Estimating Market Power in Differentiated Product Markets
|
|
- Barry Flynn
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Estimating Market Power in Differentiated Product Markets Metin Cakir Purdue University December 6, 2010 Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
2 Outline Outline Estimating structural market equilibrium models Supply side: Review of Cournot and Bertrand competition Demand side: Homogeneous vs. differentiated product markets Review of classical demand system models Random utility models: Discrete choice modeling An empirical application to ready to eat cereal industry Nevo, 2001 Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
3 Quantity Setting Firms Cournot Model: Max q i π i = P(Q)q i c(q i ) Supply Side Cournot Competition where Q is aggregate quantity and q i is quantity produced by firm i. The FOC is: π i q i where = P + q i P(Q) q i c (q i ) = 0 P(Q) q i P(Q) q i P(Q) q i = P(Q) Q Q q i = P(Q) Q = P(Q) } Q {{ } P (Q) ( qi q i + q j ( q i ) 1 + q ) j q } {{ i } θ C Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
4 Quantity Setting Firms Supply Side Cournot Competition At the optimum P = MC P (Q)θ C q i where P (Q) is the slope of inverse demand, θ C = Q q i = 1 + q j q i is the conjectural variation (not elasticity). θ C = 1 Cournot-Nash. ( q j q i = 0) θ C = 0 Perfect Comp. ( q j q i = 1) θ C = N Cartel (Symmetry) ( q j q i = 1) Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
5 Price Setting Firms Supply Side Bertrand Competition Bertrand Model: Bertrand competition refers to a model of oligopoly in which two or more firms compete by simultaneously setting prices. A price setting game can be formalized as: Players: n 2 players (firms), i,..., n Actions: Each firm simultaneously sets price p i P i = [0, ] Payoffs: π i (p i, p i ) = p i D(p i, p i ) C i (D(p i, p i )) Under assumption of profit maximization A Bertrand Nash equilibrium is a vector of prices (pi, p i ) such that for each player i, Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
6 Supply Side Bertrand Competition Price Setting Firms Bertrand equilibrium with differentiated products is simply the solution to the system of first-order conditions implied by each firms profit-maximizing pricing decision. Let output of each firm denoted as: Firm i s profit maximization problem is given as: Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
7 Supply Side Bertrand Competition Price Setting Firms P i = MC q i / dq i dp i where dq i dp i dq i dp i = q i p i p i p i + q i p j p j p i = q i p i + q i p j θ B θ B = 0 Bertrand-Nash. (p i = MC q i / q i p i ) θ B = Perfect Comp. p i = MC θ B = 1 Cartel (Symmetry) (p i = MC q i /( q i p i + q i p j )) Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
8 Demand Side Homogeneous Product Markets NEIO models are typical examples of structural market equilibrium models for homogeneous product markets. Empirical applications use macro (aggregate) data Demand side: Typically a single product demand curve is estimated Supply side: A model of Cournot competition is employed Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
9 Demand Side Differentiated Product Markets Could refer to vertical or horizontal differentiation Empirical applications use brand and/or individual level data Demand side: Requires a demand system estimation of competing brands Supply side: A model of Bertrand competition is employed Wide range of applicability of these models in IO and Marketing: Analysis of competition Market power Price discrimination Advertisement Merger analysis Analysis of consumer behavior Sensitivity to price Valuation of product attributes Brand loyalty Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
10 Demand Side Demand system models: The dimensionality problem Suppose we have observations of the same 50 brands of ice cream from 50 cities, 2500 data points. We also have data on 4 product and 6 consumer characteristics. We seek to estimate bulk ice cream demand elasticity. We can take a classical demand system approach, i.e. AIDS model. This would require: Estimating a total of 2500 own and cross price elasticities, using 2500 data points Even with symmetry, homogeneity and adding up restrictions estimation would be impractical Instead we can work in product characteristics space rather than product space (discrete choice models): Redefine consumer s utility as a function of product characteristics Redefine consumer s problem as a probability of buying a particular product rather than how much to buy Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
11 Demand Side Random Utility Models, RUM Random Utility Models RUMs describe the relation of explanatory variables to the outcome of a choice, without reference to exactly how the choice is made. Agent i, i = 1,..., n is assumed to make a choice among j = 1, 2,..., J possible alternatives. Agent i chooses the alternative that provides the greatest utility, U ij > U ik j k Researcher observes the choice and its attributes, x ij, but not the utility Therefore, the utility is assumed to be represented additively as the sum of a partially observable part, V ij, and an unobservable part, ɛ ij, such that Usually we ll assume V ij = x ij β Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
12 Demand Side Random Utility Models, RUM Random Utility Models Let f(ɛ i ) denote the joint density of random vector ɛ i = (ɛ i1,..., ɛ ij ). The probability that agent i chooses alternative j is: This cumulative distribution is the probability of each random term ɛ ik ɛ ij is below observed quantity V ij V ik. Since the joint density of random errors is f(ɛ i ), we can rewrite as: where I is indicator function equal to 1 if the term in parentheses is true. The model collapses to logit if f(ɛ i ) is i.i.d. extreme value The model collapses to probit if f(ɛ i ) is multivariate normal Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
13 Demand Side Multinomial Logit Multinomial Logit Logit model is derived by assuming error terms follow a Type I extreme value distribution. Specifically, assume that the errors are independent across i and j with a density function: f(ɛ ij ) = exp( ɛ ij )exp( e ɛ ij)), and the cumulative function F(ɛ ij ) = exp( e ɛ ij)) By this assumption the logit probability of individual i choosing alternative j is Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
14 Demand Side Multinomial Logit Estimation Likelihood function: L(β) = n J i=1 j=1 (P ij) Y ij where Y ij =1 if person i selects j and zero otherwise. The loglikelihood is: L(β) = n J i=1 j=1 Y ij(x ij β log[ J j=1 exp(x ijβ)]) where V ij = x ij β. The score is L β (β) = i j (Y ij P ij )x ij ) Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
15 Demand Side Multinomial Logit Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives, IIA MNL model is subject to IIA problem. Take 2 alternatives k and l P ik P il = [exp(v ik )/ j l=1 exp(v il][exp(v il )/ j l=1 exp(v il] 1 That is, the ratio of probabilities are unaffected from any other outside alternatives. Because they cancel at the ratio. This imposes restrictions on substitution patterns Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
16 Demand Side Multinomial Logit Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives, IIA The reason for IIA problem is i.i.d errors not the logit itself The problem is that consumer characteristics are independent of the observed product The solution to this problem can be interacting consumer characteristics with product characteristics Nested Logit Mixed Logit Multinomial Probit Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
17 Empirical Application Nevo, 2001, Econometrica RTE industry is a classic example of a concentrated differentiated-products industry: high concentration high price-cost margins large advertising to sales ratio aggressive introduction of new products The paper analyzes price competition by estimating the true economic price-cost margins (PCM) and distinguishing between three sources: firm s ability to differentiate its brands from those of its competitors portfolio effect (ability to charge more by producing imperfect substitutes) price collusion Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
18 Empirical Application Nevo, 2001, Econometrica The steps of estimation are: estimate the demand function (random coefficient logit model) as a function of observed product characteristics, unobserved product characteristics, and unknown parameters Compute PCM implied by three industry structures by using demand elasticities single product firms multi-brand oligopolistic firms multi-brand monopolistic firm Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
19 Empirical Application Supply side Empirical Framework: Supply Side Suppose there are F firms, each of which produces some subset, Γ j, of the j = 1,..., J different brands. define Ω = 1 if f : (r, j) Γ f, Ω = 0 otherwise. then Ω jr = Ω S jr where S jr = s r (p) p j s(p) Ω(p mc) = 0 Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
20 Empirical Application Supply side Empirical Framework: Supply Side Notice the resemblance to the simple Bertrand Model θ B = 0 Bertrand-Nash. (P i = MC q i / q i P i ) θ B = Perfect Comp. P i = MC θ B = 1 Cartel (Symmetry) (P i = MC q i /( q i P i + q i P j )) Ownership matrix allows to estimate different market structures. If none of the products are within the same subset it is single-product Bertrand-Nash If some of the products are within the same subset it is multi-product Bertrand-Nash If all of the products are within the same subset it is collusion Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
21 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Multinomial Logit: The estimation of the demand curves using random coefficient logit model is not an easy task. To better understand the procedure we first focus on estimation via multinomial logit. Let the utility of consumer i from choosing alternative j in town t is given by the equation: where i = 1,..., N, j = 1,..., 50, t = 1,..., 50 p jt observed price of product j in town t, x jt is 4 dimensional observed product characteristics, ξ jt is the unobserved product characteristics, ɛ ijt is mean zero error term Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
22 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Multinomial Logit: Since the coefficients are the same for all consumers we can obtain an aggregate utility function Assuming ɛ jt is i.i.d extreme value, the market share of product j is given by Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
23 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Multinomial Logit: Elasticities of Demand s jt = e x jt β αp jt +ξ jt ex kt β αp kt +ξ kt We seek to obtain s jt p kt. Let G j = e x jt β αp jt +ξ jt s jt = s jt p kt = If k j then G j G k G j p kt G k s jt 0 p kt = G k ( s jt p kt = α ( ) ( ) G + j (1+ Gk 50 1 G k ) 2 p kt ( + G j ( G k ) ) G j ( G k ) 2 ) ( G k ( G k ) ( αg k ) ) so that Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
24 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Multinomial Logit: Elasticities of Demand s jt p kt ( = α G j ( G k ) ) ( G k ( G k ) ) Products with higher shares are close substitutes regardless of content similarly it can be shown that if If k = j then Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
25 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Random Coefficient Logit u ijt = x j β i α i p jt + ξ j + ξ jt + ɛ ijt individual heterogeneity is captured as deviations from mean value: α i = α + ΠD i + Σv i β i = β + ΠD i + Σv i v i N(0, I K+1 ) Note that coefficients are functions of demographic variables and unobserved component v i Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
26 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Random Coefficient Logit Let θ = (θ 1, θ 2 ) where θ 1 = (α, β) and θ 2 = (vec(π), vec(σ)) then the utility can be rewritten as deviations from mean u ijt = δ jt (x j, p jt, ξ j, ξ jt ; θ 1 ) + µ ijt (x j, p jt, v i, D i ; θ 2 ) + ɛ ijt δ jt = x j β i α i p jt + ξ j + ξ jt Component of utility from alternative j that is same across all consumers µ ijt = [p jt, x j ] (ΠD i + Σv i ) component of utility from alternative j that is individual specific Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
27 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Random Coefficient Logit: Market Shares Under the assumption of Type I extreme value for ɛ ijt the market share s ijt is given by: s ijt = ν D e δ jt +µ ijt eδ jt +µ ijt s jt (x, p t, δ t ; θ 2 ) = [ ν] D dp (D, v, ɛ) = dp (v)dp (D) e δ jt +µ ijt eδ jt +µ ijt Integral can be evaluated by simulation to obtain shares. It adds up the market shares of different types of consumers based on distribution of types. Nevo (2000a): A Practitioner s Guide to estimation of Random Coefficients Logit Models of Demand, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 9, Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
28 Empirical Application Demand side Empirical Framework: Demand Side Random Coefficient Logit: Elasticities of Demand Own price elasticity, j = k, η jkt = p jt s jt ν D α is ijt (1 s ijt )dp (v)dp (D) Cross price elasticity, j k, η jkt = p kt s jt ν D α is ijt s ikt dp (v)dp (D) Metin Cakir (Purdue) Market Equilibrium Models December 6, / 28
Exercises Solutions: Oligopoly
Exercises Solutions: Oligopoly Exercise - Quantity competition 1 Take firm 1 s perspective Total revenue is R(q 1 = (4 q 1 q q 1 and, hence, marginal revenue is MR 1 (q 1 = 4 q 1 q Marginal cost is MC
More informationEC 202. Lecture notes 14 Oligopoly I. George Symeonidis
EC 202 Lecture notes 14 Oligopoly I George Symeonidis Oligopoly When only a small number of firms compete in the same market, each firm has some market power. Moreover, their interactions cannot be ignored.
More informationDUOPOLY. MICROECONOMICS Principles and Analysis Frank Cowell. July 2017 Frank Cowell: Duopoly. Almost essential Monopoly
Prerequisites Almost essential Monopoly Useful, but optional Game Theory: Strategy and Equilibrium DUOPOLY MICROECONOMICS Principles and Analysis Frank Cowell 1 Overview Duopoly Background How the basic
More informationLecture 9: Basic Oligopoly Models
Lecture 9: Basic Oligopoly Models Managerial Economics November 16, 2012 Prof. Dr. Sebastian Rausch Centre for Energy Policy and Economics Department of Management, Technology and Economics ETH Zürich
More informationAnswer Key. q C. Firm i s profit-maximization problem (PMP) is given by. }{{} i + γ(a q i q j c)q Firm j s profit
Homework #5 - Econ 57 (Due on /30) Answer Key. Consider a Cournot duopoly with linear inverse demand curve p(q) = a q, where q denotes aggregate output. Both firms have a common constant marginal cost
More informationChapter 3. Dynamic discrete games and auctions: an introduction
Chapter 3. Dynamic discrete games and auctions: an introduction Joan Llull Structural Micro. IDEA PhD Program I. Dynamic Discrete Games with Imperfect Information A. Motivating example: firm entry and
More informationECO410H: Practice Questions 2 SOLUTIONS
ECO410H: Practice Questions SOLUTIONS 1. (a) The unique Nash equilibrium strategy profile is s = (M, M). (b) The unique Nash equilibrium strategy profile is s = (R4, C3). (c) The two Nash equilibria are
More informationWhat s New in Econometrics. Lecture 11
What s New in Econometrics Lecture 11 Discrete Choice Models Guido Imbens NBER Summer Institute, 2007 Outline 1. Introduction 2. Multinomial and Conditional Logit Models 3. Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives
More informationL industria del latte alimentare italiana: Comportamenti di consumo e analisi della struttura di mercato
L industria del latte alimentare italiana: Comportamenti di consumo e analisi della struttura di mercato Castellari Elena * Dottorato in Economia e Management Agroalimentare Università Cattolica del Sacro
More informationEcon 8602, Fall 2017 Homework 2
Econ 8602, Fall 2017 Homework 2 Due Tues Oct 3. Question 1 Consider the following model of entry. There are two firms. There are two entry scenarios in each period. With probability only one firm is able
More informationNoncooperative Oligopoly
Noncooperative Oligopoly Oligopoly: interaction among small number of firms Conflict of interest: Each firm maximizes its own profits, but... Firm j s actions affect firm i s profits Example: price war
More informationElements of Economic Analysis II Lecture XI: Oligopoly: Cournot and Bertrand Competition
Elements of Economic Analysis II Lecture XI: Oligopoly: Cournot and Bertrand Competition Kai Hao Yang /2/207 In this lecture, we will apply the concepts in game theory to study oligopoly. In short, unlike
More informationLecture 13 Price discrimination and Entry. Bronwyn H. Hall Economics 220C, UC Berkeley Spring 2005
Lecture 13 Price discrimination and Entry Bronwyn H. Hall Economics 220C, UC Berkeley Spring 2005 Outline Leslie Broadway theatre pricing Empirical models of entry Spring 2005 Economics 220C 2 Leslie 2004
More informationThese notes essentially correspond to chapter 13 of the text.
These notes essentially correspond to chapter 13 of the text. 1 Oligopoly The key feature of the oligopoly (and to some extent, the monopolistically competitive market) market structure is that one rm
More informationThe test has 13 questions. Answer any four. All questions carry equal (25) marks.
2014 Booklet No. TEST CODE: QEB Afternoon Questions: 4 Time: 2 hours Write your Name, Registration Number, Test Code, Question Booklet Number etc. in the appropriate places of the answer booklet. The test
More informationA monopoly is an industry consisting a single. A duopoly is an industry consisting of two. An oligopoly is an industry consisting of a few
27 Oligopoly Oligopoly A monopoly is an industry consisting a single firm. A duopoly is an industry consisting of two firms. An oligopoly is an industry consisting of a few firms. Particularly, l each
More informationUCLA Department of Economics Ph.D. Preliminary Exam Industrial Organization Field Exam (Spring 2010) Use SEPARATE booklets to answer each question
Wednesday, June 23 2010 Instructions: UCLA Department of Economics Ph.D. Preliminary Exam Industrial Organization Field Exam (Spring 2010) You have 4 hours for the exam. Answer any 5 out 6 questions. All
More informationPricing Behavior in Markets with State Dependence in Demand. Technical Appendix. (for review only, not for publication) This Draft: July 5, 2006
Pricing Behavior in Markets with State Dependence in Demand Technical Appendix (for review only, not for publication) This Draft: July 5, 2006 1 Introduction In this technical appendix, we provide additional
More informationChoice Models. Session 1. K. Sudhir Yale School of Management. Spring
Choice Models Session 1 K. Sudhir Yale School of Management Spring 2-2011 Outline The Basics Logit Properties Model setup Matlab Code Heterogeneity State dependence Endogeneity Model Setup Bayesian Learning
More informationMultiproduct-Firm Oligopoly: An Aggregative Games Approach
Multiproduct-Firm Oligopoly: An Aggregative Games Approach Volker Nocke 1 Nicolas Schutz 2 1 UCLA 2 University of Mannheim ASSA ES Meetings, Philadephia, 2018 Nocke and Schutz (UCLA &Mannheim) Multiproduct-Firm
More informationLecture Note 3. Oligopoly
Lecture Note 3. Oligopoly 1. Competition by Quantity? Or by Price? By what do firms compete with each other? Competition by price seems more reasonable. However, the Bertrand model (by price) does not
More informationLecture 4: Graduate Industrial Organization. Characteristic Space, Product Level Data, and Price Indices.
Lecture 4: Graduate Industrial Organization. Characteristic Space, Product Level Data, and Price Indices. Ariel Pakes September 21, 2015 Estimation from Product Level Data: The Simple Cases. Data {(s o
More informationAutomobile Prices in Equilibrium Berry, Levinsohn and Pakes. Empirical analysis of demand and supply in a differentiated product market.
Automobile Prices in Equilibrium Berry, Levinsohn and Pakes Empirical analysis of demand and supply in a differentiated product market. about 100 different automobile models per year each model has different
More informationNoncooperative Market Games in Normal Form
Chapter 6 Noncooperative Market Games in Normal Form 1 Market game: one seller and one buyer 2 players, a buyer and a seller Buyer receives red card Ace=11, King = Queen = Jack = 10, 9,, 2 Number represents
More informationMICROECONOMICS AND POLICY ANALYSIS - U8213 Professor Rajeev H. Dehejia Class Notes - Spring 2001
MICROECONOMICS AND POLICY ANALYSIS - U813 Professor Rajeev H. Dehejia Class Notes - Spring 001 Imperfect Competition Wednesday, March 1 st Reading: Pindyck/Rubinfeld Chapter 1 Strategic Interaction figure
More informationIntroduction to Industrial Organization Professor: Caixia Shen Fall 2014 Lecture Note 5 Games and Strategy (Ch. 4)
Introduction to Industrial Organization Professor: Caixia Shen Fall 2014 Lecture Note 5 Games and Strategy (Ch. 4) Outline: Modeling by means of games Normal form games Dominant strategies; dominated strategies,
More informationEstimating the Effect of Tax Reform in Differentiated Product Oligopolistic Markets
Estimating the Effect of Tax Reform in Differentiated Product Oligopolistic Markets by Chaim Fershtman, Tel Aviv University & CentER, Tilburg University Neil Gandal*, Tel Aviv University & CEPR, and Sarit
More informationThe Costs of Environmental Regulation in a Concentrated Industry
The Costs of Environmental Regulation in a Concentrated Industry Stephen P. Ryan MIT Department of Economics Research Motivation Question: How do we measure the costs of a regulation in an oligopolistic
More informationChoice Probabilities. Logit Choice Probabilities Derivation. Choice Probabilities. Basic Econometrics in Transportation.
1/31 Choice Probabilities Basic Econometrics in Transportation Logit Models Amir Samimi Civil Engineering Department Sharif University of Technology Primary Source: Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation
More informationMKTG 555: Marketing Models
MKTG 555: Marketing Models A Brief Introduction to Game Theory for Marketing February 14-21, 2017 1 Basic Definitions Game: A situation or context in which players (e.g., consumers, firms) make strategic
More informationLECTURE NOTES ON GAME THEORY. Player 2 Cooperate Defect Cooperate (10,10) (-1,11) Defect (11,-1) (0,0)
LECTURE NOTES ON GAME THEORY September 11, 01 Introduction: So far we have considered models of perfect competition and monopoly which are the two polar extreme cases of market outcome. In models of monopoly,
More informationGame Theory and Economics Prof. Dr. Debarshi Das Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati
Game Theory and Economics Prof. Dr. Debarshi Das Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati Module No. # 03 Illustrations of Nash Equilibrium Lecture No. # 02
More informationECE 586BH: Problem Set 5: Problems and Solutions Multistage games, including repeated games, with observed moves
University of Illinois Spring 01 ECE 586BH: Problem Set 5: Problems and Solutions Multistage games, including repeated games, with observed moves Due: Reading: Thursday, April 11 at beginning of class
More informationPart 2: Monopoly and Oligopoly Investment
Part 2: Monopoly and Oligopoly Investment Irreversible investment and real options for a monopoly Risk of growth options versus assets in place Oligopoly: industry concentration, value versus growth, and
More informationWhen one firm considers changing its price or output level, it must make assumptions about the reactions of its rivals.
Chapter 3 Oligopoly Oligopoly is an industry where there are relatively few sellers. The product may be standardized (steel) or differentiated (automobiles). The firms have a high degree of interdependence.
More informationStatic Games and Cournot. Competition
Static Games and Cournot Competition Lecture 3: Static Games and Cournot Competition 1 Introduction In the majority of markets firms interact with few competitors oligopoly market Each firm has to consider
More informationStatic Games and Cournot. Competition
Static Games and Cournot Introduction In the majority of markets firms interact with few competitors oligopoly market Each firm has to consider rival s actions strategic interaction in prices, outputs,
More informationis the best response of firm 1 to the quantity chosen by firm 2. Firm 2 s problem: Max Π 2 = q 2 (a b(q 1 + q 2 )) cq 2
Econ 37 Solution: Problem Set # Fall 00 Page Oligopoly Market demand is p a bq Q q + q.. Cournot General description of this game: Players: firm and firm. Firm and firm are identical. Firm s strategies:
More informationEstimating Mixed Logit Models with Large Choice Sets. Roger H. von Haefen, NC State & NBER Adam Domanski, NOAA July 2013
Estimating Mixed Logit Models with Large Choice Sets Roger H. von Haefen, NC State & NBER Adam Domanski, NOAA July 2013 Motivation Bayer et al. (JPE, 2007) Sorting modeling / housing choice 250,000 individuals
More informationResearch Note Endogeneity and Heterogeneity in a Probit Demand Model: Estimation Using Aggregate Data
Research Note Endogeneity and Heterogeneity in a Probit Demand Model: Estimation Using Aggregate Data Pradeep K. Chintagunta Graduate School of Business, University of Chicago, 1101 East 58th Street, Chicago,
More informationThis article appeared in a journal published by Elsevier. The attached copy is furnished to the author for internal non-commercial research and
This article appeared in a journal published by Elsevier. The attached copy is furnished to the author for internal non-commercial research and education use, including for instruction at the authors institution
More informationEconomics Multinomial Choice Models
Economics 217 - Multinomial Choice Models So far, most extensions of the linear model have centered on either a binary choice between two options (work or don t work) or censoring options. Many questions
More informationHow (not) to measure Competition
How (not) to measure Competition Jan Boone, Jan van Ours and Henry van der Wiel CentER, Tilburg University 1 Introduction Conventional ways of measuring competition (concentration (H) and price cost margin
More informationECON/MGMT 115. Industrial Organization
ECON/MGMT 115 Industrial Organization 1. Cournot Model, reprised 2. Bertrand Model of Oligopoly 3. Cournot & Bertrand First Hour Reviewing the Cournot Duopoloy Equilibria Cournot vs. competitive markets
More informationEconomics Honors Exam 2009 Solutions: Microeconomics, Questions 1-2
Economics Honors Exam 2009 Solutions: Microeconomics, Questions 1-2 Question 1 (Microeconomics, 30 points). A ticket to a newly staged opera is on sale through sealed-bid auction. There are three bidders,
More informationGame Theory Fall 2003
Game Theory Fall 2003 Problem Set 5 [1] Consider an infinitely repeated game with a finite number of actions for each player and a common discount factor δ. Prove that if δ is close enough to zero then
More informationBusiness Strategy in Oligopoly Markets
Chapter 5 Business Strategy in Oligopoly Markets Introduction In the majority of markets firms interact with few competitors In determining strategy each firm has to consider rival s reactions strategic
More informationR&D, International Sourcing and the Joint Impact on Firm Performance: Online Appendix
R&D, International Sourcing and the Joint Impact on Firm Performance: Online Appendix Esther Ann Bøler Andreas Moxnes Karen Helene Ulltveit-Moe August 215 University of Oslo, ESOP and CEP, e.a.boler@econ.uio.no
More informationESTIMATING THE EFFECTS OF TAX REFORM IN DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCT OLIGOPOLISTIC MARKETS. Chaim Fershtman, Neil Gandal and Sarit Markovich
No. 2107 ESTIMATING THE EFFECTS OF TAX REFORM IN DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCT OLIGOPOLISTIC MARKETS Chaim Fershtman, Neil Gandal and Sarit Markovich INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATION AND PUBLIC POLICY ISSN 0265-8003 ESTIMATING
More informationInflation Dynamics During the Financial Crisis
Inflation Dynamics During the Financial Crisis S. Gilchrist 1 1 Boston University and NBER MFM Summer Camp June 12, 2016 DISCLAIMER: The views expressed are solely the responsibility of the authors and
More informationPhD Qualifier Examination
PhD Qualifier Examination Department of Agricultural Economics May 29, 2013 Instructions The exam consists of six questions. You must answer all questions. If you need an assumption to complete a question,
More informationMicroeconomic Foundations of Incomplete Price Adjustment
Chapter 6 Microeconomic Foundations of Incomplete Price Adjustment In Romer s IS/MP/IA model, we assume prices/inflation adjust imperfectly when output changes. Empirically, there is a negative relationship
More informationMonopolistic competition models
models Robert Stehrer Version: May 22, 213 Introduction Classical models Explanations for trade based on differences in Technology Factor endowments Predicts complete trade specialization i.e. no intra-industry
More informationCUR 412: Game Theory and its Applications, Lecture 9
CUR 412: Game Theory and its Applications, Lecture 9 Prof. Ronaldo CARPIO May 22, 2015 Announcements HW #3 is due next week. Ch. 6.1: Ultimatum Game This is a simple game that can model a very simplified
More informationPh.D. Preliminary Examination MICROECONOMIC THEORY Applied Economics Graduate Program June 2017
Ph.D. Preliminary Examination MICROECONOMIC THEORY Applied Economics Graduate Program June 2017 The time limit for this exam is four hours. The exam has four sections. Each section includes two questions.
More informationProblem 3,a. ds 1 (s 2 ) ds 2 < 0. = (1+t)
Problem Set 3. Pay-off functions are given for the following continuous games, where the players simultaneously choose strategies s and s. Find the players best-response functions and graph them. Find
More informationHeterogeneity in Multinomial Choice Models, with an Application to a Study of Employment Dynamics
, with an Application to a Study of Employment Dynamics Victoria Prowse Department of Economics and Nuffield College, University of Oxford and IZA, Bonn This version: September 2006 Abstract In the absence
More informationISSN BWPEF Uninformative Equilibrium in Uniform Price Auctions. Arup Daripa Birkbeck, University of London.
ISSN 1745-8587 Birkbeck Working Papers in Economics & Finance School of Economics, Mathematics and Statistics BWPEF 0701 Uninformative Equilibrium in Uniform Price Auctions Arup Daripa Birkbeck, University
More informationMeasuring market power in the Spanish mutual funds industry for retail investors
Measuring market power in the Spanish mutual funds industry for retail investors Ramiro Losada July 2015 Abstract The mutual fund industry is characterized by high concentration and a high number of funds
More informationGT CREST-LMA. Pricing-to-Market, Trade Costs, and International Relative Prices
: Pricing-to-Market, Trade Costs, and International Relative Prices (2008, AER) December 5 th, 2008 Empirical motivation US PPI-based RER is highly volatile Under PPP, this should induce a high volatility
More informationPhD Qualifier Examination
PhD Qualifier Examination Department of Agricultural Economics May 29, 2015 Instructions This exam consists of six questions. You must answer all questions. If you need an assumption to complete a question,
More informationTwo-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets
Two-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets Céline Bonnet, Pierre Dubois, Michel Simioni First Version : June 2004. This
More informationInflation Dynamics During the Financial Crisis
Inflation Dynamics During the Financial Crisis S. Gilchrist 1 R. Schoenle 2 J. W. Sim 3 E. Zakrajšek 3 1 Boston University and NBER 2 Brandeis University 3 Federal Reserve Board Theory and Methods in Macroeconomics
More informationSolution to Assignment 3
Solution to Assignment 3 0/03 Semester I MA6 Game Theory Tutor: Xiang Sun October 5, 0. Question 5, in Tutorial set 5;. Question, in Tutorial set 6; 3. Question, in Tutorial set 7. Solution for Question
More informationLecture 3: Tax incidence
Lecture 3: Tax incidence Economics 336/337 University of Toronto Public Economics (Toronto) Tax Incidence 1 / 18 Tax incidence in competitive markets What is the economic incidence of a tax on a single
More informationStrategic Production Game 1
Lec5-6.doc Strategic Production Game Consider two firms, which have to make production decisions without knowing what the other is doing. For simplicity we shall suppose that the product is essentially
More informationAdverse Selection in the Loan Market
1/45 Adverse Selection in the Loan Market Gregory Crawford 1 Nicola Pavanini 2 Fabiano Schivardi 3 1 University of Warwick, CEPR and CAGE 2 University of Warwick 3 University of Cagliari, EIEF and CEPR
More informationFinancial Liberalization and Neighbor Coordination
Financial Liberalization and Neighbor Coordination Arvind Magesan and Jordi Mondria January 31, 2011 Abstract In this paper we study the economic and strategic incentives for a country to financially liberalize
More informationTable 10.1: Elimination and equilibrium. 1. Is there a dominant strategy for either of the two agents?
Chapter 10 Strategic Behaviour Exercise 10.1 Table 10.1 is the strategic form representation of a simultaneous move game in which strategies are actions. s b 1 s b 2 s b 3 s a 1 0, 2 3, 1 4, 3 s a 2 2,
More informationMicroeconomics II. CIDE, MsC Economics. List of Problems
Microeconomics II CIDE, MsC Economics List of Problems 1. There are three people, Amy (A), Bart (B) and Chris (C): A and B have hats. These three people are arranged in a room so that B can see everything
More informationGeneralized Multi-Factor Commodity Spot Price Modeling through Dynamic Cournot Resource Extraction Models
Generalized Multi-Factor Commodity Spot Price Modeling through Dynamic Cournot Resource Extraction Models Bilkan Erkmen (joint work with Michael Coulon) Workshop on Stochastic Games, Equilibrium, and Applications
More informationParallel Accommodating Conduct: Evaluating the Performance of the CPPI Index
Parallel Accommodating Conduct: Evaluating the Performance of the CPPI Index Marc Ivaldi Vicente Lagos Preliminary version, please do not quote without permission Abstract The Coordinate Price Pressure
More informationIncreasing Returns and Economic Geography
Increasing Returns and Economic Geography Department of Economics HKUST April 25, 2018 Increasing Returns and Economic Geography 1 / 31 Introduction: From Krugman (1979) to Krugman (1991) The award of
More informationECON106P: Pricing and Strategy
ECON106P: Pricing and Strategy Yangbo Song Economics Department, UCLA June 30, 2014 Yangbo Song UCLA June 30, 2014 1 / 31 Game theory Game theory is a methodology used to analyze strategic situations in
More informationTwo-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets
Two-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets Céline Bonnet, Pierre Dubois, Michel Simioni First Version : April 2004.
More informationInternationalization of Production: FDI and. FDI-Outsourcing
nternationalization of Production: FD and Outsourcing giuseppe.dearcangelis@uniroma1.it 2016 1st Term Plan of the lecture Review Definition of FD Horizontal vs. Vertical FD Traditional theories of FD:
More informationEstimating a Dynamic Oligopolistic Game with Serially Correlated Unobserved Production Costs. SS223B-Empirical IO
Estimating a Dynamic Oligopolistic Game with Serially Correlated Unobserved Production Costs SS223B-Empirical IO Motivation There have been substantial recent developments in the empirical literature on
More informationTwo-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets
Two-Part Tariffs versus Linear Pricing Between Manufacturers and Retailers : Empirical Tests on Differentiated Products Markets Céline Bonnet, Pierre Dubois, Michel Simioni First Version : April 2004.
More informationEconomics Honors Exam 2008 Solutions Question 1
Economics Honors Exam 2008 Solutions Question 1 (a) (2 points) The steel firm's profit-maximization problem is max p s s c s (s, x) = p s s αs 2 + βx γx 2 s,x 0.5 points: for realizing that profit is revenue
More informationOligopoly Games and Voting Games. Cournot s Model of Quantity Competition:
Oligopoly Games and Voting Games Cournot s Model of Quantity Competition: Supposetherearetwofirms, producing an identical good. (In his 1838 book, Cournot thought of firms filling bottles with mineral
More informationNot All Oil Price Shocks Are Alike: A Neoclassical Perspective
Not All Oil Price Shocks Are Alike: A Neoclassical Perspective Vipin Arora Pedro Gomis-Porqueras Junsang Lee U.S. EIA Deakin Univ. SKKU December 16, 2013 GRIPS Junsang Lee (SKKU) Oil Price Dynamics in
More informationGS/ECON 5010 Answers to Assignment 3 November 2005
GS/ECON 5010 Answers to Assignment November 005 Q1. What are the market price, and aggregate quantity sold, in long run equilibrium in a perfectly competitive market for which the demand function has the
More informationGS/ECON 5010 Answers to Assignment 3 November 2008
GS/ECON 500 Answers to Assignment November 008 Q. Find the profit function, supply function, and unconditional input demand functions for a firm with a production function f(x, x ) = x + ln (x + ) (do
More informationOnline Appendix to R&D and the Incentives from Merger and Acquisition Activity *
Online Appendix to R&D and the Incentives from Merger and Acquisition Activity * Index Section 1: High bargaining power of the small firm Page 1 Section 2: Analysis of Multiple Small Firms and 1 Large
More informationMaximin and minimax strategies in asymmetric duopoly: Cournot and Bertrand
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive Maximin and minimax strategies in asymmetric duopoly: Cournot and Bertrand Yasuhito Tanaka and Atsuhiro Satoh 22 September 2016 Online at https://mpraubuni-muenchende/73925/
More informationEndogenous Cartel Formation with Differentiated Products and Price Competition
Endogenous Cartel Formation with Differentiated Products and Price Competition Tyra Merker * February 2018 Abstract Cartels may cause great harm to consumers and economic efficiency. However, literature
More informationDynamic Replication of Non-Maturing Assets and Liabilities
Dynamic Replication of Non-Maturing Assets and Liabilities Michael Schürle Institute for Operations Research and Computational Finance, University of St. Gallen, Bodanstr. 6, CH-9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland
More informationEconS 424 Strategy and Game Theory. Homework #5 Answer Key
EconS 44 Strategy and Game Theory Homework #5 Answer Key Exercise #1 Collusion among N doctors Consider an infinitely repeated game, in which there are nn 3 doctors, who have created a partnership. In
More informationDiscrete Choice Theory and Travel Demand Modelling
Discrete Choice Theory and Travel Demand Modelling The Multinomial Logit Model Anders Karlström Division of Transport and Location Analysis, KTH Jan 21, 2013 Urban Modelling (TLA, KTH) 2013-01-21 1 / 30
More informationLecture 6 Dynamic games with imperfect information
Lecture 6 Dynamic games with imperfect information Backward Induction in dynamic games of imperfect information We start at the end of the trees first find the Nash equilibrium (NE) of the last subgame
More informationEcon 101A Final exam Mo 18 May, 2009.
Econ 101A Final exam Mo 18 May, 2009. Do not turn the page until instructed to. Do not forget to write Problems 1 and 2 in the first Blue Book and Problems 3 and 4 in the second Blue Book. 1 Econ 101A
More informationDuopoly models Multistage games with observed actions Subgame perfect equilibrium Extensive form of a game Two-stage prisoner s dilemma
Recap Last class (September 20, 2016) Duopoly models Multistage games with observed actions Subgame perfect equilibrium Extensive form of a game Two-stage prisoner s dilemma Today (October 13, 2016) Finitely
More informationPAULI MURTO, ANDREY ZHUKOV
GAME THEORY SOLUTION SET 1 WINTER 018 PAULI MURTO, ANDREY ZHUKOV Introduction For suggested solution to problem 4, last year s suggested solutions by Tsz-Ning Wong were used who I think used suggested
More informationMicroeconomic Theory August 2013 Applied Economics. Ph.D. PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION MICROECONOMIC THEORY. Applied Economics Graduate Program
Ph.D. PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION MICROECONOMIC THEORY Applied Economics Graduate Program August 2013 The time limit for this exam is four hours. The exam has four sections. Each section includes two questions.
More informationA potentially useful approach to model nonlinearities in time series is to assume different behavior (structural break) in different subsamples
1.3 Regime switching models A potentially useful approach to model nonlinearities in time series is to assume different behavior (structural break) in different subsamples (or regimes). If the dates, the
More informationUC Berkeley Haas School of Business Game Theory (EMBA 296 & EWMBA 211) Summer 2016
UC Berkeley Haas School of Business Game Theory (EMBA 296 & EWMBA 211) Summer 2016 More on strategic games and extensive games with perfect information Block 2 Jun 11, 2017 Auctions results Histogram of
More informationPricing Problems under the Markov Chain Choice Model
Pricing Problems under the Markov Chain Choice Model James Dong School of Operations Research and Information Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853, USA jd748@cornell.edu A. Serdar Simsek
More informationHomework # 8 - [Due on Wednesday November 1st, 2017]
Homework # 8 - [Due on Wednesday November 1st, 2017] 1. A tax is to be levied on a commodity bought and sold in a competitive market. Two possible forms of tax may be used: In one case, a per unit tax
More informationCompetition in Electricity Markets with Renewable Sources
Competition in Electricity Markets with Renewable Sources Ali Kakhbod and Asu Ozdaglar Laboratory for Information and Decision Systems Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Department Massachusetts
More informationVertical Relations: Double Marginalization, Price Negotiation and Integration
Vertical Relations: Double Marginalization, Price Negotiation and Integration Jean-François Houde Cornell University & NBER October 17, 2016 Vertical Relations 1 / 41 Introduction: Vertical Contracting
More information