Financial Crisis What do we know?

Transcription

1

2 Financial Crisis What do we know? Pedro Videla IESE

3 Global

4 Propagation of the Financial Crisis United Kingdom Ireland Iceland United States Spain January 2008 March 2008 June 2008 September 2008 January 2009

5 Propagation of the Financial Crisis Canada United States Iceland United Kingdom Ireland France Spain Portugal Germany Belgium Italy Japan Mexico January 2008 March 2008 June 2008 September 2008 January 2009

6 Propagation of the Financial Crisis Canada United Etats-Unis States Mexique Mexico Iceland Ukraine Slovenia United Kingdom Baltic Countries Ireland France Spain Portugal Germany Hungary Belgium Croatia Greece Italy Pakistan UAE Taiwan Hong Kong Japan January 2008 Vietnam March 2008 Equateur Ecuador Singapore Singapour June 2008 Chili Chile Afrique South du Africa Sud Australia September 2008 January 2009

7 Propagation of the Financial Crisis Canada United States Mexico Iceland Ukraine Slovenia United Kingdom Baltic Countries Ireland Germany Hungary France Belgium Croatia Spain Greece Pakistan Portugal Italy UAE RUSSIA CHINA Taiwan Hong Kong Japan Vietnam January 2008 March 2008 Ecuador Singapore June 2008 Chile South Africa Australia September 2008 January 2009

8 Global Equity Markets 14,000 (close - price) (close - price) 180 (US$ returns, 12/31/2008 = 100) 13,000 Dow Jones 1, ,000 1, , ,000 9,000 8,000 S&P 500 1,200 1, Latin Latin America Asia Asia 7,000 6,000 Standard & Poors 500 Composite Index (Right) Dow Jones Industrial Average Index (Left) Europe 40 EM Asia EM Europe EM Latin America Jan-07 Apr-07 Jul-07 Oct-07 Jan-08 Apr-08 Jul-08 Oct-08 Jan-09 Apr-09 8 Source: Bloomberg, Market Data, Last Update Jan

9 Credit Market Losses: All Financials (bill. Usd) Credit turmoil losses since beginning of 2007 Europe, Asia, 33.9 Americas Europe Asia Americas, Source: Bloomberg, Quarterly, Last update March 2, 2009

10 Global GDP Growth (%) 6 (% change year ago) Source: IMF, av. Annual growth rates, last update Jan , WEO (2008 Estimate, 2009 forecast) 10

11 Real GDP Growth last quarter 2008 % Last quarter at annual rate USA Eurozone Germany Japan Singapore S. Korea Source: RGE

12 IMF s Financial Packages since September 2008 Country IMF ($ bl) Total ($ bl.) % of GDP Belarus Hungary Iceland Latvia Pakistan Ukraine Source: IMF, WEO Jan. 2009

13 Recurrent

14 Proportion of Countries with Financial Crises, Weighted by their share of world income The Great Depression Percent of counties The Panic of 1907 World War I The First Global Financial Crisis of 21st century Emerging Markets, Japan, the Nordic Countries, and US (S&L) Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

15 Capital Mobility and the Incidence of Financial Crisis High Index of Capital Mobility (left scale) Share of Countries in Banking Crisis (right scale) Low Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

16 Financial Crises since 1945 or independence Africa Asia Europe Latin America North America Oceania Advanced Economies Emerging Economies Share of years in crisis Number of crisis Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

17 Advanced Economies: Share of years in Financial Crises since 1800 or independence Norway US France UK Italy Finland India Canada Spain Japan Romania Belgium Denmark Hungary Germany Australia Sweden NewZealand Singapore Netherlands Austria Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009 Percent of Years

18 Costly

19 Impact of financial crises The historical examples of deep financial crises indicates: Recession 2 years Unemployment rises for four years Real housing prices fall for five years Massive increases in government debt at end

20 Advance Economies: Real Housing Prices and Financial Crises Big five crises: Spain 1977, Norway 1987, Finland 1991, Sweden 1991, and Japan Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2008

21 Advance Economies: Real Equity Prices and Financial Crises Average for Financial Crises in Advance Economies Index Index t-4=100 Average for the "Big 5 Crises Big five crises: Spain 1977, Norway 1987, Finland 1991, Sweden 1991, and Japan Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

22 Emerging Economies: Real Equity Prices and Financial Crises 40 Emerging Market Episodes 16 percent percent decline Index 10 percent percent decline Index t-4=100 The recovery of the equity market is much faster than the real estate e market Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

23 Real GDP Growth per Capita and Financial Crises in Advance Economies PPP Basis Average for the "Big 5 Crises Percent Average for Financial Crises in Advance Economies Big five crises: Spain 1977, Norway 1987, Finland 1991, Sweden 1991, and Japan Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

24 Real GDP Growth per Capita and Financial Crises in Emerging Markets PPP Basis Cnange (in index points) Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

25 Real GDP Growth per Capita and Financial Crises PPP Basis Big five crises: Spain 1977, Norway 1987, Finland 1991, Sweden 1991, and Japan Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

26 Financial crisis summary: Peak-to-trough changes, all countries Averages Real housing prices Real equity prices Unemployment, trough-to-peak Real per capita GDP Cumulative % change Duration 5 years 3.4 years 4.8 years 1.9 years

27 Ongoing Crisis

28 Real Equity Prices and Financial Crises Peak-to to-trough trough Price Declines (left panel) and Years Duration of Downturn n (right panel) percent 3.4 years Percent decline Duration in years Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

29 Unemployment Cycles and Financial Crises Peak-to to-trough trough Percent Increase in the Unemployment Rate (left panel) and Years Duration of Downturn (right panel) 7 percent 4.8 years Percent increase Duration in years Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

30 Real Per Capita GDP Cycles and Financial Crises Peak-to to-trough trough Percent Decline in Real GDP (left panel) and Years Duration of Downturn (right panel) -9.3 percent 1.9 years Percent decrease Duration in years Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

31 IMF Packages Compared to Past Crises

32 Comments While each crisis has idiosyncratic features (the Icelandic one being no exception), the run-up and unfolding of the current crisis bears many similarities to past episodes of financial crises. Furthermore, the data shows despite what the media says-- that the current situation of the Icelandic economy is no worse than many past financial crises. In fact, Iceland has better economic foundations than many of the countries in the sample analyzed (more on this later). Therefore, despite the current hardship, Iceland has reason to be optimistic about the recovery.

33 Lessons

34 Lesson 1: Social Policies The evidence shows that the negative impact on unemployment is deeper and more pervasive than is the impact on output. Therefore government policies should focus on minimizing the social impact of the crisis. The social policies implemented should neither distort the labor market nor kill incentives. The evidence shows that although output contractions are more severe in emerging markets, they present a lower increase in unemployment.

35 Lesson 2: Fiscal Policy The banking crisis should not result in a debt crisis. That the nearly universal focus on calculations of bailout costs as the centerpiece of the fiscal consequences of financial crises is misguide and incomplete. Financial crises weaken fiscal positions beyond the costs of bailouts, as government revenues contract and stimulus plans find favor.

36 Fiscal Impact of Financial Crises Country, crisis year Argentina, 2001 Chile, 1980 Colombia, 1998 Finland, 1991 Indonesia, 1997 Japan, 1992 Korea, 1997 Malaysia, 1997 Mexico, 1994 Norway, 1987 Spain, 1977 Sweden, 1991 Thailand, 1997 Year before the crisis Peak deficit (year) Central government balance/gdp (2002) -3.2 (1985) -7.4 (1999) (1994) -3.7 (2001) -8.7 (1999) -4.8 (1998) -5.8 (2000) -2.3 (1998) -2.5 (1992) -3.1 (1997) (1993) -3.5 (1999) Increase (- decrease) in the fiscal deficit

37 Cumulative increase in public debt in the three years following the banking crisis Index = 100 in year of crisis Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2008

38 Proportion of Countries with Banking and Debt Crises, Weighted by their share of world income Banking Crisis Debt Crisis Percent of counties Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

39 Watch-out for stimulus plans The government should not try to spend its way out of the crisis. Evidence shows that governments engage in stimulus packages often involving wasteful expenditure programs. At the height of Japan s banking crisis in the 1990s, repaving the streets in Tokyo became a routine exercise. As a result, Japan s gross debtto-gdp ratio is now nearly 200 percent and a drag on what once was a vibrant economy.

40 Watch out for tax increases To a great extent, fiscal positions weaken because output contracts. An increase in the tax rates may therefore decrease tax collection. Higher taxes declining output. A declining output declining tax collection.

41 Real Government Revenue and Financial Crises in Advance Economies Average for Financial Crises in Advance Economies Percent Average for the "Big 5 Crises Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

42 Real Government Revenue and Financial Crises in Emerging Markets percent Source: Reinhart and Rogoff, 2009

43 Lesson 3: Adopt the EURO It can be claimed that the current banking could have been avoided if Iceland would have been inside the EMU. Caveat: EMU membership eliminates liquidity problems, not solvency problems. The choice is NOT between euro adoption and independent monetary policy. The choice is between euro adoption and a closed financial market.

44 Which is more vulnerable? Stocks* Score Housing* Score Current acount** Score Household debt*** Score Average Score Iceland Spain UK US France Italy Germany Japan * % change end 2002 to mid-2007 ** 2007 ***Change between 2002 and 2007 Source: OECD, Haver, DB Global Markets Research

45 Fiscal Impact of Financial Crises Country, crisis year Argentina, 2001 Chile, 1980 Colombia, 1998 Finland, 1991 Indonesia, 1997 Japan, 1992 Korea, 1997 Malaysia, 1997 Mexico, 1994 Norway, 1987 Spain, 1977 Sweden, 1991 Thailand, 1997 Year before the crisis Peak deficit (year) Central government balance/gdp (2002) -3.2 (1985) -7.4 (1999) (1994) -3.7 (2001) -8.7 (1999) -4.8 (1998) -5.8 (2000) -2.3 (1998) -2.5 (1992) -3.1 (1997) (1993) -3.5 (1999) Increase (- decrease) in the fiscal deficit

46 Economic Foundations Abundant natural resources Favorable demographics Fully funded pension system Flexible labor market Competitive tax system Good education system and health system

47 Capital Flows: The highway analogy Superhighways: Modern financial markets get you where you want to go, but accidents at high speeds are more likely fatal, and so more care is required. Capital flows sudden stops: It s not the speed that kills, it s the sudden stops

48 Capital Flows: The highway analogy Is it the road or the driver? Even when multiple countries have accidents in the same stretch of road, their own policies are also important determinants; it s not just the fault of the system. Contagion is also a contributor to multi-car accidents. So a countries should implement reforms & prudential regulation to their financial system. Routine defensive driving: Keeping high reserves, low government debt and an economy open to trade is like leaving ample following-distance. The best defensive driving strategy is to adopt the a international lender of last resort

49 Conclusion Very difficult and risky GLOBAL recession. Efficient government response is warranted: short run remedies are necessary but not the solution. Capital controls Fiscal policy The history of financial crises suggests a good chance that growth will no longer be negative by the ½ half of The Icelandic economic foundations allow us to be optimistic about the future. But this is contingent to the right choice of policies.