life Insurance Industry
Canadian Life Insurance Industry Edward Kohlberg, CPA, FLMI, CLU Associate Director Anthony McSwieney Senior Financial Analyst A.M. Best Annual Insurance Market Briefing Canada September 5, 2018 Canadian
More informationMain Street Report Q3 2017
Q3 2017 1 About the report The Experian/Moody s Analytics Main Street Report brings deep insight into the overall financial well-being of the small-business landscape, as well as providing commentary around
More informationRating Action: Moody's assigns Baa3 issuer rating to Eutelsat SA Global Credit Research - 28 Jan 2010
Rating Action: Moody's assigns Baa3 issuer rating to Eutelsat SA Global Credit Research - 28 Jan 2010 New York, January 28, 2010 -- Moody's Investors Service today assigned a long-term senior unsecured
More informationEconomic Scenarios: A Glimpse Into the Future. Cristian deritis PhD, Sr. Director, Economics Timothy Daly, Director, Sales Manager
Economic Scenarios: A Glimpse Into the Future Cristian deritis PhD, Sr. Director, Economics Timothy Daly, Director, Sales Manager Presenters Dr. Cristian deritis Senior Director, Consumer Credit Analytics
More informationGuarantees and Target Volatility Funds
SEPTEMBER 0 ENTERPRISE RISK SOLUTIONS B&H RESEARCH E SEPTEMBER 0 DOCUMENTATION PACK Steven Morrison, PhD Laura Tadrowski, PhD Moody's Analytics Research Contact Us Americas +.5.658 clientservices@moodys.com
More informationRating Action: Moody's upgrades Swedbank and Swedbank Mortgage to A1; P-1 ratings affirmed Global Credit Research - 04 Jun 2013
Rating Action: Moody's upgrades Swedbank and Swedbank Mortgage to A1; P-1 ratings affirmed Global Credit Research - 04 Jun 2013 London, 04 June 2013 -- Moody's Investors Service has today upgraded Swedbank
More informationWebinar Navigating Choppy Markets: Safety-First Equity Strategies Based on Credit Risk Signals
Topics@CreditEdge Webinar Navigating Choppy Markets: Safety-First Equity Strategies Based on Credit Risk Signals Samuel Malone, Ph.D, Director Research Yukyung Choi, Associate Director Senior Research
More informationBoosting Financial Based Risk Measures with Nonfinancial Information. Douglas Dwyer
Boosting Financial Based Risk Measures with Nonfinancial Information Douglas Dwyer 27 October 2015 Movie Trivia The most valuable commodity I know of is information, wouldn t you agree? What movie is this
More informationCredit Opinion: Deutsche Bank Mexico, S.A.
Credit Opinion: Deutsche Bank Mexico, S.A. Global Credit Research - 11 Jul 2013 Mexico, Mexico Ratings Category Moody's Rating Outlook Stable Bank Deposits Baa2/P-2 NSR Bank Deposits -Dom Curr Aa1.mx/MX-1
More informationForward-looking Perspective on Impairments using Expected Credit Loss
WHITEPAPER Forward-looking Perspective on Impairments using Expected Credit Loss Author Deepak Parmani, Associate Director, Product Management Contributor Yanping Pan, Director-Research Contact Us Americas
More informationGIOA Conference Moody s Approach to Rating Government Investment Pools: CNAV and Bond Funds. Marty Duffy VP-Managed Investments Group
GIOA Conference 2012 Moody s Approach to Rating Government Investment Pools: CNAV and Bond Funds Marty Duffy VP-Managed Investments Group Local Government Investment Pool Ratings March 21, 2012 Moody s
More informationCECL Modeling FAQs. CECL FAQs
CECL FAQs Moody s Analytics helps firms with implementation of expected credit loss and impairment analysis for CECL and other evolving accounting standards. We provide advisory services, data, economic
More informationRating Transitions for Investment Grade Issuers Subject To Event Risk
Rating Methodology July 2006 Contact Phone New York Pamela Stumpp 1.212.553.1311 Europe / Middle East / Africa Eric de Bodard 331.5330.1040 Asia Pacific Clara Lau 852.2916.1133 Japan Emiko Otsuki 81.3.5408.4100
More informationGetting Ready for CECL Why Start Now? ANNA KRAYN, SENIOR DIRECTOR, SME TEAM
Getting Ready for CECL Why Start Now? ANNA KRAYN, SENIOR DIRECTOR, SME TEAM September, 2016 2 Moody s Analytics is an independent entity from Moody s Investor Services Leading global provider of credit
More informationSimple But Not Simpler: Day 1 Modeling Approaches. A review of simple approaches available to community banks on the road to their CECL journey.
Simple But Not Simpler: Day 1 Modeling Approaches A review of simple approaches available to community banks on the road to their CECL journey. A Word on Incurred Loss Approach Today Typical ALLL at a
More informationRegional Economic Outlook
Regional Economic Outlook Dan White, Director September, 2017 U.S. Macroeconomic Outlook, August, 2017 1 Remarkably Steady Growth 5 4 3 2 1 0-1 -2-3 -4 Real GDP growth, %, 4-qtr MA (L) Avg monthly change
More informationSession 3B: Stress Testing from Macro-environment, to Scenario to Impacts and Decision. Moderator: Dariush A. Akhtari, FSA, MAAA, FCIA
Session 3B: Stress Testing from Macro-environment, to Scenario to Impacts and Decision Moderator: Dariush A. Akhtari, FSA, MAAA, FCIA Presenters: Ricky Power David Wicklund, FSA SOA Antitrust Disclaimer
More informationMoody s Revised Rating Methodology: US Local Government General Obligation Debt
Moody s Revised Rating Methodology: US Local Government General Obligation Debt US Public Finance April 2014 Agenda Summary of Developments Local Government General Obligation Sector Overview GO Scorecard
More informationSyracuse Funding EUR Limited Collateralised Fund of Hedge Funds Obligations
International Structured Finance Europe, Middle East, Africa Pre-Sale Report Syracuse Funding EUR Limited Collateralised Fund of s Obligations CFO / Global This pre-sale report addresses the structure
More informationFinancial Guarantors. Special Comment
www.moodys.com Special Comment Moody s Global December 2007 Table of Contents: Introduction 1 Analysis of Mortgage Risk and Impact on Current Ratings 2 Stress-Test Outcomes 2 Rating Actions 3 Business
More informationModeling Sovereign Credit Risk in a. Nihil Patel, CFA Director - Portfolio Research
Modeling Sovereign Credit Risk in a Portfolio Setting Nihil Patel, CFA Director - Portfolio Research April 2012 Agenda 1. Sovereign Risk: New Methods for a New Era 2. Data for Sovereign Risk Modeling 3.
More informationInnovations in C&I and CRE Credit Risk Solutions. Matt McDonald, Moody s Analytics Mehna Raissi, Moody s Analytics
Innovations in C&I and CRE Credit Risk Solutions Matt McDonald, Moody s Analytics Mehna Raissi, Moody s Analytics October 2015 Agenda 1. CreditEdge 2. Excel Add-in 3. RiskCalc 4. CMM (Commercial Mortgage
More informationU.S. Municipal Market The View From the Markets Presentation to the Federal Reserve Banks of Chicago, New York and Philadelphia
U.S. Municipal Market The View From the Markets Presentation to the Federal Reserve Banks of Chicago, New York and Philadelphia GAIL SUSSMAN, MANAGING DIRECTOR, US PUBLIC FINANCE June 24, 2011 Unprecedented
More informationBest s Credit Rating Methodology (BCRM) & Market Segment Outlooks
Special Presentation at the Gen Re Winter Forum Best s Credit Rating Methodology (BCRM) & Market Segment Outlooks Stefan Holzberger Chief Rating Officer St. Petersburg, Florida 19 January 2017 Disclaimer
More informationChanging Risk Environments: Governance vs. Management
Changing Risk Environments: Governance vs. Management 24th ICMIF/Americas Annual Conference Panelists The Co-operators Group Limited Canada John Harvie, Chairman of the Board Paul Hanna, Executive Vice
More informationThe ABCP Market. For the IMF Conference on Operationalizing Systemic Risk Monitoring, May 27, 2010
The ABCP Market For the IMF Conference on Operationalizing Systemic Risk Monitoring, May 27, 2010 Contents ABCP Market Background August 2007 and September 2008 ABCP Market Today 2 ABCP Market Overview
More informationImpact of Using EDF9 on Credit Portfolio Analysis
JUNE 2017 JUNE 2017 MODELING METHODOLOGY Authors Noelle Hong Jimmy Huang Albert Lee Sunny Kanugo Marc Mitrovic Tiago Pinheiro Libor Pospisil Andriy Protsyk Yashan Wang Contact Us Americas +1.212.553.1653
More informationCECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success
CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success Cristian deritis PhD, Sr. Director, Economics SEPTEMBER 2017 Moody s Analytics CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success Today: Economic Scenarios for CECL:
More informationCorporate Finance. Refinement to ABL Ratings. Special Comment. Moody s Global. Summary. January Table of Contents: Analyst Contacts:
www.moodys.com Special Comment Moody s Global Corporate Finance January 2008 Table of Contents: Summary 1 Eligibility Requirements for ABL One-Notch Upgrade 2 Defining a True ABL 2 Exceptions to the One-Notch
More informationERM in the Rating Process: A Practical Perspective
ERM in the Rating Process: A Practical Perspective Jeffrey Mango, Group Vice President, A.M. Best Michelle Baurkot, Assistant Vice President, A.M. Best Tom Zitelli, Managing Senior Financial Analyst, A.M.
More informationDefault Risk Jumps Sharply for Troubled Bank. Figure 1: Bankia SA s One-Year EDF Measure
25 MAY 2012 CAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCH EDF TM CASE STUDY Bankia S.A. Default Risk Jumps Sharply for Troubled Bank Moody s Capital Markets Research, Inc. Authors David T. Hamilton, PhD +1 (212) 553-1695 david.hamilton@moodys.com
More informationCECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success. Irina Korablev, Senior Director Deniz Tudor, Director Anna Krayn, Senior Director
CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success Irina Korablev, Senior Director Deniz Tudor, Director Anna Krayn, Senior Director August 24, 2017 Moody s Analytics CECL Webinar Series: The Roadmap to Success
More informationProxy Techniques for Estimating Variable Annuity Greeks. Presenter(s): Aubrey Clayton, Aaron Guimaraes
Sponsored by and Proxy Techniques for Estimating Variable Annuity Greeks Presenter(s): Aubrey Clayton, Aaron Guimaraes Proxy Techniques for Estimating Variable Annuity Greeks Aubrey Clayton, Moody s Analytics
More informationMOODY'S AFFIRMS Aa3 RATING ON THE CITY OF LIVONIA'S (MI) OUTSTANDING GENERAL OBLIGATION DEBT
MOODY'S AFFIRMS Aa3 RATING ON THE CITY OF LIVONIA'S (MI) OUTSTANDING GENERAL OBLIGATION DEBT Aa3 RATING APPLIES TO $56 MILLION IN OUTSTANDING GO DEBT Livonia (City of) MI Municipality Michigan NEW YORK,
More informationDFAST and Dual Ratings: Making Practical Use of Credit Loss Estimation Measures
DFAST and Dual Ratings: Making Practical Use of Credit Loss Estimation Measures #RPC14 KEN CARSON, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, UMPQUA BANK CHRISTIAN HENKEL, SENIOR DIRECTOR, ENTERPRISE RISK SOLUTIONS October
More informationIntroducing The Deterioration Probability Metric. A New Metric for Downgrade Risk
Introducing The Deterioration Probability Metric A New Metric for Downgrade Risk Credit Risk Analytics Group May 2018 Agenda 1. Introducing the Deterioration Probability 2. Deterioration Probability Model
More informationORSA: Prospective Solvency Assessment and Capital Projection Modelling
FEBRUARY 2013 ENTERPRISE RISK SOLUTIONS B&H RESEARCH ESG FEBRUARY 2013 DOCUMENTATION PACK Craig Turnbull FIA Andy Frepp FFA Moody's Analytics Research Contact Us Americas +1.212.553.1658 clientservices@moodys.com
More informationLoan Level Mortgage Modeling
Loan Level Mortgage Modeling Modeling and Data Challenges Shirish Chinchalkar October 2015 Agenda 1. The complexity of loan level modeling 2. Our approach for modeling mortgages 3. Data Challenges 4. Conclusion
More informationLeveraging Basel and Stress Testing Models for CECL and IFRS 9. Nihil Patel, Senior Director
Leveraging Basel and Stress Testing Models for CECL and IFRS 9 Nihil Patel, Senior Director October 2016 Moody s Analytics CECL webinar series 2016 Getting Ready for CECL Why Start Now? Recording now available
More informationThe Development of Microinsurance and the Role of Credit Rating Agencies
ADB FSD CoP The Development of Microinsurance and the Role of Credit Rating Agencies Andrea E. Keenan Vice President Research & Ratings Criteria A.M. Best - Oldwick, NJ Disclaimer AM Best Company (AMB)
More informationMoody s RiskCalc External Model Specification:
Moody's Moody s RiskCalc External Model Specification: Last Updated: May 23, 2003 Contact Phone South Bend Robert Weiss 574.472.5764 Copyright 2002 by Moody s Investors Service, Inc., 99 Church Street,
More informationFigure 1: Groupon s One-Year EDF Measure
17 AUGUST 2012 CAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCH EDF CASE STUDY Groupon Inc. Moody s Capital Markets Research, Inc. Authors Sai Mao +1 (212) 553-1035 sai.mao@moodys.com Irina Makarova +1 (212) 553-4307 irina.makarova@moodys.com
More informationHigher Education Ratings & Construction Risk
Higher Education Ratings & Construction Risk Georgia Facilities Officers Conference October 25, 2012 dennis.gephardt@moodys.com Agenda Moody s in Capital Markets Moody s Outlook for Higher Education Productive
More informationFebruary Request for Comment:
www.moodys.com Special Comment Moody s Global Credit Policy February 2008 Table of Contents: Summary of Proposed Rating Scale Options 2 Background 2 Details on the Options for Consideration 3 Moody s Related
More informationRating Action: Moody's: NAMA triggers mostly positive actions on Irish Banks' BFSR's
Rating Action: Moody's: NAMA triggers mostly positive actions on Irish Banks' BFSR's Global Credit Research - 31 Mar 2010 Actions follow Government, NAMA and Financial Regulator announcements London, 31
More informationProducing Objective Income & Balance Sheet Forecasts. Brian Poi, Director November 7, 2017
Producing Objective Income & Balance Sheet Forecasts Brian Poi, Director November 7, 2017 Today s Speaker Brian Poi Director, Specialized Modeling Brian develops a variety of credit loss, credit origination
More informationErste Bank der oesterreichischen Sparkassen AG
International Structured Finance Europe, Middle East, Africa Pre-Sale Report Erste Bank der oesterreichischen Sparkassen AG Covered Bonds / Austria This pre-sale report addresses the structure and characteristics
More informationCredit Opinion: Banca Sella Holding
Credit Opinion: Banca Sella Holding Global Credit Research - 2 Nov 215 Biella, Italy Ratings Category Outlook Bank Deposits Baseline Credit Assessment Adjusted Baseline Credit Assessment Counterparty Risk
More informationAnnouncement: Moody's Disclosures on Credit Ratings of Barbados, Government of Global Credit Research - 26 Mar 2012
Announcement: Moody's Disclosures on Credit Ratings of Barbados, Government of Global Credit Research - 26 Mar 2012 New York, March 26, 2012 -- The following release represents Moody's Investors Service's
More informationCapital Buffer under Stress Scenarios in Multi-Period Setting
Capital Buffer under Stress Scenarios in Multi-Period Setting 0 Disclaimer The views and materials presented together with omissions and/or errors are solely attributable to the authors / presenters. These
More informationMooDY's. Regulatory Disclosures. Page 1 of5 INVESTORS SERVICE. Identifier: MDY:
Page 1 of5 MooDY's INVESTORS SERVICE Regulatory Disclosures Identifier: MDY: 820956995 Description: SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, CA; Hollywood Redevelopment Project
More informationRating Action: Moody's upgrades Dell's CFR to Ba2; outlook stable
Rating Action: Moody's upgrades Dell's CFR to Ba2; outlook stable Global Credit Research - 04 Feb 2015 Over $11.5 billion of rated debt affected New York, February 04, 2015 -- Moody's Investors Service
More informationU.S. Economic Outlook STEVE COCHRANE, MANAGING DIRECTOR
U.S. Economic Outlook STEVE COCHRANE, MANAGING DIRECTOR Recessions Are Few and Far Between Business cycle status, January 2017 Source: Moody s Analytics Recession At Risk Recovery Expansion Wage Growth
More informationOECD Workshop on Data Collection
OECD Workshop on Data Collection Moody's Infrastructure-relevant Data Sets ANDREW DAVISON, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT 10 MAY, 2017 Marginal Default Rate Moody s PF Bank Loan Default and Recovery Study» Moody's
More informationMoody s RiskCalc External Model Specification:
Moody s RiskCalc External Model Specification: Last Updated: March 27, 2003 Contact Phone South Bend Robert Weiss 574.472.5764 Copyright 2002 by Moody s Investors Service, Inc., 99 Church Street, New York,
More informationRocky Mountain Power Exhibit RMP (BNW-7) Docket No Witness: Bruce N. Williams BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF UTAH
Exhibit RMP (BNW-7) BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF UTAH ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER Exhibit Accompanying Direct Testimony of Bruce N. Williams May 8, 2013 Moody s Investors Service January
More informationNew Challenges in Measuring Risk and Managing Credit Portfolios. Charles Stewart and Jing Zhang IACPM Spring Meeting; 12 May 2011
New Challenges in Measuring Risk and Managing Credit Portfolios Charles Stewart and Jing Zhang Contents» Putting A Sense of Mission Back Into Portfolio Management» Liquidity Risk and CPM: An Overview»
More informationPrivate Firm Summary Report Date: May 2013 (Data as of December 2012)
MAY 2013 U.S. MIDDLE MARKET RISK REPORT Author Bryce Bewley Single Obligor Research Analyst Irina Korablev Single Obligor Research Director Stafford Perkins Single Obligor Research Senior Director Douglas
More informationUsing GCorr Macro for Multi-Period Stress Testing of Credit Portfolios
MARCH 2016 MARCH 2016 MODELING METHODOLOGY Authors Noelle Hong Jimmy Huang Albert Lee Amnon Levy Marc Mitrovic Olcay Ozkanoglu Libor Pospisil Contact Us Americas +1.212.553.1653 clientservices@moodys.com
More informationOlam International Limited
19 DECEMBER 2012 CAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCH EDF TM CASE STUDY Olam International Limited Debt Financed Expansion Drives Default Risk Sharply Higher Moody s Capital Markets Research, Inc. Author Irina Makarova
More information