Designing Energy Markets for the Future
|
|
- Sylvia Bradley
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Designing Energy Markets for the Future Presentation at IWEA Dmitri Perekhodtsev, FTI Compass Lexecon Energy IWEC 17Clayton Hotel, 28 March 2017
2 Outline Who we are Market design in the RES world Evolution of the EU RES support Conclusion 2
3 Who we are
4 FTI provides a wide range of support on energy regulation and market design and across the clean energy value chain FTI Consulting activity FTI Clean Tech FTI Consulting s Clean Energy Practice supports clients across the clean energy value chain, providing a wide array of advisory services addressing the strategic, financial, operational, reputational, regulatory and capital needs of clean energy companies with a focus on wind, solar, and biofuels/biomass, energy storage and emerging technologies. INTERNATIONAL SCOPE Over 4,200 professionals in 24 countries on 6 continents PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE Reputable consultants in a variety of domains with respect to international clients ENERGY EXPERTISE FTI-CL Energy experts have advanced expertise in the issues of electricity market design Collaboration of energy experts from FTI Consulting and Compass Lexecon that is a wholly owned subsidiary of FTI Consulting. Strategy Public policy and regulation M&A and Due Diligence Clean Energy and Renewables Value Chain FTI Compass Lexecon Energy Competition Economics & State Aid Economic expertise in commercial disputes 4
5 Market design in the RES world
6 Two recent studies on market design in presence of RES Towards Target Model 2.0 Current EU Target Model was designed in the early 2000s with different policy priorities and a dominance of variable cost technologies New policy priorities to fight climate change whilst maintaining security of supply and a costs structure evolving toward fixed cost technologies call for a rethink Policy proposals to address long-term investment incentives and flexibility remuneration issues RES-E-MARKETS: Electricity market design and renewable energy deployment Will the evolution towards a power system with high shares of variable renewable energy sources (VRE) require a new electricity market design? Practical, relevant and implementable policy recommendations differentiated between jurisdictions with and without liberalised wholesale electricity markets, for a time horizon of
7 Lessons from international case studies: Applicability to Europe of competition in two steps Investment planning (years ahead) Operations planning (days /hours ahead) Competition for the market Tendering of long term capacity contracts Can be technology neutral or specific Puts competitive pressure where it matters: CAPEX Can be used to stimulate new entrants and development of competitive market Ensures coordinated system development Competition in the market Well integrated and liquid forward, day ahead and intraday markets Optimizes short term dispatch and minimizes costs for consumers Level playing field with balancing obligation No distortions as subsidies not based on production Alternatives to implement two step competition based on long term contracts : Mandate an independent organization to define the type of contracts and to procure them through a centralized auction (e.g. capacity auction, CFDs, etc.), or Implement a decentralized process with contracting obligations on suppliers (e.g. capacity obligation, renewables obligation, etc.) 7
8 Three main challenges of VRE to power systems Capital intensity Limited predictability and variability Decentralized and scattered generation Cost recovery: Credible investment incentives Credible investment signals Implications for the design of energy markets, capacity markets, support schemes Cost of capital: limiting risk exposure Exposure to risk, including policy risk, is a fundamental factor determining total system costs if the system is capital-intensive Trade-off between policy flexibility and regulatory risk Price volatility More volatile prices Product definition (e.g., peak/off-peak) looses relevance Spot market design Reduced gate closer Higher frequency Both day-ahead and intra-day Assurance of system stability Need for new AS products, e.g. providing system inertia Redesign AS to allow VRE participation Coordination between generation and grids Increased investment demand requires new approach to TSO and DSO regulation Locational price signals for generators needed Prosumers Retail prices becomes investment signal Base for taxes and grid fee erodes Many small producers need access to wholesale markets 8
9 The diversity of power systems and implications for market design Vertically integrated monopolist Vertically integrated monopolist + IPPs Single Buyer as a national genco, disco or disco, or a combined notional gencotransco or transco-disco + IPPs Many discos and gencos, including IPPs, transco as a Single Buyer with Third- Party access Power market of gencos, discos and large users, transco and ISO 9 Source: FTI-CL Energy analysis based on various sources including World Bank
10 Stylized models of power system organization: 4 different prototypes Real-world market and policy design is diverse, complex, multi-level and path-dependent. To address this diversity in a transparent way, we studied a small number of power system prototypes Each real-world market represents a combination of these prototypes Each prototype allows to focus on a specific aspect of market design Dispatch decisions Investment generation Examples Energy-only Decentralised through wholesale market prices Decentralised through wholesale market prices Texas, Australia, Europe Hybrid Decentralised through wholesale market prices Centralised based on planning and/or risk sharing mechanism Vertically integrated Centralised based on costs and other drivers Centralised based on planning Prosumer Decentralised through retail market prices Decentralised through retail market prices Brazil, UK South Africa, US Germany, Australia, California 10
11 Energy-only policy recommendations Design of spot and ancillary services markets Locational price signals Development of hedging products Harmonise market designs across time frames Increase price caps and remove barriers to scarcity pricing Market power monitoring Improve balancing markets Improve the operating reserve markets Introduce geographical price differentiation through Zonal splitting Nodal prices Other location signals, e.g. locational connection charges, locational loss charges, etc. Geographical differentiation of balancing prices Introduce measures to improve opportunities for voluntary forward hedging Let the market demand for hedging develop as the intensity of price spikes increases Allow DSR participation in all market segments 11
12 Significant Limited Engineering the transition to hybrid approaches Challenges presented by high-vre on market designs may require the introduction of hybrid system elements, combining the centralised and decentralised approaches to the short-term and long-term decision making. Transition to hybrid approaches under two drivers Policy-maker s Policy maker s intervention The degree of a policy-maker s intervention and the resulting tendency for centralised solutions. This is determined by policy-maker s attitude to risk and information asymmetry Hybrid capacity remuneration mechanism (CRM) focused on security of supply intervention Advanced energy-only market Technology development of flexibility The development of the generation mix along the decarbonisation path leading to high shares of VRE, especially the flexibility of the mix A mix with higher flexibility reduces the urgency of market design challenges presented by VRE and smooths the transition of the market design. Slow Hybrid investment market focused on specific technologies Hybrid technology neutral investment market Rapid Technology development of flexibility Source: FTI-Cl Energy and NEON 12
13 Hybrid approach policy recommendations Integrated resource planning Interface between centralised and decentralised processes Organisation of mandatory risk hedging instruments Efficient resource planning and procurement process. Transparent process for determination of investment needs. Efficient governance and incentives of the planning agency. Design products to allow and encourage participation of renewables Ensure product definition and procurement process remunerates capacity irrespectively of the plant s output and short-term operations. Account for specificities of RES cost structure to design mandatory hedging contracts that allow an efficient risk allocation and support capital intensive investments. Award the risk-hedging contracts through a transparent auctionbased procurement process. Design auctions procurement processes so that they encourage participation of renewables and demand response providers. Favour a decentralised procurement to allow contracts to be tailored to meet the specific needs of suppliers and capacity providers. 13
14 Evolution of the EU RES support
15 With historically very strong subsidy regimes, state aid rules are moving the EU from FiTs to competitive auctions Strong subsidies are being replaced The European Union has been the main driver of renewable policy development over the past 10 years The primary support mechanism across Europe was the use of Feed in tariffs providing fixed revenue support for long durations State Aid Guidelines have spelt the END for subsidies Support schemes for renewables have also faced difficulties over the EU state aid directives in recent years, as costs have also come down. All new regulatory systems will need to adhere to the state aid guidelines for renewable support There is now a requirement for competition within support schemes (except for small installations), and therefore the majority of regulatory schemes are becoming market based. Fixed Price Market Based FiT Direct Subsidy FiP Tax Credits Competitive Auction Tender Based 15
16 There is a gradual introduction of auctions across the EU as existing RES support for individual states comes to an end and is replaced Transport Applications The 2003 Directive requires individual countries to introduce legislation and support schemes that meet minimum proportion of fuel produced from biomass that is used for transport EU Climate Change Plan In 2008, fixed 2020 targets for individual countries and the entire EU were set. The target was 20% RES share by 2020 and 10% in the transport sector. Pilot Phase Member states will start to implement competitive bidding \\\\\\\\\\\ procedures for a small share (>5%) of new renewable capacity RES Directive The 2001 RES legislation set the overall EU s target of energy consumption from renewables to 21%. Its aim was to set national RES targets and promote the security and diversification of energy supply. The directive relies on individual country s RES support mechanisms in order to fulfil the target Applications Application of the Energy and environmental State aid guidelines. These replace the previous aid protection that entered into force in Compensation Obligation Generators need to sell electricity in the market. They will also become subject to balancing responsibilities. i.e. have to compensate for shortterm deviations from their targeted generation. Producers may receive compensation in the form of a market premium. Aid to Renewables All member states shall set up tenders to grant support to all new installations, unless it can be shown that bidding would lead to suboptimal results. Bidding will be open to all other member states to encourage competition. 16
17 Many EU states are moving towards competitive support systems with a very small number currently with no support Competitive tenders Feed-in tariffs Green certificates Market premium No Support United Kingdom Contracts for difference (Pay as Clear*) Ireland Feed-in tariffs until 2017, new support scheme to be introduced in Norway Green Certificates Finland Feed-in tariffs Sweden Green Certificates Netherlands Pay as Bid auctions Belgium Green Certificates France Regulated FIP and competitive tenders Spain Competitive (Pay as Bid) auctions to be held in Q Italy Portugal Feed-in tariffs (new installations remunerated through open energy market) Notes: Support schemes for new installations, does not consider legacy schemes *Pay as clear auction is an auction where participants are awarded the price of the most expensive offer that is accepted (clearing price). Typically this refers to all technologies that have CfD support scheme. Source: FTI Intelligence, RES Legal, AURES Denmark Market Premium Germany Competitive tenders (Pay as Bid) Poland Competitive auctions (Pay as Bid) Competitive tenders (Pay as Bid) Greece Feed-in tariffs moving to Pay as Clear auctions 17
18 Although historically considerably higher, solar PV tenders are now broadly at a similar level to onshore wind 2016 low auction price comparison, /MWh Average Wind Price, 48.77/MWh Wind Price Range, /MWh Solar PV Price Range, /MWh Average Solar Price, 44.93/MWh Findings The lowest onshore wind price is 27.10/MWh in Morocco compared to 21.52/MWh in Dubai for Solar PV Solar PV low bid prices have a higher range than onshore wind, this is primarily caused by different climate conditions within markets Mexico, Argentina and Chile all held auctions for both solar PV and onshore wind each giving similar prices for both technologies: - Wind Solar Mexico Chile Argentina Kreigers Flak (Offshore) Borssele III & IV (Offshore) Italy Morocco Canada Peru India Dubai Germany China Source: FTI Intelligence collation of publically announced tender results Tender Price /MWh Solar PV Onshore Wind Mexico Argentina Chile
19 Auction price reductions are being driven by reductions in LCOE, with mean levels for both wind and solar falling below 50/MWh Solar PV LCOE Greenfield (Range and Average) ( /MWh) Max Min Mean Onshore Wind LCOE Greenfield (Range and Average) ( /MWh) Max Min Mean Solar PV s LCOE has decreased steadily between 2009 and 2017 with a 70% reduction in mean values. Average Year on Year decrease has been 13.8% Onshore wind projects have a smaller decrease of 56% with Average Year on Year decrease of 8% On average onshore wind remains marginally cheaper compared to Solar 37/MWh compared to $46/MWh in 2017, although we expect solar to be cheaper by 2021 Source: Solar PV Lazard LCOE, versions 3 to to 2016, 2017 value average of markets considered by FTI Intelligence excluding Turkey for FTI Intelligence 19
20 The case of Spain: retroactive cuts on solar subsidies The PV boom in Spain has had the impact of significantly increasing the electricity system regulated costs. As a result a series of regulatory measures were introduced by the Spanish Government to reduce this deficit: 1.Freezing subsidies for new capacity from January 2012; and 2.Retroactive cuts in a series of measures which started in 2010 with RFII and RFIII. Regulatory Framework I Original RD 661/0027 regulatory framework Regulatory Framework II Changes from 2010-July 2013 RD 1565/2010, RDL 14/2010, LES, Act 15/2012, RDL 2/2013 Regulatory Framework III (RDL 9/3013, RD 413/2014, Order IET/1045/2014) July 2013 onwards Plants received a fixed payment per unit of production ( Feed-in-tariff or FiT ). FiT updated annually according to CPI-0.5 and applicable to all production. FiT varies according to the size of the installation. 20% reduction in FiT after first 25 years. Extension in FiT terms from 25 to 30 years but then falls to zero (vs 20% reduction). Caps on production introduced and production in excess of caps receives the market price. New 7% tax on revenues effective 1 January CPI indexing modified resulting in a permanent reduction of 3% in revenues. Under RF III each plant receives three defined payments: 1. Wholesale market pool price payment: for each MWh produced. 2. A regulated operating payment: each plant is assigned a operating payment based on the level of production up to a fixed annual production cap. 3. Regulated annual investment payments: for each MW of installed capacity so as to achieve a set rate of return ( RoR ). Currently 45 pending international arbitration cases against Spain, amounting to billions of US dollars in investment 20
21 Installations (GW) The EU could follow the US with a rapid growth of corporate PPAs for renewables Strong US market Growth Large volumes of installations in both wind and solar with continued growth Large volume of corporates with increased corporate social responsibility focus Driven by the PTC/ITC schemes providing revenue despite offtake circumstances European Opportunity Historic domination from large utilities shifting towards smaller generators European regulation becoming more liberalised and a move from FiTs FTI believe Europe to be about 4-5 years behind the US leading to large growth with about 1GW contracted today Cumulative corporate renewable PPA capacity contracted in the US (MW) 1 8,000 7,000 7,150 6,000 5,590 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1, ,150 1, Source 1): Business Renewables Centre, December
22 Conclusion
23 Conclusions Hybrid market designs Our market design analysis suggests that the world with high shares of RES may require a transition from the EOM to hybrid market designs Renewable support schemes evolution Compliance with the new State aid guidelines on energy drives a considerable change in the renewable support schemes across Europe towards competitive auctions Policy interventions and re-regulation have become the new normal, giving rise to regulatory disputes Regulatory disputes over design and impact of new regulations (e.g. capacity mechanisms, changes in RES support mechanisms, etc.) Potential international arbitration disputes when retroactive changes introduced (e.g. Spain) Contracts are making a come back The market for corporate offtake PPAs for renewables generation is taking off in Europe New business models for energy services involve complex contractual structures for revenues and cost sharing 23
24 Critical Thinking at the Critical Time Dmitri Perekhodtsev Vice President COMPASS LEXECON on.com
25 Ireland: RES support under the new market for electricity (I-SEM) New support scheme for RES in Ireland The current REFIT scheme was supposed to be close on 31 Dec 2015 but extended to 31 Dec The Department of Communication, Climate Action and Environment is working on developing a new RES support scheme compliant with the State aid guidelines to promote a gradual move to market-based support for renewable energy. Introduction of a new support scheme is expected in The public consultation on the new scheme is about to be opened. RES operation under I-SEM Balancing responsibility for all participants, ensuring their notification of generation or demand reflects their actual expectations The I-SEM will include a transitional mechanism to help smaller players to access the market in ex-ante time-frames, without necessarily needing to invest in trading capability of their own. Challenges for variable generators, especially wind farms The reform will introduce new risks for RES operators which could be unable to adequately mitigate the balancing risk in the intraday and balancing markets. They could be required to participate in the imbalance market at potentially punitive rates. Aggregator of Last Resort (AOLR) will help to mitigate these risks for smaller players in transitioning to a new market design 25
Support mechanisms for RES-e
Support mechanisms for RES-e Regional ECREEE Training Workshop on National Renewable Energy Policy and Incentive Schemes Praia, 9-11 April 2012 Sofía Martínez International Relations Department Table of
More informationPower Trading in the Coupled European Markets
Power Trading in the Coupled European Markets Challenges for policy-makers February 2016-1 - Europe Economics is registered in England No. 3477100. Registered offices at Chancery House, 53-64 Chancery
More informationThe 2030 Energy & Climate Package for the EU: the challenges that lie ahead The utilities view
The 2030 Energy & Climate Package for the EU: the challenges that lie ahead The utilities view Dr. Hans Bünting CEO, RWE Innogy GmbH Brussels, 3 rd December 2014 RWE Innogy 04/12/2014 PAGE 1 New targets:
More informationMarket Integration of Renewable Energies A European Perspective
Market Integration of Renewable Energies A European Perspective British- German Workshop Renewable Energies and Electricity Market Design Squaring the Circle? 13.06.2013 Dr. Corinna Klessmann Diversity
More informationADAPTING THE TARGET MODEL TO VALUE FLEXIBILITY
ADAPTING THE TARGET MODEL TO VALUE FLEXIBILITY Stephen Woodhouse 3 November 2015 AGENDA ADAPTING THE TARGET MODEL TO VALUE FLEXIBILITY To be covered in this session: What is flexibility? Reality and misconceptions
More informationGREEK RENEWABLES SUPPORT SCHEME PROPOSALS
BRIEFING GREEK RENEWABLES SUPPORT SCHEME PROPOSALS MARCH 2016 BRIEF OUTLINE OF THE SCHEME PHOTOVOLTAIC PROJECTS TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS NON-INTERCONNECTED ISLANDS COMPETITIVE BIDDING PROCESS FROM 2017
More informationCorrigendum. OECD Pensions Outlook 2012 DOI: ISBN (print) ISBN (PDF) OECD 2012
OECD Pensions Outlook 2012 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/9789264169401-en ISBN 978-92-64-16939-5 (print) ISBN 978-92-64-16940-1 (PDF) OECD 2012 Corrigendum Page 21: Figure 1.1. Average annual real net investment
More informationThe Road to the I-SEM
The Road to the I-SEM 1 Agenda Development of power markets in Ireland and Northern Ireland Development of power markets across Europe Market coupling explained The road to the I-SEM The elements of the
More informationThe Spread of Feed-in Tariffs: Lessons Learned
The Spread of Feed-in Tariffs: Lessons Learned Prepared by: Christina Hanley, Meister Consultants Group 1 The Presentation Outline A. Diffusion of Feed-in Tariffs Worldwide B. Feed-in Tariff Design in
More informationElectricity Markets and Principle Market Design Models
Electricity Markets and Principle Market Design Models (prepared for the European Copper Institute) Dr. Konstantin Petrov KEMA Consulting GmbH Kurt-Schumacher-Straße 8 53113, Bonn Tel: + 49 228 4469000
More informationFOCUS ON EDF EN Analyst Group Lunch Meeting - 6 July 2017
FOCUS ON EDF EN Analyst Group Lunch Meeting - 6 July 2017 Antoine Cahuzac - Group Senior Executive VP of Renewable Energies and CEO of EDF Énergies Nouvelles Bruno Fyot COO of EDF EN Denis Rouhier CFO
More informationAuctions to support renewable energy deployment overview and design elements Reverse Auctions to Scale Renewable Energy 6 June 2017
Auctions to support renewable energy deployment overview and design elements Reverse Auctions to Scale Renewable Energy 6 June 2017 Targets in the global renewable energy landscape 173 countries have at
More informationQuick Guide to the Integrated Single Electricity Market. Version 1
Quick Guide to the Integrated Single Electricity Market Version 1 1 Contents 1. What is the I-SEM? 2. Market coupling 3. Administration 4. Markets 5. Participation and roles 6. Trading options 7. Settlement
More informationFeed in Tariff Guidelines
COMMON MARKET FOR EASTERN AND SOUTHERN AFRICA Feed in Tariff Guidelines Zambia Lusaka August 7 to 11 2017 Feed in tariff Guidelines I. Objectives of the Feed In Tariff Guideline II. Feed In Tariffs Policy
More informationDownstream natural gas in Europe the role of upstream oil and gas companies
Downstream natural gas in Europe the role of upstream oil and gas companies Presentation at PETROPOL research conference on natural gas Opportunities for Norway in the future European natural gas market
More informationWe guide companies leading the electricity transformation
0 POWER & RENEWABLES RESEARCH GTM, MAKE & Wood Mackenzie form the premier market intelligence provider on the decarbonization and decentralization of energy We guide companies leading the electricity transformation
More informationGROWING OUR INDUSTRY-LEADING POSITION
GROWING OUR INDUSTRY-LEADING POSITION Juan Araluce EVP & Chief Sales Officer Copenhagen, 29 November 2018 Track record and Performance Trends in the Sector Commercial Strategy to maintain #1 position AGENDA
More informationIntegrated Single Electricity Market (I-SEM)
Integrated Single Electricity Market (I-SEM) Laura Brien, Director of Electricity Markets, CER Ibec Energy Conference Portlaoise Heritage Hotel 12 June 2014 Agenda The I-SEM Energy Trading Arrangements
More informationFinancing Utility Scale Solar
Financing Utility Scale Solar Matt Handel Vice President Solar, Distributed Generation & Storage August 25, 2016 Headquartered in Juno Beach, FL, NextEra Energy, Inc. has operations in 27 states, Canada,
More informationInvestor presentation. H results September 26, 2017
Investor presentation H1 2017 results September 26, 2017 Speakers of the day Sébastien CLERC Chief Executive Officer Joined Voltalia in 2011 Marie de LAUZON Chief Administrative Officer Joined Voltalia
More informationWorld Bank. The Gas Sector. Oil and Gas Sector Review Workshop December 17-18, Franz Gerner Energy Specialist
World Bank Oil and Gas Sector Review Workshop December 17-18, 2003 The Gas Sector Franz Gerner Energy Specialist Accomplishments (1) Pakistan has made impressive progress in reforming and restructuring
More informationGlobal Offshore Wind Market
Global Offshore Wind Market Presented at: Wind Shipping and Logistics Conference Presented by Bruce Hamilton Navigant Copenhagen, Denmark March 12, 2015 2015 Navigant Consulting, Inc. D I S P U T E S &
More informationChoosing Appropriate Incentives to Deploy Renewable Energy
Choosing Appropriate Incentives to Deploy Renewable Energy Workshop, World Bank Headquarters Global Head of Climate Change Investment Research Climate Change Advisors http://www.dbcca.com/research January
More informationPension Fund Investment and Regulation - An International Perspective and Implications for China s Pension System
Pension Fund Investment and Regulation - An International Perspective and Implications for China s Pension System Yu-Wei Hu, Fiona Stewart and Juan Yermo Financial Affairs Division OECD, Paris OECD/IOPS
More informationSupport regimes for offshore wind in Europe Florian Bauernfeind
Winter Academy 2018 Trading, Sales and Financing in the European Energy Market and Industry Support regimes for offshore wind in Europe Florian Bauernfeind Vattenfall Agenda 1. Wind Power in Vattenfall
More information20 years operation of the Nordic electricity market
ENERGY 20 years operation of the Nordic electricity market ADB Regional Energy Trade Workshop September 8-9, 2014 Manila Dr. Per Christer Lund 1 SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER Electricity market world wide 2
More informationTHE REFORM OF THE SPANISH POWER SYSTEM: TOWARDS FINANCIAL STABILITY AND REGULATORY CERTAINTY
THE REFORM OF THE SPANISH POWER SYSTEM: TOWARDS FINANCIAL STABILITY AND REGULATORY CERTAINTY 1. The starting point: evolution of system s costs and tariff deficit 2. The reform of the Spanish power system:
More informationCapital Markets Day. Global Renewable Energies. Antonio Cammisecra
Capital Markets Day Global Renewable Energies Antonio Cammisecra Integrated model fit for digitalized, low carbon world Generation growth engine Leading geographic expansion Growth engine for the utility
More informationCOMPANY PROFILE. ACCIONA, sustainable development as a factor for leadership
COMPANY PROFILE ACCIONA is one of the world's leading companies in terms of sustainability, standing out especially for its drive to develop renewable energies, infrastructures, water and services, placing
More informationSan Francisco Retiree Health Care Trust Fund Education Materials on Public Equity
M E K E T A I N V E S T M E N T G R O U P 5796 ARMADA DRIVE SUITE 110 CARLSBAD CA 92008 760 795 3450 fax 760 795 3445 www.meketagroup.com The Global Equity Opportunity Set MSCI All Country World 1 Index
More informationInterconnector participation in Capacity Remuneration Mechanisms
Interconnector participation in Capacity Remuneration Mechanisms A REPORT PREPARED FOR ENERGY NORWAY January 2014 Frontier Economics Ltd, London. January 2014 Frontier Economics i Interconnector participation
More informationCan The EU Be An Example To Turkish Electricity Market Liberalisation?
Can The EU Be An Example To Turkish Electricity Market Liberalisation? Istanbul Energy Day 8 September 2015 Dr. Jan Haizmann Managing Director CORREGGIO CONSULTING Introduction Dr. Jan Haizmann Academia
More informationEnergiewende. Drivers and Enablers for German Offshore Wind. Dr. Martin Schöpe
Energiewende Drivers and Enablers for German Offshore Wind Dr. Martin Schöpe BMWi Head of Unit IIA1 International Cooperation on Energy Hamburg, 25 September 2018 18-09-24 Referent 1 Source: Ecofys 2018
More informationRecommendation of the Council on the Implementation of the Polluter-Pays Principle
Recommendation of the Council on the Implementation of the Polluter-Pays Principle OECD Legal Instruments This document is published under the responsibility of the Secretary-General of the OECD. It reproduces
More informationSouth East Europe Electricity Market options paper
EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR ENERGY AND TRANSPORT DIRECTORATE C - Conventional Energies Electricity & Gas Brussels, 5 December 2005 DG TREN/C2/MS South East Europe Electricity Market options
More informationBrexit and electricity interconnectors. Jason Mann
Brexit and electricity interconnectors Jason Mann 12 May 2018 Expansion of UK interconnection capacity driven by strong fundamentals and benign policies - but complicated by Brexit Mounting political pressures
More informationMAIN REGULATORY ISSUES FOR INVESTORS
MAIN REGULATORY ISSUES FOR INVESTORS Ester Benigni A2A Manager October 2016 AGENDA A2A Regulatory Affairs Regulatory topics Capacity Market Abolition of the regulated tariffs in the power sales 2 DIVERSIFIED
More informationFinancial law reform: purpose and key questions
Conference on Cross-Jurisdictional Netting and Global Solutions Update on Netting in Asia May 12, 2011 London School of Economics and Political Science Peter M Werner Senior Director ISDA pwerner@isda.org
More informationWholesale power market challenges:
EU Electricity Market Reform Seminar Dublin 13 March 2013 Wholesale power market challenges: from simplicity and efficiency to complexity and regulation Peter Styles European Federation of Energy Traders
More informationA Closer Examination of Wind Generation in Ireland
Industry Insight June 2015 A Closer Examination of Wind Generation in Ireland How the changing market is making it hard for generators to forecast revenues With enviable wind resources, ambitious renewables
More informationSALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2017 FIRST QUARTER
SALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2017 FIRST QUARTER DISCLAIMER This presentation does not constitute an offer to sell securities in the United States or any other jurisdiction. No reliance should be placed on the
More informationObstacles to Trade and Compatibility of Market Rules in Southeast Europe
Obstacles to Trade and Compatibility of Market Rules in Southeast Europe Findings/ Recommendations of SEETEC Final Draft Report Athens Forum June 22st, 2006 REM-1202-47RP-I-0006 National wholesale markets
More informationSTOXX EMERGING MARKETS INDICES. UNDERSTANDA RULES-BA EMERGING MARK TRANSPARENT SIMPLE
STOXX Limited STOXX EMERGING MARKETS INDICES. EMERGING MARK RULES-BA TRANSPARENT UNDERSTANDA SIMPLE MARKET CLASSIF INTRODUCTION. Many investors are seeking to embrace emerging market investments, because
More informationFull year Vestas Wind Systems A/S. Copenhagen, 7 February Classification: Public
Full year Vestas Wind Systems A/S Copenhagen, 7 February 2018 Classification: Public Disclaimer and cautionary statement This document contains forward-looking statements concerning Vestas financial condition,
More informationSALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2018 THIRD QUARTER
SALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2018 THIRD QUARTER DISCLAIMER This presentation does not constitute an offer to sell securities in the United States or any other jurisdiction. No reliance should be placed on the
More informationHow multi-technology PPA structures could help companies reduce risk
How multi-technology PPA structures could help companies reduce risk 1 How multi-technology PPA structures could help companies reduce risk Table of contents Introduction... 3 Key PPA risks related to
More informationDFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Quarterly Performance Report Q2 2014
DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Quarterly Performance Report Q2 2014 This presentation has been prepared by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ), manager of the Dimensional Funds.
More informationName Organisation Date
European Public Leadership Driving Innovation In Construction and Operations Name Organisation Date Construction: declining productivity and low digitalisation Productivity Digitalisation Other non-farm
More informationEU Renewable Energy Infrastructure Market Report Q1 2017
Introduction For the last 15 years Tom Murley, the principal of Two Lights Energy Advisors, has been an active investor in European Renewable Energy infrastructure. The Two Lights Energy Advisors Quarterly
More informationGRANT THORNTON INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS REPORT Cross-border mergers and acquisitions: building momentum
GRANT THORNTON INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS REPORT 2012 Cross-border mergers and acquisitions: building momentum Foreword MIKE HUGHES GLOBAL SERVICE LINE LEADER MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS GRANT THORNTON INTERNATIONAL
More informationInvestor presentation. December 2018
Investor presentation December 2018 Disclaimer The following presentation is being made only to, and is only directed at, persons to whom such presentation may lawfully be communicated ( relevant persons
More informationDFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q2 2017
DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q2 2017 This presentation has been prepared by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ), manager of the Dimensional Funds. This presentation
More informationDFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2018
DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2018 This presentation has been prepared by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ), manager of the Dimensional Funds. This presentation
More informationDFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q4 2017
DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q4 2017 This presentation has been prepared by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ), manager of the Dimensional Funds. This presentation
More informationQuarterly Investment Update First Quarter 2017
Quarterly Investment Update First Quarter 2017 Market Update: A Quarter in Review March 31, 2017 CANADIAN STOCKS INTERNATIONAL STOCKS Large Cap Small Cap Growth Value Large Cap Small Cap Growth Value Emerging
More informationDFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2015
DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2015 This presentation has been prepared by Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ), manager of the Dimensional Funds. This presentation
More informationCOUNTRY COST INDEX JUNE 2013
COUNTRY COST INDEX JUNE 2013 June 2013 Kissell Research Group, LLC 1010 Northern Blvd., Suite 208 Great Neck, NY 11021 www.kissellresearch.com Kissell Research Group Country Cost Index - June 2013 2 Executive
More informationRenewable Energy and Mining Summit. Toronto, September 25th, 2013
Renewable Energy and Mining Summit Toronto, September 25th, 2013 1 SOLARPACK- Company Profile Company Overview Started operations in 2005 in Spain 60 highly specialized professionals 79 MW own developed
More informationEUROPEAN UNION SOUTH KOREA TRADE AND INVESTMENT 5 TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE FTA. Delegation of the European Union to the Republic of Korea
EUROPEAN UNION SOUTH KOREA TRADE AND INVESTMENT 5 TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE FTA 2016 Delegation of the European Union to the Republic of Korea 16 th Floor, S-tower, 82 Saemunan-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul, Korea
More informationSecond quarter Vestas Wind Systems A/S. Copenhagen, 18 August Classification: Public
Second quarter Vestas Wind Systems A/S Copenhagen, 18 August Disclaimer and cautionary statement This presentation contains forward-looking statements concerning Vestas' financial condition, results of
More informationSALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2018 FIRST QUARTER
SALES AND HIGHLIGHTS 2018 FIRST QUARTER DISCLAIMER This presentation does not constitute an offer to sell securities in the United States or any other jurisdiction. No reliance should be placed on the
More informationREFORMING PENSION SYSTEMS: THE OECD EXPERIENCE
REFORMING PENSION SYSTEMS: THE OECD EXPERIENCE IX Forum Nacional de Seguro de Vida e Previdencia Privada 12 June 2018, São Paulo Jessica Mosher, Policy Analyst, Private Pensions Unit of the Financial Affairs
More informationThe development of offshore wind - The case of Denmark
9 February 2017 The development of offshore wind - The case of Denmark Camilla Holbech, Deputy Manager Danish Wind Industry Association Zooming in on the Danish wind industry More than 30,000 employees
More informationRENEWABLE ELECTRICTY SUPPORT IN THE EU WHAT LESSONS CAN BE LEARNED?
RENEWABLE ELECTRICTY SUPPORT IN THE EU WHAT LESSONS CAN BE LEARNED? 16 th Global Conference on Environmental Taxation University of Technology Sydney, 24 th September 2015 Claudia Kettner & Daniela Kletzan-Slamanig
More informationSunEdison s Comments on NERSA REFIT 2011 Consultation Paper
8.2 MW Alamosa Solar Energy Facility (First utility scale PV plant in the USA) 1 72 MW Plant in Italy, the largest Solar PV Power Plant in Europe SunEdison s Comments on NERSA REFIT 2011 Consultation Paper
More informationRenewable Energy Auctions Analysing IRENA Energy Community Workshop on Renewable Energy Auctions 8 March 2017
Renewable Energy Auctions Analysing 2016 IRENA Energy Community Workshop on Renewable Energy Auctions 8 March 2017 Renewable Energy Auctions Recent highlights 2 Price trends: solar PV auctions 3 Price
More informationIs 2016 a game changer for renewable investment?
Is 2016 a game changer for renewable investment? Presentation at the by Matt Rennie, EY 4 October 2016 Matt Rennie EY Oceania Power and Utilities leader, EY Global Leader Transactions, Power and Utilities
More informationMETIS Technical Note T3. Market module configuration for study S12. Focus on day-ahead, intraday and balancing markets
METIS Technical Note T3 Market module configuration for study S12 Focus on day-ahead, intraday and balancing markets METIS Technical Notes November 2016 Prepared by Christopher Andrey (Artelys) Maxime
More informationAllianz Global Corporate & Specialty
Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty Company presentation January 2012 Allianz An Introduction Allianz Group is one of the world s leading insurers and financial services providers Founded in 1890 in Berlin,
More informationSpurring Growth of Renewable Energies in MENA through Private Sector Investment
MENA-OECD Business Council: Task Force on Energy and Infrastructure WORKING PAPER PRESENTING THE PRIVATE SECTOR S VIEW Spurring Growth of Renewable Energies in MENA through Private Sector Investment Agenda
More informationThe Rule of Law as a Factor for Competitiveness
The Rule of Law as a Factor for Competitiveness Lessons from the Global Competitiveness Index 2008-2009 Irene Mia Director, Senior Economist Global Competitiveness Network, World Economic Forum OECD Workshop
More informationFinancial wealth of private households worldwide
Economic Research Financial wealth of private households worldwide Munich, October 217 Recovery in turbulent times Assets and liabilities of private households worldwide in EUR trillion and annualrate
More informationEconomic and financial feasibility of PV projects
Economic and financial feasibility of PV projects Monika BIERI Research Associate Solar Energy Research Institute of Singapore (SERIS) National University of Singapore (NUS) SERIS INDUSTRY DAY on PV Quality
More informationOffshore Wind Cost Reduction Recent and future trends in the UK and Europe
Offshore Wind Cost Reduction Recent and future trends in the UK and Europe Gavin Smart November 2016 TLI-SP-00007 Summary Over the last few years, the UK s levelised cost of energy (LCOE) for offshore
More informationEnterprise Europe Network SME growth outlook
Enterprise Europe Network SME growth outlook 2018-19 een.ec.europa.eu 2 Enterprise Europe Network SME growth outlook 2018-19 Foreword The European Commission wants to ensure that small and medium-sized
More informationDIVERSIFICATION. Diversification
Diversification Helps you capture what global markets offer Reduces risks that have no expected return May prevent you from missing opportunity Smooths out some of the bumps Helps take the guesswork out
More informationThe current state of the electricity market in Bulgaria
The current state of the electricity market in Bulgaria Towards market liberalization Current state of the market Generation 42 TWh Export - 18% Losses - 9% Regulated market 33% Domestic free market -
More informationReporting practices for domestic and total debt securities
Last updated: 27 November 2017 Reporting practices for domestic and total debt securities While the BIS debt securities statistics are in principle harmonised with the recommendations in the Handbook on
More informationReview of Support Mechanisms and Policy Options for Offshore Wind. Prepared by the Center for Wind Energy at James Madison University.
Review of Support Mechanisms and Policy Options for Offshore Wind Prepared by the Center for Wind Energy at James Madison University August 2012 Denmark Denmark s long-term target is to achieve complete
More informationFocus on: Cleantech. International Business Report 2010 Sector focus series
Focus on: Cleantech International Business Report 2010 Sector focus series The Grant Thornton International Business Report (IBR) 2010 reveals that privately held businesses (PHBs) in the cleantech sector
More informationSkills gap in offshore RES: challenges for Intelligent Energy Europe Programme
Skills gap in offshore RES: challenges for Intelligent Energy Europe Programme Dana Dutianu, Project Officer, Executive Agency for Competitiveness and Innovation EACI Brussels, 04 October 2010 IEE: TURNING
More informationInternational Transfer Pricing Framework
Are you ready for transfer pricing? Seminar on November 28th, 2005 Swissotel, Istanbul International Framework Marc Diepstraten, Partner, PwC Amsterdam, +31 20 568 64 76 PwC Agenda Transfer pricing environment
More informationCapacity mechanisms in Europe
Capacity mechanisms in Europe The fundamental issues behind the ongoing sector enquiry Brussels, 28 th September 2015 Session 2 - If a capacity mechanism, which design is most appropriate? Andrea Villa
More informationEuropean transmission tariff structures Cambridge Economic Policy Associates
European transmission tariff structures Cambridge Economic Policy Associates 24 March 2015 Cambridge Economic Policy Associates (CEPA) We are an economic and financial policy consulting business Our energy
More informationChapter 5: Trading. Industry Guide to the I-SEM
Chapter 5: Trading Industry Guide to the I-SEM 1 5.1 Submission timelines Each market operates over different timelines, as described in Chapter 4. By way of an example, the combined submission timelines
More informationRECENT EVOLUTION AND OUTLOOK OF THE MEXICAN ECONOMY BANCO DE MÉXICO OCTOBER 2003
OCTOBER 23 RECENT EVOLUTION AND OUTLOOK OF THE MEXICAN ECONOMY BANCO DE MÉXICO 2 RECENT DEVELOPMENTS OUTLOOK MEDIUM-TERM CHALLENGES 3 RECENT DEVELOPMENTS In tandem with the global economic cycle, the Mexican
More informationQuarterly Investment Update First Quarter 2018
Quarterly Investment Update First Quarter 2018 Dimensional Fund Advisors Canada ULC ( DFA Canada ) is not affiliated with [insert name of Advisor]. DFA Canada is a separate and distinct company. Market
More information5th Annual Renwable Energy Finance in Practice 21 October Support Tendering - François van Leeuw CEO of Parkwind
5th Annual Renwable Energy Finance in Practice 21 October 2016 - Support Tendering - François van Leeuw CEO of Parkwind AGENDA 1. Introduction to Parkwind 1. Corporate Overview 2. Shareholders structure
More informationBETTER POLICIES FOR A SUCCESSFUL TRANSITION TO A LOW-CARBON ECONOMY
BETTER POLICIES FOR A SUCCESSFUL TRANSITION TO A LOW-CARBON ECONOMY Rintaro Tamaki Deputy Secretary-General, OECD International Forum for Sustainable Asia and the Pacific (ISAP)1 Yokohama, July 1 Four
More informationRegional Power Market Challenges and Opportunities from Nepalese perspective
Regional Power Market Challenges and Opportunities from Nepalese perspective Hitendra Dev Shakya Director, Power Trade Department, Nepal Electricity Authority Outline of the Presentation 1. Energy sector
More informationDeutsche Bank DB Climate Change Advisors. GET FiT Programme. Scaling-up renewable energy in developing countries. Mark Fulton October 2011
GET FiT Programme Scaling-up renewable energy in developing countries A number of barriers typically constrain renewable energy scale-up in developing countries Are renewable energy technologies cost-competitive
More informationGeneration investment in a liberalised electricity market. 28 March 2008
Generation investment in a liberalised electricity market 28 March 2008 Darryl Biggar Australian Competition and Consumer Commission Australian Energy Regulator Investment in electricity markets Demand
More informationInvesting in Climate Change
Investing in Climate Change Mark Fulton Global Head of Climate Change Investment Research DB Climate Change Advisors April 10, 2010 http://www.dbcca.com/research DB Climate Change Advisors (DBCCA) DBCCA
More informationFY 2016 results. April 4, 2017
FY 2016 results April 4, 2017 Speakers of the day Sébastien CLERC Chief Executive Officer Joined Voltalia in 2011 Marie de LAUZON Chief Administrative Officer Joined Voltalia in 2014 27 years of experience
More informationAlgorithmic Order Guide
Algorithmic Order Guide STRATEGIES SUPPORTED MARKETS... 3 VWAP... 4 TWAP... 5 WITH VOLUME... 6 IMPLEMENTATION SHORTFALL... 7 PRE-MARKET LIMIT... 8 ICEBERG... 9 RELOAD...10 DARK....11 2 / 11 SUPPORTED MARKETS
More informationHow can renewables support Europe?
Florence School of Regulation, Annual Climate Conference 2016 How can renewables support Europe? Karsten Neuhoff German Institute for Economic Research (DIW Berlin) Technical University Berlin 1 Moving
More informationFrance consolidates its competitiveness in a general converging trend
INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON OF RESEARCHER RATES REPORTED BY GROUPS RECEIVING RESEARCH TAX CREDIT (RTC) IN 2016 ANRT, October 2017 France consolidates its competitiveness in a general converging trend Policies
More informationThe macroeconomic effects of a carbon tax in the Netherlands Íde Kearney, 13 th September 2018.
The macroeconomic effects of a carbon tax in the Netherlands Íde Kearney, th September 08. This note reports estimates of the economic impact of introducing a carbon tax of 50 per ton of CO in the Netherlands.
More informationInvesco Indexing Investable Universe Methodology October 2017
Invesco Indexing Investable Universe Methodology October 2017 1 Invesco Indexing Investable Universe Methodology Table of Contents Introduction 3 General Approach 3 Country Selection 4 Region Classification
More informationThe Nordic Market Model 10 Years of Experience
The Nordic Market Model 10 Years of Experience 7 th International Workshop on Electric Power Control Centers Ortisei, Italy May 25-28, 2003 Presentation by Ole Gjerde Senior Adviser, Statnett SF 1 Contents
More information