Money Demand. ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics. Prof. Eric Sims. Spring University of Notre Dame

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Money Demand. ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics. Prof. Eric Sims. Spring University of Notre Dame"

Jerome Elliott
5 years ago
Views:

1 Money Demand ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics Prof. Eric Sims University of Notre Dame Spring / 26

2 Readings GLS Ch / 26

3 What is Money? Might seem like an obvious question but really not so clear Money is an asset i.e. it s a stock that can be taken across time But it s a special kind of asset in that it can be used in exchange Whereas with most things we define them according to intrinsic characteristics (e.g. coffee is a dark liquid substance necessary for sustaining life), with money we instead give a functional definition Money is any asset which serves the following three functions: 1. Medium of exchange 2. Store of value 3. Unit of account 3 / 26

4 Medium of Exchange The most important role played by money is its role as a medium of exchange This solves the double coincidence of wants problem associated with barter Bonds and capital can serve as stores of values (any asset does so, so money is not unique), and anything can serve as a unit of account But money is unique in its role as medium of exchange No exaggeration that money s role as a medium of exchange has been critical to the historical growth in economic activity Fiat money is the best medium of exchange, so long as people believe it has value 4 / 26

5 Including Money in the Neoclassical Model Is not so easy Why? Model only features one good (e.g. fruit). Makes medium of exchange role uninteresting We will include money essentially as a store of value and will use money as a nominal unit of account But money is a crummy store of value bonds pay interest, money does not We will take a reduced form shortcut and assume that the household receives utility from holding money New variables: M t : stock of money (held between periods t and t + 1 (i.e. store of value like S t )) P t : price of goods measured in units of money i t : nominal interest rate 5 / 26

6 Nominal Budget Constraints Period t: P t C t + P t S t + M t P t w t N t P t T t + P t D t Period t + 1: P t+1 C t+1 + P t+1 S t+1 P t S t + M t+1 M t P t+1 w t+1 N t+1 P t+1 T t+1 + i t P t S t + P t+1 D t+1 + P t+1 D I t+1 Terminal conditions: S t+1 = 0 and M t+1 = 0. Writing constraints in real terms: C t + S t + M t P t = w t N t T t + D t C t+1 = w t+1 N t+1 T t+1 + D t+1 + (1 + i t ) P t P t+1 S t + D I t+1 + M t P t+1 M t P t : real money balances 6 / 26

7 Fisher Relationship The Fisher relationship is a relationship between the real and nominal interest rates It is given by: 1 + r t = (1 + i t ) P t P t+1 Define expected inflation between t and t + 1 as: 1 + π e t+1 = P t+1 P t Fisher relationship is then approximately: r t = i t π e t+1 We will treat expected one period ahead inflation rate, π e t+1, as exogenous. Means movements and nominal and real rates are the same for a given rate of expected inflation 7 / 26

8 The Real Intertemporal Budget Constraint Can write t + 1 constraint as: C t+1 = w t+1 N t+1 T t+1 + D t+1 + D I t+1 + (1 + r t )S t r t 1 + i t M t P t Solve out for S t, combining with period t constraint: C t + C t r t + i t 1 + i t M t P t = w t N t T t + D t + w t+1n t+1 T t+1 + D t+1 + D I t r t Exactly the same as before, just this additional expenditure category of M t P t how many period t goods you choose to hold in money 8 / 26

9 Preferences Note that money is held across periods, not within a period (i.e. it is a stock variable, not a flow) Assume household receives a utility flow from its holding of real balances via the function v( ). Increasing and concave (e.g. log) This utility flow is received in period t Lifetime utility: U = u(c t, 1 N t ) + v ( Mt P t ) + βu(c t+1, 1 N t+1 ) 9 / 26

10 Optimality Conditions FOC for consumption and labor exactly the same as before: u C (C t, 1 N t ) = β(1 + r t )u C (C t+1, 1 N t ) u L (C t, 1 N t ) = w t u C (C t, 1 N t ) New FOC for money: ( ) v Mt = i t u C (C t, 1 N t ) P t 1 + i t Interpretation... marginal benefit equals marginal cost! If no utility benefit from holding money (v ( ) = 0), then could only hold if i t = 0: money dominated as a store of value by bonds if i t > 0 10 / 26

11 Optimal Decision Rules Can go from FOC to optimal decision rules as before Presence of money does not impact optimal decision rules for consumption or labor supply: C t = C d (Y t G t, Y t+1 G t+1, r t ) N t = N s (w t, θ t ) Cutting a few corners (i.e. treating C t and Y t as interchangebale), optimal decision rule for money is: M t = P t M d (i t, Y t + ) Or, using the Fisher relationship: M t = P t M d (r t + πt+1 e, Y t ) + This is our money demand function demand for real balances is decreasing in the nominal rate and increasing in total expenditure 11 / 26

12 Government Firm and financial intermediary problems can be written either in real or nominal terms. Firms do not hold money across periods, so optimal decision rules are identical Government prints money, and we take this to be exogenous. Period t budget constraint: P t G t P t T t + P t B t + M t Government can use money as an additional revenue source (way to finance spending). Period t + 1 constraint: P t+1 G t+1 + i t P t B t + M t P t+1 T t+1 + P t+1 B t+1 P t B t Government essentially has to buy back in period t + 1 the money it issues in period t. Terminal condition: B t+1 = 0, implying: P t+1 G t+1 + (1 + i t )P t B t + M t P t+1 T t+1 12 / 26

13 Government s IBC In real terms, the two flow budget constraints for the government are: G t = T t + B t + M t P t G t+1 + (1 + i t ) P t P t+1 B t + M t P t+1 = T t+1 Combining the two and using the Fisher relationship, we get: G t + G t r t = T t + T t r t + i t 1 + i t M t P t Similar to before, but additional revenue category related to money (what we call seignorage). Analogous to household IBC which features the same term but as an expenditure category. When combining firm and household IBCs, these terms cancel (money irrelevant for consumption decision) 13 / 26

14 Equilibrium Conditions These are: C t = C d (Y t G t, Y t+1 G t+1, r t ) N t = N s (w t, θ t ) N t = N d (w t, A t, K t ) I t = I d (r t, A t+1, f t, K t ) Y t = A t F (K t, N t ) Y t = C t + I t + G t M t = P t M d (i t, Y t ) r t = i t π e t+1 First six are identical to what we had before and have no reference to any nominal variable Eight endogenous variables: Y t, C t, I t, N t, w t, r t, P t, and i t New exogenous variables: M t and πt+1 e (treat expected inflation as exogenous) 14 / 26

15 Classical Dichotomy First six equations feature six real endogenous variables and no nominal variables Means that the real endogenous variables are determined independently of nominal variables This is known as the classical dichotomy Do not need to know nominal variables to determine real variables Converse not true: nominal variables will be affected by real variables 15 / 26

16 Graphing the Equilibrium Can use the same five part graph as before to determine equilibrium of the real side of the economy The real interest rate, r t, and output, Y t, are relevant for money demand Once we know r t and Y t, along with the exogenous quantity of money supplied, can determine P t Given an exogenous π e t+1, given r t can determine i t (i t and r t always move in same direction absent a change in π e t+1 ) 16 / 26

17 Money Market Equilibrium PP tt MM ss PP tt MM dd ee (rr 0,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 0,tt ) PP 0,tt MM tt MM 0,tt Looks funny to have demand upward-sloping, but P t is price of goods in terms of money, so 1 P t is price of money in terms of goods. Demand decreasing in 1 P t 17 / 26

18 Monetary Neutrality Increase in M t does not affect first six equations no effect of change in M t on any real endogenous variable We say that money is neutral Useful medium run benchmark, but in the short run nominal rigidities may break monetary neutrality Only effect of an increase in M t is an increase in P t 18 / 26

19 Increase in M t No Effect on Real Variables dd dd = dd = CC dd ( GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr tt) + II dd (rr tt, AA tt+1, ff tt, KK tt) + GG tt ww tt NN ss (ww tt, θθ tt) rr tt YY ss ww 0,tt rr 0,tt NN dd (ww tt, AA tt, KK tt) IIII NN tt = AA ttff(kk tt, NN tt) NN 0,tt NN tt YY 0,tt 19 / 26

20 Increase in M t Raises P t PP tt MM ss MM ss PP tt MM dd ee (rr 0,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 0,tt ) PP 1,tt PP 0,tt MM tt MM 0,tt MM 1,tt 20 / 26

21 Real Shocks Affect Nominal Variables Increase in A t : lowers r t and raises Y t, both of which pivot money demand to the right, and hence lower P t Increase in θ t : raises r t and lowers Y t, both of which pivot money demand to the left, and hence raise P t Positive demand shocks (increases in A t+1 or G t, or decreases in f t or G t+1 ): raise r t, no effect on Y t. Hence, money demand shifts left, and price level rises Increase in π e t+1 : i t rises by same amount. Money demand pivots in, so price level increases. Self-fulfilling inflation 21 / 26

22 Supply Shock: A t New Equilibrium dd = CC dd GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr 1,tt dd dd = + II dd rr 1,tt, AA tt+1, ff tt, KK tt + GG tt dd = CC dd GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr 0,tt + II dd rr 0,tt, AA tt+1, ff tt, KK tt + GG tt ww tt NN ss (ww tt, θθ tt) rr tt YY ss YY ss ww 1,tt ww 0,tt rr 0,tt rr 1,tt NN dd (ww tt, AA 1,tt, KK tt) NN dd (ww tt, AA 0,tt, KK tt) IIII NN tt AA 1,ttFF(KK tt, NN tt) = AA 0,ttFF(KK tt, NN tt) NN 0,tt NN 1,tt NN tt YY 0,tt YY 1,tt 22 / 26

23 Increase in A t Lowers P t PP tt MM ss MM dd ee (rr 0,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 0,tt ) MM dd ee (rr 1,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 1,tt ) PP 0,tt PP 1,tt MM tt MM 0,tt 23 / 26

24 Demand Shock: f t New Equilibrium dd dd = dd = CC dd GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr 0,tt + II dd rr 0,tt, AA tt+1, ff 0,tt, KK tt + GG tt YY dd tt = CC dd GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr 1,tt + II dd rr 1,tt, AA tt+1, ff 1,tt, KK tt + GG tt YY dd tt = CC dd GG tt, +1 GG tt+1, rr 0,tt + II dd rr 0,tt, AA tt+1, ff 1,tt, KK tt + GG tt ww tt NN ss (ww tt, θθ tt) rr tt YY ss ww 0,tt rr 0,tt rr 1,tt NN dd (ww tt, AA tt, KK tt) IIII IIII NN tt = AA ttff(kk tt, NN tt) NN 0,tt NN tt YY 0,tt 24 / 26

25 Increase in f t Lowers P t PP tt MM ss MM dd ee (rr 0,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 0,tt ) MM dd ee (rr 1,tt + ππ tt+1, YY 0,tt ) PP 0,tt PP 1,tt MM 0,tt MM tt 25 / 26

26 Qualitative Effects Exogenous Shock Variable A t θ t f t A t+1 G t G t+1 M t π e t+1 Y t C t + - +? I t + - -? N t w t r t i t P t / 26

Midterm 2 Review. ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics Professor Sims University of Notre Dame, Spring 2018

Midterm 2 Review. ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics Professor Sims University of Notre Dame, Spring 2018 Midterm 2 Review ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics Professor Sims University of Notre Dame, Spring 2018 The second midterm will take place on Thursday, March 29. In terms of the order of coverage,