It s Time: Ditch your Business Rules
|
|
- Heather Kelley
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Larry Goldberg and Barbara von Halle Larry was at the headquarters of one of the largest industrial organizations in the U.S., and his task, on behalf of a business rules technology vendor, was to understand why this client had decided to replace his client s technology with a package. The decision could not have been taken lightly this was a custom built order processing system, a huge system by any measure. It had been built but ten years previously at a cost that ran into eight figures. By the vendor s count it contained over 20,000 rules. Why would the client take the extreme case of replacing the system that they themselves, only a short time previously, had spoken about with high praise? Turns out, the problem lay in the rules! We have lost track of our rules, the client explained. The business doesn t feel able to manage the rules in the system. Larry understood immediately, and they really didn t have to spend the rest of the day giving us the details of the problem. We have other clients who discover that managing 1,500 business rules is a daunting task. Heck, one client with but 600 business rules cried Uncle! The hard, hard truth is that managing business rules is very, very difficult. Period. Now we know that we preach the value of business rules, and we glibly talk about them as levers that management can use to manage their business. We plead as guilty as others because it certainly seemed to make good sense. But one should only pull a lever that is appropriately labeled, and when the consequences of pulling that lever are well understood! Here is the reality: the business rules projects that have worked well, that have inspired our commitment to the discipline, and which we can point to as delivering on the promise of business rules, are those where the business rules have been abstracted into a form that is recognizable, and at a level of granularity that is manageable by the business people. One of the most successful business rules project in Larry s professional experience was implemented some 14 years ago at a financial services firm in the Midwest. Their system was years ahead of its time, and it transformed the company strategically, helping it become a leader in its primary market. But when we asked them if they would present at a business rules event, they were mystified. But we don t do anything with business rules was the response. But, of course, they did they were simply not aware of the underlying business rules engine that drove the technology. Their business rules were abstracted into, and exposed as, artifacts that had a greater granularity and a more meaningful context in their business than individual business rules. Consequently, they were managing far fewer that the 26,000 rules that we counted in their system. In fact, they viewed their system through the prism of what they called bricks about 100 or so sets of logic that were grouped in ways that made sense to the business. These bricks today would be called decision services, each having all the characteristics that define a well architected web service. These guys were ahead of their time, but their approach was one of the several that served as inspirations for Decision Management (DM), a new discipline that promises to deliver what we haven t been able to achieve with business rules. Of course, we say, Ditch your business rules, with our tongues firmly in our cheeks. But today we no longer ask people to think about managing individual business rules. We understand that managing at that fine level of granularity is challenging because of the multiplicity of the number of rules across the enterprise. Individual business rules are seldom of much business value by themselves without considering many other related business rules that almost certainly impact them. We also believe that the days of organizing business rules into natural language sentences are over, because they have proven to be unmanageable in that form. Business rules, sans context and structure, are fairly meaningless or of little management value by themselves. What do we mean by context and structure? 1
2 Let s start with context. By this we mean the context of the business decisions within which the business rules reside. Take the case of a business rule related to determining the preferred status of a customer. It would seem to be simple to express such a rule in a natural language, particularly with the well accepted forms of rule grammar that we have today. However, the fact is that the determination of customer status can be very complex, involving not one but perhaps tens of business rules, even in some cases hundreds of rules. Let s take a naïve example. A business rule may say: A customer is a preferred customer only if all the following are true: Customer s account is currently in good standing Customer has accumulated purchases in excess of $5,000 in the prior 12 month period This sounds pretty straightforward. Until you learn, as you dig deeper, that actually the customer s preferred status hinges on several more unrelated items (the grammar we are using in this example does not indicate, with the use of the words only if, that these things being true, then the customer is preferred; it merely means that if these things are not true, then the customer cannot be preferred). It may turn out that there are a slew of marketing rules to which the customer may have to comply to be considered preferred, and then there may also be a geographic issue that relates to preferred customers. There may also be business rules in several other areas that touch upon the customer s preferred status, such as supplier agreements, long term commitments from the customer, and so on. Well, the problem may be solved giving the rule context by gathering into one group all the business rules that relate to the customer being preferred. You could call that group a rule set, or, better yet, a business decision, and then you can manage that business decision as a single unit. So a business decision is a context for business rules, enabling you to see the business rules with all business rules that together reach a single decision. So much for context. What about structure? Well, just putting the business rules into sets that we conveniently call business decisions does not solve the problem of complexity. Turns out that some of the rules used to determine validity for the preferred program are also used to determine the amount of money that may be provided for co-op marketing or other purposes. So many (perhaps even most) business rules may belong to several sets (or business decisions). What happens when the business rule needs to change in one business decision for a particular business purpose, what is the impact on the business in the other sets in which the business rule is used? When business rules reach into the thousands then the complexities of this interwoven logic becomes fearsome, and problems abound. How do you test the business rules for completeness? How can you be sure that there are no duplicates? How can you make sure that there are no rules that contradict one another? The answer to that problem lies in structure. Think about the problem of data. Unstructured data is chaotic and difficult to use. So it needs to be structured. Everybody with very few exceptions uses a specific model to organize data: this is called the Relational Model. This model enables the data to be normalized that is, they are reduced to more desirable structures and soon enough it becomes easier to access, to understand, to manage. The Relational Model has become universal because it organizes the data based on the inherent structure of the data, so everybody pretty much understands it, and feels confident in accessing the data in such a structure. So the answer to the problems with business rules lies in a model for business logic that has a structure that is as elegant, as simple, as the Relational Model is for data. A model that will organize the logic, based on the inherent structure of the logic itself, into structures that are normalized and stable, and that make sense to the business person. 2
3 Such is the purpose of the Decision Model, a model proposed by us in our new book called The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework Linking Business and Technology. We believe that the model meets the goal we set out to achieve, and will enable business to manage the large aggregates of business rules or, as we prefer to call it, business logic that inherently exist in organizations today but are unstructured and unmanaged. The model creates both a context that is, it combines a set of business logic into groupings that make business sense and a structure that is normalized and stable over time. One significant value of the model is that it can be represented visually, promoting a shared understanding of the logic just as a process model promotes shared understanding between all stakeholders. Look at the diagram in Figure 1. Determine Policy Tier Within Bounds (P2, P3) Override (P1), (P3) Policy Tier Within Bounds Policy Discount (P2) Policy Tier(P1)(P2) Override Insured Major Ownership Change (P2) Insured Major Location Change (P1) Policy Annual Premium (P3) Policy Discontinued Agent (P4) Policy Manual Flag (P5) Policy Discount Policy Grade (P1) Package Grade (P1) Package Discount (P1) Location State Category (P1) Insured Major Ownership Change Insured Minority Stockholder(P2) Insured Majority Stockholder(P3) Insured Board Change(P1) Insured CEO Change (P1)(P3) Insured Major Location Change Insured Location Zip 5 (P1) Insured Location Occupied Square Footage (P2) Insured Location Construction (P3) Figure 1. Sample Decision Model Adapted from: The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework Linking Business and Technology, von Halle & Goldberg, 2009 Auerbach Publications/Taylor & Francis LLC. Reprinted with the permission of the Publisher. This diagram gives you the top level view of the Decision Model. A Decision Model diagram contains only two kinds of shapes. One is the octagon representing a business decision, and the other represents a Rule Family. The name of a Rule Family is always the name of its conclusion fact type and always appears above the solid line within the Rule Family shape. You can see from the business decision shape in Figure 1 that this is a model of Determine. This business decision is important to the success of the insurance company client: the higher the percentage of policies that they can renew automatically, the less out cost, and the better the service they can provide their customers. However, the quality of underwriting can t be compromised. So in order to balance these considerations, you may use the Decision Model to manage this business decision. Here you see a very important characteristic of a business decision: it is, we say, a conclusion that is based upon fact, and which the business is interested in managing. 3
4 Policy Tier Within Bounds Policy Tier(P1)(P2) Policy Discount (P2) Policy Discount Policy Grade (P1) Package Grade (P1) Policy Discount (P1) State Category (P1) Determine Policy Tier Within Bounds (P2, P3) Manual Policy Override (P1) Major Ownership Change Minority Stockholder(P3)(P4) Majority Stockholder(P2) Board Change(P1) CEO Change (P1)(P3) Manual Policy Override Major Ownership Change (P2) Major Location Change (P1) Annual Premium (P3) Discontinued Agent (P4) Manual Flag (P5).. (P6) Major Location Change Zip 5 (P1) Occupied Square Footage (P2) Construction (P3) BPTrends January 2010 A Decision Model always begins with the business decision, which, in turn, always connects to one Rule Family, called a Decision Rule Family. The Decision Rule Family has a conclusion fact type (or term) matching the business decision. Consequently, the Decision Rule Family in Figure 1 is called, which is its conclusion fact type. A Rule Family always contains only one conclusion fact type, which is why a Rule Family has only one name. However, a Rule Family also contains condition fact types leading to the conclusion. These always appear below the solid line. So, the Rule Family for Policy Tier Within Bounds contains two condition fact types: Policy Tier and Policy Discount. This means that the business logic in this Rule Family tests these two fact types to determine a value for its conclusion fact type, Policy Tier Within Bounds. Note that Policy Discount appears between the solid and dotted line, but Policy Tier appears below the dotted line. This is important. The values for Policy Tier are simply available as raw data from a database or web page. So this fact type appears below the dotted line. Yet, the values for Policy Discount are determined by other business logic. Therefore, this condition fact type relates to another Rule Family having this fact type as its conclusion fact type. So, Figure 3 contains a Rule Family whose conclusion fact type is Policy Discount, and there is a line connecting these Rule Families. This connection is an inferential relationship. It means the Rule Family called Policy Tier Within Bounds is dependent on the Rule Family called Policy Discount. Because the Decision Model diagram reveals only the inherent structure of its business logic, not its details, we need a way to expose the details. Policy Tier Within Bounds (P2, P3) Policy Manual Override (P1) Figure 2. Rule Family Structures in the Decision Model Source: The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework Linking Business and Technology, von Halle & Goldberg, 2009 Auerbach Publications/Taylor & Francis LLC. Reprinted with the permission of the Publisher. 4
5 The details are in the Rule Family table and consist of rows conforming to its condition and conclusion columns. Figure 2 shows two inferentially related Rule Families and their Rule Family tables. The Rule Family for Policy Tier Within Bounds has two condition fact types, each of which has its own column in the Rule Family table under conditions. The conclusion fact type has its own column under conclusion. The Rule Family table is populated with combinations of conditions that lead to all the permutations for reaching conclusion values. You can add, delete, or update rows without making changes to the Decision Model structure. You can also guess at the Decision Model structure before knowing all business logic. This is extremely valuable for agile projects. At first glance, a Rule Family looks like a conventional decision table, but, in fact, it is a highly normalized structure that rigorously complies with the 15 Decision Model principles to ensure that it is stable and contains logic that has both inferential and business integrity. The two sample Rule Families in Figure 2 are good examples that you can use to explore this briefly. If you look at the Decision Rule Family for, you can read the business logic statement in the first row as If (or when) the policy manual override is yes, then the renewal method is manual. Or you could read row three in the Rule Family for Policy Tier Within Bounds to say, If the policy tier is less than or equal to 2, and the policy discount is greater than 20, then the Policy Tier is not within bounds. It may be interesting for readers experienced in business rules (and perhaps even or especially! those that are not) to analyze the Rule Family for Policy Tier Within Bounds shown in Figure 2. We hope that only a brief analysis should show you that this Rule Family is incomplete and is clearly missing rows. The value of the principles of the Decision Model is that they give you a set of tools to analyze the logic of the Rule Families to a much greater degree than this simple example. They allow you to analyze populated Rule Families for completeness, inferential integrity, and to normalize them to the three levels of normalization. This ensures that the structures are Predictable: Two different analysts sent to gather business rules from a business group arrive at an identical set of business rule structures, and two different programmers sent to implement those rules into code would arrive at identical code structures; Stable and Normalized: A particular business rule belongs in only one place and in the right place in the decision model structure, ensuring the integrity of the Decision Model; Maintainable: If the business rules were changed, or some business rules were added to (or removed from) a given decision, changes are often made as simply as data rows are added to (or removed from) a data table; Aligned with Business: Correlated to business motivations and metrics. The benefits that flow from using the Decision Model to separate the business rules, and manage them, are very significant. They extend into many areas of management and information technology practice, such as BPM, decision management, architecture, and software development. Yes, it is true that managing your business rules is difficult but managing your decisions is practical, and could be very rewarding for both business and IT. To discover more details on the Decision Model, you can download a primer that contains the essential details on the model at To explore the Decision Model in full, including its role in the many disciplines it impacts, and to get a start in methodologies that support it, we recommend that you read the book, also obtainable from that site. Portions of this article are drawn from the book, The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework Linking Business and Technology, von Halle & Goldberg, 2009 Auerbach 5
6 Publications/Taylor & Francis, LLC. This article consists, in part, of abstracts from the book; directly quoted passages, diagrams, and tables are cited, and are copyright 2009 Auerbach Publications/Taylor & Francis LLC. Reprinted with the permission of the Publisher 6
Introducing The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework
Introducing The Decision Model: A Business Logic Framework Larry Goldberg, Managing Partner January, 2012 2012 Knowledge Partners International LLC www.kpiusa.com www.thedecisionmodel.com Timeline Barbara
More informationSymposium) Larry Goldberg & Barbara von Halle. Managing Partners, Knowledge Partners International, LLC
Linking Business and Technology (MIT Information Quality Industry Symposium) Larry Goldberg & Barbara von Halle Managing Partners, Knowledge Partners International, LLC lgoldberg@kpiusa.com BvonHalle@kpiusa.com
More informationDesigning a Retirement Portfolio That s Just Right For You
Designing a Retirement Portfolio That s Just Right For You July 10, 2015 by Chuck Carnevale of F.A.S.T. Graphs Introduction No one knows your own personal financial situation better than you do. Every
More informationEffective Corporate Budgeting
Effective Corporate Budgeting in 8 Easy Steps This ebook will offer 8 easy and easy and proven steps for improving your corporate budgeting and planning process. You will see that by making a few small
More informationSending Supplements. (c) Copyright Roof Sales Mastery, LLC - All Rights Reserved.
Sending Supplements Sending Supplements Where, How, & Why You ve built your revised Xactimate and are ready to send it over to the insurance company. Now we ll Where to send your supplement saved and documented
More informationUnderstanding Pension Auto Enrolment. Essentials Guide
Understanding Pension Auto Enrolment Essentials Guide Contents Introduction 3 Employer responsibilities in a nutshell 4 How can KPMG Small Business Accounting help you? 5 Staging date checker and tracking
More informationA Layman s Guide to Earned Value
A Layman s Guide to Earned Value A TenStep White Paper Contact us at info@tenstep.com TenStep, Inc. 2363 St. Davids Square Kennesaw, GA. 30152 877.536.8434 770.795.9097 If you are a project manager, you
More informationConversations: Jeffrey Owens and Rick McDonell
Volume 75, Number 9 September 1, 2014 Conversations: Jeffrey Owens and Rick McDonell Reprinted from Tax Notes Int l, September 1, 2014, p. 763 Conversations: Jeffrey Owens and Rick McDonell Jeffrey Owens
More informationCommuniqué. A Practice Management Newsletter. July Insurance Design Professional
Communiqué A Practice Management Newsletter Insurance Design Professional July 2015 In this issue: Fee Claims: A Cautionary Tale How Do You Measure Success? Communiqué July 2015 2 Fee Claims: A Cautionary
More informationSAMURAI SCROOGE: IMPORTANT CONCEPTS
SAMURAI SCROOGE: IMPORTANT CONCEPTS CONTENTS 1. Trend vs. swing trading 2. Mechanical vs. discretionary trading 3. News 4. Drawdowns 5. Money management 6. Letting the system do the work 7. Trade journal
More informationMind the Retail Mortgage Gap. To Close More Loans, First Close the Gap
Mind the Retail Mortgage Gap To Close More Loans, First Close the Gap Mind the Retail Mortgage Gap Table of Contents Executive Summary Shifting Lending Landscape............. 2 An Industry Riddled with
More informationIntroduction To The Income Statement
Introduction To The Income Statement This is the downloaded transcript of the video presentation for this topic. More downloads and videos are available at The Kaplan Group Commercial Collection Agency
More informationTrue Program Costs: Program Budgets and Allocations
True Program Costs: Program Budgets and Allocations While the long-term goal for nonprofits is not to return profits to shareholders, we all know that nonprofits are business entities that need to maintain
More informationAccounting Part 1 STUDY UNIT. Accounting Part 1 STUDY UNIT
Accounting Part 1 STUDY UNIT Accounting Part 1 STUDY UNIT 06100202 Study Unit Accounting, Part 1 By John R. Cerepak, Ph.D., C.P.A. Department Chairman and Professor of Accounting and Quantitative Analysis
More informationErrors in Operational Spreadsheets: A Review of the State of the Art
Errors in Operational Spreadsheets: A Review of the State of the Art Abstract Spreadsheets are thought to be highly prone to errors and misuse. In some documented instances, spreadsheet errors have cost
More informationthe household money organizer
the household money organizer O 2009 by Baker Publishing Group Published by Revell a division of Baker Publishing Group P.O. Box 6287, Grand Rapids, MI 49516-6287 www.revellbooks.com Printed in China All
More informationRetirementWorks. The input can be made extremely simple and approximate, or it can be more detailed and accurate:
Retirement Income Amount RetirementWorks The RetirementWorks Retirement Income Amount calculator analyzes how much someone should withdraw from savings at or during retirement. It uses a needs-based approach,
More information42 % 33 % Many small business owners understand the actions needed to plan for transition (based on transition-focused owners, ratings of importance)
Building a Template for Transition Four best practices to tackle transition, retirement and succession Small business owners often combine vision and hard work to build companies that support them in their
More informationThe New ROI. Applications and ROIs
Denne_02_p013-026 9/10/03 3:42 PM Page 13 The New ROI If software development is to be treated as a value creation exercise, a solid understanding of the financial metrics used to evaluate and track value
More informationScenic Video Transcript End-of-Period Accounting and Business Decisions Topics. Accounting decisions: o Accrual systems.
Income Statements» What s Behind?» Income Statements» Scenic Video www.navigatingaccounting.com/video/scenic-end-period-accounting-and-business-decisions Scenic Video Transcript End-of-Period Accounting
More informationInsurers Driving Agility and Cost Optimization With BPM-Enabled SOA
Insurers Driving Agility and Cost Optimization With BPM-Enabled SOA An SMA Whitepaper Author: Deb Smallwood, Founder Published Date: September 2009 Table of Contents About This Whitepaper This paper is
More informationOutline of insider trading
Internal training materials Outline of insider trading Trainers: These materials provide a simple explanation of insider trading. Slides 1 through 10 provide a basic overview of insider trading regulations,
More informationTechnical Debt (TD) ( Technical Debt (TD) 1 / 23
Technical Debt (TD) https://softwarch.wordpress.com (https://softwarch.wordpress.com) Technical Debt (TD) 1 / 23 Introducing the metaphor Technical Debt The term technical debt was coined by Ward Cunningham.
More informationFind Out How Much You May Really Need
Find Out How Much You May Really Need to Retire with Confidence 1300023 What s Your Number? At J.D. Mellberg Financial, one of our flagship strategies is using a fixed index annuity with select rider
More informationTransforming the Insurance Enterprise through Adaptive Systems. An Oracle White Paper December 2009
Transforming the Insurance Enterprise through Adaptive Systems An Oracle White Paper December 2009 Transforming the Insurance Enterprise through Adaptive Systems By Chuck Johnston TRANSFORMATION: BUSINESS
More informationNonprofit Budgeting Part 2: Building Better Budgets
Nonprofit Budgeting Part 2: Building Better Budgets CompassPoint Nonprofit Services 500 12 th Street Suite 320 Oakland, CA 94607 ph 510-318-3755 fax 415-541-7708 web: www.compasspoint.org e-mail: workshops@compasspoint.org
More informationTerm Par Swap Rate Term Par Swap Rate 2Y 2.70% 15Y 4.80% 5Y 3.60% 20Y 4.80% 10Y 4.60% 25Y 4.75%
Revisiting The Art and Science of Curve Building FINCAD has added curve building features (enhanced linear forward rates and quadratic forward rates) in Version 9 that further enable you to fine tune the
More informationQUANTUM SALES COMPENSATION Designing Your Plan (How to Create a Winning Incentive Plan)
QUANTUM SALES COMPENSATION Designing Your Plan (How to Create a Winning Incentive Plan) Good morning, everyone. Welcome to our third installment of Master Classes on Sales Compensation Design with the
More informationRookie Mistake #7. What is a Capitalization Table and what does it say about my Company?
THE TECHNOLOGY VENTURE ALLIANCE Rookie Mistake #7 What is a Capitalization Table and what does it say about my Company? The Mistake Entrepreneurs are often confused when a potential investor asks to see
More informationTe c h n o l o gy : According to a recent ELAOnline
Te c h n o l o gy : Use it or Lose it Lessors are beginning to take advantage of the newest credit tool for the leasing industry. by Suzanne Jackson According to a recent ELAOnline poll, 80 percent of
More informationThe Math of Intrinsic Value
The Math of Intrinsic Value Introduction: In India and across the world, the most commonly found investment options are bank fixed deposits, gold, real estate, bonds and stocks. Since over a hundred years
More informationOne statement we continually hear after talking to new members is, I didn t think that y all did that!
One statement we continually hear after talking to new members is, I didn t think that y all did that! We started to dig into why we heard that so much, and the answer was clear there are way too many
More information4 BIG REASONS YOU CAN T AFFORD TO IGNORE BUSINESS CREDIT!
SPECIAL REPORT: 4 BIG REASONS YOU CAN T AFFORD TO IGNORE BUSINESS CREDIT! Provided compliments of: 4 Big Reasons You Can t Afford To Ignore Business Credit Copyright 2012 All rights reserved. No part of
More informationWatch the Bottom Line
Thinkstock images/comstock/thinkstock Objective Watch the Bottom Line istockphoto/thinkstock Last winter, Tucker and Ian started a lawn-mowing and snow-shoveling service. Although they did well initially,
More informationHARP Refinance Guide. How You can Benefit from the HARP Program
HARP Refinance Guide How You can Benefit from the HARP Program Contents How HARP Can Help You You Might Qualify for HARP but Not Know It HARP Qualification Basics HARP History HARP 1.0 HARP 2.0 HARP 3.0
More informationCONTENTS. Introduction 2. Survey Highlights 3. Survey Demographics 5. Processes 10. Challenges 17
CONTENTS Introduction 2 Survey Highlights 3 Survey Demographics 5 Processes 10 Challenges 17 INTRODUCTION Solvency II is the most significant regulatory change ever to be implemented throughout the European
More information11 Critical Mistakes Many Entrepreneurs Make
11 Critical Mistakes Many Entrepreneurs Make Chances are YOU may be making one of them Costing you Thousands of dollars NOW and maybe even your Business tomorrow! By Paul C. Morin, PBA www.padgettnw.com
More informationBuilding the Healthcare System of the Future O R A C L E W H I T E P A P E R F E B R U A R Y
Building the Healthcare System of the Future O R A C L E W H I T E P A P E R F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 7 Introduction Healthcare in the United States is changing rapidly. An aging population has increased
More informationIFRS Today. The IFRS 17 journey No time to rest. KPMG s podcast series on IFRS and financial reporting EPISODE 9 TRANSCRIPT. Host. Mary.
IFRS Today: The IFRS 17 journey No time to rest 1 IFRS Today KPMG s podcast series on IFRS and financial reporting 7 November 2018 EPISODE 9 TRANSCRIPT The IFRS 17 journey No time to rest Speakers H Trussell
More informationSTRATEGIC IT FINANCE. 6 best practices for. Executive summary. Empowering IT Finance to align spend with business priorities.
6 best practices for STRATEGIC IT FINANCE Empowering IT Finance to align spend with business priorities. Executive summary For many IT Finance teams, manual budget processes make it difficult to see where
More informationINSURANCE ASSET MANAGEMENT, NORTH AMERICA 2016
PUBLISHED BY NOVEMBER 2016 INSURANCE ASSET MANAGEMENT, NORTH AMERICA 2016 Successfully managing assets to meet underwriting commitments and regulatory requirements ASSET SERVICING SPONSOR Download the
More informationUsing data mining to detect insurance fraud
IBM SPSS Modeler Using data mining to detect insurance fraud Improve accuracy and minimize loss Highlights: combines powerful analytical techniques with existing fraud detection and prevention efforts
More informationReport of the VA CARVM Survey Results of the American Academy of Actuaries Variable Annuity Reserve Work Group
Report of the VA CARVM Survey Results of the American Academy of Actuaries Variable Annuity Reserve Work Group Presented to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners Life and Health Actuarial
More informationREPORT ON FINANCIAL ACTIVITY FACILITATOR MANUAL WITH SIMULATED ONLINE BUSINESS ASSESSMENT BSBFIA402A
REPORT ON FINANCIAL ACTIVITY FACILITATOR MANUAL WITH SIMULATED ONLINE BUSINESS ASSESSMENT BSBFIA402A Precision Group (Australia) Pty Ltd 44 Bergin Rd, Ferny Grove, QLD, 4055 Email: info@precisiongroup.com.au
More informationInsure Oklahoma. Oklahoma Health Care Authority. Employer Survey April 9, 2008
Employer Survey 2007 Insure Oklahoma Oklahoma Health Care Authority Employer Survey 2007 April 9, 2008-1 - Executive Summary Measuring the impact of a state-funded program is vital to measuring success.
More informationNetPicks Keltner Bells
Page 1 NetPicks Keltner Bells NetPicks, LLC HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS HAVE MANY INHERENT LIMITATIONS, SOME OF WHICH ARE DESCRIBED BELOW. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY TRADING ACCOUNT
More informationchief ombudsman & chief executive s report
chief ombudsman & It s approaching 20 years ago now that discussions were underway about setting up a single ombudsman for financial services. This would replace eight existing schemes each covering individual
More informationStrategy Paper: Financial Planning for Generation-Y. SMSF Specialists Investment Management Financial Planning Accounting
Strategy Paper: 190 Through Road Camberwell VIC 3124 T: (03) 9809 1221 F: (03) 9809 2055 enquiry@gfmwealth.com.au www.gfmwealth.com.au ABN 69 006 679 394 Financial Planning for Generation-Y SMSF Specialists
More informationNFIB SMALL BUSINESS. William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wad SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS. Seasonally Adjusted Level
NFIB SMALL BUSINESS ECONOMIC TRENDS William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wad November 212 Based on a Survey of Small and Independent Business Owners SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS Index Component Seasonally
More informationIn this chapter: Budgets and Planning Tools. Configure a budget. Report on budget versus actual figures. Export budgets.
Budgets and Planning Tools In this chapter: Configure a budget Report on budget versus actual figures Export budgets Project cash flow Chapter 23 479 Tuesday, September 18, 2007 4:38:14 PM 480 P A R T
More information2017 ONLINE CARD SCHOOL
2017 ONLINE CARD SCHOOL Session #2 Calculating Card Program Profitability Timothy Kolk (603) 924-4438 tkolk@trkadvisors.com May 2017 The Online Card School Purpose Provide market intelligence including
More informationQuickBooks. For Evaluation Only. Premier 2015 Level 2. Courseware MasterTrak Accounting Series
QuickBooks Premier 2015 Level 2 Courseware 1702-1 MasterTrak Accounting Series QuickBooks Premier 2015 Level 2 Lesson 2: Banking and Credit Cards Lesson Objectives In this lesson you will learn how to
More informationDeferred Maintenance. Data Gathering and Presentation. By Tim McDonald 36 MAY/JUNE 2016 FACILITIES MANAGER
Deferred Data Gathering and Presentation By Tim McDonald 36 MAY/JUNE 2016 FACILITIES MANAGER APPA s online glossary defines deferred maintenance as the total dollar amount of existing maintenance repairs
More informationKnow when to use them.know when to lose them
Know when to use them.know when to lose them Or, why an income rider is rarely appropriate.. Before I get started please let me state something clearly: there is nothing wrong with buying an income rider
More informationKey Performance Indicators. An Introductory Guide. Stephen Mabey Managing Director
Key Performance Indicators An Introductory Guide Stephen Mabey Managing Director smabey@appliedstrategies.ca 902.472.3032 Key Performance Indicators An Introductory Guide All rights reserved. No part of
More informationROYAL BANK OF CANADA SPEAKS AT NATIONAL BANK FINANCIAL CANADIAN FINANCIAL SERVICES CONFERENCE
ROYAL BANK OF CANADA SPEAKS AT NATIONAL BANK FINANCIAL CANADIAN FINANCIAL SERVICES CONFERENCE WEDNESDAY MARCH 26, 2008 DISCLAIMER THE FOLLOWING SPEAKERS NOTES, IN ADDITION TO THE WEBCAST AND THE ACCOMPANYING
More informationPractical Considerations for Building a D&O Pricing Model. Presented at Advisen s 2015 Executive Risk Insights Conference
Practical Considerations for Building a D&O Pricing Model Presented at Advisen s 2015 Executive Risk Insights Conference Purpose The intent of this paper is to provide some practical considerations when
More informationNFIB SMALL BUSINESS. William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wad SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS. Seasonally Adjusted Level
NFIB SMALL BUSINESS ECONOMIC TRENDS William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wad May 214 Based on a Survey of Small and Independent Business Owners SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS Index Component Seasonally
More informationRemember, your job is to manage working capital (cash) and ensure your company has enough of it to grow and to weather economic downturns.
Remember, your job is to manage working capital (cash) and ensure your company has enough of it to grow and to weather economic downturns. We encourage you to read Simple Numbers, Straight Talk, Big Profits!
More informationUser guide for employers not using our system for assessment
For scheme administrators User guide for employers not using our system for assessment Workplace pensions CONTENTS Welcome... 6 Getting started... 8 The dashboard... 9 Import data... 10 How to import a
More informationHow Do Small Businesses Shop for a New 401(k)?
How Do Small Businesses Shop for a New 401(k)? 2017 Fisher Investments. Intended for use by employers considering or sponsoring retirement plans; not for personal use by plan participants. Investing in
More informationFosters Construction Deryl Northcott, University of Manchester
Fosters Construction Deryl Northcott, University of Manchester Permission to reprint this case has been granted by Captus Press Inc. and the Accounting Education Resource Centre of the University of Lethbridge.
More informationPresenter: And Paul, you've been quite vocal on the inadequacies of the SRRI calculation.
Morningstar - KIID Key Investor Information Document - KIID Paul Kaplan, Jeff Strazis & Neil Simmonds Presenter: I'm joined now by Neil Simmonds, Partner at Simmons & Simmons, Dr Paul Kaplan, Director
More informationHow to Handle FASB s Unfair Value Standard
How to Handle FASB s Unfair Value Standard By Colleen Cunningham November 4, 2008 I had planned to write a completely different column for this month but, much like the Treasury Department, was inspired
More informationLP Perspectives. Real Estate Obsolescence: Portfolio Risks and Opportunities
LP Perspectives Real Estate Obsolescence: Portfolio Risks and Opportunities Institutional investors discuss real estate obsolescence and its impact on portfolio strategies and manager selection Four Principles
More informationFOR AN UNCLAIMED FUNDS AUDIT
PREPARING YOUR DENTAL PRACTICE FOR AN UNCLAIMED FUNDS AUDIT Reports to run & Coaching to smooth out this experience JILL NESBITT Practice Administrator & Dental Consultant Mission 77, LLC 615-970-8405
More informationWhat s My Note Worth? The Note Value Handbook
What s My Note Worth? The Note Value Handbook Inside Information Regarding Valuation of your Seller Financed Note in the Note Investor Market Compiled and published by Nationwide Secured Capital Retail
More informationHow to Control Your Own Destiny, Generate More Fees and Explode Your Wealth By Structuring Your Own Deals Using Little of Your Own Money WEALTH
How to Control Your Own Destiny, Generate More Fees and Explode Your Wealth By Structuring Your Own Deals Using Little of Your Own Money A Business Designed for Brokers That ll Increase Your Fees and Explode
More informationWhat else could you do with the time you spend on budgeting?
What else could you do with the time you spend on budgeting? Budgeting As your company evolves, you have to devote more and more time to preparing your budgets. That s why Prophix brings you. This Best
More informationINSIGHTS REPORT VOLUME 08 WHAT S INSIDE. A variable swine market means there are key areas producers should focus on for shortand long-term planning.
INSIGHTS REPORT VOLUME 08 WHAT S INSIDE A variable swine market means there are key areas producers should focus on for shortand long-term planning. With the current state of the ag economy, it s more
More informationHow to Use the New NeighborWorks New Homebuyer Full Information Service Module in CounselorMax
How to Use the New NeighborWorks New Homebuyer Full Information Service Module in CounselorMax Introduction... 2 Client Intake... 2 Using the GPS Form and Carrying out the Service Steps... 5 Collect NW
More informationLegal entity reduction: Savings on tap?
Legal entity reduction: Savings on tap? Perhaps few other corporate planning opportunities better embody the concept of less is more than legal entity reduction. At a time when many multinational companies
More informationCreative Project Accounting
The PROJECT PERFECT White Paper Collection Creative Project Accounting Neville Turbit Overview Project accounting is one of the least exciting parts of project management. It is also usually a minefield
More informationMonthly Treasurers Tasks
As a club treasurer, you ll have certain tasks you ll be performing each month to keep your clubs financial records. In tonights presentation, we ll cover the basics of how you should perform these. Monthly
More informationPace Complete. Pace. Members Report. The Co-op pension scheme. December 2017
Pace Complete Members Report Pace The Co-op pension scheme December 2017 Welcome to your update from Pace Complete Dear member On behalf of the Trustee Board, I m very pleased to introduce your annual
More informationRunning Your Business for Growth
Accenture Insurance Running Your Business for Growth Could Your Operating Model Be Standing in the Way? 1 95 percent of senior executives are not certain their companies have the right operating model
More informationShow Me the Money. Watch the Bottom Line. Objectives. Nature of Accounting. For discussion only. Fig 1. Student Guide
Student Guide Product/Service Management Financial Analysis LAP LAP 1 85 Performance Indicator: PM:013 FI:085 Nature of Accounting Last winter, Tucker and Ian started a lawnmowing and snow-shoveling service.
More informationBeware the Enterprise Valuation Measure
SEPTEMBER 2016 By Tedd Powers, Senior Consultant, Fisher International Determining the value of a business requires an in-depth analysis of the current and future financial state of the company along with
More informationModule 4. Table of Contents
Copyright Notice. Each module of the course manual may be viewed online, saved to disk, or printed (each is composed of 10 to 15 printed pages of text) by students enrolled in the author s accounting course
More informationNFIB SMALL BUSINESS. William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wade SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS
NFIB SMALL BUSINESS ECONOMIC TRENDS William C. Dunkelberg Holly Wade February 211 Based on a Survey of Small and Independent Business Owners SMALL BUSINESS OPTIMISM INDEX COMPONENTS Seasonally Change From
More informationFIS INSURANCE PROCESS CONTROLLER SYSTEM INTEGRATION, PROCESS AUTOMATION AND COMPOSITE APPLICATION PLATFORM
FIS INSURANCE PROCESS CONTROLLER SYSTEM INTEGRATION, PROCESS AUTOMATION AND COMPOSITE APPLICATION PLATFORM FIS Insurance Process Controller 1 Empowering a new age of insurance Unrelenting regulatory change
More informationYour guide to pension transfers. About this guide
Informed This guide has all the things you need to think about if you re considering transferring your pension to Legal & General. It s designed to help you weigh up the pros and the cons so you can make
More informationExpectations for Project Work
Expectations for Project Work Form a group of about 3 students and together select one of the approved topics for your project. Please note the due date carefully - late projects will not receive full
More informationFinancial reports give a snapshot of a company s value at the end of a
Chapter 1 Opening the Cornucopia of Reports In This Chapter Reviewing the importance of financial reports Exploring the different types of financial reporting Discovering the key financial statements Financial
More informationHow to Find and Qualify for the Best Loan for Your Business
How to Find and Qualify for the Best Loan for Your Business With so many business loans available to you these days, where do you get started? What loan product is right for you, and how do you qualify
More informationManaging operational tax risk through technology
Managing operational tax risk through technology EY Africa Tax Conference September 2014 Panel Daryl Blakeway Director Tax Performance Advisory Leader EY South Africa Anthony Davis Director Tax Performance
More informationGlossary of Terms Sales Performance Management
Glossary of Terms Sales Performance Management Accelerator Account Account management Account Planning or Plan Accrual Adjustment Annual Bonus Annual Total Target Annual Wage Adjustment Award Base Salary
More informationThe role of an actuary in a Policy Administration System implementation
The role of an actuary in a Policy Administration System implementation Abstract Benefits of a New Policy Administration System (PAS) Insurance is a service and knowledgebased business, which means that
More informationSeven Considerations Before Creating a Family Office
Seven Considerations Before Creating a Family Office Should I create a family office to manage my wealth and investments? This is a question that many wealthy families with over $100 million in investable
More informationMonthly Treasurers Tasks
As a club treasurer, you ll have certain tasks you ll be performing each month to keep your clubs financial records. In tonights presentation, we ll cover the basics of how you should perform these. Monthly
More informationVenture capital trusts. An Octopus guide
Venture capital trusts An Octopus guide About this guide For UK investors only. This guide has been written for UK residents who are interested in finding out more about Venture Capital Trusts (VCTs).
More informationste vv art Recorded Documents- By Bill Pratt, Underwriting Counsel IN THIS ISSUE...
ste vv art Recorded Documents- By Bill Pratt, Underwriting Counsel Have you ever found yourself in a situation where a recorded document needs correcting and you don t know what to do? There is a misconception
More informationInsurance Program Benchmarking Methodology July 2015 Global Headquarters 1430 Broadway, 8th Floor New York, NY
Insurance Program Benchmarking Methodology July 2015 Table of Contents Table of Contents Overview 4 Why Insurance Program Benchmarking? 4 Advisen Patent US8762178 B2 4 What Insurance Program Data is included?
More informationMicrosoft Forecaster. FRx Software Corporation - a Microsoft subsidiary
Microsoft Forecaster FRx Software Corporation - a Microsoft subsidiary Make your budget meaningful The very words budgeting and planning remind accounting professionals of long, exhausting hours spent
More informationP1: TIX/XYZ P2: ABC JWST JWST075-Goos June 6, :57 Printer Name: Yet to Come. A simple comparative experiment
1 A simple comparative experiment 1.1 Key concepts 1. Good experimental designs allow for precise estimation of one or more unknown quantities of interest. An example of such a quantity, or parameter,
More informationWhy Buy & Hold Is Dead
Why Buy & Hold Is Dead In this report, I will show you why I believe short-term trading can help you retire early, where the time honored buy and hold approach to investing in stocks has failed the general
More informationWhen events are measured: results improve. When feedback is provided the rate of improvement accelerates.
Critical Management Reports For Homebuilders presented by Mike Benshoof, Vice President and Partner SMA Consulting When events are measured: results improve. When feedback is provided the rate of improvement
More informationFIGHTING AGAINST CRIME IN A DIGITAL WORLD DAVID HARTLEY DIRECTOR, SAS FRAUD & FINANCIAL CRIME BUSINESS UNIT
FIGHTING AGAINST CRIME IN A DIGITAL WORLD DAVID HARTLEY DIRECTOR, SAS FRAUD & FINANCIAL CRIME BUSINESS UNIT AGENDA Fraudsters love digital Fighting back Social Network Analysis BACKGROUND THE DIGITAL BUSINESS
More informationECO155L19.doc 1 OKAY SO WHAT WE WANT TO DO IS WE WANT TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN NOMINAL AND REAL GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT. WE SORT OF
ECO155L19.doc 1 OKAY SO WHAT WE WANT TO DO IS WE WANT TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN NOMINAL AND REAL GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT. WE SORT OF GOT A LITTLE BIT OF A MATHEMATICAL CALCULATION TO GO THROUGH HERE. THESE
More informationComponents of a Complete Plan
As principals and owners of engineering consulting firms grow older, their dreams of retirement may be clouded by concerns about funding their retirement and how their businesses will continue without
More information