Big Science: Public investment in large scientific facilities
|
|
- Claud James Harrell
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities LONDON: The Statioery Office Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 22 Jauary 2007 REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 153 Sessio Jauary 2007
2 EXECuTIvE SummARy 1 The Govermet ivests i a rage of large scietific facilities to support ad develop the atio s sciece base. Sice 2000 the Departmet of Trade ad Idustry s (the Departmet) Office of Sciece ad Iovatio has established ew arragemets to co-ordiate plaig for large facilities. The mai compoets are a road map describig large facilities which UK scietists are likely to eed i the ext 10 to 15 years, ad a cetral fud (the Large Facilities Capital Fud) of aroud 100 millio per year to support ivestmets i such facilities by Research Coucils. The Research Coucils are the Arts ad Humaities Research Coucil (AHRC), Biotechology ad Biological Scieces Research Coucil (BBSRC), Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils (), Ecoomic ad Social Research Coucil (ESRC), Egieerig ad Physical Scieces Research Coucil (EPSRC), Medical Research Coucil (MRC), Natural Eviromet Research Coucil (NERC) ad Particle Physics ad Astroomy Research Coucil (PPARC). 2 The Departmet has earmarked 830 millio from the cetral fud to 15 prioritised projects as set out i Figure 1 o page 6. Oce prioritised, these projects progress by presetig sciece ad busiess cases to secure project approval. To date 10 projects have received Departmetal approval. Part 1 of this report evaluates the stregth of curret processes for the idetificatio, appraisal ad prioritisatio of potetial ivestmets i large scietific facilities. Part 2 evaluates performace i deliverig those facilities prioritised for support. Te projects examied i detail i this report are outlied i Figure 2 o pages 8 ad 9. I total they have a capital budget of 1 billio. The study methods are summarised at Appedix 1. 4 BIG SCIENCE: PuBLIC INvESTmENT IN LARGE SCIENTIFIC FACILITIES
3 summary 3 Ultimately, the value for moey to be obtaied from these facilities will deped o the scietific discoveries they help make ad the effective exploitatio of that sciece. Our study cocludes that, though such outcomes will always remai ucertai, the curret arragemets should deliver a sigificat cotributio to the developmet of the atio s scietific ifrastructure. The arragemets iclude the developmet of a commo pla kow as the road map. This is co-ordiated by Research Coucils UK a partership of the research coucils which addresses priorities which cut across scietific disciplies. The road map has allowed scietific priorities to be cosidered i a more systematic way across disciplies. Workig withi HM Treasury s Gree Book guidace o project appraisal ad evaluatio, 1 special attetio ow eeds to be paid to stregtheig the iformatio available to support choices betwee large facility projects. 4 The projects we examied had geerally bee established i accordace with good practice priciples ad stadards as set out i methodology advocated by the Office of Govermet Commerce for maagig projects, called PRINCE2. 2 More cosistet applicatio of that Office s Gateway reviews to the key stages of every project, would esure all teams beefit from wider sources of advice o areas such as project maagemet, project costig ad fudig ad procuremet optios. 5 It is still early to assess fully the portfolio of projects agaist delivery to time ad budget. To date, performace agaist the approved capital budgets suggests some good budget maagemet, for example o the James Cook research ship, but also projects where forecast capital costs already exceed budget eve though still at a early stage. More sigificatly, some project teams have sigificatly uderestimated the likely ruig costs of facilities oce they are delivered. I additio, more work is eeded by Research Coucils to examie the potetial impact of these facilities o the future demad for research fudig, their capacity to support ay ew demad, or the effect of doig so o other areas of activity. Full use of these facilities will deped o research ideas competig successfully for research fudig, through peer review, agaist other calls o limited Research Coucil budgets. As the ew facilities come o stream, the Research Coucils will eed to moitor the impact o the demad for research fudig ad esure lessos are leared for the appraisal of similar facilities i the future. 6 Our detailed coclusios are as follows: Curret arragemets idetify potetial projects over a sesible plaig horizo, allow prioritisatio across the sciece base, ad are deliverig a sigificat programme of ew or replacemet large scietific facilities. The road map approach was pioeered by the Uited Kigdom ad has bee widely commeded ad adopted by other coutries. Prioritisatio ad assessmet strogly reflect the primary policy objective of advacig scietific kowledge, but ecoomic potetial ad possible exploitatio by idustry are less fully aalysed. Curret arragemets cocetrate attetio o availability of capital fudig to build facilities but there are sigificat weakesses i assessig their ogoig costs, ad the impact (ormally i future spedig review periods) of meetig those costs o the balace of Research Coucil fuded activities. At prioritisatio estimates of costs ad assessmets of beefits are prelimiary, yet priorities are ot reviewed if costs or beefits are sigificatly revised as busiess cases are prepared. Opportuities to maximise the overall sciece beefits of the portfolio of projects may thus be missed. Procuremet strategies have bee adapted to the particular circumstaces of each project. Future projects ca beefit from better sharig of experiece ad lessos leared. More attetio eeds to be give to specifyig from the start how the success of idividual projects will be assessed ad measured, drawig o examples from some curret ad existig projects. This should eable a fuller assessmet of value for moey to be made oce facilities are operatioal ad iform appraisal of future potetial projects. Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities 5
4 1 Sixtee large scietific facilities have bee prioritised, of which 15 have received, or bee earmarked, for support1 Project 2 Year of prioritisatio Lead Research Coucil Large Facilities Capital Fud Allocatio 3 ( millio) Research Coucil Capital Fudig 3 ( millio) Other Capital Fudig 3 ( millio) Total Capital Budget 3 ( millio) Status as at autum 2006 Diamod Sychrotro (Phases I ad II) 3, 4 Royal Research Ship James Cook ISIS 2d Target Statio ad first suite of istrumets Before the 2003 road map NERC Commissioig Post delivery commissioig Uder costructio Eergy Recovery Liac Prototype Uder costructio Halley Atarctic Research Statio 5 NERC Cotracts awarded HECToR (High Ed Computig) Muo Ioisatio Coolig Experimet (Phase I) Laboratory of Molecular Biology 2003 road map EPSRC PPARC MRC I egotiatios with preferred bidders Uder costructio Preparig procuremet strategy Istitute for Aimal Health 6 BBSRC Pricipal cotractor appoited Research Complex icludig ifrastructure MRC/ Preparig procuremet strategy Natioal Istitute for Medical Research 1 MRC Budget ad fudig ot yet determied Prioritised i road map Europea X-Ray Free Electro Laser (XFEL) Fudig earmarked Europea High Performace Computig Service 8 Household Pael Survey ISIS 2d Target Statio secod suite of istrumets 2005 road map EPSRC ESRC Fudig earmarked Fudig earmarked Fudig earmarked Oceaographic Research Ship NERC Fudig earmarked Total , ,229.5 Source: Natioal Audit Office aalysis of Research Coucil data NOTES 1 The Office of Sciece ad Iovatio is awaitig developmet of the Natioal Istitute for Medical Research s busiess case before takig a view o earmarkig of fuds to the project from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. 2 The te projects i blue text were prioritised from the 2003 road map or before the 2003 road map ad were examied i detail for this report. 3 The allocatios ad curret budgets are as at autum The figure for the Large Facilities Capital Fud Allocatio for Diamod Phase I ad II, icludes allocatios made directly by the Office of Sciece ad Iovatio to the project as well as others that passed through the Large Facilities Capital Fud. 4 The Diamod Sychrotro is beig built, ad will be operated, by Diamod Light Source Ltd a joit veture with the Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils ad the Wellcome Trust as shareholders. Wellcome are the source of the other capital fudig of 53.6 millio. 5 The figures for Halley iclude the capital fudig for costructig a ew Atarctic statio but exclude the o-capital fudig of 8.5 millio for decommissioig the existig statio Halley V millio for the redevelopmet of the Istitute for Aimal Health is beig provided by the Departmet for the Eviromet, Food ad Rural Affairs. 7 The XFEL project is beig led by Germay which will bear 60 per cet of the costructio cost. It is plaed that other coutries will cotribute the remaider of the fuds with the UK providig 11 per cet of the total o-germa cotributio. 8 The Europea high performace computer project plas to share costs of 192 millio betwee the UK, Frace ad Germay with the balace of aroud 200 millio comig from the Europea Commissio ad idustry. 6 Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities
5 Recommedatios 1 The Office of Sciece ad Iovatio, Research Coucils UK ad idividual Research Coucils should stregthe project appraisal by: esurig the productio of more cosistet estimates of costs ad assessmets of beefits at the iitial poit of prioritisatio; ad esurig that if a project s expected costs or beefits at busiess case are sigificatly differet from those iitially aticipated, its priority is recosidered at the ext available opportuity. 2 The Office of Sciece ad Iovatio, Research Coucils UK ad idividual Research Coucils should give greater attetio to the future fiacial sustaiability of projects. Project proposals should be based o realistic estimates of their ogoig costs, the sources of fudig available to cover those costs ad ay implicatios for other activities fuded by Research Coucils. 3 Research Coucils UK should esure that the road map differetiates projects where there is a choice of locatio from those where o such choice is practically available. Research Coucils UK ad the Office of Sciece ad Iovatio should provide Research Coucils with guidace to aid preparatio of comparisos of differet locatios where a choice is available. 4 To improve the trasparecy of ivestmet decisios, ad provide a better opportuity for scrutiy or challege by scietific ad idustrial stakeholders, Research Coucils UK should publish the outcomes of ad ratioale behid the prioritisatio of proposals as part of the large facilities road map. The ratioale should iclude commetary o the implicatios for the overall research programme of supportig the costructio ad operatio of prioritised projects. 5 The Office of Sciece ad Iovatio, Research Coucils UK ad idividual Research Coucils should: esure a evaluatio of the ature ad scale of the ecoomic impacts derived from buildig ad operatig large scietific facilities, oce they have bee brought ito service, is udertake; ad provide guidace to project teams o assessig ad presetig aticipated ecoomic impacts of large facility proposals. 6 The Sciece ad Techology Facilities Coucil, which will be established i April 2007, should: promote awareess of kowledge ad lessos from plaig, procuremet ad operatio of large scietific facilities by brigig project teams or members together to share experieces ad traiig; develop ad promote a cosistet meas of applyig the sciece performace maagemet framework developed by the Office of Sciece ad Iovatio i 2005 to large facilities plaig ad operatio; ad use its ow skills base ad parterships with exteral providers to improve other Research Coucils access to high-grade project maagemet skills for large projects. 7 The Departmet of Trade ad Idustry should work with Research Coucils to esure the Govermet-wide Gateway review process is applied to large facility projects cosistetly ad with a level of idepedece appropriate to their assessmet of risk. 8 Large facility project teams should build o procuremet lessos from previous projects to secure improvemets i value for moey. Across the portfolio of projects there is scope: to udertake a deeper aalysis of risks so that project teams ca separate those which should be trasferred to a cotractor ad those which should be retaied; to make greater use of icetives to ecourage the timely delivery of key compoets or project milestoes; to exted the use of pai/gai share coditios i cotracts, thereby icreasig the icetives for cotractors to cotai costs; to improve the packagig of work by cosiderig the separatio of those elemets where there is a limited pool of potetial suppliers from less demadig elemets; ad for more active promotio of the work o offer to potetial suppliers who might otherwise be deterred from biddig by the scietific ature of the overall project. Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities 7
6 2 The Natioal Audit Office looked at te projects i detail1 Diamod Sychrotro (Diamod Light Source Ltd) Diamod is a 24 cell, 3 giga electro volt, 3rd geeratio sychrotro light source producig itese x-rays ad shorter wavelegth emissios for research i the biological, physical, evirometal ad egieerig scieces. The sychrotro is beig built by, ad will be operated by, a joit veture compay Diamod Light Source Ltd, partly owed by the Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils ad partly by the Wellcome Trust. Locatio: Harwell Sciece ad Iovatio Campus, Oxfordshire. Budget ad Fudig: millio for Phases I ad II, with millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: Phase I, icludig the first seve beamlies, is due to begi operatios i Jauary 2007 ad Phase II, icludig the ext 15 beamlies, is due to be completed i Royal Research Ship James Cook (Natural Eviromet Research Coucil) The RRS James Cook is a replacemet for the RRS Charles Darwi ad is sposored by the Natural Eviromet Research Coucil. Its users will be marie scietists based, for example, at UK uiversities ad the Research Coucil s Natioal Oceaographic Cetre i Southampto. Locatio: Worldwide but maily Atlatic waters built i Polad ad Norway. Budget ad Fudig: 40 millio, of which 25 millio will come from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: The ship was delivered to the Natioal Oceaographic Cetre i August ISIS Neutro Source, Secod Target Statio (Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils) The ISIS Neutro ad Muo Scatterig Facility is the most powerful eutro producer of its kid i the world. The first phase of the project ivolves supplemetig the existig facilities with a secod target statio ad the istallatio of a first suite of istrumets. It will eable the ISIS sciece programme to attract ew users from the key research areas of soft matter, advaced materials ad bio-sciece. Locatio: Harwell Sciece ad Iovatio Campus, Oxfordshire. Budget ad Fudig: millio for the first phase, with millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: The experimetal programme is set to begi i October Eergy Recovery Liac Prototype (Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils) The Prototype is phase oe of the 4th Geeratio Light Source (4GLS) project. The project will use free electro lasers ad sychrotro radiatio coverig the terahertz to soft X-ray eergy regimes for ultra fast dyamic studies of matter. The first phase has bee desiged to address some of the pricipal techical challeges that would be faced i a full 4GLS facility. Locatio: Daresbury Sciece ad Iovatio Campus, Cheshire. Budget ad Fudig: 21.3 millio, with 10.1 millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: Full operatioal eergy recovery by April Halley VI Atarctic Research Statio (Natural Eviromet Research Coucil) The project ivolves the buildig of the Halley VI Atarctic research statio ad the removal of the existig statio, Halley V. Halley provides a uique locatio for moitorig climate, ozoe ad space weather ad forms a key part of the UK s regioal presece. The primary users of Halley VI will come from withi the British Atarctic Survey, a istitute of NERC. Locatio: Atarctic Ice Shelf. Budget ad Fudig: 34.7 millio for both costructio of Halley VI ( 26.2 millio) ad decommissioig of Halley V (8.5 millio). The Large Facilities Capital Fud is providig 20 millio for costructio. Delivery: Delivery of Halley VI ad decommissioig of Halley V by ed of Atarctic summer. Source: Natioal Audit Office NOTES 1 Project summaries set out the positio as at autum More detail o each of the te projects is provided i Appedix millio for the redevelopmet of the Istitute for Aimal Health is beig provided by the Departmet for Eviromet, Food ad Rural Affairs. 8 Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities
7 High Ed Computig Terascale Resource (HECToR) (Egieerig ad Physical Scieces Research Coucil) HECToR is the ext geeratio of high performace computer. It is the resposibility of Egieerig ad Physical Scieces Research Coucil ad will succeed the CSAR ad HPCx computer services. Users will spa several fields of sciece icludig computatioal chemistry, physics ad climate modellig. Locatio: depedet o tederers proposals. Budget ad Fudig: 65 millio i total; 52 millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: Phase I scheduled to start i September Muo Ioisatio Coolig Experimet (MICE) (Particle Physics ad Astroomy Research Coucil is the lead coucil. The experimet is hosted by the Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils) The Muo Ioisatio Coolig Experimet is a step towards the possible creatio of a eutrio factory which would aid the uderstadig of the properties of eutrios oe of the fudametal particles which make up the uiverse. MICE seeks to demostrate that muo coolig makig a tightly focused muo beam is possible through a process of ioisatio. Locatio: Harwell Sciece ad Iovatio Campus, Oxfordshire. Budget ad Fudig: Phase I of MICE will cost 22.7 millio. Of this, the UK will fud 9.7 millio, of which 7.5 millio will come from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: Phase I is set to be complete by November Istitute for Aimal Health (Biotechology ad Biological Scieces Research Coucil) The Istitute is resposible for research, diagostics ad surveillace o epizootic (fast spreadig) viral diseases of farm aimals. The project ivolves buildig a ew laboratory for the Istitute s staff ad employees of the Virology Departmet of the Veteriary Laboratories Agecy (part of the Departmet for Eviromet, Food ad Rural Affairs). Locatio: Pirbright, Surrey. Budget ad Fudig: Curret approved cost is 121 millio with 31 millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. 2 Delivery: The mai laboratory buildig is scheduled for delivery i December Research Complex (Medical Research Coucil) ad Essetial Ifrastructure (Coucil for the Cetral Laboratory of the Research Coucils) The project will provide a research laboratory, hostel accommodatio ad other ifrastructure to eable scietists to make optimum use of the Diamod Sychrotro, ISIS ad other facilities at Harwell. Locatio: Harwell Sciece ad Iovatio Campus, Oxfordshire. Budget ad Fudig: 33.5 millio for the Complex ad ifrastructure, with 32.4 millio from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: The mai elemet of the ifrastructure programme a ew hostel for visitig scietists was delivered i July The Research Complex is set for completio i Jue Laboratory of Molecular Biology (Medical Research Coucil) The Laboratory of Molecular Biology opeed i 1962 ad is ackowledged as oe of the world s leadig biochemical laboratories with users from the fields of immuology, cacer biology ad biotechology. The LMB project will provide a ew, moder laboratory buildig o the curret hospital campus. Locatio: Addebrooke s Hospital Site, Cambridge. Budget ad Fudig: 155 millio, of which 67 millio will come from the Large Facilities Capital Fud. Delivery: buildig due to be available May Big Sciece: Public ivestmet i large scietific facilities 9
The roll-out of the Jobcentre Plus Office network
Departmet for Work ad Pesios The roll-out of the Jobcetre Plus Office etwork REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 346 Sessio 2007-2008 22 February 2008 SummARy What is the Jobcetre Plus roll-out?
More informationAn Initiative to Minimise the Non- Technical Barriers to DG within Europe
Distributio Europe 2005, Sessio 4.3 Maagig for Growth i Distributed Geeratio A Iitiative to Miimise the No- Techical Barriers to DG withi Europe Richard Kight Rolls-Royce Strategic Research Cetre 2005
More informationOne Community - One Vision - One Direction. Mapping. the. for the City of Greater Sudbury
Oe Commuity - Oe o - Oe Directio Mappig Mappig The Purpose of this Documet This documet, Mappig o, reaffirms City of Greater Sudbury's visio, missio, values ad goals adopted by City Coucil i 2001. It also
More informationBuilding and maintaining river and coastal flood defences in England
Eviromet Agecy Buildig ad maitaiig river ad coastal flood defeces i Eglad LONDON: The Statioery Office 13.50 Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 11 Jue 2007 REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR
More informationA Framework for evaluating the implementation of Private Finance Initiative projects: Volume 1
A Framework for evaluatig the implemetatio of Private Fiace Iitiative projects: Volume 1 REPORT BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE 15 May 2006 For further iformatio about the Natioal Audit Office please cotact:
More informationCollaborative Credit Risk Management Counters Impact of Bad Loans
Cosultig Collaborative Credit Risk Maagemet Couters Impact of Bad Loas Abstract Though credit ratig agecies provide detailed scores uder the Basel II guidelies, baks have the optio to develop their credit
More informationThree Lines of Defense to Enhance Technology Risk Management Maturity
Three Lies of Defese to Ehace Techology Risk Maagemet Maturity Abstract Icreasig reliace o techology has added to high complexity of the risk ladscape, makig risk maagemet ad goverace a huge challege for
More informationModernising Construction
Moderisig Costructio REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 87 Sessio 2000-2001: 11 Jauary 2001 LONDON: The Statioery Office 0.00 Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 8 Jauary 2001 executive
More informationBuilding more affordable homes: Improving the delivery of affordable housing in areas of high demand
Buildig more affordable homes: Improvig the delivery of affordable housig i areas of high demad LONDON: The Statioery Office 11.25 Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 19 December 2005 REPORT
More informationShared services in the Department for Transport and its agencies
Shared services i the Departmet for Trasport ad its agecies REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 481 Sessio 2007-2008 23 May 2008 SummARy Itroductio 1 Shared services have the potetial to release
More informationBuild on Our Expertise. Grow your mortgage business with PNC Partnership Solutions, LLC
Build o Our Expertise Grow your mortgage busiess with PNC Partership Solutios, LLC Partership Solutios 1 To some, ew obstacles. For you, ew opportuities. The mortgage ladscape has chaged i recet years,
More informationInland Flood Defence. REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 299 Session : 15 March LONDON: The Stationery Office 0.
Ilad Flood Defece REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 299 Sessio 2000-2001: 15 March 2001 LONDON: The Statioery Office 0.00 Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 8 March 2001 executive
More informationEU ETS Hearing, European Parliament Xavier Labandeira, FSR Climate (EUI)
EU ETS Hearig, Europea Parliamet Xavier Labadeira, FSR Climate (EUI) 0. Thaks Chairma, MEPs. Thak you very much for ivitig me here today. I am hoored to participate i the work of a Committee whose previous
More informationManaging the waste PFI programme
Departmet for Eviromet, Food ad Rural Affairs Maagig the waste PFI programme REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 66 Sessio 2008-2009 14 Jauary 2009 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public
More informationSecurely managed insurance solutions. Protected Cell, Incorporated Cell and Segregated Account facilities
Securely maaged isurace solutios Protected Cell, Icorporated Cell ad Segregated Accout facilities About us White Rock is a uique ad leadig group of isurace ad reisurace vehicles with operatios i a umber
More informationIII. RESEARCH METHODS. Riau Province becomes the main area in this research on the role of pulp
III. RESEARCH METHODS 3.1 Research Locatio Riau Provice becomes the mai area i this research o the role of pulp ad paper idustry. The decisio o Riau Provice was supported by several facts: 1. The largest
More informationGuide for. Plan Sponsors. Roth 401(k) get retirement right
Uited of Omaha Life Isurace Compay Compaio Life Isurace Compay mutual of omaha retiremet services Roth 401(k) Guide for Pla Sposors MUGC8764_0210 get retiremet right roth 401(k) expads your optios Drive
More informationThe financial analysis for the London Underground Public Private Partnerships
The fiacial aalysis for the Lodo Udergroud Public Private Parterships REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 54 Sessio 2000-2001: 15 December 2000 This report has bee prepared uder Sectio 6 of
More informationBuilding more affordable homes: Improving the delivery of affordable housing in areas of high demand
Buildig more affordable homes: Improvig the delivery of affordable housig i areas of high demad REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL PREPARED JOINTLY BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE AND THE AUDIT
More informationGuide to R&D Tax Benefits for Large Companies
Guide to R&D Tax Beefits for Large Compaies This publicatio has bee prepared as a guide oly ad you should obtai professioal advice specific to your ow circumstaces before actig or refraiig from actig as
More informationREINSURANCE ALLOCATING RISK
6REINSURANCE Reisurace is a risk maagemet tool used by isurers to spread risk ad maage capital. The isurer trasfers some or all of a isurace risk to aother isurer. The isurer trasferrig the risk is called
More informationResearch on the Risk Management Model of Development Finance in China
486 Proceedigs of the 8th Iteratioal Coferece o Iovatio & Maagemet Research o the Ris Maagemet Model of Developmet Fiace i Chia Zou Huixia, Jiag Ligwei Ecoomics ad Maagemet School, Wuha Uiversity, Wuha,
More informationSecurely managed insurance solutions. Protected Cell, Incorporated Cell and Segregated Account facilities
Securely maaged isurace solutios Protected Cell, Icorporated Cell ad Segregated Accout facilities About us White Rock is a uique ad leadig group of isurace ad reisurace vehicles with operatios i a umber
More informationOptimizing of the Investment Structure of the Telecommunication Sector Company
Iteratioal Joural of Ecoomics ad Busiess Admiistratio Vol. 1, No. 2, 2015, pp. 59-70 http://www.aisciece.org/joural/ijeba Optimizig of the Ivestmet Structure of the Telecommuicatio Sector Compay P. N.
More informationThis article is part of a series providing
feature Bryce Millard ad Adrew Machi Characteristics of public sector workers SUMMARY This article presets aalysis of public sector employmet, ad makes comparisos with the private sector, usig data from
More informationInformation Services Group Public Sector
IV&V Assessmet Report - Deliverable IVV2.2 Preseted by: Iformatio Services Group Public Sector September 11, 2018 2018 Iformatio Services Group, Ic. All Rights Reserved Copyright 2018, Iformatio Services
More informationCHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
C A R E E R O P P O R T U N I T Y CHANGING OFFENDERS' LIVES THROUGH INNOVATIVE JOB TRAINING FOR A SAFER CALIFORNIA. CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER CALIFORNIA PRISON INDUSTRY AUTHORITY SALARY: $144,000 $180,000
More informationSecurely managed insurance solutions. White Rock Netherlands Protected Cell Company
Securely maaged isurace solutios White Rock Netherlads Protected Cell Compay About us White Rock is a uique ad leadig group of isurace ad reisurace vehicles with operatios i a umber of key domiciles icludig
More informationExecution Risk Management at Wachovia Yousef Valine
Executio at Wachovia Yousef Valie Head of Istitutioal Group ad COO, Wachovia Corporatio 1 Ageda Why We Care About Executio Our Approach Accomplishmets Aligmet with AMA ad Operatioal Why We Care About Executio
More informationRollover & Superannuation Fund
Rollover & Superauatio Fud A fud that allows you to build your savigs for retiremet i a tax effective eviromet. Product Disclosure Statemet This is a combied Fiacial Services Guide ad Product Disclosure
More informationA Leading Diversified Mid-Tier Miner
A Leadig Diversified Mid-Tier Mier Q3 2017 & TIMOK PEA RESULTS CONFERENCE CALL October 27, 2017 TSX & NYSE MKT NSU 1 Forward Lookig Statemets This Presetatio cotais forward-lookig statemets or forward-lookig
More information1031 Tax-Deferred Exchanges
1031 Tax-Deferred Exchages About the Authors Arold M. Brow Seior Maagig Director, Head of 1031 Tax-Deferred Exchage Services, MB Fiacial Deferred Exchage Corporatio Arold M. Brow is the Seior Maagig Director
More informationKEY INFORMATION DOCUMENT CFD s Generic
KEY INFORMATION DOCUMENT CFD s Geeric KEY INFORMATION DOCUMENT - CFDs Geeric Purpose This documet provides you with key iformatio about this ivestmet product. It is ot marketig material ad it does ot costitute
More informationIndependent Reporting
Idepedet Reportig Competet Perso s Reports Reserves Reports Equity Determiatio Reports Due Diligece Reports rpsgroup.com/eergy Our Experiece RPS has umerous professioally qualified egieers ad geologists
More informationReach higher with all of US
Reach higher with all of US Reach higher with all of US No matter the edeavor, assemblig experieced people with the right tools ehaces your chaces for success. Whe it comes to reachig your fiacial goals,
More informationIntellectual Assets and Value Creation: Synthesis Report
Itellectual Assets ad Value Creatio: Sythesis Report Douglas Lippoldt Directorate for Sciece, Techology ad Idustry The views expressed do ot ecessarily represet those of the OECD or its member coutries.
More informationpolicy Strategic Budgeting Process for Scale-Up of Family Planning Costed Implementation Plans (CIPs) for Family Planning
Strategic Budgetig Process for Scale-Up of Family Plaig Costed Implemetatio Plas (CIPs) for Family Plaig Aie Che Nichole Zlatuich Modibo Maiga Doald Dickerso policy November 2013 1 Ackowledgmets Doors
More informationSubject CT1 Financial Mathematics Core Technical Syllabus
Subject CT1 Fiacial Mathematics Core Techical Syllabus for the 2018 exams 1 Jue 2017 Subject CT1 Fiacial Mathematics Core Techical Aim The aim of the Fiacial Mathematics subject is to provide a groudig
More informationMUTB/MUFG Company Profile
MUTB/MUFG Compay Profile 10 OCTOBER 2017 A member of MUFG, a global fiacial group Who we are Mitsubishi UFJ Trust ad Bakig Corporatio (MUTB) is oe of the largest Trust Baks i Japa. MUTB is a core member
More informationImplementing the Rule on Work Zone Safety and Mobility
23 CFR 630 Subpart J Implemetig the Rule o Work Zoe Safety ad Mobility Notice The Federal Highway Admiistratio provides high-quality iformatio to serve Govermet, idustry, ad the public i a maer that promotes
More informationImproving the PFI tendering process
Improvig the PFI tederig process REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 149 Sessio 2006-2007 8 March 2007 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o behalf of Parliamet. The Comptroller
More information2018 Q1 Earnings Presentation
2018 Q1 Earigs Presetatio May 9, 2018 NYSE: PUMP www.propetroservices.com FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS Certai iformatio icluded i this presetatio costitutes forward-lookig statemets withi the meaig of the
More informationREITInsight. In this month s REIT Insight:
REITIsight Newsletter February 2014 REIT Isight is a mothly market commetary by Resource Real Estate's Global Portfolio Maager, Scott Crowe. It discusses our perspectives o major evets ad treds i real
More informationCost-benefit analysis of plasma technologies
Cost-beefit aalysis of plasma techologies Professor Adra Blumberga, Riga Techical uiversity Part-fiaced by the Europea Uio (Europea Regioal Developmet Fud Cost- beefit aalysis Part-fiaced by the Europea
More information(Zip Code) OR. (State)
Uiform Applicatio for Ivestmet Adviser Registratio Part II - Page 1 Name of Ivestmet Adviser: Stephe Craig Schulmerich Address: (Number ad Street) 10260 SW Greeburg Rd. Ste 00 (State) (City) Portlad (Zip
More informationSecurely managed insurance solutions. Protected Cell, Incorporated Cell and Segregated Account facilities
Securely maaged isurace solutios Protected Cell, Icorporated Cell ad Segregated Accout facilities About us White Rock is a uique ad leadig group of isurace ad reisurace vehicles with operatios i a umber
More informationMethodology on setting the booking prices Project Development and expansion of Bulgartransgaz EAD gas transmission system
Methodology o settig the bookig prices Project Developmet ad expasio of Bulgartrasgaz EAD gas trasmissio system Art.1. The preset Methodology determies the coditios, order, major requiremets ad model of
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE. Project: Reviewing the Capital Adequacy Regulation
TERMS OF REFERENCE Project: Reviewig the Capital Adequacy Regulatio Project Ower: Project Maager: Deputy Project Maagers: Techical Achor (TAN): Mr. Idrit Bak, Bak of Albaia, Supervisio Departmet. Mrs.
More informationAllocation and management of risk in Ministry of Defence PFI projects
Allocatio ad maagemet of risk i Miistry of Defece PFI projects REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 343 Sessio 2007-2008 30 October 2008 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o
More informationThe Independent Police Complaints Commission
The Idepedet Police Complaits Commissio LONDON: The Statioery Office 14.35 Ordered by the House of Commos to be prited o 12 November 2008 REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 1035 Sessio 2007-2008
More informationEstimating and monitoring the costs of building roads in England
departmet for trasport Estimatig ad moitorig the costs of buildig roads i Eglad REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 321 Sessio 26-27 15 March 27 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public
More informationMine Closure Risk Assessment A living process during the operation
Tailigs ad Mie Waste 2017 Baff, Alberta, Caada Mie Closure Risk Assessmet A livig process durig the operatio Cristiá Marambio Golder Associates Closure chroology Chilea reality Gov. 1997 Evirometal basis
More informationQUARTERLY PORTFOLIO REVIEW
QUARTERLY PORTFOLIO REVIEW Quarter 2015 PAYDEN.COM LOS ANGELES BOSTON LONDON PARIS LETTER FROM THE CEO Jauary 2016 Dear Cliet, As ivestmet maagers, we evaluate future treds i the ecoomy ad traslate them
More informationInnovations and Emerging Practices in Local Government 2016 Survey Summary Report of Results
Iovatios ad Emergig Practices i Local Govermet 2016 Survey Summary Report of Results Itroductio The Iovatios ad Emergig Practices i Local Govermet 2016 Survey is part of a ogoig research partership betwee
More informationBUSINESS PLAN IMMUNE TO RISKY SITUATIONS
BUSINESS PLAN IMMUNE TO RISKY SITUATIONS JOANNA STARCZEWSKA, ADVISORY BUSINESS SOLUTIONS MANAGER RISK CENTER OF EXCELLENCE EMEA/AP ATHENS, 13TH OF MARCH 2015 FINANCE CHALLENGES OF MANY FINANCIAL DEPARTMENTS
More informationThe Time Value of Money in Financial Management
The Time Value of Moey i Fiacial Maagemet Muteau Irea Ovidius Uiversity of Costata irea.muteau@yahoo.com Bacula Mariaa Traia Theoretical High School, Costata baculamariaa@yahoo.com Abstract The Time Value
More informationUpdate on PFI debt refinancing and the PFI equity market
Update o PFI debt refiacig ad the PFI equity market REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 14 Sessio 25-26 21 April 26 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o behalf of Parliamet.
More informationREITInsight. In this month s REIT Insight:
REITIsight Newsletter March 2014 REIT Isight is a mothly market commetary by Resource Real Estate's Global Portfolio Maager, Scott Crowe. It discusses our perspectives o major evets ad treds i real estate
More informationPPI Investment Advice
Tailored property advice ad solutios PPI Ivestmet Advice www.ppiivestmetadvice.com.au portfoliopropertyivestmets.com.au/propertycoach AFSL umber 276 895 PPI, chagig the property ivestig ladscape! Everythig
More informationHM REVENUE & CUSTOMS. Management of large business Corporation Tax
HM REVENUE & CUSTOMS Maagemet of large busiess Corporatio Tax REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 614 Sessio 2006-2007 25 July 2007 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o behalf
More informationManaging financial resources to deliver better public services
Maagig fiacial resources to deliver better public services REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 240 Sessio 2007-2008 20 February 2008 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o behalf
More informationThe ROI of Ellie Mae s Encompass All-In-One Mortgage Management Solution
The ROI of Ellie Mae s Ecompass All-I-Oe Mortgage Maagemet Solutio MAY 2017 Legal Disclaimer All iformatio cotaied withi this study is for iformatioal purposes oly. Neither Ellie Mae, Ic. or MarketWise
More informationReview Procedures and Reporting by Peer Reviewer
Review Procedures ad Reportig by Peer Reviewer QUALITY OF REPORTING BY AUDITORS Desired Quality Audit report to cotai a clear writte expressio of opiio o the fiacial iformatio PU should have policies ad
More informationLONG-TERM FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY FRAMEWORK
LONG-TERM FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY FRAMEWORK Prepared by Corporate Fiace ad Corporate Plaig March 2018 Log-Term Fiacial Sustaiability Framework a CONTENTS b b Fiacial Services EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 LONG-TERM
More informationThe Open Cybernetics & Systemics Journal, 2015, 9, Green Construction Economy Research Based on LCC Theory
Sed Orders for Reprits to reprits@bethamsciece.ae The Ope Cyberetics & Systemics Joural, 2015, 9, 2805-2810 2805 Gree Costructio Ecoomy Research Based o LCC Theory Ope Access Zheli Ya * Departmet of Egieerig
More informationGLOBAL ALPHA STRATEGY INSIGHT JULY
STRATEGY INSIGHT JULY 2016 FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY The Marti Currie Global Alpha strategy aims to provide superior log-term returs by ivestig i a highcovictio, diversified portfolio of primarily
More informationCAPITAL PROJECT SCREENING AND SELECTION
CAPITAL PROJECT SCREEIG AD SELECTIO Before studyig the three measures of ivestmet attractiveess, we will review a simple method that is commoly used to scree capital ivestmets. Oe of the primary cocers
More informationFiling VAT and Company Tax returns
HM Reveue & Customs Filig VAT ad Compay Tax returs REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 102 Sessio 2006-2007 13 December 2006 The Natioal Audit Office scrutiises public spedig o behalf of Parliamet.
More informationCollections & Recoveries policy
Collectios & Recoveries policy The purpose of this policy is to set out the actio Ledy takes to ecourage borrowers to repay their loas withi term. This policy also serves to set out the actio Ledy takes
More informationSpeak to the experts before you start any project involving basement construction, engineered foundations, underpinning or structural repairs
ASUCplus represets Specialist Domestic Cotractors i: UNDERPINNING Ad Subsidece Repair T E C H N I Q U E S ENGINEERED FOUNDATION S O L U T I O N S CONSTRUCTION OF RETRO-FIT BASEMENTS Speak to the experts
More informationQUARTERLY PORTFOLIO REVIEW
QUARTERLY PORTFOLIO REVIEW Quarter 2015 PAYDEN.COM LOS ANGELES BOSTON LONDON PARIS LETTER FROM THE CEO Jauary 2016 Dear Cliet, As ivestmet maagers, we evaluate future treds i the ecoomy ad traslate them
More informationliving well in retirement Adjusting Your Annuity Income Your Payment Flexibilities
livig well i retiremet Adjustig Your Auity Icome Your Paymet Flexibilities what s iside 2 TIAA Traditioal auity Icome 4 TIAA ad CREF Variable Auity Icome 7 Choices for Adjustig Your Auity Icome 7 Auity
More informationFinancial Analysis of Public- Private Partnership (PPP) Projects in Highways
Trasport Forum ad Learig Week 2006 Workshop o HDM-4 Fiacial Aalysis of Public- Private Partership (PPP) Projects i Highways Cesar Queiroz Highway Advisor TUDTR World Bak, 24 March 2006 Presetatio Outlie
More informationA Technical Description of the STARS Efficiency Rating System Calculation
A Techical Descriptio of the STARS Efficiecy Ratig System Calculatio The followig is a techical descriptio of the efficiecy ratig calculatio process used by the Office of Superitedet of Public Istructio
More informationCompanies COMPANIES BUILDING ON A SOLID FOUNDATION. 1 Intrust Manx
Compaies COMPANIES BUILDING ON A SOLID FOUNDATION 1 Itrust Max Itrust Max Limited Itrust (Max) Limited is based i Douglas, Isle of Ma. Our objective is to provide a bespoke, flexible, cost-effective, efficiet
More informationHorizon 2020 Policy Support Facility
Horizo 2020 Policy Support Facility Mutual Learig Exercise Ope Sciece, Challege Paper 3: Icetives ad Rewards for Ope Sciece 13 / 09 / 2017 Professor Sabia Leoelli Exeter Cetre for the Study of the Life
More informationStatement of compliance with the UK Corporate Governance Code
Statemet of compliace with the UK Corporate Goverace Code The Board of Directors believes i high stadards of corporate goverace, otwithstadig the Compay s size ad status as a member of the FTSE SmallCap
More informationHM Customs and Excise
Appropriatio Accouts 1999-2000 Volume 16: Class XVI Departmets of the Chacellor of the Exchequer: HM Customs ad Excise Report of the Comptroller ad Auditor Geeral HC 25-XVI 9 February 2001 Cotets Executive
More informationEnhancing Urban Green Space
Office of the deputy prime miister Ehacig Urba Gree Space REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 935 Sessio 2005-2006 2 March 2006 Office of the deputy prime miister Ehacig Urba Gree Space LONDON:
More informationA Strategic Plan for a Growing Community. Five Priorities COUNCIL S PRIORITIES AND INITIATIVES Vision Excellence.
A Strategic Pla for a Growig Commuity COUNCIL S PRIORITIES AND INITIATIVES 2015-2018 Five Priorities Visio Excellece. Excellece i Everythig (Drivig all our commuity relatioships). Missio Sustaiability.
More informationThe Channel Tunnel Rail Link
Departmet of the Eviromet, Trasport ad the Regios The Chael Tuel Rail Lik REPORT BY THE COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL HC 302 Sessio 2000-2001: 28 March 2001 Departmet of the Eviromet, Trasport ad the
More informationEl Dorado County: CED Economic Outlook Placerville, CA December 1, 2010
El Dorado Couty: CED Ecoomic Outlook Placerville, CA December, Robert Eyler, Ph.D. Chair, Ecoomics Departmet Director, Ecoomic Developmet ad Iovatio Accelerator Sooma State Uiversity eyler@sooma.edu Global
More informationSTANFORD UNIVERSITY BUDGET PLAN 2017/18
S TA N F O R D U N I V E R S I T Y STANFORD UNIVERSITY BUDGET PLAN 2017/18 B U D G E T P L A N 2 0 17 / 1 8 Approved: This Budget Pla was approved by the Staford Uiversity Board of Trustees Jue 14 15,
More informationsetting up the business in sage
3 settig up the busiess i sage Chapter itroductio Settig up a computer accoutig program for a busiess or other orgaisatio will take some time, but as log as the correct data is etered i the correct format
More informationStatistics for Economics & Business
Statistics for Ecoomics & Busiess Cofidece Iterval Estimatio Learig Objectives I this chapter, you lear: To costruct ad iterpret cofidece iterval estimates for the mea ad the proportio How to determie
More informationThe Navy Yard Corporate Center Philadelphia, PA
The Navy Yard Corporate Ceter Philadelphia, PA FA S T FAC T S Buildigs rage from 50,000 square feet to 250,000 square feet Master plaed by Robert A.M. Ster Architects Dramatic day-lit atriums uildigs desiged
More informationMineral Products Association. AMPS th Annual Mineral Planning Survey Report
Mieral Products Associatio AMPS 28 7th Aual Mieral Plaig Survey Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The 7th Aual Mieral Plaig Survey, AMPS 28, has bee produced i the cotext of a revised Natioal Plaig Policy Framework
More informationThe Delays in Administering the 2005 Single Payment Scheme in England
DEPTMENT FO ENVIONMENT, FOOD ND UL FFIS, ND UL PYMENTS GENCY The Delays i dmiisterig the 2005 Sigle Paymet Scheme i Eglad EPOT BY THE COMPTOLLE ND UDITO GENEL HC 1631 Sessio 2005-2006 18 October 2006 The
More informationAn Introduction to Employee Share Trust Services
A Itroductio to Employee Share Trust Services Why create a Employee ShareTrust? A public compay ca buy its ow shares ad hold them i treasury. However it has limited optios as to how it ca use those shares.
More informationOsborne Books Update. Financial Statements of Limited Companies Tutorial
Osbore Books Update Fiacial Statemets of Limited Compaies Tutorial Website update otes September 2018 2 f i a c i a l s t a t e m e t s o f l i m i t e d c o m p a i e s I N T R O D U C T I O N The followig
More informationResults Cascade REFRESHER
Results Cascade REFRESHER Documet, Moitor, Evaluate March 27, 2017 SKILLS-BUILDING SESSION Beth Fredrick, Bill & Melida Gates Istitute for Populatio ad Reproductive Health James Mlali, Advace Family Plaig
More informationsummary of cover CONTRACT WORKS INSURANCE
1 SUMMARY OF COVER CONTRACT WORKS summary of cover CONTRACT WORKS INSURANCE This documet details the cover we ca provide for our commercial or church policyholders whe udertakig buildig or reovatio works.
More informationCOSE Health and Wellness Trust 1240 Huron Road, Suite 300 Cleveland, OH
COSE Health ad Welless Trust 1240 Huro Road, Suite 300 Clevelad, OH 44115-1717 2016 Medical Mutual of Ohio Z8116-GHP R10/16 COSE Health ad Welless Trust A self-fuded beefit optio for small group employers
More informationWe learned: $100 cash today is preferred over $100 a year from now
Recap from Last Week Time Value of Moey We leared: $ cash today is preferred over $ a year from ow there is time value of moey i the form of willigess of baks, busiesses, ad people to pay iterest for its
More informationCCH Tax Basic. For more information
CCH Tax Basic CCH Tax Basic is the ideal choice for advisors who eed a cocise source of tax iformatio. With the full rage of Tax Guide mid-level commetary titles, complete with aotated curret tax legislatio,
More informationCHAPTER 2 PRICING OF BONDS
CHAPTER 2 PRICING OF BONDS CHAPTER SUARY This chapter will focus o the time value of moey ad how to calculate the price of a bod. Whe pricig a bod it is ecessary to estimate the expected cash flows ad
More informationEnhancing Service to Large Businesses. The Audit Protocol Real-Time Audit Concurrent Audit Single-Window Focus
Ehacig Service to Large Busiesses The Audit Protocol Real-Time Audit Cocurret Audit Sigle-Widow Focus 5&(5HY Visually impaired persos ca get iformatio o services available to them, ad ca order publicatios
More informationCost Benefit Analysis for Public E-services Investment Projects
Cost Beefit Aalysis for Public E-services Ivestmet Projects DRD. LUCIAN PĂUNA Departmet of Ecoomic Cyberetics Academy of Ecoomic Studies Bucharest, Adria Carstea 75, bl. 35, ap. 39, sector 3 paualucia@yahoo.com
More informationFOUNDATION ACTED COURSE (FAC)
FOUNDATION ACTED COURSE (FAC) What is the Foudatio ActEd Course (FAC)? FAC is desiged to help studets improve their mathematical skills i preparatio for the Core Techical subjects. It is a referece documet
More informationSubject CT5 Contingencies Core Technical. Syllabus. for the 2011 Examinations. The Faculty of Actuaries and Institute of Actuaries.
Subject CT5 Cotigecies Core Techical Syllabus for the 2011 Examiatios 1 Jue 2010 The Faculty of Actuaries ad Istitute of Actuaries Aim The aim of the Cotigecies subject is to provide a groudig i the mathematical
More information