By Electronic Mail Only. August 24, 2018
|
|
- Elwin Stevens
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 John A. Zecca Senior Vice President General Counsel North America 805 King Farm Blvd, Suite 100 Rockville, MD / USA (301) john.zecca@nasdaq.com Nasdaq.com By Electronic Mail Only August 24, 2018 Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. ( ISS ) 702 King Farm Boulevard, Suite 400 Rockville, MD policy@issgovernance.com Re: 2019 Annual Policy Survey Dear Sir or Madam: Nasdaq, Inc. ( Nasdaq ) 1 appreciates the opportunity to comment on ISS 2019 Annual Policy Survey. We respond as a public company and a home to public companies, especially high-growth, earlystage companies, and their investors. We strive to operate our markets consistent with the highest regulatory standards to protect investors and the public interest, and we have a unique lens on the issues facing global companies and their investors in today s marketplace. The Annual Policy Survey consists of two parts: the high-level Governance Principles Survey and the follow-on Policy Application Survey. Nasdaq reviewed the latter with respect to the Americas region. Nasdaq has submitted responses to certain survey questions online, and we are respectfully providing feedback on some of the survey topics and on proxy advisory firms generally through this letter. We appreciate ISS soliciting our views and the views of the public. 1 Nasdaq is a leading global provider of trading, clearing, exchange technology, listing, information and public company services. Through its diverse portfolio of solutions, Nasdaq enables customers to plan, optimize and execute their business vision with confidence, using proven technologies that provide transparency and insight for navigating today s global capital markets. As the creator of the world s first electronic stock market, its technology powers more than 100 marketplaces in 50 countries, and 1 in 10 of the world s securities transactions. Nasdaq is home to approximately 4,000 total listings with a market value of approximately $14 trillion. To learn more, visit business.nasdaq.com. 1
2 I. Comments on ISS Governance Principles Survey A. Questions 5-6: Auditors and Audit Committees In Question 5, ISS asks what audit-related factors, other than non-audit services and fees, could be considered to evaluate the independence and performance of the external auditor in connection with periodic shareholder votes on auditor ratification. 2 Arguments can be made for each of the potential factors listed by ISS as well as other factors, but as with all ISS policies, Nasdaq cautions against applying a one-size-fits-all approach to proxy proposals on auditor ratification. In particular, audit firm tenure is a complicated and nuanced issue, and it is difficult and expensive for companies to change auditors given that there are only four major, multinational accounting firms. In addition, auditors acquire specialized knowledge about a particular company and its risks over time, so a longer audit tenure can be a factor in favor of a particular audit firm. Finally, Nasdaq notes that there are already extensive SEC rules in place regarding audit partner tenure and auditor independence; 3 these rules were subject to a robust rulemaking process, including a public notice and comment period. Nasdaq therefore cautions ISS against using its process to set more stringent standards than those already embodied in the existing SEC rules. On a related topic, question 6 asks what information should be considered by shareholders in evaluating a company s audit committee. 4 Again, while these all may seem like reasonable factors to consider in evaluating an audit committee, Nasdaq cautions against a one-size-fits-all approach or attaching too much weight to any one individual factor. 5 For example, factors that may be important in evaluating the audit committee of a global manufacturing company may be less important in evaluating the audit committee of an early-stage biotech company. Similar to the discussion on audit firm tenure above, Nasdaq especially cautions against overemphasizing the frequency of audit committee refreshment. Audit committee members gain specialized knowledge about a company, its risks, its accounting procedures and its external auditors over time, so audit committee members with longer tenure may actually provide a benefit to a company and its shareholders. B. Questions 7-9: Director Accountability and Track Records Questions 7-9 inquire whether ISS should note in its research reports where a director at one company has received a negative ISS vote recommendation at another company due to ISS assessment that the individual director failed in his or her oversight responsibilities. In the abstract, transparency on 2 Potential factors suggested by ISS include: identity of the audit partner and any links to the company or its management; audit firm tenure; audit partner tenure; significant audit controversies; regulatory fines or other penalties on the company related to financial disclosure practices or weaknesses not identified in the audit report; and regulatory fines or other penalties on the auditor for weaknesses or errors in audit practices. 3 See 17 CFR Potential factors suggested by ISS include: skills and experience of audit committee members (including number of financial experts, if applicable); quality of the company s financial reporting (e.g., number of restatements; nature of restatements); significant financial reporting or audit controversies; the level of disclosure of factors used in the audit committee s assessment of the external auditor s independence, tenure, qualifications and work quality; frequency of audit committee meetings; and frequency of audit committee refreshment. 5 Nasdaq urges ISS to avoid one size fits all approaches in developing all of its policies. Another example of an area where such an approach should be avoided is in connection with question 5 on the Policy Application Survey for the Americas, which asks about factors that should be considered in evaluating an independent chair proposal. 2
3 past oversight failures could be useful for investors, provided that the disclosure is unbiased and based on accurate information. However, Nasdaq frequently hears from other companies that ISS research reports often contain errors and that ISS does not adequately take into account the views of issuers in its proxy recommendation process. For example, in the United States, only companies in the S&P 500 index have the opportunity to receive and comment on a draft of their ISS report prior to publication and those companies are limited only to a factual review of the draft analysis. Since ISS comments can greatly influence the voting results of a company s stockholder meeting, all companies should have the opportunity to comment on ISS reports prior to publication. In addition, companies should be allowed to provide feedback on the entirety of the ISS report, not just the accuracy of factual statements. When companies do have the opportunity to respond to ISS draft reports, the turnaround time is often unreasonably short and there is no guarantee to the companies that ISS will give their feedback the appropriate weight or consideration. It would also improve ISS reports, to the benefit of investors and transparency, if companies could provide a rebuttal statement that would be included in the final ISS report. If ISS moves forward with its proposal on director track records, it should give companies, and perhaps also the relevant directors, the opportunity to set the record straight on any inaccuracies in ISS assessment that an oversight failure occurred. C. Questions 10-11: Gender Diversity on Boards Questions 10 and 11 focus on gender diversity in corporate boardrooms, a topic that ISS is revisiting from last year s Annual Policy Survey. As Nasdaq stated last year, diversity is an important factor for public companies in determining board composition. In fact, in 2018, Nasdaq affirmed its own commitment to diversity in the boardroom with membership in the 30% Club, which campaigns in the U.S. to achieve 30% female directors on S&P 100 boards by It makes good business sense for the boards of public companies to be as diverse as their investors and customers. Over time, diverse boards will have more robust debates, make sounder decisions, understand customers better and attract higher performing employees. A focus on diversity should, however, include all types of diversity, especially diversity of gender, race, age and skill sets. 6 Achieving gender diversity is but one step in building a strong board. We encourage other public companies to consider diversity (not just of gender, but of all types) as an important factor as they regularly refresh their boards. However, we do not believe that it is appropriate for ISS to attempt to force this issue by recommending votes against directors of public companies without female directors. D. Questions 12-14: One Share, One Vote Principle Questions also revisit a topic from last year s survey, differential voting rights. This year ISS explores that topic further, asking if it should provide adjusted vote results where possible in its reports on companies with multi-class capital structures with differential voting rights. ISS also asks whether it 6 Nasdaq s own board currently consists of ten directors, of whom 30% are women and 30% were born outside the U.S. As of the filing of our most recent proxy statement on March 14, 2018, our directors ranged from 45 to 67 years of age, with an average age of Finally, our board members exhibit a broad range of skills, including experience with capital markets, cybersecurity, fintech, mergers & acquisitions, public company boards & corporate governance, risk management and strategic acumen & leadership. 3
4 should use adjusted vote results to determine the need for board responsiveness to shareholder vote results in the following year. As stated last year, Nasdaq released a report, entitled The Promise of Market Reform: Reigniting America s Economic Engine (the Revitalize Report ), which notes that the continued strength of U.S. financial markets is far from certain and issues a call to action to revitalize those markets. 7 Among its many recommendations in the report, Nasdaq expressed its continued support for differential class structures in appropriate situations. Each publicly traded company should have the flexibility to determine the class structure that is most appropriate for it, so long as this structure is fully transparent and disclosed up-front so that investors have complete visibility into the company. While differential class structures have existed for some time, they have risen in prominence recently as companies are using them as a method to facilitate long-term thinking and value creation. For example, these structures may: provide protection against short termers, raiders and activists looking to promote their own agenda, such as stock buybacks or an untimely company sale; reduce pressure on companies to achieve short-term earnings targets at the expense of long-term growth; and allow companies to pursue opportunities with longer time horizons but significant upside potential. In the United States, securities exchanges prohibit any action that disenfranchises existing shareholders. 8 For this reason, differential class structures are generally adopted only when a company first goes public, ensuring that the structure is disclosed in advance to all public investors. Accordingly, differential voting classes are transparent from the outset. In order to ensure the long-term success of the American economy, we need to be careful about assuming that a one-size-fits-all voting structure is appropriate for all companies. Differential class structures allow Main Street investors to invest in innovative and high-growth companies, enjoying the financial benefits of these companies success. If such companies decide not to go public, retail investors are denied these opportunities to share in wealth creation. Investors have the choice as to whether to invest in these companies or not. Going public, of course, provides the investing public with more information on which to base their decision than the private market. For these reasons, Nasdaq discourages ISS from adopting policies that penalize companies with differential class structures. II. Comments on ISS Policy Application Survey: Americas Nasdaq also would like to provide feedback on Questions 6-8 in the Policy Application Survey for the Americas, which ask whether companies should be allowed to set minimum stock ownership 7 The Promise of Market Reform: Reigniting America s Economic Engine, issued May 2017, available at: The report, which is based on extensive research and insights, is a blueprint for reform designed to create a dialogue and facilitate common sense action steps that help reignite America s economic engine by modernizing market structure, reconstructing the regulatory framework and reorienting to a longer term view. See also Progress In Process: Update on Nasdaq s Blueprint to Revitalize Capital Markets, issued May 2018, available at: 8 See, e.g., Nasdaq Listing Rule 5640, which provides that voting rights of existing shareholders of publicly traded common stock cannot be disparately reduced or restricted through any corporate action or issuance. 4
5 requirements (in excess of that specified in SEC Rule 14a-8) for shareholders who want to propose binding amendments to corporate by-laws. In connection with the Revitalize Report and related initiatives, Nasdaq has specifically called for increases in the minimum ownership amount and holding period required for shareholders to submit proposals under Rule 14a-8 to ensure that such proposals have meaningful shareholder backing. Rule 14a-8 currently allows any shareholder holding $2,000 or more of company stock for one year or longer the ability to include an issue on the company proxy for a shareholder vote, 9 even if the issue is not material or relevant to the company s business. The current rule 14a-8 process is costly, time-consuming and frustrating for companies, often with little or no value for shareholders. Accordingly, Nasdaq believes it is entirely reasonable for companies to set a minimum stock ownership requirement in excess of that in Rule 14a-8 for shareholders who want to propose binding by-law amendments. Finally, determination of the appropriate ownership threshold and other procedural requirements for such proposals is best left to individual companies and their shareholders. III. Comments on Proxy Advisory Firms Generally Nasdaq s concerns about proxy advisory firms, particularly relating to transparency and conflicts of interest, are well-known. 10 We reiterated those views in the Revitalize Report 11 and related initiatives, where we continue to advocate for transparency and fairness in the proxy advisory industry, and we have articulated many of our concerns above. We note that others, including the Congress 12 and the Wall Street Journal Editorial Board, 13 share our concerns. We emphasize again, however, that in practice, the proxy advisory industry is a largely unregulated black box, rife with opacity, lack of accountability and conflicts of interest. Absent requirements to explain their criteria or to provide companies a means to question analysis or even correct factual errors, the outcome of critical decisions is often at the whim of unpredictable and impenetrable advisory firms. Additionally, these firms are not even required to disclose whether they have a financial relationship or ownership stake in the companies on which they report. Proxy advisors must have a line of communication with the companies they analyze and clear transparency around ownership of, or short interest in, covered companies. We continue to urge you to voluntarily adopt measures to fully address these important concerns. * * * * * 9 See 17 CFR a See letter from Mr. Edward S. Knight, Executive Vice President, General Counsel and Chief Regulatory Officer, Nasdaq, to Ms. Elizabeth M. Murphy, Esq., U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, dated October 8, 2013, available at: 11 See the Revitalize Report, at page In 2017, the House of Representatives passed a bill that would increase the transparency and accountability of proxy advisory firms by, among other things, requiring them to register with the SEC. 13 See The Editorial Board, "The Proxy Advisors Veto," The Wall Street Journal, August 10, 2018, available at: 5
6
Shareholder approval is required prior to the issuance of securities in connection with a transaction other than a public offering involving:
SOLICITATION OF COMMENTS BY THE NASDAQ LISTING AND HEARING REVIEW COUNCIL ABOUT THE DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE FOR PURPOSES OF SHAREHOLDER APPROVAL RULES June 14, 2017 Nasdaq recently released its blueprint
More informationBipartisan Bill Would Require SEC Registration, Annual Reporting, and Disclosure of Conflicts and Policy Formulation
Bipartisan Bill Would Require SEC Registration, Annual Reporting, and Disclosure of Conflicts and Policy Formulation Over the past several years, there has been a significant focus on the influence, conflicts
More informationLooking ahead for public companies: what you need to know for 2018
November 20, 2017 Looking ahead for public companies: what you need to know for 2018 By Kelly D. Babson, David R. Brown and Lloyd H. Spencer In today s market, public companies face a variety of challenges
More informationNASDAQ REPORTS SECOND QUARTER 2017 RESULTS; ACHIEVES RECORD QUARTERLY NET REVENUES 1
N E W S R E L E A S E D A T E : July 26, 2017 NASDAQ REPORTS SECOND QUARTER 2017 RESULTS; ACHIEVES RECORD QUARTERLY NET REVENUES 1 Net revenues were a record $602 million in the second quarter of 2017,
More informationStatement of Niels Holch Executive Director Shareholder Communications Coalition
Statement of Niels Holch Executive Director Shareholder Communications Coalition Before the Subcommittee on Capital Markets and Government Sponsored Enterprises Committee on Financial Services U.S. House
More informationEY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly. January 2017
EY Center for Board Matters Board Matters Quarterly January 2017 2 Board Matters Quarterly January 2017 January 2017 Board Matters Quarterly In this issue 04 Governance trends at Russell 2000 companies
More informationLet s talk: governance
EY Center for Board Matters Let s talk: governance Special edition 2014 proxy season preview ey.com/boardmatters 1 Proxy season 2014 preview Boards face shifting investor priorities and expectations Proxy
More informationWhile concerns about shareholder activism and the
Yoo Jaechang/TongRo Images/Corbis Lessons for the 2015 Proxy Season In her regular column on corporate governance issues, Holly Gregory examines trends emerging from the 2014 proxy season and related developments,
More informationHot Topics in Corporate Governance. November 14, 2017
Hot Topics in Corporate Governance November 14, 2017 Changes at the SEC New Chair: Jay Clayton New Director of the Division of Corporation Finance: Bill Hinman Two open Commission seats remain, with two
More informationJune 24, RILA Testimony for CPSC Agenda and Priorities Hearing for Fiscal Years 2016 and 2017
June 24, 2015 Todd Stevenson Secretary U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission 4330 East West Highway Bethesda, MD 20814 RILA Testimony for CPSC Agenda and Priorities Hearing for Fiscal Years 2016 and
More informationZebra Technologies Corporation Audit Committee Charter (November 3, 2017)
Zebra Technologies Corporation Audit Committee Charter (November 3, 2017) A. Authority The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Zebra Technologies Corporation ( Zebra
More informationMONDELĒZ INTERNATIONAL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. Effective January 26, 2015
Purpose. MONDELĒZ INTERNATIONAL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Effective January 26, 2015 The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Mondelēz International,
More informationCIT Group Inc. Charter of the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors. Adopted by the Board of Directors October 16, 2013
Last Amended: October 16, 2017 Last Ratified: May 9, 2017 CIT Group Inc. Charter of the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors Adopted by the Board of Directors October 16, 2013 I. PURPOSE The
More informationHot Topics 2013 Proxy season highlights
Hot Topics 2013 Proxy season highlights Recent governance trends, regulatory developments, and the expectation of future governance-related legislation were highlighted in the June 25 Deloitte Dbriefs
More information8/20/2002. Changes from the Initial NYSE Proposal Morrison & Foerster LLP. All Rights Reserved.
NYSE Adopts Changes to its Corporate Governance and Listing Standards; Differences between Current NYSE and Nasdaq Proposals and Sarbanes-Oxley Act Requirements 8/20/2002 Corporate, Financial Institutions
More informationLessons from the 2017 Proxy Season
Lessons from the 2017 Proxy Season S&C Client Webinar September 18, 2017 Janet Geldzahler Glen Schleyer Overview of Presentation Summary of proxy access proposals for 2017; further confirmation of market
More informationGENESCO INC. CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
GENESCO INC. CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS PURPOSE The primary purpose of the Audit Committee (the Committee ) is to assist the Board of Directors (the Board ) in fulfilling
More informationPublic consultation on the 2014 Review of the OECD Principles of Corporate Governance
2 January 2015 Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 2, rue André Pascal 75775 Paris Cedex 16 France Submitted via email to: dafca.contact@oecd.org
More informationLETTER TO STOCKHOLDERS FROM OUR CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD
LETTER TO STOCKHOLDERS FROM OUR CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD Dear Fellow Stockholders, Your directors are proud to have had the opportunity to represent you over the last year as we took an active role in the
More informationCITIGROUP INC. RISK MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE CHARTER As of January 18, 2018
CITIGROUP INC. RISK MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE CHARTER As of January 18, 2018 Mission The Risk Management Committee (the Committee ) of Citigroup Inc. ( Citigroup ) is a standing committee of the Board of Directors
More informationSUBMITTED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON CAPITAL MARKETS AND GOVERNMENT SPONSORED ENTERPRISES COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL SERVICES U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
STATEMENT FOR THE RECORD FROM JOHN HAYES CHAIRMAN, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF BALL CORPORATION, AND CHAIR OF THE BUSINESS ROUNDTABLE COMMITTEE ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE SUBMITTED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE
More informationInstitutional Shareholder Services Inc. Due Diligence Compliance Package
Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. Due Diligence Compliance Package 702 King Farm Blvd., Suite 400 Rockville, MD 20850 (301) 556-0500 Fax (301) 556-0491 www.issgovernance.com Copyright 2017, Institutional
More informationResponsible Ownership: Proxy and Engagement Report
Responsible Ownership: 2017 Proxy and Engagement Report March 2018 Introduction Russell Investments believes that being an active owner is an important component of its investment responsibilities. Through
More informationG OV ERNANC E I NITIATIVE
C O R P OR ATE G OV ERNANC E I NITIATIVE Reinvigorating the Public Company Model SPRING 2018 1 INTRODUCTION Over the last few decades the U.S. has experienced a steady decline in public companies. In fact,
More informationNASDAQ OMX GROUP, INC.
NASDAQ OMX GROUP, INC. FORM 8-K (Current report filing) Filed 01/05/15 for the Period Ending 01/05/15 Address ONE LIBERTY PLAZA NEW YORK, NY 10006 Telephone 2124018700 CIK 0001120193 Symbol NDAQ SIC Code
More informationBlackRock Investment Stewardship
BlackRock Investment Stewardship Global Corporate Governance & Engagement Principles October 2017 Contents Introduction to BlackRock... 2 Philosophy on corporate governance... 2 Corporate governance, engagement
More informationPARKER DRILLING COMPANY CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PRINCIPLES
1. Director Qualifications PARKER DRILLING COMPANY CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PRINCIPLES The Board of Directors (the Board ) of Parker Drilling Company (the Company ) will have a majority of directors who meet
More informationCorporate Governance Under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform & Consumer Protection Act
Corporate Governance Under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform & Consumer Protection Act John Brantley, Partner, Bracewell & Giuliani LLP October 22, 2010 The Law in Context Corporate governance has been
More informationPROXY VOTING GUIDELINES
PROXY VOTING GUIDELINES T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. and its affiliated investment advisers ( T. Rowe Price ) recognize and adhere to the principle that one of the privileges of owning stock in a company
More informationNASDAQ REPORTS SECOND QUARTER 2018 RESULTS; COMPLETES DIVESTITURE; DELIVERS STRONG ORGANIC REVENUE GROWTH
N E W S R E L E A S E D A T E : July 25, 2018 NASDAQ REPORTS SECOND QUARTER 2018 RESULTS; COMPLETES DIVESTITURE; DELIVERS STRONG ORGANIC REVENUE GROWTH In April, the company completed the divestiture of
More informationConnecticut Water Issues Statement Regarding Eversource Energy s Intention to Launch Distracting Proxy Contest
Connecticut Water Issues Statement Regarding Eversource Energy s Intention to Launch Distracting Proxy Contest Believes SJW Group Merger Is Superior Transaction with Significantly Greater Benefits to Connecticut
More informationNASDAQ REPORTS THIRD QUARTER 2018 RESULTS; DELIVERS SOLID ORGANIC REVENUE GROWTH
N E W S R E L E A S E D A T E : October 24, 2018 NASDAQ REPORTS THIRD QUARTER 2018 RESULTS; DELIVERS SOLID ORGANIC REVENUE GROWTH Third quarter 2018 net revenues 1 were $600 million, including 5% organic
More informationNASDAQ REPORTS THIRD QUARTER 2017 RESULTS; DELIVERS STRONG PROFITABILITY AND INCOME GROWTH
N E W S R E L E A S E D A T E : October 25, 2017 NASDAQ REPORTS THIRD QUARTER 2017 RESULTS; DELIVERS STRONG PROFITABILITY AND INCOME GROWTH Net revenues 1 were a record $607 million in the third quarter
More informationRe: Release No , Request for Comment, Draft FY Strategic Plan for the Securities and Exchange Commission
Īll MSRB Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board The Honorable Jay Clayton Chairman 100 F Street, NE Washington, D.C. 20549 Re: Release No. 34-83463, Request for Comment, Draft FY 2018-2022 Strategic Plan
More informationCorporate and Securities Law Update
Corporate and Securities Law Update NASDAQ Corporate Governance Standards for Listed Companies December 11, 2003 On November 4, 2003, the SEC approved the final version of The NASDAQ Stock Market s corporate
More informationIntroduction. The Assessment consists of: A checklist of best, good and leading practices A rating system to rank your company s current practices.
ESG / CSR / Sustainability Governance and Management Assessment By Coro Strandberg President, Strandberg Consulting www.corostrandberg.com September 2017 Introduction This ESG / CSR / Sustainability Governance
More informationJanuary 30, Proxy Statements under Maryland Law 2017
January 30, 2017 Proxy Statements under Maryland Law 2017 The 2017 proxy season is here. Based on our experience reviewing proxy statements for Maryland public companies, we would like to call your attention
More informationINTEGRATED DEVICE TECHNOLOGY, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
INTEGRATED DEVICE TECHNOLOGY, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER This amendment to the Amended and Restated Audit Committee Charter (this Charter ) was adopted by the Board of Directors
More informationNasdaq Reports Third Quarter 2018 Results; Delivers Solid Organic Revenue Growth
Nasdaq Reports Third Quarter 2018 Results; Delivers Solid Organic Revenue Growth October 24, 2018 Third quarter 2018 net revenues 1 were $600 million, including 5% organic revenue growth. Third quarter
More informationSTANDING ADVISORY GROUP MEETING
1666 K Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20006 Telephone: (202) 207-9100 Facsimile: (202)862-8430 www.pcaobus.org STANDING ADVISORY GROUP MEETING PANEL DISCUSSION SIGNING THE AUDITOR'S REPORT OCTOBER 22-23,
More informationIDPN Advocate & Connect Webinar:
IDPN Advocate & Connect Webinar: A discussion on board earnings & trends on Director Compensation with Pearl Meyer Tuesday 16 May 2017 INSEAD International Directors Program Corporate Governance Network,
More informationESCALADE, INCORPORATED
ESCALADE, INCORPORATED Approved by the Board of Directors on July 25, 2003 I. MEMBERSHIP AND QUALIFICATIONS Members; Chairperson. The members of the Committee are appointed annually by the Board of Directors
More informationAudit Committee Transparency Barometer
2017 Audit Committee Transparency Barometer NOVEMBER 2017 About the Center for Audit Quality The Center for Audit Quality (CAQ) is an autonomous, nonpartisan public policy organization dedicated to enhancing
More informationNIRI Talking Points on Proxy Advisor Reform
NIRI Talking Points on Proxy Advisor Reform Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis & Co. collectively control 97 percent of the U.S. market for proxy advisory services, and thus have
More information2018 Corporate Governance & Incentive Design Survey Fall 2018
2018 Corporate Governance & Incentive Design Survey Fall 2018 Contents Executive Summary 2 Corporate Governance Practices 3 Proxy Disclosure 12 Company Policies 19 Annual Incentive Plan Design Practices
More informationUNITEDHEALTH GROUP BOARD OF DIRECTORS AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER (November 8, 2016)
UNITEDHEALTH GROUP BOARD OF DIRECTORS AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER (November 8, 2016) INTRODUCTION AND PURPOSE UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (the "Company") is a publicly-held company and operates in a complex,
More informationAudit committee reporting to shareholders: going beyond the minimum
Audit committee reporting to shareholders: going beyond the minimum Join the conversation on audit committee transparency February 2013 Ernst & Young supports effective audit committees and believes that
More informationSEC Adopts Rules Related to Executive Compensation and Corporate Governance Disclosure
Securities Law ADVISORY December 17, 2009 SEC Adopts Rules Related to Executive Compensation and Corporate Governance Disclosure At an open meeting yesterday, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
More informationNew NYSE and NASDAQ Listing Rules Raise the Accountability of Company Boards and Compensation Committees Through Flexible Standards
New NYSE and NASDAQ Listing Rules Raise the Accountability of Company Boards and Compensation Committees Through Flexible Standards By Todd B. Pfister and Aubrey Refuerzo* On January 11, 2013, the U.S.
More informationNotice of Annual Meeting of Stockholders
18MAR201514195548 Notice of Annual Meeting of Stockholders Wednesday, May 2, 2018 11:00 a.m. Papa John s International, Inc. 2002 Papa John s Boulevard Louisville, Kentucky Items of Business Election of
More informationI. Ensuring the Basis for an Effective Corporate Governance Framework
OECD Corporate Governance Committee 4 January 2015 Re: OECD Principles of Corporate Governance CFA Institute 1 appreciates the opportunity to comment on the review of the OECD Principles of Corporate Governance.
More informationJuly 30, Secretary Securities and Exchange Commission 100F Street, NE Washington, D.C
July 30, 2008 Secretary Securities and Exchange Commission 100F Street, NE Washington, D.C. 20549-1090 RE: File No. S7-11-08, Interactive Data to Improve Financial Reporting Dear Sir or Madame: On behalf
More informationGOVERNANCE AND PROXY VOTING GUIDELINES
GOVERNANCE AND PROXY VOTING GUIDELINES NOVEMBER 2017 ABOUT NEUBERGER BERMAN Founded in 1939, Neuberger Berman is a private, 100% independent, employee-owned investment manager. From offices in 30 cities
More informationNOTICE OF 2017 ANNUAL MEETING OF SHAREHOLDERS AND PROXY STATEMENT
NOTICE OF 2017 ANNUAL MEETING OF SHAREHOLDERS AND PROXY STATEMENT Wyndham Worldwide Corporation 22 Sylvan Way Parsippany, New Jersey 07054 March 29, 2017 Dear Fellow Shareholder: On behalf of the entire
More informationRe: Security Holder Approval Requirements for Acquisitions Exemption in Subsection 611(d) of the TSX Company Manual
December 12, 2007 Toronto Stock Exchange The Exchange Tower 130 King Street West Toronto, ON M5X 1J2 Attention: Deanna Dobrowsky Legal Counsel, Market Policy and Structure Dear Madam: Re: Security Holder
More informationRegulatory Notice. Request for Comment on Draft MSRB Rule G-44, on Supervisory and Compliance Obligations of Municipal Advisors
Regulatory Notice 2014-04 Publication Date February 25, 2014 Stakeholders Municipal Advisors, Issuers, General Public Notice Type Request for Comment Comment Deadline April 28, 2014 Category Fair Practice
More informationCorporate Governance After the Dodd-Frank Act: Recent Developments
Corporate Governance After the Dodd-Frank Act: Recent Developments John C. Coffee, Jr. Cape Town, South Africa IOSCO Annual Meeting April, 2011 Slide 1 MAJOR DEVELOPMENTS 1. Proxy Access: 3% can now propose
More informationThe following shall be the principal recurring duties of the Committee in carrying out its oversight responsibility.
AEVI GENOMIC MEDICINE, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER 1. PURPOSE The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Aevi Genomic Medicine, Inc. (the Company ) has the oversight
More informationBRIEFING PAPER AUDITOR INDEPENDENCE AND TAX SERVICES ROUNDTABLE JULY 14, 2004
1666 K Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20006 Telephone: (202) 207-9100 Facsimile: (202) 862-8430 www.pcaobus.org AUDITOR INDEPENDENCE AND TAX SERVICES ROUNDTABLE JULY 14, 2004 On the Public Company Accounting
More informationFebruary 3, Dear Fellow Shareholder:
25435 Harvard Road Beachwood, OH 44122 www.omnova.com Dear Fellow Shareholder: February 3, 2017 Fiscal 2016 has been an exciting year of change for OMNOVA Solutions Inc. (the Company or OMNOVA ). The Company
More informationShareholder Engagement and Activism:
Eduardo Gallardo, Gibson Dunn Brian Lutz, Gibson Dunn Lori Zyskowski, Gibson Dunn Matthew Sherman, Joele Frank Scott Winter, Innisfree Shareholder Engagement and Activism: Preparing for the 2018 Proxy
More informationNotice of 2018 Annual Meeting and Proxy Statement
Notice of 2018 Annual Meeting and Proxy Statement Notice of Annual Meeting of Stockholders Notice of Annual Meeting of Stockholders On behalf of the Board of Directors, I am honored to invite you to attend
More informationDefinition of Employer Small Business Health Plans (RIN 1210 AB85)
Robyn Boerstling Vice President Infrastructure, Innovation and Human Resources Policy Office of Regulations and Interpretations Employee Benefits Security Administration, Room N-5655 U.S. Department of
More informationCorporate Governance and Executive Compensation Provisions in the Dodd-Frank Act
June 29, 2010 Corporate Governance and Executive Compensation Provisions in the Dodd-Frank Act On June 25, 2010, a House and Senate conference committee negotiating the blueprint for the reform of the
More informationRe: Internal Control Roundtable / File Number 4-511
1001 PENNSYLVANIA AVE., NW SUITE 500 SOUTH WASHINGTON, DC 20004 TEL 202-289-4322 FAX 202-628-2507 Impacting Policy. Impacting People. E-Mail rwhiting@fsround.org www.fsround.org RICHARD M. WHITING EXECUTIVE
More informationLast revised July 2018 Glass Lewis Korea Stewardship Code Statement
Last revised July 2018 Glass Lewis Korea Stewardship Code Statement Korea s Stewardship Code ( Code ), published by the Korea Stewardship Code Council on December 16, 2016, is an effort to promote greater
More informationThe Importance of Hiring a Quality Auditor. to Perform Your Employee Benefit Plan Audit. Plan Advisory
The Importance of Hiring a Quality Auditor to Perform Your Employee Benefit Plan Audit Plan Advisory The AICPA EBPAQC is a firm-based, volunteer membership center created with the goal of promoting quality
More informationNOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS YOUR VOTE IS IMPORTANT
NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS November 7, 2018 To our stockholders: YOUR VOTE IS IMPORTANT NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Annual Meeting of Stockholders of KLA-Tencor Corporation ( we or the
More informationIntroduction. The Assessment consists of: Evaluation questions that assess best practices. A rating system to rank your board s current practices.
ESG / Sustainability Governance Assessment: A Roadmap to Build a Sustainable Board By Coro Strandberg President, Strandberg Consulting www.corostrandberg.com November 2017 Introduction This is a tool for
More informationAugust 7, Mr. Brent J. Fields Secretary U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, NE Washington D.C
August 7, 2018 Mr. Brent J. Fields Secretary U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, NE Washington D.C. 20549-1090 RE: Comments of the Association for Corporate Growth on Proposed Commission
More informationDODGE & COX FUNDS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES. Revised February 15, 2018
DODGE & COX FUNDS PROXY VOTING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Revised February 15, 2018 The Dodge & Cox Funds have authorized Dodge & Cox to vote proxies on behalf of the Dodge & Cox Funds pursuant to the following
More informationINVESTORS & ACTIVISM. David F. Larcker and Brian Tayan Corporate Governance Research Initiative Stanford Graduate School of Business
INVESTORS & ACTIVISM David F. Larcker and Brian Tayan Corporate Governance Research Initiative Stanford Graduate School of Business THE ROLE OF SHAREHOLDERS The shareholder-centric view holds that the
More informationEVINE LIVE INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
EVINE LIVE INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER I. PURPOSE, DUTIES, and RESPONSIBILITIES The audit committee (the Committee ) is established by the board of directors (the board ) of EVINE Live Inc. (the company
More information2017 proxy statements
SEC Financial Reporting Series 2017 proxy statements An overview of the requirements and observations about current practice Contents 1 Overview... 1 1.1 Section highlights... 2 1.2 EY publications and
More informationRe: Response to SEC Request Highlighting Municipal Market Practices
October 17, 2017 Rick A. Fleming Investor Advocate U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, NE Washington, DC 20549-1090 Dear Mr. Fleming: Re: Response to SEC Request Highlighting Municipal
More information2015 BDO BOARD SURVEY
www.bdo.com BDO BOARD SURVEY BDO USA CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PRACTICE BDO USA s Corporate Governance Practice is a valued business advisor to corporate boards. The firm works with a wide variety of clients,
More informationAugust 11, Office of the Secretary Public Company Accounting Oversight Board 1666 K Street, N.W. Washington, D.C
MFS Investment Management 111 Huntington Avenue Boston, MA 02199 August 11, 2016 Office of the Secretary Public Company Accounting Oversight Board 1666 K Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20006-2803 File Reference:
More informationPDC ENERGY, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. Amended and Restated September 18, 2015
PDC ENERGY, INC. AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Amended and Restated September 18, 2015 1. Purpose. The Board of Directors (the Board ) of PDC Energy, Inc. (the Company ) has duly established the Audit Committee
More informationNasdaq Reports First Quarter 2018 Results; Delivers Strong Growth in Revenues and Income
Nasdaq Reports First Quarter 2018 Results; Delivers Strong Growth in Revenues and Income April 25, 2018 First quarter 2018 net revenues 1 were $666 million, a 15% increase compared to the first quarter
More informationRE: Consultation Paper on Recommendations of the Corporate Governance Council
14 March 2018 The Secretariat, Corporate Governance Council c/o Markets Policy & Infrastructure Department Monetary Authority of Singapore 10 Shenton Way, MAS Building Singapore 079117 Submitted via email
More informationThe MSRB s Agenda for Remarks of Lynnette Kelly, Executive Director. at the. Bond Buyer National Municipal Bond Summit. Fort Lauderdale, FL
The MSRB s Agenda for 2015 Remarks of Lynnette Kelly, Executive Director at the Bond Buyer National Municipal Bond Summit Fort Lauderdale, FL March 2, 2015 INTRODUCTION Good afternoon and thank you for
More informationRe: Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board s Recommendations for Update of 1994 Interpretive Guidance
Commissioner Elisse B. Walter U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, NE Room 10200 Washington, DC 20549 Re: Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board s Recommendations for Update of 1994 Interpretive
More informationPartnerRe Board of Directors Issues Letter to Shareholders
PartnerRe Board of Directors Issues Letter to Shareholders PEMBROKE, Bermuda May 20, 2015 PartnerRe Ltd. (NYSE:PRE) today issued the following letter to shareholders on behalf of the Company s Board of
More informationAssociation of Corporate Counsel 2017 Shareholder Proxy Season: Governance Decision Making in a Maelstrom of Change
Association of Corporate Counsel 2017 Shareholder Proxy Season: March 22, 2017 Speakers: Christine Edwards Jerry Loeser Michael Melbinger Speakers: Christine Edwards Chair of Winston & Strawn LLP s Bank
More informationNasdaq Reports Third Quarter 2016 Earnings; Delivers Record Subscription and Recurring Revenues(1)
October 26, 2016 Nasdaq Reports Third Quarter 2016 Earnings; Delivers Record Subscription and Recurring Revenues(1) Net revenues 2 were a record $585 million in the third quarter of 2016, up 11% year-over-year.
More informationAUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER. Purpose. Composition
AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER Purpose The Audit Committee (the Committee ) is established by the Board of Directors (the Board ) primarily for the purpose of overseeing the accounting and financial reporting
More informationMATTEL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
Purpose MATTEL, INC. AMENDED AND RESTATED AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER The purpose of the Audit Committee (the Committee ) is to provide assistance to the Board of Directors (the Board ) of Mattel, Inc. (the
More informationTHOMSON REUTERS CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES
THOMSON REUTERS CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES ADOPTED EFFECTIVE MARCH 1, 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. GENERAL... 1 2. BOARD COMPOSITION... 1 3. BOARD RESPONSIBILITIES... 4 4. PRINCIPAL SHAREHOLDER... 6
More informationSJW Group Board of Directors Issues Letter to Fellow SJW Group Stockholders. The Choice is Clear: Concrete Value Creation vs.
SJW Group Board of Directors Issues Letter to Fellow SJW Group Stockholders The Choice is Clear: Concrete Value Creation vs. Illusory Value San Jose, CA May 11, 2018 SJW Group (NYSE: SJW) today announced
More informationKush Bottles, Inc. A Nevada corporation (the Company )
Kush Bottles, Inc. A Nevada corporation (the Company ) Audit Committee Charter The Audit Committee (the Committee ) is created by the Board of Directors of the Company (the Board ) to: assist the Board
More information12367 Crosthwaite Circle Poway, California NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS To Be Held On May 16, 2018
12367 Crosthwaite Circle Poway, California 92064-6817 NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS To Be Held On May 16, 2018 TO OUR STOCKHOLDERS: The Annual Meeting of Stockholders (the Meeting ) of Cohu,
More information2016 Proxy Season Preparations
2016 Proxy Season Preparations March 11, 2016 Guest Speaker Patrick McGurn, Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc. Christine Edwards, Winston & Strawn LLP Karen Weber, Winston & Strawn LLP Jerry Loeser,
More informationINVESTMENT STEWARDSHIP REPORT: AMERICAS
INVESTMENT STEWARDSHIP REPORT: AMERICAS Q3 2018 SEPTEMBER 30, 2018 Contents Engagement and Voting Highlights... 2 Engagement and Voting Statistics... 5 Active Ownership and Responsible Leadership... 6
More informationComments to Notice , Request for Input on Draft FAQ s Regarding Rule G-42 and the Making of Recommendations
800 Nicollet Mall, J12NPF, Minneapolis, MN 55402 P 612-303-6657 F612-303-1032] Piper Jaffray & Co. Since 1895. Member SIPC and NYSE. Ronald W. Smith Corporate Secretary Municipal Securities Rulemaking
More informationANSYS, INC. COMPENSATION COMMITTEE CHARTER
I. General Statement of Purpose ANSYS, INC. COMPENSATION COMMITTEE CHARTER The Compensation Committee (the Compensation Committee ) of the Board of Directors (the Board ) of ANSYS, Inc. (the Company )
More informationCHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF APARTMENT INVESTMENT AND MANAGEMENT COMPANY (Reviewed & Modified October 24, 2017)
CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF APARTMENT INVESTMENT AND MANAGEMENT COMPANY (Reviewed & Modified October 24, 2017) The Audit Committee (the Committee ) of the Board of Directors
More informationPacesetters in Financial Reporting. Key takeaways from the conference hosted by Pace University, FEI and EY
Pacesetters in Financial Reporting Key takeaways from the conference hosted by Pace University, FEI and EY Overview In late 2016, Lubin School of Business at Pace University, Financial Executives International
More informationWhy your board should take a fresh look at risk oversight: a practical guide for getting started
January 2017 Why your board should take a fresh look at risk oversight: a practical guide for getting started Boards play a critical role in overseeing company risk. Ongoing and evolving challenges call
More informationDisclosure Reform. Cynthia M. Krus, Sutherland Miriam G. Krieger, Allied Capital Corporation Lisa A. Morgan, Sutherland. September 16, 2009
Cynthia M. Krus, Sutherland Miriam G. Krieger, Allied Capital Corporation Lisa A. Morgan, Sutherland September 16, 2009 Disclosure Reform Overview Regulatory Reform Impact of Amended NYSE Rule 452 on the
More informationFinancial Reporting Council. Proposed Revisions to the UK Corporate Governance Code
Aberdeen Standard ilivesliiielik- Catherine Horton Financial Reporting Council 8th Floor 125 London Wall London EC2Y 5AS 1 George Street Edinburgh EH2 2LL phone: 0131 245 7956 email: mike.everett@aberdeenstandard.com
More information