Cargills (Ceylon) PLC (CARG) 1QFY15 results

Transcription

1 Sri Lanka Beverage, Food & Tobacco EQUITY RESEARCH Earnings review note 02 September 2014 Cargills (Ceylon) PLC (CARG) 1QFY15 results Key highlights and outlook Revenue grows, while margins are impacted by several charges: CARG posted revenue of LKR15.9bn (up 8.0% YoY) in 1QFY15, driven by growth of 9.0% YoY from the retail segment, which accounts for roughly 83% of group revenue. Higher operating costs, along with several other expenses (mainly an irrecoverable VAT charge of LKR190m, a loss of LKR116m arising from the scale down in brewery operations, and costs relating to restaurant refurbishment), which were not there in 1QFY14, resulted in the EBIT margin narrowing by 165bps to 2.6%. The lower net finance cost was not enough to offset a higher income tax expense that included a one-off tax charge of LKR101m due to the transfer of fixed assets as a part of the company s restructuring process. This resulted in CARG recording a net loss of LKR145m and a negative EPS of LKR0.65. Key developments: On June 20, CARG announced that it had entered into an agreement with Lion Brewery (Ceylon) PLC (LION) and Pearl Springs (Private) Limited (a wholly owned subsidiary of LION) to dispose of its stake in Millers Brewery Limited (CARG s brewery operations, which comes under the FMCG segment) for roughly LKR5.15bn. CARG expects the transaction to be completed during 2QFY15. Furthermore, on August 25, CARG announced that International Finance Corporation (IFC) plans to make a private equity investment in Cargills Foods Company (Pvt) Limited (CFC), a wholly owned subsidiary of CARG, which carries out its retail business. Under the proposed agreement, IFC will invest LKR2.55bn (roughly USD20m) to obtain an 8% stake in CFC. Revising our forecasts: We lower our FY15E revenue estimate to LKR62.0bn (from our prior estimate of LKR63.9bn) mainly to incorporate the revenue loss from the disposal of its brewery operations. However, we have maintained our FY15E EBIT margin at 4.3%, as we believe higher operating costs will be offset by a possible margin improvement in the FMCG segment, following the disposal of its brewery operation, which was incurring a loss. As a result, we lower our FY15E EPS estimate to LKR3.17 (from LKR3.32). Valuation outlook: After incorporating CARG s 1QFY15 results, our valuation range has slightly increased to LKR (versus our previous estimate of LKR ). Refer to page 2 for further details on our valuation outlook. Segmental review and our forecasts CARG s retail segment (83% of revenue in 1QFY15) grew 9.0% YoY to LKR13.1bn driven new store additions and possible growth in same store sales. According to our calculations, as of 30 June 2014, we believe CARG had 255 stores under operations. The segment s EBIT margin contracted by 257bps to 2.5% in 1QFY15 due mainly to an increase in costs associated with a LKR190m VAT adjustment. Furthermore, higher operating costs also dragged margins lower. We have maintained our FY15E retail segment revenue forecast at LKR49.3bn. However, we have slightly lowered the FY15E EBIT margin to 3.9% (down from prior 4.2%) to account for costs associated with the irrecoverable VAT impact, as a result of recent fiscal measures, which limit the volume of VAT-exempted supplies to 25% starting from January Key statistics CSE/Bloomberg tickers Share price (01 Sep 2014) No. of issued shares (m) Market cap (USDm) Enterprise value (USDm) Free float (%) 52-week range (H/L) Avg. daily vol (shares,1yr) Avg. daily turnover (USD 000) CARG.N0000/CARG SL LKR % LKR165/135 17, Note: USD/LKR=130.8 (avg. for the one year ended 01 Sep 2014) Share price movement 130% 120% 110% 100% 90% 80% Aug-13 Nov-13 Jan-14 Apr-14 Jun-14 Sep-14 Share price performance 3m 6m 12m CARG 12.3% 18.5% 1.9% S&P SL % 20.3% 18.9% All Share Price Index 12.3% 18.4% 20.5% Summary financials LKRm (quarter end 30 June) 1QFY15 1QFY14 YoY change Revenue 15,906 14, % EBITDA 942 1, % EBIT % Net profit to equity holders CARG ASPI S&P SL 20 (145) 121 NM Reported EPS (0.65) 0.54 NM ROE (%) (4.8) 1.7 (6.45ppts) P/E (x) NM NM 1

2 The FMCG segment (14% of revenue in 1QFY15) reported revenue of LKR2.2bn (up 3.3% YoY). We believe slow revenue growth could be primarily attributed to the scale down in production of its brewery operation in anticipation of the spin-off, which offset strong growth seen in diary operations, the largest business line within the segment. The segment s EBIT margin came in at 3.0% (up 444bps from the year-ago quarter) and was impacted by a LKR116m loss associated with the scale down in the brewery operation. We have lowered our FY15E revenue estimate to LKR10.3bn to incorporate the loss of revenue from its brewery operations. However, we have increased our EBIT margin to 4.2%, as we believe the disposal of the high-volume, low-margin brewery business, which had tempered the segment s margins, would provide a margin improvement going forward. CARG s restaurant segment (3% of revenue in 1QFY15) comprises the KFC chain of fast food outlets (28 in total as of end-1qfy15) and the TGI Friday s restaurant, which opened during FY14. Revenue came in at LKR544m, a modest growth of 5.4% YoY and posted a negative EBIT of LKR25m, as three restaurants were closed for refurbishment during the period, while operating costs continued to escalate. We have maintained our FY15E revenue forecast of LKR2.4bn; however, we have lowered our EBIT margin to 6.5% (versus prior 9.6%), as we expect the restaurant segment to continue to be impacted by lower diner footfall, which we believe is due to the increasing variety and number of restaurants currently in the market, as well as the presence of numerous lower-priced informal food outlets. At the end of 1QFY15, CARG s gearing level increased to 59.6% (up from 57.7% as at end-fy14) mainly the back of an 8.2% QoQ increase in short-term debt. Valuation outlook: After incorporating CARG s 1QFY15 results and the value from Cargills Bank Limited, our 12-month valuation range increase slightly to LKR (from LKR ), based on our DCF/SOTP and P/E analyses. Our DCF/SOTP valuation yields a share price range of LKR using our base-case assumptions of a risk-free rate of 9.0% and a market risk premium of 6.0%. We also use bull- and bear-case scenarios to arrive at this valuation range by considering a higher/lower number of Cargills store openings during our explicit forecast period of FY15E-FY17E, compared with our base-case forecast. Beyond FY17E, we consider an improved/worsened revenue performance compared with our base case, and also easing/worsening cost pressures affecting the margin. CARG currently trades at an FY15E P/E multiple of 50.5x, higher than its three-year normalized forward P/E of 40.0x. Our P/Ebased scenario analysis applies a 5% premium/discount to this multiple, resulting in a valuation range of LKR This multiple premium may be validated by better-than-expected growth in CARG s retail segment, on the back of improving consumer demand and an increase in the proportion of shopping done at supermarkets, while the discount could be justified based on sluggish consumption levels affecting the performance of the retail and FMCG segments. Figure 1: The valuation range analysis provides a range of LKR per share (current share price: LKR160) SOTP P/E analysis week range Source: CARG, Bloomberg, Copal Amba estimates 2

3 Appendix 1: Results summary Income statement (LKRm, except where stated otherwise) 1QFY15 4QFY14 1QFY14 QoQ change (%) YoY change (%) Revenue 15,906 10,212 14, % 8.0% Cost of goods sold 13,945 7,986 12, % 9.2% Gross profit 1,962 2,226 1, % 0.4% EBITDA , % -9.8% EBIT % -33.8% Finance costs % -18.7% Profit before tax % -65.2% Tax expense % 91.4% Profit for the period (144) % % Net income attributable to equity holders of the parent (145) % % Diluted EPS (LKR) (0.65) % % Financial summary of key segments Revenue (LKRm) 1QFY15 1QFY14 % change FY15E FY16E FY17E Retail 13,115 12, % 49,356 53,337 57,147 FMCG 2,247 2, % 10,298 11,431 12,688 Restaurant % 2,369 2,433 2,497 EBIT (LKRm) 1QFY15 1QFY14 % change FY15E FY16E FY17E Retail % 1,945 2,293 2,572 FMCG 67 (32) % Restaurant (25) % Note: Full-year figures are for the year ended 31 March 3

4 Appendix 2: Key financial data Summary group financials (LKRm) INCOME STATEMENT E 2016E 2017E (For the year ended 31 March) Revenue 48,256 55,379 58,323 62,024 67,201 72,332 EBITDA 3,415 3,604 3,897 4,678 5,094 5,461 EBIT 2,241 2,262 2,211 2,693 3,097 3,437 Earnings before Tax (EBT) 1,558 2,143 1,130 1,329 1,667 1,981 Net profit available to equity holders 1,049 1, ,145 1,360 BALANCE SHEET E 2016E 2017E (As at 31 March) Current assets Cash and cash equivalents ,433 1,614 Short-term investments Total current assets 8,676 9,590 10,763 11,207 13,960 14,979 Non-current assets Property, plant and equipment 14,230 20,638 22,121 22,253 22,556 23,008 Intangible assets 1,731 1,665 1,708 1,706 1,706 1,706 Total non-current assets 16,261 25,981 28,582 29,730 31,034 32,486 Total assets 24,937 35,571 39,345 40,938 44,994 47,464 Current liabilities Short term debt 7,369 12,276 15,481 16,749 16,749 16,749 Total current liabilities 16,451 20,460 24,094 25,152 27,747 28,497 Non-current liabilities Long term debt 243 1,850 1,289 1,415 1,731 2,091 Total non-current liabilities 1,017 3,071 2,941 2,775 3,091 3,451 Equity Total equity 7,468 12,039 12,310 13,011 14,156 15,516 Total liabilities and equity 24,937 35,571 39,345 40,938 44,994 47,464 CASH FLOW STATEMENT E 2016E 2017E (For the year ended 31 March) Net cash flow from operating activities 4,076 2,106 2,754 3,529 4,855 4,742 Net cash flow from investing activities (3,848) (6,517) (3,472) (2,191) (2,300) (2,476) Net cash flow from financing activities (1,934) 4,631 2,887 (1,288) (2,103) (2,085) Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents (1,706) 220 2, KEY RATIOS E 2016E 2017E EBIT margin (%) Net profit margin (%) ROE (%) Debt/capital (%) P/E (x)

5 IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER This document has been prepared on behalf of the Colombo Stock Exchange ( CSE ) by Amba Research Lanka Private Limited ( Amba ) and is sponsored by the CSE. The views expressed in this document are those of the authors based on available and accessible information from the public domain and do not represent those of the CSE. Please note, inter alia, that with the publication of this document on the CSE website, neither Amba, as author, nor CSE (as sponsor) intend to assume and are not assuming any responsibility or liability (including under contract, common law or tort) to any party arising out of or with respect to this document. This document is not intended to, and does not form part of any contract with anyone (including a contract between author and reader/recipient) and no one shall have any right (contractual or otherwise) to enforce any claim in relation to the document either directly or indirectly. Except as otherwise indicated, you may only view and print one copy of the document for your own personal, non-commercial use. You may not copy, store [either in hardcopy or in an electronic retrieval system] transmit, transfer, broadcast, publish, reproduce, create a derivative work from, display, distribute, sell, license, rent, lease or otherwise transfer any of the contents to any third person (including, without limitation, to others in your company or organization) whether for direct or indirect commercial or monetary gain or otherwise without the prior written permission of Amba and CSE. This document does not contain any investment advice nor does it constitute an offer to buy, sell or hold any of the investment product(s)/asset class (es) mentioned herein. Prospective investors are required to possess sufficient knowledge when evaluating the advantages and risks inherent to such investment product(s)/asset class(es) mentioned herein and to take into consideration their circumstances and financial position when assessing the suitability of such investments.. Prior to making an investment decision, prospective investors are strongly advised to obtain independent advice from competent legal, financial, tax, accounting and other professionals. Amba and CSE shall not be held liable in any manner for any direct, indirect or consequential loss that may arise as a result of investing in the investment product(s)/asset class (es) mentioned herein. Amba and CSE expressly disclaim any fiduciary responsibility or liability for any consequences, financial or otherwise from any reliance placed on the information in this document. The investment product(s)/asset class (es) described in this document may not be eligible for sale or subscription within a particular jurisdiction or to particular categories of investors. This document is not intended for distribution to a person or, within a jurisdiction where such distribution would be restricted or illegal. It is the responsibility of any person reading this document to observe all applicable laws and regulation of the relevant jurisdiction. Neither Amba, nor CSE, shall be responsible for any error which may have occurred at the time of printing of this document. The information set out in this document is subject to change without notice. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable and Amba and CSE make no warranty, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, timeliness, completeness or correct sequencing of the information. This document does not purport to list all of the terms and conditions, nor to identify or define all or any of the risks that would be associated with the purchase or sale of the investment product(s)/asset class (es) described herein. Please note that any price levels, rates, simulations, illustrations, terms or conditions contained herein are indicative only, and may vary in accordance with changes in market conditions.all the information included in this document is current at the time of preparing this document and subject to change at any time. Any forecast, projection or forward looking statement made in this document embodies assumptions and predictions about future events that by their nature cannot be verified as facts. They are not necessarily indicative of future or likely performance, of investment product(s)/asset class (es), countries, markets or companies. Any past market conditions or product performances may not be representative of future market conditions or product performances. 5