Flash Report Gold & JPM January 21 st, 2014

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Flash Report Gold & JPM January 21 st, 2014"

Roland Sims
5 years ago
Views:

Flash Report Gold & JPM January 21 st, 2014 francescomaggioni.

know how many of you remember last year news concerning JP Morgan and their troubled situation with their Gold deposit.

1 Flash Report Gold & JPM January 21 st, 2014 francescomaggioni.com IT UK Quantitative approach for asymmetric results Investing in gold like a real pro Figure 1: Total Eligible Gold in Comex Warehouses (Troy Ounces) I don t know how many of you remember last year news concerning JP Morgan and their troubled situation with their Gold deposit. Around May last year the news was that JP Morgan vault was empty and that had to borrow Gold from third parties in order to proceed and delivery it for those who wanted the physical against their future contracts. The news was in May, but looking at the chart above and the following ones, it is clear that the bank was forced to constant and huge deliveries for the physical even weeks and months before. What exactly does it say about Gold? That there is a huge request for the physical despite all the reports claiming a bear market for the yellow metal. Remember, Gold at that point was valued at a 6 months average (November 2012 to April 2013, just before the May event and biggest drop in price of the metal) at 1,580 usd circa and still demand was huge. Can you guess today with Gold at 1,238 usd how strong the demand is (the chart on Figure 6 will try to anser this question)? 1

2 Figure 2: Gold (Bloomberg ticker: GC) monthly chart with highlighted the worst drawdown The JPM vault - the largest private gold vault in the world - is located at 1 Chase Manhattan Plaza, and is literally adjacent to the vault of the New York Fed 80 feet, and 5 sublevels, below street level. It is known that for a long time the vault held around 2.5 million ounces of eligible (commercial) gold, a number which declined only gradually until end of What many may not know, is that while registered Comex gold has been flat, the amount of eligible gold in Comex warehouses in the past several weeks has plunged from nearly 9 million ounces, to just 6.1 million ounces as April the lowest since mid Figure 3: CME April 26 th report showing movement in the CME deposits 2

3 What nobody knows, is why virtually the entire move in warehoused eligible gold is driven exclusively by one firm: JPMorgan, whose eligible gold has collapse from just under 2 million ounces as of the end of 2012 to a nearly record low 402,374 ounces as of April 2013, a drop of 20% in one day, though slightly higher compared to the recent record low hit on April 5 when JPM warehoused commercial gold touched a post-vault reopening low of just over 4 tons, or 142,700 ounces. This happened just days ahead of the biggest ever one-day gold slam down in history. Figure 4: JP Morgan Eligible Gold (Troy Ounces) The following table shows how still in August 2013 JP Morgan s eligible gold was just little above the lowest level registered during the previous April one and brings evidence to the fact that the bank was borrowing the yellow metal from other institutions, Scotia bank in this case. Figure 5: CME August 23 rd showing movements of eligible gold among banks. 3

4 We can then make some assumptions based on the facts above: 1. Demand for physical gold never declined, actually between 2012 and 2013 there has been an incontrollable spike in physical delivery requests that JP Morgan was not able to control. 2. During the same period of time JP Morgan decided not to buy gold in the open market in order to fullfil their obligations, letting its gold deposit go even negative. With hindsight another safe assumption is that someone at JP Morgan was correctly forecasting that a strong downward movement in the price of the metal was just around the corner, suggesting the executives to wait and buy it at a better prices. 3. Since then we (those who took the bother of looking at this matter) have been witnessing a divergency between reports released by investment banks and the actual physical gold behaviour. Most of the reports in fact have been declaring a new bear market in gold, while behind the (media) scenes the opposite was actually happening. To bring some confirmation about point 1. in particular, at the following chart you can see Comex gold stocks (= read quantity of gold requested, not gold listed companies) that are eligible for delivery versus open interest has risen to a historic extreme of 112:1. This means that the gold owners will demand higher prices to put their gold up for delivery and is bullish for gold prices. Figure 6: Gold: price, open Interest, eligible amount, and open Interest/eligible amount 4

5 What can be derived that could be put in our investment strategy so far, even without going any further? That the current gold price range between 1170 and 1280 usd can be safely labelled as a good accumulation range, and that to me it will be very surprisingly if such low will be broken. In addition to all the above we can safely assume that we will be witnessing the return of an upward trend in the price of gold only when the banks deposits will show significant increase in the amount of eligible gold held, which to date it is not yet happening. Now let s move on and try to give additional information which can be used to predict future gold price movements. Investing in gold has two main goals: protection against inflation, and protection against possible implosion of the financial system. We can debate that concerning a possible implosion of the financial system, either politicians and central bankers did a good job in making us to believe we avoided it for good, or it has been just postponed, while for what concerns inflation there is no question that sooner or later we will be dealing with it. It is just math, and math does not lie. However what I have been wrong on gold is that before getting to the upcoming (hyper) inflation new era there would have been an intermediate period of low inflation and anemic growth in most of the western countries due to real problems in the real economies: that therefore did not immediately translate into outright inflation. The question is then, am I still right in forecasting at least a double top in Gold in the near future? In the next charts you will see how gold prices are quite correlated to the Fed s balance sheet expansion, and surprisingly since when that correlation has been temporarily put off. Similarly there has been a correlation between the US Debt (being possible thanks to the Fed?) and Gold prices too. 5

Figure 7: Correlation between Fed Balance Sheet and Gold price For the stable and long lasting relationship between central bank balance sheets

6 Figure 7: Correlation between Fed Balance Sheet and Gold price For the stable and long lasting relationship between central bank balance sheets and gold to recouple, Gold would need to be back to around $1800 an ounce as of late Figure 8: Correlation between US Debt and Gold price 6

Figure 9: Monthly chart showing historical inflation level in the US The above chart shows the historical inflation level in the US up to 2010.

7 Figure 9: Monthly chart showing historical inflation level in the US The above chart shows the historical inflation level in the US up to It does not contain very recent data but very little has changed since 2010 apart from a massive QE injected in the financial system. What it is interesting to note though is to see when in the last few years there have been spikes in inflation, and namely there were in: 1990, 1998, 2002, To which events those years have a connection to? Each of those years are subsequent to a financial crisis and namely the 1987, 1998, 2001 and we have yet to see the consequences to the 2009 one. Let me remind you that each and every market top from 1990 to today has been achieved mainly (but not solely) by a prolonged environment of low interest rates. The deviation to the normal set of actions to exit from a financial crisis happened only in 2009, when together to the usual lowering of interest rates the Fed had to also directly inject liquidity just to achieve the same result as before. Is it therefore safe to assume that a period of higher inflation is just in front of us? The answer is yes, and it is also a very conservative answer. Below you can find a final chart which shows the historical movements of the Dow Jones index / Gold ratio. 7

8 Figure 10: Historical chart of the Dow/Gold ratio The first interesting information you can derive from the chart (source: solarcycles.net) is the effective intrusion that the creation of the Fed has generated since its creation in On a pure technical analysis point of view the formation that resulted since 1913 is called an opening wedge or a fan and it would imply that the instrument which is inside such formation should touch on both sides of the wedge s extremes. Indeed is what some are waiting. However please note that the chart is up to 2009 and therefore it does not show the latest price actions. Most probably the current level of the ratio should be in near the upper side of the wedge. That forecast makes perfect sense with the inflation expectation that we can derived from the current situation and the chart on Figure 6. However I tend to make a more conservative forecast for the chart on Figure 10 and you can see it in the black box I added. It is a safer bet to expect the ratio to come back where it has been most of the 20 th century rather than shoot for the extremes, but let us not forget that it is quite a wide box. The higher side of the box still implies around 1,000 points for the SP500 or 10,000 points for the Dow, with no movements for Gold. Such level of the ratio will be more probably achieved via a combination of both effects, meaning a decrease of the Dow and an increase of Gold price at the same time. 8

9 Let s sum up the facts from all the above: 1. JP Morgan starts entering into the Comex deposit and start selling most of its gold in January 2011 up to most of From late 2012 to April 2013 JP Morgan does not have any more gold and needs to borrow it from third parties in order to fulfill its requirements to delivery physical gold against futures contracts. 3. In April 2013 Gold has its worst drawdown in more than ten years: it is safe to call it a sort of flash crash for the breadth of the range achieved in so little time. What are the safe conclusions to this? 1. Sooner or later the positive correlation between Gold and Fed Balance Sheet will resume; 2. Expect news of sudden shortage of gold in Comex deposits which will make price spikes violently; 3. (Current) Shortage of gold will be covered until it won t be possible anymore; 4. Such cover up will be lifted in possible moment of crisis, when gold will be sought after the most; 5. Keep an eye on the news concerning JP Morgan and Gold; 6. Keep an eye on movements of banks gold deposits; Fed Balance Sheet would translate into a 1,800 usd. Gold price target; 8. With QEs still in place, Fed Balance Sheet and therefore Gold price target should be both revised up. With this study I am in no way saying explicitly or implicitly that JP Morgan did any wrongdoing with their gold deposit nor I am assuming that gold price is or has been manipulated (by someone or some institution), of which I do not believe even to be possible. My intention is only to show how professional investors are behaving with their gold strategy and how their behavior can be read it to predict possible future prices. 9

Mr. Maggioni has been working in the financial markets for the last 13 years covering different roles and working in tier 1 consulting companies and banks worldwide.

10 Mr. Maggioni has been working in the financial markets for the last 13 years covering different roles and working in tier 1 consulting companies and banks worldwide. In recent years his studies have been focused on the psychoemotional aspects of trading and how those aspects have an impact on traders behavior. Before starting this venture, he was head of a hedge fund desk at HSBC Private Bank in Monaco and before that he was employed at Credit Suisse Asset Management (CSAM) in Zurich covering the in-house single manager hedge funds. Most of his experience in hedge funds was gained while working in a Swiss family office where he was in charge of the research and analysis as well as due diligence for US and European hedge funds. He also performed quantitative analysis and portfolio construction for several funds advised by the family office. Prior to that he worked as an external consultant for KPMG Financial Services in the Milan office. In 2002 he has been hired by Ernst & Young LLP, San Francisco as auditor for hedge funds, auditing large single funds and fund of funds. In 2000 he joined Ernst & Young in Milan as an auditor for mid-sized companies. Mr. Maggioni holds an MBA from IUM and a Portfolio Management degree from the University of Chicago GSB. Useful Links: European Central Bank: Bank for International Settlements: International Monetary Fund: Federal Reserve: US CFTC Disclaimer Nothing in this report constitutes a representation that any investment strategy or recommendation contained herein is suitable or appropriate to a recipient s individual circumstances or otherwise constitutes a personal recommendation. It is published solely for information purposes, it does not constitute an advertisement and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. No representation or warranty, either express or implied, is provided in relation to the accuracy, completeness or reliability of the information contained herein, nor is it intended to be a complete statement or summary of the securities, markets or developments referred to in the report. The writer does not undertake that investors will obtain profits, nor will it share with investors any investment profits nor accept any liability for any investment losses. Investments involve risks and investors should exercise prudence in making their investment decisions. The report should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The value of any investment or income may go down as well as up and you may not get back the full amount invested. Any opinions expressed in this report are subject to change without notice. The securities described herein may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain categories of investors. Options, derivative products and futures are not suitable for all investors, and trading in these instruments is considered risky. Foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or income of any security or related instrument mentioned in this report. For investment advice, trade execution or other enquiries, investors should contact their local sales representative. Any prices stated in this report are for information purposes only and do not represent valuations for individual securities or other instruments. 10

Flash report: Nokia. December 19 th Update on the Capitulation that WAS happening. Quantitative approach for asymmetric results

Flash report: Nokia. December 19 th Update on the Capitulation that WAS happening. Quantitative approach for asymmetric results Flash report: Nokia December 19 th 2012 Francesco Maggioni francesco.maggioni@gmail.com IT +39 393 70 40 234 UK +44 757 681 62 43 Quantitative approach for asymmetric results Update on the Capitulation