Downloaded from yafte.lums.ac.ir at 21: on Friday March 22nd 2019

Transcription

1 TOPSIS $#!"."! 1 1 1*! -1 6,%% / 9 %') / 2 # / $%&' # /! 9/2/2: 96/12/5:!"!# $ % & ' (# )#* + $*, -./ 01% & 21% +# 3% 2./ 45: -,B 01% & + $0? $0 >/$01 >3# >%=*</% :;* (#.2 -+% 6 $8#% & 21% >-K +.* + $JJA0 <EI# +D >/8'G0H% CD :#E,F >/-++:/+ $0 >/$01 >%=* % > N3* % NO PA0 M&-B/+C* 0 (# +.> +' L#+<E 01%.2. 0&+ /M& (# Q % $0? -+= $3!# % + >/M& G?S + 01% & 21% $0 >/$01 H /+ $" R#0:/0# % -+ $Z?+>/$01 2'S,+-L#D+0/4662/=M&% +D% $01 Y2#? +0/462/=M&% +%,&.0' S4/+ 41-L#D+0/2830/2842/=>/M&% G** + 0H+ >/M& bj& + G** % $0 a+_c`(#0"% -,B >/8? % D* % :>'B0 ^;%.2--/" 21% & >+ >/0 d+(c./ YC2A* >1 + 01% 8H >L* 8H.$0? $0 > N3* 01% & 21% :>H >/-e *.! : a.nezami1998@gmil.com :%&'(!#$ 9 / 22

2 d</ GO' * ;= [' _& -1.(4) 9Bh,","*+ '$%& $'9 5 _O5( 5+* - 5! 5+*.5/ 5* F95 $ $B -L,.,jc d</.2 + $ "& 5 "'> :&,jc "12, P 5 "5 "5 5+*.5/ -9*5)& $ $! VX F9+QI,"*+ $ 'B.5/ -9*5)& $ F2 F9 [9&& F5 5 59b& 5 "5((:.$+ " +* -S59*& -51 _5& ;5=& "5& $5 $1 $5 g $ (= +* "./ 5 $5(8' 5< G59I T9:5L S5$5 $5 F _& 9=P $ H ->O!.(5) + -1 l 65 $=08 "12, B IL B 559$= 55& $ 55 F9 559=& $55 55)& 5+* 3 *+ ","*+ $5 "5 5 5 $5 n5.5'!c F&55! 0/4 $ ' "55*+ "5*+ F5& 5: 0/93 $5 5 "*+.(6) + $!'+ " 5'T85 F25P $5=08 "12, (9B& "S C "5s "5 5,"5*+ "5 5+*!5 5, m!+ ' * "5* * "*+ $ 'B "S9 F2 F9 [9&& $ 9 39 *9c $5 "5 5+*.5/ ' *.() tq!! 5'$5%& $5 5,jc "512, 5*.5/ $ u:0," 5 589:?): 25) $=& <> $=& A,5B $=5&?%5 *'& $ " +* $=& D5> A9(5) 9C A9() $$ $1< 2 + $& ) E + " $ "9/ >! H%& $ +,! G(: *'&.( F $ 52, 52 5I -* $= $=& $5 $5K 5+*.5 $=5& 5* 5 J%& 5= F5&A5* * 5=2 -L $ $K B -L $5= B F92N& M(& "). B >2,.( 6 P O+ $ 5 R5 "5) 5 5+* QI -9 T85.S5B A5, +* -! FS5 G5O "5 5%* A,,") (V ) $B " [5' +* -! $Z.(1) XY 5 $=5& -! $L> \S 9(B ^ $ " +* $<]) $5< R $ $= 5(<& 5S "5Q( 5 ^QB $5= _95 P [% $ < > F9 b5& 5! 5 "5I 29 ^L $ '.(2) c ) 553 >552 T5 V5 15+Sc 5,%I d5<1 c B +* -! $ , ( 9C $29 -L $,5 2>, ^: e5b 0,2 -! F9I G%O ^L 5'K 5,.(3) 52 F9 b5& 5 B R& R& $'9 $=, +* -! 5 c $=& 9.9c B 2) F5 $5 5 5c $=5& $ 9 $ g 23

3 $5/ l.,jc F, 2>./.5/.55 t5q! "5QQ/ 5 $5 {5 '5 $=08 3*x ^ +, 5 5 F5 $5 5 5 $O B5 $=5& 5 5* H%& F99%& T& 5N $5= +* -! +*./ F "'+ "%! -3 $ 5 S5 5+ 5' g %> $. G9I ; _' + = "50 "5 $ '0) Ls _ (15+Sc F95QQ/ T85-5 J& 5<> 5 -+S F5& 5'K 3*x S F95'y2, 15+Sc 5<>, $+ 59: $5'9 F5 5%! "5'+ "5 5'$5%& $5)( 5 ^ m/ $ F&A* 5 $5 +* -! 9=P $5 52> R5+Sc $5 F'> m!+ 9, 5 $ R+S} $ mq/ R+Sc $5 $ $! $ R+Sc9c $ -5)Y $ &c S $ /%& S $5 5* $5 59* c $ ;=B $5 5+* $!, L ;=B /& 5+* S5 ~1= $5 *5+ 5 +* S F9'y2, +* $! $ 5) $=5& ls5 $5 '5+ $55<2 &55(9(:& [55 (8) 55: $55B (11) 55>S 9 ^55< \ " 55 (10) "559 (9) *55+ (TOPSIS) N3*.+ 5 5* 5'$5 5, 5 w5c 5,;5 51 $5 5B w9)c& ; '$%& $5 "5 $<L n.'!c " +* "5 5+*./, m!+ $ u:0 "5)9 " 2 [) ; $%& "'2 ".(4) B I! ")K< $55)( 55'$55%& 55P.,j55c v55, - 5! +*./ "0 ","*+ m!5+ 59, $5c 5 w95)c& l $5 5+* 5+* - 5! 5+* 9=P '+.+ $5 + [ * '$%& ","*+ 5 F5& 5 "@59 "S$ $ +* -! $=& H,$ $59.'5+ $+ B $& "*+, 9=P "5 5 5+*, " G9(:& F 15+Sc <> $0: dx "0 " +*./ $ H,$ F& M5: $5 $ ) $2, "0 " F9'y2, 5' 5* "50 "5 5+* - 5! d5</.2 R2 '+ / + -55(9(:& 55 v55, 553.,j55c F55-69L& z l 3 9 I 9=5P 5,5j 5 $ $. <9<:& - 5! 5+*.5/ 5), $5 $5" A J+ c +* $ 69L& z, I 5+*./ $ H F99%& '+ 5'+ "QQ/ +* -!.5+5?): S9 <9<:& z * - 5! 5+*.5/ 5 $5= ) "50 "5, "*+ (+, $<)< "60!!<c ; 24

4 9= 5'K 59A925Q& 5,l '$(%O.+ $5B, 'K) $ $ z2 $ [9&& F 5'K 5 5,;5.5+ A9)(& ($Q!+ 'K ;5.'5+ 5% 9C % F12 $Q!+ 5I 5% 5,; w95)c& 5'K 59A925Q& ;5 F959%& w5c (15) ?5/ ;5 5 $5 B $Q!+ w95)c& R9'1&. B w9)c& l 6 56' 5% ; ^ $'S $<LB, ; ^ $ %) 1S FB $<9 $ " S2,.(16) + R9'1& F -I H( $ ',%5+ l 65 ^ (1), FK 59A925Q& $<]5) R5 5B ; $'S $ : $Z + $ $'S ^5 m 9= 9= 'K A92Q& w& ^91& (1,9= " w& F99=& (2 B A92Q& w& " ~9( (3 " B A92Q& w& F99=& (4 (FPIS, A * ) 5B ; 5 ^ FB (5 (FPIS, A + ) n B ; P B ; P ; $<LB $%: (6,%+ m!+ $%: ( m!5+ "S59 $ $& :,$'S '$%& (8 $5 5O $ '$5%& 5,$'S,%+. I 0,%+ m!+,$'s /0# $5!c $ R59'1& 5;5 l 595* w} + $5%& (FTOPSIS) 5B ;5 $5'S $5,%5+ -%> ^%& "c.+ F99=&,"*+ 5 ;5 $5, " & g B > $ 5.5!c n5 5* ^59<:& $ B 59= 59= ;5 5'K 59A925Q& 5'B F5.5 [',9= 5'K 59A925Q& 5 F5&A5*?/!'+ ;5 $58( $'S R $<LB FB 3 > S59 5B 6' 5 5/ $5'S $ '= 5B 5% 56' ; $8( " $<LB B % ; F $ E+ $B 3 ^ $<LB F2 ;5 ^5 $<LB F& ; F9> $5Q!+ 5'K 9A92Q&,;.+ B 3 % F!c F2P $ 680 $B B F G8'.(12) + 8 5> [5 B,$>2 $5 9=8I 5]& <5L ->5) d=p ) 16& * $ ]& "'> :& > " (> $ ]& F * 5I 5, " "5 " 5& 5B,$>2 5> 5* $5 _5I "5* 5,5c 5 A*%.(13) 595 $5<2 5 5= 5I =8I 5,A5)9 B G8' 5;5 9A92Q&.(14) 6 ^I 5+ $!'+ F'> 1 9= 'K 9A92Q&.5 $<]5) 25+ $5 9A92Q&,A)9,l R5 ^ I [5<C B G58' A,B 9= 'K 9A92Q& 5B G9I 9C, 9= 'K 9A92Q& ^Z) 5 =I 9 9A92Q& J+ R.'), 5 5&5 9= 5'K 59A92Q& ;2=,l $5>2,9= ^90 $ + <2> : 5 F $5-5>O G59I 59C (MODM) $=5& 5B $5B, 5'K 59A92Q&,l (MADM) 5B $Q!+ 'K 9A92Q& 25

5 "'> A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A A8 A9 A10 A11 A12 A13 A14 A15 A16 A1 A18 1 % h% >J0&, /M&.2YD m!+ (6 S,, $) 2> R+Sc $ (6 S,, $) mq/ R+Sc $ (6 S,, $) R+Sc" $ (6 S,, $) $ (6 S,, $) R+Sc9c $ (6 S,, $) $! $ (6 S,, $) $ * $ (6 S, L, $) /%& S $ (6 S, L, $) &c S $ (6 S, L, $)("29);=B -)Y $ (6 S,, $) ;=B /& $ (6 S,, $) 9* c $ (6 S,, $) *+ +* S $ (6 S,, $) +* S $ ( 6 S,, $) +* $! $ +* $!, L (6 S,, $) 9 \ ~1= > + % H = i#=* LLj.3YD ~1= B > (1 1 1) (2/3 1 2) (1/2 2/3 1) (2/5 1/2 2/3) (1/3 2/5 1/2) (2/ 1/3 2/5) < B > (1 1 1) (1/2 1 3/2) (1 3/2 2) (3/2 2 5/2) (2 5/2 3) (5/2 3 /2) -%> ) (9I 92, &A* 2 &A* &A* <9! &A* <9! &A* d %> [0I * -3 "%!,-NI B ^5%&.5+ ^5%& B > $ + " ; B > $ -%> $%5Q 92, '0. n5.b@5c -5L 5%! "5'+ 5N $55 "55 "55' '% 55 55," F59 A15 A13 A12 A11 A2 A1 5 5$+ m!+ 9, F9 92, A16 A9 5 $ H 92, "S9 /$01 >J0&,.1YD Q! City1 City2 City3 City4 City5 City6 City City8 City9 City10 "*+ 90!<c! "60 $<)< +,. F2 d A18 % 0+ C% ) /$01 #1>%=*.2 +. (01% & 2./ /M& 3# >

6 0/36,%5+ m!+ (City10) +, "*+ 5+* 9=5P t5q! 35*x 3' $ m!5+ 5 (City4)!5<c "5*+ A6, R5 "50 "5 5,"*+ +* -! "5560 "55*+ A55, 55 0/316,%55+ 5 $ ZS ;Y5 5< ;Y A55* 55 0/284,%55+ m! /283,%5+ m!5+ 5 (City8) (City6) "5*+.B I! A, "5 $<L n G9(:& ZS -gy $ c 5 tq!! "*+ $ 5,m!5+ t5q! "*+ A14 5,m!5+ t5q! "*+ A14 t555q! $<555)< "555*+ A "5*+ A1 A1 A5 A4 A1 A14 A11 A4 A12 A10 A A2 A A4 A13 A10 555,m!555+ t555q! 5,m!5+ tq! "*+ 5 tq! +, "*+ A14 t5q!!5<c "5*+ A12 "560 "*+ A1 A1 A4 A2 A14 A10 A6 A4 A3 A12 A10 A9 A8 A11 A10 A4 5 tq! 5 tq! "*+!g 555 $555 %555) A13 A12 A11 A10 A9 A6.5 5I 5&F95c T85 $, "5 5,"*+ T8 d=p F9 z2 +*./ "0 ","*+ '$%& '), +* -!.5/ "50 "5 5,"5*+ '$%& ^5L n5 ~5 5 5+* -! +*.+ ; + $ B w9)c& ^9<:& /$01 01% & 21% >3# 2C`.4 YD,%+ m!+ 0/46 0/466 0/462 0/450 0/438 0/30 0/36 0/316 0/284 0/283 $%& "*+! $<)< 90 +,!<c "60 >'B0 ^;% 5+* 9=5P t5q! 35*x 3' R5 "50 "5 5,"*+ +* -! $5 $<5L n5.+ 8 $ ZS ;Y < ;Y. + A12 A14 A10 A4 5 tq! [9&& $ 5'$5%& $5 H5 $5 5< ;Y5 t5q!. +, A1-5! +*./ "0 ","*+ F95 $)( R $ ZS ;Y tq! (City5)! "*+ $ + m/ +* 5 5,m!5+ 53 "0 ","*+ " 5*+ ; 50 0/46,%5+ m!5+ 5 :$ + m/ 0/466,%+ m!+ (City3) "5 5,"5*+ T8 d=p F9 (d0 0/462,%5+ m!5+ 5 (City1) 5 "5*+ ~ 69L& -L $ "0,%+ m!+ (City9) $<)< "*+ 5 $5 5,m!5+ t5q! [59&& $5 + 6) 55&c S55 $55 ("55*+ 6) 55 6) * * S5 $ ("*+ 5 (City2) 590 "*+ *K 0/450 "*+ A'c 0/438,%+ m!+ A5+ 5 0/30,%5+ m!5+ 5 (City) 2

7 ,"*+ /%& S $ m!+ (".)9 0%I ^I T8!<c "60 "*+ R+Sc" $ m!+ (~. I '9c T8 "560,"*+ $! $ m!+ (z. %?<8 55'$5%& t5q! 5(9I -5=08 5'K, 5+* - 5! $'9 "0 ","*+ 5,$ '% 5*, 2& $+ -5(9(:& n '$%&$=08 (4) (1390) "12, () (1392) "512, (9B5& E5 5,"5 5C"s ","*+ 'T8 tq! E"5 +*! ' * F959=& t5q! (6) (1393) "512, 5BI5L 53 *5+ "5,"*+ B$=& $ (1393) "512, P E +* 5+*.5/ -9*)& $ tq! (5),5 F9 $ * F " " 5 v5! $O *. $+ * $ G%8' 5,m!5+ ~ $ n ~ 59) *'59c $5 "5& ! +* 9=P %* $ R2 (.2 $Z $O -1 _& K +* :9,*'9c -1 5 $5.,j5c F5 n5 FB 3 - " * -551 " 55 _55& 55 *'59c 5 $5=08 5,"*+ 5 5+* " & + F99=&,"*+ '$%& ~.+ $+ " $=& %) ;=& * F95'y2, ("5*+ 4) ;5=B /& $ ("*+ ("5*+ 4) 5+* $5!,5 5L. +, m!5+ 5* 5!,"*+ (?.'), d=p F9 mq/ R+Sc * * S55 m!55+ ( !,"*+. I '9c T8 "60 *5& ^5I d=5p 5 $ ( "560 +, 90,"*+.! t55q! $<55)< 55 55,"55*+ (.'+ d9=p $ m!+ 5 5,"5*+ 5&c S $ ( '95c T8 "60!<c +, $<)<. + ","*+ 9* c $ (. '9c T8!<c +, $<)<,"*+ (.$B I '9c T8 ;=B /& $ 3 5+* $5!, L m!+ (H "560!5<c 590 $<)<,"*+. I '9c T , 90,"*+ ( ("29) ;=B -)Y $ m!+.'+ ^1 "5*+ 52> R5+Sc $5 m!5+ ({. F9c "*+ R+Sc9c $ m!+ (;. *& ^I T8 "55*+ 55* $55 m!55+ (. '9c T8 28

8 M5(& $5 [59&& $! "*+ %* -. 9 $& A2 A14 M5(& $5 [59&& $5 "560 "*+ %* - $55& A1 A6 A3 A10 A14 A4 55,m! M5(& $5 [59&& $5 "5*+ %* -. 9 $& A14 A5 A8 A4 M5(& $5 [59&& $5 "5*+ 5%* 5 - A6 A4 A12 A11 A2 A9 A13 A $& M5(& $5 [59&& $5 $<)< "*+ %* -. 9 $& A A1 A12 A10 M5(& $ [9&& $ +, "*+ %* -. 9 $& A12 A11 A10 A4 +S!"* 5'$5%& 5'+ 5* $5 ) 2& 9&55 t55q/ , 55,m!55+ "5 +* -! +* "3[L. ^2> $ I 1& ;2 "0 z5p F5 F95% $<5L n5 $1' $ $& -!5<c "560 5' 5,"*+ $ > -1 +* -1 3 $5& F90]) $ + *'9c F.'), -5%> m9q/& $+,"*+ F $ j $5&,"*+ F T8 +* -! _& -5%> A5, 5) z5p F5.5'2 9 5I $5&.9c.9 < T8 A,.9 :(),*'9c -2 M5(& $5 [59&& $5 5 "5*+ 5%* $& A13 A10 A14 M5(& $5 [59&& $ 90 "*+ %* -. 9 $& A11 A1 A14 A4 M5(& $5 [59&& $5 "*+ %* -. 9 $& A A14 A4 M5(& $5 [59&& $5!<c "*+ %* -. 9 $& A10 A1 A12 A9 29

9 References 1. Haghparast H, Moeini E. Health Economics: Views and Theories. Soc Security. 2004; 12(16): Ahmadi AM, Mohammadqhaffari H, Emadi SJ. The relationship between economics macro variables and health in Iran. Soc Security. 2010; 10(9): Mansouri-Sales M. Determining development index of cities in Tehran Province. MA Thesis, Shahid Beheshti University Tahari-Mehrjerdi MH, Babaei-Meibodi H, Morvati Sharifabadi A. Ranking provinces I.R. Iran in terms of health indexes. Health Information Manag. 2012; 9(3): Rezaee S, Ghazanfari S, Kazemi Zh, Kazemi-Karyani A. Availability of health section facilities (A case study in Kermanshah Provinc). J Kermanshah Univ Med Sci. 2014; 18(): Sadeqhifar J, Seidin SH, Anjom-Shoaa M, Rajabi-Wasokolae Gh, Moosavi SM, Armon B. Determining development index of cities in Booshehr Province in trems of health indexes using numerical taxonomy. J Razi Univ Med Sci. 2014; 21(11): Tofighi Sh, Hamoozadeh P, Moradizadeh H, Sadeqhifar J. Leveling of the cities of West Azarbayjan province in using structural indicators of health and treatment. J Qazvin Univ Med Sci. 2013; 1(2): UN human development report (tables and selected text). Translated by Memarzadeh Q. Organization of Planning and Budjet. 2003; Shahdadi H. Application of social and economic indexes in development planning. Tehran: Organization of Planning and Budjet of Tehran. 2003; 33(4): Borzooian S. Determining development index of Mazandaran cities. MA Thesis, Tarbiat Modares University. 1995; Mazroei R. Determining development index of Isfahan cities. MA Thesis. Shahid Beheshti University. 1994; Zarghami M, Szidarovszky F. Stochasticfuzzy multi criteria decision making for robust water resources management. Stochastic Environ Res Risk Assess. 2009; 23: Ravanshadnia M, Bozorgmehr MA. Multi factor fuzzy decision making. Tehran: Simaye Danesh Pub. 2014; Ghazanfari M, Rezaei M. An introduction to theorizing fuzzy systems. Tehran: Science and Technology University Pub. 2010; Asgharpoor MJ. Multi factor decision making. 2 nd ed. Tehran: Tehran University Pub. 2002; Srdjevic B, Medeiros YDP, Faria AS. An Objective Multi-Criteria Evaluation of Water Management Scenarios. Water Resources Manage. 2004; 18: Chen SJ, Hwang LC. Fuzzy Multiple Attribute Decision Making: Methods and Applications. Berlin: Springer Verlag Pub. 2008;

10 Ranking and comparison of health and health services in cities of Lorestan province using TOPSIS method Nezami A *1, Purrashno F 2, Mir A 3 1. Department of Management, Khorramabad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Khorramabad, Iran, a.nezami1998@gmil.com Received: 24 Feb 2018 Accepted: 1 April 2018 Abstract Background: In spite of the great importance of health and health services, the imbalance in distribution of such services has always been one of the main problems of planners. This research was carried out with the aim of ranking and comparing health and health services in cities in Lorestan province. Materials and Methods: Data was collected from books and documents, and from experts in the field of health and health services. To do this, 18 indicators of health and related services were selected, and ranked utilizing the fuzzy TOPSIS method. Results: Results showed that there were significant differences among the cities under investigation, in terms of health services. Khorramabad ranked first for similarity index and Boroujerd ranked second (similarity index= 0.466). Also, Delfan and Dooreh came 9 th and 10 th, with a similarity index of and , respectively. Conclusion: According to the analysis, the main weaknesses in the province were the pharmacist's per capita indices, per capita radiography centers, per capita urban health centers, per capita active beds, as well as the percentage of health centers in villages. Key words: Health, Health services, Fuzzy TOPSIS, Lorestan Province. *Citation: Nezami A, purrashno F, Mir A, Ranking and comparing Lorestan Province cities in terms of health and health services using the TOPSIS method. Yafte. 2018; 20(2):