2016 Proxy Season Preparations
|
|
- Job Pitts
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 2016 Proxy Season Preparations March 11, 2016 Guest Speaker Patrick McGurn, Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc. Christine Edwards, Winston & Strawn LLP Karen Weber, Winston & Strawn LLP Jerry Loeser, Winston & Strawn LLP
2 Winston & Strawn conducts an annual webinar series to assist Financial Institution directors in understanding issues, regulatory requirements, investor priorities and market realities. This series complements our weekly Financial Services Update which is designed to provide quick, readable, and ongoing information about what Congress, regulators, courts and competitors are doing. If you wish to sign up to receive the Update, please visit winston.com/subscribe. 2
3 MARK YOUR CALENDARS! Three More 75-minute Webinars: Today April 8 April Proxy Season Preparations Personal Liability and Other Considerations The Directors Perspective 3
4 2016 Proxy Season Preparations Christine Edwards Chair of Winston & Strawn s bank regulatory practice Nationally recognized expert on corporate governance Over 30 years of experience, including as Former EVP and Chief Legal Officer, of Bank One and of Morgan Stanley Karen Weber Partner in Winston & Strawn who concentrates her practice in public securities offerings, securities law compliance, and corporate governance. Represents companies and underwriters in debt and equity offerings 4
5 2016 Proxy Season Preparations Julius L. ( Jerry ) Loeser Of Counsel in Winston & Strawn s bank regulatory practice 45 years of bank regulatory experience Former Federal Reserve Board lawyer, chief regulatory counsel at Wells Fargo & Co., and Deputy General Counsel at Comerica Bank 5
6 Proxy Advisors Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc. ( ISS ) and Glass Lewis & Co. ( Glass Lewis ) are the largest proxy advisors in the US, respectively controlling 61% and 36% of the proxy advisory market. Proxy advisors provide resources for companies with services such as: objective governance research and recommendations; socially responsible investment data, analytics, and research; end-to-end proxy voting and distribution solutions; turnkey securities class-action claims management; and reliable global governance data and modeling tools. Institutional clients use proxy advisors to better understand the corporate governance environment, identify various governance risks and manage their proxy voting needs. Proxy advisors provide voting recommendations to their investor clients in accordance with their policies, which are updated each year. Some proxy advisors employ a process to solicit outside views through policy surveys regarding possible changes. Available resources to companies and investors: ISS policies by contacting the ISS Research Helpdesk at Usresearch@issgovernance.com or Glass Lewis policies at info@glasslewis.com or
7 2016 Proxy Season Preparations Guest Speaker: Patrick McGurn Special Counsel Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc. 7
8 Governance Practices at Banks and Diversified Financials ISS QuickScore Data for S&P 500 Banks (17) Diversified Financials (26) Board size 13.6 directors 12.2 directors % of independent directors 87.2% 83.8% % of current/former insiders 10% 11% # of financial experts Combined CEO/chair 13 of of 26 Independent chairs 3 of 17 7 of 26 Independent lead director 15 of of 26 Overboarded CEOs 3 of 17 1 of 26 Overboarded outside directors 0 1 of 26 Truants on boards at # firms 2 of 17 0 Majority voting 14 of of 26 Average support for directors in % of votes cast (218) 98.6% of votes cast (288) Average support for MSoP in % of votes cast 95.2 percent of votes cast (24) Top SH proposal topics for 16 (Source: ISS Voting Analytics Database) Proxy Access, Double Trigger (AV), Lobbying, Independent Chair (IC) & Clawbacks (Derivatives out at SEC) Access, Lobbying, Employment Diversity, Simple Majority Vote, AV & Data Security. Voting on climate change and CEO pay. 8
9 1. Role of Board 2. Director Qualifications Proxy Issues: Proxy Access Proxy Issues: Activist Shareholders Proxy Issues: Executive Compensation 6. Other Issues: I. Diversity II. Lobbying Spend and Political Contributions III. Related Party Disclosure Standard 9
10 Role of Financial Institution Board Increasing regulatory expectations Oversight vs. approvals vs. management Trend began as traditional state corporate law dominance (Delaware) was supplemented by Federal corporate governance laws Sarbanes-Oxley Audit Committee requirements Dodd-Frank Compensation Committee and Board requirements 10
11 Role of Financial Institution Board Prudential regulators have substantially increased requirements for Financial Institutions boards. Examinations include board performance, and management reporting to, the board, regarding those responsibilities. Examples: Capital Adequacy Plans: approve the plan and oversee implementation Internal Audit Annual Report: review for independence and approve Information Security: review plan, approve and oversee Risk Committee: monitor implementation of liquidity risk-management and liquidity stress-testing Incentive Compensation Plans: review, evaluate for risk incentives and approve Federally mandated Resolution Plan: review and approve Proposed Liquidity Coverage Rule: oversee implications and adoption 11
12 Role of Financial Institution Board "Directors must exercise their independent judgment when managing the bank's affairs A board that is excessively influenced by management, a single director, or a shareholder, or any combination thereof, may not be fulfilling its responsibilities " Source: FRB Commercial Bank Examination Manual 12
13 Director Qualifications Governance Environment Observations: Greater frequency of Board and Committee meetings Increasing detail and size of Board and Committee materials Increasing regulatory mandated reviews and approvals Increasing level of sophistication to understand requirements Increasing number of Director/Regulator meetings (many in Executive Session) Holding Company: across line of business oversight requirements increasing Implications of Environment on Director Qualifications Director knowledge and experience in the industry critical Availability of director candidates who are in Executive Positions is decreasing Board size is shrinking Greater responsibility for each director on smaller boards Complexity of issues reviewed in Committees (particularly Risk Committees) requires substantial time for preparation. Professional boards? 13
14 Director Qualifications Director Tenure and Term Limits Proxy advisors: Is nine years the limit? ISS: no change yet in voting policy that tenure can lead to a determination that a director is not independent. Shareholders should scrutinize average tenure of all directors if their tenure exceeds 15 years in order to promote independence and alternative perspectives. State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) revised its view on board tenure in 2014 to reflect its support for board refreshment and planning for director succession. The Council of Institutional Investors supports board turnover in order to guard against a seasoned board member losing his or her independence or thinking more like an insider over time. Glass Lewis does not believe in an inflexible rule. Glass Lewis supports periodic director rotation through shareholder monitoring to promote fresh perspectives, new ideas, and business strategies. Question: with the amount of time, knowledge and sophistication required of financial institution directors, is a shorter tenure a good thing? Said another way, how long does it take for directors of financial institutions to know their institutions and be capable of doing their job well? 14
15 Proxy Access Major developments in Proxy Access On July 22, 2011, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit vacated the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission s Rule 14a-11. This proxy access rule was adopted shortly after Section 971 of the Dodd-Frank Act clarified the SEC s authority to promulgate the rule. The Court held that the SEC was arbitrary and capricious in adopting the rule Following these developments, proxy advisory firms and institutional shareholders began to demand changes in company bylaws relating to proxy access. Many companies have voluntarily implemented proxy access bylaws and other companies have done so prompted by institutional shareholders. Since November 2014, the number of firms with proxy access bylaws has grown from 6 to New York City Comptroller Press Release, PR , dated January 11,
16 Proxy Access Growing Success for Proxy Access resolutions In 2014, 28% of proxy access proposals were approved by shareholders In 2015, that grew to more than 50% of proxy access proposals were approved by shareholders Percentage of shareholders voting in favor: 34% in 2014; 55% in 2015 Institutional shareholders are more likely than retail investors to vote for proxy access proposals. 85% of retail shareholders voted against the proposals; 61% of institutional shareholders voted for the proposals. 16
17 Proxy Access SEC Proposal Most Common Company Provision Proxy Advisory Firm Ownership Threshold 3% 3% (minority position of 5%) 3% (some institutional shareholders favor 5%) Duration of Ownership 3 years 3 years 3 years Nomination Limit 25% of Board 20% of Board (significant minority position of 2 directors or 20% of Board; minority position of 25% of Board) At least 2 directors or 25% of Board Shareholder Aggregation No limit 20 shareholders No limit 17
18 Proxy Access ISS Position on Company Adopted Bylaws: if either (1) the bylaw standards differ from the approved shareholder proposal without sufficient disclosure, or (2) a company implements a Proxy Access bylaw that is substantially below the above standards, then ISS may issue an "adverse recommendation" as to the company's board of directors in advance of the company's annual meeting. 18
19 Proxy Access In 2016, the New York City Comptroller is targeting 72 companies for proxy access proposals. 36 are repeat firms from 2015 where no acceptable proxy access bylaw was implemented. Other Institutional Investors that support proxy access bylaws include: Blackrock, CalPERS, CalSTRS, TIAA- CREF, T. Rowe Price, and Vanguard. 19
20 Proxy Access Defensive Strategies Are Diminishing Companies may try to implement their own proxy access standards and exclude shareholder proposals as having already been substantially implemented. Note: Adoption of multiple No-Action Letters from SEC: In mid-february 2016, the SEC largely allowed companies to block shareholder proposals on proxy access if the company had substantially implemented proxy access on its own however additional letters then began to define "substantially implemented". The SEC denied No-Action Relief to three companies who set the minimum ownership threshold at 5% rather than 3%. 20
21 Proxy Access Defense Strategies are Diminishing Propose a management-favored proxy access rule for vote by the shareholders and exclude shareholder proposals as directly conflicting". Ability of company to find "direct conflict" limited by SEC issued guidance in October 2015 that in evaluating whether two proposals directly conflict the SEC will consider whether a reasonable shareholder could logically vote for both proposals Submit both the management and shareholder proposals in the proxy materials Negotiated settlements whereby the company either agrees to adopt a bylaw or will agree to recommend that shareholders adopt proxy access the following year 21
22 Proxy Access Question for Directors: If your company has adopted proxy access, have you discussed how the bylaw will work in light of various potential activist strategies? 22
23 Proxy Access and Activist Campaigns Bylaws are structured to discourage use by short term, financial activist investors: Proxy access bylaws frequently restrict use to passive investors Activist investors often do not meet the 3-year holding period Limitations on nominating a maximum of 25% of the board: designed to avoid allowing activist investors to gain control of the board. 23
24 Activist Campaigns Activist campaigns have been increasing 2010 Activist campaigns: Activist campaigns: Activist campaigns: Activist campaigns: Activist campaigns: Activist campaigns numbered 355 as of mid-december Prior maximum: 353 in 2008 Through mid-december of 2015, 127 of the campaigns resulted in the activist investor acquiring at least one board seat (35.77% of all campaigns that year). 24
25 Activist Campaigns Activist investors are having a significant impact on the corporate governance landscape. Examples of Recent Activist Campaigns Appaloosa Management in combination with Harry Wilson, Hayman Capital Management, HG Vora Capital Management, and Taconic Capital Advisors campaign against General Motors for a board position and/or return of capital Carl Icahn s bid for a Merger or Acquisition or board position on ebay Corvex Management s campaign for Yum Brands Inc. to effect Business strategy and/or Merger or Acquisition JANA Partners bid for Qualcomm for return of capital and/or Merger or Acquisition Marcato Capital Management s campaign for BNY Mellon for a board position and certain management changes PAR Capital Management, Inc. and Altimeter Capital Management, L.P campaign for board positions on United Continental Holdings, Inc. Starboard Value bid for Yahoo Inc., for return of capital and/or Merger or Acquisition Trian Fund Management s separate bids for PepsiCo Inc. and DuPont E.I. De Nemours & Co., in each case for Merger or Acquisition or board position 25
26 Activist Campaigns Other Considerations: Motivations for activist shareholders include: Increase in stock price and company valuation Board changes Strategy changes Mergers and Acquisitions Poison Pills. Proxy advisors are not categorically against them. Considerations include: Whether the board adopts a poison pill with a term of 12 months or less ("short-term pill"); The date of the pill's adoption relative to the date of the next meeting of shareholdersi.e. whether the company had time to put the pill on the ballot for shareholder ratification given the circumstances; The issuer's rationale; The issuer's governance structure and practices; and The issuer's track record of accountability to shareholders. 26
27 Total Shareholder Return Total Shareholder Return ( TSR ) There is a market trend to use relative TSR as the sole or key performance metric for long-term incentive performance plans. A WSJ/Hay Group CEO pay survey found that TSR rose 34.6% in 2013, while CEO pay only rose 5.5%. In 2014, TSR increased by 16.6%, but pay rose by only 4.6% A turbulent 2015 resulted in negative total shareholder return (TSR) MSCI ESG Research showed that declining stock values have resulted in the average one-year TSR falling to negative 2.93% First time since 2009 that TSR has been negative. 27
28 Total Shareholder Return TSR BUT, there is disagreement over whether TSR should be used as a sole, or even primary metric. Relative TSR (company TSR measured against an external comparator group) is often replacing a broad portfolio of other key business metrics such as profitability, cash flow and capital returns. Depending on the length of potential claw-back provisions, this change may have negative consequences on executive motivation and possibly encourage excessive risk taking. In order to beat the median relative TSR over a given period a company would need to take on above median risk. 28
29 Other Issues: Diversity Shareholder Resolutions pertaining to Diversity where previously the focus was on gender diversity now have broadened to ethnic and racial diversity. Apple s 2016 proxy contained a shareholder resolution to require the company to increase diversity including particularly Hispanic, African-American, Native-American and other people of color--of senior management and its board of directors Management urged shareholders to vote against the resolution as unduly burdensome and not necessary and described the diversity already existing within their board and senior management. The New York City Comptroller has specifically highlighted lack of board diversity as an area ripe for additional proxy resolutions. 29
30 Other Issues: Lobbying Costs and Political Contributions Although lobbying and political contributions proposals again were frequent shareholder proposal topics, the total number of such proposals has decreased in recent history, with shareholders submitting 110 such proposals for 2015 stockholder meetings, compared to 126 proposals for 2014 shareholder meetings. Shareholder proposals range from requests for disclosure of lobbying costs and political contributions to prohibitions against such spending. ISS Policy: Vote CASE-BY-CASE on proposals requiring greater disclosure of a company s lobbying activities, policies or procedures; generally vote FOR proposals requesting greater disclosure of a company's political contributions and trade association spending policies and activities Support Disclosure of Lobbying Activities: 30 proposals voted on and an average of 25.5% support, with 0 proposals passing. Political Contributions: 25 proposals voted on and an average of 33.9% support, with 0 proposal passing. 30
31 Other Issues: Related Party Transaction Disclosure Auditing Standard 18: new definition of related party is very broad and includes anyone who can control or influence a principal owner, director or member of management Standard 18, by itself, does not change public disclosure rules, but is intended to broaden reporting to external auditors and expand the range of potential relationships and transactions to review. Auditors can then assess the transactions identified as having a material impact, and discloseable in financial statements, and determine whether the company's processes are sufficient. Companies must have sufficient processes and controls to identify and monitor related party transactions Prior emphasis focused on the related-party transaction itself New emphasis is on sufficient processes to identify all related parties New focus on all directors and officers respective relationships, including extended families, friends, and outside business partners. Question: Has your company changed its D&O questionnaire? 31
32 Executive Compensation On March 30, 2011, the federal banking agencies proposed a rule on incentive compensation. Applicable to financial institutions with more than $1 billion in assets Complemented guidance issued by the regulators Incentive compensation arrangements should not incent inappropriate risk Financial institutions with $50 billion or more in assets Defer at least 50% of incentive compensation of certain officers for at least three years Amounts ultimately paid should reflect losses and performance over time. Not yet adopted. 32
33 CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure SEC s Pay Ratio Disclosure Rule Effective for 2018 Proxy Season Most companies are beginning preparations now Dodd-Frank Act Section 953(b) requires every public company to disclose: 1. The median of the annual total compensation of all employees, except the CEO (including employees outside the U.S.); 2. The annual total compensation of the CEO (or any equivalent position) of the company; 3. The ratio of the amount described above in bullet 1 to the amount described in bullet 2; and 4. The methodology and material assumptions used to calculate the above. 33
34 CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure In August 2015, the SEC issued final rules on the CEO pay ratio rules The new disclosure requirements do not apply to: Smaller reporting companies Foreign private issuers Multijurisdictional filers Emerging growth companies Registered investment companies 34
35 Dodd-Frank Report: SEC Rulemaking Provision Proposed Final Effective Applicable To CEO Pay Ratio September 18, 2013 August 5, 2015 W/r/t compensation in fiscal years beginning on or after January 1, 2017 (reported in 2018 proxy statement). Transition for newly public companies Reporting companies other than emerging growth companies, smaller reporting companies and foreign private issuers Clawback July 1, 2015 TBD SEC TBD; exchanges have 1 year to adopt rules following effectiveness of SEC rule; companies then have 60 days to adopt policy All issuers listed on a national exchange. Covers compensation based on financial info for periods ending on and after SEC effectiveness Pay for Performance Disclosure Hedging Disclosure April 29, 2015 TBD TBD; phase-in for number of covered years in the new table Reporting companies other than emerging growth companies and foreign private issuers. February 9, 2015 TBD TBD Reporting companies other than foreign private issuers 35
36 Contact Information Chris Edwards Partner Karen Weber Partner +1 (312) Jerry Loeser Of Counsel Sterling Sears Associate
37
Association of Corporate Counsel 2017 Shareholder Proxy Season: Governance Decision Making in a Maelstrom of Change
Association of Corporate Counsel 2017 Shareholder Proxy Season: March 22, 2017 Speakers: Christine Edwards Jerry Loeser Michael Melbinger Speakers: Christine Edwards Chair of Winston & Strawn LLP s Bank
More informationHot Topics in Corporate Governance. November 14, 2017
Hot Topics in Corporate Governance November 14, 2017 Changes at the SEC New Chair: Jay Clayton New Director of the Division of Corporation Finance: Bill Hinman Two open Commission seats remain, with two
More informationFederal Financial Agencies Propose New Regulations on Executive Compensation: Here Is What You Need to Know
Federal Financial Agencies Propose New Regulations on Executive Compensation: Here Is What You Need to Know May 19, 2016 Winston & Strawn conducts an annual webinar series to assist Financial Institution
More informationLessons from the 2017 Proxy Season
Lessons from the 2017 Proxy Season S&C Client Webinar September 18, 2017 Janet Geldzahler Glen Schleyer Overview of Presentation Summary of proxy access proposals for 2017; further confirmation of market
More informationLooking ahead for public companies: what you need to know for 2018
November 20, 2017 Looking ahead for public companies: what you need to know for 2018 By Kelly D. Babson, David R. Brown and Lloyd H. Spencer In today s market, public companies face a variety of challenges
More informationDodd-Frank Corporate Governance
Dodd-Frank Corporate Governance 1 The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act: Executive Compensation and Corporate Governance Reforms, SEC Disclosure and Proxy Access Implications for
More informationLessons from the 2018 Proxy Season
SC1: 4706990 Lessons from the 2018 Proxy Season S&C Client Webinar September 13, 2018 Janet Geldzahler Melissa Sawyer Marc Trevino Overview of Presentation Environmental/social/political proposals more
More informationINSTITUTIONAL SHAREHOLDER SERVICES (ISS) AND GLASS LEWIS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS FOR THE 2013 PROXY SEASON
January 29, 2013 INSTITUTIONAL SHAREHOLDER SERVICES (ISS) AND GLASS LEWIS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS FOR THE 2013 PROXY SEASON To Our Clients and Friends: Institutional Shareholder Services
More information2018 Corporate Governance & Incentive Design Survey Fall 2018
2018 Corporate Governance & Incentive Design Survey Fall 2018 Contents Executive Summary 2 Corporate Governance Practices 3 Proxy Disclosure 12 Company Policies 19 Annual Incentive Plan Design Practices
More information2016 Navigating the Annual Report and Proxy Season
2016 Navigating the Annual Report and Proxy Season 2016 Governance Hot Topics Look Ahead to 2016 2 Board composition issues: Tenure/refreshment Diversity 0 Companies not worried about proxy access 1 Dodd-Frank
More informationCHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF MINERALS TECHNOLOGIES INC.
I. PURPOSE The primary purposes of the Audit Committee (the Committee ) are to: 1. Assist the Board of Directors (the Board ) in its oversight of (i) the integrity of the Company s financial statements,
More informationProxy Access Struck Down by Courts. Additional Dodd-Frank Act Compensation and Governance Provisions Delayed
Proxy Access Struck Down by Courts August 4, 2011 Additional Dodd-Frank Act Compensation and Governance Provisions Delayed As we reached the first anniversary of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer
More informationShareholder Activism Webinar. Dealing with Evolving Activist Investor Strategies. March 12, Moderator: Shirley Westcott
Shareholder Activism Webinar Dealing with Evolving Activist Investor Strategies March 12, 2014 Moderator: Shirley Westcott Senior Vice President Alliance Advisors LLC. Copyright 2012 by Alliance Advisors,
More informationPROXY SEASON AND FORM 10-K FILINGS: A look back at 2015 and what to expect in 2016
PROXY SEASON AND FORM 10-K FILINGS: A look back at 2015 and what to expect in 2016 DECEMBER 2015 OVERVIEW This overview summarizes new disclosure requirements and other developments that will generally
More informationComp Talks Proxy Season Rundown Scrutinizing 2017 to Improve 2018
Comp Talks Proxy Season Rundown Scrutinizing 2017 to Improve 2018 Reid Pearson, Alliance Advisors Megan Arthur Schilling, Cooley Moderated by Amy Wood, Cooley attorney advertisement Copyright Cooley LLP,
More informationPROXY VOTING GUIDELINES
PROXY VOTING GUIDELINES T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. and its affiliated investment advisers ( T. Rowe Price ) recognize and adhere to the principle that one of the privileges of owning stock in a company
More informationShareholder Proposals: Strategies and Tactics
Shareholder Proposals: Strategies and Tactics Cam Hoang Gary Tygesson Violet Richardson Dorsey & Whitney LLP 1 Introduction CAM HOANG Cam, a partner in our Corporate Group, advises clients on governance
More informationShareholder Proposals: Strategies and Tactics
Shareholder Proposals: Strategies and Tactics Cam Hoang Gary Tygesson Violet Richardson Dorsey & Whitney LLP 1 Introduction CAM HOANG Cam, a partner in our Corporate Group, advises clients on governance
More informationMONDELĒZ INTERNATIONAL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. Effective January 26, 2015
Purpose. MONDELĒZ INTERNATIONAL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Effective January 26, 2015 The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Mondelēz International,
More informationAs revised at the September 23, 2013 Board of Directors Meeting
As revised at the September 23, 2013 Board of Directors Meeting PURPOSE The Audit and Finance Committee ( AFC ) is appointed by the Board of Directors (the Board ) to assist the Board (1) in fulfilling
More informationEVINE LIVE INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
EVINE LIVE INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. PURPOSE, DUTIES, and RESPONSIBILITIES The audit committee (the Committee ) is established by the board of directors (the board ) of EVINE Live Inc. (the company
More informationBank Regulatory Practice
Bank Regulatory Practice SEPTEMBER 2016 Does the Federal Reserve Board have Authority to Set Incentive Compensation? Earlier this year, the Agencies 1 published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (the Proposed
More informationIs Proxy Access Inevitable?
November 4, 2015 SIDLEY UPDATE Is Proxy Access Inevitable? Review of 2015 Proxy Access Results and Provisions Related Considerations for Boards and Counsel This article revises our Sidley Updates issued
More informationShareholder Engagement and Activism:
Eduardo Gallardo, Gibson Dunn Brian Lutz, Gibson Dunn Lori Zyskowski, Gibson Dunn Matthew Sherman, Joele Frank Scott Winter, Innisfree Shareholder Engagement and Activism: Preparing for the 2018 Proxy
More informationCorporate Governance Under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform & Consumer Protection Act
Corporate Governance Under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform & Consumer Protection Act John Brantley, Partner, Bracewell & Giuliani LLP October 22, 2010 The Law in Context Corporate governance has been
More informationSeven for '11: Directors Roll Dice in Proxy Season Craps Game. Today s Presenters. Patrick McGurn Executive Director ISS
Seven for '11: Directors Roll Dice in Proxy Season Craps Game 1 2 Today s Presenters Patrick McGurn Executive Director ISS Steven R. Barth Partner Foley & Lardner LLP Patrick G. Quick Partner Foley & Lardner
More information2017 PROXY SEASON PREVIEW NORTH AMERICA
2017 PROXY SEASON PREVIEW NORTH AMERICA TODAY S SPEAKERS Kern McPherson Sr. Director, North American Research Greg Waters Director, North American Research Courteney Keatinge - Director, Environmental,
More informationBLOOM ENERGY CORPORATION CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES. (As adopted on May 10, 2018)
BLOOM ENERGY CORPORATION CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES (As adopted on May 10, 2018) The following Corporate Governance Guidelines have been adopted by the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Bloom Energy
More informationCorporate Governance and Responsible Investment Policy North America 2018
Corporate Governance and Responsible Investment Policy North America 2018 Contents Company board...3 Structure and operation...3 Board effectiveness...3 Compensation...4 Shareholder rights...6 This policy
More informationINSTITUTIONAL SHAREHOLDER SERVICES REBRANDS AND RELEASES UPDATED GOVERNANCE QUALITYSCORE MODEL
November 8, 2016 NEW YORK CHICAGO LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO ATLANTA HOUSTON BOSTON ALERT INSTITUTIONAL SHAREHOLDER SERVICES REBRANDS AND RELEASES UPDATED GOVERNANCE QUALITYSCORE MODEL Institutional Shareholder
More informationRequirements for Public Company Boards
Public Company Advisory Group Requirements for Public Company Boards Including IPO Transition Rules November 2016 Introduction. 1 The Role and Authority of Independent Directors. 2 The Definition of Independent
More informationFANNIE MAE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES
FANNIE MAE CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES 1. The Roles and Responsibilities of the Board and Management On September 6, 2008, the Director of the Federal Housing Finance Authority, or FHFA, our safety
More informationHot Topics 2013 Proxy season highlights
Hot Topics 2013 Proxy season highlights Recent governance trends, regulatory developments, and the expectation of future governance-related legislation were highlighted in the June 25 Deloitte Dbriefs
More informationCorporate Governance and Executive Compensation Provisions in the Dodd-Frank Act
June 29, 2010 Corporate Governance and Executive Compensation Provisions in the Dodd-Frank Act On June 25, 2010, a House and Senate conference committee negotiating the blueprint for the reform of the
More informationActivist Defense Practice
Activist Defense Practice Peter Casey Executive Vice President - Proxy Solicitation Group pcasey@allianceadvisorsllc.com Jeffrey Nisenson Senior Vice President - Market Surveillance Group jnisenson@allianceadvisorsllc.com
More informationDispatches from the Proxy Front: A Preview of the 2013 Annual Meeting Season. Steven M. Pantina Managing Director January 18, 2013
Dispatches from the Proxy Front: A Preview of the 2013 Annual Meeting Season Steven M. Pantina Managing Director January 18, 2013 A Look Back at Say-on-Pay Votes in the 2012 Proxy Season Nearly 2,000 ballots
More informationWhile concerns about shareholder activism and the
Yoo Jaechang/TongRo Images/Corbis Lessons for the 2015 Proxy Season In her regular column on corporate governance issues, Holly Gregory examines trends emerging from the 2014 proxy season and related developments,
More informationISS Releases QualityScore Updates and Opens Data Verification Period
November 2, 2016 SIDLEY UPDATE ISS Releases QualityScore Updates and Opens Data Verification Period ISS Publishes New Questions and Other Methodology Updates to Its QualityScore (Formerly QuickScore) Governance
More informationLooking Back: 2010 Proxy Season in Review
Cynthia M. Krus, Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Lisa A. Morgan, Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Reid Pearson, The Altman Group Francis H. Byrd, The Altman Group June 30, 2010 Looking Back: 2010 Proxy
More informationGENESCO INC. CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
GENESCO INC. CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS PURPOSE The primary purpose of the Audit Committee (the Committee ) is to assist the Board of Directors (the Board ) in fulfilling
More information2010 Proxy Season Review: Say on Pay
Cynthia M. Krus, Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Lisa A. Morgan, Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Reid Pearson, The Altman Group Francis H. Byrd, The Altman Group July 27, 2010 2010 Proxy Season Review:
More informationFREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT PERIODIC REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR U.S. ISSUERS PRINCIPAL EXCHANGE ACT REPORTS
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT PERIODIC REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR U.S. ISSUERS PRINCIPAL EXCHANGE ACT REPORTS These Frequently Asked Questions should be read together with our Frequently Asked Questions
More information8/20/2002. Changes from the Initial NYSE Proposal Morrison & Foerster LLP. All Rights Reserved.
NYSE Adopts Changes to its Corporate Governance and Listing Standards; Differences between Current NYSE and Nasdaq Proposals and Sarbanes-Oxley Act Requirements 8/20/2002 Corporate, Financial Institutions
More informationWSGR ALERT PRESIDENT TO SIGN FINANCIAL OVERHAUL BILL. Corporate Governance and Executive Compensation Update. I. Corporate Governance
WSGR ALERT JULY 2010 PRESIDENT TO SIGN FINANCIAL OVERHAUL BILL Corporate Governance and Executive Compensation Update On July 15, 2010, after months of deliberation, Congress passed a comprehensive financial
More informationnot have participated in the preparation of the Company s or any of its subsidiaries financial statements at any time during the past three years;
SABRE CORPORATION AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. Statement of Purpose The Audit Committee (the Committee ) is a standing committee of the Board of Directors (the Board ). The purpose of the Committee is to
More informationHAMILTON BEACH BRANDS HOLDING COMPANY AUDIT REVIEW COMMITTEE CHARTER
HAMILTON BEACH BRANDS HOLDING COMPANY AUDIT REVIEW COMMITTEE CHARTER Purposes The purposes of the Audit Review Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Hamilton Beach Brands
More informationTHE PROXY SEASON FIELD GUIDE Third Edition
THE PROXY SEASON FIELD GUIDE Third Edition Acknowledgements: The Proxy Season Field Guide was prepared by the Public Companies and Corporate Governance Practice of Morrison & Foerster LLP. The MoFo Proxy
More informationBy Electronic Mail Only. August 24, 2018
John A. Zecca Senior Vice President General Counsel North America 805 King Farm Blvd, Suite 100 Rockville, MD 20850 / USA (301) 978-8498 john.zecca@nasdaq.com Nasdaq.com By Electronic Mail Only August
More information2017 Proxy Season Review
+ SEPTEMBER 2017 2017 Proxy Season Review What were the big headlines in the 2017 proxy season? Environmental, social and governance issues like climate change and board diversity. Institutional investors
More information2017 proxy statements
SEC Financial Reporting Series 2017 proxy statements An overview of the requirements and observations about current practice Contents 1 Overview... 1 1.1 Section highlights... 2 1.2 EY publications and
More informationMorgan Stanley Compensation & Governance Practices. March 2014
Morgan Stanley & Governance Practices March 2014 Executive Summary Executive Summary Morgan Stanley s Board of Directors unanimously recommends that shareholders vote: 1. FOR: Non-binding advisory vote
More informationG OV ERNANC E I NITIATIVE
C O R P OR ATE G OV ERNANC E I NITIATIVE Reinvigorating the Public Company Model SPRING 2018 1 INTRODUCTION Over the last few decades the U.S. has experienced a steady decline in public companies. In fact,
More informationCorporate Governance of the Largest US Public Companies General Governance Practices
Corporate Governance of the Largest US Public Companies General Governance Practices 2011 This Survey and our companion survey regarding director and executive compensation are available on the website
More informationKush Bottles, Inc. A Nevada corporation (the Company )
Kush Bottles, Inc. A Nevada corporation (the Company ) Audit Committee Charter The Audit Committee (the Committee ) is created by the Board of Directors of the Company (the Board ) to: assist the Board
More information2018 proxy statements
SEC Financial Reporting Series 2018 proxy statements An overview of the requirements and observations about current practice Contents 1 Overview... 1 1.1 Section highlights... 2 1.2 EY publications and
More informationCorporate Governance After the Dodd-Frank Act: Recent Developments
Corporate Governance After the Dodd-Frank Act: Recent Developments John C. Coffee, Jr. Cape Town, South Africa IOSCO Annual Meeting April, 2011 Slide 1 MAJOR DEVELOPMENTS 1. Proxy Access: 3% can now propose
More informationPreparing for the 2017 Proxy Season
Preparing for the 2017 Proxy Season Presented by: Michael Falk & Mike Melbinger November 10, 2016 Brought to you by Winston & Strawn s Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation Practice Today s elunch
More information2018 Proxy Season Preview United States
2018 Proxy Season Preview United States 2017 was a momentous year in corporate governance. We observed a growing emphasis on investor stewardship as a global phenomenon, with the proliferation of investor
More informationThe principal purposes of the Audit Committee (Committee) of the Board of Directors (Board) of Vistra Energy Corp.
VISTRA ENERGY CORP. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. PURPOSES OF THE COMMITTEE The principal purposes of the Audit Committee (Committee) of the Board of Directors (Board) of Vistra Energy Corp. (Company) are
More informationISS: THE GLOBAL LEADER IN GOVERNANCE
ISS: THE GLOBAL LEADER IN GOVERNANCE Santa Barbara County Employees Retirement System January 24, 2018 Now more than ever, Matters www.issgovernance.com AGENDA Corporate Evolution Proxy Voting Policy Options
More informationCORPORATE GOVERNANCE ALERT: COMPLYING WITH THE SEC'S FINAL DISCLOSURE RULES REGARDING THE DIRECTOR NOMINATION PROCESS
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE ALERT: COMPLYING WITH THE SEC'S FINAL DISCLOSURE RULES REGARDING THE DIRECTOR NOMINATION PROCESS AND SHAREHOLDER-DIRECTOR COMMUNICATIONS JANUARY 15, 2004 This memorandum is designed
More informationMARSH & McLENNAN COMPANIES NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING AND PROXY STATEMENT
MARSH & McLENNAN COMPANIES NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING AND PROXY STATEMENT 2011 Important Notice Regarding the Availability of Proxy Materials for the Marsh & McLennan Companies Annual Meeting of Stockholders
More informationCHARTER OF AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS (as amended through November 13, 2012)
CENTURYLINK, INC. CHARTER OF AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS (as amended through November 13, 2012) I. SCOPE OF RESPONSIBILITY A. General Subject to the limitations noted in Section VI, the primary
More informationThe following shall be the principal recurring duties of the Committee in carrying out its oversight responsibility.
AEVI GENOMIC MEDICINE, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER 1. PURPOSE The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Aevi Genomic Medicine, Inc. (the Company ) has the oversight
More informationSTANDARD DIVERSIFIED INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
STANDARD DIVERSIFIED INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER This Audit Committee Charter (this Charter ) was adopted by the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Standard Diversified Inc. (the Company ) on April 3,
More informationCo r p o r at e a n d
Co r p o r at e a n d Securities Law Update July 2010 Analysis of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act Executive Compensation, Corporate Governance and Enforcement Provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act Affecting
More informationTCG BDC II, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. the quality and integrity of the Company s financial statements;
TCG BDC II, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. PURPOSE The purposes of the Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of TCG BDC II, Inc. and its subsidiaries (collectively, the
More informationISS and Glass Lewis Policy Updates for the 2018 Proxy Season
November 29, 2017 SIDLEY UPDATE and Policy Updates for the 2018 Proxy Season Institutional Shareholder Services () and & Co. () have updated their proxy voting policies for shareholder meetings held on
More informationVycor Medical, Inc. Audit Committee Charter
Vycor Medical, Inc. Audit Committee Charter I. Purpose and authority The audit committee is established by and among the board of directors for the primary purpose of assisting the board in: Overseeing
More informationEY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly. January 2017
EY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly January 2017 2 Board Matters Quarterly January 2017 January 2017 Board Matters Quarterly In this issue 04 Governance trends at Russell 2000 companies
More informationCITIGROUP INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER As of March 21, 2012
CITIGROUP INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER As of March 21, 2012 Mission The Audit Committee ( Committee ) of Citigroup Inc. ( Citigroup ) is a standing committee of the Board of Directors ( Board ). The purpose
More informationImpacts of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act on Executive Compensation and Corporate. Governance THOUGHT LEADERSHIP
THOUGHT LEADERSHIP Alerts Service Securities & Corporate Governance Professionals Craig A. Adoor St. Louis: 314.345.6407 craig.adoor@ James M. Ash Kansas City: 816.983.8137 james.ash@ Steven R. Barrett
More information2018 Americas Proxy Voting Guidelines Updates
2018 Americas Proxy Voting Guidelines Updates Benchmark Policy Changes for U.S., Canada, and Brazil Effective for Meetings on or after February 1, 2018 Published November 16, 2017 www.issgovernance.com
More informationAudit committee reporting to shareholders: going beyond the minimum
Audit committee reporting to shareholders: going beyond the minimum Join the conversation on audit committee transparency February 2013 Ernst & Young supports effective audit committees and believes that
More informationGovernance Round-Up. In this Issue: SEC Issues Guidance on Rule 14a-8(i)(9) Delaware Courts Changing Rules on Disclosure-Only Settlements
Governance Round-Up 1 Governance Round-Up In this Issue: SEC Issues Guidance on Rule 14a-8(i)(9) Delaware Courts Changing Rules on Disclosure-Only Settlements ISS Quickscore Data Verification Open Until
More informationCOMMERCE BANCSHARES, INC. AUDIT AND RISK COMMITTEE CHARTER
COMMERCE BANCSHARES, INC. AUDIT AND RISK COMMITTEE CHARTER Committee Purpose The Audit and Risk Committee ( Committee ) is appointed by the Board of Directors to assist the Board in monitoring and oversight
More informationBANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES. As of October 25, 2017
BANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES As of October 25, 2017 The Board of Directors (the Board ) of Bank of America Corporation (the Company ), acting on the recommendation of its
More informationU.S. PROXY VOTING CONCISE GUIDELINES. Effective for Meetings on or after February 1, 2017
PROXY VOTING GUIDELINES U.S. PROXY VOTING CONCISE GUIDELINES Effective for Meetings on or after February 1, 2017 Vert Asset Management, LLC has delegated the authority to vote proxies for the portfolio
More informationFTI CONSULTING, INC. June 7, 2017 EXPERTS WITH IMPACT FTI Consulting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FTI CONSULTING, INC. June 7, 2017 EXPERTS WITH IMPACT 2017 FTI Consulting, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 1101 K Street NW Washington, DC 20005 +1.202.312.9100 April 25, 2017 DEAR FELLOW STOCKHOLDERS: You
More informationLet s talk: governance
EY Center for Board Matters Let s talk: governance Special edition 2014 proxy season preview ey.com/boardmatters 1 Proxy season 2014 preview Boards face shifting investor priorities and expectations Proxy
More informationVisa Inc. Audit and Risk Committee Charter
Visa Inc. Audit and Risk Committee Charter I. PURPOSE The Audit and Risk Committee (Committee) of the Board of Directors (Board) of Visa Inc. (Company) assists the Board in its oversight of the independent
More informationEY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly. April 2016
EY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly April 2016 2 Board Matters Quarterly April 2016 April 2016 Board Matters Quarterly In this issue 04 2016 proxy season preview: a focus on the long term
More informationEven before the five-year EGC limit expires, a company can lose EGC treatment by tripping any one of the following triggers, including:
June 2017 Once a company exits the JOBS Act, it must hold Say-on-Pay votes and disclose a host of new governance and compensation information planning early makes for a much easier transition. The JOBS
More informationNASD and NYSE Rulemaking: Relating to Corporate Governance
Home Previous Page NASD and NYSE Rulemaking: Relating to Corporate Governance SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION (Release No. 34-48745; File Nos. SR-NYSE-2002-33, SR-NASD-2002-77, SR- NASD-2002-80, SR-NASD-2002-138,
More informationLegal Alert: Overview of NYSE and Nasdaq Corporate Governance Listing Rules December 10, 2003
Legal Alert: Overview of NYSE and Nasdaq Corporate Governance Listing Rules December 10, 2003 Introduction On November 4, 2003, the SEC approved changes to the listing rules of the NYSE and the Nasdaq.
More informationDealing With Activist Hedge Funds
November 21, 2013 Dealing With Activist Hedge Funds This year has seen a continuance of the high and increasing level of activist campaigns experienced during the last 14 years, from 27 in 2000 to more
More informationAUDIT & RISK MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE CHARTER
AUDIT & RISK MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE CHARTER I AUTHORITY The Audit & Risk Management Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Enerplus Corporation (the Corporation ) shall be comprised
More informationA. Composition of the Board The Independent Director. 1) Desirability of Independent Directors Generally
Section 3 Fund Governance A. Composition of the Board The Independent Director 1) Desirability of Independent Directors Generally The 1940 Act contemplates independent oversight and monitoring of investment
More informationMorgan Stanley Compensation & Governance Practices. March 2013
Morgan Stanley & Governance Practices March 2013 Notice The information provided herein may include certain non-gaap financial measures. The reconciliation of such measures to the comparable GAAP figures
More informationPDC ENERGY, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. Amended and Restated September 18, 2015
PDC ENERGY, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Amended and Restated September 18, 2015 1. Purpose. The Board of Directors (the Board ) of PDC Energy, Inc. (the Company ) has duly established the Audit Committee
More informationBoard Composition, Refreshment and Tenure Hot Issues for Corporate Boards. October 2015
Board Composition, Refreshment and Tenure Hot Issues for Corporate Boards October 2015 Introductions Glenn Booraem a Principal at Vanguard Group, Inc. and Treasurer of each of the Vanguard Funds Rakhi
More informationDodd-Frank: What You Don t Want to Know but
Dodd-Frank: What You Don t Want to Know but Probably Should Bart J. Biggers, Shareholder Corporate, Securities/Mergers & Acquisitions Thursday, October 7, 2010 Dallas, Texas 2 3 Recent Sweeping Securities-Related
More informationSYSCO CORPORATION AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
APPROVED MAY 2013 SYSCO CORPORATION AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. Organization The Board of Directors of Sysco Corporation shall establish an Audit Committee whose members shall be appointed by the Board
More informationSARBANES-OXLEY UPDATE. NASDAQ: Summary of the Corporate Governance Proposals as of April 25, 2003
NEWS ALERT SARBANES-OXLEY UPDATE NASDAQ: Summary of the Corporate Governance Proposals as of April 25, 2003 Executive Summary Nasdaq has proposed several corporate governance reforms. As of April 25, 2003,
More informationPLI Annual Disclosure Documents
PLI Annual Disclosure Documents The Current State of Clawback Requirements and Considerations December 13, 2016 Agenda Overview of Proposed Rules Review of clawback policy considerations View from ISS
More informationCHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF APARTMENT INVESTMENT AND MANAGEMENT COMPANY (Reviewed & Modified October 24, 2017)
CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF APARTMENT INVESTMENT AND MANAGEMENT COMPANY (Reviewed & Modified October 24, 2017) The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors
More informationDODGE & COX FUNDS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES. Revised February 15, 2018
DODGE & COX FUNDS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Revised February 15, 2018 The Dodge & Cox Funds have authorized Dodge & Cox to vote proxies on behalf of the Dodge & Cox Funds pursuant to the following
More informationAUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Purposes The Audit Committee ( Committee ) is appointed by and generally acts on behalf of the Board of Directors (the Board ). The Committee s purposes shall be: (a) to assist
More informationAudit Committee Charter. Fly Leasing Limited
Audit Committee Charter Fly Leasing Limited As of: February 25, 2018 Fly Leasing Limited Audit Committee Charter 1. Background This Audit Committee Charter was originally adopted on November 6, 2007 and
More informationAudit Committee Charter
Audit Committee Charter JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC. BOARD OF DIRECTORS Mission Statement The Audit Committee (the Committee ) is appointed by the Board of Directors (the Board ) to assist the Board in fulfilling
More information