SUMMARY. EDRi's recommendations for vote on amendments: Amendments regarding... SUPPORT OPPOSE

Transcription

1 European Digital Rights (EDRi) is an umbrella organisation which represents 33 civil rights associations from 9 European countries, protecting digital freedom. Following our work with eight committees, EDRi would like to make recommendations of vote [] in order to ensure that our red lines are respected in the TTIP Resolution, subject to debate on 7 July and vote on 8 July 05. SUMMARY EDRi's recommendations for vote on amendments: Amendments regarding... SUPPORT OPPOSE Data Protection 4, 53, 73 and Privacy 00 "Intellectual Property" 8 (or 69); 3 and 09 ISDS 7 or 06; Alternatively, 4 and 5; 9, 40, 7, 07 and 08 6 and 6 Regulatory Cooperation 7, 0, 9, 56, 88, 95 and 98 6 and 97 Transparency & Democracy 4,, 4, 5, 4, 70, 76 Human Rights clauses 5, 80, 8 and 3 EDRi's recommendations regarding split votes requested are: - On Data Protection:, point b, point xii st part: nd part: Text as a whole excluding the words "as a key point" these words - On Regulatory Cooperation:, point c, point i st part: nd part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to include cross-cutting disciplines... for goods and services" these words []EDRi is especially grateful for comments received by our members Access and Vrijschrift in the preparation of this analysis. European Digital Rights 0 Rue Belliard, 040 Bruxelles, Belgium Tel

2 TABLING SERVICE INDICATIVE VOTING LIST FINAL VERSION Report: LANGE (A8-075/05) [init.] Negotiations for the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) Committee: Committee on International Trade Subject of the amendment Am No Author RCV etc. Vote Remarks Before 43 EPP 77 RCV - adoption 77 = /3 fall Greens/ EFA RCV + adoption = 3 falls Transparency and Democracy 3 EFDD RCV, point a, point i 78, point a, after point i 79 RCV 80 RCV + Human Rights 8 RCV + Human Rights, point a, point ii ECR RCV 8 RCV, point a, point iii 83 RCV, point a, after point v 3 EFDD RCV, point b, point ii 84 RCV adoption 84 = 46 falls 46 EPP 3, point b, point iii 45 EPP split, point b, point v 3 Greens/ EFA, EFDD, RCV

3 , point b, point vi 34 EFDD RCV, point b, after point vi 35 EFDD RCV 36 EFDD RCV, point b, point vii, point b, point viii 85D RCV - adoption 85 = 86 falls 86 RCV + Data Protection, point b, point ix, point b, after point ix 87 RCV, point b, point xi 89 RCV, point b, after point xi 4 Greens/ EFA 90 RCV, point b, point xii MEPs - adoption 50 = 4 falls Data Protection 4 EFDD RCV + Data Protection + Data Protection + Data Protection, point b, point xviii 5 Greens/ EFA + Human Rights 9 RCV, point b, after point xx 6 Greens/ EFA RCV, point b, after point xxii 9 RCV 3

4 , point c, point i ECR 88 RCV + Regulatory cooperation + Regulatory cooperation - Regulatory cooperation, point c, after point i 7= 37= Greens/ EFA EFDD RCV 93 RCV adoption 93 = 8 falls 8 Greens/ EFA 94 RCV, point c, point ii 38 EFDD RCV - adoption 38 = 95 falls 95 RCV + Regulatory cooperation, point c, after point ii 9 Greens/ EFA RCV 39 EFDD RCV 96 RCV, point c, after point iii 97 - Regulatory cooperation, point c, point iv 98 RCV + Regulatory cooperation, point c, after point iv 99 RCV, point c, after point v 00 RCV + Privacy, point d, point i 3 ECR, point d, point ii 0 RCV, point d, point iii 0 Greens/ EFA RCV, point d, point vi 0 RCV, point d, point vii 03D RCV adoption 03 = 47 falls 47 EPP, point d, after point vii Greens/ EFA 4

5 , point d, point viii 04 RCV, point d, after point viii Greens/ EFA RCV, point d, point x 05D RCV, point d, point xiv 40 EFDD RCV + ISDS, point d, after point xiv 07 RCV + ISDS 08 RCV + ISDS, point d, point xv, intro 06cp RCV + adoption 06 = 7 falls ISDS 7cp 40+MEPs RCV + ISDS original text RCV - ISDS, point d, point xv, indent 7cp=D 06cp= D 4=D 40+MEPS S&D RCV + ISDS, point d, point xv, indent 7cp=D 06cp= D 40+MEPS RCV + ISDS, point d, point xv, indent 3 7cp=D 06cp= D 40+MEPS RCV + adoption 7/06 = 5/6 fall ISDS 5 S&D RCV + adoption 5 = 6 falls ISDS 6 EPP RCV - ISDS, point d, point xv, indent 4 7cp=D 06cp= D 40+MEPS RCV + adoption 7/06 = 6 falls ISDS 6 S&D RCV - ISDS, point d, point xvi 09 RCV + adoption 09 = 3 falls Intellectual Property 3 Greens/ EFA + Intellectual Property, point d, point xix 0 RCV, point e, point i 4 Greens/ EFA + Transparency and Democracy, point e, point iii 5 Greens/ EFA + Transparency and Democracy, point e, after point iii RCV 5

6 , point e, after point iv 4 EFDD RCV + Transparency and Democracy, after point e RCV 3 RCV + Human Rights After citation 5 RCV 5 RCV Before recital A 54 RCV Recital A 55 RCV After recital A 53 RCV + Data Protection 56= 0= Greens/ EFA RCV + Regulatory Cooperation 57 RCV 58 RCV adoption 58 = 7 falls 7 Greens/ EFA 59 RCV 60 RCV Recital B 6 RCV After recital B 6 RCV Recital E 63 RCV 3 After recital E 4 Greens/ EFA + Transparency and Democracy Recital F 66 RCV After recital F 67 RCV 68 RCV 69= 8= Greens/ EFA RCV + Intellectual Property 6

7 After recital G 5 Greens/ EFA 6 Greens/ EFA - Regulatory Cooperation 70 RCV + Transparency and Democracy 7 RCV + ISDS After recital H 73 RCV + Data Protection Recital I 74 RCV After recital I 9 Greens/ EFA 44 EPP Recital J 48D 40+MEPs Recital K 75 RCV adoption 75 = 49 falls MEPs Recital M 76 RCV + Transparency and Democracy After recital N Greens/ EFA Recital P 9 EFDD RCV + ISDS After recital P 30 EFDD RCV vote: resolution (as a whole) RCV + If all suggestions, in line with EDRi red lines, are followed - If suggestions are not respected =identical amendments D=Deleting amendment vote "FOR"=delete text vote "AGAINST"=maintain text There is no vote on the original text Amendment 8 has been withdrawn Amendment 33 has been cancelled Amendment 7 has been withdrawn Requests for roll-call votes ECR ams, 6, 7, 40, 06, 4, 5, 6 and, point d, point xv ams 7, 5 to 63, 66 to 70, 7 to 77, 79 to 96, 98 to 6 EFDD ams 9 to 3, 34 to 4 Greens/ EFA ams, 3, 6, 7, 9, 0,, 6 and 7 7

8 ALDE, point d, point xv EPP ams 6, 7, 40, 06, 4, 5 and 6 Requests for split votes ECR am 45 st part: nd part: Text as a whole excluding the words "carbon-leakage" these words EFDD, point c, point i st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to include cross-cutting disciplines... for goods and services" nd part: these words Greens/ EFA, point c, point i st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to include cross-cutting disciplines... for goods and services" nd part: these words, point c, point ii st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to aim in the first place... permanent import measure" nd part: these words S&D, point b, point v st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "a 'hybrid list approach', using for market access" and without "and using 'negative list approach' for national treatment" nd part: these words EPP, point b, point ii st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "all" and without "noting that CETA could be a good point of reference in this regard" nd part: "all" 3rd part: "noting that CETA could be a good point of reference in this regard", point b, point vii st part: "to build on the joint... EU's negotiating mandate" nd part: "this exclusion should apply irrespective of how the services are provided and funded", point b, point ix st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to increase, in the context of the negociations, political pressure on the US" nd part: these words, point b, point xii st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "as a key point" nd part: these words Recital E 8

9 st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "up to 40% of European industrial products are manufactured from imported upstream products" and without "whereas since industrial production will increasingly take place in global value chains and" nd part: "up to 40% of European industrial products are manufactured from imported upstream products" 3rd part: "whereas since industrial production will increasingly take place in global value chains and" VOTING SCHEME, point c, point i st part: Text as a whole excluding the words "to include cross-cutting disciplines... for goods and services" nd part: these words 9