HOPE NOW. Snapshot Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics

Similar documents
HOPE NOW. Snapshot Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics

HOPE NOW. Snapshot Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics

HOPE NOW WORKOUT PLANS (Repayment Plans + Modifications) and FORECLOSURE SALES July July 2009

HOPE NOW Reports 99K Mortgage Solutions for Homeowners in November K Permanent Loan Modifications Completed for the Month

FORECLOSURE PREVENTION REPORT

FHFA Perspectives on Foreclosure Prevention and Principal Forgiveness

HOPE NOW: 444,000 Non-Foreclosure Solutions for Homeowners during Q1 2015

LPS Mortgage Monitor

MI Industry Workout Reporting Template FAQs

HOPE NOW: 319,000 Non-Foreclosure Solutions for Homeowners during Q1 2016

The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners

Black Knight Mortgage Monitor

Fourth Quarter 2014 Financial Results Supplement

The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners

HOPE NOW Reports 122K Mortgage Solutions for Homeowners in July

HUD NSP-1 Reporting Apr 2010 Grantee Report - New Mexico State Program

The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize The Housing Market and Help American Homeowners

HOPE NOW: Proprietary Loan Modifications for Homeowners Continue at a Steady Pace 120K Completed in September

Black Knight Mortgage Monitor

Freddie Mac Principal Reduction Modification Quick Reference

The US Housing Market Crisis and Its Aftermath

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 11/03/ :05 PM INDEX NO /2014 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 166 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/03/2014 EXHIBIT N

XML Publisher Balance Sheet Vision Operations (USA) Feb-02

HOPE NOW: Mortgage Servicers Completed 1.76 Million Loan Modifications for Homeowners in 2010

Big Walnut Local School District

WESTWOOD LUTHERAN CHURCH Summary Financial Statement YEAR TO DATE - February 28, Over(Under) Budget WECC Fund Actual Budget

Rent vs. Own Analysis

Customer Integration Testing Strategy

Housing and Mortgage Market Update

Exhibit B FREDDIE MAC SERVICER DILIGENCE QUESTIONS SALE OF NON-PERFORMING SINGLE FAMILY MORTGAGE LOANS SAMPLE

Mortgage Trends Update

Freddie Mac Servicer Conference November 14 Bulletin Freddie Mac Servicer Success Scorecard

Spheria Australian Smaller Companies Fund

The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize the Housing Market and Help American Homeowners

HOPE NOW: 181K Loan Modifications for Homeowners During Q3 2013

PRESS RELEASE. Securities issued by Hungarian residents and breakdown by holding sectors. October 2018

The Obama Administration s Efforts To Stabilize the Housing Market and Help American Homeowners

MBA Economic and Mortgage Finance Outlook

Affordable Care Act Implementation Alert

Release date: 12 July 2018

Quarterly Statistical Digest

Business & Financial Services December 2017

This Month in Real Estate

Supplemental Directive May 11, Home Affordable Unemployment Program. Help for Unemployed Borrowers. Background

U.S. Housing Markets: Looking Back, Looking Forward

Retrieving and Interpreting the NPV Test Results

Sanford C. Bernstein Investor Presentation

First Quarter 2013 Financial Results Supplement. May 8, 2013

PASSENGER REJECTION REDUCTION INITIATIVE KIRK PEREIRA. 24 th April 2018

HOUSING FINANCE REFORM DEBATE: HOW CAN THE FHA MEET THE FUTURE NEEDS OF US HOUSING? #LiveAtUrban

Cost Estimation of a Manufacturing Company

Released: February 5, 2010

PRESS RELEASE. Securities issued by Hungarian residents and breakdown by holding sectors. January 2019

June 2018 MLS Statistical Report

Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternative (HAFA) Eligibility Worksheet

Announcement SVC September 21, 2010

Review of Registered Charites Compliance Rates with Annual Reporting Requirements 2016

Real Estate Market. Lawrence Yun, Ph.D. Presentation to New England REALTORS Conference. February 2, 2010 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS

Allowed State Foreclosure Timeline Delays and How Freddie Mac Calculates the Additional Time Granted for Such Delays

Servicing Alignment Initiative Overview for Freddie Mac Servicers

Release date: 14 August 2018

HOPE NOW Alliance. Statement for the Record. Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. U.S. House of Representatives. Hearing

PRESS RELEASE. Securities issued by Hungarian residents and breakdown by holding sectors. April 2016

Making Home Affordable

Factor Leave Accruals. Accruing Vacation and Sick Leave

Lunchtime Data Talk. Housing Finance Policy Center. Mortgage Origination Pricing and Volume: More than You Ever Wanted to Know

Constructing a Cash Flow Forecast

Executive Summary. July 17, 2015

Making Home Affordable

NAME AMOUNT AND DESCRIPTION GUIDE SECTION REFERENCE

Making Home Affordable Program Performance Report Through April 2013

Fiscal Year 2018 Project 1 Annual Budget

Financial & Business Highlights For the Year Ended June 30, 2017

STAFF REPORT Corporate Services

Supplemental Directive October 18, 2013

Asset Manager Performance Comparison

Loan Modifications: Determining What Programs are Available. Joseph Rebella Senior Staff Attorney MFY Legal Services, Inc.

Asset Manager Performance Comparison

HOPE NOW: Proprietary Loan Mods for Homeowners Increased 43% in July

QUARTERLY FINANCIAL REPORT June 30, 2017

Big Walnut Local School District

PRESS RELEASE. Securities issued by Hungarian residents and breakdown by holding sectors. October 2017

THE B E A CH TO WN S O F P ALM B EA CH

Quarterly Statistical Digest

August 2017 MLS Statistical Report. Median Sale Price

HOPE NOW: Mortgage Servicers Completed 850,000 Loan Modifications for Homeowners in 2012

Freddie Mac Standard Modification Overview for Housing Counselors. Counselor Connection Baltimore, Maryland May 8, 2012

Making Home Affordable Base Net Present Value (NPV) Model (v5.02) Training Module for Servicers

Economic Activity Index ( GDB-EAI ) For the month of May 2013 G O V E R N M E N T D E V E L O P M E N T B A N K F O R P U E R T O R I C O

Specialized Loan Servicing LLC ( SLS ) Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternative (HAFA) Matrix

TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR THE INVESTMENT COMMITTEE

Release date: 16 May 2018

1 Long Term Debt $ 9,298,554 $ (250,000) $ 9,048, Preferred Stock 30,450 30, % 5 Common Equity 250, %

OCC and OTS Mortgage Metrics Report Disclosure of National Bank and Federal Thrift Mortgage Loan Data

WORRIED. about Foreclosure? HAFA MAY BE ABLE TO HELP HOME AFFORDABLE FORECLOSURE ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (HAFA)

City of Joliet 2014 Revenue Review. October 2013

FOR RELEASE: MONDAY, MARCH 21 AT 4 PM

Using projections to manage your programs

Ohlone Community College District

SELF-STORAGE FOR SALE

Transcription:

Snapshot Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics Three Month Q2-215 Q3-215 Q4-215 Q1-216 Q2-216 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total Completed Modifications 119,658 97,773 84,798 86,167 1,198 41,872 34,815 36,6 HAMP Permanent Modifications 1 35,738 28,748 23,68 24,329 31,684 16,8 12,81 1,61 Proprietary Modifications Completed 2 83,92 69,25 61,118 61,838 68,514 25,864 22,734 25,396 Reduced P&I Modifications (1% or greater) 51,577 4,743 34,217 31,88 32,12 1,481 1,437 11,72 % of Proprietary Modifications 61% 59% 56% 52% 47% 41% 46% 46% Completed Short Sale 23,67 2,822 18,675 18,6 18,444 6,317 5,665 5,77 Deed-In-Lieu 5,344 4,478 4,237 5,32 4,924 1,7 1,425 1,625 Foreclosure Starts 173,613 159,139 156,433 178,976 151,555 54,355 51,421 57,847 Foreclosure Sales 89,445 8,77 76,627 9,998 81,473 28,667 25,314 25,69 6+ Days Delinquency 1,811,343 1,654,348 1,624,769 1,718,297 1,54,483 1,467,847 1,571,242 1,512,868 1 Source - Making Home Affordable. Estimated. 2 Extrapolated. Modifications Completed was revised in December 29 to include Current Modifications and specifically exclude HAMP. *Survey data may be restated from time to time based on servicers' collection and reporting. HOPE NOW reports and extrapolates data. Any data changes will be reflected in monthly reporting. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 1

Industry Market Coverage Hope Now Alliance Survey (Aug 216) INDUSTRY MARKET COVERAGE Millions of Residential Mortgage Loans Loan Count MBA Delinquency Survey (Q2-216)* MBA Survey Extrapolated to Total Industry Hope Now Estimated Percent of Industry # of Hope Now Companies Reporting Total 2.8 37.7 42.8 48.5% 16 Prime 16.9 34.9 41.7 4.5% 14 Subprime 3.9 2.8 4. 97.5% 14 *"MBA Delinquency Survey" data is for Q2-216, while "HOPE NOW Alliance Survey" data is for August 216. MBA estimates that its survey covers approximately 88% of the total industry. "Hope Now Estimated Percent of Industry" is derived by dividing "Hope Now Alliance Survey" (August 216) by "MBA Survey Extrapolated to Total Industry" (Q2-216). "Hope Now Estimated Percent of Industry" estimates may increase or decrease slightly when the MBA releases its Delinquency Survey data for Q3-216. **Survey data may be restated from time to time based on servicers' collection and reporting. HOPE NOW reports and extrapolates data as provided by servicers to a third-party data aggregation vendor. Any data changes will be reflected in monthly reporting. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 2

Industry Extrapolations and Metrics (August 216) Table of Contents Page Industry Market Coverage (All Count) 3 "Life to Date" Total Solutions 4 "Life to Date" Modifications 5 Proprietary Modifications 6 Work Out Plans (Non-HAMP) 7 6+ Delinquency (All Loans) 8 Foreclosure Starts and Sales 9 Graphs 1 October 2, 216

Total Solutions Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics (July 27 - August 216) "Life to Q3-Q4 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Date" Total Total Solutions 912,671 2,258,63 4,252,78 4,579,587 3,64,54 3,56,234 2,649,63 1,881,515 1,448,828 119,143 112,378 118,743 25,565,178 HAMP Permanent "LIFE TO DATE" TOTAL SOLUTIONS Modifications 1 N/A N/A 66,938 512,712 353,677 23,155 175,76 136,898 117,267 16,8 12,81 1,61 1,644,427 HAMP Trial Modifications 1 N/A N/A 955, 526, 293,595 21,54 176,64 127,694 116,265 9,764 12,749 9,445 2,466,946 Proprietary Modifications Completed 2 26,24 961,355 1,172,49 1,245,95 692,385 66,642 592,382 352,134 31,786 25,864 22,734 25,396 6,362,993 Other Workout Plans Completed (Non-HAMP) 3 76,431 1,297,248 2,57,649 2,295,78 2,3,883 1,991,383 1,76,18 1,264,789 913,51 67,57 64,814 73,292 15,9,812 1 Source - Making Home Affordable. Estimated. Trial modifications that become permanent may be double counted ²HOPE NOW data is extrapolated based on the "MBA Delinquency Survey" for Q2-216. MBA estimates that its survey covers approximately 88% of the total industry. HOPE NOW data estimates for August 216 may increase or decrease slightly when the MBA releases its Delinquency Survey data for Q3-216. 3 Extrapolated. Other Workout Plans Completed is comprised of Repayment Plans Initiated (tracked from Q3-27), Other Retention Plans Completed and Liquidation Plans (tracked from December 29). OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 4

"Life to Date" Completed Modifications Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics (July 27 - August 216) "LIFE TO DATE" COMPLETED MODIFICATIONS Q3-Q4 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total Completed Modifications 26,24 961,355 1,239,428 1,757,87 1,46,62 863,797 767,458 489,32 419,53 41,872 34,815 36,6 8,7,42 HAMP Permanent Modifications 1 N/A N/A 66,938 512,712 353,677 23,155 175,76 136,898 117,267 16,8 12,81 1,61 1,644,427 Proprietary Modifications Completed 2 26,24 961,355 1,172,49 1,245,95 692,385 66,642 592,382 352,134 31,786 25,864 22,734 25,396 6,362,993 "Life to Date" Total 1 Source - Making Home Affordable. Estimated. 2 Extrapolated. Modifications Completed was revised in December 29 to include Current Modifications and specifically exclude HAMP. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 5

Proprietary Modifications (Non-HAMP) Industry Extrapolations (August 215 - August 216) PROPRIETARY MODIFICATIONS (Non-HAMP) 1 Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total Jun-1 to Aug-16 Proprietary Modifications 2 22,987 22,31 21,677 18,34 21,137 19,28 19,82 23,548 21,464 21,186 25,864 22,734 25,396 3,57,547 Proprietary Reduced P&I Modifications 3 (1% or greater) 13,553 12,845 12,418 1,482 11,734 9,717 1,16 12,147 1,785 1,746 1,481 1,437 11,72 2,3,4 % of Proprietary Modifications 59% 58% 57% 57% 56% 51% 52% 52% 5% 51% 41% 46% 46% 66% ¹HOPE NOW data is extrapolated based on the "MBA Delinquency Survey" for Q2-216. MBA estimates that its survey covers approximately 88% of the total industry. HOPE NOW data estimates for August 216 may increase or decrease slightly when the MBA releases its Delinquency Survey data for Q3-216. 2 Definition of Modification Field was adjusted in December 29 to reflect Proprietary Modifications (specifically excluding HAMP) and include Current Modifications. 3 Total for this field begins in June 21. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 6

Total Solutions Industry Extrapolations WORKOUT PLANS (Non-HAMP) Q3-Q4 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total Jul-7 to Aug-16 Total Workout Plans (Non-HAMP) 912,671 2,258,63 3,27,275 3,432,66 2,592,359 2,25,727 1,983,898 1,458,366 1,19,372 85,354 8,458 91,293 19,834,636 Prime 38,858 941,247 1,92,889 2,192,799 1,688,366 1,292,267 1,257,613 1,4,531 838,1 65,55 61,922 71,46 12,51,92 Subprime 531,813 1,317,356 1,34,386 1,239,87 93,993 913,46 726,285 417,835 271,362 19,84 18,536 19,888 7,782,734 Repayment Plans Initiated 1 76,431 1,297,248 1,964,944 1,34,56 1,117,162 738,278 731,989 698,336 541,143 36,56 35,295 41,51 9,443,955 Prime 314,51 674,27 1,374,529 1,6,452 856,586 56,226 497,847 543,279 44,76 28,429 27,925 32,714 6,46,931 Subprime 391,921 622,978 59,415 334,18 26,577 232,52 234,142 155,57 11,68 8,132 7,37 8,337 2,983,24 Proprietary Modifications Completed 2 26,24 961,355 1,172,49 1,245,95 692,385 66,642 592,382 352,134 31,786 25,864 22,734 25,396 6,362,993 Prime 66,348 266,978 493,58 71,16 431,284 42,859 448,275 242,75 227,973 2,52 17,974 2,562 3,436,64 Subprime 139,892 694,377 678,91 543,935 261,12 239,783 144,17 19,43 73,812 5,362 4,76 4,834 2,926,353 Other Retention Plans Completed 3 69,84 846,951 782,812 86,87 659,527 47,896 266,443 22,929 22,428 24,846 4,27,688 Prime 34,779 485,187 4,497 365,182 311,491 254,548 169,961 16,62 16,22 18,129 2,154,331 Subprime 35,61 361,763 382,315 441,625 348,36 153,348 96,482 6,31 6,46 6,717 1,873,357 1 Definition of this field was revised in December 29. HOPE NOW also began collecting Occupancy data at this time. 2 Proprietary Modifications Completed was revised in December 29 to include Current Modifications and specifically exclude HAMP. 3 Other Retention Plans Completed is a new field added in December 29. It is defined as the number of loans where the customer completed the terms of other retention plan such as: FHA Partial Claim, FHA Secured, VA Refund, Stipulated Repayment / Stip-to-Mod, Forbearance Plans, MI Claim Advance, Reaged / Deferred / Extended, FNMA Home Saver Forbearance, Payment Reduction Plan, or other GSE-sponsored forbearance program. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 7

6+ Delinquency Industry Extrapolations 6+ DELINQUENCY (All Loans) In thousands except for ratios Aug-15 Sep-15 Oct-15 Nov-15 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Average Dec-9 to Aug-16 Number of Estimated Industry Loans 1 44,72 44,72 44,154 44,154 44,154 44,248 44,248 44,248 42,841 42,841 42,841 42,841 42,841 47,339 Prime 41,444 41,444 4,99 4,99 4,99 4,957 4,957 4,957 39,657 39,657 39,657 39,657 39,657 43,14 Subprime 3,276 3,276 3,164 3,164 3,164 3,291 3,291 3,291 3,183 3,183 3,183 3,183 3,183 4,325 6+ Days Delinquency 1,655 1,657 1,632 1,625 1,617 1,858 1,652 1,645 1,587 1,566 1,468 1,571 1,513 2,381 Prime 1,29 1,211 1,28 1,24 1,26 1,42 1,213 1,216 1,177 1,156 1,67 1,174 1,131 1,624 Subprime 446 445 424 421 412 456 439 429 41 41 41 397 382 756 6 Days+ Delinquency (Percentage of Total Loans) 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 3% 4% 4% 5% Prime 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 4% Subprime 14% 14% 13% 13% 13% 14% 13% 13% 13% 13% 13% 12% 12% 17% ¹HOPE NOW data is extrapolated based on the "MBA Delinquency Survey" for Q2-216. MBA estimates that its survey covers approximately 88% of the total industry. HOPE NOW data estimates for August 216 may increase or decrease slightly when the MBA releases its Delinquency Survey data for Q3-216. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 8

Foreclosure Starts and Sales Industry Extrapolations (July 27 - August 216) FORECLOSURE STARTS (All Loans) Q3-Q4 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total 1,6,52 2,215,413 2,836,739 2,621,264 2,259,18 1,922,523 1,277,322 841,676 74,545 54,355 51,421 57,847 Prime 429,815 1,156,48 1,972,242 1,983,291 1,696,421 1,479,618 966,215 638,27 56,359 42,783 42,745 46,637 Subprime 63,237 1,58,932 864,497 637,974 562,687 442,95 311,17 23,469 144,185 11,572 8,676 11,21 FORECLOSURE SALES (All Loans) Q3-Q4 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Total 321,621 914,624 946,527 1,83,573 84,186 778,58 624,445 454,717 342,38 28,667 25,314 25,69 Prime 125,657 423,774 62,347 811,944 638,987 61,712 487,863 34,77 259,528 21,934 19,571 19,913 Subprime 195,964 49,85 326,18 271,629 21,199 167,796 136,582 113,947 82,511 6,733 5,743 5,777 ¹HOPE NOW data is extrapolated based on the "MBA Delinquency Survey" for Q2-216. MBA estimates that its survey covers approximately 88% of the total industry. HOPE NOW data estimates for August 216 may increase or decrease slightly when the MBA releases its Delinquency Survey data for Q3-216. OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 9

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 5 Solutions Offered vs. Foreclosure Sales* 4 3 2 1 Total Solutions Foreclosure Sales Source: Making Home Affordable and HOPE NOW *Total Solutions is comprised of HAMP Permanent and Trial Loans, Proprietary Modifications Completed, Repayment Plans Initiated, Other Retention Plans Completed, Short Sales and Deedin-Lieu 14 12 1 8 6 4 2 Proprietary Modifications Completed* Total Prime Subprime *Non-HAMP THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 1

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 2 Total Modifications Completed 15 1 5 Total Permanent Modification Completed (Proprietary) Completed HAMP HAMP Trial Modification Source: Making Home Affordable and HOPE NOW Total Permanent Modifications is the sum of Completed HAMP and Completed (Proprietary). HOPE NOW has collected data on Completed (Proprietary) Modifications since 27. Data for HAMP Trial Modifications began in May 29 while data for Completed HAMP loans began in September 29. 25% 6+ Delinquencies as Percentage of Total Loans 2% 15% 1% 5% % Total Prime Subprime THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 11

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 3 25 2 15 1 5 Foreclosure Starts Total Prime Subprime 12 1 8 6 4 2 Foreclosure Sales Total Prime Subprime THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 12

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% % Completed Foreclosure Sales as a % of Foreclosure Starts Source: Freddie Mac State Foreclosure Timelines and HOPE NOW *There is a time lag between a foreclosure start and its completion. During this time many foreclosure starts drop out for a variety of reasons. The time lag varies for individual states, ranging between 2 and 12 months. The percentages in this graph adjust for this lag. The weighted average time between foreclosure start to completion is approximately 6 months. This is calculated by multiplying the number of loans for each state by the average time from foreclosure initiation to completed foreclosure sale, summing the results for all states, and then dividing the aggregate by the total number of loans for all states. HAMP Modifications 11% Breakdown of Total Solutions HAMP Trial 11% Proprietary Modifications 2% Repayment Plans Initiated 32% Other Retention Plans Completed 2% Deed in Lieu 1% Short Sales 5% THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 13

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 2 Modifications Completed 15 1 5 Completed (Proprietary) Completed HAMP 11, 1, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, Cumulative Total Modifications and Short Sales Completed Completed (Proprietary) Completed HAMP Completed Short Sale Source: Making Home Affordable and HOPE NOW HOPE NOW has collected data on Completed (Proprietary) Modifications since 27. Data for Completed HAMP loans began in September 29. HOPE NOW began collecting short sale data in December of 29. THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 14

Industry Extrapolations and HAMP Metrics August 216 3. Ratio of Permanent Modifications to Foreclosures 2.5 2. 1.5 1..5. Permanent Mods to FC Starts Permanent Mods to FC Sales Permanent Modifications vs. Foreclosure Sales 2 15 1 5 Total Permanent Modification Foreclosure Sales Source: Making Home Affordable and HOPE NOW Permanent Modifications is the sum of Completed HAMP and Completed (Proprietary). HOPE NOW has collected data on Completed (Proprietary) Modifications since 27. Data for Completed HAMP loans began in September 29. THESE DATA ARE FOR ANALYSIS PURPOSES ONLY. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION, PUBLISHING, DATABASING, OR PUBLIC POSTING WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION. 15