Client Seminar: End game in the Eurozone? slaughter and may 18 September 2012
Eurozone Crisis: End game in the Eurozone? Over the past four years, the EU has responded decisively to the economic and financial crisis. (EU Commission Communication on Banking Union, 12 September 2012) The four eurozone crises Economic crisis Political crisis Debt crisis Banking crisis Where are we now? ECB s 6 September 2012 announcement of unlimited Outright Monetary Transactions secondary market purchases of shorter-dated eurozone sovereign bonds: purchases to be sterilised for countries complying with strict and effective conditionality attached to an EFSF/ESM programme, ideally with IMF involvement pari passu ranking for ECB SLAUGHTER AND MAY 01
German Constitutional Court decision, 12 September 2012: allows establishment of ESM and fiscal pact to proceed requires Germany s obligations to be interpreted as subject to a cap of EUR 190 billion excludes the possibility of ESM borrowing from the ECB Possible scenarios Euro survives intact One or more Member States exit from the eurozone Euro breaks up 02 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
Eurozone outlook: lost decade or breakup? Ernst & Young Eurozone Forecast Marie Diron, Oxford Economics Deleveraging to take years Eurozone: government debt % of GDP 100.0 France: Sectoral indebtedness % of GDP 180 90.0 80.0 160 140 120 Non-financial business 70.0 60.0 50.0 100 80 60 40 Domestic financial sector Consumer 40.0 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 2018 2021 Source : Oxford Economics/Haver Analytics 20 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 Source : Oxford Economics/Haver Analytics Social costs of internal devaluation is high Unemployment rate % 25 20 15 10 Spain Greece Portugal Eurozone 5 UK 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Source : Oxford Economics SLAUGHTER AND MAY 03
What is needed to hold Eurozone together? The Eurozone has ammunition to deal with crisis but needs to act swiftly: ECB even more interventionist September meeting outcome was very positive More bailouts mini bailouts for Spain? Italy? New bailout for Portugal? Renegotiation for Greece Move towards fiscal & banking union Change in macro policy Piecemeal policy action leading to Eurozone s lost decade? Eurozone GDP growth % point difference from historical average (2.3% pa) 0.0-0.5-1.0-1.5-2.0-2.5-3.0 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 Source : Oxford Economics 04 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
Immediate consequences of a breakup Exiting countries Large devaluations of new currencies: +/- 50%? Inflation to rise sharply Interest rates to soar Bank runs and capital controls Risk aversion to lead to slump in share prices, foreign direct investment etc. Immediate consequences of a breakup Residual Eurozone Movement of the euro vis-à-vis the US dollar, sterling etc? Risk aversion to lead to slump in share prices, foreign direct investment etc. Strains on banking sector Steep weakening of export markets Bank exposures to government debt US$ billion, 2012Q1 Germany France UK Japan Spain Italy US Row 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Source : BIS SLAUGHTER AND MAY 05
With breakup risk rising, the longer weak growth prevails Eurozone*: GDP % year 6 4 2 0-2 -4 Forecast Baseline best case breakup scenario -6 Eurozone break-up -8 * Remaining 12 countries -10 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Source : Oxford Economics/Haver Analytics Breakup would send unemployment to yet new highs Eurozone* unemployment % of labour force Spain unemployment % of labour force 16.0 14.0 Eurozone break-up 39 34 Eurozone break-up 12.0 29 10.0 8.0 Baseline 24 19 14 Baseline 6.0 * Remaining 12 countries 4.0 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 Source : Oxford Economics/Haver Analytics 9 4 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 Source : Oxford Economics/Haver Analytics 06 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
Case Study: Greek Exit from the Eurozone May 2010 Bail-out by IMF and Eurozone Austerity results in prolonged recession with 20% fall in GDP while unemployment increases to 24.4% (55% for under 25s) (June 2012) with further increases expected Political/social opposition blocks implementation of many structural reforms July 2011 announcement of second Greek package including PSI Protracted negotiations accompanied by increasing tensions between eurozone member states lead to agreement on 21 February 2012 on a second bail-out Orderly restructuring of privately held Greek bonds representing 74% reduction in NPV (but ECB stands aside) New Government Formed to Renegotiate Bail-Out New Democracy forms a government in coalition with PASOK and Democratic left after 17 June election Mandate to re-negotiate Greece s second EU/IMF bail- out tax cuts suspension of cuts in public sector employment extension of timeframe for compliance EU refuses to agree substantial concessions Things Fall Apart Attempts to implement agreed programme fail Spain seeks enhanced conditions credit line from ESM to activate ECB bond purchases under Outright Monetary Transactions programme EU/IMF freeze further funding of Greece Government unable to pay public sector workers SLAUGHTER AND MAY 07
Violent disorder on streets/army deployed in city centres Government falls as PASOK/Democratic Left withdraw New elections called leading to SYRIZA victory From Default to Eurozone Exit Tsipras seeks fundamental renegotiation of Greek programme involving cancellation of austerity measures and debt forgiveness Refusal by EU leads government to declare moratorium on non-imf loans Mass capital flight leads Greece to impose capital and exchange controls; suspends Schengen membership Greek exit agreed privately by Merkel and Hollande and announced at an emergency EU summit EU adopts a regulation under Article 352 TFEU to give immediate effect to Greek exit Buttressed by treaty amendment under simplified revision procedure to provide retrospective authority for regulation in case of legal challenge The Return of the Drachma Banks close for one week after exit announced (with limited ability to make cash withdrawals) Drachma introduced electronically. Euros may continue to circulate as cash at market rate of exchange. Alternatively, Greece may overprint Euros as new drachma Drachma initially loses 50%-60% of value against Euro Greece seeks new IMF package to cover balance of payments deficit Paris Club negotiations on sovereign debt forgiveness possible (no payments of principal due on private bonds until 2023) 08 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
Redenominating Existing Transactions Greek legislation provides for redenomination of Greek law governed Euro debts, contracts and bank accounts at 1:1 exchange rate Foreign law governed contracts redenominated if contract closely connected with Greece Non-Euro contracts not affected but subject to exchange controls EU refuses to enforce Greek legislation owing to differences of view between member states but does not prohibit recognition either Redenomination Risk for Existing Contracts Greek courts will apply Greek law UK and other EU member states likely to recognise redenomination of contracts governed by Greek law Possible exception if redenomination is in breach of EU Treaties (e.g. if discriminatory) or if violates ECHR Foreign law contracts will be redenominated if lex monetae is the monetary system of Greece How do you identify the lex monetae where a contract requires payment in euros? Will a hard Euro definition help? What other practical steps can I take? If contract is governed by foreign law and lex monetae is not Greek contract will not be redenominated Exchange controls will complicate picture Possible claims under BITs Exchange Control Risk IMF/GATS provide international framework Article 65(1)(b) TFEU allows exchange controls if justified on grounds of public policy or public security Greek courts will enforce controls SLAUGHTER AND MAY 09
An English court will recognise Greek exchange controls if: (A) required to do so by EU law (e.g. regulation implementing Greek exit); (B) transaction is subject to Greek law; or (C) the contract is an exchange contract and Greek exchange controls are consistent with Article VIII 2(b) IMF Agreement UK/US courts take a narrow view on what constitutes an exchange contract. Other EU jurisdictions including France and Germany take a broad approach. Wider Impact of Greek Exit Risk of exit by other periphery states Deposit flight and renewed banking crisis Second credit crunch: increased funding costs and contraction in availability of credit across EU Eurozone recession will be longer and deeper how will ECB respond? Further recapitalisation of EU banks who pays? Will this lead to greater integration or a slow unravelling of the Eurozone? Exit Day 1 action points Exit is announced How robust is your contingency plan? Consider whether to test contingency plan with a dry-run and give thought to Day 1 action points, e.g.: 1. Preliminary communications (internal and external) identify material exposures/arrangements which are likely to be affected (including intra-group arrangements) 10 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
obtain legal documentation consider whether input from advisers is required (legal and/or financial) Analyse key legal issues and risks impact of new legislation, including local and EU legislation scope of new monetary law and capital and exchange controls guidance issued to markets (e.g. by ISDA) Remedies contractual termination rights and remedies impact of redenomination and capital and exchange controls on remedies notices and performance obligations litigation strategy 2. Analyse key legal issues and risks impact of new legislation, including local and EU legislation scope of new monetary law and capital and exchange controls guidance issued to markets (e.g. by ISDA) 3. Remedies contractual termination rights and remedies impact of redenomination and capital and exchange controls on remedies notices and performance obligations litigation strategy SLAUGHTER AND MAY 11
4. Insolvency establish which legal framework/insolvency regime applies based on type of counterparty proprietary or unsecured claim consider notifying insolvency official to reserve rights/remedies consider impact on termination, set-off, netting and collateral consider impact of any moratorium (if applicable) monitor insolvency process and take note of any deadlines/bar dates 5. Strategy consider group strategy and next steps consider applicable decision making-process call board/committee meetings as required consider paper trail 6. Other considerations impact on operations, infrastructure and systems regulatory overlay Risk mitigation Continue to monitor, update and stress-test contingency plan Reduce exposure Consider whether to amend existing contracts and update internal guidelines/policies for new contracts Additional disclosures 12 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
Consider additional protections for new M&A deals more targeted due diligence more bespoke provisions to address completion/valuation risk Potential areas of dispute Contractual Jurisdictional Regulatory International : Bilateral Investment Treaties Challenges to EU/national legislative measures? Insolvency Remedies/DR issues Jurisdictional considerations: Commencement Enforcement Interim relief Substantive relief: Breach Frustration SLAUGHTER AND MAY 13
What s next? Longer-term market reaction as the OMT programme is implemented? Terms of Spanish and Cypriot bailouts to be confirmed Ireland and Portugal to work towards regaining market access Greek austerity package to be renegotiated/official sector debt forgiveness if exit is to be avoided Further steps towards fiscal union (fiscal transfer, eurobills, eurobonds)? Further steps towards banking union (bank resolution framework, single regulator and rule book) More elections (Italy, Germany) and years of continuing uncertainty 14 SLAUGHTER AND MAY
London Brussels Hong Kong Beijing One Bunhill Row Square de Meeûs 40 47th Floor, Jardine House 2903/2905 China World Office 2 London EC1Y 8YY 1000 Brussels One Connaught Place No.1 Jianguomenwai Avenue United Kingdom Belgium Central Beijing 100004 Hong Kong People s Republic of China T +44 (0)20 7600 1200 T +32 (0)2 737 94 00 T +852 2521 0551 T +86 10 5965 0600 F +44 (0)20 7090 5000 F +32 (0)2 737 94 01 F +852 2845 2125 F +86 10 5965 0650 Slaughter and May 2012 This material is for general information only and is not intended to provide legal advice. For further information, please speak to your usual Slaughter and May contact. www.slaughterandmay.com TL126.indd912
www.slaughterandmay.com