Satisfying Warranty Claims on an Obsolete Product
|
|
- Gwen Scarlett Williams
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Dwayne Cole College of Business Adminisraion Florida A&M Universiy Tallahassee, FL 33 Burak Kazaz Marin J. Whiman School of Managemen Syracuse Universiy Syracuse, NY 344 Sco Webser W.P. Carey School of Business Arizona Sae Universiy Tempe, AZ 8587 ABSTRACT We invesigae a problem faced by a durable-goods manufacurer of a produc ha is no longer manufacured bu sill under warrany. A supplier announces ha a componen of he produc will be phased ou and specifies a deadline for he final order. A common response in radiional pracice is o place a final order sufficien o cover fuure warrany claims. We analyze and compare his policy wih a policy ha uses a rade-in program o supplemen he final order quaniy. KEYWORDS: Warrany, rade-in policies, susainabiliy INTRODUCTION We invesigae a problem faced by a durable-goods manufacurer of a produc ha is no longer manufacured bu sill under warrany. A supplier announces ha a componen of he produc will be phased ou and specifies a deadline for he final order. The manufacurer projecs he componen needs for he produc under warrany and considers a wo-sage decision problem: () he size of he final order and, in he even ha he final order is less han acual requiremens, () he design of a rade-in program for componen harvesing. The imporance and prevalence of his problem have increased over ime due o shrinking produc life-cycles and growh in ousourcing. These rends are especially pronounced in he compuer indusry where he high pace of change and echnical challenges favor supply chains of independen firms wih specialized experise (e.g., AMD and Inel for processors, Seagae and Wesern Digial and for hard drives, Cisco and D-Link for rouers, Flexronics and Selecron for assembly).
2 We consider he seing where he componen phase-ou announcemen (CPOA) occurs afer he manufacurer has disconinued manufacuring and sales of he paren produc. The paricular componen conribues significanly o he value of he produc and is no easily or inexpensively obained from alernaive suppliers (e.g., highly engineered and expensive componen). These feaures elevae he imporance of managerial aenion on an effecive response o he CPOA. We invesigae how a firm s opimal final order quaniy and rade-in program decisions are influenced by indusry and marke characerisics. Our main conribuion lies in wo observaions ha come from our analysis. Firs, a rade-in program has poenial o significanly reduce a firm s warrany liabiliy. Second, here are wo key indicaors ha savings from a rade-in program will be significan. One indicaor is he difference beween he componen cos and he marginal cos of he firs uni acquired via radein. A second indicaor is he expeced fracion of producs under warrany ha will fail. Boh of hese values should no be difficul for a firm o esimae. ELEMENTS OF THE COMPONENT PHASE-OUT ANNOUNCEMENT PROBLEM As a new generaion of a componen is inroduced and he volume of he previous generaion declines, a supplier evenually ceases o supply he older generaion componen and announces a ime-line for phase ou. While i is possible ha a CPOA may occur when he manufacurer is sill producing a produc wih he componen, we limi consideraion o he case where he produc is no longer being manufacured (as is consisen wih CPOA iming examples described o us by hose in indusry). Thus, he final componen purchase decision is driven by warrany obligaion consideraions. Durable-goods manufacurers commonly offer a limied-ime warrany o consumers. The CPOA problem can be viewed as a wo-sage decision problem. The firs-sage decision is he number of componens in he final order. Afer he final order is placed, componen demand is realized over ime. The second-sage decision, if necessary, is he price discoun o be offered on a rade-in. We assume ha he firm has access o cusomer-specific warrany daa. In hese seings, he rade-in offer can be argeed o specific cusomers based on produc age and ime remaining under warrany. We also assume ha warrany claim demand and rade-in reurn volume are known wih cerainy. Through his simplifying assumpion we are able o gain some insigh ino wha drives he value of a rade-in program. We leave consideraion of uncerainy for fuure research. LITERATURE REVIEW Mos consumer durables come wih eiher a pro-raa refund or a free repair/replacemen warrany policy (Blischke and Murhy 99). Murhy e al. (4) provide a comprehensive review of various issues associaed wih warrany managemen. Warrany claims are driven by he warrany populaion, usage characerisics, produc reliabiliy, and warrany erms. Seiz (7) repors ha he use of recovered componens o saisfy warrany claims is a common pracice in he auomobile and home appliance indusries. Cisco began using reurns o suppor warrany claims in 8. The iniiaive increased he recovered value from reurns by nine-fold, from 5% o 45% (Nidumolu e al. 9). There are hree sreams of research relaed o our wo-sage problem of how a manufacurer
3 deermines he size of he final order and designs he rade-in program for componen harvesing. One of he sreams relaes o he final order quaniy problem, which is he firssage decision in our model. Foruin (98) inroduces a model wherein he machines remaining operaing life is divided ino discree inervals and he number of componens ha fail in each inerval is random. He proposes a mehod for esimaing he componen sock-ou probabiliy as a funcion of he final order quaniy. Teuner and Hansveld (998) exend he single componen seing of he previous papers o a muli-componen ordering problem. They show he muli-componen problem can be decomposed ino independen single-componen ordering problems. Bradley and Guerrero (9) also consider he muli-componen final buy problem, hough in conras o Teuner and Hansveld (998) who assume all componens are phased ou a he same momen in ime, componens are phased ou gradually over ime. Teuner and Foruin (999) develop a single-sage dynamic program o deermine he opimal final order quaniy for a single componen. Their model allows for he possibiliy of harvesing componens from reurns as a source for spare-pars. However, he firm passively acceps used-produc reurns. This differs from our model where heir firm acively manages reurn volumes hrough he seing of rade-in discouns over ime. In sum, our work exends he lieraure on he final order quaniy problem by supplemening he final order quaniy wih produc acquired via a rade-in program he second sage in our model. A second relaed sream of research addresses he use of reurns as a source for spare pars. The lieraure on his opic is vas (e.g., see Kennedy e al. for a review). Wihin his lieraure, a number of researchers have sudied he problem of managing componen pars afer he paren produc has reached he end of is sales life-cycle. Minner and Kleber () examine a seing where he firm produces a new componen and remanufacures used componens o mee a deerminisic demand for spare pars. The auhors develop a dynamic invenory framework and use opimal conrol echniques o deermine an opimal producion and recovery sraegy for a firm ha passively acceps used producs. Spengler and Schröer (3) also develop a dynamic model ha inegraes componen harvesing. They use he model o sudy flows of new produc sales, spare pars demands, produc reurns, and recovery raes. Their model focuses on he behavior of he spare pars managemen sysem. Acquisiion cos and reurns flows are exogenous in heir model, and are endogenous in our model; hey are influenced by he firm s choices. Inderfurh and Mukherjee (8) develop a decision model where he firm mus mee a dynamic demand for spare-pars during he phase-ou period. Our model resembles ha of Inderfurh and Mukherjee (8) in he sense ha he firm chooses he final order quaniy and remanufacures componens from reurned producs o mee dynamic demand for spare pars. However, our model improves heir model in wo ways: () As opposed o an exogenous flow of reurns, we assume ha he firm proacively acquires used producs from is insall base; he firm ses rade-in discouns o influence he iming and quaniy of he reurn flow. () We accoun for he impac of reurns of produc under warrany on fuure warrany claims. A hird sream of relaed lieraure examines he relaionships beween new produc prices, rade-in rebaes, produc reurn volumes, and new produc purchases. Ray e al. (5) examine how a rade-in program for a produc ha is remanufacured can be used as a pricediscriminaion mechanism o increase profis. Bruce e al. (6) sudy rade-in programs for expensive durables purchased wih he aid of a loan (e.g., auomobiles). They examine he relaionship beween he magniude of he rade-in discoun and he durabiliy of he produc. Rao e al. (9) sudy he value of rade-in programs for producs in which used produc prices are negaively affeced due o informaion asymmery (e.g., a posiive probabiliy of buying a lemon ). A key difference beween hese papers and our work is ha here is no demand for
4 used componens ha mus be me, as is he case in our problem. The papers ha are mos closely relaed o our second-sage problem address he procuremen of end-of-use producs from he insall base. Guide and Van Wassenhove () consider a firm ha ses a buyback price o mach he supply of cores wih he demand for remanufacured componens. Bakal and Akcali (6) also consider a buyback price o mach supply wih demand. Galbreh and Blackburn (6) sudy he ineracion beween procuremen lo size and he firm s soring policies. Zikopoulos and Tagaras (7) consider he problem of ordering used producs from muliple supply sources wih correlaed recovery yield. Each of hese papers considers a singlesage decision environmen. Our work differs from his lieraure by including a firs-sage decision on he final order quaniy. In addiion, his lieraure focuses on reurns o suppor he remanufacured produc demand, no warrany claims. As a consequence, he models do no capure he negaive correlaion beween reurn volume and fuure demand. In summary, our sage-one problem is similar o final purchase quaniy problems in he lieraure. A key difference is he consideraion of a rade-in program ha leads o a wo-sage decision problem. The final purchase quaniy lieraure has no considered he design of radein programs as a mechanism for acquiring used componens. Our sage-wo problem is similar o he problem of designing a rade-in program ha is considered in he markeing and remanufacuring lieraure. As in his lieraure, we need o model how feaures of he rade-in program and oher facors influence reurn volume. However, as noed above, a key difference is ha we need o capure how reurn volumes influence fuure warrany claims. MODELS AND ANALYSES A firm has received a CPOA for a componen from a sole-source supplier and mus deermine he final order quaniy q ha will be received a ime =. The purchase cos per uni is c, he invenory holding cos rae is h, and he warrany claim service cos per uni is c w (e.g., disassembly, componen replacemen, reassembly, es, and shipping). The difference beween he firm s discoun rae and he rae of inflaion in operaing coss and margin is r. The las warrany expires a ime = (i.e., he uni of ime is seleced so as o normalize he warrany liabiliy horizon o one period). The componen demand rae a ime (due o warrany claims) is d(), he cumulaive demand hrough period is D(), i.e., D() = d x dx, () and he remaining warrany demand is D, i.e., D D D. () The componen demand rae is ne of any passive reurns of produc conaining a working componen. We assume deerminisic demand and focus on idenifying he drivers of performance in his seing. We le T (q ) denoe he ime ha componen invenory from he final order reaches zero, or he end of he warrany horizon, whichever is smaller, i.e.,
5 T (q ) = min min D q, The oal cos o service warrany claims is T q r w C q cq e h q D c d dc T q (3) where C () is he cos of saisfying warrany claims over ime inerval [, ] given ha he final order quaniy runs ou a ime. The firs erm in (3) is he componen purchase cos of he final order of q unis. The second erm in (3) is he invenory holding and warrany claim servicing cos, of which he parenheical erm in he inegrand is he invenory a ime ha is assessed a holding cos rae h. Second-Sage Trade-in Policy A firm offering a rade-in program specifies he discoun off he purchase price of a new model if he cusomer reurns he old model. The rade-in credi is offered only o cusomers wih produc under warrany. Conceivably a firm could offer he rade-in discoun o a cusomer wih a produc ha is no longer under warrany. While such a cusomer migh be willing o rade-in for a lower discoun, he acic of offering a rade-in discoun for produc no under warrany has wo drawbacks. Firs, here is a risk ha he componen in he reurned produc will be fauly. This risk is low for produc under warrany because, if i was fauly, he firm would have likely already received a claim. Second, he reurn of a produc under warrany reduces he firm s warrany liabiliy associaed wih he obsolee componen (i.e., he produc conaining he obsolee componen is raded in for a new model of he produc). The firm offers a ime-sensiive rade-in o some fracion of warrany holders in each period so as o mach he rae of supply wih he rae of demand. We refer o his policy as a maching rade-in policy. A maching rade-in policy is viable in seings where he firm has access o cusomer-specific warrany daa (i.e., cusomer conac informaion for producs under warrany). Firms ha sell direcly o cusomers are likely o have his level of deail in warrany daa. Before analyzing he rade-in policy, we describe how we model relaionships beween he rade-in discoun, rade-in volume, and rade-in cos. We begin wih wo assumpions ha allow us o define he fracion of cusomers who accep a rade-in offer as a funcion of he rade-in discoun: Assumpion (A). A cusomer receiving a rade-in offer receives a single ake-i-or-leave-i offer and acceps he offer if consumer surplus is posiive. Assumpion (A). The valuaion of he new model in exchange for he old model under warrany, denoed V, is independen of ime and is uniformly disribued and ordered by age of ownership wih range normalized o [, ]. An alernaive o A is o allow muliple rade-in offers o he same cusomer over ime. However, his promoes sraegic behavior ha grealy complicaes he analysis and may work agains he ineres of he firm (e.g., cusomer holds ou for a beer offer). Uniformly disribued
6 valuaion (A) is common in he lieraure (e.g., Mussa and Rosen 978, Purohi and Saelin 994) and resuls in reurn volume ha is linear in price. A also specifies ha a consumer who recenly purchased he produc will have a higher valuaion han a consumer who has owned he produc for a longer period of ime, i.e., cusomers wih older produc will accep a lower rade-in offer han cusomers wih newer produc. A firm offering a rade-in program mus selec he rade-in discoun and he rae a which cusomers are exposed o he rade-in offer (i.e., he rade-in offer rae), boh of which may vary wih ime. The rade-in discoun is c () and he rade-in offer rae is () (e.g., () is he number of cusomers receiving a rade-in offer in period ). The conribuion margin of a new model of he produc is m and he variable cos is c n, i.e., he new model selling price is p n = c n + m. Thus, he rade-in price is c n + m c () and, by A and A, he fracion of cusomers who accep he rade-in offer from among hose who receive i is P V c m c c m c c p n n n (4) Rewriing (4) in erms of he rade-in credi, c p. (5) n We see ha he rade-in price is he complemen of he accepance rae (), i.e., p c. n Noe ha he new model selling price should be more han he maximum valuaion of a rade-in exchange, i.e., p c m. (6) n n Condiion (6) reflecs he pracical realiy ha cusomers are unlikely o rade in a produc under warrany unless here is a rade-in discoun. For example, p n < would imply ha fracion p n of cusomers would be willing o reurn heir produc (ha is under warrany and funcional) and pay full price for he new model. The value of p n is a measure of rade-in resisance. This value is he minimum rade-in discoun ha is required before any cusomers will be willing o reurn heir uni. The larger he value of p n, he greaer he marke resisance o a rade-in offer, and herefore, he firm is pressured o increase is rade-in offer wih a higher value of c (). In (4), we see ha he difference beween he rade-in credi, c (), and he rade-in resisance, p n, gives he fracion of hose receiving he rade-in offer who accep he offer. Thus, he produc reurn rae s() is s c p n. In general, he specificaion of rade-in acquisiion cos can be challenging due o he effec of cannibalizaion. We model his effec hrough parameer. The inerpreaion of is relaively
7 sraighforward when he difference beween he firm s discoun rae and he rae of inflaion (in coss and margin) is zero (i.e., r = ): is he fracion of rade-in cusomers who would have purchased he new model a full price in he fuure if he rade-in program was no offered, or repea purchase rae. If r >, hen he value of he full margin in he fuure is lower due o he ime-value-of-money. All ime-value-of-money effecs and, more generally, all cannibalizaion effecs are incorporaed ino he value of parameer. Indeed, i is possible for o be negaive in some seings, e.g., by reducing secondary marke supply and hus cannibalizaion of new produc sales. Accordingly, he cos of a componen obained hrough a rade-in is he reducion in margin hrough a rade-in sale, which is where c c m (7) = ( )m (p n ). We refer o he value of as he rade-in poenial, which can be inerpreed as he difference beween he gain from locking-in disloyal cusomers via he rade-in offer, ( )m, and he marke resisance o a rade-in offer, p n. More generally, is he marginal profi on rade-in volume a he origin. For example, if >, hen rade-in poenial is posiive and rade-ins are profiable up o accepance rae (). On he oher hand, if <, hen rade-in poenial is negaive and rade-ins are cosly from he ge-go. Wihou loss of generaliy, we define he produc uni such ha he warrany populaion a ime zero is. In he absence of a rade-in program, he rae a which warranies expire a ime is given by n(), which is known wih cerainy (e.g., obained from company records). While n() can conceivably ake any funcional form, in he ineres of parsimony, we limi consideraion o he following form ha depends on a single parameer, n [, ]: n, n() =, n, i.e., warranies expire a rae n over ime inerval [, ) and n warranies expire a ime =. Figure illusraes hree alernaive warrany populaion funcions over ime in he absence of a rade-in program. Figure. Warrany populaion over ime a differen warrany expiraion raes n =,.5,. The case of n = reflecs a seing where monhly sales of he produc is relaively fla near he end of is life-cycle (e.g., warrany expires x monhs afer purchase). The cases of n < reflec seings where monhly sales of he produc is relaively fla near he end of is life-cycle excep n = n =.5 n =
8 for a jump in sales a he end hrough clearance pricing. The smaller he value of n, he larger he clearance sale volume relaive o volume prior o clearance discouning. Wih he warrany populaion characerized, he remaining conribuor o demand for componens o service warrany claims is he componen failure rae. We assume ha he failure rae funcion is consan a value. This assumpion is common in he lieraure (e.g., Murhy and Rodin 99, Zhou e al. 9). Assumpion 3 (A3). The componen failure rae is consan. Due o A3, in he absence of a rade-in program, he demand rae is d() = ( n) and demand funcions () and () become (8) D() = nxdx.5n.5 D D D n. In boh expressions, he erm in brackes reflecs he degree o which cumulaive demand and remaining demand are reduced when he warrany expiraion rae n is greaer han. We noe ha a reurned uni may conain some value beyond he componen ha has been phased ou. This value can be incorporaed ino our model as an addiional parameer ha does no change he srucure of he model or he resuls. In he ineres of parsimony, we do no inroduce a separae parameer; is value, if significan, is included in parameer m (e.g., if margin is m and savings generaed from oher componens in a reurned produc is s, hen m = m + s/( )). Maching Trade-In Policy The firm ses he rade-in credi c () and he rade-in offer rae () so ha componen supply maches componen demand over he remainder of he warrany horizon, i.e., s d (9) where () = c () is he rade-in accepance rae among hose cusomers exposed o he rade-in offer a ime (see (4)), or he rade-in fracion. Noe ha () mus be a valid fracion, i.e., () [, ], () and ha a cusomer receives a rade-in offer no more han once (see A), i.e., d. () The firm s choice of cusomers who will receive he rade-in offer over ime is influenced by A. Recall ha A implies ha cusomers wih a soon-o-expire warrany are more likely o accep a
9 rade-in offer han cusomers wih a more disan warrany expiraion dae. In recogniion of A, he firm sends he rade-in offer o cusomers in order of warrany expiraion dae. From (7), he componen acquisiion cos rae for he maching rade-in policy is c = c m. () n Thus, he cos of he maching rade-in policy is r, w C e c d d where funcions () and () saisfy (9) (). We wish o find he funcion () ha minimizes he second-sage cos subjec o he relevan consrains. The problem is r C min e cw d d: d, d,. The following proposiion characerizes he opimal soluion o he preceding problem. Proposiion. If.5r r e e, (3) hen he opimal rade-in fracion is.5r.5r e e, (4).5r he opimal rade-in offer rae is.5r.5re e.5r, e he demand (and supply rae) is d() = e, he oal number of unis raded in is q e, and he opimal second-sage cos is.5r.5r e e C = c w..5r r Table shows he maximum value of he failure rae ha saisfies condiion (3) for various values of he ne discoun rae r. Recall ha is he failure rae over he duraion of he second sage. For example, if he second-sage duraion is five years and he annual ne discoun rae is 5%, hen condiion (3) holds for a failure rae up o 5% per year (i.e., divide he figures in he row wih r = 5% by 5). In he compuer indusry ha moivaes his work, componen failure
10 raes end o be low (e.g., less han %) and he warrany duraion is on he order of hree o five years. In hese seings, he condiion given in (3) is highly likely o hold. r maximum value of saisfying (3) % % 549% % 33% 5% 49% 5% 88% % 3% % 79% Table. Upper limi on componen failure rae for differen ne discoun raes r. The following corollary gives he opimal soluion for he special case of r =. Corollary. If r =, hen he opimal rade-in fracion is e, he opimal rade-in offer rae is e, (5) e he demand (and supply rae) is d() = e, he oal number of unis raded in is q e, and he opimal cos is e e cw. (6) C = We see ha he opimal soluion has a simpler srucure when r =. In paricular, he opimal rade-in fracion () is independen of ime. This means ha he opimal rade-in discoun says consan over he warrany horizon, i.e., c p e, (7) n (obained by subsiuing () ino (5)). The erm in he parenheses in he righ-hand side of (5) is he fracion of he populaion exposed o he rade-in offer (i.e., e is he warrany populaion over ime), which also says consan over he warrany horizon. In conras, a r >, we see ha he opimal rade-in fracion () is increasing in ime (see (4)), and consequenly, he rade-in discoun is increasing in ime (e.g., he firm offers higher discouns laer in he horizon, which are less cosly for he firm due o he posiive discoun rae). Similarly, he fracion of he populaion exposed o he rade-in offer is decreasing over ime. Firs-Sage Problem Under a policy where he final order quaniy is se o mach oal demand, he oal cos is
11 .5 w r C cq e h q n c n d (8) and he final order quaniy is q D n.5 (see (3) and (8)). We refer o his policy, which is idenified by superscrip, as he benchmark policy. The opimal oal cos under he maching rade-in program is where Tq r C cq e hq D cwd dc T q Tq r arg min w q q cq e h q D c d d C T q. Clearly, C C wih equaliy if and only if he opimal second-sage rade-in quaniy is zero (i.e., C C q ). The following proposiion idenifies a simple indicaor of when i is profiable o supplemen he final order quaniy wih a rade-in program. r Proposiion. If c e, hen C C. A rade-in program clearly adds value when rade-in poenial () is nonnegaive (because c > ). In he even ha rade-in poenial is negaive, we can be assured ha rade-in programs save money if he presen value of he magniude of he rade-in poenial (discouned from he end of he warrany horizon) is less han he purchase cos per uni. Figure illusraes how he final order quaniy under he maching rade-in policy differs from he benchmark final order quaniy. Figure 3 illusraes he percen savings due o he maching rade-in policy relaive o he benchmark. Noe ha in figures and 3, a maching rade-in program is no used when n = and = -. (i.e., q q ).
12 Figure. Opimal final order quaniies under he maching rade-in policy as a percen of he benchmark final order quaniy. The rade-in poenial is =. in he lef plo and = in he righ plo. The oher parameer values, which are common o boh plos are c =., c w =., h =.7, r =. Figure 3. Percen savings in oal cos when he benchmark policy is replaced wih he maching rade-in policy. The rade-in poenial is =. in he lef plo and = in he righ plo. The oher parameer values, which are common o boh plos are c =., c w =., h =.7, r =. The lef plos of figures and 3 reflec he seing where c = -. In his seing, he rade-in acquisiion cos wih he rade-in credi is so low ha he cos of a single reurned uni is he same as he cos from he vendor. This seing is exremely unfavorable o a rade-in program and may rarely arise in pracice. Neverheless, even in his unfavorable seing, he rade-in policy is less expensive han he benchmark when n =. Figure shows ha he rade-in policy explois he flexibiliy of dividing he source of componens beween he final order quaniy and hose ha come from rade-ins. The fracion acquired from he vendor via he final order quaniy
13 increases as he failure rae increases. This is because he rade-in cos is sensiive o oal volume acquired, so a higher fracion of oal warrany demand is shifed o he final order quaniy. Figure 3 also illusraes ha he percenage savings due o he rade-in policy is significan when he aggregae failure rae is small, and diminishes as he failure rae increases (i.e., as he opimal final order quaniy covers an increasing fracion of oal demand). However, while percenage savings is decreasing in he failure rae, he cos of he benchmark policy is increasing in he failure rae. In paricular, he oal cos of he benchmark policy is proporional o he failure rae (see (8)). Depending on parameer values, he absolue savings may be eiher increasing or decreasing in he failure rae. For he parameer values in Figure 3, for example, absolue savings is nondecreasing in failure rae excep for he maching rade-in policy a n = =, which is iniially increasing, hen decreasing. SUMMARY OF LESSONS FOR MANAGERS We have considered wo policies for a CPOA response. The radiional policy, which we refer o as he benchmark policy, is o place a final order ha is large enough o cover componen warrany demand over he remainder of he warrany horizon. An alernaive is o be less aggressive on he final order quaniy and, as componen invenory approaches zero, acquire addiional componens hrough a rade-in program offered o consumers wih produc under warrany. A rade-in offer is made o only a fracion of he warrany populaion in each period, wih he fracions adding o % by he end of he warrany horizon. The rade-in credi and he number of cusomers who receive he offer in a period are designed o achieve a reurn response ha is sufficien o cover he warrany demand in he upcoming period. A maching rade-in program is viable for companies wih relaively accurae and complee informaion on he warrany populaion (e.g., cusomer conac daa). Our analysis leads o wo main lessons for managers. Firs, rade-in programs dominae he benchmark policy and have poenial o significanly lower cos. Trade-in programs can be perceived as a new sourcing opion, and herefore, incorporaing hem ino he se of alernaives will no increase cos. Wha is more perinen for managers are indicaors ha a rade-in program will generae significan savings. The single mos imporan indicaor is rade-in poenial. The value of rade-in poenial is he difference beween wo values: () he margin from a rade-in ransacion, or new-produc margin imes he probabiliy of a cusomer no purchasing from he firm if no for he rade-in offer, and () he reducion in new produc price required o ge a leas one cusomer o paricipae in he rade-in program. If rade-in poenial is posiive, hen he cos of acquiring componens via rade-in is negaive (a leas a low volumes); he firm earns money from acquiring a componen via rade-in raher han spending money buying a componen from he vendor. Managemen should examine he difference beween rade-in poenial and he cos of buying he componen from he vendor. These values should no be difficul o esimae, and a large difference is a srong indicaor of high savings from a rade-in program. A secondary indicaor of high savings from a rade-in program is he fracion of he warrany populaion expeced o fail prior o warrany expiraion. This indicaor draws on a more suble value proposiion han he difference in cos beween a rade-in-sourced uni and a vendorsourced uni: a rade-in program reduces warrany claims. Each uni raded in reduces he warrany populaion of he obsolee produc, which ranslaes ino fewer warrany claims. And he higher he failure rae, he greaer he reducion in warrany claims.
14 The overarching lesson from our analysis is ha he use of a rade-in program o suppor warrany claims should be considered by managemen. I is surprising o see ha he use of rade-ins o suppor warrany claims is no discussed in he indusry or academic lieraure. One possible reason is ha, relaive o he benchmark policy, a rade-in program is more difficul o implemen, i.e., he firm has o design and communicae he program. However, i is also he case ha rade-in programs are no unusual in pracice. Indeed, here is a wide lieraure in economics and markeing on his opic, and his may hin a he possibiliy of an organizaional barrier. Trade-in programs are ypically designed and adminisered by he markeing group for markeing reasons (e.g., price discriminaion, spur sales when a new generaion of a produc is inroduced, ec.). Reducing he cos of warrany claim processing is ofen ouside he mission of a markeing deparmen. Our work can moivae firms o lower such organizaional barriers. REFERENCES Bakal, I.S., & Akcali, E. (6). Effecs of random yield in remanufacuring wih price-sensiive supply and demand. Producion and Operaions Managemen, 5, Blischke, W., & Murhy, D. (99). Produc warrany managemen--i: A axonomy for warrany policies. European Journal of Operaional Research, 6(), Bradley, J. R., & Guerrero, H.H. (9). Lifeime buy decisions wih muliple obsolee pars. Producion and Operaions Managemen, 8(), 4-6. Bruce, N., Desai, P., & Saelin, R. (6). Enabling he willing: Consumer rebaes for durable goods. Markeing Science, 5(4), Fleischmann, M., van Nunen, J., & Gräve, B. (3). Inegraing closed-loop supply chains and spare-pars managemen a IBM. Inerfaces, 33(6), Foruin, L. (98). The all-ime requiremen of spare pars for service afer sales heoreical analysis and pracical resuls. Inernaional Journal of Operaions & Producion Managemen, (), Galbreh, M.R., & Blackburn, J.D. (6). Opimal acquisiion and soring policies for remanufacuring. Producion and Operaions Managemen, 5, Guide, V.D.R. Jr., & Van Wassenhove, L.N. (). Business aspecs of closed-loop supply chain managemen. V.D.R. Guide Jr., L.N. Van Wassenhove, eds. Business Aspecs of Closed-loop Supply Chain Managemen. Pisburgh, PA: Carnegie Mellon Universiy Press, 7-4. Inderfurh, K., & Mukherjee, K. (8). Decision suppor for spare pars acquisiion in pos produc life cycle. Cenral European Journal of Operaions Research, 6(), 7-4. Kennedy, W., Paerson, J.W., & Fredendall, L. (). An overview of recen lieraure on spare pars invenories. Inernaional Journal of Producion Economics, 76(), -5. Linon, J.D. (8). Assessing he economic raionaliy of remanufacuring producs. Journal of Produc Innovaion Managemen, 5(3), Minner, S., & Kleber, R. (). Opimal conrol of producion and remanufacuring in a simple recovery model wih linear cos funcions. OR Spekrum, 3, 3-4. Murhy, D. N. P., & Rodin, E.Y. (99). A new warrany cosing model. Mahemaical and Compuer Modelling, 3(9), Murhy, D., Solem, O., & Roren, T. (4). Produc warrany logisics: Issues and challenges. European Journal of Operaional Research, 56(), -6. Mussa, M., & Rosen, S. (978). Monopoly and produc qualiy. Journal of Economic Theory, 8(), Nidumolu, R., Prahalad, C.K., & Rangaswami, M.R. (9). Why susainabiliy is now he key driver of innovaion. Harvard Business Review, 87(9), 56-64
15 Purohi, D., & Saelin, R. (994). Renals, sales, and buybacks: Managing secondary disribuion channels. Journal of Markeing Research, 3, Rao, R., Narasimhan, O., & John, G. (9). Undersanding he role of rade-ins in durable goods markes: Theory and evidence. Markeing Science, 8(5), Ray, S., Boyaci, T., & Aras, N. (5). Opimal prices and rade-in rebaes for durable, remanufacurable producs. Manufacuring Service Operaions Managemen, 7(3), 8-8. Seiz, M.A. (7). A criical assessmen of moives for produc recovery: The case of engine remanufacuring. Journal of Cleaner Producion, 5(-), Spengler, T., & Schröer, M. (3). Sraegic Managemen of Spare Pars in Closed-Loop Supply Chains - A Sysem Dynamics Approach. Inerfaces, 33(6) 7-7. Teuner, R.H., & Foruin, L. (998). End-of-life service: A case sudy. European Journal of Operaional Research, 7(), Teuner, R.H., & Foruin, L. (999). End-of-life service. Inernaional Journal of Producion Economics, 59(-3), Teuner, R.L., & Haneveld, W.K. (998). The final order problem. European Journal of Operaional Research, 7(), Zhou, Z., Li, Y., & Tang, K. (9). Dynamic pricing and warrany policies for producs wih fixed lifeime. European Journal of Operaional Research, 96(3) Zikopoulos, C., & Tagaras, G. (7). Impac of uncerainy in he qualiy of reurns on he profiabiliy of a single-period refurbishing operaion. European Journal of Operaional Research, 8(), 5-5. APPENDIX Maching Trade-in Policy Cos for q r r r e he h e Cqq ch cw r r r r h e e h e n cw e r n r r r r r r r.5r.5r e e.5r When r =, he expression reduces o r w.5.5 w.33. C q q c h c h n c h n e e c w Proof of Proposiion. For his proof, we will no use he normalizaion of = in order o clarify he expressions under a general second-sage saring ime, expressions ha will appear in our analysis of he firs-sage problem. We iniially develop he resuls for he special case of n =. We will hen show ha he opimal soluion for his special case remains valid when n >. c w
16 Assume n =. Le N() denoe he warrany populaion a ime. Due o n =, we have N() = for all <. The demand and supply rae over ime inerval [, ] is d() = s() =N() and he warrany populaion funcion is N() = sxdxdxdx Nxdx,,. We obain an explici expression for N() by aking he limi of a discree-ime model as he ime inerval goes o zero. Given ime inerval >, he failure rae per ime inerval is, and we have d s N s s N s N s N N N s and, in general, for ineger i N i. i Le = = i. Taking he limi as approaches zero, N() = lim / lim / ln lim / e e e for [, ]. Thus, d() = N() = e for [, ]. By subsiuing () = d()/() = e / (9) ino (5), we see ha c () is decreasing in (). Therefore, we replace he inequaliy consrain () wih equaliy, and he consrain can be wrien as e d d, () and he second-sage problem can be wrien as
17 r e min w :, r C e e c d d We solve he following equivalen problem min :,. r e e d d, () bu we iniially relax he bound consrain () [, ] (i.e., unresriced problem), i.e., we solve min : r e e d d. () Afer solving he unresriced problem (), we idenify condiions on parameer values ha ensure he soluion is also opimal for he resriced problem (). To simplify noaion, we emporarily le = (we accoun for he impac of > laer). We define which implies x e y() = dx, x y() = e e y' Thus, problem () is. (3) min ' :, y r e y d y y, (4) which can be solved using calculus of variaions mehods. Le y * () denoe he opimal funcion. We express y() in erms of parameer a, y * (), and difference funcion h(), i.e., y() = y * () + ah() and hus y() = y * () + ah(). For any feasible y(), we mus have h() = h() = (i.e., in order o saisfy he boundary condiions, which are clearly saisfied by he funcion y * ()). Le r r * g(a) = e y' d e y ' ah' d.
18 Noe ha r * g(a) = e y ' ah' h' d. (5) Applying inegraion by pars and recognizing uv = due o h() = h() =, we have * ry ' ah' r g(a) = e h d. * 3 * y ' ah' y " ah" Since y * () is opimal, we can conclude ha for any h() (wih h() = h() = ), we mus have g() =. This implies ha he inegrand of he above (wih a = ) mus be equal o zero a all values of, i.e., we mus have ry * y * r * * 3 * e r y ' y ' y " h ' " * r y " y * ' Solving he differenial equaion, we ge *.5r y ' Ae, where A is obained from he boundary condiion, i.e., Thus * *.5r y y d A e y * '.5r '.5r e e.5r.5r. (6) The funcion y * ' is a unique exremal (i.e., no oher funcion yields g() = ). Taking he derivaive of (5) and evaluaing a a =, we ge r * 3 g() = e y ' h' d. Since y * () > for all [, ], i follows ha g() >, and hus Subsiuing (6) ino (3) yields opimal rade-in fracion y * ' solves (4).
19 .5 r.5 r.5 r.5 r e e e e e e y'.5r.5r, and accouning for > yields opimal rade-in fracion for he unresriced problem.5 r.5 r e e.5r. (7) Recall ha he difference beween he unresriced problem and he resriced problem is ha he resriced problem includes he consrain () [, ]. From (7) we see ha () is increasing in and ( ) [, ]. Thus, if (), hen he opimal soluion o he unresriced problem is also opimal for he resriced problem. Noe ha.5r.5r e e.5r r.5r e e. (8) Thus, () [, ] if and only if (8) holds. The opimal rade-in offer rae is obained by subsiuing (7) ino (9) and solving for (), he rade-in quaniy is obained from q d, and he opimal cos is obained by subsiuing he opimal accepance rae and rade-in offer rae funcions ino he cos funcion: q.5r e e e.5r.5r e.5r.5r e e.5r r r C e cw. (9) In he preceding, we derived he opimal soluion under he assumpion ha n =. We nex show ha he soluion is also opimal when n >. Noe ha warrany populaion a he beginning of he second sage when he rade-in program goes ino effec is n. Adaping he soluion in (9) o accoun for he fac ha a oal n are made during he second sage, we ge n e.5r e.5r.5r e, (3) i.e., due o our normalizaion of he populaion size o, (9) gives he opimal fracion of he warrany populaion ha receives he rade-in offer over ime. If n >, hen i is conceivable ha some warranies will expire during he second-sage prior o a
20 cusomer receiving a rade-in offer. If such a scenario canno occur under he opimal rade-in offer rae given in (3), hen he preceding analysis coninues o apply. Indeed, as we show below, his is he case. According o soluion (3), he oal number of rade-in offers during inerval [, ] is f() =.5rx.5r e x xdx e dx.5r e. Observe ha f() is a concave increasing funcion over he inerval [, ] wih f( ) = and f() = n. If here was no rade-in policy, he oal number of warranies ha would expire during inerval [, ] is n,, g() =. n, Thus, f() g() for all [, ], i.e., no warranies expire during he second sage prior o receip of a rade-in offer. Therefore, he srucure of he opimal soluion for he case of n = holds for he case of n >, hrough he expressions for (), q, and C are generalized o accoun for he lower warrany populaion a he sar of he second sage:.5 r.5 r e e. (3).5r.5r.5r e n e.5r, (3) e q n e (33).5r.5r e e r C e n c.5r r w. (34) Proof of Proposiion. The uni acquisiion cos under a rade-in program wih accepance rae is c = (see (7)), and he acquisiion cos a he origin ( = ) is c =. Compared o he benchmark, rade-in programs resul in lower invenory and fewer oal warrany claims. Thus, a necessary condiion for q, is c e -r (i.e., he firm canno reduce acquisiion cos by acquiring produc a he end of he warrany horizon via a rade-in), and he conraposiive of is r q c e c e q. r
An Incentive-Based, Multi-Period Decision Model for Hierarchical Systems
Wernz C. and Deshmukh A. An Incenive-Based Muli-Period Decision Model for Hierarchical Sysems Proceedings of he 3 rd Inernaional Conference on Global Inerdependence and Decision Sciences (ICGIDS) pp. 84-88
More informationAppendix B: DETAILS ABOUT THE SIMULATION MODEL. contained in lookup tables that are all calculated on an auxiliary spreadsheet.
Appendix B: DETAILS ABOUT THE SIMULATION MODEL The simulaion model is carried ou on one spreadshee and has five modules, four of which are conained in lookup ables ha are all calculaed on an auxiliary
More informationUCLA Department of Economics Fall PhD. Qualifying Exam in Macroeconomic Theory
UCLA Deparmen of Economics Fall 2016 PhD. Qualifying Exam in Macroeconomic Theory Insrucions: This exam consiss of hree pars, and you are o complee each par. Answer each par in a separae bluebook. All
More informationFINAL EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MAY 11, 2004
FINAL EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MAY 11, 2004 This exam has 50 quesions on 14 pages. Before you begin, please check o make sure ha your copy has all 50 quesions and all 14 pages.
More informationLIDSTONE IN THE CONTINUOUS CASE by. Ragnar Norberg
LIDSTONE IN THE CONTINUOUS CASE by Ragnar Norberg Absrac A generalized version of he classical Lidsone heorem, which deals wih he dependency of reserves on echnical basis and conrac erms, is proved in
More informationSupplement to Models for Quantifying Risk, 5 th Edition Cunningham, Herzog, and London
Supplemen o Models for Quanifying Risk, 5 h Ediion Cunningham, Herzog, and London We have received inpu ha our ex is no always clear abou he disincion beween a full gross premium and an expense augmened
More informationIntroduction. Enterprises and background. chapter
NACE: High-Growh Inroducion Enerprises and background 18 chaper High-Growh Enerprises 8 8.1 Definiion A variey of approaches can be considered as providing he basis for defining high-growh enerprises.
More informationMA Advanced Macro, 2016 (Karl Whelan) 1
MA Advanced Macro, 2016 (Karl Whelan) 1 The Calvo Model of Price Rigidiy The form of price rigidiy faced by he Calvo firm is as follows. Each period, only a random fracion (1 ) of firms are able o rese
More informationDocumentation: Philadelphia Fed's Real-Time Data Set for Macroeconomists First-, Second-, and Third-Release Values
Documenaion: Philadelphia Fed's Real-Time Daa Se for Macroeconomiss Firs-, Second-, and Third-Release Values Las Updaed: December 16, 2013 1. Inroducion We documen our compuaional mehods for consrucing
More informationCh. 1 Multinational Financial Mgmt: Overview. International Financial Environment. How Business Disciplines Are Used to Manage the MNC
Ch. Mulinaional Financial Mgm: Overview Topics Goal of he MNC Theories of Inernaional Business Inernaional Business Mehods Inernaional Opporuniies Exposure o Inernaional Risk MNC's Cash Flows & Valuaion
More informationHow Risky is Electricity Generation?
How Risky is Elecriciy Generaion? Tom Parkinson The NorhBridge Group Inernaional Associaion for Energy Economics New England Chaper 19 January 2005 19 January 2005 The NorhBridge Group Agenda Generaion
More informationCh. 10 Measuring FX Exposure. Is Exchange Rate Risk Relevant? MNCs Take on FX Risk
Ch. 10 Measuring FX Exposure Topics Exchange Rae Risk: Relevan? Types of Exposure Transacion Exposure Economic Exposure Translaion Exposure Is Exchange Rae Risk Relevan?? Purchasing Power Pariy: Exchange
More informationSpring 2011 Social Sciences 7418 University of Wisconsin-Madison
Economics 32, Sec. 1 Menzie D. Chinn Spring 211 Social Sciences 7418 Universiy of Wisconsin-Madison Noes for Econ 32-1 FALL 21 Miderm 1 Exam The Fall 21 Econ 32-1 course used Hall and Papell, Macroeconomics
More informationTechnological progress breakthrough inventions. Dr hab. Joanna Siwińska-Gorzelak
Technological progress breakhrough invenions Dr hab. Joanna Siwińska-Gorzelak Inroducion Afer The Economis : Solow has shown, ha accumulaion of capial alone canno yield lasing progress. Wha can? Anyhing
More informationAn Introduction to PAM Based Project Appraisal
Slide 1 An Inroducion o PAM Based Projec Appraisal Sco Pearson Sanford Universiy Sco Pearson is Professor of Agriculural Economics a he Food Research Insiue, Sanford Universiy. He has paricipaed in projecs
More informationThe Mathematics Of Stock Option Valuation - Part Four Deriving The Black-Scholes Model Via Partial Differential Equations
The Mahemaics Of Sock Opion Valuaion - Par Four Deriving The Black-Scholes Model Via Parial Differenial Equaions Gary Schurman, MBE, CFA Ocober 1 In Par One we explained why valuing a call opion as a sand-alone
More informationEmpirical analysis on China money multiplier
Aug. 2009, Volume 8, No.8 (Serial No.74) Chinese Business Review, ISSN 1537-1506, USA Empirical analysis on China money muliplier SHANG Hua-juan (Financial School, Shanghai Universiy of Finance and Economics,
More information2. Quantity and price measures in macroeconomic statistics 2.1. Long-run deflation? As typical price indexes, Figure 2-1 depicts the GDP deflator,
1 2. Quaniy and price measures in macroeconomic saisics 2.1. Long-run deflaion? As ypical price indexes, Figure 2-1 depics he GD deflaor, he Consumer rice ndex (C), and he Corporae Goods rice ndex (CG)
More informationSession IX: Special topics
Session IX: Special opics 2. Subnaional populaion projecions 10 March 2016 Cheryl Sawyer, Lina Bassarsky Populaion Esimaes and Projecions Secion www.unpopulaion.org Maerials adaped from Unied Naions Naional
More informationMacroeconomics II A dynamic approach to short run economic fluctuations. The DAD/DAS model.
Macroeconomics II A dynamic approach o shor run economic flucuaions. The DAD/DAS model. Par 2. The demand side of he model he dynamic aggregae demand (DAD) Inflaion and dynamics in he shor run So far,
More informationExam 1. Econ520. Spring 2017
Exam 1. Econ520. Spring 2017 Professor Luz Hendricks UNC Insrucions: Answer all quesions. Clearly number your answers. Wrie legibly. Do no wrie your answers on he quesion shees. Explain your answers do
More informationA Method for Estimating the Change in Terminal Value Required to Increase IRR
A Mehod for Esimaing he Change in Terminal Value Required o Increase IRR Ausin M. Long, III, MPA, CPA, JD * Alignmen Capial Group 11940 Jollyville Road Suie 330-N Ausin, TX 78759 512-506-8299 (Phone) 512-996-0970
More informationProblem Set 1 Answers. a. The computer is a final good produced and sold in Hence, 2006 GDP increases by $2,000.
Social Analysis 10 Spring 2006 Problem Se 1 Answers Quesion 1 a. The compuer is a final good produced and sold in 2006. Hence, 2006 GDP increases by $2,000. b. The bread is a final good sold in 2006. 2006
More informationThe macroeconomic effects of fiscal policy in Greece
The macroeconomic effecs of fiscal policy in Greece Dimiris Papageorgiou Economic Research Deparmen, Bank of Greece Naional and Kapodisrian Universiy of Ahens May 22, 23 Email: dpapag@aueb.gr, and DPapageorgiou@bankofgreece.gr.
More informationECONOMIC GROWTH. Student Assessment. Macroeconomics II. Class 1
Suden Assessmen You will be graded on he basis of In-class aciviies (quizzes worh 30 poins) which can be replaced wih he number of marks from he regular uorial IF i is >=30 (capped a 30, i.e. marks from
More informationMulti-Time-Scale Decision Making for Strategic Agent Interactions
Proceedings of he 2010 Indusrial Engineering Research Conference A. Johnson and J. Miller eds. Muli-Time-Scale Decision Making for Sraegic Agen Ineracions Chrisian Wernz Virginia Tech Blacksburg VA 24060
More information1 Purpose of the paper
Moneary Economics 2 F.C. Bagliano - Sepember 2017 Noes on: F.X. Diebold and C. Li, Forecasing he erm srucure of governmen bond yields, Journal of Economerics, 2006 1 Purpose of he paper The paper presens
More informationEffect of Probabilistic Backorder on an Inventory System with Selling Price Demand Under Volume Flexible Strategy
Inernaional Transacions in Mahemaical Sciences and compuers July-December 0, Volume 5, No., pp. 97-04 ISSN-(Prining) 0974-5068, (Online) 0975-75 AACS. (www.aacsjournals.com) All righ reserved. Effec of
More informationEVA NOPAT Capital charges ( = WACC * Invested Capital) = EVA [1 P] each
VBM Soluion skech SS 2012: Noe: This is a soluion skech, no a complee soluion. Disribuion of poins is no binding for he correcor. 1 EVA, free cash flow, and financial raios (45) 1.1 EVA wihou adjusmens
More informationOutput: The Demand for Goods and Services
IN CHAPTER 15 how o incorporae dynamics ino he AD-AS model we previously sudied how o use he dynamic AD-AS model o illusrae long-run economic growh how o use he dynamic AD-AS model o race ou he effecs
More informationIJRSS Volume 2, Issue 2 ISSN:
A LOGITIC BROWNIAN MOTION WITH A PRICE OF DIVIDEND YIELDING AET D. B. ODUOR ilas N. Onyango _ Absrac: In his paper, we have used he idea of Onyango (2003) he used o develop a logisic equaion used in naural
More information(1 + Nominal Yield) = (1 + Real Yield) (1 + Expected Inflation Rate) (1 + Inflation Risk Premium)
5. Inflaion-linked bonds Inflaion is an economic erm ha describes he general rise in prices of goods and services. As prices rise, a uni of money can buy less goods and services. Hence, inflaion is an
More informationOrigins of currency swaps
Origins of currency swaps Currency swaps originally were developed by banks in he UK o help large cliens circumven UK exchange conrols in he 1970s. UK companies were required o pay an exchange equalizaion
More informationModels of Default Risk
Models of Defaul Risk Models of Defaul Risk 1/29 Inroducion We consider wo general approaches o modelling defaul risk, a risk characerizing almos all xed-income securiies. The srucural approach was developed
More informationLi Gan Guan Gong Michael Hurd. April, 2006
Ne Inergeneraional Transfers from an Increase in Social Securiy Benefis Li Gan Guan Gong Michael Hurd April, 2006 ABSTRACT When he age of deah is uncerain, individuals will leave bequess even if hey have
More informationOptimal Early Exercise of Vulnerable American Options
Opimal Early Exercise of Vulnerable American Opions March 15, 2008 This paper is preliminary and incomplee. Opimal Early Exercise of Vulnerable American Opions Absrac We analyze he effec of credi risk
More informationYou should turn in (at least) FOUR bluebooks, one (or more, if needed) bluebook(s) for each question.
UCLA Deparmen of Economics Spring 05 PhD. Qualifying Exam in Macroeconomic Theory Insrucions: This exam consiss of hree pars, and each par is worh 0 poins. Pars and have one quesion each, and Par 3 has
More informationThis specification describes the models that are used to forecast
PCE and CPI Inflaion Differenials: Convering Inflaion Forecass Model Specificaion By Craig S. Hakkio This specificaion describes he models ha are used o forecas he inflaion differenial. The 14 forecass
More informationInventory Investment. Investment Decision and Expected Profit. Lecture 5
Invenory Invesmen. Invesmen Decision and Expeced Profi Lecure 5 Invenory Accumulaion 1. Invenory socks 1) Changes in invenory holdings represen an imporan and highly volaile ype of invesmen spending. 2)
More informationEquivalent Martingale Measure in Asian Geometric Average Option Pricing
Journal of Mahemaical Finance, 4, 4, 34-38 ublished Online Augus 4 in SciRes hp://wwwscirporg/journal/jmf hp://dxdoiorg/436/jmf4447 Equivalen Maringale Measure in Asian Geomeric Average Opion ricing Yonggang
More informationMarket and Information Economics
Marke and Informaion Economics Preliminary Examinaion Deparmen of Agriculural Economics Texas A&M Universiy May 2015 Insrucions: This examinaion consiss of six quesions. You mus answer he firs quesion
More informationReconciling Gross Output TFP Growth with Value Added TFP Growth
Reconciling Gross Oupu TP Growh wih Value Added TP Growh Erwin Diewer Universiy of Briish Columbia and Universiy of New Souh Wales ABSTRACT This aricle obains relaively simple exac expressions ha relae
More informationProblem 1 / 25 Problem 2 / 25 Problem 3 / 30 Problem 4 / 20 TOTAL / 100
Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Maryland Economics 325 Inermediae Macroeconomic Analysis Final Exam Professor Sanjay Chugh Spring 2009 May 16, 2009 NAME: TA S NAME: The Exam has a oal of four (4) problems
More informationOn the Impact of Inflation and Exchange Rate on Conditional Stock Market Volatility: A Re-Assessment
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive On he Impac of Inflaion and Exchange Rae on Condiional Sock Marke Volailiy: A Re-Assessmen OlaOluwa S Yaya and Olanrewaju I Shiu Deparmen of Saisics, Universiy of Ibadan,
More informationAid, Policies, and Growth
Aid, Policies, and Growh By Craig Burnside and David Dollar APPENDIX ON THE NEOCLASSICAL MODEL Here we use a simple neoclassical growh model o moivae he form of our empirical growh equaion. Our inenion
More informationFinal Exam Answers Exchange Rate Economics
Kiel Insiu für Welwirhschaf Advanced Sudies in Inernaional Economic Policy Research Spring 2005 Menzie D. Chinn Final Exam Answers Exchange Rae Economics This exam is 1 ½ hours long. Answer all quesions.
More informationMonetary policy and multiple equilibria in a cash-in-advance economy
Economics Leers 74 (2002) 65 70 www.elsevier.com/ locae/ econbase Moneary policy and muliple equilibria in a cash-in-advance economy Qinglai Meng* The Chinese Universiy of Hong Kong, Deparmen of Economics,
More informationAN INTERACTIVE PROCEDURE FOR AGGREGATE PRODUCTION PLANNING
AN INERACIVE PROCEDURE FOR AGGREGAE PRODUCION PLANNING Maciej Nowak Universiy of Economics in Kaowice 40-287 Kaowice, ul. 1 Maja 50, Poland E-mail: maciej.nowak@ue.kaowice.pl Posal Address Absrac Minimizing
More informationVERIFICATION OF ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF LIGNITE DEPOSIT DEVELOPMENT USING THE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
1 Beaa TRZASKUŚ-ŻAK 1, Kazimierz CZOPEK 2 MG 3 1 Trzaskuś-Żak Beaa PhD. (corresponding auhor) AGH Universiy of Science and Technology Faculy of Mining and Geoengineering Al. Mickiewicza 30, 30-59 Krakow,
More informationEcon 546 Lecture 4. The Basic New Keynesian Model Michael Devereux January 2011
Econ 546 Lecure 4 The Basic New Keynesian Model Michael Devereux January 20 Road map for his lecure We are evenually going o ge 3 equaions, fully describing he NK model The firs wo are jus he same as before:
More informationAggregate and Workforce Planning (Huvudplanering)
Aggregae and Workforce Planning (Huvudplanering) Producion and Invenory Conrol (MPS) MIO030 The main reference for his maerial is he book Facory Physics by W. Hopp and M.L Spearman, McGraw-Hill, 200. Wha
More informationSMALL MENU COSTS AND LARGE BUSINESS CYCLES: AN EXTENSION OF THE MANKIW MODEL
SMALL MENU COSTS AND LARGE BUSINESS CYCLES: AN EXTENSION OF THE MANKIW MODEL 2 Hiranya K. Nah, Sam Houson Sae Universiy Rober Srecher, Sam Houson Sae Universiy ABSTRACT Using a muli-period general equilibrium
More informationIf You Are No Longer Able to Work
If You Are No Longer Able o Work NY STRS A Guide for Making Disabiliy Reiremen Decisions INTRODUCTION If you re forced o sop working because of a serious illness or injury, you and your family will be
More informationA NOTE ON BUSINESS CYCLE NON-LINEARITY IN U.S. CONSUMPTION 247
Journal of Applied Economics, Vol. VI, No. 2 (Nov 2003), 247-253 A NOTE ON BUSINESS CYCLE NON-LINEARITY IN U.S. CONSUMPTION 247 A NOTE ON BUSINESS CYCLE NON-LINEARITY IN U.S. CONSUMPTION STEVEN COOK *
More informationThe relation between U.S. money growth and inflation: evidence from a band pass filter. Abstract
The relaion beween U.S. money growh and inflaion: evidence from a band pass filer Gary Shelley Dep. of Economics Finance; Eas Tennessee Sae Universiy Frederick Wallace Dep. of Managemen Markeing; Prairie
More informationCHAPTER CHAPTER18. Openness in Goods. and Financial Markets. Openness in Goods, and Financial Markets. Openness in Goods,
Openness in Goods and Financial Markes CHAPTER CHAPTER18 Openness in Goods, and Openness has hree disinc dimensions: 1. Openness in goods markes. Free rade resricions include ariffs and quoas. 2. Openness
More informationCURRENCY CHOICES IN VALUATION AND THE INTEREST PARITY AND PURCHASING POWER PARITY THEORIES DR. GUILLERMO L. DUMRAUF
CURRENCY CHOICES IN VALUATION AN THE INTEREST PARITY AN PURCHASING POWER PARITY THEORIES R. GUILLERMO L. UMRAUF TO VALUE THE INVESTMENT IN THE OMESTIC OR FOREIGN CURRENCY? Valuing an invesmen or an acquisiion
More informationSession 4.2: Price and Volume Measures
Session 4.2: Price and Volume Measures Regional Course on Inegraed Economic Saisics o Suppor 28 SNA Implemenaion Leonidas Akriidis Office for Naional Saisics Unied Kingdom Conen 1. Inroducion 2. Price
More informationDescription of the CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrite Index (BXY SM )
Descripion of he CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrie Index (BXY SM ) Inroducion. The CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrie Index (BXY SM ) is a benchmark index designed o rack he performance of a hypoheical 2% ou-of-he-money
More informationAn inventory model for Gompertz deteriorating items with time-varying holding cost and price dependent demand
Inernaional Journal of Mahemaics rends and echnology (IJM) Volume 49 Number 3 Sepember 7 An invenory model for Gomperz deerioraing iems wih ime-varying holding cos and price dependen demand Absrac Nurul
More informationOPTIMUM FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICY USING THE MONETARY OVERLAPPING GENERATION MODELS
Kuwai Chaper of Arabian Journal of Business and Managemen Review Vol. 3, No.6; Feb. 2014 OPTIMUM FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICY USING THE MONETARY OVERLAPPING GENERATION MODELS Ayoub Faramarzi 1, Dr.Rahim
More informationa) No constraints on import- export, no limit on reservoir, all water in the first period The monopoly optimisation problem is:
Monopoly and rade Monopoly conrol impors, bu akes expor price as given. a No consrains on impor- expor, no limi on reservoir, all waer in he firs period he monopoly opimisaion problem is: Max p ( x x +
More informationSIMPLE DSGE MODELS OF MONEY DEMAND: PART I OCTOBER 14, 2014
SIMPLE DSGE MODELS OF MONEY DEMAND: PART I OCTOBER 4, 204 Inroducion BASIC ISSUES Money/moneary policy issues an enduring fascinaion in macroeconomics How can/should cenral bank conrol he economy? Should
More informationDynamic Programming Applications. Capacity Expansion
Dynamic Programming Applicaions Capaciy Expansion Objecives To discuss he Capaciy Expansion Problem To explain and develop recursive equaions for boh backward approach and forward approach To demonsrae
More informationMoney/monetary policy issues an enduring fascination in macroeconomics. How can/should central bank control the economy? Should it/can it at all?
SIMPLE DSGE MODELS OF MONEY PART I SEPTEMBER 22, 211 Inroducion BASIC ISSUES Money/moneary policy issues an enduring fascinaion in macroeconomics How can/should cenral bank conrol he economy? Should i/can
More informationPortfolio investments accounted for the largest outflow of SEK 77.5 billion in the financial account, which gave a net outflow of SEK billion.
BALANCE OF PAYMENTS DATE: 27-11-27 PUBLISHER: Saisics Sweden Balance of Paymens and Financial Markes (BFM) Maria Falk +46 8 6 94 72, maria.falk@scb.se Camilla Bergeling +46 8 6 942 6, camilla.bergeling@scb.se
More informationUNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA
MA5100 UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA MSC/POSTGRADUATE DIPLOMA IN FINANCIAL MATHEMATICS 009 MA 5100 INTRODUCTION TO STATISTICS THREE HOURS November 009 Answer FIVE quesions and NO MORE. Quesion 1 (a) A supplier
More informationA Simple Method for Consumers to Address Uncertainty When Purchasing Photovoltaics
A Simple Mehod for Consumers o Address Uncerainy When Purchasing Phoovolaics Dr. Thomas E. Hoff Clean Power Research 10 Glen C. Napa, CA 94558 www.clean-power.com Dr. Rober Margolis Naional Renewable Energy
More informationEconomic Growth Continued: From Solow to Ramsey
Economic Growh Coninued: From Solow o Ramsey J. Bradford DeLong May 2008 Choosing a Naional Savings Rae Wha can we say abou economic policy and long-run growh? To keep maers simple, le us assume ha he
More informationProcess of convergence dr Joanna Wolszczak-Derlacz. Lecture 4 and 5 Solow growth model (a)
Process of convergence dr Joanna Wolszczak-Derlacz ecure 4 and 5 Solow growh model a Solow growh model Rober Solow "A Conribuion o he Theory of Economic Growh." Quarerly Journal of Economics 70 February
More informationANSWER ALL QUESTIONS. CHAPTERS 6-9; (Blanchard)
ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS CHAPTERS 6-9; 18-20 (Blanchard) Quesion 1 Discuss in deail he following: a) The sacrifice raio b) Okun s law c) The neuraliy of money d) Bargaining power e) NAIRU f) Wage indexaion
More informationDEBT INSTRUMENTS AND MARKETS
DEBT INSTRUMENTS AND MARKETS Zeroes and Coupon Bonds Zeroes and Coupon Bonds Ouline and Suggesed Reading Ouline Zero-coupon bonds Coupon bonds Bond replicaion No-arbirage price relaionships Zero raes Buzzwords
More informationUzawa(1961) s Steady-State Theorem in Malthusian Model
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive Uzawa(1961) s Seady-Sae Theorem in Malhusian Model Defu Li and Jiuli Huang April 214 Online a hp://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/55329/ MPRA Paper No. 55329, posed 16. April
More informationDYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus University Toruń Krzysztof Jajuga Wrocław University of Economics
DYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus Universiy Toruń 2006 Krzyszof Jajuga Wrocław Universiy of Economics Ineres Rae Modeling and Tools of Financial Economerics 1. Financial Economerics
More informationPricing FX Target Redemption Forward under. Regime Switching Model
In. J. Conemp. Mah. Sciences, Vol. 8, 2013, no. 20, 987-991 HIKARI Ld, www.m-hikari.com hp://dx.doi.org/10.12988/ijcms.2013.311123 Pricing FX Targe Redempion Forward under Regime Swiching Model Ho-Seok
More informationCHAPTER 3 How to Calculate Present Values. Answers to Practice Questions
CHAPTER 3 How o Calculae Presen Values Answers o Pracice Quesions. a. PV $00/.0 0 $90.53 b. PV $00/.3 0 $9.46 c. PV $00/.5 5 $ 3.5 d. PV $00/. + $00/. + $00/. 3 $40.8. a. DF + r 0.905 r 0.050 0.50% b.
More informationDescription of the CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrite Index (BXR SM )
Descripion of he CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrie Index (BXR SM ) Inroducion. The CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrie Index (BXR SM ) is a benchmark index designed o rack he performance of a hypoheical a-he-money buy-wrie
More informationA Theory of Tax Effects on Economic Damages. Scott Gilbert Southern Illinois University Carbondale. Comments? Please send to
A Theory of Tax Effecs on Economic Damages Sco Gilber Souhern Illinois Universiy Carbondale Commens? Please send o gilbers@siu.edu ovember 29, 2012 Absrac This noe provides a heoreical saemen abou he effec
More informationt=1 C t e δt, and the tc t v t i t=1 C t (1 + i) t = n tc t (1 + i) t C t (1 + i) t = C t vi
Exam 4 is Th. April 24. You are allowed 13 shees of noes and a calculaor. ch. 7: 137) Unless old oherwise, duraion refers o Macaulay duraion. The duraion of a single cashflow is he ime remaining unil mauriy,
More informationPricing Vulnerable American Options. April 16, Peter Klein. and. Jun (James) Yang. Simon Fraser University. Burnaby, B.C. V5A 1S6.
Pricing ulnerable American Opions April 16, 2007 Peer Klein and Jun (James) Yang imon Fraser Universiy Burnaby, B.C. 5A 16 pklein@sfu.ca (604) 268-7922 Pricing ulnerable American Opions Absrac We exend
More informationDOES EVA REALLY HELP LONG TERM STOCK PERFORMANCE?
DOES EVA REALLY HELP LONG TERM STOCK PERFORMANCE? Wesley M. Jones, Jr. The Ciadel wes.jones@ciadel.edu George Lowry, Randolph Macon College glowry@rmc.edu ABSTRACT Economic Value Added (EVA) as a philosophy
More informationMoney in a Real Business Cycle Model
Money in a Real Business Cycle Model Graduae Macro II, Spring 200 The Universiy of Nore Dame Professor Sims This documen describes how o include money ino an oherwise sandard real business cycle model.
More informationSection 4 The Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Secion 4 he Exchange Rae in he Long Run 1 Conen Objecives Purchasing Power Pariy A Long-Run PPP Model he Real Exchange Rae Summary 2 Objecives o undersand he law of one price and purchasing power pariy
More informationMultiple Choice Questions Solutions are provided directly when you do the online tests.
SOLUTIONS Muliple Choice Quesions Soluions are provided direcly when you do he online ess. Numerical Quesions 1. Nominal and Real GDP Suppose han an economy consiss of only 2 ypes of producs: compuers
More informationProblem 1 / 25 Problem 2 / 25 Problem 3 / 11 Problem 4 / 15 Problem 5 / 24 TOTAL / 100
Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Maryland Economics 35 Inermediae Macroeconomic Analysis Miderm Exam Suggesed Soluions Professor Sanjay Chugh Fall 008 NAME: The Exam has a oal of five (5) problems and
More informationValuing Real Options on Oil & Gas Exploration & Production Projects
Valuing Real Opions on Oil & Gas Exploraion & Producion Projecs March 2, 2006 Hideaka (Hugh) Nakaoka Former CIO & CCO of Iochu Oil Exploraion Co., Ld. Universiy of Tsukuba 1 Overview 1. Inroducion 2. Wha
More informationThe Impact of Interest Rate Liberalization Announcement in China on the Market Value of Hong Kong Listed Chinese Commercial Banks
Journal of Finance and Invesmen Analysis, vol. 2, no.3, 203, 35-39 ISSN: 224-0998 (prin version), 224-0996(online) Scienpress Ld, 203 The Impac of Ineres Rae Liberalizaion Announcemen in China on he Marke
More informationDo Changes in Pension Incentives Affect Retirement? A Longitudinal Study of Subjective Retirement Expectations
Do Changes in Pension Incenives Affec Reiremen? A Longiudinal Sudy of Subjecive Reiremen Expecaions February 2001 Sewin Chan Rober F. Wagner School of Public Service New York Universiy sewin.chan@nyu.edu
More informationA Note on Missing Data Effects on the Hausman (1978) Simultaneity Test:
A Noe on Missing Daa Effecs on he Hausman (978) Simulaneiy Tes: Some Mone Carlo Resuls. Dikaios Tserkezos and Konsaninos P. Tsagarakis Deparmen of Economics, Universiy of Cree, Universiy Campus, 7400,
More informationEvaluating Projects under Uncertainty
Evaluaing Projecs under Uncerainy March 17, 4 1 Projec risk = possible variaion in cash flows 2 1 Commonly used measure of projec risk is he variabiliy of he reurn 3 Mehods of dealing wih uncerainy in
More informationCapital Strength and Bank Profitability
Capial Srengh and Bank Profiabiliy Seok Weon Lee 1 Asian Social Science; Vol. 11, No. 10; 2015 ISSN 1911-2017 E-ISSN 1911-2025 Published by Canadian Cener of Science and Educaion 1 Division of Inernaional
More informationCENTRO DE ESTUDIOS MONETARIOS Y FINANCIEROS T. J. KEHOE MACROECONOMICS I WINTER 2011 PROBLEM SET #6
CENTRO DE ESTUDIOS MONETARIOS Y FINANCIEROS T J KEHOE MACROECONOMICS I WINTER PROBLEM SET #6 This quesion requires you o apply he Hodrick-Presco filer o he ime series for macroeconomic variables for he
More informationINSTITUTE OF ACTUARIES OF INDIA
INSTITUTE OF ACTUARIES OF INDIA EXAMINATIONS 05 h November 007 Subjec CT8 Financial Economics Time allowed: Three Hours (14.30 17.30 Hrs) Toal Marks: 100 INSTRUCTIONS TO THE CANDIDATES 1) Do no wrie your
More informationMacroeconomics. Typical macro questions (I) Typical macro questions (II) Methodology of macroeconomics. Tasks carried out by macroeconomists
Macroeconomics Macroeconomics is he area of economics ha sudies he overall economic aciviy in a counry or region by means of indicaors of ha aciviy. There is no essenial divide beween micro and macroeconomics,
More informationOption Valuation of Oil & Gas E&P Projects by Futures Term Structure Approach. Hidetaka (Hugh) Nakaoka
Opion Valuaion of Oil & Gas E&P Projecs by Fuures Term Srucure Approach March 9, 2007 Hideaka (Hugh) Nakaoka Former CIO & CCO of Iochu Oil Exploraion Co., Ld. Universiy of Tsukuba 1 Overview 1. Inroducion
More informationHEDGING SYSTEMATIC MORTALITY RISK WITH MORTALITY DERIVATIVES
HEDGING SYSTEMATIC MORTALITY RISK WITH MORTALITY DERIVATIVES Workshop on moraliy and longeviy, Hannover, April 20, 2012 Thomas Møller, Chief Analys, Acuarial Innovaion OUTLINE Inroducion Moraliy risk managemen
More informationChapter Outline CHAPTER
8-0 8-1 Chaper Ouline CHAPTER 8 Sraegy and Analysis in Using Ne Presen Value 8.1 Decision Trees 8.2 Sensiiviy Analysis, Scenario Analysis, and Break-Even Analysis 8.3 Mone Carlo Simulaion 8. Opions 8.5
More informationThe Global Factor in Neutral Policy Rates
The Global acor in Neural Policy Raes Some Implicaions for Exchange Raes Moneary Policy and Policy Coordinaion Richard Clarida Lowell Harriss Professor of Economics Columbia Universiy Global Sraegic Advisor
More informationCorporate Finance. Capital budgeting. Standalone risk of capital project
Corporae Finance Capial budgeing Iniial oulay = FCInv + NWCInv Sal afer ax operaing cashflow = 0 + T ( Sal0 B0 ) ( R C)( 1 ax) + ax Ter min al year non opereaing cashflow = Sal T Dep + NWCInv ax ( Sal
More informationFundamental Basic. Fundamentals. Fundamental PV Principle. Time Value of Money. Fundamental. Chapter 2. How to Calculate Present Values
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chaper 2 How o Calculae Presen Values Principles of Corporae Finance Tenh Ediion Slides by Mahew Will And Bo Sjö 22 Copyrigh 2 by he McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All righs reserved. Fundamenal
More information