IN THE COMPETITION TRIBUNAL REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA. Case No: 14/LM/Feb00. In the large merger between: Santam Limited. and
|
|
- Lizbeth Louise Small
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 IN THE COMPETITION TRIBUNAL REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA Case No: 14/LM/Feb00 In he large merger beween: Sanam Limied and Guardian Naional Insurance Company Limied Reasons for Compeiion Tribunal s Decision Approval 1. We approved he merger beween Sanam Limied ( Sanam ) and Guardian Naional Insurance Company Limied ( Guardian Naional ) wihou condiions on 4 April The reasons for our decision follow below. The Merger Transacion 2. The ransacion involved Sanam acquiring he enire issued share capial of Guardian Naional from Guardian Naional s shareholders, which included Libery Life Associaion of Africa Ld ( Libery ) and GRE Souh Africa Holdings (Py) Ld ( Gresa ). Prior o his ransacion Libery and Gresa held 40.8% and 52.56% of Guardian Naional s shares. The holding company of Gresa, AXA S.A., was a pary o he merger agreemen and a paricipan in he merger hearing. Evaluaion of he Merger The Relevan Marke 3. Boh Sanam and Guardian Naional are regisered shor erm insurers in erms of he Shor Term Insurance Ac 53 of 1998 and are auhorized in erms of he Ac o carry on shor erm insurance business under all he classes of policies provided
2 2 for in Secion 67 he Ac1. As a resul, here is a direc produc overlap beween he businesses of he wo firms. However, he wo firms concenrae on differen classes of producs: Sanam focuses on personal insurance producs, while Guardian Naional focuses more on insurance for corporaes and group schemes2 4. There are a leas hree approaches o defining he relevan produc marke in his merger: (a) (b) (c) Defining a separae marke for each ype of shor erm insurance produc; Defining a single marke for all shor erm insurance producs; and Defining a separae marke for differen clusers of shor erm insurance producs. 5. The Commission s analysis of he merger concenraed on he firs wo of hese approaches, alhough heir repor did in passing menion he possibiliy of a relevan marke based on clusers. 6. The firs approach is consisen wih inernaional pracice in respec of mergers in he shor erm insurance indusry. This pracice is o define a separae relevan marke for each ype of risk covered3. Such a definiion recognizes ha insurance cover for a paricular risk is a disinc produc, which is no subsiuable from he cusomer s poin of view for cover in respec of any oher risk for insance fire cover canno be subsiued for burglary cover. 7. In he presen case, he Commission used he produc classes provided for under he repealed Insurance Ac, 1943 as he basis for defining a produc marke based on his concep of a separae marke for each risk caegory. The repealed Ac recognized six produc classes, as opposed o he eigh esablished under he new Ac, o which we referred in paragraph 3 above. The six produc classes under he repealed Ac are fire, marine, moor, personal acciden, guaranee and miscellaneous. The Commission appear o have chosen he produc classificaion of he repealed Ac raher han he classificaion esablished under he new Ac in order o use hisorical (1998) informaion on marke shares in heir analysis. 8. The broader definiion based on a single marke for all shor erm insurance producs may neverheless also be jusifiable if sufficien supply side subsiuion beween he various produc classes is possible i.e. if insurers ha only paricipae in cerain of he classes are able o swich from providing one ype of 1 The Ac currenly provides for eigh classes of policies: acciden and healh, engineering, guaranee, liabiliy, miscellaneous, moor, propery, and ransporaion. 2 See Figure 2 a p. 40 of he Compeiion Commission s repor. 3 See for example he approach of he European Commission in Allianz/AGF (Case no. IV/M.1082); Commerial Union/General Acciden (Case no. IV/M.1142); CU Ialia/Banca Delle Marche/JV (Case no. IV/M.1627).
3 3 cover o providing anoher ype of cover or are able o exend heir produc lines o include oher caegories of cover. Alhough we have no been presened wih sufficien informaion o evaluae he exen of supply side subsiuion in he indusry in any deail, he evidence on enry condiions, o which we will refer in more deail below, suggess ha he supply side srucure of he marke may indeed suppor a produc definiion based on a single produc marke for all shorerm insurance producs. 9. The remaining marke definiion, which was no pursued by he Commission, is based on he general idea ha a separae produc marke exiss for various combinaions of he disinc produc caegories. This would be he case if consumers of shor erm insurance producs showed a preference for insurance policies ha covered more han one ype of risk. The Commission advised us ha some of he brokers ha hey inerviewed had confirmed ha consumers do in fac normally seek combinaion insurance i.e. cover for a number of differen risks under a single policy. Defining he relevan marke in erms of specific clusers would, however, lead o a myriad of relevan markes due o he large number of differen combinaions of risk ha can be incorporaed under a single policy. Due o limied informaion, we have defined a surrogae cluser marke insead of defining a separae marke for each cluser permuaion. Our surrogae marke focuses on he supply side of he marke and includes all insurers ha are in a posiion o offer clusered producs. In his case, we have included all insurers ha are regisered in all or mos of he produc classes provided for in he repealed Ac. 10. We do no have sufficien informaion o deermine which of hese approaches o defining he relevan produc marke is he mos appropriae for analyzing his merger. We have herefore considered he merger s effec on compeiion based on all hree approaches. In any even, as is clear from our analysis below, he choice of produc marke definiion is no deerminaive of our decision in his merger. 11. We agree wih he Commission s recommendaion ha he relevan geographic marke for shor erm insurance producs in Souh Africa is a naional marke. Unlike mos reail producs, insurance producs are no sold o consumers hrough reail oules a specific locaions. Raher, consumers rely on a naionwide nework of brokers who source insurance cover from insurers naionwide. The geographic marke does no exend beyond he naional boundaries because legislaion requires insurers who operae wihin he counry o be licensed here. Consumers can accordingly no source shor erm insurance inernaionally. Marke Concenraion
4 4 12. Table 1 conains he pre merger marke shares of firms in he six relevan markes based on produc classes. The column on he exreme righ gives he marke shares in he single marke for all shor erm insurance producs. The pos merger marke share of he merged eniy in each of hese markes is shown in Table 2. Table 1 Insurer Fire Marine Moor Personal Acciden Guarane e Miscel. Toal Mu. & Fed Sanam GNI CGU SA Eagle (a) Ohers Toal Source: Fich IBCA Saisical Repor (Augus 1999) and draf 1998 FSB Repor (Table 4 in he Compeiion Commission s recommendaion) (a) The oher caegory comprised more han sixy small firms wih very small markes shares. Table 2 Marke Share Fire Marin e Moor Personal Acciden Guarane e Miscel Source: FSB, Regisrar of Shor Term Insurance, Annual Repor, 1998 (Table 7 of Compeiion Commission s recommendaion) mainly Toal Shor erm insurance 13. The marke shares in Tables 1 and 2 ranslae ino low o moderae pre merger concenraion levels in mos of he produc markes, as refleced in Tables 3 and 4. However, he increase in concenraion in mos of he markes following he merger will be subsanial. Table 3 Concenrai on Fire Marine Moor Personal Acciden Guaranee Miscel.
5 5 Pre (a) HHI in HHI Source: FSB, Regisrar of Shor Term Insurance, Annual Repor (Table 7 of Compeiion Commission s recommendaion) (a) Herfindahl Hirschman Index4 Table 4 Po s 87 7 Shorerm Insurance Source: Compeiion Commission Recommendaion, Table 10 a p. 28 Pre merger HHI in HHI Pos merger HHI 14. Marke concenraion in he surrogae marke for clusers, which we defined in paragraph 9 above, can be roughly esimaed wih reference o he marke shares of hose insurers regisered in all or mos of he six policy classes. According o Financial Services Board records, as a 30 June 1999 more han wo hirds of he 90 regisered shor erm insurers were regisered in all six produc classes, and many of he remaining insurers were regisered in hree or more of hose classes. The marke for clusers should herefore no be much narrower han he marke based on all shor erm insurance producs. This mean ha he level of concenraion in his marke, and increase in concenraion as a resul of he merger, is likely o be only slighly higher han in he marke based on all shorerm insurance producs. 15. In summary, while marke concenraion afer he merger will be moderaely high in mos of he markes considered, he increase in concenraion will be relaively high5. The only marke ha will be highly concenraed afer he merger is he narrow marke for guaranee insurance. However, his marke was highly concenraed before he merger as well and he increase in concenraion as a resul of he merger is quie small. Effec on Compeiion 16. Despie he relaively high increase in concenraion in mos of he relevan 4 According o he US Merger Guidelines (1992, as revised in 1997) a marke wih pos merger HHI of beween 0 and 1000 poins is considered o be unconcenraed; a marke wih pos merger HHI of beween 1000 and 1800 poins is considered o be moderaely concenraed; a marke wih pos merger HHI above 1800 poins is considered o be highly concenraed. 5 The US Merger Guidelines consider an HHI increase of more han 100 poins in a merger ha leads o a moderae level of concenraion as a relaively large increase in concenraion.
6 6 markes, he srucural and dynamic characerisics of he shor erm insurance indusry in Souh Africa sugges ha he merger is unlikely o significanly resric compeiion in hese markes. 17. The role played by independen insurance brokers as inermediaries beween consumers and insurers is a paricularly significan characerisic of he indusry from a compeiion perspecive. According o he Commission s repor, more han 95% of insurance business is conduced hrough independen brokers. These brokers receive requess for insurance cover from cusomers and hen shop around for he bes producs available from insurers in erms of price and produc characerisics. Because brokers have exensive knowledge of he indusry and are well informed abou produc choices and marke condiions, his arrangemen conribues o a compeiive marke for shor erm insurance producs. 18. The manner in which brokers are remuneraed suppors he pro compeiive role broker inermediaion plays in his indusry. They are remuneraed in a manner which boh encourages consumers o use brokerage services o source insurance cover as well as encourages brokers o pursue he bes ineress of cusomers in doing so. Consumers are encouraged o use brokers as inermediaries because hey do no hemselves pay for he brokers services; he insurer whose produc is evenually chosen by he consumer pays he broker a commission. Moreover, insurers are prohibied by legislaion from paying brokers an incenive bonus. This measure seeks o ensure ha he fac ha brokers are remuneraed by insurers does no encourage brokers o esablish a comforable relaionship wih any given insurer and hus reduce compeiion beween insurers. Insead, brokers incenives in recommending an insurer are direced a proecing heir clien base hrough saisfacory cusomer service. 19. The broker s role as inermediary beween he cusomer and insurer effecively consolidaes he buying power of cusomers and should herefore conribue significanly owards counervailing he poenial marke power esablished by moderae o high concenraion levels on he supply side of he markes. This conclusion is consisen wih he findings of he European Commission in insurance mergers Furhermore, he increase in concenraion in he markes arrived a on he basis of simply summing he marke shares of he merging firms probably overesimaes he rue increase, because his approach does no ake ino accoun he run off ha could be expeced as a resul of he merger. The merging firms esimaed ha hey sood o lose up o 15% of heir combined marke share afer he merger. They aribued his o wo facors: he pracice by brokers of sourcing insurance producs from a number of differen insurers; and he effec of uncerainy afer he merger on service levels. Alhough he exen o which hese facors will 6 See for example Allianz/AGF (Case no. IV/M. 1082) a par. 33.
7 7 conribue o he merged eniy losing marke share is difficul o quanify, he pracice by some brokers of using a shor lis of insurers wih which hey place heir business suppors he view ha a cerain amoun of run off will resul from he merger if boh merging firms appeared on a broker s shor lis before he merger, an addiional firm would now be included on is lis afer implemenaion of he ransacion, which could resul in less business being placed wih he merged firm han he combined amoun of business placed wih he wo merging firms prior o he merger. 21. Anoher facor ha enhances compeiion in he shor erm insurance markes is he ease wih which cusomers are able o move heir business from one insurer o anoher. According o a number of brokers inerviewed by he Commission, he exisence of claim reducing measures such as so called no claim bonuses does no resric cusomers from moving beween insurers since hese bonuses are generally ransferable beween insurers. 22. Apar from regulaory requiremens, here do no appear o be significan barriers o enry ino any of he shor erm insurance markes. The mos significan regulaory requiremen is ha regisraion in erms of he Shor Term Insurance Ac, 53 of 1998 is required o gain access o he indusry. The Ac prescribes a number of requiremens for regisraion mainly of a prudenial naure, none of which are paricularly onerous. The large number of smaller firms ha have enered he marke recenly suppors he view ha barriers o enry o he shorerm insurance markes are no significan The exisence of a highly compeiive environmen in he shor erm insurance indusry is verified by commens made in inernal managemen documens of Guardian Naional, which were prepared for purposes unrelaed o noificaion of he merger. A background documen for a Business Review and Budge Meeing held on 2 November 1998 menions he aggressive markeing campaigns of compeiors who were engaging in fierce price compeiion, saing ha compeiion from new and exising players [was] making i increasingly difficul o reain cliens. 24. Based on he above, we conclude ha his merger is unlikely o subsanially preven or lessen compeiion in any of he relevan markes. We herefore need no consider he long lis of mainly unsubsaniaed efficiency gains claimed by he merging firms. Dae: 3 May See Table 13 a page 34 of he Commission s repor.
8 8 N.M. Manoim D. H Lewis and S. Zilwa concurred.
Introduction. Enterprises and background. chapter
NACE: High-Growh Inroducion Enerprises and background 18 chaper High-Growh Enerprises 8 8.1 Definiion A variey of approaches can be considered as providing he basis for defining high-growh enerprises.
More informationPortfolio investments accounted for the largest outflow of SEK 77.5 billion in the financial account, which gave a net outflow of SEK billion.
BALANCE OF PAYMENTS DATE: 27-11-27 PUBLISHER: Saisics Sweden Balance of Paymens and Financial Markes (BFM) Maria Falk +46 8 6 94 72, maria.falk@scb.se Camilla Bergeling +46 8 6 942 6, camilla.bergeling@scb.se
More informationEffective from 1 April Version 1.0
Saemen of charges for he provision of Legacy Meering Equipmen by Norhern Powergrid (Yorkshire) plc and by Norhern Powergrid (Norheas) Limied Effecive from 1 April 2015 Version 1.0 Norhern Powergrid (Yorkshire)
More information2. Quantity and price measures in macroeconomic statistics 2.1. Long-run deflation? As typical price indexes, Figure 2-1 depicts the GDP deflator,
1 2. Quaniy and price measures in macroeconomic saisics 2.1. Long-run deflaion? As ypical price indexes, Figure 2-1 depics he GD deflaor, he Consumer rice ndex (C), and he Corporae Goods rice ndex (CG)
More information(1 + Nominal Yield) = (1 + Real Yield) (1 + Expected Inflation Rate) (1 + Inflation Risk Premium)
5. Inflaion-linked bonds Inflaion is an economic erm ha describes he general rise in prices of goods and services. As prices rise, a uni of money can buy less goods and services. Hence, inflaion is an
More informationBalance of Payments. Second quarter 2012
Balance of Paymens Second quarer 2012 Balance of Paymens Second quarer 2012 Saisics Sweden 2012 Balance of Paymens. Second quarer 2012 Saisics Sweden 2012 Producer Saisics Sweden, Balance of Paymens and
More informationFinal Exam Answers Exchange Rate Economics
Kiel Insiu für Welwirhschaf Advanced Sudies in Inernaional Economic Policy Research Spring 2005 Menzie D. Chinn Final Exam Answers Exchange Rae Economics This exam is 1 ½ hours long. Answer all quesions.
More informationCh. 10 Measuring FX Exposure. Is Exchange Rate Risk Relevant? MNCs Take on FX Risk
Ch. 10 Measuring FX Exposure Topics Exchange Rae Risk: Relevan? Types of Exposure Transacion Exposure Economic Exposure Translaion Exposure Is Exchange Rae Risk Relevan?? Purchasing Power Pariy: Exchange
More information2. Remittances, other than dividends, by business entities to be made against invoices consistent with bills of entry collected by ZRA.
,, ;., Tel. (260 1) 228888 /228903-20 BANK OF ZAMBIA P.O. Box 30080, f~: Fax: (260 1) 237070 LUSAKA 10101 ' r f~. January 23,2001 CB Circular No. 08/2001. L;' f. i..new To: All Commercial Banks and Financial
More informationBalance of Payments. Third quarter 2009
Balance of Paymens Third quarer 2009 Balance of Paymens Third quarer 2009 Saisics Sweden 2009 Balance of Paymens. Third quarer 2009 Saisics Sweden 2009 Producer Saisics Sweden, Balance of Paymens and
More informationIf You Are No Longer Able to Work
If You Are No Longer Able o Work NY STRS A Guide for Making Disabiliy Reiremen Decisions INTRODUCTION If you re forced o sop working because of a serious illness or injury, you and your family will be
More informationGUIDELINE Solactive Gold Front Month MD Rolling Futures Index ER. Version 1.1 dated April 13 th, 2017
GUIDELINE Solacive Gold Fron Monh MD Rolling Fuures Index ER Version 1.1 daed April 13 h, 2017 Conens Inroducion 1 Index specificaions 1.1 Shor name and ISIN 1.2 Iniial value 1.3 Disribuion 1.4 Prices
More informationHow Risky is Electricity Generation?
How Risky is Elecriciy Generaion? Tom Parkinson The NorhBridge Group Inernaional Associaion for Energy Economics New England Chaper 19 January 2005 19 January 2005 The NorhBridge Group Agenda Generaion
More informationCapital Strength and Bank Profitability
Capial Srengh and Bank Profiabiliy Seok Weon Lee 1 Asian Social Science; Vol. 11, No. 10; 2015 ISSN 1911-2017 E-ISSN 1911-2025 Published by Canadian Cener of Science and Educaion 1 Division of Inernaional
More informationParameters of the IRB Approach. 1. Class of exposures to central governments and central banks, exposures to institutions or corporate exposures
Annex 13 Parameers of he IRB Approach I. The PD value 1. Class of exposures o cenral governmens and cenral bans, exposures o insiuions or corporae exposures a) The PD value for an exposure o an insiuion
More informationOPTIMUM FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICY USING THE MONETARY OVERLAPPING GENERATION MODELS
Kuwai Chaper of Arabian Journal of Business and Managemen Review Vol. 3, No.6; Feb. 2014 OPTIMUM FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICY USING THE MONETARY OVERLAPPING GENERATION MODELS Ayoub Faramarzi 1, Dr.Rahim
More informationOrigins of currency swaps
Origins of currency swaps Currency swaps originally were developed by banks in he UK o help large cliens circumven UK exchange conrols in he 1970s. UK companies were required o pay an exchange equalizaion
More information*Corresponding author Keywords: CNH, Currency Intervention Index, Central Bank Reaction Function, Exchange Rate Intervention.
016 3rd Inernaional Conference on Advanced Educaion and Managemen (ICAEM 016) ISBN: 978-1-60595-380-9 Exchange Rae Inervenion by Cenral Bank: Based on he Influence of he Hong Kong Offshore RMB Exchange
More informationGUIDELINE Solactive Bitcoin Front Month Rolling Futures 5D Index ER. Version 1.0 dated December 8 th, 2017
GUIDELINE Solacive Bicoin Fron Monh Rolling Fuures 5D Index ER Version 1.0 daed December 8 h, 2017 Conens Inroducion 1 Index specificaions 1.1 Shor name and ISIN 1.2 Iniial value 1.3 Disribuion 1.4 Prices
More informationSession IX: Special topics
Session IX: Special opics 2. Subnaional populaion projecions 10 March 2016 Cheryl Sawyer, Lina Bassarsky Populaion Esimaes and Projecions Secion www.unpopulaion.org Maerials adaped from Unied Naions Naional
More informationDescription of the CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrite Index (BXR SM )
Descripion of he CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrie Index (BXR SM ) Inroducion. The CBOE Russell 2000 BuyWrie Index (BXR SM ) is a benchmark index designed o rack he performance of a hypoheical a-he-money buy-wrie
More informationProposed changes to the compilation of zone aggregates for monetary aggregates and other variables in the OECD Main Economic Indicators publication
Proposed changes o he compilaion of zone aggregaes for moneary aggregaes and oher variables in he OECD Main Economic Indicaors publicaion Summary The Main Economic Indicaors (MEI) has radiionally published
More informationAn Incentive-Based, Multi-Period Decision Model for Hierarchical Systems
Wernz C. and Deshmukh A. An Incenive-Based Muli-Period Decision Model for Hierarchical Sysems Proceedings of he 3 rd Inernaional Conference on Global Inerdependence and Decision Sciences (ICGIDS) pp. 84-88
More informationThe Impact of Interest Rate Liberalization Announcement in China on the Market Value of Hong Kong Listed Chinese Commercial Banks
Journal of Finance and Invesmen Analysis, vol. 2, no.3, 203, 35-39 ISSN: 224-0998 (prin version), 224-0996(online) Scienpress Ld, 203 The Impac of Ineres Rae Liberalizaion Announcemen in China on he Marke
More informationDescription of the CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrite Index (BXY SM )
Descripion of he CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrie Index (BXY SM ) Inroducion. The CBOE S&P 500 2% OTM BuyWrie Index (BXY SM ) is a benchmark index designed o rack he performance of a hypoheical 2% ou-of-he-money
More informationCRO Forum Best Practice Paper - Extrapolation of Market Data
CRO Forum Bes Pracice Paper - Exrapolaion of Marke Daa Augus 00 able of conens able of conens 3. Execuive summary 4. Inroducion 6 3. Principles of Exrapolaion 9 4. Exrapolaion of ineres rae curve 6 5.
More informationSecretary-General of the European Commission, signed by Mr Jordi AYET PUIGARNAU, Director
COUNCIL OF THE ROPEAN UNION Brussels, 14 May 2014 (OR. en) 9858/14 COVER NOTE From: dae of receip: 14 May 2014 To: No. Cion doc.: Subjec: RESPR 17 FIN 365 CADREFIN 80 POLGEN 67 Secreary-General of he European
More informationTechnological progress breakthrough inventions. Dr hab. Joanna Siwińska-Gorzelak
Technological progress breakhrough invenions Dr hab. Joanna Siwińska-Gorzelak Inroducion Afer The Economis : Solow has shown, ha accumulaion of capial alone canno yield lasing progress. Wha can? Anyhing
More informationEVA NOPAT Capital charges ( = WACC * Invested Capital) = EVA [1 P] each
VBM Soluion skech SS 2012: Noe: This is a soluion skech, no a complee soluion. Disribuion of poins is no binding for he correcor. 1 EVA, free cash flow, and financial raios (45) 1.1 EVA wihou adjusmens
More informationSubdivided Research on the Inflation-hedging Ability of Residential Property: A Case of Hong Kong
Subdivided Research on he -hedging Abiliy of Residenial Propery: A Case of Hong Kong Guohua Huang 1, Haili Tu 2, Boyu Liu 3,* 1 Economics and Managemen School of Wuhan Universiy,Economics and Managemen
More informationDYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus University Toruń Krzysztof Jajuga Wrocław University of Economics
DYNAMIC ECONOMETRIC MODELS Vol. 7 Nicolaus Copernicus Universiy Toruń 2006 Krzyszof Jajuga Wrocław Universiy of Economics Ineres Rae Modeling and Tools of Financial Economerics 1. Financial Economerics
More informationBUDGET ECONOMIC AND FISCAL POSITION REPORT
BUDGET ECONOMIC AND FISCAL POSITION REPORT - 2004 Issued by he Hon. Miniser of Finance in Terms of Secion 7 of he Fiscal Managemen (Responsibiliy) Ac No. 3 of 1. Inroducion Secion 7 of he Fiscal Managemen
More informationOFFICIAL INFORMATION OF THE CZECH NATIONAL BANK of 24 October 2017
OFFICIAL INFORMATION OF THE CZECH NATIONAL BANK of 24 Ocober 2017 regarding Aricles 23, 24 and 25 of Ac No. 6/1993 Coll., on he Czech Naional Bank, as amended, and regarding Decree No. 253/2013 Coll.,
More informationServices producer price indices for Market research and public opinion polling
Services producer price indices for Marke research and public opinion polling Indusry descripion for SNI group 74.13 SPPI repor no 24 Ulf Johansson Services producer price indices, Price Saisics Uni, Saisics
More informationSection 4 The Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Secion 4 he Exchange Rae in he Long Run 1 Conen Objecives Purchasing Power Pariy A Long-Run PPP Model he Real Exchange Rae Summary 2 Objecives o undersand he law of one price and purchasing power pariy
More informationService producer price index (SPPI) for storage and warehousing Industry description for SNI group SPPI report no 14
Service producer price index (SPPI) for sorage and warehousing Indusry descripion for SNI group 63.12 SPPI repor no 14 Kaarina Båh Chrisian Schoulz Service producer price index (SPPI), Price programme,
More informationDO FINANCIAL MARKETS DISCIPLINE FIRMS FOR ILLEGAL CORPORATE BEHAVIOUR?
DO FINANCIAL MARKETS DISCIPLINE FIRMS FOR ILLEGAL CORPORATE BEHAVIOUR? Monique ARNOLD, Peer-Jan ENGELEN Urech Universiy, The Neherlands Absrac. This paper examines he relaionship beween he discovery of
More informationCorporate Finance. Capital budgeting. Standalone risk of capital project
Corporae Finance Capial budgeing Iniial oulay = FCInv + NWCInv Sal afer ax operaing cashflow = 0 + T ( Sal0 B0 ) ( R C)( 1 ax) + ax Ter min al year non opereaing cashflow = Sal T Dep + NWCInv ax ( Sal
More informationSuggested Template for Rolling Schemes for inclusion in the future price regulation of Dublin Airport
Suggesed Templae for Rolling Schemes for inclusion in he fuure price regulaion of Dublin Airpor. In line wih sandard inernaional regulaory pracice, he regime operaed since 00 by he Commission fixes in
More informationLi Gan Guan Gong Michael Hurd. April, 2006
Ne Inergeneraional Transfers from an Increase in Social Securiy Benefis Li Gan Guan Gong Michael Hurd April, 2006 ABSTRACT When he age of deah is uncerain, individuals will leave bequess even if hey have
More informationAn Introduction to PAM Based Project Appraisal
Slide 1 An Inroducion o PAM Based Projec Appraisal Sco Pearson Sanford Universiy Sco Pearson is Professor of Agriculural Economics a he Food Research Insiue, Sanford Universiy. He has paricipaed in projecs
More informationStock Market Behaviour Around Profit Warning Announcements
Sock Marke Behaviour Around Profi Warning Announcemens Henryk Gurgul Conen 1. Moivaion 2. Review of exising evidence 3. Main conjecures 4. Daa and preliminary resuls 5. GARCH relaed mehodology 6. Empirical
More informationThe relation between U.S. money growth and inflation: evidence from a band pass filter. Abstract
The relaion beween U.S. money growh and inflaion: evidence from a band pass filer Gary Shelley Dep. of Economics Finance; Eas Tennessee Sae Universiy Frederick Wallace Dep. of Managemen Markeing; Prairie
More informationGUIDELINES. Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, and in particular Article 128 thereof,
L 77/4 Official Journal of he European Union 22.3.2017 GUIDELINES GUIDELINE (EU) 2017/469 OF THE EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK of 7 February 2017 amending Guideline ECB/2008/8 on daa collecion regarding he euro
More information1 Purpose of the paper
Moneary Economics 2 F.C. Bagliano - Sepember 2017 Noes on: F.X. Diebold and C. Li, Forecasing he erm srucure of governmen bond yields, Journal of Economerics, 2006 1 Purpose of he paper The paper presens
More informationNASDAQ-100 DIVIDEND POINT INDEX. Index Methodology
NASDAQ-100 DIVIDEND POINT INDEX Index Mehodology April 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Inroducion 2. Index calculaion 2.1 Formula 2.1.1 dividends 2.1.2 Rese of he index value 2.2 Oher adjusmens
More informationMarket and Information Economics
Marke and Informaion Economics Preliminary Examinaion Deparmen of Agriculural Economics Texas A&M Universiy May 2015 Insrucions: This examinaion consiss of six quesions. You mus answer he firs quesion
More informationA Simple Method for Consumers to Address Uncertainty When Purchasing Photovoltaics
A Simple Mehod for Consumers o Address Uncerainy When Purchasing Phoovolaics Dr. Thomas E. Hoff Clean Power Research 10 Glen C. Napa, CA 94558 www.clean-power.com Dr. Rober Margolis Naional Renewable Energy
More informationDOES EVA REALLY HELP LONG TERM STOCK PERFORMANCE?
DOES EVA REALLY HELP LONG TERM STOCK PERFORMANCE? Wesley M. Jones, Jr. The Ciadel wes.jones@ciadel.edu George Lowry, Randolph Macon College glowry@rmc.edu ABSTRACT Economic Value Added (EVA) as a philosophy
More informationEssay 3. The liquidity impact of open market share repurchases * repurchases *
Essay 3 The liquidiy impac of open marke share repurchases * repurchases * * The essay is co-auhored wih Adri De Ridder. We hank William Bradford, David Burnie, Marin Holmén and Holmén and seminar paricipans
More informationA Decision Model for Investment Timing Using Real Options Approach
A Decision Model for Invesmen Timing Using Real Opions Approach Jae-Han Lee, Jae-Hyeon Ahn Graduae School of Managemen, KAIST 207-43, Cheongrangri-Dong, Dongdaemun-Ku, Seoul, Korea ABSTRACT Real opions
More informationCh. 1 Multinational Financial Mgmt: Overview. International Financial Environment. How Business Disciplines Are Used to Manage the MNC
Ch. Mulinaional Financial Mgm: Overview Topics Goal of he MNC Theories of Inernaional Business Inernaional Business Mehods Inernaional Opporuniies Exposure o Inernaional Risk MNC's Cash Flows & Valuaion
More informationAppendix B: DETAILS ABOUT THE SIMULATION MODEL. contained in lookup tables that are all calculated on an auxiliary spreadsheet.
Appendix B: DETAILS ABOUT THE SIMULATION MODEL The simulaion model is carried ou on one spreadshee and has five modules, four of which are conained in lookup ables ha are all calculaed on an auxiliary
More informationPRESS RELEASE EURO AREA ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENTS BY INSTITUTIONAL SECTOR - FIRST QUARTER August 2012
1 Augus 212 PRESS RELEASE EURO AREA ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENTS BY INSTITUTIONAL SECTOR - FIRST QUARTER 212 In he firs quarer of 212, he annual growh rae 1 of households gross disposable income
More informationJemena Electricity Networks (Vic) Ltd
Jemena Elecriciy Neworks (Vic) Ld 2016-20 Elecriciy Disribuion Price Review Regulaory Proposal Price conrol mechanisms Public 30 April 2015 TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ii Public 30 April 2015 Jemena
More informationMemorandum of Understanding
MoU producer_buyer_faciliaor.doc Dae Memorandum of Undersanding beween: he producer organisaion: < of organisaion> he rading parner: < of rading parner> and he faciliaing organisaion: < of faciliaing organisaion>
More informationDocumentation: Philadelphia Fed's Real-Time Data Set for Macroeconomists First-, Second-, and Third-Release Values
Documenaion: Philadelphia Fed's Real-Time Daa Se for Macroeconomiss Firs-, Second-, and Third-Release Values Las Updaed: December 16, 2013 1. Inroducion We documen our compuaional mehods for consrucing
More informationRevenues and Earnings as Key Value Drivers in Various Contexts: Implications for Financial Management and Statement Analysis
Revenues and Earnings as Key Value Drivers in Various Conexs: Implicaions for Financial Managemen and Saemen Analysis Iay Kama Graduae School of Business Adminisraion Tel Aviv Universiy Tel Aviv 69978,
More informationJoint Committee on Taxation
bs_bs_banner Review of Income and Wealh Series 60, Number 4, December 2014 DOI: 10.1111/roiw.12043 ACCOUNTING FOR UNITED STATES HOUSEHOLD INCOME INEQUALITY TRENDS: THE CHANGING IMPORTANCE OF HOUSEHOLD
More informationA Method for Estimating the Change in Terminal Value Required to Increase IRR
A Mehod for Esimaing he Change in Terminal Value Required o Increase IRR Ausin M. Long, III, MPA, CPA, JD * Alignmen Capial Group 11940 Jollyville Road Suie 330-N Ausin, TX 78759 512-506-8299 (Phone) 512-996-0970
More information1. FIXED ASSETS - DEFINITION AND CHARACTERISTICS
1. FIXED ASSETS - DEFINITION AND CHARACTERISTICS Fixed asses represen a par of he business asses of he company and is long-erm propery, which canno be easily liquidaed (convered ino cash). Their characerisics
More informationThe Concept of Generational Accounts (GA) in Comparison with National Transfer Accounts (NTA)
The Concep of Generaional Accouns (GA) in Comparison wih Naional Transfer Accouns (NTA) The GA is defined as he presen value of ne ax paymen (=ax paid minus benefi received from he governmen) for he remaining
More informationFundamental Basic. Fundamentals. Fundamental PV Principle. Time Value of Money. Fundamental. Chapter 2. How to Calculate Present Values
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chaper 2 How o Calculae Presen Values Principles of Corporae Finance Tenh Ediion Slides by Mahew Will And Bo Sjö 22 Copyrigh 2 by he McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All righs reserved. Fundamenal
More informationThe Fair Value of Insurance Contracts by Sam Gutterman, David Rogers, Larry Rubin, David Scheinerman
The Fair Value of Insurance Conracs by Sam Guerman, David Rogers, Larry Rubin, David Scheinerman Execuive summary Over he las decades, accouning sandard seers have given greaer emphasis o he use of fair
More informationManagers beyond borders: side-by-side management in mutual funds and. pension funds.
Managers beyond borders: side-by-side managemen in muual funds and pension funds. Absrac The simulaneous managemen (also called side-by-side -SBS- managemen) in muual and pension funds is increasing; however,
More informationPrivatization, Foreign Entry, and Bank Risk in an Emerging Banking System: The Case of Argentina,
Privaizaion, Foreign Enry, and Bank Risk in an Emerging Banking Sysem: The Case of Argenina, 1996-1999 Pedro Elosegui Faculad de Ciencias Economicas Universidad Nacional de La Plaa La Plaa 1900 mail@depeco.econo.unlp.edu.ar
More informationThe Relationship between Money Demand and Interest Rates: An Empirical Investigation in Sri Lanka
The Relaionship beween Money Demand and Ineres Raes: An Empirical Invesigaion in Sri Lanka R. C. P. Padmasiri 1 and O. G. Dayarana Banda 2 1 Economic Research Uni, Deparmen of Expor Agriculure 2 Deparmen
More informationTrading Costs of Public Investors with Obligatory and. Voluntary Market-Making: Evidence from Market Reforms
Trading Coss of Public Invesors wih Obligaory and Volunary Mare-Maing: Evidence from Mare Reforms by Narayan Y. Nai and Pradeep K. Yadav Absrac In 997, he London Soc Exchange, lie NASDAQ, allowed he public
More informationFINAL EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MAY 11, 2004
FINAL EXAM EC26102: MONEY, BANKING AND FINANCIAL MARKETS MAY 11, 2004 This exam has 50 quesions on 14 pages. Before you begin, please check o make sure ha your copy has all 50 quesions and all 14 pages.
More informationVolume 31, Issue 1. Pitfall of simple permanent income hypothesis model
Volume 31, Issue 1 ifall of simple permanen income hypohesis model Kazuo Masuda Bank of Japan Absrac ermanen Income Hypohesis (hereafer, IH) is one of he cenral conceps in macroeconomics. Single equaion
More informationBank of Japan Review. Performance of Core Indicators of Japan s Consumer Price Index. November Introduction 2015-E-7
Bank of Japan Review 5-E-7 Performance of Core Indicaors of Japan s Consumer Price Index Moneary Affairs Deparmen Shigenori Shirasuka November 5 The Bank of Japan (BOJ), in conducing moneary policy, employs
More informationThe Empirical Study about Introduction of Stock Index Futures on the Volatility of Spot Market
ibusiness, 013, 5, 113-117 hp://dx.doi.org/10.436/ib.013.53b04 Published Online Sepember 013 (hp://www.scirp.org/journal/ib) 113 The Empirical Sudy abou Inroducion of Sock Index Fuures on he Volailiy of
More informationPOSITIVE SCOPING STUDY OUTCOME
ASX Release 1 December 2008 ASX code: IMA POSITIVE SCOPING STUDY OUTCOME HIGHLIGHTS Image has several opions for he commercialisaion of is exising Norh Perh Basin indicaed and inferred resources: sand
More informationThe Mathematics Of Stock Option Valuation - Part Four Deriving The Black-Scholes Model Via Partial Differential Equations
The Mahemaics Of Sock Opion Valuaion - Par Four Deriving The Black-Scholes Model Via Parial Differenial Equaions Gary Schurman, MBE, CFA Ocober 1 In Par One we explained why valuing a call opion as a sand-alone
More informationINNOVATIVE CUSTOMISED SOLUTIONS. Global Securities Lending
INNOVATIVE CUSTOMISED SOLUTIONS Global Securiies Lending Providing You Wih Innovaive Soluions Wih Norhern Trus you ge proven performance, unrivalled clien focus and excepional capial srengh. These qualiies,
More informationGas Distribution Services Default Price-Quality Path Determination 2013 [2013] NZCC 4
ISBN no. 978-1-869453-11-4 Projec no. 15.01/13199 Public version Gas Disribuion Services Defaul Price-Qualiy Pah Deerminaion 2013 [2013] NZCC 4 The Commission: S Begg Dr M Berry P Duignan Dr S Gale Dae
More informationWatch out for the impact of Scottish independence opinion polls on UK s borrowing costs
Wach ou for he impac of Scoish independence opinion polls on UK s borrowing coss Cosas Milas (Universiy of Liverpool; email: cosas.milas@liverpool.ac.uk) and Tim Worrall (Universiy of Edinburgh; email:
More informationPUBLIC CONSULTATION. April Consultation on copper local-loop costing methods
PUBLIC CONSULAION April 25 Consulaion on copper local-loop cosing mehods Auorié de régulaion des élécommunicaions CONENS Inroducion Summary 2 Par one: Conex I. Copper local loop 5 II. Principles 9 III.
More informationProblem 1 / 25 Problem 2 / 25 Problem 3 / 11 Problem 4 / 15 Problem 5 / 24 TOTAL / 100
Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Maryland Economics 35 Inermediae Macroeconomic Analysis Miderm Exam Suggesed Soluions Professor Sanjay Chugh Fall 008 NAME: The Exam has a oal of five (5) problems and
More informationBackground paper prepared for the Education for All Global Monitoring Report Youth and skills: Putting education to work.
2012/ED/EFA/MRT/PI/01 Background paper prepared for he Educaion for All Global Monioring Repor 2012 Youh and skills: Puing educaion o work GDP Projecions Eric A. Hanushek & Ludger Woessmann 2012 This paper
More informationABN AMRO Bank N.V. The Royal Bank of Scotland N.V.
On 6 February 2010 ABN AMRO Bank N.V. (regisered wih he Duch Chamber of Commerce under number 33002587) changed is name o The Royal Bank of Scoland N.V. and on 1 April 2010 ABN AMRO Holding N.V. changed
More informationHorizontal Product Differentiation: Disclosure and Competition
Horizonal Produc Differeniaion: Disclosure and Compeiion Mariya Teeryanikova Universiy of Vienna, Ausria. Maaren C.W. Janssen Universiy of Vienna, Ausria. January 31, 2012 This Version Absrac The unravelling
More informationProblem Set 1 Answers. a. The computer is a final good produced and sold in Hence, 2006 GDP increases by $2,000.
Social Analysis 10 Spring 2006 Problem Se 1 Answers Quesion 1 a. The compuer is a final good produced and sold in 2006. Hence, 2006 GDP increases by $2,000. b. The bread is a final good sold in 2006. 2006
More informationInflation Tax and Economic Growth in Iran
J. Basic. Appl. Sci. Res., ( 7-6,, TexRoad Publicaion ISSN 9- Journal of Basic and Applied Scienific Research www.exroad.com Inflaion Tax and Economic Growh in Iran Ahmad Jafari Samimi; Reza Moghadassi;
More informationLabour market participation rate in the euro area: performance and outlook, a long-term view
ECONOMIC BULLETIN 1/218 ANALYTICAL ARTICLES Labour marke paricipaion rae in he euro area: performance and oulook, a long-erm view Crisina Fernández and David Marínez Turégano 11 January 218 This aricle
More informationPrice and Volume Measures
8 Price and Volume Measures Price and volume measures in he QNA should be derived from observed price and volume daa and be consisen wih corresponding annual measures. This chaper examines specific aspecs
More informationProvide a brief review of futures markets. Carefully review alternative market conditions and which marketing
Provide a brief review of fuures markes. Carefully review alernaive marke condiions and which markeing sraegies work bes under alernaive condiions. Have an open and ineracive discussion!! 1. Sore or Wai
More informationFederal Reserve Bank of Chicago
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago A Sequenial Bargaining Model of he Fed Funds Marke wih Excess Reserves Sam Schulhofer-Wohl and James Clouse REVISED July 2018 WP 2018-08 hps://doi.org/10.21033/wp-2018-08
More informationChapter 12 Fiscal Policy, page 1 of 8
Chaper 12 Fiscal olicy, page 1 of 8 fiscal policy and invesmen: fiscal policy refers o governmen policy regarding revenue and expendiures fiscal policy is under he capial resources secion of he ex because
More informationChapter 10: The Determinants of Dividend Policy
Chaper 10: The Deerminans of Dividend Policy 1. True True False 2. This means ha firms generally prefer no o change dividends, paricularly downwards. One explanaion for his is he clienele hypohesis. Tha
More informationCompleting Markets in a One-Good, Pure Exchange Economy. Without State-Contingent Securities
Compleing Markes in a One-Good, Pure Exchange Economy Wihou Sae-Coningen Securiies David M. Eagle Deparmen of Managemen, RVPT#3 College of Business Adminisraion Easern Washingon Universiy 668 N. Riverpoin
More informationUNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA
MA5100 UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA MSC/POSTGRADUATE DIPLOMA IN FINANCIAL MATHEMATICS 009 MA 5100 INTRODUCTION TO STATISTICS THREE HOURS November 009 Answer FIVE quesions and NO MORE. Quesion 1 (a) A supplier
More informationBalance of Payments. Third quarter 2008
Balance of Paymens Third quarer 2008 Balance of Paymens Third quarer 2008 Saisics Sweden 2008 Balance of Paymens. Third quarer 2008 Saisics Sweden 2008 Producer Saisics Sweden, Balance of Paymens and
More informationWarranty Reserve: Contingent Liability, Strategic Signal, or Earnings Management Tool?*
Warrany Reserve: Coningen Liabiliy, Sraegic Signal, or Earnings Managemen Tool?* Daniel Cohen a, Masako Darrough b, Rong Huang c, Tzachi Zach d a Sern School of Business, New York Universiy, dcohen@sern.nyu.edu
More informationGUIDELINE Solactive US Large Cap CAD Index (CA NTR) Version 1.0 dated December 15 th, 2017
GUIDELINE Solacive US Large Cap CAD Index (CA NTR) Version 1.0 daed December 15 h, 2017 Conens Inroducion 1 Index specificaions 1.1 Shor name and ISIN 1.2 Iniial value 1.3 Disribuion 1.4 Prices and calculaion
More informationSession 1 AUTOMATIC STABILISERS AND DISCRETIONARY FISCAL POLICY
Session 1 AUTOMATIC STABILISERS AND DISCRETIONARY FISCAL POLICY GOVERNMENT FISCAL AND REAL ECONOMY RESPONSES TO THE CRISES: AUTOMATIC STABILISERS VERSUS AUTOMATIC STABILISATION Jonas Fischer * and Isabelle
More informationVERIFICATION OF ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF LIGNITE DEPOSIT DEVELOPMENT USING THE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
1 Beaa TRZASKUŚ-ŻAK 1, Kazimierz CZOPEK 2 MG 3 1 Trzaskuś-Żak Beaa PhD. (corresponding auhor) AGH Universiy of Science and Technology Faculy of Mining and Geoengineering Al. Mickiewicza 30, 30-59 Krakow,
More informationBoxes Box 12.1 Compilation and Revision Schedule: An Example...16 Box 12.2 Presentation of Revisions: An Illustration based on Country Practices...
UPDATE OF QUARTERLY NATIONAL ACCOUNTS MANUAL: CONCEPTS, DATA SOURCES AND COMPILATION 1 CHAPTER 12. REVISIONS 2 Table of Conens 1. Inroducion... 2 2. User Requiremens and Resource Consrains... 3 3. Waves
More informationA Note on Missing Data Effects on the Hausman (1978) Simultaneity Test:
A Noe on Missing Daa Effecs on he Hausman (978) Simulaneiy Tes: Some Mone Carlo Resuls. Dikaios Tserkezos and Konsaninos P. Tsagarakis Deparmen of Economics, Universiy of Cree, Universiy Campus, 7400,
More informationECON Lecture 5 (OB), Sept. 21, 2010
1 ECON4925 2010 Lecure 5 (OB), Sep. 21, 2010 axaion of exhausible resources Perman e al. (2003), Ch. 15.7. INODUCION he axaion of nonrenewable resources in general and of oil in paricular has generaed
More information