STRATHCLYDE DISCUSSION PAPERS IN ECONOMICS CAN MIGRANTS SAVE GREECE FROM AGEING? A COMPUTABLE GENERAL EQUILIBRIUM APPROACH USING G-AMOS.
|
|
- Whitney Bradford
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 STRATHCLYDE DISCUSSION PAPERS IN ECONOMICS CAN MIGRANTS SAVE GREECE FROM AGEING? A COMPUTABLE GENERAL EQUILIBRIUM APPROACH USING G-AMOS. BY NIKOS PAPPAS NO DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS UNIVERSITY OF STRATHCLYDE GLASGOW
2 Can Mgrants save Greece from Ageng? A Computable General Equlbrum Approach usng G-AMOS. Pappas, N. Fraser of Allander nsttute, Department of Economcs, Unversty of Strathclyde n Glasgow, UK Abstract: The populaton of Greece s projected to age n the course of the next three decades. Ths paper combnes demographc projectons wth a mult-perod economc Computable General Equlbrum (CGE) modellng framework to assess the macroeconomc mpact of these future demographc trends. The smulaton strategy adopted n Lsenkova et. al. (2008) s also employed here. The sze and age composton of the populaton n the future depends on current and future values of demographc parameters such as the fertlty, mortalty rates and the level of annual net mgraton. We use FIV-FIV software n order to project populaton changes for 30 years. Total populaton and workng age populaton changes are ntroduced to the G- AMOS modellng framework calbrated for the Greek economy for the year Postve net mgraton s able to cancel the negatve mpacts of an ageng populaton that would otherwse occur as a result of the shrnkng of the labour force. The polcy mplcaton s that a vable, long-lastng mgraton polcy should be mplemented, whle the mportance of polces that could ncrease fertlty should also be consdered. JEL classfcaton: J11, J21 Key words: CGE modellng, ageng populaton, mgraton, demography, Greece Acknowledgements: I would lke to thank Grant Allan, Karen Turner, Peter McGregor and Km Swales of the Fraser of Allander Insttute for useful comments. I would also lke to thank Katya Lsenkova for comments on demographc modellng. The usual dsclamer apples. 2
3 1. Introducton As n most western countres, populaton n Greece s projected to declne and age. Greece has tradtonally been a country of out-mgraton. However, n the last two decades the populaton outflow has reversed. Ths has generated a stock of foregn populaton, whch s estmated to be close to 10% of the natonals 1 (Konts et. al., 2006). Ths has been a real demographc shock. In contrast, the country has experenced a declnng fertlty rate (1.3 n 2004) and a contnuously ncreasng lfe expectancy. Fertlty rates n Greece have been lower than the European average untl the end of the 60 s and peaked durng the 70 s but never acheved the levels reached n the baby boom perod n Europe. The baby boom n Greece was late and small due to the poltcal nstablty of the post World War II perod. However, the fertlty rate has largely converged to the European average durng the last two decades. If the assumptons of ESYE (Natonal Statstcs Agency) on future trends of demographc varables (fertlty, mortalty, mgraton) materalse, then n the course of the next three decades (by 2034) s projected to ncrease slghtly by 0.54%. However at the same tme workng age populaton s expected to decrease by 6.13%. Under the same assumptons but wthout the presence of mgraton total populaton wll fall by 11.5% and workng age populaton by 19.76%. We are gong to try and analyse the mpacts, of these future demographc trends. At present very lttle attenton s pad to the macroeconomc mpacts that these wll have n the foreseeable future. Exstng lterature focuses on the mpacts of mmgraton upon the economy. Lanos (1996) found that wages of (llegal) mmgrants n Northern Greece were 40-60% lower than the ones of the local populaton. He also found that the vast majorty of mmgrants take jobs that the locals would never do. Ths study s rather descrptve, and thus does not assess the mpact of mmgraton on macroeconomc varables n a quantfable way. Sarrs and Zografaks (1999) use a Computable General Equlbrum model to assess the mpact of llegal mmgraton upon the Greek economy. In ther exercse, populaton stock s only adjusted by a one shot nflux of llegal mmgrants n the Greek economy. They fnd that almost a thrd of the 1 Contrary to many countres Greece defnes foregners by blood and not by brth. So, there are people that have been born n the country but have not got ctzenshp. In contrast, others have not been born and brought up n the country but are granted ctzenshp. So, when we refer to foregners we may nclude people that have been born n the country. 3
4 populaton s adversely affected from llegal mmgraton. However, the negatve mpact dsappears when they model labour market rgdtes. (Fxed nomnal wage). The paper at hand adds to the relevant lterature n lnkng demographc projectons wth consstent economc modellng. Thus t sheds lght on the effect of current and future fertlty, mortalty and mgraton trends wth the use of consstent economc and demographc modellng. Whle demographc changes have many economc mplcatons that are related to publc expendture, expected ncrease n demand for health care, fundng of pensons of a growng aged populaton etc., the focus of ths paper s to assess the mpact of future demographc trends upon the economy through the consequent changes n the labour market. We combne a demographc model, (FIV-FIV) and a Computable General Equlbrum (CGE) model of the Greek Economy (G-AMOS) calbrated for the year The projecton and smulaton horzon s three decades, a span that s long enough to allow for the populaton changes to be fed nto the rest of the economy and at the same tme not too long to make our populaton projectons completely unrelable. The remander of the paper s structured as follows. The next secton provdes the theoretcal framework upon whch our analyss s based. The two followng sectons provde detals on the demographc and the economc model. The economc mpact of the base projecton s dscussed n secton 5. Secton 6 focuses on senstvty analyss that we have performed by varyng values of demographc as well as economc parameters. Secton 7 concludes. 2. Theoretcal settng In ths secton we outlne the theoretcal foundaton for the smulaton results that are reported n the subsequent sectons. The focal pont s the labour market, whch s analysed usng an aggregate labour demand and supply framework (Lsenkova et.al., 2008). We present a long run approach, n order to dentfy the drecton n whch we expect the equlbrum wages and employment to move as the tme passes. Fgure 1 represents the nteracton of the labour supply and general equlbrum labour demand curves n the unfed Greek labour market, a unfed labour market, n whch workers can freely move between the dentfed sectors. When the workng age populaton s unchanged (n our case ths s equvalent to an unchanged labour force), the quantty 4
5 2 of labour suppled can only ncrease f the real wage s ncreased. The general equlbrum Labour demand s slopng downwards and ths s the case for most of the research that has utlsed the AMOS modellng framework (Gllmartn et. al. 2007, Lsenkova et. al. 2008, Turner, 2002). However, for combnatons of extreme product demand and factor substtuton elastctes, the general equlbrum labour demand curve can be upward slopng (McGregor et al, 1995). Note that the endogenously determned level of household ncome wll also affect labour demand n the general equlbrum. Fgure 1- Impact of an ageng and declnng populaton Wage NS 2034 NS 2004 W n, 2034 B W n, 2004 A ND 2004 ND 2034 N 2034 N 200 Employment In Fgure 1 we compare the long-run labour market equlbrum n 2034 wth that n 2004, under the assumpton that the base populaton projecton apples and that real per capta expendture of the Greek government remans constant. As mentoned before n the smulaton exercse there s no demand shock mposed assocated wth the ageng of the populaton. Instead, the assumpton s that government expendture per capta remans constant. One would expect that consumer and government demand patterns are age specfc and therefore shftng demographcs would alter the ndustral composton of consumer and government demand. However, for now we wll assume that government expendture per head remans constant over the smulaton perod. That s government expendture follows the changes of total populaton. The ntal equlbrum s represented by pont A, where the base-perod 2 We actually use a wage curve specfcaton for the labour market. (Blanchflower and Oswald, 1994; Layard et a ). 5
6 (2004) labour demand and supply curves ND 2004 and NS 2004 ntersect. Ths generates the ntal equlbrum employment and real wage levels w n,2004, N As mentoned before, over the perod up to 2034, the total populaton n Greece wll ncrease margnally but at the same tme age. Frst, the lower workng age populaton reduces labour supply at each wage level generatng an nward shft of the labour supply curve. The new labour supply curve NS 2034, s on the left of the orgnal labour supply curve NS On the other hand total populaton changes wll affect labour demand through changes n government expendture. The new demand curve s on the rght of the orgnal because durng ths perod government expendture (an element of fnal demand) ncreases n lne wth the slght ncrease of total populaton. The new equlbrum B, s at the ntersecton of the general equlbrum labour demand and supply curves ND 2034 and NS Both labour supply and labour demand shft have pushed the real wage upwards. However, whle ncreased labour demand tends to ncrease employment whle decreased labour supply tends to decrease t. We expect the supply effect to be of greater magntude n ths case. Fgure 2 - The Labour Market n 2034 comparng base projectons and hgher postve net mgraton every year Wage NS BASE B NS MIG W BASE W MIG C N BASE N MIG ND BASE ND MIG Employment In Fgure 2 we expand our nvestgaton to show the mpact on the labour market n 2034 of ncreased nward mgraton. Fgure 2 compares the labour market n 2034 under two dfferent scenaros. One smply takes the base populaton projecton. The second represents a stuaton n whch there s hgher postve net n-mgraton. Ths s 6
7 a polcy parameter that can be altered mmedately at the wll of the Greek government 3. The stuaton under the base projecton s gven by pont B, whch s the ntersecton of the labour demand and supply functons NS 2034, ND Ths was the fnal poston llustrated n Fgure 1. Now mpose net n-mgraton at a rate hgher than that assumed under base scenaro. Workng age populaton, and therefore the labour force, s gong to be hgher than under the base predcton for Ths s llustrated n Fgure 2 by an outward shft of the labour supply curve to NS MIG. Labour demand wll also shft outwards to ND MIG as a result of hgher populatonlnked government expendture. The new equlbrum s at pont C, the ntersecton of the new labour supply and demand curves. In ths case the shfts n labour demand and supply both work to ncrease equlbrum employment (compared to the equlbrum at B). Further, because we expect that the ncrease n labour supply wll domnate the ncrease n labour demand, pressure n the labour market should ease and the wage fall. The two fgures exhbt the mpact of populaton ageng and n-mgraton on the labour market. We expect these changes to have major mpacts through a tghtenng of the labour market, and consequences upon compettveness. These labour market changes wll have major mpacts on the economy overall. In partcular, wth an ageng populaton, we expect a negatve effect upon compettveness due to the ncreased wage, whch s a major cost of producton. Ths reduced compettveness has a negatve mpact on GDP. In mgraton s expected to counteract the tghtenng of the labour market (Sarrs and Zografaks, 1999). The Computable General Equlbrum framework we use allows us to explore such mpacts n greater detal by consstently modellng all the complex nteractons wthn the economy whle t gve us a suffcent degree of detal n terms of results. 3 An extensve dscusson of the current mgraton polcy n Greece can be found n Konts et. al. (2006) as well as n Katrougalos et.al. (2004) 7
8 3. The FIV-FIV software The software produces populaton projecton by usng the cohort component method, whch s the most wdely used. The cohort component method tracks each cohort and ts mortalty, fertlty, and mgraton over tme. Startng wth a base populaton, year-by-year deaths are subtracted, and brths and net mgraton are added to the populaton. Ths program allows us to project future populaton by sex and age structure, based on the current age-sex structure and addtonal assumptons about man demographc varables: mortalty, fertlty and mgraton. Projectons are made n fve-year cycles and can nvolve fve to nfnte years. Brths create a cohort of the age 0-4 at the end of the cycle. The rest of the cohorts face a probablty of mortalty and ther survvors are fve years older n the end of the cycle. Net mgraton s algebracally added to cohorts durng the cycle. The defned cohorts are presented n the followng table. Table 1 Cohorts dentfed n the FIV-FIV software Cohort Intal Fnal Cohort Intal Fnal ndex Age Age ndex Age Age 0 Born In the end of every cycle, the populaton of the cohorts 15 and 16 are added together to form the group 75+. Projectons are separately done for men and women. The frst step s to calculate the populaton alve n the begnnng of the cycle, whch comprses of cohorts one to sxteen. The second step s to calculate the populaton of cohort zero whch s the remanng and s born durng the cycle. Populaton alve s calculated by takng nto account the effect of mortalty for each cohort. That s: 8
9 (1) C F s,c = C I s,c Ss,c Where, C stands for the populaton of cohort c, sex s at a date 0 or fve ndcated by the superscrpt. S s the survval rate for each cohort. Mgraton s ncorporated the followng way. It s assumed that mgrants enter or leave the country followng a unform dstrbuton durng the fve year cycle. So, mgrants are exposed to mortalty for an average of one half of the cycle. Therefore for mgraton to be taken nto account the equaton above should be augmented the followng way. (2) C F s,c = C I S + M (1+ S )/2 for the cohorts one to sxteen. s,c s,c s,c s,c The number of brths wll depend on the number and age of women n chldbearng age, and ther age specfc fertlty rates. Women of the age group are the ones consdered of beng chldbearng age. These are seven cohorts, namely 15-19, 20-24, 25-29, 30-34, 35-39, 40-44, and The mean number of women wth a probablty of havng a chld for each of these cohorts wll be: (3) P = (P F F,C+ P I F,C)/2 where s the cohort ndex. The number of women s ether gven when we have superscrpt of zero, (snce t s gven by the prevous step) or calculated survval n the precedng when superscrpt s fve. The number of brths s calculated by usng age specfc fertlty rates, F, and for the whole cycle total number of brths wll be: 10 (4) B = 5 Σ 4 (P F ) F,C C Brths are calculated for males and females separately. Adjustng for the proporton of each gender and the correspondng survval rates males and females of the brth cohort are: (5a) C F 5 f,0 = g B S f,0 (5b) C = (1- g) B S m,0 m,0 Where g s the proporton of females born. Agan n order to augment the above equatons for mgraton we need to make assumptons about the tme and age dstrbuton of mgrants. The assumpton s that mgrants come n followng a unform dstrbuton, durng the fve year perod and that brths are equally dstrbuted between all ages 0 to 5. Ths s a suffcent approxmaton f we assume that the probablty of dyng declne n a lnear manner from brth untl the age of 5. Ths s not partcularly true especally for the newborns. In addton, very few mgrants are of the age of some 9
10 weeks or months. The software does not requre makng assumptons related to nfant mortalty of mgrants. Instead t adjusts arbtrarly the above approxmaton and assumes that the survval rate comes n wth a factor of one thrd nstead of a half. Equatons 5a and 5b take the form: (6a) C 5 f,0 = g B S s f,0 + M f,0 (2/3+1/3 S f,0 ) (6b) C 5 = (1- g) B S + M (2/3+1/3 S ) m,0 s m,0 m,0 m,0 We have now calculated the new cohort and the projecton to the next fve-year cycle s complete. In the next step each cohort ndex s ncreased by one and the fnal populaton of cohort s used as the ntal populaton of cohort +1. The data we have used for the projecton s publshed by ESYE. However there have been some gaps n data avalablty. For example, a problem we have faced s the fact that there s no data for the age and sex composton of mgrants. We have therefore assumed that mgrants have the age and sex composton of the foregn populaton of the country. The lack of data, that has been mentoned elsewhere (Konts et.al., 2006) as well as the software structure has caused small dscrepances between the ESYE Base projecton and the projecton we have generated under the same assumptons for the demographc varables. We are gong to refer to ths projecton as the Base scenaro although there are small dscrepances. The sze of these devatons s neglgble n relaton to the queston at hand. 10
11 4. G-AMOS: The Economc Model G-AMOS stands for Greek-AMOS, whch uses the AMOS modellng framework. (A Macro-Mcro Model Of Scotland) and has been developed by a team of researchers n the Unversty of Strathclyde. It s referred to as a Computable General Equlbrum modellng framework because t encompasses a range of behavoural assumptons, reflected n equatons whch can be actvated and confgured n many dfferent ways (Harrgan et al, 1991, p. 424). A wde range of model closures as well as parameter values s avalable to the user, as approprate for partcular applcatons. A good general descrpton of CGE modellng s gven n Greenaway et al (1992) and an extensve revew of regonal CGE models can be found n Partrdge and Rckman (1998). We have calbrated the G-AMOS modellng framework to data on the Greek economy gven n the form of a Socal Accountng Matrx (SAM) for the year The model has 3 transactor groups - households, frms and government - and 2 exogenous external transactors the rest of the EU (REU) and the rest of the world (ROW). The model has 25 actvtes/commodtes and these are lsted n Table A1.1 n Appendx 1. A condensed account of the model structure s gven n Table A2.1. In the verson of AMOS used here, producton takes place n perfectly compettve ndustres usng mult-level producton functons. Ths means that n every tme perod all commodty markets are n equlbrum, wth prce equal to the margnal cost of producton. Value-added s produced usng captal and labour va standard producton functon formulatons so that, n general, factor substtuton occurs n response to relatve factor-prce changes. Typcally, constant elastcty of substtuton (CES) technology s adopted, whch s the case n smulatons reported here. 4 In each ndustry ntermedate purchases are modelled as the demand for a composte commodty wth fxed (Leontef) coeffcents. These are substtutable for mported commodtes va an Armngton lnk. The composte nput then combnes wth valueadded (captal and labour) n the producton of each sector s gross output. Cost mnmsaton drves the ndustry cost functons (equaton 1 n Table A2.1) and the factor demand functons (equatons 7 and 8 n Table A2.1). 4 Leontef and Cobb-Douglas optons are avalable as specal cases. 11
12 Whlst the AMOS framework offers a wde choce of labour market closures, n the smulatons reported here the labour market s charactersed by a regonal barganng functon (also expressed as a wage curve, represented as equaton 5 n Table A2.1). Ths establshes a negatve relatonshp between the real wage and the unemployment rate (Mnford et al, 1994). Emprcal support for ths wage curve specfcaton s now wdespread (Blanchflower and Oswald 1994). The barganng functon s parametersed usng the regonal econometrc work reported n Layard et al. (1991): ln 0.113ln 0.40ln rwnt, = a ut+ rwnt, 1 where rw s the Greek real wage, u s the Greek unemployment rate, t s the tme subscrpt and a s a calbrated parameter. 5 To transform the real wage to the nomnal wage, we multply by the consumer prce ndex (equaton 2 n Table A2.1). Nevertheless, senstvty analyss has been performed n secton 6 where we examne extreme cases for the closure of the labour market. Perfect labour moblty s assumed between sectors, generatng a unfed labour market. Therefore, although wage rates vary between sectors n the base-year data set, n the smulatons wages n all sectors change by the same proportonate amount n response to exogenous shocks. The nomnal wage n each tme perod s then derved through the nteracton of the resultng wage curve and the general equlbrum labour demand curve (equaton 9 n Table A2.1). In the dervaton of the general equlbrum labour demand curve, t s mportant to note that all prces and ncomes are taken to be endogenous. The four man components of commodty fnal demand (represented by equaton 12 n Table A2.1) are consumpton, nvestment, government expendture and exports. Household consumpton s a lnear homogenous functon of real dsposable ncome and relatve prces (equatons 2, 11 and 13 n Table A2.1). Real government expendture per head s assumed to be constant (equaton 17, Table A2.1) and n these smulatons the populaton s determned exogenously usng the demographc model. 5 The calbraton s made so that the model, together wth the set of exogenous varables, wll recreate the base year data set. Ths calbrated parameter does not nfluence smulaton outputs, but the assumpton of ntal equlbrum s, of course, mportant. 12
13 Exports are determned by exogenous external demand va an Armngton lnk, makng exports relatve prce senstve (equaton 18, Table A2.1). The modellng of nvestment demand s a lttle more complex. In the mult-perod varant of the model, captal stock adjustment at the sectoral level, whch ultmately determnes aggregate nvestment demand, s dealt wth n the followng way. Wthn each tme perod, both the total captal stock and ts sectoral composton are fxed. The nteracton between ths fxed captal supply and captal demand at the sectoral level determnes each sector s captal rental rate (equaton 10, Table A2.1). The captal stock n each sector s then updated between perods va a smple captal stock adjustment procedure, accordng to whch nvestment equals deprecaton plus some fracton of the gap between the desred and actual level of the captal stock (equatons 6, 14 and 15 n Table A2.1). 6 Desred captal stocks are determned on costmnmsaton crtera, usng the user cost of captal as the relevant prce of captal (equatons 3 and 4 n Table A2.1). In the base perod the economy s assumed to be n long-run equlbrum, where desred and actual captal stocks are equal, wth nvestment smply equal to deprecaton. Investment as a source of product demand s then determned by runnng the demand for ncreased captal stock by sector through the captal matrx (equaton 16, Table A2.1). We nterpret the conceptual tme perods of the model as years: annual data are used for the calbraton and, where applcable, the estmaton of parameter values. As stated earler n ths secton, the structural characterstcs of the AMOS model are parametersed on a Socal Accountng Matrx (SAM) for Greece for In all sectors, the elastcty of substtuton between captal and labour n the producton of value added s 0.3 although senstvty analyss s conducted. Intermedate composte goods are assumed to be produced by a Leontef type producton procedure wth fxed coeffcents. Ths s requred because of the large number of zero entres. The default Armngton trade elastctes for mports and exports are 8.0. Ths s to reflect the fact that the country s consdered to be a prce taker n nternatonal markets. Sarrs and Zografaks (1999) also appled a hgh value of Armngton elastcty whle Ioakmoglou (1999) econometrcally estmated that 80% of varaton of prces n Greece s attrbutable to nternatonal prce changes. Nevertheless senstvty analyss 6 Ths process of captal accumulaton s compatble wth a smple theory of optmal frm behavour gven the assumpton of quadratc adjustment costs. The whole process s analogous to Tobn s q. 13
14 usng the values of 2, 5 and 8 s performed later on. The speed of adjustment parameter for the adjustment of actual to desred captal stock s 0.5. Before dscussng the smulaton results t s mportant to clarfy a key characterstc of the G-AMOS model. G-AMOS s not a forecastng model. When t s parametersed on the base year data set, t s assumed that the economy s n long-run equlbrum. If there are no changes to the exogenous varables and the model s run n perod-by-perod mode, then the model wll smply report an unchangng economy. Results are presented as percentage changes from the base year value and thus demonstrate devatons from what would occur f nothng happened n the economy. 5. The Consequences for the Greek Economy of the Base scenaro for the projected populaton ESYE has examned three scenaros of future demographc trends. These are labelled low, medum, hgh and the related assumptons on the values of demographc parameters are shown n fgures 3,4 and 5. Fertlty s recorded to be 1.29 n the year Under the low scenaro t assumed to fall to 1.19 chldren per woman n chldbearng age by For the medum and hgh scenaros the correspondng fgures are 1.53 and 1.87 respectvely. Fgure 3 below shows the assumed trends. Fgure 3- Assumpton for the fertlty rate Low Medum Hgh
15 Lfe expectancy s assumed to rse n a lnear manner and to reach for men years, years, years n 2050 for the low medum and hgh scenaros respectvely. The correspondng numbers for women are 83.19, 85.32, Below we see the graphcal representaton of the assumptons beng made. Fgure 4- Lfe expectancy assumptons Men Low Men Medum Men Hgh Women Low Women Medum Women Hgh Fnally, the medum scenaro assumes that net-mgraton wll reman constant at the current level of 40,000 per annum. In the hgh scenaro the assumpton s Fgure 5- Assumptons for net mgraton Low Medum Hgh Usng the medum values for fertlty, lfe expectancy and net mgraton we have generated a populaton projecton for three decades after our base year whch suffcently approxmates the projected populaton by ESYE under the medum 15
16 assumptons. The table below shows changes for total and workng age populaton for fve year perods and the fgure shows the correspondng trajectores for our base scenaro. Table 2- Total and workng age populaton under the base scenaro % change Total % 1.4% 1.1% 0.5% -0.8% -2.8% -6.1% % change 0.0% 1.3% 2.0% 2.2% 1.9% 1.3% 0.5% Fgure 6- Percentage changes n total and workng age populaton under the base scenaro 3.00% 2.00% 1.00% 0.00% -1.00% -2.00% -3.00% -4.00% -5.00% -6.00% -7.00% Workng populaton changes Total populaton By 2034 the total populaton s expected to be 11.1 mllon people, whch s an ncrease of 0.54%. However, the group falls to mllon, a fall of 6.1% snce the year These exogenously generated populaton changes are fed nto the economc model as explaned above. The table below presents changes n the man macroeconomc varables. Table 3 - The mpact of the BASE demographc projectons on Greek aggregate economc ndcators GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI As we expect from the theoretcal dscusson, employment falls, n ths case by 3.23% n 2034, wth a correspondng declne n GDP of a lttle less at 2.82%. Note that because of the lnearsaton of the change n the workng age populaton n the 16
17 model, the results shown n Table 1 wll overestmate the reducton n the ntal years, where an ncrease n output and employment s expected, but underestmate the rate (but not the level) of declne n the latter perod of the smulaton where workng age populaton s fallng. One thng to notce s that the fall n employment s lower than the fall n workng age populaton. Workng age populaton falls by 6.13% whlst employment only declnes by 3.23%, mplyng an ncrease n the partcpaton rate and a fall n the unemployment rate to partally offset the negatve supply sde mpacts. Ths tghtenng of the Greek labour market s apparent as we see ncreases n nomnal and real Greek take home wage of 2.40% and 2.48% respectvely by the year GDP and employment follow a very smlar pattern as shown n Fgure 7. GDP falls both because of supply and demand effects. On the demand sde although we have an ncrease n government expendture, whch s appled n some sectors, both export demand and household demand fall because of the compettveness effect and reduced labour ncome respectvely. Remember we have assumed a hgh value of Armngton elastcty n order to reflect the fact that the country s largely a prcetaker. Changes n real and nomnal wage are shown n Fgure 8. Fgure 9 shows the CPI and export prce ndces. Although wth small devatons consumer prces ntally ncrease and then fall below equlbrum. By 2034 the prce of the composte exported good that has been calculated as the weghted average of the prce of exported commodtes rses by 0.35%. As a consequence, the demand for exported goods falls by 2.85%. From the supply sde, n each sector the captal stock wll adjust to changes n output demand but more slowly than the changes n employment so that the change n GDP wll slghtly lag the changes n total employment. There wll also be a tendency for producton to become more captal ntensve as the nomnal wage ncreases, so that there s some substtuton of captal for labour. 7 There s not full pass through of the ncreased wages to prces, that s prces ncrease by less than wages, prmarly because of the presence of mports from outwth Greece as elements of the consumpton basket and as ntermedate nputs n producton. 17
18 Fgure 7- Percentage Change of GDP and Employment GDP Employment Fgure 8- Percentage changes of nomnal and real after tax wage Wages - nomnal Wages - real Fgure 9 - Percentage changes for cp and the exported prce ndex Consumer Prce Index (CPI) Export Prce Index
19 The fact that prces do not move upwards mmedately s somethng to notce. In a smple back of the envelope model of a two good prce taker economy that s presented n Appendx 3, t can be shown that n the short run prces wll move up or down dependng on the relatve labour ntensty of the exportng and non exportng sectors. It should be noted that when we run the model forward for more perods than our conventonal projecton horzon, and the negatve supply shock becomes bgger, prces do move upwards. Fgure 10 shows the changes by 2034 n sectoral output and employment generated by the base demographc projecton for Greece. At ths stage we must underlne once agan, that we do not take nto account any compostonal changes n government and household demand that may sprng from the changes n age composton of the populaton. For example, there s much dscusson of the mplcatons for health care and educaton provson resultng from longer lfe expectancy (Economc Polcy Commttee and European Commsson, 2006). Such compostonal demand changes are lkely to be mportant but they are not the subject of ths paper. These dsaggregated results therefore prmarly reflect more general demand-sde factors. These are the extent to whch the sector supples export, nvestment, and household consumpton or government demand. Fgure 10- Impact on sectoral output and employment. (Percentage changes by the year 2034) Food Products Beverages Tobacco Agrculture Huntng Forestry Fshng Mnng and Quarrng Textles Leather Footwear Wood Paper Prntng Publshng Machnery Equpment Coke Refned Petroleum Product Other Manufacturng Transport Equpment etc Electrcty Gas and Water Supply Constructon Wholesale Retal Transport and Storage Hotels and Restaurants Employment Post Telecommuncatons Fnance Insurance Real Estate Actvtes Rentng Machnery Equpment Output Research and Development Computer and Related Actvtes Other Busness Actvtes Publc Admn Educaton Health and Socal Work Other Servces By 2034 most sectors wll exhbt lower employment and output than equlbrum. There s a wde varaton n the mpacts, rangng from an output ncrease of 0.3% for Publc Admnstraton output to a decrease of 5.9% for Transport and 19
20 Storage. In general those sectors sellng most of ther output to government demand (Publc Admnstraton, Health and Socal Work, Educaton) are affected least because government expendture, whch n these smulatons s lnked to total populaton, remans relatvely constant over the whole smulaton perod, and t actually ncreases by only 0.54% by In addton these sectors are sheltered n the sense that they are not subject to nternatonal competton. The extent of the negatve effect upon other sectors (whch are mostly ht much harder) s determned by two factors. Frst, labour ntensve sectors are worst affected because of the ncreased cost of labour. Second, the sectors that are more exposed to nternatonal trade feel the negatve compettveness effect more strongly. For example, sectors such as Agrculture Huntng Forestry Fshng clearly suffer these negatve compettveness effects. Transport and Storage s the sector that realses the bggest decrease. Ths s somethng that should be attrbuted to the hgh labour ntensty and export propensty of the sector. However, Coke and refned Petroleum Products s labour exportng a lot (31% of output) but s not so labour ntensve (7% of nput goes to wages) and thus the negatve mpact appears to be only -2.6%. As argued above, n all sectors employment falls by more than output because as the prce of labour rses frms substtute labour for captal and captal stock takes tme to adjust to optmal levels. 6. Senstvty analyss It s well known n CGE lterature that closures of markets are partcularly mportant n the generaton of results. The AMOS modellng framework allows a range of labour market closures. In order to test how senstve the results are to varaton n labour market assumptons, we conducted smulatons usng the base populaton projecton under two lmtng cases. The frst mposes wthn-perod fxed labour supply. Ths means that labour supply s a gven proporton of the labour force, where the labour force s adjusted perod-by-perod through demographc changes. There s therefore assumed to be no unemployment or partcpaton rate adjustment as the labour market tghtens. In any ndvdual tme perod, ths stuaton s represented by a vertcal labour supply curve. The second, alternatve, assumpton s that there s so much slack n the local labour market that an ncrease n labour demand s met by a change n employment but no change n the real wage. In ths case, n each tme perod the labour supply curve would be horzontal and employment adjusts to 20
21 changes n labour demand through changes n the unemployment and partcpaton rates. In the fxed labour supply case we expect the employment reducton and the wage ncrease to be larger than under our base case. In the fxed real wage scenaro, the opposte results hold: we expect the employment to fall and the wage ncrease to be less than n the conventonal wage curve confguraton. When we attempt to run the model wth a fxed real wage, we get a relatvely stable GDP trend whle under the fxed labour supply closure GDP follows the lnear reducton that we exogenously mpose to the labour force. In a smlar smulaton by Lsenkova et. al (2008) the model fals to solve. The problem s that n ths case the model produces a negatve unemployment rate. The key practcal pont s smply ths: the populaton constrants mpled by demographc projectons, combned wth fxed government expendture per head, put upward pressure on wages and contnuously reduce unemployment. On the other hand, where labour supply s completely nelastc, the whole adjustment to the labour force contracton must come through hgher wages. As we have argued already, we expect employment and output to fall by more under ths labour market closure, as partcpaton and unemployment rates are not allowed to adjust. Ths wll be combned wth an even grater pressure upon wages. The fgure below shows GDP trends for the dfferent labour market closures. In Table 3 I present the percentage changes n the man aggregate ndcators for 2034 under the fxed labour supply, fxed real wage and wage curve labour market closures. Fgure 11- GDP trends under dfferent labour market closures %change FLS RWR Barganng year 21
22 Table 4- Man aggregate ndcators n 2034 under dfferent labour market closures Gross Domestc Product Employment Unemployment Consumer Prce Index Real after tax consumpton wage Barganng Fxed Real Fxed Labour (LNJ estmates) Wage Supply Indeed our results are consstent wth what economc theory suggests. Employment wth fxed labour supply s expected to fall by 6.13%, exactly n lne wth the reducton n the labour force (and workng age populaton), whlst under the barganng closure the employment reducton s only -3.23%. In the case of fxed real wage we have a mnor change of 0.14%, whch s generated, by the demand changes that I have exogenously mposed. The correspondng fgures for GDP are -5.41%, % and -0.01% respectvely. The wage rate shows a reducton of an ncrease of 2.48% under the Barganng closure and a 4.11% ncrease under fxed labour supply. By defnton there s no change under the fxed real wage closure. Unemployment falls to 7.34% (from 9.12%) under Barganng whle under fxed real wage t lands at 5.30% as the labour market s purely quantty clearng. By defnton, under fxed labour supply, the unemployment rate remans unaltered. We have also tested how senstve these economc results are to changes n the value of captal labour elastcty as well as to changes n the value of Armngton elastcty. The values we have mposed for the elastcty of substtuton between captal and labour are 0.8 and 1, whch corresponds to the Cobb-Douglas case. For the Armngton elastcty we have mposed 2.0, whch s the value that s most commonly used, and 5.0. Recall that the value mposed n the analyss of the mpacts of the base scenaro s 8.0. The table below presents the changes n the man aggregate ndcators under each scenaro. 22
23 Table 5- Man Aggregate Indcators by 2034 under dfferent values of elastcty of substtuton between local and mported goods and elastcty of labour and captal substtuton (BASE) (CD) 0.3 CES 1 CES 0.8 CES 0.3 CES 0.3 CES Arm.=8 Arm.=8 Arm.=8 Arm.=5 Arm.=2 GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI The expectaton s, that wth the mposton of a negatve labour supply shock employment wll fall more rapdly n the cases where substtutablty between captal and labour s easer as frms lay off workers n the lght of ncreased wages. Indeed employment falls by more under the Cobb-Douglas assumpton by less when we have elastcty of substtuton equallng 0.8 and even by less wth the value of 0.3. Reversely, the wage rate ncreases by more the lower the substtutablty between captal and labour. When layng off workers s not easy more pressure falls upon wages. In partcular by the year 2034 employment falls by 4.58%, 4.38% and 3.23% for the values of unty (Cobb-Douglas), 0.8 and 0.3 respectvely. The correspondng fgures for GDP are 3.93%, 3.79%, 2.82% respectvely. When lookng at real wage, not surprsngly the rankng s reversed and the correspondng mpacts are 1.26%, 1.43%, 2.48%. The fgure below, shows GDP trajectores for dfferent degrees of substtutablty. Fgure 12 - GDP trends under dfferent values of elastcty of substtuton between captal and labour %change year Cobb Douglas 0.8 CES BASE
24 It should be noted that although the results are obvously dependng on the values of elastctes, the magntude of the varaton can be consdered of mnor mportance n relaton to the varaton that s caused by varyng demographc parameters as we shall see n the next secton. We have also mposed dfferent values of elastctes for the substtuton of local and foregn produced goods. In ths case, the hgher the value of elastcty, the easer t s for frms to substtute local wth foregn nputs. Thus, the more dampenng the mpact wll be for the local economy. As the labour market tghtens, producng goods locally becomes more expensve and local goods are substtuted by mports. The easer ths swtch the worse the news for the local economy s employment and GDP. Alternatvely, the wage rate ncreases by more the lower the substtutablty between local and mported goods. When mport substtuton s dffcult frms nsst on producng locally. Fnally, we expect that the hgher the value of elastcty the less the prce of exported goods (nverse of compettveness) wll devate from zero. In fact mposng elastcty to equal nfnty would be equvalent to assumng that the law of one prce holds. The values of elastctes we have mposed are 2,5 and 8. Indeed, employment falls by 2.77% when the value of elastcty s 2, by 3.11% when elastcty s 5 and 3.23% when t s 8. For GDP the correspondng fgures 2.30%, 2.69% and 2.82% respectvely. As expected the rankng of mpacts s agan reversed when one looks at the behavour of real wages and prce of exported goods. Hence the correspondng ncreases of real wage are 2.94%, 2.60% and 2.48% respectvely. The fgures for compettveness are 1.12%, 0.53% and 0.35% wth the mpact of elastcty beng even clearer. Agan, as before the magntude of devatons n the results s small and one can clam that the values of these elastctes are not the factors that generate the results. The fgure below shows the trajectores of GDP under dfferent assumptons. 24
25 Fgure 13 - GDP trends under dfferent values of elastcty of substtuton between local and mported goods %change Armngton 2 Armngton BASE (8 Armngton) year 7. Varant demographc scenaros Havng checked the senstvty of results to dfferent labour market closures and key elastcty values we turn to assessng the senstvty of results to varyng demographc parameters. These parameters are the fertlty rate, the male and female lfe expectancy, and the net-mgraton rate. The tables below summarse the combnaton of assumptons that s used n each scenaro and gve the projected changes of total and workng age populaton by 2034 n each case. Table 6 Combnaton of assumptons for each demographc scenaro Scenaro Fertlty Lfe expectancy Mgraton 1 Base projecton Base Base Base 2 Hgh fertlty Hgh Base Base 3 Low fertlty Low Base Base 4 Hgh lfe expectancy Base Hgh Base 5 Low lfe expectancy Base Low Base 6 Hgh mgraton Base Base Hgh 7 Low mgraton Base Base Low 25
26 Table 7 Percentage changes of total and workng age populaton by 2034 under dfferent scenaros % -6.13% Total % 0.5% BASE Low Hgh Low Hgh Low Hgh Scenaro Expectancy Expectancy fertlty Fertlty Mgraton Mgraton % -5.81% -7.2% -4.8% % 0.68% % 1.8% -1.7% 3.6% -5.5% 6.6% Comparng the columns of table 6 we see that the varaton n net-mgraton s the demographc varable that causes the greater varaton n the sze of total and workng age populaton and thus n sze of shocks ntroduced nto the economc model. The amount of net mgraton assumed n the low mgraton scenaro s 20,000 per year whle n the hgh mgraton scenaro t s 60,000 per year. The values of fertlty and lfe expectancy are the ones that are assumed by ESYE n the correspondng scenaros and presented n secton 5. In partcular, assumng hgh and low lfe expectancy results n GDP beng 2.57% and 2.99% below base respectvely by The correspondng fgures when we vary fertlty are -1.94% and 3.55%. However, the dscrepancy of results between the scenaros of hgh and low netmgraton s much bgger. Assumng low (20,000) net-mgraton results n GDP beng 6.86% below base, but assumng hgh mgraton results n GDP beng above base by 0.88%. The paramount mportance of net-mgraton has led us to generate further scenaros by varyng even more the amount of net-mgraton whle holdng the other two varables constant. We generate a scenaro wth zero net mgraton as well as scenaros that nvolve 80,000 and 100,000 annual net-mgraton. The results summarsed n the table and the fgures below are llumnatng and the postve mpact of n-mgraton s very apparent. Note that n the scenaro where we assume zero net mgraton (natural change only) GDP falls by 11.33% n
27 Table 8 Man aggregate economc ndcators for dfferent net-mgraton scenaros BASE GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI Zero Gross Domestc Product Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI Low Mgraton (20,000) GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI Hgh Mgraton (60,000) GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI Eghty GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI Hundred GDP Real wage Unemployment Employment Export Prce Index CPI
28 Fgure 14 - GDP % change under dfferent scenaros for the amount of annual mgraton %change Hgh Mgraton BASE Low year Mgraton eghty hundred Fgure 15 Real wage % change under dfferent scenaros for the amount of annual mgraton 6.00 %change Hgh Mgraton BASE Low Mgraton eghty hundred year The mportance of net-mgraton stems from the fact that mgrants due to ther age structure have an mmedate mpact upon the sze of the workng age populaton as a great deal of them s wthn the age-group. The thng to notce s that the hgher the level of mgraton the hgher the GDP and lower the real wage. The result to hghlght s that only wth scenaros that nvolve 60,000 postve net-mgraton per annum or more wll the GDP reman above equlbrum levels. In ths case the real wage remans practcally stable as the level of net-mgraton s completely off settng the tghtenng of the labour market. The results of the economc model are consstent wth the theoretcal framework, whch we put n place n Secton 2 and they are manly drven by the labour market and the subsequent mpact on compettveness. Fgure 15 shows the real wage change 28
29 assocated wth the dfferent mgraton scenaros. In ths case, the 60,000 n-mgraton case produces a neglgble change n the real wage. We know that n ths smulaton, the workng age populaton s rsng, but more slowly than the total populaton. In terms of the analyss n Secton 2, the outward shft of the labour demand curve, as government expendture rses n lne wth total populaton, s greater than the outward shft n the labour supply curve as the workng age populaton ncreases. There s therefore an ncrease n employment but also a small ncrease n the wage. However, for the examples where n-mgraton s less than 60,000, the wage ncrease s much greater and s not accompaned by any expanson n government expendture. 8. Conclusons Ths paper attempts to explore the consequences of projected demographc developments n Greece. We have nteracted a demographc model (FIV-FIV) and an economc model G-AMOS whch s an economc model for the Greek economy. We conclude that f current demographc trends contnue, that s under what we call the base scenaro there wll be a negatve mpact upon economc actvty, whch wll stem from a tghtenng of the labour market. GDP falls by 2.82% whle the real wage ncreases by 2.48% n the next three decades. Employment also falls by 3.23%. The demographc varable wth the greatest mportance appears to be the level of annual net-mgraton. Mgrants are manly of younger ages and are often accompaned wth chldren, and thus ther presence tends to mtgate the tendency for populaton ageng. The mportance of net-mgraton s apparent n the results of the zero net-mgraton scenaro. Ths scenaro answers the followng queston. What would happen f Greek borders close completely and the Greek populaton changes depend only on the underlyng brth rate and lfe expectancy? Ths s the worst scenaro of all the ones we have examned and t reveals to a great extend the postve mpact that mgrants have had and wll contnue to have n the years to come. Accordng to ths scenaro, GDP and employment fall by 11.33% and 12.99% respectvely whle the real wage ncreases by 8.33%. Remember that n the course of ths paper we have not examned, the mpacts of a change n the composton of publc and prvate demand that may occur due to a change n the demographcs, nether we have explored the mpact of the lkely 29
Macroeconomic Impacts of Demographic Change in Scotland: A Computable General Equilibrium Analysis
Macroeconomc Impacts of Demographc Change n Scotland: A Computable General Equlbrum Analyss Katya Lsenkova Unversty of Strathclyde Peter McGregor Unversty of Strathclyde Nkos Pappas Unversty of Strathclyde
More informationQuiz 2 Answers PART I
Quz 2 nswers PRT I 1) False, captal ccumulaton alone wll not sustan growth n output per worker n the long run due to dmnshng margnal returns to captal as more and more captal s added to a gven number of
More informationMacroeconomic equilibrium in the short run: the Money market
Macroeconomc equlbrum n the short run: the Money market 2013 1. The bg pcture Overvew Prevous lecture How can we explan short run fluctuatons n GDP? Key assumpton: stcky prces Equlbrum of the goods market
More information2) In the medium-run/long-run, a decrease in the budget deficit will produce:
4.02 Quz 2 Solutons Fall 2004 Multple-Choce Questons ) Consder the wage-settng and prce-settng equatons we studed n class. Suppose the markup, µ, equals 0.25, and F(u,z) = -u. What s the natural rate of
More informationUniversity of Toronto November 9, 2006 ECO 209Y MACROECONOMIC THEORY. Term Test #1 L0101 L0201 L0401 L5101 MW MW 1-2 MW 2-3 W 6-8
Department of Economcs Prof. Gustavo Indart Unversty of Toronto November 9, 2006 SOLUTION ECO 209Y MACROECONOMIC THEORY Term Test #1 A LAST NAME FIRST NAME STUDENT NUMBER Crcle your secton of the course:
More informationUniversity of Toronto November 9, 2006 ECO 209Y MACROECONOMIC THEORY. Term Test #1 L0101 L0201 L0401 L5101 MW MW 1-2 MW 2-3 W 6-8
Department of Economcs Prof. Gustavo Indart Unversty of Toronto November 9, 2006 SOLUTION ECO 209Y MACROECONOMIC THEORY Term Test #1 C LAST NAME FIRST NAME STUDENT NUMBER Crcle your secton of the course:
More informationFall 2017 Social Sciences 7418 University of Wisconsin-Madison Problem Set 3 Answers
ublc Affars 854 enze D. Chnn Fall 07 Socal Scences 748 Unversty of Wsconsn-adson roblem Set 3 Answers Due n Lecture on Wednesday, November st. " Box n" your answers to the algebrac questons.. Fscal polcy
More informationRaising Food Prices and Welfare Change: A Simple Calibration. Xiaohua Yu
Rasng Food Prces and Welfare Change: A Smple Calbraton Xaohua Yu Professor of Agrcultural Economcs Courant Research Centre Poverty, Equty and Growth Unversty of Göttngen CRC-PEG, Wlhelm-weber-Str. 2 3773
More informationWelfare Aspects in the Realignment of Commercial Framework. between Japan and China
Prepared for the 13 th INFORUM World Conference n Huangshan, Chna, July 3 9, 2005 Welfare Aspects n the Realgnment of Commercal Framework between Japan and Chna Toshak Hasegawa Chuo Unversty, Japan Introducton
More informationElements of Economic Analysis II Lecture VI: Industry Supply
Elements of Economc Analyss II Lecture VI: Industry Supply Ka Hao Yang 10/12/2017 In the prevous lecture, we analyzed the frm s supply decson usng a set of smple graphcal analyses. In fact, the dscusson
More information>1 indicates country i has a comparative advantage in production of j; the greater the index, the stronger the advantage. RCA 1 ij
69 APPENDIX 1 RCA Indces In the followng we present some maor RCA ndces reported n the lterature. For addtonal varants and other RCA ndces, Memedovc (1994) and Vollrath (1991) provde more thorough revews.
More informationMODELLING SECTORAL SPILLOVERS FOR REGIONAL CAPITAL SUBSIDIES USING AMOS
European Regonal Scence Assocaton 36th European Congress ETH Zurch, Swtzerland 26-30 August 996 Erc P. McVtte Aberdeen Busness School, The Robert Gordon Unversty Aberdeen, UK Emal: bmsepm@bs-staff.rgu.ac.uk
More informationImpacts of Population Aging on Economic Growth and Structure Change in China
Impacts of Populaton Agng on Economc Growth and Structure Change n Chna The feature of Chnese demographc structure s changng from a hgh fertlty rate, hgh death rate and low lfe expectancy to low fertlty
More informationMicroeconomics: BSc Year One Extending Choice Theory
mcroeconomcs notes from http://www.economc-truth.co.uk by Tm Mller Mcroeconomcs: BSc Year One Extendng Choce Theory Consumers, obvously, mostly have a choce of more than two goods; and to fnd the favourable
More informationSTRATHCLYDE DISCUSSION PAPERS IN ECONOMICS. The Impact of the Barnett Formula on the Scottish Economy: A General Equilibrium Analysis
STRATHCLYDE DISCUSSION PAPERS IN ECONOMICS The Impact of the Barnett Formula on the Scottsh Economy: A General Equlbrum Analyss BY Lnda Ferguson, Davd Learmonth, Peter G McGregor, J Km Swales and Karen
More informationSpatial Variations in Covariates on Marriage and Marital Fertility: Geographically Weighted Regression Analyses in Japan
Spatal Varatons n Covarates on Marrage and Martal Fertlty: Geographcally Weghted Regresson Analyses n Japan Kenj Kamata (Natonal Insttute of Populaton and Socal Securty Research) Abstract (134) To understand
More informationDomestic Savings and International Capital Flows
Domestc Savngs and Internatonal Captal Flows Martn Feldsten and Charles Horoka The Economc Journal, June 1980 Presented by Mchael Mbate and Chrstoph Schnke Introducton The 2 Vews of Internatonal Captal
More informationReal Exchange Rate Fluctuations, Wage Stickiness and Markup Adjustments
Real Exchange Rate Fluctuatons, Wage Stckness and Markup Adjustments Yothn Jnjarak and Kanda Nakno Nanyang Technologcal Unversty and Purdue Unversty January 2009 Abstract Motvated by emprcal evdence on
More informationLECTURE 3. Chapter # 5: Understanding Interest Rates: Determinants and Movements
LECTURE 3 Hamza Al alk Econ 3215: oney and ankng Wnter 2007 Chapter # 5: Understandng Interest Rates: Determnants and ovements The Loanable Funds Approach suggests that nterest rate levels are determned
More informationMacroeconomic Theory and Policy
ECO 209 Macroeconomc Theory and Polcy Lecture 7: The Open Economy wth Fxed Exchange Rates Gustavo Indart Slde 1 Open Economy under Fxed Exchange Rates Let s consder an open economy wth no captal moblty
More informationUNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM
UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS DISCUSSION PAPER 99/28 Welfare Analyss n a Cournot Game wth a Publc Good by Indraneel Dasgupta School of Economcs, Unversty of Nottngham, Nottngham NG7 2RD,
More information15-451/651: Design & Analysis of Algorithms January 22, 2019 Lecture #3: Amortized Analysis last changed: January 18, 2019
5-45/65: Desgn & Analyss of Algorthms January, 09 Lecture #3: Amortzed Analyss last changed: January 8, 09 Introducton In ths lecture we dscuss a useful form of analyss, called amortzed analyss, for problems
More informationINTRODUCTION TO MACROECONOMICS FOR THE SHORT RUN (CHAPTER 1) WHY STUDY BUSINESS CYCLES? The intellectual challenge: Why is economic growth irregular?
INTRODUCTION TO MACROECONOMICS FOR THE SHORT RUN (CHATER 1) WHY STUDY BUSINESS CYCLES? The ntellectual challenge: Why s economc groth rregular? The socal challenge: Recessons and depressons cause elfare
More informationPrice and Quantity Competition Revisited. Abstract
rce and uantty Competton Revsted X. Henry Wang Unversty of Mssour - Columba Abstract By enlargng the parameter space orgnally consdered by Sngh and Vves (984 to allow for a wder range of cost asymmetry,
More informationTests for Two Correlations
PASS Sample Sze Software Chapter 805 Tests for Two Correlatons Introducton The correlaton coeffcent (or correlaton), ρ, s a popular parameter for descrbng the strength of the assocaton between two varables.
More informationCHAPTER 9 FUNCTIONAL FORMS OF REGRESSION MODELS
CHAPTER 9 FUNCTIONAL FORMS OF REGRESSION MODELS QUESTIONS 9.1. (a) In a log-log model the dependent and all explanatory varables are n the logarthmc form. (b) In the log-ln model the dependent varable
More informationTHE VOLATILITY OF EQUITY MUTUAL FUND RETURNS
North Amercan Journal of Fnance and Bankng Research Vol. 4. No. 4. 010. THE VOLATILITY OF EQUITY MUTUAL FUND RETURNS Central Connectcut State Unversty, USA. E-mal: BelloZ@mal.ccsu.edu ABSTRACT I nvestgated
More information5. Market Structure and International Trade. Consider the role of economies of scale and market structure in generating intra-industry trade.
Rose-Hulman Insttute of Technology GL458, Internatonal Trade & Globalzaton / K. Chrst 5. Market Structure and Internatonal Trade Learnng Objectves 5. Market Structure and Internatonal Trade Consder the
More informationHomework 4 Answer Key
Economcs 141 UCSC Professor Kletzer Sprng 2017 Homework 4 Answer Key 1. Use producton functon and MPK dagrams to examne Turkey and the EU. Assume that Turkey and the EU have dfferent producton functons
More informationECO 209Y MACROECONOMIC THEORY AND POLICY LECTURE 8: THE OPEN ECONOMY WITH FIXED EXCHANGE RATES
ECO 209 MACROECONOMIC THEOR AND POLIC LECTURE 8: THE OPEN ECONOM WITH FIXED EXCHANGE RATES Gustavo Indart Slde 1 OPEN ECONOM UNDER FIXED EXCHANGE RATES Let s consder an open economy wth no captal moblty
More informationMacroeconomic Theory and Policy
ECO 209 Macroeconomc Theory and Polcy Lecture 7: The Open Economy wth Fxed Exchange Rates Gustavo Indart Slde 1 Open Economy under Fxed Exchange Rates Let s consder an open economy wth no captal moblty
More informationAn Application of Alternative Weighting Matrix Collapsing Approaches for Improving Sample Estimates
Secton on Survey Research Methods An Applcaton of Alternatve Weghtng Matrx Collapsng Approaches for Improvng Sample Estmates Lnda Tompkns 1, Jay J. Km 2 1 Centers for Dsease Control and Preventon, atonal
More informationII. Random Variables. Variable Types. Variables Map Outcomes to Numbers
II. Random Varables Random varables operate n much the same way as the outcomes or events n some arbtrary sample space the dstncton s that random varables are smply outcomes that are represented numercally.
More informationFinance 402: Problem Set 1 Solutions
Fnance 402: Problem Set 1 Solutons Note: Where approprate, the fnal answer for each problem s gven n bold talcs for those not nterested n the dscusson of the soluton. 1. The annual coupon rate s 6%. A
More informationc slope = -(1+i)/(1+π 2 ) MRS (between consumption in consecutive time periods) price ratio (across consecutive time periods)
CONSUMPTION-SAVINGS FRAMEWORK (CONTINUED) SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 The Graphcs of the Consumpton-Savngs Model CONSUMER OPTIMIZATION Consumer s decson problem: maxmze lfetme utlty subject to lfetme budget constrant
More informationLinear Combinations of Random Variables and Sampling (100 points)
Economcs 30330: Statstcs for Economcs Problem Set 6 Unversty of Notre Dame Instructor: Julo Garín Sprng 2012 Lnear Combnatons of Random Varables and Samplng 100 ponts 1. Four-part problem. Go get some
More informationStochastic ALM models - General Methodology
Stochastc ALM models - General Methodology Stochastc ALM models are generally mplemented wthn separate modules: A stochastc scenaros generator (ESG) A cash-flow projecton tool (or ALM projecton) For projectng
More informationProblem Set 6 Finance 1,
Carnege Mellon Unversty Graduate School of Industral Admnstraton Chrs Telmer Wnter 2006 Problem Set 6 Fnance, 47-720. (representatve agent constructon) Consder the followng two-perod, two-agent economy.
More informationAnswers to exercises in Macroeconomics by Nils Gottfries 2013
. a) C C b C C s the ntercept o the consumpton uncton, how much consumpton wll be at zero ncome. We can thnk that, at zero ncome, the typcal consumer would consume out o hs assets. The slope b s the margnal
More informationHighlights of the Macroprudential Report for June 2018
Hghlghts of the Macroprudental Report for June 2018 October 2018 FINANCIAL STABILITY DEPARTMENT Preface Bank of Jamaca frequently conducts assessments of the reslence and strength of the fnancal system.
More informationProductivity Levels and International Competitiveness 5 Between Canada and the United States
Productvty Levels and Internatonal Compettveness 5 Between Canada and the Unted States Frank C. Lee and Janmn Tang 5.1 Introducton T HE PURPOSE OF THIS PAPER s to compare total factor productvty (TFP)
More informationCANADA I. BASIC "T3ICAT0RS
Trade Development Summary September 1953 CANADA I. BASIC "T3ICAT0RS (a) Producton The rate of ncrease n ndustral producton s not losng any of ts momentum, and output durng the frst four months of the year
More informationClearing Notice SIX x-clear Ltd
Clearng Notce SIX x-clear Ltd 1.0 Overvew Changes to margn and default fund model arrangements SIX x-clear ( x-clear ) s closely montorng the CCP envronment n Europe as well as the needs of ts Members.
More informationA MODEL OF COMPETITION AMONG TELECOMMUNICATION SERVICE PROVIDERS BASED ON REPEATED GAME
A MODEL OF COMPETITION AMONG TELECOMMUNICATION SERVICE PROVIDERS BASED ON REPEATED GAME Vesna Radonć Đogatovć, Valentna Radočć Unversty of Belgrade Faculty of Transport and Traffc Engneerng Belgrade, Serba
More informationMonetary Tightening Cycles and the Predictability of Economic Activity. by Tobias Adrian and Arturo Estrella * October 2006.
Monetary Tghtenng Cycles and the Predctablty of Economc Actvty by Tobas Adran and Arturo Estrella * October 2006 Abstract Ten out of thrteen monetary tghtenng cycles snce 1955 were followed by ncreases
More information3/3/2014. CDS M Phil Econometrics. Vijayamohanan Pillai N. Truncated standard normal distribution for a = 0.5, 0, and 0.5. CDS Mphil Econometrics
Lmted Dependent Varable Models: Tobt an Plla N 1 CDS Mphl Econometrcs Introducton Lmted Dependent Varable Models: Truncaton and Censorng Maddala, G. 1983. Lmted Dependent and Qualtatve Varables n Econometrcs.
More informationWork, Offers, and Take-Up: Decomposing the Source of Recent Declines in Employer- Sponsored Insurance
Work, Offers, and Take-Up: Decomposng the Source of Recent Declnes n Employer- Sponsored Insurance Lnda J. Blumberg and John Holahan The Natonal Bureau of Economc Research (NBER) determned that a recesson
More informationA Utilitarian Approach of the Rawls s Difference Principle
1 A Utltaran Approach of the Rawls s Dfference Prncple Hyeok Yong Kwon a,1, Hang Keun Ryu b,2 a Department of Poltcal Scence, Korea Unversty, Seoul, Korea, 136-701 b Department of Economcs, Chung Ang Unversty,
More informationEconomics 1410 Fall Section 7 Notes 1. Define the tax in a flexible way using T (z), where z is the income reported by the agent.
Economcs 1410 Fall 2017 Harvard Unversty Yaan Al-Karableh Secton 7 Notes 1 I. The ncome taxaton problem Defne the tax n a flexble way usng T (), where s the ncome reported by the agent. Retenton functon:
More informationAnalyzing Economic Structural Change in a General Equilibrium Framework: The case of Switzerland from 1990 to 2001
Analyzng Economc Structural Change n a General Equlbrum Framework: The case of Swtzerland from 1990 to 2001 Laurent Cretegny Ecoplan, Swtzerland May 1, 2005 Abstract Structural change s nfluenced by many
More informationLecture Note 2 Time Value of Money
Seg250 Management Prncples for Engneerng Managers Lecture ote 2 Tme Value of Money Department of Systems Engneerng and Engneerng Management The Chnese Unversty of Hong Kong Interest: The Cost of Money
More informationSurvey of Math: Chapter 22: Consumer Finance Borrowing Page 1
Survey of Math: Chapter 22: Consumer Fnance Borrowng Page 1 APR and EAR Borrowng s savng looked at from a dfferent perspectve. The dea of smple nterest and compound nterest stll apply. A new term s the
More informationConsumption Based Asset Pricing
Consumpton Based Asset Prcng Mchael Bar Aprl 25, 208 Contents Introducton 2 Model 2. Prcng rsk-free asset............................... 3 2.2 Prcng rsky assets................................ 4 2.3 Bubbles......................................
More informationRandom Variables. b 2.
Random Varables Generally the object of an nvestgators nterest s not necessarly the acton n the sample space but rather some functon of t. Techncally a real valued functon or mappng whose doman s the sample
More informationPolitical Economy and Trade Policy
Poltcal Economy and Trade Polcy Motvaton When asked why no free trade?, most nternatonal economsts respond t must be poltcs In representatve democraces, trade polcy shaped not only by general electorate,
More informationECONOMETRICS - FINAL EXAM, 3rd YEAR (GECO & GADE)
ECONOMETRICS - FINAL EXAM, 3rd YEAR (GECO & GADE) May 17, 2016 15:30 Frst famly name: Name: DNI/ID: Moble: Second famly Name: GECO/GADE: Instructor: E-mal: Queston 1 A B C Blank Queston 2 A B C Blank Queston
More information4. Greek Letters, Value-at-Risk
4 Greek Letters, Value-at-Rsk 4 Value-at-Rsk (Hull s, Chapter 8) Math443 W08, HM Zhu Outlne (Hull, Chap 8) What s Value at Rsk (VaR)? Hstorcal smulatons Monte Carlo smulatons Model based approach Varance-covarance
More informationTHE CONTRIBUTION OF ICT TO ECONOMIC ACTIVITY: A GROWTH ACCOUNTING EXERCISE WITH SPANISH FIRM-LEVEL DATA
THE CONTRIBUTION OF ICT TO ECONOMIC ACTIVITY: A GROWTH ACCOUNTING EXERCISE WITH SPANISH FIRM-LEVEL DATA Ignaco Hernando and Soledad Núñez Banco de España Banco de España Servco de Estudos Documento de
More informationMgtOp 215 Chapter 13 Dr. Ahn
MgtOp 5 Chapter 3 Dr Ahn Consder two random varables X and Y wth,,, In order to study the relatonshp between the two random varables, we need a numercal measure that descrbes the relatonshp The covarance
More informationSpring 2018 Social Sciences 7418 University of Wisconsin-Madison. Transactions and Portfolio Crowding Out
Economcs 44 Menze D. Cnn Sprng 8 Socal Scences 748 Unversty of Wsconsn-Madson. Standard IS-LM Transactons and Portfolo Crowdng Out Transactons crowdng out of nvestment s te reducton n nvestment attrbutable
More information- contrast so-called first-best outcome of Lindahl equilibrium with case of private provision through voluntary contributions of households
Prvate Provson - contrast so-called frst-best outcome of Lndahl equlbrum wth case of prvate provson through voluntary contrbutons of households - need to make an assumpton about how each household expects
More informationEconomic Design of Short-Run CSP-1 Plan Under Linear Inspection Cost
Tamkang Journal of Scence and Engneerng, Vol. 9, No 1, pp. 19 23 (2006) 19 Economc Desgn of Short-Run CSP-1 Plan Under Lnear Inspecton Cost Chung-Ho Chen 1 * and Chao-Yu Chou 2 1 Department of Industral
More informationQuiz on Deterministic part of course October 22, 2002
Engneerng ystems Analyss for Desgn Quz on Determnstc part of course October 22, 2002 Ths s a closed book exercse. You may use calculators Grade Tables There are 90 ponts possble for the regular test, or
More informationEvaluating Performance
5 Chapter Evaluatng Performance In Ths Chapter Dollar-Weghted Rate of Return Tme-Weghted Rate of Return Income Rate of Return Prncpal Rate of Return Daly Returns MPT Statstcs 5- Measurng Rates of Return
More informationNet Pension Liabilities, Intergener Title and Pension Reforms.
Net Penson Labltes, Intergener Ttle and Penson Reforms Author(s) Osho, Takash Ctaton Issue 2002-2 Date Type Techncal Report Text Verson publsher URL http://hdl.handle.net/0086/4486 Rght Htotsubash Unversty
More informationPRESS RELEASE. CONSUMER PRICE INDEX: December 2016, annual inflation 0.0% HELLENIC REPUBLIC HELLENIC STATISTICAL AUTHORITY Piraeus, 11 January 2017
HELLENIC EPUBLIC HELLENIC STATISTICAL AUTHOITY Praeus, 11 January 2017 PESS ELEASE CONSUME PICE INDE: December 2016, annual nflaton % The Consumer Prce Index (CPI), wth reference year 2009=10, n December
More informationGOODS AND FINANCIAL MARKETS: IS-LM MODEL SHORT RUN IN A CLOSED ECONOMIC SYSTEM
GOODS ND FINNCIL MRKETS: IS-LM MODEL SHORT RUN IN CLOSED ECONOMIC SSTEM THE GOOD MRKETS ND IS CURVE The Good markets assumpton: The producton s equal to the demand for goods Z; The demand s the sum of
More informationPRESS RELEASE. The evolution of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of March 2017 (reference year 2009=100.0) is depicted as follows:
HELLENIC EPUBLIC HELLENIC STATISTICAL AUTHOITY Praeus, Aprl 27 PESS ELEASE CONSUME PICE INDEX: March 27, annual nflaton.7% The evoluton of the Consumer Prce Index (CPI) of March 27 (reference year 29=.)
More informationMeasures of Spread IQR and Deviation. For exam X, calculate the mean, median and mode. For exam Y, calculate the mean, median and mode.
Part 4 Measures of Spread IQR and Devaton In Part we learned how the three measures of center offer dfferent ways of provdng us wth a sngle representatve value for a data set. However, consder the followng
More informationBilateral Trade Flows and Nontraded Goods
Blateral Trade Flos and Nontraded Goods Yh-mng Ln Department of Appled Economcs, Natonal Chay Unversty, Taan, R.O.C. Emal: yxl173@mal.ncyu.edu.t Abstract Ths paper develops a monopolstc competton model
More informationMaturity Effect on Risk Measure in a Ratings-Based Default-Mode Model
TU Braunschweg - Insttut für Wrtschaftswssenschaften Lehrstuhl Fnanzwrtschaft Maturty Effect on Rsk Measure n a Ratngs-Based Default-Mode Model Marc Gürtler and Drk Hethecker Fnancal Modellng Workshop
More informationIn the 1990s, Japanese economy has experienced a surge in the unemployment rate,
Productvty Growth and the female labor supply n Japan Yoko Furukawa * Tomohko Inu Abstract: In the 990s, Japanese economy has experenced a surge n the unemployment rate, and ths s due partly to the recent
More informationRisk and Return: The Security Markets Line
FIN 614 Rsk and Return 3: Markets Professor Robert B.H. Hauswald Kogod School of Busness, AU 1/25/2011 Rsk and Return: Markets Robert B.H. Hauswald 1 Rsk and Return: The Securty Markets Lne From securtes
More informationEPPE6024: Macroeconomics Lecture 2: Aggregate Demand (AD), Aggregate Supply (AS), and Business Cycle
EE6024: Macroeconomcs Lecture 2: Aggregate Demand (AD), Aggregate Suppl (AS), and Busness Ccle The Goods Market: the IS curve IS curve shows the combnaton of the nterest rates and output level at whch
More informationEDC Introduction
.0 Introducton EDC3 In the last set of notes (EDC), we saw how to use penalty factors n solvng the EDC problem wth losses. In ths set of notes, we want to address two closely related ssues. What are, exactly,
More informationSolution of periodic review inventory model with general constrains
Soluton of perodc revew nventory model wth general constrans Soluton of perodc revew nventory model wth general constrans Prof Dr J Benkő SZIU Gödöllő Summary Reasons for presence of nventory (stock of
More informationFORD MOTOR CREDIT COMPANY SUGGESTED ANSWERS. Richard M. Levich. New York University Stern School of Business. Revised, February 1999
FORD MOTOR CREDIT COMPANY SUGGESTED ANSWERS by Rchard M. Levch New York Unversty Stern School of Busness Revsed, February 1999 1 SETTING UP THE PROBLEM The bond s beng sold to Swss nvestors for a prce
More informationSpurious Seasonal Patterns and Excess Smoothness in the BLS Local Area Unemployment Statistics
Spurous Seasonal Patterns and Excess Smoothness n the BLS Local Area Unemployment Statstcs Keth R. Phllps and Janguo Wang Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Research Department Workng Paper 1305 September
More informationThe Integration of the Israel Labour Force Survey with the National Insurance File
The Integraton of the Israel Labour Force Survey wth the Natonal Insurance Fle Natale SHLOMO Central Bureau of Statstcs Kanfey Nesharm St. 66, corner of Bach Street, Jerusalem Natales@cbs.gov.l Abstact:
More informationAnalysis of the Influence of Expenditure Policies of Government on Macroeconomic behavior of an Agent- Based Artificial Economic System
Analyss of the Influence of Expendture olces of Government on Macroeconomc behavor of an Agent- Based Artfcal Economc System Shgeak Ogbayash 1 and Kouse Takashma 1 1 School of Socal Systems Scence Chba
More informationTaxation and Externalities. - Much recent discussion of policy towards externalities, e.g., global warming debate/kyoto
Taxaton and Externaltes - Much recent dscusson of polcy towards externaltes, e.g., global warmng debate/kyoto - Increasng share of tax revenue from envronmental taxaton 6 percent n OECD - Envronmental
More informationIndustrial specialisation, trade, and labour market dynamics in a multisectoral model of technological progress. Robert Stehrer*)
DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS JOHANNES KEPLER UNIVERSITY OF LINZ Industral specalsaton, trade, and labour market dynamcs n a multsectoral model of technologcal progress by Robert Stehrer*) Workng Paper No. 0102
More informationUniform Output Subsidies in Economic Unions versus Profit-shifting Export Subsidies
nform Output Subsdes n Economc nons versus Proft-shftng Export Subsdes Bernardo Moreno nversty of Málaga and José L. Torres nversty of Málaga Abstract Ths paper focuses on the effect of output subsdes
More informationDecember 2012 SECTORAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO LABOUR PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH IN CANADA: DOES THE CHOICE OF DECOMPOSITION FORMULA MATTER?
December 2012 1 151 Slater Street, Sute 710 Ottawa, Ontaro K1P 5H3 613-233-8891, Fax 613-233-8250 csls@csls.ca CENTRE FOR THE STUDY OF LIVING STANDARDS SECTORAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO LABOUR PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH
More informationWeek 02, Lecture 03 Detailed Listing and Derivation of Accounting Equations
Wee 02, Lecture 03 Detaled Lstng and Dervaton of Accountng Equatons In the GTAP Data Base all the equlbrum condtons hold. The pre-smulaton data base also represents the ntal or pre-smulaton equlbrum. The
More information4: SPOT MARKET MODELS
4: SPOT MARKET MODELS INCREASING COMPETITION IN THE BRITISH ELECTRICITY SPOT MARKET Rchard Green (1996) - Journal of Industral Economcs, Vol. XLIV, No. 2 PEKKA SULAMAA The obect of the paper Dfferent polcy
More informationFall 2016 Social Sciences 7418 University of Wisconsin-Madison. Transactions and Portfolio Crowding Out
Economcs 435 Menze D. Cnn Fall 6 Socal Scences 748 Unversty of Wsconsn-Madson. Standard IS-LM Transactons and ortfolo Crowdng Out Transactons crowdng out of nvestment s te reducton n nvestment attrbutable
More informationoccurrence of a larger storm than our culvert or bridge is barely capable of handling? (what is The main question is: What is the possibility of
Module 8: Probablty and Statstcal Methods n Water Resources Engneerng Bob Ptt Unversty of Alabama Tuscaloosa, AL Flow data are avalable from numerous USGS operated flow recordng statons. Data s usually
More informationChapter 5 Bonds, Bond Prices and the Determination of Interest Rates
Chapter 5 Bonds, Bond Prces and the Determnaton of Interest Rates Problems and Solutons 1. Consder a U.S. Treasury Bll wth 270 days to maturty. If the annual yeld s 3.8 percent, what s the prce? $100 P
More informationThe Economic Impact of Health Care Provision: A Preliminary CGE Assessment for the UK 1. University of Nottingham
The Economc Impact of Health Care Provson: A Prelmnary CGE Assessment for the UK 1 Martne Rutten, 2 Adam Blake 3 and Geoffrey Reed 4 Unversty of Nottngham 1. Introducton Ths paper presents some prelmnary
More informationTests for Two Ordered Categorical Variables
Chapter 253 Tests for Two Ordered Categorcal Varables Introducton Ths module computes power and sample sze for tests of ordered categorcal data such as Lkert scale data. Assumng proportonal odds, such
More informationCh Rival Pure private goods (most retail goods) Non-Rival Impure public goods (internet service)
h 7 1 Publc Goods o Rval goods: a good s rval f ts consumpton by one person precludes ts consumpton by another o Excludable goods: a good s excludable f you can reasonably prevent a person from consumng
More informationProductivity growth, skill bias and sanctions: Intertemporal Ramsey growth model of South Africa*)
1 Productvty growth, skll bas and sanctons: Intertemporal Ramsey growth model of South Afrca*) Jørn Rattsø and Hldegunn E. Stokke, Department of Economcs, Norwegan Unversty of Scence and Technology, N-7491
More informationPeople s Republic of China s export threat to ASEAN: Competition in the US and Japanese markets
ADB Insttute Dscusson Paper No. 2 People s Republc of Chna s export threat to ASEAN: Competton n the US and Japanese markets John Wess and Gao Shanwen Asan Development Bank Insttute January 2003 John Wess
More informationJoensuu, Finland, August 20 26, 2006
Sesson Number: Parallel Sesson 4A Sesson Ttle: Productvty Measurement: Methodology and Internatonal Comparsons Sesson Organzer(s): Bart van Ark, Unversty of Gronngen, Netherlands Sesson Char: Bart van
More information3: Central Limit Theorem, Systematic Errors
3: Central Lmt Theorem, Systematc Errors 1 Errors 1.1 Central Lmt Theorem Ths theorem s of prme mportance when measurng physcal quanttes because usually the mperfectons n the measurements are due to several
More informationChapter 3 Student Lecture Notes 3-1
Chapter 3 Student Lecture otes 3-1 Busness Statstcs: A Decson-Makng Approach 6 th Edton Chapter 3 Descrbng Data Usng umercal Measures 005 Prentce-Hall, Inc. Chap 3-1 Chapter Goals After completng ths chapter,
More informationStructural change and New Zealand s productivity performance
Structural change and New Zealand s productvty performance Workng Paper 214/4 June 214 Author: Lsa Meehan New Zealand Productvty Commsson Workng Paper 214/4: Structural change and New Zealand s productvty
More informationBid-auction framework for microsimulation of location choice with endogenous real estate prices
Bd-aucton framework for mcrosmulaton of locaton choce wth endogenous real estate prces Rcardo Hurtuba Mchel Berlare Francsco Martínez Urbancs Termas de Chllán, Chle March 28 th 2012 Outlne 1) Motvaton
More informationTHIRD MIDTERM EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MARCH 24, 2004
THIRD MIDTERM EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MARCH 24, 2004 Ths exam has questons on eght pages. Before you begn, please check to make sure that your copy has all questons and all eght
More information