The Equifax Equation. Innovative Corporate Citizenship

Similar documents
ASSOCIATED BANK, N.A. COMMUNITY COMMITMENT PLAN FOR

31% 41% 11% 50% 18% PROFILE ASSETS & OPPORTUNITY PROFILE: SAN FRANCISCO KEY HIGHLIGHTS ABOUT THE PROFILE ASSETS & OPPORTUNITY

Identifying Opportunities. Aligning Resources. Community Commitment Plan Summary Report. Measuring Outcomes. Advancing What Works

B U I L D I N G A F R I C A N - A M E R I C A N A N D L A T I N O P I P E L I N E S F O R T H E F I N A N C I A L S E R V I C E S I N D U S T R Y

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLAN

National Case Statement

Community Development Investment Program (CDIP) for CDCUs SECONDARY CAPITAL I APPLICATION

In Baltimore City today, 20% of households live in poverty, but more than half of the

It s more than our tag line.

BUILDING STRONGER COMMUNITIES TOGETHER: IMMIGRANTS AND ASSET BUILDING FLORIDA PHILANTHROPY NETWORK SUMMIT FEBRUARY 2017

Ontario Co-investment Fund Feasibility Assessment. Completed by Community Forward Fund Assistance Corporation (CFFAC)

Community. An Overview of the CDFI Industry. by Brandy Curtis

Investing in our communities

RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE COMMUNITY REINVESTMENT ACT TO EXPAND REACH AND IMPACT. October 12, 2017

Credit Strength Framework. Making Credit Building Count

Creating a Sustainable Foundation for Financial Inclusion

Introduction. The Assessment consists of: A checklist of best, good and leading practices A rating system to rank your company s current practices.

Increase career awareness Build the pipeline Foster retention and development in the career Improve and strengthen the organization

Building Capacity for the Future

Domini social equity fund and MSCI KLD 400. Source: Bloomberg.

39% 22% 56% 49% 35% 60% PROFILE. Assets & opportunity ProfILe: winston-salem ANd forsyth CoUNtY. KeY HIgHLIgHts. AboUt the ProfILe

TOMORROW'S PROMISE THE COMPREHENSIVE CAPITAL CAMPAIGN FOR FLORIDA A&M UNIVERSITY

BOARD RESOURCES COMMITTEE DESCRIPTIONS ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE COMMITTEE CHARTER. Terms of Reference:

The 2018 U.S. Trust Study of High Net Worth Philanthropy 1

FY Strategic Plan CHESLA

Economic and Social Council

The UNOPS Budget Estimates, Executive Board September 2013

INTRODUCTION THREE-YEAR STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK THREE-YEAR STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK 1

National Network of Fiscal Sponsors. Guidelines for Pre-Approved Grant Relationship Fiscal Sponsorship

Strategic priorities. Sustainable banking. Inspire and engage our people. A better bank contributing to a better world. Enhance client centricity

Credit Union Access to Capital

PUBLIC DISCLOSURE COMMUNITY REINVESTMENT ACT PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

Charter and focus. Community priorities. The New Normal. Structural recommendations. Short-term recommendations

CRA History. The Community Reinvestment Act passage did two things:

CITY OF VILLA PARK The Hidden Jewel

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

35% 26% 57% 51% PROFILE. CIty of durham: Assets & opportunity ProfILe. key highlights. ABoUt the ProfILe ASSETS & OPPORTUNITY

Community Investments Vol 16, Issue 1 W 3 Wall Street Without Walls: Preparing Community Development Organizations for the Capital Markets

RE: Request for Information Regarding Bureau Financial Education Programs (Docket No. CFPB )

Business Plan 2016/ /19

SOLUTIONS FINANCE SERIES BEYOND IMPACT INVESTING, TOWARDS SOLUTIONS FINANCE ISSUE #1

ESG: Impact on Companies Doing Business in America and Why They Must Care

ALLEGANY COUNTY UNITED WAY INCOME IMPACT COUNCIL STRATEGIES AND APPROACHES

Place-Based Impact Investing:

THE CREDIT UNION EXTENSION PROGRAM Financial Counseling Integrated Into CDCUs JUSTINE ZINKIN, CEO MAY 14, 2014

AIB Bank Financial Management Diploma

A NEW FRONTIER STRATEGIC PLAN YMCA OF GREATER SPRINGFIELD

2018 Annual Meeting. April 26, 2018

Financial Wellness and Economic Inclusion

A Foundation Guide to Investing. in Community Development Financial Institutions

February 14, Dear Ms. Naulty:

CDFI Certification. A Pathway to Growth and Impact

In the Red: Debt in Low- and Moderate-Income African American Communities. November 16, 2017

AIB Bank Financial Management Diploma

January 22, SUBJECT: Comments on Request for Information on Small-Dollar Lending (RIN 3064-ZA04)

ADVOCATE GENERATE COLLABORATE PARTICIPATE SPORT NOVA SCOTIA STRATEGIC PLAN

PUBLIC DISCLOSURE. October 10, 2006 COMMUNITY REINVESTMENT ACT PERFORMANCE EVALUATION. BPD BANK RSSD No

CRA COMMUNITY BENEFIT 3-YEAR PLAN

Report of Independent Auditor and Consolidated Financial Statements. Women s Funding Network

AIB Bank Financial Management Diploma

nammba MISSION CONNECTING 50,000 STUDENTS TO THE MORTGAGE INDUSTRY

Albuquerque Entrepreneurial Co-op Capital Request For Proposals

Community-based Interventions for Foreclosure Prevention and Mitigation

Office of the Chief Operating Officer

Roger W Ferguson, Jr: Economic progress and small business

CANADIAN PARENTS FOR FRENCH CPF

STRATEGIC DIRECTION. Several years ago the City adopted a Strategic Management System (SMS) which drives the way the City conducts its business.

MATRIX OF STRATEGIC VISION AND ACTIONS TO SUPPORT SUSTAINABLE CITIES

WISDOM FUND CREDIT ACCESS FOR WOMEN OWNED SMALL BUSINESSES RESEARCH BRIEF

West Windsor-Plainsboro Regional School District Financial Literacy

UBS and Society. Hubertus Kuelps. Head of UBS and Society Group Head Communications & Branding

Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs)

APEC Checklist of Enablers for Alternative Health Financing

PROCUREMENT FISCAL YEAR 2020 BUDGET TESTIMONY APRIL 16, 2019 INTRODUCTION DEPARTMENT MISSION & PLANS PROCUREMENT

2015 Letter to Our Shareholders

Volunteers for Economic Growth Alliance (VEGA)

Executive Administration. Office of Community Engagement

The Delli Carpini Group at Morgan Stanley

10/20/2016. Small Dollar Innovations in Credit Building. October 26, Good Credit : Passport to the New Economy #OFNCONF #RETHINK

Articles of Incorporation. Of the. North Star Community Foundation

IFF Position Description. Title: Managing Director, Credit and Policy. Reports to: Senior Vice President, Capital Solutions.

Homeownership Policies to Improve the Financial Security of Households of Color and Low-Income Families. September 25, 2017

S TAT U S R E P O R T

Lynn Todman, PhD. Executive Director of Population Health Lakeland Health

Nonprofits face many challenges. Growing investments. to support your operational needs. Meeting the need for

STRATEGIC PLAN PERFORMANCE MEASURES COMMITTEE TORONTO PUBLIC LIBRARY BOARD. AGENDA Page 1

Community Development Financial Institutions Fund United States Department of the Treasury. Performance and Accountability Report FY 2010

United Way Financial Stability Partnership

Introduction. The Assessment consists of: Evaluation questions that assess best practices. A rating system to rank your board s current practices.

Submission. To the Senate Standing Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology. February Presented by Hilary Pearson, President

Benefits of Credit Reporting

Capacity Development Strategies and Priorities Supporting Research, Developing Minds

Ken Goodgames Chief Executive Officer Transformance

27% 42% 51% 16% 51% 19% PROFILE. Assets & opportunity ProfILe: PortLANd. key highlights. ABoUt the ProfILe ASSETS & OPPORTUNITY

Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC): A Major Financial Benefit to Low Income Families

Igniting Change An Introduction to RBC s Social Finance Initiative

CASUALTY ACTUARIAL SOCIETY STRATEGIC PLAN

PROFESSIONAL COMPENSATION. A Position Paper. Prepared by the AFP Ethics Committee Adopted March, 1992 Revised September 2016

GENDER EQUALITY BOND PROGRESS REPORT

PRIMARY MEMBERSHIP GUIDE

Transcription:

The Equifax Equation Innovative Corporate Citizenship

Mission & Vision: Delivering Financial Capability At Equifax, we focus on supporting healthy communities starting with our own internal community of engaged employees. Central to our approach is a desire to engage in a collaborative process with residents, non-profits, fellow corporations, foundations and government stakeholders. We implicitly understand that businesses cannot be healthy and successful if the society around them is ill. As a world class provider of information solutions in the financial sector, we seek to balance our business priorities with complimentary focus areas in underserved communities often with a special emphasis on creating economically healthy individuals and communities. With operations across the globe, Equifax understands that our human and financial investments will vary from community to community. However, through strategic alignment of our resources, insights, and financial partnerships we can transform the communities in which we live and work. Proving the WHY In the 21st century, there must be a closer relationship between business priorities and corporate citizenship. As global partnerships and international collaboration becomes the standard, there are new opportunities for corporations to use their skills, expertise and services to make communities better. We must create a new narrative for corporate philanthropy as an investment in society. A collaboration of top executives noticed that, Most companies still perceive their philanthropy as charity. They do not focus on the actual results of their philanthropy or how it has affected the company s interests. They advocate for a rethinking, where, Companies view their philanthropy as contributors to breakthrough collaborations and innovations that address complex social challenges. This aim benefits everyone - as communities gain financial independence, goods and services provided by Equifax gain customers, creating a mutually beneficial cycle of financial capability. Emerging Trends in Corporate Philanthropy Operations In order for us to maximize our community engagement across all operations we must adopt best practices and innovate Traditional Philanthropy Emerging Best Practices Charity Mindset Investment Mindset Transactions Relationships Isolated Aligned and Integrated Cash, Employees Cash, Employees, Full Value Chain Managerial Function A Leadership Function 2

Our Emphasis on Financial Capability Financial Capability: What is it? The President s Advisory Council on Financial Capability defines financial capability as the capacity, based on knowledge, skills, and access, to manage financial resources effectively. Knowledge What a person knows about positive money management Knowing where to go and what to do Financial literacy Action What a person does with their financial knowledge Does behavior match knowledge? Influences Factors that contribute to beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors External and internal supports and barriers Access Availability and use of appropriate financial products and services Does a person have access to services? Financial Education Small Business Support & Workforce Development Innovation & Entrepreneurship 1 2 3 Supporting individuals to make, manage, and invest money toward asset-building. Supporting small businesses and job training to promote equity and well being. Building capacity and support for communities to develop solutions that address complex issues. Partner with non-profits, credit unions, fellow foundations and corporations, and neighborhood leaders to create opportunities for financial counseling. Create insight into capabilities of local workforce, access to practical skill development and mentorship, connections between small businesses and access to credit. Drive creativity and innovation across all of our investments with a special emphasis on co-location opportunities with tech and entrepreneurship zones, sponsorship of innovation programs, and access to resources to accelerate new ideas. 3

Understanding Our Efforts to Outcomes Our goal is to move from a traditional approach which places philanthropy first to an innovative strategy where investments are aligned and integrated with our core business strategies. One way to go about this is to determine the economic development index for our investments Elements of the index could include: Leverages Equifax Foundation Funding Utilizes Equifax Volunteers Leverages Equifax Solutions Partners with Equifax Customers Partners with Equifax Vendors Develops Community Financial Skills Directly Creates Employment Focused on Target Neighborhood 4

Understanding Our Efforts to Outcomes Over time the Equifax economic development index has improved Equifax Economic Development Index 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 ^ Investment in North St. Louis ^ Atlanta Westside 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Leverages Equifax Foundation Funding Utilizes Equifax Volunteers Leverages Equifax Solutions Partners with Equifax Customers Partners with Equifax Vendors Develops Community Financial Skills Develops Community Employment Focused on Target Neighborhood Index Partner X 7 Partner X - Partner X 3 Partner X 13 Partner X 17 Partner X 3 Partner X 27 Rick Smith At Equifax, we believe Corporate Social Responsibility exists beyond simple philanthropic investments. The essential lifeblood of our community engagement stems from the dual goal of creating a rewarding environment for our employees as well as powerful opportunities for the citizens of our global community. By leveraging our employees skillsets and their desire to make a contribution, we are able to create positive and measurable impact. As an innovative global information solutions company that enables access to credit, our unique commitment aligns our workforce s professional talents, core business competencies and philanthropic resources to enrich the communities in which we live and work. I wholeheartedly support Equifax community efforts and am extremely proud of the work we are doing to improve the financial capability, and ultimately the possibility of a brighter future, of consumers around the world. 5

Implementing The Strategy Through Centers of Engagement Business Products & Services Philanthropy Impact Volunteerism 6

Center of Engagement: Business Products and Services Business Products & Services Better alignment of philanthropic resources with existing and emerging products and services is imperative if we are to achieve lasting impact. Such alignment offers us the opportunity to not only address societal challenges on a global scale, but exceed the limitations of traditional philanthropy. Equifax Supplier Diversity Program Provide Fair Opportunity for Minority-Owned and Women-Owned Businesses to Compete for Procurement of Goods & Services 2010 Dodd-Frank Act: Implement Supplier Diversity Policy Evaluate and Assess Program Engage in Outreach Practices Compliance Competitive Advantage Supplier Diversity Corporate Social Responsibility Business Imperative: Enable Revenue Growth - Projected $100M+ Facilitate Government RFX Initiatives Meet Customer Mandates in B2B Ethical Inclusion: Commitment to Equifax Foundation Ensure Supplier Base is Diverse ($35M Identified) Enhance Image in Community/Industry 7

Key Program Elements Outreach Selection Tracking Reporting Councils Membership and engagement Conferences promote Equifax opportunities Workshops provide sessions to suppliers Registration portal for suppliers to access Buying Groups engage Equifax 4 Buying Groups Opportunities determine sourcing needs RFPs make suppliers aware of opportunities Solicitation facilitate supplier participation Requirements be in compliance with contracts Source develop & maintain listing of suppliers Certifications determine official status of suppliers Contracts identify population/create repository Goal Setting establish enterprise spend targets Spend Analysis review trends in supplier spend Metrics track/submit per contract requirement Monitoring consistency across contracts Status November 2016: Policy document ownership with Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) team within HR Program details ongoing management by Third Party Oversight (TPO) team Benchmark review visited with Coca-Cola and participated in diversity councils outreach events Partnerships with CSR and the St. Louis Small Business Devlp Corp on economic inclusion Scope analysis program enables expanded sales opportunities within government & mortgage verticals Products & Services: The Work Number, credit pulls, data analytics Case Study: Per Scholas Per Scholas, a national non-profit providing IT job training to low income individuals, uses The Work Number. Their greatest need is technical support and advice on bulk or nonprofit pricing, optimizing their use, and other services Equifax regularly provides to general consumers. Community Affairs + Supplier Diversity Program Setting attainable goals for making purchases from minority-owned businesses (MBEs) and womenowned business (WBEs) is critical to the success of any supplier diversity program. Goals set the necessary performance standards. They are established by customer requirements, benchmarking and using historical best performance. Case Study: Federal Reserve Bank of New York The Federal Reserve Bank used credit bureau data from Equifax on local and financial health in order to identify and understand the financial circumstances and needs of communities, which led to development of policies and effective practices, as well as metrics, to foster financial capability. 8

Center of Engagement: Philanthropy Philanthropy Maximize Foundation grants, Matching Gifts & Annual Giving Campaigns through better alignment with core business competencies and volunteer efforts Foundation Grants: dollars allocated by the Foundation Trustees and Community Affairs Team to agencies and organizations aligned with our strategic focus. Matching Gifts: The Equifax Matching Gifts Program was established to support the interests and concerns of our employees, and to recognize and encourage active community involvement. Under the plan provisions, cash donations made by employees to qualified charitable, educational, and other nonprofit organizations are matched by Equifax with dollar-for-dollar contributions called matching gifts. Regular full-time and part-time employees may participate in the matching gifts plan after completing 90 days of service. Employees may request up to a maximum of $5,000 dollars per calendar year to match their personal cash donations to qualified nonprofit organizations. A minimum donation of $50 dollars to a single organization is required to qualify for a matching gift. Employees may choose to divide the Equifax matching gift maximum amount between one or more nonprofit organizations. Annual Giving Campaigns: annual commitment to the United Way as well as the Woodruff Arts Campaign Center (Atlanta only). Disaster Relief efforts: Leadership will review investments in disaster relief efforts based on the following two considerations. First, do we want primarily to give philanthropic donations, or do we want to engage in efforts to improve the aid delivery process at a more systemic level. Second, do we want to foster a deep partnership with a single agency, or do we want to pool our resources with other companies to extend their impact to more aid agencies by joining one of several recently established consortiums. 9

Center of Engagement: Volunteerism Volunteerism We need to make volunteerism a business priority and view the function as a strategic asset in talent attraction and retention. Our commitment to volunteerism is threefold. First, skills-based volunteering means leveraging the specialized skills and talents of individuals to strengthen the infrastructure of nonprofits, helping them build and sustain their capacity to successfully achieve their missions. Secondly, volunteerism is an opportunity for us to further develop talent. Finally, volunteerism takes on the form of Affinity Groups to help drive a sophisticated and responsive internal culture. $2,400 On average, every employee who participates in corporate community engagement activities adds of value to the company as a result of decreased turnover and increased employee engagement. HR IT Marketing / Communications Finance Legal Operations Remote Employees Volunteerism Strengthening Communities Talent Development Affinity Groups Building an effective internal and external network of volunteers and Volunteer Effort Leaders is critical to extending our impact. Towards that end we will create the following: Volunteer Advisory Committee on Financial Capability Recommend engagements based on investments and strategy Track impact Communicate the narrative through internal and external channels Alumni Volunteer Corps on Financial Capability We need to preserve institutional memory and leverage experience to support our investments 10

An Example of The Future of Catalytic Partnerships Catalytic Partnership: Federation The National Federation of Community Development Credit Unions is a network of Community Development Credit Unions (CDCUs) organized by, of and for low-income people. Their mission is to help low- and moderate- income people and communities achieve financial independence through credit unions. With more than 200 member credit unions serving more than 5 million members nationwide, there is great opportunity in this partnership. Investor CDFI Intermediary invested $120M in CDCUs since Inception Secondary Mortgage Market for nonconforming CDCU mortgages Federation Innovator Capacity-Builder Advocate High-impact Financial Counseling model Immigrant Financial Inclusion Safe and affordable small dollar lending Technical Assistance and Consulting Online Small Business Lending System CU Impact: Core Banking Platform Support CDCUs and consumer protection with CFPB and NCUA Partner with credit union industry and CUNA CDFI Fund supporter and collaborator The chart above details the major components of the Federation, as an investor, innovator, capacity-builder and advocate. We increase our recognition as a key player in the advancement of financial capability. There is potential to support delivery of financial counseling through credit unions through provision of credit data to counselors and their clients. We can also integrate The Work Number into CDCU lending to expand access to credit in low-income communities. Collaborative research on the impact that utilization of Equifax consumer data has on financial health has long-term impacts on our corporate philanthropy. The countless opportunities for partnership with the Federation are in line with a shift in our understanding of corporate citizenship. 11

Continue to Use Geographic Footprints as Testing Grounds for Impact and Innovation Tier 1 Castleberry Hill English Avenue Vine City Tier 2 Ashview Heights Atlanta University Center (AUC) Bankhead Grove Park Washington Park Tier 3 Zip code 30314 Zip code 30318 The National Federation of Community Development Credit Unions operates across several dimensions including as an investor, innovator, capacity-builder and advocate. Equifax s active partnership with them supports our goal of building financial capability in underserved communities. They can leverage our unique assets as they build this capability: Federation Capability Delivery of financial counseling through credit unions Expand access to credit in lowincome communities Guide community in focus areas for growth Equifax Support Provision of credit data to counselors and their clients Integrate The Work Number into CDCU lending; establish greater VOE and VOI hit rate Delivery of geographic financial profile insights to identify coverage gaps Financial Education Geographic Footprints Small Business Support & Workforce Development Innovation & Entrepreneurship 12

Westside Financial Capability Center St. Louis: North City St. Louis s Old North Neighborhood is one of the most historic communities in the region, dating back nearly 200 years. Over the past few decades, the community has undergone economic disinvestment and a loss of population. Currently, the neighborhood contains 47% residents living in poverty, with an unemployment rate of 23%. Over the past decade, Equifax has made major investments in the neighborhood through financial capability, educational and workforce development, as well as physical infrastructure. These projects have included vacant land programs like Land Labs (below left) and financial literacy programs supporting Grace Hill and other community stakeholders. EQUIFAX INVESTMENTS AND NORTHSIDE STL CONTEXT OLD NORTH ST LOUIS DEMOGRAPHICS: Gender: Male: 1853 Female: 1690 Race: Black: 78% White: 19% Other: 3% Housing Units: Vacant 41.51% Employment: Poverty 48.5% 47.7% 52.3% Food Preparation 19.6% Office Support 17.4% Custodial/Janitorial 9.2% Healthcare Staff 5.9% Occupied 59.49% National Geospatial Agency Site Choice Neighborhood Housing Focus Old North St. Louis Equifax Focus Area Near North Side STL Choice Neighborhood Planning Initiative 13

Extending Impact Through Our Financial Capability Centers North St. Louis Excel Center Inputs Activities Outputs Outcomes Funding Staff Partners Data Management System Provide one-on-one financial coaching Provide group classes # individuals reached through one-on-one coaching sessions # clients who create an action plan to reach financial goals # clients who decrease outstanding debt # clients who increase credit score # clients who increase personal savings # clients who become banked # clients who acquire an asset Knowledge, Beliefs, Attitudes and Skills Clients have greater knowledge and skills related to personal finance Clients have greater awareness of available community resources Clients have increased confidence in their current and future financial aptitude Clients have a greater sense of financial security Behaviors Clients utilize healthy financial products and services Clients develop and practice healthy financial habits Facility Curriculum # clients who report increased level of confidence in their ability to achieve their financial goals Status/Condition Clients realize improvement in their financial wellness and well-being Refer clients to safe and reliable products and services #individuals reached through classes # referrals made Short-Term Medium-Term Long-Term # individuals reached through events Participate in external events # individual who utilize Excel Center services 14

Westside Financial Capability Center Financial Capability Center Non-profit that returns net income to community through education and services 1 Pathway to mainstream banking services through financial coaching and education 2 Safe, affordable banking services for the unbanked and/or underserved 3 Financial Capability Center: A destination point for affordable banking and loan services, financial classes, and one-on-one financial counseling - all free to the community - with the goal of improving the financial and personal lives of individuals and families. It is a proven model with strong potential for replicability and scalability. Financial Institiution A credit union is a member-owned financial cooperative operated to promote community development and provide financial services to its members. Proposed Products and Services Low-cost, trusted, alternative source for financial services Microlending Small Dollar Payday Alternative Loans Second Chance Checking Check cashing 15

Financial Capability Center Social Entrepreneurship & Small Business Support In Progress Next Steps Notes Extending services available through the Small Business Empowerment Center to North St. Louis business owners and community members. Services include assistance with tax credits, securing loans, planning, government contracting, access to capital, and various forms of technical assistance Small Business Empowerment Center partners with training centers to offer classes and train business owners and individuals to get businesses up and running successfully. The Center acts as a conduit for funding, providing coaches/ counselors to help coordinate efforts, and emphasizes healthy economic growth Development of the St. Louis Metropolitan Business League The St. Louis Metropolitan Business League will be built out from current business efforts to create a service/resource district housed in one large warehouse space. Ten businesses have been identified to fill the space, and offer a range of services including healthcare, construction and building resources, inventory management services, a food court, and additional communal offce space Establish a rotating schedule for when services and training classes will be provided and who will be available for consultation Raise awareness of services available and how utilizing the supports offered through the Small Business Empowerment Center can benefit area businesses and entrepreneurs Construction of the warehouse space will begin in 2017 Business owners will recruit employees from North St. Louis communities LinkStL will assist with recruitment efforts with priority given to the Old North and Hyde Park neighborhoods 16

Emerging Opportunities CDFI & Credit Union Markets Coordination with additional International Equifax offices Canada United Kingdom El Salvador Uruguay Paraguay 16-8641 17