arxiv: v1 [q-fin.ec] 11 Jun 2015

Transcription

1 How log-normal is your ountry? An analysis of the statistial distribution of the exported volumes of produts Mario Alberto Annunziata* *Corresponding author: CNR- Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi Area della Riera Roma Tor Vergata, via del Fosso del Cavaliere 100, Roma -Italy Alberto Petri, Giorgio Pontuale, and Andrea Zaaria CNR - Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi Dipartimento di Fisia, Università Sapienza, P.le A. Moro 2, Roma - Italy arxiv: v1 [q-fin.ec] 11 Jun 2015 We have onsidered the statistial distributions of the volumes of the different produst exported by 148 ountries. We have found that the form of these distributions is not unique but heavily depends on the level of development of the nation, as expressed by maroeonomi indiators like GDP, GDP per apita, total export and a reently introdued measure for ountries eonomi omplexity alled fitness. We have identified three major lasses: a) an inomplete log-normal shape, trunated on the left side, for the less developed ountries, b) a omplete log-normal,with a wider range of volumes, for nations haraterized by intermediate eonomy, and ) a strongly asymmetri shape for ountries with a high degree of development. The ranking urves of the exported volumes from eah ountry seldom ross eah other, showing a lear hierarhy of export volumes. Finally, the log-normality hypothesis has been heked for the distributions of all the 148 ountries through different tests, Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Cramér-Von Mises, onfirming that it annot be rejeted only for the ountries of intermediate eonomy.

2 2 I. INTRODUCTION The volume of exported goods is a useful, although partial, proxy for assessing the eonomial status of nations. Statistis of exported volumes from different ountries have been onsidered from several authors under many aspets [9]. Espeially reently, fluxes between exporters and importers have been investigated also from the point of view of omplex networks [10, 21]. Here we have onsidered the gross volume exported in eah different setor by 148 ountries and found that there is no a unique form haraterizing their statistial distribution. Indeed, the shape of the distribution evolves more or less ontinuously aording to the maro indiators haraterizing the development of nations. As suh indiators we have onsidered the GDP, the per apita GDP, the total export, and the fitness, reently introdued in [22]. Continuous evolution in the distribution shape of nations is espeially well shown by the ranking urve of the exported volumes of eah nation, that we disuss in Se. 2. Eah urve seldom rosses the others and a lear hierarhy of ountries is visible. Conerning the densities, disussed in Se. 3, less developed ountries display distribution shapes lose to a log-normal, but trunated on the left side. Distributions widen their range and beome omplete log-normal for intermediate nations, whereas for those with high degree of development they show an asymmetri, skewed shape, shared by many other phenomena [2]. Finally, we have heked the log-normality of the distribution of all the 148 ountries against different tests, inluding Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Cramér-Von Mises, finding not ompletely agreeing results, as reported in Se. 4. In any ase log-normality must be very likely rejeted for the nations having the smallest and the largest eonomies. We shortly disuss some possible origins of these differenes in Se. V. II. THE NATIONAL RANKING OF THE EXPORTED GOODS The UN Comtrade database, as proessed in [11] ontains, among other information, the exported volumes of about 150 ountries aggregated for different produtivity setors. These setors are labeled by numerial odes whose number of digits expresses the level of aggregation, from a few tenths, lassified by two digits, to about five thousands of lasses, lassified by six digits. We adopted the four-digit lassifiation, inluding about twelve hundred lasses, sine in our opinion it represents a good ompromise between produt identifiation and exessive detail. Data are available for many different years. As an instane we shall show here the results for the year 2010, but we have heked that similar results are obtained also for the years between 1995 and We have started our analysis by ranking in desending order the exported volumes of eah setor for eah ountry in the database. Less developed ountries have in general less items than the others, and the ranking urves will be shorter. It is important to remark that, in general, the volume ranking will list produts in different order for eah ountry, sine there is no strit orrespondene between the rank of a volume and the kind of produt, although we shall see that some regularities on the large sale an be deteted. The urves resulting from the ranking are reported in Fig. 1, in thousands of U.S. dollars. It an be seen that they are very well separated, and that those belonging bigger exporters lay above those of smaller exporters in the whole range, so the first important property that emerges is that urves seldom ross eah other: if the top ranked volumes of a given ountry are larger than the top ranked of another, in almost all ases this relation will hold for all the ranked volumes. This unveils a hierarhy, where nations exporting less produts have urves staying below those of nations exporting more produts. In other words there is a diret orrelation between the exported volume of eah produt and their total number. Another important point onerns the appearane of the urves: Not only they lay at different heights in the graph, but also have different shapes. The weak-exporting ountries have urves deaying almost linearly in the lin-log plot of Fig. 1, implying an exponential deay, whereas intermediate ountries follow a slower derease, whih ends with a sudden drop in the ountries with the largest volumes, showing that they export low volumes very seldom, as displayed by the sparsity of point in the tails. Although, as remarked above, the volume ranking does not produe the same order of produts in the different urves, some regularities an be aught on a wide sale. The different olors on the urves of Fig. 1 represent different lasses of produts aording to the two-digit Comtrade lassifiation, reported in the legend together with the olor assigned to eah one. It emerges that lasses of low average tehnologial ontent appear more frequently in the tail of the urves of big exporters, but in the head for the others, where instead the formers display mostly high-teh produts. Of ourse, these qualitative onsiderations require more refined and quantitative analyses in order to draw striter onlusions, and an be subjet of future work.

3 3 FIG. 1. The ranking urves of export volumes for the different ountries. Eah urve starting above another rarely rosses the urves below. The olors indiate where eah produt ategory loates itself in the ranking. Larger exporters learly differentiate in the tails, medium in the head (E are in U.S. k$, log is in base 10). III. THE FREQUENCY HISTOGRAMS OF EXPORTED VOLUMES: HOW ARE THEY LOG-NORMAL? To our knowledge this is the first statistial investigation of the export volumes of a nation aggregated for produt and importer, so we have no information about whih kind of distributions they might be tight to. However, similar studies have been performed in the past for related quantities, speifially for the export flows [10], finding in some ases frequeny distributions lose to a log-normal. Frequently, log-normals with right-handed power-law tails (also alled Pareto-log-normal distributions) have also been found. Log-normal distributions are observed whenever statistis result from the produt of independent, random variables provided of variane. It is not obvious to whih extent the export abilities of a nation an be generated by suh ombinations. However, there have been ases where observations have been suessfully interpreted in terms of suh proesses. A historial example omes from the study on the sientifi produtivity of researhers that the Bell Labs ommissioned to the Nobel laureate Shokley, the inventor of transistor [20]. In his study Shokley disovered that, not only at Bell s, labs have generally a log-normal distribution of sientifi prodution rates, and explained this ourrene in terms of the set of different apabilities that eah researher has to possess and to put together (multiply) in order to produe a sientifi paper or patent. So we an assume, in analogy, that the volume of eah exported good results from joining (multiplying) a ertain set of apabilities of the ountry, that are possessed in a given amount and that hange from good to good. This ombinatorial approah resembles the mirosopi model illustrated in [23]. Thus, after building a histogram for eah ountry, representing the empirial frequenies of exported volumes, we have followed the suggestions oming from the theoretial and empirial arguments exposed above, and fitted the export volume distributions with log-normal distributions. As for the ranking, we have performed a thorough study of the export volumes from 148 ountries adopting the 4- digit Comtrade indexing of goods. In this way the number of produts exported from eah ountry ranges from about 100 to In the present work we report these analyses for the year 2010, but similar results are generally obtained for the other years we have analyzed, from 1995 to For eah ountry we built an histogram representing the empirial probability of exporting a given volume, irrespetive of the orresponding produts. Atually our statistis onsiders the logarithms of the exported volumes and of the resulting frequenies, and it is therefore expeted to be paraboli if our assumption of log-normality is true. A glane at the shapes of the resulting distributions suggests that they an be roughly grouped into three main ategories, that however have no sharp separation. Rather, passing through the statistis of the different ountries, shapes are seen to evolve gradually. In Fig. 2 three instanes of the different emerging shapes are shown. To the first group belong the ountries whose urves lay at bottom in the graph of Fig. 1, like in this ase Ghana. Their export distribution appears quite lose to a log-normal, but with a ut at low values. The mode of the distribution is low (log E < 3, where E is the volume in thousands of dollars), and a omplete log-normal distribution annot show itself.

4 4 FIG. 2. Frequeny distribution of exported volumes (thousands of dollars) for three ountries representative of the different typologies: Ghana (up left), Argentina (right) and China (down). Red solid lines represent log-normal fits (logarithms are in base 10). The seond group is made by the middle-settled ountries. The shape of their export distribution appears very well fitted by the log-normal, with larger parameters than the low-lying nations. The mode of the distribution is higher (3 < log E < 7) and a log-normal distribution is fully displayed with standard deviation around 10 3 < σ < 10 4, like for Argentina in the figure. The world s largest exporters, like China, belong to the last ategory, lying on top in Fig.1, with the largest modes and standard deviations Their distribution is log-normal for the setor involving not too large volumes, but the right hand side of the urve displays a different harater, similar to the above mentioned Pareto-log-normal. When trying to fit them with a log-normal, a bump beomes evident at the right side of the fitting parabola vertex. However, one an easily hek that repeating the fit after dropping the points on the right of the modal value, a log-normal with different parameters an be found that well suits the empirial data, on the left wing, and the bump disappears. So one an onlude that what atually happens is that the distribution hanges shape on the right side. IV. EMPIRICAL EVIDENCES ON COUNTRY S FEATURES IN THE LIGHT OF MACRO INDICATORS The results of the previous setion learly show that the eonomi level of a ountry affets not only the amount of its export but also its volume distribution. This poses the problem of identifying whih fators are responsible for the hange not only in the amount, rather in the harater of the exported volumes. This is a very hard hallenge, and in the present work we limit ourselves to hek if any relation between the distribution shape and maroeonomi

5 indiators exists. For the latter we have made three hoies. Three are very simple and widely employed indexes: the Gross Domesti Produt, the same per apita (GDPp) and the total exported volume. The fourth is a more sophistiated quantity reently introdued with the name of fitness [22]. The definition of this estimator of the ompetitiveness of a nation, that takes into aount the features of the export in a non-linear and self-onsistent way, is briefly realled in the Appendix. It an be useful to note that both GDPp and fitness are intensive (i.e. per apita) quantities, whereas the total export and GDP are extensive. In order to highlight the possible relationship between the indiators and the volume export distributions we have olored eah urve of piture of Fig. 1 on the base of the values that a given indiator assumes for the respetive ountry. In Fig. 3, 3a), 3b) and 3) we report the same ranking urves of Fig. 1, this time giving eah urve a olor, from blue (low values of the maro indiator) to red (high values). Atually, in order to get a more linear distribution of olors, eah of them does not refer to the atual value of the indiator rather to its ranking among the 148 values [6, 24]. All the indiators appear to be signifiantly related to the health status of the eonomy of a ountry, as far as this an be assoiated to how high is the relative position of its export urve in the graph. This happens despite two of them, total export and GDP, are extensive (proportional to the ountry size), and two are intensive (fitness and GDPp). From these plots it is lear that ountries with higher indiators export more produts and in higher volumes, although the GDPp, Fig. 3b, seems not to be as good as the others. It is seen that in this ase some urves on top may have low indiators and vie versa. On the other hand, the pronouned monotoniity of the olor gradient for the other indiators, from low values (blue) to high values (red), suggests that these should be more orrelated to observed hierarhy in the ountries distributions. If one sorts all the density urves disussed in Se. III aording, for instane, to the fitness of the orresponding nation, one goes in asending order from the more trunated-log-normal distributions to the more skewed Pareto-log-normal, passing through the fully log-normal ones. This is well shown in the 3-d plot displayed in Fig. 4 where all the ountries export distributions are shown, olored aording to the fitness. A quantitative analysis ould get rid of whih indiator is really more orrelated with the position of the orresponding ranking urves with respet to the others, and will be subjet of a forthoming work. 5 V. STATISTICAL TESTS FOR THE DISTRIBUTIONS The frequeny histograms of the exported volumes disussed in the previous setions offer a good glimpse on the differenes haraterizing ountries of different eonomies. However, binning data in histograms always suffers from some degree of arbitrariness with respet to the number of adopted bins. In order to assess the reliability of the log-normal assumption on the base of statistial tests, we have thus onsidered the empirial umulative distributions of the exported volumes. They are stritly related to the ranking urves, disussed in Se. 2, from whih they an be obtained in a straightforward way by swithing the axes and ranking the N volumes of the given ountry in asending order from 1/N to 1. Thus the shape of the urves remains the same, although the sales hange. In order to hek the goodness of log-normal fits, we performed Cramér-von Mises (CvM) and Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) [8] tests for the umulative distributions of the exported volumes under the hypothesis of log-normality. For the CvM test the values of the resulting statistis are suh that even with a signifiane as low as α = 1%, lognormality annot be rejeted only for 26 ountries out of 148. This result is reported graphially in Fig. 5a), where the ountries are ordered following the ranking indued by the fitness. It is seen that log-normality an be aepted in the full-log-normal region (medium fitness), while for distributions belonging to trunated-log-normal (low fitness) and Pareto-log-normal regions (high fitness) the log-normal hypothesis has to be rejeted. The trend of CvM-sore is worth notie, beause it definitely shows how log-normal a ountry is : it dereases in the trunated-log-normal region, has a minimum in the full-log-normal region and then inreases in the Pareto-log-normal region. The KS test produes a similar qualitative behavior, shown in Fig. 5b). However, the level needed to rejet a signifiant number of ountries is sensibly higher, 5% and despite this, the number remains sensibly larger than with the CvM test. The two tests give thus different aeptanes for the log-normal hypothesis, but there is in any ase a set of ountries of intermediate ranking whose volume statistis an reasonably be assumed log-normal. VI. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND PERSPECTIVES The statistis of the export volumes of ountries, aggregated in produt ategories, has shown distintive features that depend strongly on the values of suh maroeonomi indiators as national GDP, GDPp, total export volume, or fitness. Speifially, log-normal urves seem to fit well the distributions for middle and low-developed ountries, but with a laking tail at low volumes for the latter. Countries with large export display a skewed urve, with a

6 FIG. 3. Ranking urves of exported volumes for eah ountry, olored in eah pitures aording to the value of a different indiator. From top to bottom: fitness, total export, GDPp, and GDP. Blue orresponds to the lowest values, red to the highest. 6

7 7 FIG. 4. A three-dimensional plot of the export distributions for the different ountries, ordered by the fitness (blue: low fitness, red: high fitness). By inreasing the fitness, shape goes from a trunated-log-normal to the fully-log-normal, ending with Pareto-log-normal (logarithms are in base 10). tail shorter at high volumes than at low ones. Their shape resembles other statisti sometimes denominated Pareto log-normal. The log-normal shape haraterizing middle eonomy ountries points to some multipliative proess behind the prodution, and exportation, of goods. As skethed above, this ould be related to the apabilities needed to aomplish the goal. Trunation of small export volumes in less developed ountries suggests the existene of a minimal threshold to generate effetive export. Several mehanisms have been proposed to explain skewed Pareto log-normal shapes, as well as different approahes for their preise mathematial haraterization [2, 12, 15, 19]. We just wish to point out that, assuming a genuine multipliative proess at the origin of the observed log-normalities, there an be different auses making them to deviate from the normal onvergene and for the on-set of asymmetries at large volumes. The simplest, at least from the mathematial point of view, is the presene of orrelations among the variables ontributing to the multipliative proess. This an give rise to shapes different from the (log) normal with rih and interesting properties [3, 14, 16]. On the other hand, the steepest deay of the tails at high volume ould signal the existene of upper limits to export, due to the buyers demand and resoures in the world trade. Hene a full log-normal distribution annot develop and, on the right of the maximum, volumes fall rapidly. We are onfident that further investigation an relate more quantitatively the eonomi indiators to the distribution shape and the relative ountry positioning. This ould allow to make assessments about the different eonomies, still more if arried on together with studies on the time evolution of the urve shapes and parameters. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are grateful to A. Tahella for supplying proessed Comtrade data, and to M. Cristelli and E. Pugliese for stimulating disussions. A.P. and A.Z. also thank the European projet FET-Open GROWTHCOM (grant num ) and the Italian PNR projet CRISIS-Lab. APPENDIX: A PRIMER ON THE FITNESS AND COMPLEXITY ALGORITHM In a reent paper, Tahella et al. [22] proposed a novel approah to measure some intangible properties of ountries and of the produts they export. Their base is onstituted by the ideas of Hidalgo and Hausmann [13] the total exported volume or tehh, who introdued a linear, oupled algorithm to measure suh properties starting from the export basket of ountries. Tahella et al. prosed an improved, non linear algorithm, whose new features are motivated by empirial [4] and eonomial [6] evidenes. We refer to these referenes for an exhaustive presentation of suh approah, whih is beyond the sope of the present ontribution. The input data is given by the binary export

8 8 FIG. 5. Top: Results of Crámer-von Mises statistis applied to the umulative distributions of the export of ountries, under the hypothesis of log-normality. Green line: rejetion threshold orresponding to α = 1%, red dashed line: a paraboli fit of the statistis. Bottom: results of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistis. Setting aeptane at 5% log-normal hypothesis must be rejeted for the points below the red line. The blue line is a paraboli fit of the obtained probability values matrix M, whose elements M p are equal to 1 if ountry has a Revealed Comparative Advantage [1] in exporting the produt p. The algorithm alulates, by means of two oupled iterative equations, two variables whih are proxies for ountries ompetitiveness, the Fitness F, and produts omplexity, Q, as a funtion of M and the other variable. At eah step both variables are normalized in suh a way that their sum is equal to the total number of ountries and produts in the database, whih orrespond to the rows and the olumns of the matrix M, respetively. In formulas, the algorithm to alulate the fitness F of the ountry and the omplexity Q p of the produt p an be written in

9 9 the following form: F = p M p Q (n 1) p (1) Q p = 1 M 1 p F (n 1) (2) F = < F F > (3) Q p = < Q p Q p > p (4) where the normalization of the intermediate tilded variables is made as a seond step by dividing eah by the respetive averages, < F > 1 C F < Q p > 1 P p Q p F and Q p where C and P are the total number of ountries and produts in the database, respetively, and n is the iteration index. The onvergene properties of suh algorithm are not trivial and have been studied in [17]. Reent appliations of suh algorithm inludes both the study speifi geographial areas, suh as the Netherlands [24] and the Subsaharan ountries [5], and general features of growth and development [7, 18]. [1] B. Balassa. Trade liberalisation and revealed omparative advantage. The Manhester Shool, 33(2):99 123, [2] M. Bee, M. Riaboni, and S. Shiavo. Pareto versus lognormal: A maximum entropy test. Phys. Rev. E, 84:026104, Aug doi: /physreve URL [3] S. T. Bramwell, T. Fennell, P. C. W. Holdsworth, and B. Portelli. Universal flutuations of the danube water level: A link with turbulene, ritiality and ompany growth. EPL (Europhysis Letters), 57(3):310, URL org/ /57/i=3/a=310. [4] G. Caldarelli, M. Cristelli, A. Gabrielli, L. Pietronero, A. Sala, and A. Tahella. A network analysis of ountries export flows: Firm grounds for the building bloks of the eonomy. PLoS ONE, 7(10):e47278, [5] M. Cristelli, A. Tahella, A. Zaaria, and L. Pietronero. Growth senarios for sub-saharan ountries in the framework of eonomi omplexity. [6] M. Cristelli, A. Gabrielli, A. Tahella, G. Caldarelli, and L. Pietronero. Measuring the intangibles: A metris for the eonomi omplexity of ountries and produts. PLoS ONE, (8):e70726, [7] M. Cristelli, A. Tahella, and L. Pietronero. The heterogeneous dynamis of eonomi omplexity. PLoS ONE, 10(2): e , [8] D. A. Darling. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Cramer-von Mises Tests. The Annals of Mathematial Statistis, 28(4): , ISSN doi: /aoms/ [9] W. Easterly, A. Reshef, and J. Shwenkenberg. The power of exports. The World Bank Poliy Researh Working Paper, 5081, Otober [10] G. Fagiolo. The international-trade network: gravity equations and topologial properties. Journal of Eonomi Interation and Coordination, 5(1):1 25, ISSN X. doi: /s y. URL s y. [11] G. Gaulier and S. Zignago. Bai: International trade database at the produt-level. Centre d Etudes Prospetives et d Informations Internationales, [12] E. Helpman, M. J. Melitz, and S. R. Yeaple. Export versus fdi. Tehnial report, National Bureau of Eonomi Researh, [13] C. Hidalgo and R. Hausmann. The building bloks of eonomi omplexity. Proeedings of the National Aademy of Sienes, 106: , [14] I. M. Jánosi and J. A. C. Gallas. Growth of ompanies and water-level flutuations of the river danube. Physia A, 271: , 1999.

10 [15] M. J. Melitz. The impat of trade on intra-industry realloations and aggregate industry produtivity. Eonometria, 71 (6): , [16] A. Petri, A. Baldassarri, F. Dalton, G. Pontuale, L. Pietronero, and S. Zapperi. Stohasti dynamis of a sheared granular medium. Europhysis Journal B, 64: , [17] E. Pugliese, A. Zaaria, and L. Pietronero. On the onvergene of the fitness-omplexity algorithm. arxiv preprint arxiv: , [18] E. Pugliese, G. L. Chiarotti, A. Zaaria, and L. Pietronero. Eonomi omplexity as a determinant of the industrialization of ountries: the ase of India, [19] W. J. Reed and M. Jorgensen. The double pareto-lognormal distribution a new parametri model for size distributions. Communiations in statistis: Theory and Methods, 33: , [20] W. Shokley. On the Statistis of Individual Variations of Produtivity in Researh Laboratories. Proeedings of the IRE, 45: , ISSN doi: /jrproc [21] T. Squartini, G. Fagiolo, and D. Garlashelli. Randomizing world trade. ii. a weighted network analysis. Phys. Rev. E, 84: , Ot doi: /physreve URL [22] A. Tahella, M. Cristelli, G. Caldarelli, A. Gabrielli, and L. Pietronero. A new metris for ountries fitness and produts omplexity. Sientifi Reports, (2):723, [23] A. Zaaria, M. Cristelli, A. Tahella, and L. Pietronero. How the taxonomy of produts drives the eonomi development of ountries. PLoS ONE, 9(12):e113770, [24] A. Zaaria, M. Cristelli, R. Kupers, A. Tahella, and L. Pietronero. A ase study for a new metris for eonomi omplexity: The Netherlands. Journal of Eonomi Interation and Coordination, pages 1 19,