Susan St John, Co-director, Retirement Policy and Research centre introduced the session:
|
|
- Osborne Caldwell
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Breakfast Briefing, Wednesday 3 November KiwiSaver turns 3: are we celebrating? Proceedings of a breakfast seminar at The University of Auckland Business School, Decima Glenn Room, Level 3, Owen G Glenn Building Wednesday 3 November Whether or not New Zealanders are saving enough is unresolved, yet there are calls for KiwiSaver to be made compulsory. Has KiwiSaver been a success? Is it welldesigned? What are the costs and benefits? Has it been good for New Zealand or just for the industry? Susan St John, Co-director, Retirement Policy and Research centre introduced the session: The Retirement Policy Research Centre has been very keenly monitoring KiwiSaver. It is a world first; auto enrolment, opt- out scheme and there is much interest in it from other countries. The RPRC has written several briefings and a working paper on the distributional implications of KiwiSaver and we have a keen interest in how schemes are compared. The RPRC produced a paper on KiwiSaver for the Pensions Policy Group in Ireland and Susan presented it there in June. Attendees at the presentation were 1
2 astonished at how the scheme was developed and that it had three major incarnations KiwiSaver 1, 2 and 3 since it was first a gleam in Michael Cullen s eye in Right from the beginning no-one has been clear about whether this is a scheme to address our national saving problem (CAD/overseas debt) or to help people save more for their retirement by increasing household savings to give people a better standard of living in retirement. The goals are actually contradictory. Policy design has been driven by a particular view of human behaviour that people save more when returns are higher and when they are tripped (or tricked) into saving. The experience in Japan indicates savings can be insensitive to returns. The incentive effects of KiwiSaver, including the opt-out auto-enrolment feature, has become impossible to evaluate because so many other things have also changed: tax cuts, the recession, and the global financial crisis. Now, there is an implicit acknowledgment that past settings have not worked by the latest tax rebalancing exercise with a rise in GST. In this context, the government has now set up another special taskforce to come up with some answers. The Savings Working Group has an unenviable task. Susan then welcomed and introduced the three speakers. Craig Ansley (formerly professor in the Accounting and Finance Department at the University of Auckland), Director Capital Markets Research at Russell Investments and is a member of the Savings Working Group (SWG). Craig discussed the saving problem faced by New Zealand as seen by the government. New Zealand s net external liabilities are very large (86% of GDP)...and rising (100% of GDP by 2014). This provides a point of reference for savings policy. New Zealand has low Gross Public debt, but high overseas indebtedness as shown in the chart. Countries that are in the most difficulty such a Greece and Ireland have high public and national debt. A high level of debt: leaves New Zealand vulnerable to creditors sentiment, limits NZ s options in dealing with future problems, and potentially limits future growth prospects. New Zealand is vulnerable to a sudden stop in the lending: High debt reduces unused borrowing capacity; as borrowing costs rise, the currency weakens; with lower growth, the tax base erodes. The SWG hopes to stimulate public discussion on savings and is looking at: - Fiscal policy government vs private saving; 2
3 - Tax policy dual tax system, indexation - KiwiSaver efficiency, compulsion, subsidies. Out of bounds for the Savings Working Group are New Zealand Superannuation, welfare policy, capital gains and land tax. Craig Ansley s full slides are available here. Alasdair Thompson; Chief Executive of Employers & Manufacturers Association (Northern) Inc (EMA). Voluntary saving is done for both short term and long term reasons at different stages in the lifetime of both individuals and families. In some countries workplace saving, via a tax on payrolls, is compulsory as they do not have universal pension systems. The ability or propensity to save is not as high in NZ as in other OECD countries because our incomes per capita (and labour productivity) are among the lowest in the OECD, and we also have a relatively (in the OECD) high number of people living on low incomes however that didn t stop the likes of Chile and Singapore introducing compulsory savings when their GDP per capita was lower than ours. Many people, especially those who leave secondary school with sub-standard numeracy and literacy skills, are either in low paid jobs or spend time on welfare. Even many people who are in work are being partially supported by Working for Families tax credits. There are approximately 300,000 families receiving Working for Families tax credits. Their ability to save is clearly impaired as the state considers their incomes (despite over 3
4 70% being on a highest marginal tax rate of 17.5%) to be so low that they need state support. Within the OECD, New Zealand has a lower per capital GDP of just over $US27,000in New Zealand s GDP per capita is almost 20% below the OECD average. Our low GDP and thus income per capita relative to other OECD countries means that our capacity for savings per capita is also going to be lower. In a general sense, way too many New Zealanders have a lifetime income insufficiency which impairs their ability to save. So not only is the per capita income of New Zealanders not high, but quite a large number (10.8%) have incomes less than half our median income level. Their capacity to save is very low, if possible at all. Our highly regarded National Super scheme makes it less essential for people to save for their retirement. It should be retained and at the point the government can get back to running a surplus, it could resume its prefunding. Better still it should use any future surplus to reduce its debt. In the event that it becomes necessary due to the aging of our population and more importantly due to people living fitter longer lives, the government should phase in a rise in the age of eligibility for National Super and/or incentivize people to stay in the workforce after the age of 65 by offering them a higher entitlement to National Super if they delay taking it up from age 65. Backing up our universal National Super are voluntary private savings of which KiwiSaver has become the focus for its 1.662m members. KiwiSaver provides substantial incentives for people to save and has attracted 1,662,000 (equal to 76.6% of the employed workforce June 2010). It is likely that the generous taxpayer funded incentives have been a key factor in its success. But these incentives are adding to the government s deficit or dis-saving. We don t see the point of the government borrowing $1.7 billion+ per annum to pay $1,043 annually into individual KiwiSaver accounts, Yes, keep the initial $1,000 taxpayer funded start-up subsidy as an incentive, but we say the $1,043 annual subsidy should be dropped. Because people taking up new jobs are automatically enrolled and many don t exercise the opt-out provision, the number of people in KiwiSaver will grow without further intervention. The extent to which the private sector has increased its reliance on foreigners savings is high. For example, according to the Reserve Bank of New Zealand, Corporate sector foreign debt has proportionately gone up 2.15 times in the last 15 years from 53.8% of GDP in June 1995 to 115.7% in June But in that same time frame Official Government foreign debt went down from 24.4% to 14.5% GDP. Total foreign debt went up from 78.2% to 130.2% GDP. However, New Zealanders appear to be responding to this by making reduction of debt and increasing savings, especially via KiwiSaver, their number one financial priority. 4
5 So given our low propensity or ability to save and our universal National Super scheme, should we increase the burden of saving by making it compulsory in New Zealand. Well, for the state to compel its citizens to do things is well accepted for such things as funding public expenditure (taxes and property rates), acquiring land for public works, compulsory military service and laws regulating illegal and antisocial behavior, but compelling people to save against their will, individual best interests or income ability is not a particularly good public policy in a democracy that values the maximization of freedom of choice and which already has a tax funded universal pension. Compulsory savings are justifiable, even essential, for social purposes, i.e. to provide means for the elderly, in countries that do not have a tax funded universal National Super Scheme as we have in New Zealand. Their way of ensuring the elderly have means in their old age is to impose compulsory savings via separate taxes on payroll directed into individualized savings accounts. New Zealand has one of the lowest levels of elderly poverty in the world and this indicates that New Zealand s universal National Superannuation scheme has been very effective. It must get the credit for us sharing with the Netherlands the lowest level of elderly poverty in the OECD. Yes, the EMA would like to see us collectively become more self reliant on domestic savings, but we are sceptical that compulsory savings would actually increase total savings. For example if those on Working for Families were forced to save then this may cause the government to have to increase its Working for Families tax credits. For others it might reduce their debt reduction or other forms of saving rather than increase net total savings. Making savings compulsory is hard to justify in the NZ context. Unlike Australia, Chile or Singapore, NZ has a tax funded universal National Super scheme. One aspect of KiwiSaver that is a pain, however, for employers is the opt-out provision. When a new employee is engaged they are automatically enrolled in KiwiSaver, but the employee has a subsequent right to opt out. Most employers don t like the forced in/opt out provision because both the employer and employee are forced to pay IRD the joint contribution and then wait ages for it to be reversed and refunded if the employee subsequently opts out. They would much rather be required to ask all new employees if they want in the first place. The EMA thinks the best solution would be that no one is required to start paying money until the forced in/opt-out period has finished 56 days after the new employee has started their job. Alternatively, if the government wants to continue the forced in requirement, employers would prefer that the opt out provision be removed, but the holiday provision be retained in order that employee KiwiSaver members retain control over what is best for them rather than to be compelled to save via KiwiSaver. 5
6 But the real challenge, of course, is to achieve policy settings that will drive increased investment to raise productivity and exports as a percentage of our GDP. Michael Littlewood, Co-director, Retirement Policy and Research Centre Michael thinks that KiwiSaver was a solution looking for a problem to resolve. It was not an example of a research-based answer to an identified shortcoming in public policy. Does that mean KiwiSaver should be dumped? Perhaps not. For KiwiSaver to justify its continuation, some basic questions need addressing. Michael Littlewood thought we should celebrate KiwiSaver s birthday with 18 questions. [A] First, fundamental questions: 1. Are New Zealanders really behaving inappropriately? We didn t really know until What we have is, perhaps, not the best information but it s the best we have. 2. Do retirees really need more financial help? The best evidence we have is that the old have the lowest levels of financial hardship (and greatest levels of satisfaction with their position) of any group in New Zealand. 3. Do we really want to increase the future economic claims of the old? 4. Is KiwiSaver really the best use of $1.2 billion in 2010? 5. Why wouldn t New Zealanders change their other saving decisions, whatever the government decides? In 2006, after about 15 years of settled, but very different public policy on saving issues, Australian households had financial assets that were about 54.5% of total net assets. The equivalent number in New Zealand for 2006 was 51.2%; not so different. 6. What is the real problem that KiwiSaver addresses? Is it financial savings for retirement? If so, where is the evidence that New Zealanders are not saving enough? In fact the evidence says they are. [B] Given KiwiSaver s continued existence, there are 12 more questions: 1. Why does the government give business to default providers? Who are they protecting? Default status seems to be worth about 60,000 free members: there is no marketing costs or risk for the default providers in collecting those members. 2. Why do we have home purchase subsidies for first home buyers? 3. Why doesn t the IRD charge for administration? Do we even know how much that subsidy is costing taxpayers? 4. If KiwiSaver s design is really about behavioural economics, why are there any tax subsidies? The 2004 Savings Working Group was captured by the glamour of behavioural economics but did not identify what the problem was. 5. Why allow children to join a retirement savings scheme? Surely, that should be available only once people start working. 6. Why require employers to contribute? 6
7 Should the country really be concerned about the total remuneration practices of employers? That should be a private matter for employers and employees to resolve. 7. Why fix the minimum benefit age? Back to behavioural economics issue if we are concerned to get people thinking about retirement saving then we should let them make use of that money as they think fit. The savings belong to the members. 8. Why isn t everyone a member? The IRD says only 38% of eligible citizens are members in employer subsidised schemes. In the old days that would be a disappointing result for a subsidised savings scheme and those schemes typically required somewhat higher contributions than KiwiSaver s. 9. Are financial assets better than clearing debt? For most New Zealanders with debt, paying that off first should be a priority. 10. Why wasn t the Retirement Commission asked to address the questions put to the SWG? The Retirement Commission is due to report in December 2010 and the SWG s project should have been part of that. 11. Can we ask that SoFIE extends beyond 2010? Once the last tranche of SoFIE data is processed for 2010, there is no current commitment to extend that longitudinal work. If, as Craig has suggested, micro data such as produced by SoFIE are important, we need to ensure its continuance. 12. Is political consensus too much to ask for? The mere presence of the SWG is a bit of an indictment. The Retirement Commission is in the midst of a review. The SWG is not just about retirement but neither is the Retirement Commission s review. Michael Littlewood concluded by saying that he was therefore happy that the SWG seems not particularly interested in KiwiSaver. That still leaves the 18 questions that need answering. Summing up Susan St John If we listen to government hype, we might think that the KiwiSaver can be judged simply on the basis of the number who have joined. This morning has shown Issues are much deeper than that. The speakers have reinforced the conclusion that KiwiSaver is very difficult to evaluate. Official Evaluations may be little more that an ex post justification. Does it affect saving? May be we will never know in a climate where GST, tax have changed dramatically and we have experienced a global financial crisis and a recession But KiwiSaver is here to stay. Like Kiwibank and KiwiRail it is part of us now. The good points have not been discussed this morning and we should not forget its positive aspects. KiwiSaver has given everyone access to a work-based scheme while not excluding non workers and it is portable which is a huge improvement over what happens in Australia. So perhaps we can celebrate, albeit modestly 7
What are the next steps?
KiwiSaver and the ageing population: What are the next steps? Susan St John RPRC Business School The University of Auckland KiwiSaver is here to stay But how stable and sensible are our policies looking
More informationLabour s plan will make KiwiSaver compulsory for every employee aged 18 to 65 from 2014.
SAVINGS POLICY: QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS Universal KiwiSaver Why is Labour introducing universal KiwiSaver? We are heavily indebted as a country. Our private debt is now over $140 billion (70 per cent of
More informationKiwiSaver employer guide
KS4 April 2018 KiwiSaver employer guide What employers need to know about KiwiSaver WHAT IS KIWISAVER? KiwiSaver is a voluntary, work-based savings initiative designed to make regular saving for retirement
More informationInternational comparison of poverty amongst the elderly
International comparison of poverty amongst the elderly RPRC PensionBriefing 2009-1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- This PensionBriefing
More informationOECD PENSIONS OUTLOOK 2012
OECD PENSIONS OUTLOOK 2012 Recent pension reforms will lead to lower public pensions for future generations of retirees, around 20-25% on average. This first edition of the Pensions Outlook argues that
More informationThursday 27 October, New Zealand s structural economic problems will not fix themselves. Structural problems need structural solutions.
David PARKER Economic Development Associate Finance Spokesperson Thursday 27 October, 2011 SPEECH SAVINGS SPEECH New Zealand s structural economic problems will not fix themselves. Structural problems
More informationThe pensions reform White Paper Are we on the right track? Speech by Alison O Connell Scottish Widows 30 June 2006
The pensions reform White Paper Are we on the right track? Speech by Alison O Connell Scottish Widows 30 June 2006 Page 1 of 5 All of us, especially if we have worked in the financial services industry
More informationWELCOME TO THE NEW ZEALAND UNIVERSITIES SUPERANNUATION SCHEME YOUR SUPER GUIDE
WELCOME TO THE NEW ZEALAND UNIVERSITIES SUPERANNUATION SCHEME YOUR SUPER GUIDE 30 June 2014 CONTENTS 1. Advantages of Scheme membership 4 2. How your Scheme works 5 3. Your benefits 9 4. Investment choice
More informationONEANSWER KIWISAVER SCHEME PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
ONEANSWER ONEANSWER KIWISAVER SCHEME PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT 10 AUGUST 2018 ISSUER AND MANAGER: ANZ NEW ZEALAND INVESTMENTS LIMITED This product disclosure statement replaces the product disclosure
More informationFirst-time employer s guide
IR 333 April 2013 First-time employer s guide Information you ll need if you re thinking of taking on staff for the first time 2 First-time employer s guide Introduction This booklet takes a brief look
More informationHow does the Treasury s Long-Term Fiscal Model work, and what is our initial analysis showing?
How does the Treasury s Long-Term Fiscal Model work, and what is our initial analysis showing? Speech delivered by Girol Karacaoglu Chief Economist, the Treasury Affording O ur Future Conference 2012 Victoria
More informationNewsletter August 2016
Newsletter Introduction Welcome to our newsletter for. This newsletter combines the articles that we have published on our site since we last published a discrete newsletter. We provide the newsletter
More informationPRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT SuperEasy KiwiSaver Superannuation Scheme
PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT SuperEasy KiwiSaver Superannuation Scheme Offer of membership of the SuperEasy KiwiSaver Superannuation Scheme 9 March 2018 Issued by Local Government Superannuation Trustee
More informationUniSaver New Zealand
UniSaver New Zealand Product disclosure statement Offer of membership of UniSaver New Zealand 1 February 2018 This document gives you important information about this investment to help you decide whether
More informationPeter Whiteford. University of NSW
New Zealand and the KiwiSaver scheme Presentation for Conference on The Potential for Matching Defined Contributions (MDC) Design Features in Pension Systems to Increase Coverage in Low and Middle Income
More informationHow much will New Zealand Superannuation really cost?
How much will New Zealand Superannuation really cost? RPRC PensionBriefing 2010-4 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- This PensionBriefing
More informationNational strategy for financial literacy and retirement savings: The New Zealand experience
International Seminar on Social Security Employees Provident Fund, Malaysia National strategy for financial literacy and retirement savings: The New Zealand experience 14 July 2010 Michael Littlewood 1
More informationModelling the distributional aspects of KiwiSaver: methodology and results
Modelling the distributional aspects of KiwiSaver: methodology and results RPRC PensionBriefing 2009-6 The taxpayer-funded subsidies to KiwiSaver are distributed to members based on the contributions made
More informationANZ KIWISAVER SCHEME PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
ANZ KIWISAVER SCHEME PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT 24 NOVEMBER 2017 ISSUER AND MANAGER: ANZ NEW ZEALAND INVESTMENTS LIMITED This product disclosure statement replaces the product disclosure statement dated
More informationAnnual report. KiwiSaver evaluation. July 2011 to June 2012
KiwiSaver evaluation Annual report July 2011 to June 2012 Prepared by: National Research and Evaluation Unit, Inland Revenue for the KiwiSaver Evaluation Steering Group Date: September 2012 1 Contents
More informationDecumulation, Problems, policies and potentials? Financial Advisers Annual Conference Grosvenor Financial Services Group Ltd 4 th November 2016
Decumulation, Problems, policies and potentials? Financial Advisers Annual Conference Grosvenor Financial Services Group Ltd 4 th November 2016 Associate Professor Susan St John Retirement Policy and Research
More informationANZ KiwiSaver Scheme INformAtIoN for employers
ANZ KiwiSaver Scheme Information for employers One KiwiSaver scheme makes it easy KiwiSaver is a voluntary savings initiative, designed to make it easier for New Zealanders to save for their retirement.
More informationA Presentation for the Singapore Central Provident Fund
A Presentation for the Singapore Central Provident Fund Dr Brian McCulloch Strategy Unit 30 August 2006 The Treasury The Treasury -- 2 NZ has a multi-pillared retirement income framework. simple and efficient
More informationThe Savings Product Working Group
In May this year, the government appointed a Savings Product Working Group (SPWG) to investigate the role of workplace superannuation. In summary, the SPWG was asked to provide advice to the government
More informationNZ Funds KiwiSaver Scheme
NZ Funds KiwiSaver Scheme Product Disclosure Statement Issued by New Zealand Funds Management Limited 20 December 2017 This document replaces the Product Disclosure Statement dated 30 June 2017 This document
More informationSoft mandatory systems
Soft mandatory systems National soft mandatory savings schemes have been proposed for New Zealand (the Kiwisaver) and the United Kingdom (the National Pension Savings Scheme or NPSS). Below are brief summaries
More informationPart 5: Building up saving, and running nest eggs down
Part 5: Building up saving, and running nest eggs down Looking at the tax settings on savings and capitalare we there yet? Broad base, low rate and superannuation taxation Questions about whether tax is
More informationMERCER KIWISAVER SENTIMENT INDEX STUDY MAY 2012
SECURING SECURING RETIREMENT RETIREMENT INCOMES INCOMES MERCER KIWISAVER SENTIMENT INDEX STUDY MAY 2012 CONTENTS Message from Martin Lewington, Head of Mercer New Zealand Introduction to the Mercer KiwiSaver
More informationNew Zealand s Economic & Fiscal Outlook, Treasury s Long-Term Fiscal Statement, and Treasury s Living Standards Framework October 2013.
New Zealand s Economic & Fiscal Outlook, Treasury s Long-Term Fiscal Statement, and Treasury s Living Standards Framework October 2013 Short-Term (next five years) Economic and Fiscal Outlook Five Key
More informationKiwi Wealth KiwiSaver Scheme. Annual Report
Kiwi Wealth KiwiSaver Scheme. Annual Report for the year ended 31 March 2017 ` Welcome to a year in the life of Kiwi Wealth Welcome to the annual report of the Kiwi Wealth KiwiSaver Scheme (the Scheme).
More information00:00:24:26 Glenn Emma, can you give us a brief background into, into auto enrolment?
Time-codes Pensions 00:00:04:08 Interviewer Hello my name s Glenn Collins and I m ACCA UK s Head of Technical Advisory. Today s vodcast we re going to consider work place pension reforms. It s part of
More informationSuperLife. KiwiSaver scheme. Product Disclosure Statement. Offer of membership of the SuperLife. 29 March Issued by Smartshares Limited
29 March 2018 SuperLife KiwiSaver scheme Product Disclosure Statement Offer of membership of the SuperLife KiwiSaver scheme Issued by Smartshares Limited This document gives you important information about
More informationMr Lance Dawber-Ashley
Mr Lance Dawber-Ashley Wealth Adviser Kiwi Wealth Wellington 16:30-17:25 WS #166: Kiwisaver - The Key Benefits For Your Financial Health 17:35-18:30 WS #178: Kiwisaver - The Key Benefits For Your Financial
More informationROYAL LONDON POLICY PAPER 4. Britain s Forgotten Army : The collapse in pension membership among the selfemployed and what to do about it
ROYAL LONDON POLICY PAPER 4. : The collapse in pension membership among the selfemployed and what to do about it ABOUT ROYAL LONDON POLICY PAPERS The Royal London Policy Paper series was established in
More informationABOUT YOUR SUPER PLAN Issued: 1 March 2018
Deseret Benefit Plan for Australia ABOUT YOUR SUPER PLAN Issued: 1 March 2018 CONTENTS Introduction 2 Plan overview 2 How super works 3 Benefits of investing with the Plan 7 Risks of super 17 How we invest
More informationPOLICY TRENDS IN OECD COUNTRIES TO INCREASE COVERAGE AND CONTRIBUTIONS INTO FUNDED PENSION PLANS
Future of Super Conference Auckland 14 October 2013 POLICY TRENDS IN OECD COUNTRIES TO INCREASE COVERAGE AND CONTRIBUTIONS INTO FUNDED PENSION PLANS Stéphanie Payet Private Pensions Analyst OECD Financial
More informationOffer of membership of the Lifestages KiwiSaver Scheme Product Disclosure Statement
Offer of membership of the Lifestages KiwiSaver Scheme Product Disclosure Statement As at 13 April 2018 Issued by Funds Administration New Zealand Ltd ( FANZ ) This is a replacement product disclosure
More informationEMPLOYEE RETIREMENT PLAN MEMBER BOOKLET. 31 January Planning tomorrow s retirement today
EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT PLAN MEMBER BOOKLET 31 January 2019 Planning tomorrow s retirement today INTRODUCTION The Teachers Retirement Savings Scheme (Teachers scheme or scheme) has been specially designed
More informationKiwiSaver and Superannuation policy
1 of 7 KiwiSaver and Superannuation policy National is committed to keeping the KiwiSaver scheme and making it an enduring and affordable scheme for members, employers, and taxpayers. National is committed
More informationWork and Pensions Select Committee inquiry into pensions auto enrolment
Work and Pensions Select Committee inquiry into pensions auto enrolment A response from NEST About NEST NEST is a trust-based defined contribution (DC) pension scheme that UK employers can use to meet
More informationProduct Disclosure Statement
2 December 2016 Product Disclosure Statement Offer of membership in Superannuation Scheme This document replaces the product disclosure statement dated 23 September 2016 Issued by Shamrock Superannuation
More informationSCOTLAND S FISCAL DEFICIT
SCOTLAND S FISCAL DEFICIT or THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM SUMMARY REPORT May 2017 Update 1 Chart 1 25 20 15 20 12 18 19 14 SUMMARY Scotland's deficit billions 17 13 16 14 15 15 14 14 10 10 9 7 5 5 4 2 0 *Author
More informationKIWISAVER GLOSSARY. Brought to you by: Workplace Savings NZ
KIWISAVER GLOSSARY Brought to you by: Introduction This glossary is designed for consumers and KiwiSaver providers. Its aim is to bring simplicity to a complex world, explaining technical terms in a clear
More informationThese slides are for financial advisers only
These slides are for financial advisers only Standard Life has provided these template slides for you to use with the employees of your corporate clients. You can use these slides to tell employees about
More informationCh In other countries the replacement rate is often higher. In the Netherlands it is over 90%. This means that after taxes Dutch workers receive
Ch. 13 1 About Social Security o Social Security is formally called the Federal Old-Age, Survivors, Disability Insurance Trust Fund (OASDI). o It was created as part of the New Deal and was designed in
More informationNew Zealand Superannuation and KiwiSaver
New Zealand Superannuation and KiwiSaver Dr Brian McCulloch Green Paper on Pensions Learning from International Experience Conference Dublin, May 29 th, 2008 1 The New Zealand policy framework is built
More informationNATIONAL PENSION STRATEGY
FEBRUARY 2016 NATIONAL PENSION STRATEGY An Ireland for all. MICHAEL McGRATH FIANNA FÁIL SPOKESPERSON ON FINANCE Executive summary Pension provision is an issue which should concern everyone in society,
More informationStrategy Paper: Financial Planning for Generation-Y. SMSF Specialists Investment Management Financial Planning Accounting
Strategy Paper: 190 Through Road Camberwell VIC 3124 T: (03) 9809 1221 F: (03) 9809 2055 enquiry@gfmwealth.com.au www.gfmwealth.com.au ABN 69 006 679 394 Financial Planning for Generation-Y SMSF Specialists
More informationTax Working Group Session: The Fiscal Framework
Tax Working Group Session: The Fiscal Framework John Whitehead, Secretary to the Treasury Rutherford House, Victoria University Friday 5 June 2009 Thank you for having me here today as you start your work
More informationAustralia s super system stacks up well internationally. Ross Clare, Director of Research ASFA Research and Resource Centre
Australia s super system stacks up well internationally Ross Clare, Director of Research ASFA Research and Resource Centre January 2019 The Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia Limited (ASFA)
More informationAustralian Superannuation Transfer Guide
Australian Superannuation Transfer Guide Contents Page Making an informed decision 3 How do I know if I have Super in Australia? 3 How do I know if my Australian Super can be transferred? 4 Why should
More informationBudget repair and the changing size of Australia s government. Crawford Australian Leadership Forum John Daley, Grattan Institute June 2016
Budget repair and the changing size of Australia s government Crawford Australian Leadership Forum John Daley, Grattan Institute June 2016 Commonwealth expenditure is high relative to history; revenue
More informationRetirement Policy. the International Debate?
Susan St John What Has New Zealand s Retirement Policy Framework to Offer the International Debate? Introduction 1 New Zealanders don t realise that they are regularly regarded in other countries as world
More informationNATIONAL S ECONOMIC ROAD TEST JANUARY 2013 DAVID PARKER, LABOUR FINANCE SPOKESPERSON
NATIONAL S ECONOMIC ROAD TEST JANUARY 2013 DAVID PARKER, LABOUR FINANCE SPOKESPERSON 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS NATIONAL - MANAGING OUR DECLINE...3 AVERAGE ANNUAL ECONOMIC GROWTH: 1935-2012...3 UNEMPLOYMENT...5
More informationPlanning for the Future: What Women Need to Know About Social Security September 7, 2011
Planning for the Future: What Women Need to Know About Social Security September 7, 2011 Speakers for this Session Maria Freese Director of Government Relations and Policy, National Committee to Preserve
More informationSubmission on Automatic Enrolment Retirement Savings System. Strawman Consultation November 2018
Submission on Automatic Enrolment Retirement Savings System Strawman Consultation November 2018 Early Childhood Ireland is the largest representative of early childhood education and care settings in Ireland.
More informationTax Working Group Information Release. Release Document. September taxworkingroup.govt.nz/key-documents
Tax Working Group Information Release Release Document September 2018 taxworkingroup.govt.nz/key-documents This paper contains advice that has been prepared by the Tax Working Group Secretariat for consideration
More informationKIWISAVER ANNUAL REPORT 1 JULY JUNE 2016 B30A
KIWISAVER ANNUAL REPORT 1 JULY 2015 30 JUNE 2016 B30A Purpose of this report The main objective of the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) is to promote the development of fair, efficient and transparent
More informationKey Features of the WorkSave Pension Plan. This is an important document which you should keep in a safe place.
Key Features of the WorkSave Pension Plan This is an important document which you should keep in a safe place. Welcome to your Key Features Document. It explains all the important information you need
More informationFREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
New Zealand Defence Force Savings Schemes FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS NEW ZEALAND DEFENCE FORCE KIWISAVER SCHEME Is this scheme guaranteed by the Government or CDF? However, the legal framework for KiwiSaver
More informationInterTrade Ireland Economic Forum 25 November 2011 The jobs crisis: stylised facts and policy challenges
InterTrade Ireland Economic Forum 25 November 2011 The jobs crisis: stylised facts and policy challenges John P. Martin Director for Employment, Labour and Social Affairs, OECD The jobs crisis An unprecedented
More informationSCOTLAND S FISCAL DEFICIT
SCOTLAND S FISCAL DEFICIT or THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM SUMMARY REPORT 11th April 2016 1 Chart 1 25 SUMMARY Scotland's deficit billions 20 15 20 13 19 19 14 17 13 17 15 15 15 10 10 9 7 5 5 4 2 0 0 2010-11
More informationKIWISAVER ANNUAL REPORT
B30A KIWISAVER ANNUAL REPORT 1 July 2014 30 June 2015 fma.govt.nz AUCKLAND Level 5, Ernst & Young Building 2 Takutai Square, Britomart PO Box 106 672, Auckland 1143 Phone: +64 9 300 0400 Fax: +64 9 300
More informationAn employee s guide to auto enrolment
RETIREMENT An employee s guide to auto enrolment So, what is auto enrolment? Auto enrolment is the UK s workplace pensions initiative geared towards motivating the working population into saving towards
More informationInvestment Guide December 2015
Investment Guide December 2015 For members of the Hewlett Packard Enterprise Investment Scheme Your investment guide This guide is for members of the Hewlett Packard Enterprise Investment Scheme (the Scheme)
More informationDo I Really Need to Save for Retirement Now?
Do I Really Need to Save for Retirement Now? Retirement Savings Guide For PSERS Participants YES! Start Early. As an employee of Barrow County School System, your retirement plan has three parts: Part
More informationMinistry of Business, Innovation and Employment ( MBIE )
Kiwibank Limited and Gareth Morgan KiwiSaver Limited Joint submission to the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment ( MBIE ) on the Review of KiwiSaver Default Provider Arrangements Discussion
More informationCLARKS FLEXIBLE PENSION SCHEME YOUR MEMBER GUIDE
CLARKS FLEXIBLE PENSION SCHEME CLARKS FLEXIBLE PENSION SCHEME YOUR MEMBER GUIDE Page 1 1 WHY DO I NEED A PENSION? EVERYONE HAS A DIFFERENT IDEA OF WHAT THEY WANT IN THEIR LATER YEARS. MANY PEOPLE WILL
More informationZacks Earning Trends
November 5, 2014 Zacks Earning Trends Sheraz Mian SMian@Zacks.com Q4 Earnings Estimates Are Coming Down With more than 80% of Q3 results already on the books, the picture emerging from this reporting cycle
More informationWestern Power Distribution: consumerled pension strategy
www.pwc.com Western Power Distribution: consumerled pension strategy Workstream 3: Stakeholder engagement Phase 2 Domestic and Business bill-payers focus groups October 2016 Contents Workstream overview
More informationThe tax implications of pay, salary sacrifice, KiwiSaver and PIEs
The tax implications of pay, salary sacrifice, KiwiSaver and PIEs RPRC Briefing Paper 06/2007 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction
More informationDo I Really Need to Save for Retirement Now?
Do I Really Need to Save for Retirement Now? Retirement Savings Guide For TRS Participants YES! Start Early. As an employee of Barrow County School System, your retirement plan has three parts: Part 1:
More informationLocal Government Pension Scheme (LGPS)
A Brief Guide to the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) Employees in England and Wales April 2017 www.norfolkpensionfund.org If you need this information in large print, audio, Braille, alternative
More informationBudget repair and the size of Australia s government. Melbourne Economic Forum John Daley, Grattan Institute December 2015
Budget repair and the size of Australia s government Melbourne Economic Forum John Daley, Grattan Institute December 2015 Budget repair and the size of Australia s government Attitudes to the best approach
More informationThe main lessons to be drawn from the European financial crisis
The main lessons to be drawn from the European financial crisis Guido Tabellini Bocconi University and CEPR What are the main lessons to be drawn from the European financial crisis? This column argues
More informationMaking sense of the budget crisis. ACOSS National Conference John Daley Grattan Institute 11 June 2014
Making sense of the budget crisis ACOSS National Conference John Daley Grattan Institute 11 June 2014 Overview What sort of budget crisis do we have? Australia s debt levels are relatively manageable However,
More informationDeconstructing construction loans
Deconstructing construction loans The different types of construction loans There are a variety of construction contracts available and it s important you pick the right one for you. Here s 3 options to
More informationMaking it easier for borrowers to repay their student loans
Making it easier for borrowers to repay their student loans A government discussion document Hon Peter Dunne Minister of Revenue First published in June 2009 by the Policy Advice Division of Inland Revenue,
More informationPension Automatic Enrolment Your questions answered. This provides the answers to some of the questions that you have
Pension Automatic Enrolment Your questions answered This provides the answers to some of the questions that you have Q1 A1 Does automatic enrolment affect everyone? Starting from October 2012 (very large
More informationA guide to reviewing the. recommendations of the Retirement. Options Task Force. J. Daniel Hare *
A guide to reviewing the recommendations of the Retirement Options Task Force J. Daniel Hare * James A. Chalfant ** January 15, 2016 The report from the Retirement Options Task Force is lengthy and complex.
More informationGUIDE TO RETIREMENT PLANNING MAKING THE MOST OF THE NEW PENSION RULES TO ENJOY FREEDOM AND CHOICE IN YOUR RETIREMENT
GUIDE TO RETIREMENT PLANNING MAKING THE MOST OF THE NEW PENSION RULES TO ENJOY FREEDOM AND CHOICE IN YOUR RETIREMENT FINANCIAL GUIDE Green Financial Advice is authorised and regulated by the Financial
More informationBeing 50 and up in Australia today An investigation into the Cost of Living Pressures for the Over-50 s in Australia
Being 50 and up in Australia today An investigation into the Cost of Living Pressures for the Over-50 s in Australia September 2015 Message from Christopher Zinn The cost of living is a potent phrase much
More informationFirst-time employer s guide
First-time employer s guide Information you ll need if you re thinking of employing workers for the first time IR333 April 2018 Contents About this guide 3 Why paying tax matters 3 Are you an employer?
More informationEconomics of the Budget Deficit
Supporting Teachers: Inspiring Students Economics Revision Focus: 2004 AS & A2 Economics tutor2u (www.tutor2u.net) is the leading free online resource for Economics, Business Studies, ICT and Politics.
More informationNew PAYE and tax framework proposals an initial reaction
11 November 2015 Regular commentary from our experts on topical tax issues Issue 1 Today s documents raise building block questions as a foundation for New Zealand s 21 st century tax system The result
More informationPart I. Prepared Remarks to the Jacksonville Pension Reform Task Force David Draine 10/29/2013
Prepared Remarks to the Jacksonville Pension Reform Task Force David Draine 10/29/2013 Part I Good morning. It is my pleasure to present once again to the Jacksonville Task Force on Pension Reform. I would
More informationThe Local Government Pension Scheme
The Local Government Pension Scheme HR SHARED SERVICES PENSIONS TEAM EMPLOYEE GUIDE 2015 THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSION SCHEME (LGPS) employee guide 1 A BRIEF GUIDE TO THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSION SCHEME
More informationLifestages KiwiSaver Scheme Investment Statement
22 September 2016 The is brought to you by Funds Administration New Zealand Limited (FANZ). Investment Statement Important information (The information in this section is required under the Securities
More informationAn employee s guide to auto enrolment
RETIREMENT An employee s guide to auto enrolment So, what is auto enrolment? Auto enrolment is the UK s workplace pensions initiative geared towards motivating the working population into saving towards
More informationWhy do people have SMSFs?
Introduction Depending on what you read, views on self managed superannuation funds range from them being either the greatest invention of the modern age or the most likely cause of the next great financial
More informationAuto Enrolment - Effective 1 st August 2014 Hanson Ship Management. Presentation dated: 28th May 2014
Auto Enrolment - Effective 1 st August 2014 Hanson Ship Management Presentation dated: 28th May 2014 A change in the law affecting everyone To help people save more for their retirement, the government
More informationWorkplace pensions AUTO ENROLMENT HAS TAKEN OFF
Workplace pensions AUTO ENROLMENT HAS TAKEN OFF INTRODUCTION The Government introduced auto enrolment to help more people save for their future. It means your employer will have to give you access to a
More informationwe make it easy for you
Insurance Guide PDS Supplement we make it easy for you Dated 30 September 2017 CARE Super Pty Ltd (Trustee) ABN 91 006 670 060 AFSL 235226 CARE Super (Fund) ABN 98 172 275 725 PDS Supplement The information
More information17. Social Security. Congress should allow workers to privately invest at least half their Social Security payroll taxes through individual accounts.
17. Social Security Congress should allow workers to privately invest at least half their Social Security payroll taxes through individual accounts. Although President Bush failed in his efforts to reform
More informationPOST-CABINET PRESS CONFERENCE: MONDAY, 31 OCTOBER
31 October 2017 POST-CABINET PRESS CONFERENCE: MONDAY, 31 OCTOBER 2017 Good afternoon, everyone. We have held our second Cabinet meeting this afternoon, and this press conference gives me an opportunity
More informationWelcome to Canada. I welcome the opportunity to share with you the journey our national pension plan has been on over the past 15 years.
Welcome to Canada. I welcome the opportunity to share with you the journey our national pension plan has been on over the past 15 years. I have a short presentation, and then will be happy to answer any
More informationAdditional information about your superannuation
Elphinstone Group Superannuation Fund 19 March 2018 Additional information about your superannuation Contents Important information 1 How super works 2 Benefits of investing with the Elphinstone Group
More informationHSAs: A retirement saving tool?
HSAs: A retirement saving tool? Lula Tadesse: The rapid growth of health savings accounts, or HSAs, in recent years has created more opportunities for individuals to save for retirement and other long-term
More informationJanuary A guide to your. retirement options
January 2016 A guide to your retirement options Contents Section Page Introduction 4 Questions about you for you to think about 5 State Pensions Deferring Your State Pension 8 Voluntary National Insurance
More informationPlum Super Product Disclosure Statement
Plum Super Product Disclosure Statement MySuper compliant This Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) is a summary of significant information and contains references to further important information available
More information