Comments on IMF Taxation of Natural Resource Rents Paper. Revenue Watch, April 2012
|
|
- Silas Horton
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Comments on IMF Taxation of Natural Resource Rents Paper Revenue Watch, April 2012 Revenue Watch Institute (RWI) is pleased to offer the following observations on selected questions raised in the IMF s consultation paper on the taxation of natural resource rents. A number of common threads run through our comments: While there can be no one-size-fits-all fiscal regime appropriate for every country, fiscal regimes should generally have certain core features. o Gross income-based, royalty-type fiscal tools ensure that states directly share in the value of their resource endowments and assure governments a baseline level of revenues throughout production. o Flexible fiscal tools that are robust to changing economic circumstances enable states to share in windfalls, and are more credible than overly rigid contractually stabilized fiscal regimes. Fiscal regimes are best enshrined in generally applicable legislation, and ad hoc fiscal regime design in the context of negotiated agreements often results in sub-par fiscal regimes while exacerbating administration challenges. Well designed and transparent competitive rights allocation processes can support greater rent capture by the state. I/ Characteristics Bearing on Tax Design Whether weaknesses in macro-fiscal management within a resource rich country should inform tax design is a complicated question. Poor macro-fiscal management could weigh against design of a tax system that is excessively front-loaded. For instance, a fiscal regime emphasizing signature bonuses is likely to exacerbate the waste that accompanies weak macro-economic management. It is not necessarily the case, however, that a weak macro management environment should then weigh in favor of more rent-based systems (which tend to be more back-end loaded) over systems more heavily emphasizing royalties, for instance. Greater emphasis on profit- and rent-based measures can increase revenue volatility, the negative impact of which is likely to be much greater in a country with weak macro-fiscal management. We would argue that the need for a solid floor of revenues, as provided by a robust royalty, is even more important in a weak macro environment than elsewhere. However, we would also argue that all systems should have some mechanism for capturing a share of rents in the case of high windfall profits. While the increased revenues that can come with such tax systems will no doubt test weak macro-fiscal management systems, a 1
2 failure to share in windfalls makes a tax system vulnerable to excessive renegotiation and other disruptions that can be even more damaging, as discussed in greater detail below. Fiscal decentralization (distinguished from revenue sharing by the degree of autonomy in policy setting afforded the subnational government) can constrain rent capture in particular where subnational governments have weaker capacity than the central government or higher levels of corruption. Apart from these direct impacts on overall rent capture, fiscal decentralization can also have an important bearing on tax efficiency and the achievement of sector policy objectives. In order to maximize efficiency of revenue collection within a decentralized system and to reduce unnecessarily burdensome compliance costs borne by companies, rules should be carefully coordinated between the central and subnational governments. Australia s recent disputes between the central government and the states around the interaction of state-level royalties and the new central government resource rent tax illustrates well some of the challenges and the need for coordination. The creditability of state royalties against the MRRT sets up clear incentives for states to alter their royalty regimes, and the end result has potential to frustrate the intended effect of the new tax. II/ Specific circumstances: One size does not fit all Our reaction to this question is inherent in our responses to many of the questions discussed herein. Objective analysis of the modeled outcomes of fiscal packages under varying assumptions should serve as a core element of government decision-making. But it must be supplemented by a realistic assessment of the impact on various factors, including those listed below, on the tradeoffs among options and the likelihood of long-term success. Administrative Capacity. The relative ability of the state to monitor costs and counteract attempts to fiscal tax burdens to outside jurisdictions has a significant impact on a government s ability to successfully collect anticipated revenues. Policy-makers should take administrative capacity into account when choosing among fiscal instruments (see the discussion of royalties and resource rent taxes, below), and in the design of individual elements of the fiscal regime (particularly when dealing with transfer pricing, where administratively-challenged countries should seek to measure key variables relative to observable and verifiable variables such as world prices wherever possible. 1 Political Economy and Time Pressures. It has become a well-accepted position that in order to be stable, fiscal regimes should include progressive elements that are robust to changing circumstances, thus reducing the risk that as markets change citizens (or companies) will demand renegotiation as a result of feeling undercompensated for the value of the resource, as has happened repeatedly in recent years from Ecuador to Algeria to the Democratic Republic of Congo. At the same time, governments facing immediate-term time pressures to deliver results (a group including many new democracies in fragile states) have high political discount rates (see discussion of resource rent taxes vs. royalties, below), and may need to rely more heavily on fiscal instruments that deliver returns quickly. It is crucial that a system s design recognize these considerations and seek some effective valuation mechanism to help a government avoid sacrificing too much in the future in favor of revenues today. These considerations 1 Natural Resource Charter, November 2010, page 6, 2
3 are also important for governments considering fiscal packages that include direct provision of infrastructure or payments made by companies directly to communities. Rather than dismissing such approaches out of hand as deviations from traditional tax-and-spend theories of public finance, RWI encourages international technical assistance providers to help governments analyze the value of the offered goods more objectively, so as to more effectively weigh advantages and disadvantages while remaining responsive to citizen demands for visible benefits. Risk Tolerance. As is discussed in detail below, the greater the tolerance of a government for risk, the more fitting a system oriented primarily toward profits-based fiscal instruments is likely to be. III/ Observations on extent of rent capture In the majority of the countries in which Revenue Watch works, rents appear to be significantly under-taxed relative to potential or optimal tax levels. Revenue Watch s analysis of EITI report data highlights just how little some resource rich countries, especially countries dependent on mining, have managed to collect. 2 In at least one reporting year for which EITI reports have been produced, mining revenues totaled less than $30 million in each of the following countries: Sierra Leone, Niger, Ghana, Liberia, Burkina Faso and Mauritania. While project lifecycles or other specific circumstances explain these figures to some extent, the persistence of such low numbers across (and within) countries suggests broader failures of policy and/or implementation. A recent World Bank study on the mining sector in Zambia highlights the scale of the problem there: Despite the revival of the industry since privatization, the mining industry s contribution to government revenues has remained low, peaking at just 1.4 percent of GDP in Mining taxes amount to just 8 percent of total tax revenue. This is a low figure given the industry s share of GDP (15 18 percent) and the value of copper exports (over $3 billion). Worldwide, taxes represent between percent of export revenues. In Zambia, they represent 3 5 percent. 3 In the Philippines, the Finance Secretary recently revealed that the mining sector paid a mere $47 million in taxes in 2011, or 0.17% of total tax collections. Official statistics indicate a mineral export value for 2011 of $2.66 billion 4. The Philippine government s extremely poor resource rent collection is due to a host of factors, starting with widely granted and overly generous tax holidays and investment incentives and compounded by inadequate tax auditing and mineral production monitoring. These figures just a selection among many similar stories not only underscore the failure of countries to capture a fair share of mineral rents, they also highlight the inadequacy of some of the more commonly cited government take calculations, which appear at least in certain cases to overestimate the strength of 2 See A. Gillies: What Do the Numbers Say? Analyzing Report Data at 3 World Bank Zambia: What Would it Take for Zambia s Copper Mining Industry to achieve its Potential? Report No ZM (2011) at: /IB/2011/08/18/ _ /Rendered/PDF/623780ESW0Gray0e0only0900BOX361532B.pdf 4 See Exports by Major Commodity Groups at: 3
4 particular fiscal regimes by disregarding implementation failures or failing to take into account fully the effect of common incentives. Modeled take figures provide a useful basis for comparing fiscal regime design, but caution should be exercised in using them as a basis for predicting actual rent capture. IV/ Appropriate mix of royalty-type and rent-based taxes We believe that royalties should be a part of any well-designed extractive resource fiscal regime. Reasonable ad valorem royalties guarantee some revenue from the start of production and during periods of low profitability. Countries in a position to take on more risk, those with more diversified (and not highly correlated) resource bases, or those less reliant on resource revenues as a share of total revenues may well opt to de-emphasize royalties in favor of a larger (potential) share of rents, but even in such countries there is an opportunity cost to current production which should be reflected in the price of the resource to the producer. We believe that zeroroyalty regimes represent an inappropriate shifting of risk to the resource owner (the host country) risk that is exacerbated by the more difficult implementation of profit-based instruments requiring cost accounting. That being said, we believe that fiscal regimes focused too heavily on gross revenue-based measures are often susceptible to political pressure to renegotiate due to their inability to capture a significant share of unexpected windfalls. 5 So long as an adequate floor is created through a reasonable royalty and upside potential is preserved through use of more flexible instruments, we believe that the government s discount rate is a key factor in determining the relative mix of fiscal tools used. This will differ from country to country. Many resource rich developing countries face extremely urgent short term needs and many leaders, particularly in countries in early stages of transition, face significant political pressures to deliver results quickly in order to shore up legitimacy. While care must be taken to distinguish these preferences for short term revenues from run-of-the-mill short-sightedness, the high government discount rate implied by such preferences may weigh in favor of some form of bonus in certain cases, or a fiscal regime that otherwise ensures some significant early payment stream. V/ Administration challenges While the issue raised by the question in the discussion draft is no doubt of great importance, from our perspective a more fundamental impediment to extractive industry tax administration is the excessive use of bespoke agreements making ad hoc and often inconsistent changes to generally applicable fiscal rules. While variations to tax and royalty rates in negotiated agreements may not be appropriate policy, such variations do not generally pose material additional administrative burdens. However, where agreements deviate from basic legislative and regulatory rules in their calculation of income (e.g., utilizing different bases and value measurements for assessing royalties, providing entirely different thin capitalization rules or loss carry forward 5 Of course, gross-income based measures can be designed to capture an increasing share of rents. Variable rate royalties, for example, may utilize triggers based on changes to published price indices. While price alone is an imperfect proxy for rent, coupled with a review clause or other mechanisms such tools may be a means of balancing the respective advantages of royalties and rent-based mechanisms. 4
5 rules for different projects, allowing one company special exceptions to ring-fencing rules, establishing complicated multi-phase rate escalations for various charges, etc.) tax administrators and other regulatory bodies are put at a significant disadvantage. Greater use of standardized form agreements and reliance on legislated fiscal terms whatever the balance between gross income-based and rent-based tools ultimately chosen would foster much more efficient use of limited human and technological resources within already under-capacitated tax administrators. Questions of the relative ease of implementation of rent taxes versus royalties are certainly important, and we agree that rent taxes insofar as their cost accounting burden is not materially different from that of basic income taxes are not as difficult to administer as is often argued. VI/ Methods of awarding mineral and petroleum rights Where they are possible, competitive licensing processes provide the best tool for allocating petroleum and mineral contracts, and not just via the well-documented benefit of providing a market-based determinant of the government s maximum fiscal package. Well-designed bidding procedures provide the government with a system for choosing companies that are more likely to explore and develop resources effectively. Thus a competitive process can both enhance the likely fiscal take of the state in the event of production and increase the likelihood that production will be optimized (though there can be tension between these goals, as discussed below). An important component is the impact of auctions on middlemen companies that seek to profit from the undervaluation by the state of its assets while doing little or nothing to increase the expected value of a license. 6 Particularly in countries with weak institutions, these companies are frequently able to gain access to licenses through non-competitive processes, and can occupy acreage that could otherwise be more vigorously explored or developed by companies with deeper experience and a keener interest in investing. These middlemen sometimes seek to transfer (total or partial) control over the license to a company with a stronger commitment to investing. Several governments and international institutions (including the IMF) are working to improve strategies for taxing the inherent capital gain, but these mechanisms face certain fundamental challenges, and a competitive system that awards the right to the most effective partner from the outset represents a fundamentally more efficient mechanism for rent capture by the state (assuming, or course, that the underlying fiscal regime effectively captures a fair share of rent). An additional benefit of competitive award processes at least those which are conducted with appropriate levels of transparency is that by publicizing the bases of bids and awards, they provide an 6 This analysis should not be interpreted to suggest that there is no useful role for junior oil and mining companies that take on significant exploration risk and ultimately transfer control to another company for development or exploitation (though capturing capital gains poses a significant challenge for governments vis-à-vis these companies). 5
6 opportunity to increase public scrutiny on the execution of the contracts, thereby increasing the chances that the state and the contractor will abide by the agreed terms. The Republic of Guinea presents a powerful example of the risk of lost value associated with noncompetitive licensing processes, and of the potential of competition to be extended to new areas. In 2008, the Guinean government regained control of half of a concession that by that point had been demonstrated to contain one of the most attractive iron ore deposits in the world. The government awarded this relinquished acreage behind closed doors, to a company with no experience developing large-scale iron ore projects. Two years later, the company is reported to have sold a controlling interest in the project to another global iron major at a value of $2.5 billion. This represents value that could have accrued directly to the state if the allocation process was more efficient and the fiscal regime sufficiently robust. In its reform to the country s mining legislation, the new government elected in late 2010 decided to require that for any areas already prospected, containing a known deposit or attracting the interest of several companies, award will only be made via competitive tender. This sort of provision can be used to extend the reach of competitive processes beyond petroleum and into mining, where first-come-first-served awards have been more common. Despite the well-established benefits of competitive award procedures, many countries continue to award rights via opaque and closed-door proceedings, even in petroleum. A recent survey by Revenue Watch indicates that for many countries at the early stages of the development of their petroleum industries, including Ghana, Uganda and Sierra, licenses have overwhelmingly been awarded via noncompetitive processes. One challenge that international technical assistance providers can help governments overcome is the information deficits that prompt many public officials to shy away from public tenders because they believe that oil companies consider them to be frontier states that are not sufficiently attractive to justify bidding. We have encountered this argument frequently in our engagement with governments, particularly in Africa, and believe that it is important to give governments tools to recognize the attractiveness of their potential assets, particularly given the evolution of the global oil market and the intense competition among international oil companies for limited open acreage. It is important to note that by standardizing fiscal terms in law to the maximum extent possible and by insisting that contracts conform to the generally-applicable regime, states can reduce the impact of licensing processes on fiscal floors, enabling governments to direct selection criteria at technical competence, work plans and/or bids on fiscal terms (bonuses, production share) that build on the established floors. Beyond the classical considerations that go into the careful design of bidding systems (how many biddable terms, which biddable terms, etc.), it is also important that policy-makers structure auctions to reflect consideration of the following: 6
7 Pre-qualification. In order to accurately reflect market perceptions and achieve the goals of finding optimal contractors, governments must include rigorous pre-qualification procedures. Where company bids are not subject to strong pre-qualification, governments can encounter the situation most infamously encountered in Nigeria in the mid-2000s, wherein companies win ostensibly competitive bids only to either fail to make the payments due or to seek to quickly flip control to a higher bidder and reap the benefits of the margin. Transparency of Bidding Procedures, Bids, Contracts and Beneficial Ownership. In order for competitive processes to meet their potential, they must be conducted transparently. This includes making sure that bidding criteria and timeframes are clearly explained and widely disseminated, that the content of winning and losing bids are disclosed wherever possible, that the contracts resulting from the processes are published and that the ultimate beneficial ownership of licensees is disseminated. 7 Without transparency, the likelihood that competition will, on its own, produce better fiscal terms and especially that it will produce more effective enforcement of those tools is greatly reduced, especially in countries with weak institutions. In connection with the discussion in preceding questions on appropriate context-specific fiscal design, it is important that auctions are designed so as to be compatible with the financial goals and the political economy of the country in question. When deciding whether to establish a signature bonus, profit oil split or work program as the principal biddable item, a government should reflect carefully on short- and medium-term revenue projections, enforcement capability, geological risk and political pressures. An award based primarily on the work program, for example, may result in a lower promised fiscal package than one emphasizing the profit split, but this may be justified if the government is prioritizing maximum exploration of its acreage as its most important goal. Outside technical service providers would be well-served to help governments analyze these questions in context rather than proposing generic solutions based purely on numerical models of economic efficiency. VII/ Stability and credibility of fiscal regimes In the vast majority of cases, countries would be better off utilizing a fiscal regime established through general legislation. As noted in our response to earlier questions on ease of administration, we see clear evidence that contract negotiations involving numerous or significant deviations from generally applicable fiscal rules can undermine administrative efficiency and effectiveness. At the same time, the contract negotiation and renegotiation process itself can strain limited human resources within government, particularly where there is limited technical expertise within relevant ministries, and excessively drawn-out or poorly managed renegotiation processes the risk of which is heightened where government capacity is already low can discourage investors, leading to unnecessary delays on 7 For a more detailed discussion of the elements of a transparent allocation process, see Global Witness, Rigged? The Scramble for Africa s Oil, Gas and Minerals, January 2012, 7
8 current or planned projects. 8 Of course, negotiations over some aspects of major extractive projects are inevitable, but negotiations over fiscal regimes are often the most contentious and fiscal elements are better established in law. Negotiations should be reserved for other project-specific considerations. Legislated fiscal regimes may also have positive impact on investor perception of risk, as contract-based fiscal regime raise the likelihood of discriminatory treatment of different investors. Lastly, negotiations too often result in sub-par fiscal regimes, particularly where negotiable issues are not clearly defined in law and ministerial discretion is unchecked. For all of these reasons, we strongly believe that greater standardization is to the benefit of governments. That being said, the question posed here appears to consider the negotiation vs. general legislation decision in terms of its impact on stability and credibility. We would argue that legal stability is quite distinct from the issue of credibility, and that true stability (we prefer the term robustness to distinguish this concept from that of contractual stabilization) is more a function of the fiscal regime s elements than of the instruments that create that regime. The last several years have seen many contracts with legal stabilization agreements come under renegotiation pressure, as the terms so stabilized resulted in unsustainable rent sharing under sharply higher mineral prices. Such contracts were apparently not stable, even with the threat of arbitration. 9 Rather than relying on outdated notions of contractual stabilization, we believe the better approach is for governments to develop robust fiscal regimes that respond predictably to changes in economic circumstances and in a manner that preserves incentives for investors while effectively capturing a fair share of rents for the government. In this regard, flexible fiscal instruments such as resource rent taxes are quite promising. Contact: Matthew Genasci Head, Legal and Economics Revenue Watch Institute mgenasci@revenuewatch.org 8 Despite these risks, renegotiation can be worthwhile as a response to substantially flawed deals. A number of countries Liberia and Sierra Leone for instance have managed to significantly increase rent capture on strategic projects governed by unbalanced contracts through formal renegotiation processes. These processes have been resource-intensive, however, and the end result has seldom been as favorable as the generally applicable law would have been. 9 See, e.g., P. Daniel and E.M. Sunley, Contractual Assurance of Fiscal Stability in The Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals: Principles, Problems and Practice (IMF and Routledge, 2010) at 419 ( In some of these cases [of fiscal term revision], fiscal stability assurance were included in agreements illustrating that they do not necessarily prevent renegotiation, or unilateral action by governments, when circumstances are perceived to have changed. Contract renegotiation appears to have occurred mainly where fiscal regimes in place did not contain instruments that could respond with adequate adaptability and progressivity to changed circumstances. ) 8
BEST PRACTICES IN IMPLEMENTING EITI
QUERY Can you provide information regarding best practices in EITI implementation? More specifically could you inform us about good practices related to (i) financial and non-financial data collection;
More informationMethodology of the Resource Governance Index
Methodology of the Resource Governance Index This methodology note explains what the Resource Governance Index (RGI) measures; how countries and sectors were selected; how data was collected and managed;
More informationTaxation of Natural Resource Rents: Questions, Approaches, Challenges
Philip Daniel Fiscal Affairs Department International Monetary Fund Taxation of Natural Resource Rents: Questions, Approaches, Challenges IMF Natural Resources Consultation Session on Taxation and Wealth
More informationResource Dependence and Budget Transparency By Antoine Heuty and Ruth Carlitz 1
By Antoine Heuty and Ruth Carlitz 1 Are natural resource abundance and opaque budgets inextricably linked? The Open Budget Survey 2008 a comprehensive evaluation of budget transparency in 85 countries
More informationTRAINING WORKSHOP FOR UEMOA MEMBERS STATES OFFICIALS ON MINING ECONOMICS
TRAINING WORKSHOP FOR UEMOA MEMBERS STATES OFFICIALS ON MINING ECONOMICS BAMAKO, MALI JULY 3 7, 2017 INTRODUCTION The training workshop for government agency officials from the member states of the West
More informationCan Bonus Bids Capture Economic Rent? Should Governments Opt for Increased Reliance on Bonus Bids Over Royalties?
Can Bonus Bids Capture Economic Rent? Should Governments Opt for Increased Reliance on Bonus Bids Over Royalties? The Toronto based C.D. Howe Institute (Institute) has recommended that governments should
More informationContractual Assurances of Fiscal Stability
Contractual Assurances of Fiscal Stability Philip Daniel and Emil M. Sunley September 19, 2008 This paper was prepared for the IMF conference on Taxing Natural Resources: New Challenges, New Perspectives,
More informationPrecept 4. Fiscal regimes and contract terms
Precept 4. Fiscal regimes and contract terms 1. Introduction 1 Technical Guide Fiscal regimes and their implementation are critical to the overall strength of the resource sector decision chain. The effectiveness
More informationThe benefits for Uganda of joining the emerging global transparency standard for extractive industry revenues
The benefits for Uganda of joining the emerging global transparency standard for extractive industry revenues August 2013 This paper summarizes the implications for Uganda of the new international transparency
More informationAzerbaijan Compliant since: Latest report: Government revenue: Population: Revenue per capita:
Azerbaijan 16 February 2009 2011 US $3 035 423 996 9 168 000 US $331 Total revenues received by the government from the oil, gas and mining sector in 2011 was over US $3 billion. But full picture is not
More informationNegotiations Roadmap
Background For many developing countries, large-scale projects carried out by foreign investors, for example, in extractive industries, or large-scale land investments in agriculture or forestry, are the
More informationMaking it add up. A constructive critique of the EITI Reporting Guidelines and Source Book
A constructive critique of the EITI Reporting Guidelines and Source Book Is the EITI Adding Up? Since its inception in 2003, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) has recorded some important
More informationTaxation of extractive industries in East and Central Africa. Are these in harmony?
Taxation of extractive industries in East and Central Africa Are these in harmony? Panel Moderator Panel Max Mangoro Silke Mattern Albena Todorova Partner EY Zimbabwe Partner EY Tanzania Partner EY Mozambique
More informationFINANCING MINING PROJECTS GLOBALLY AND CONSEQUENCES FOR THE MINING SECTOR IN KAZAKHSTAN
FINANCING MINING PROJECTS GLOBALLY AND CONSEQUENCES FOR THE MINING SECTOR IN KAZAKHSTAN KARSTEN FUELSTER KARSTEN FUELSTER SECTOR LEAD FOR OIL, GAS AND MINING IN EASTERN EUROPE, CENTRAL ASIA, MIDDLE EAST
More informationLEGISLATIVE COUNCIL Question on notice
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL Question on notice Tuesday, 17 February 2015 2338. Hon Robin Chappie to the Minister for Agriculture and Food representing the Minister for Mines and Petroleum. I refer to the royalty
More informationEffective Extractive Industries Taxation Regimes
Workshop on Mining Taxation African Union & European Commission in co-operation with UNECA Anton Mélard de Feuardent December 10, 2011 SUMMARY Specific for the Mining Sector Adjustment of taxation regimes
More informationFiscal Regimes for Mining
NATURAL RESOURCE TAXATION IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC REGION AUGUST 11-13, 2015 JAKARTA, INDONESIA Fiscal Regimes for Mining Bryan Land Lead Extractives Specialist Main message Governments should design the mining
More informationFiscal Regimes for Extractive Industries Design and Implementation
Fiscal Regimes for Extractive Industries Design and Implementation Peter Mullins Fiscal Affairs Department Conference on Natural Resource Taxation in the Asia-Pacific Region Jakarta, Indonesia August 11,
More informationOur commentary focuses on five main issues. Supplementary comments relating to specific paragraphs or issues are provided in the appendix.
Comments on the Revised Discussion Draft on Transfer Pricing Aspects of Intangibles by the Confederation of Netherlands Industry and Employers (VNO-NCW) We are pleased to see the significant progress which
More informationCURRENT TAX ISSUES IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
CURRENT TAX ISSUES IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES Policy Dialogue on Natural Resource-Based Development Work Stream 3 December 2015 Dan Devlin Tax and Development Programme Introduction key focus areas: Current
More informationFirst I would like to extent a sincere thank you the organizers of this conference. The topic is
The Role of Companies in Conflicts within the Court s Jurisdiction First I would like to extent a sincere thank you the organizers of this conference. The topic is cutting edge and of great importance
More informationAnnex. GUIDELINES FOR CONDUCTING ADVANCE PRICING ARRANGEMENTS UNDER THE MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE ("MAP APAs")
Annex GUIDELINES FOR CONDUCTING ADVANCE PRICING ARRANGEMENTS UNDER THE MUTUAL AGREEMENT PROCEDURE ("MAP APAs") A. Background i) Introduction 1. Advance Pricing Arrangements ("APAs") are the subject of
More informationAfDB. Africa Economic Brief. Fairer Mining Concessions in Africa: How Can this be Achieved? OUTLINE. Key Issues. Chief Economist Complex
Volume 3 Issue 3 April 2012 AfDB Chief Economist Complex Africa Economic Brief OUTLINE 1 Introduction 1 2 A Review of Mining Deals in Africa 2 3 Operationalizing Fair Mining Concessions 3 4 Conclusion
More informationE.ON General Statement to Margin requirements for non-centrally-cleared derivatives
E.ON AG Avenue de Cortenbergh, 60 B-1000 Bruxelles www.eon.com Contact: Political Affairs and Corporate Communications E.ON General Statement to Margin requirements for non-centrally-cleared derivatives
More informationRevenue Transparency in Extractive Economies: Innovations and Assessment Tools
Revenue Management in Hydrocarbon Economies: Panel on Transparency and Accountability Revenue Transparency in Extractive Economies: Innovations and Assessment Tools The University of the West Indies, St.
More informationFiscal Regimes for Extractive Industries The IMF s Work
Fiscal Regimes for Extractive Industries The IMF s Work VICTORIA PERRY IMF FISCAL AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT ECOSOC JUNE 5, 2014 Why distinct fiscal regimes for EI? Substantial rents Pervasive uncertainty 2 3
More informationNatural Resource Taxation: Challenges in Africa
Philip Daniel Fiscal Affairs Department International Monetary Fund Natural Resource Taxation: Challenges in Africa Management of Natural Resources in Sub-Saharan Africa Kinshasa Conference, March 22,
More informationFISCAL RULE OPTIONS FOR PETROLEUM REVENUE MANAGEMENT IN UGANDA
April 214 POLICY PAPER FISCAL RULE OPTIONS FOR PETROLEUM REVENUE MANAGEMENT IN UGANDA APPENDIX Revenue Watch Institute Thomas Lassourd Andrew Bauer Revenue Watch Institute Table of Contents Appendix 1:
More informationBlackRock Investment Stewardship
BlackRock Investment Stewardship Global Corporate Governance & Engagement Principles October 2017 Contents Introduction to BlackRock... 2 Philosophy on corporate governance... 2 Corporate governance, engagement
More informationConcept Release on possible revisions to PCAOB Standards related to reports on audited financial statements
Attachment A Concept Release on possible revisions to PCAOB Standards related to reports on audited financial statements Questions 1 through 32: 1. Many have suggested that the auditor's report, and in
More informationDraft Natural Resource Fiscal Transparency Code
Draft as of May 9, 2016 Draft Natural Resource Fiscal Transparency Code A. FISCAL TRANSPARENCY PRINCIPLES I. FISCAL REPORTING Fiscal reports should provide a comprehensive, relevant, timely, and reliable
More informationTaxing the Minerals Industry in Turbulent Times
Extractive Industries Week Taxing the Minerals Industry in Turbulent Times Moderated by Bryan Land Senior Oil, Gas and Mining Specialist, World Bank Preston Auditorium World Bank Washington DC March 4,
More informationGovernment Fiscal Take
Government 1. Executive Summary Government s share from development of natural resources can include many components. It is not limited to the taxes and e.g. royalties applicable to the extractive industry
More informationAfrica Upstream Fiscal Systems: Evaluation and Rating, and Analysis of State Company Participation
Africa Upstream Fiscal Systems: Evaluation and Rating, and Analysis of State Company Participation - CHAPTER 3: FISCAL SYSTEMS BACKGROUND & CONTEXT Prepared by: Rodgers Oil & Gas Consulting July, 2017
More informationSEC overhauls mining property disclosure regime
SEC Update January 16, 2019 This is a commercial communication from Hogan Lovells. See note below. SEC overhauls mining property disclosure regime On October 31, 2018, the SEC released comprehensive property
More informationTaxation of natural resources: principles and policy issues
Taxation of natural resources: principles and policy issues Charles Makola The better the question. The better the answer. The better the world works. Introduction Simplified economic and political framework
More informationHeads and staffs of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) and The Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI),
MANAGING NATURAL RESOURCE REVENUE FOR SUSTAINABLE GROWTH & DEVELOPMENT Opening Address by Mr. Alex Ashiagbor, Chairman of the Governing Council, IFS and former Governor of the Bank of Ghana Introduction
More informationRevenue Administration Reforms in Anglophone Africa since the early 1990s
Revenue Administration Reforms in Anglophone Africa since the early 1990s Developments & Trends David Kloeden IMF Fiscal Affairs Department Anglophone Sub-Saharan Africa Grouping West Africa Southern Africa
More informationReview of the legislative base for investments in oil and gas sector of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Maidan K Suleimenov Yerlan B Osipov Review of the legislative base for investments in oil and gas sector of the Republic of Kazakhstan An Executive Summary of the article by Suleimenov M.K. and Osipov
More informationThe expansion of the U.S. economy continued for the fourth consecutive
Overview The expansion of the U.S. economy continued for the fourth consecutive year in 2005. The President has laid out an agenda to maintain the economy's momentum, foster job creation, and ensure that
More informationEffects of Transfer Pricing in developing countries: Cases in Africa
ACCOUNTANTS ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2016 Effects of Transfer Pricing in developing countries: Cases in Africa APC- Bunju 3 rd December, 2016 CPA Ahmad Mohamed (MARLA, ADA, Dip-Edu) Disclaimer This presentation
More informationBasel Committee on Banking Supervision & Board of the International Organisation of Securities Commissions
1 Basel Committee on Banking Supervision & Board of the International Organisation of Securities Commissions Margin requirements for non-centrally cleared derivatives Response provided by: Standard Life
More informationThe Commission s Study on Company
HOME STATE TAXATION VS. COMMON BASE TAXATION jurisdictions by an automatic formula, and taxed at the national tax rates, which member states will continue to establish themselves. A comprehensive solution
More informationReforming State-Owned Enterprises in the Extractive Industries: International Experiences and Implications for Myanmar
Briefing January 2016 Reforming State-Owned Enterprises in the Extractive Industries: International Experiences and Implications for Myanmar Patrick R. P. Heller As Myanmar seeks to open its oil, gas and
More informationManaging Nonrenewable Natural Resources
International Monetary Fund Managing Nonrenewable Natural Resources Vitor Gaspar Fiscal Affairs Department Third IMF Statistical Forum: Official Statistics to Support Evidence-Based Policy-Making Frankfurt,
More informationREADING 5.1 SHARPENING A BUDGET ADVOCACY OBJECTIVE
READING 5.1 SHARPENING A BUDGET ADVOCACY OBJECTIVE The five elements of an advocacy strategy are as follows: 1. Strategic Analysis 2. Advocacy Objective 3. Stakeholder Analysis 4. Advocacy Message (Development
More informationPublic Expenditure and Financial Accountability Baseline Report. Central Provincial Government
Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability Baseline Report Central Provincial Government 1 Table of Contents Summary Assessment... 4 (i) Integrated assessment of PFM performance... 4 (ii) Assessment
More informationSovereign Wealth Funds and Long-Term Development Finance: Risks and Opportunities
Sovereign Wealth Funds and Long-Term Development Finance: Risks and Opportunities Alan Gelb, Silvana Tordo and Håvard Halland World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 6776 Natural Resource Charter Annual
More informationThe Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals: Principles, Problems and Practice
OxCarre Oxford Centre for the Analysis of Resource Rich Economies The Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals: Principles, Problems and Practice Edited by Philip Daniel, Michael Keen and Charles McPherson Routledge
More informationPension Schemes Bill Delegated Powers
Pension Schemes Bill Delegated Powers Memorandum from DWP to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee November 2014 1 Introduction The Pension Schemes Bill was introduced in the House of Commons
More informationSTRATEGIC CASE STUDY MAY 2015 EXAM ANSWERS Variant 1
STRATEGIC CASE STUDY MAY 2015 EXAM ANSWERS Variant 1 THE MAY 2015 EXAM CAN BE VIEWED AT https://connect.cimaglobal.com/groups/strategic-case-study-exam/resources These answers have been provided by CIMA
More informationPOSSIBLE UPDATE OF THE EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES HANDBOOK
Distr.: General 13 October 2017 Original: English Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters Fifteenth session Geneva, 17-20 October 2017 Item 5 (c) (ii) Possible update of the Extractive
More informationFiscal Rules and Natural Resource Funds
NRGI Reader March 2015 Fiscal Rules and Natural Resource Funds Methods to Save and Stabilize Revenues KEY MESSAGES Natural resource funds (a subset of sovereign wealth funds) can help governments respond
More informationAllocation of risk between parties - fixed price mechanisms Price setting mechanisms
10.0 Price setting mechanisms Price setting mechanisms fall into two main categories: fixed and variable. A fixed price mechanism is a straightforward concept which typically results in a relatively stable
More informationAugust 6, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Attention: Matthew Burton & PRA Office 1700 G Street NW Washington, DC 20552
August 6, 2013 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Attention: Matthew Burton & PRA Office 1700 G Street NW Washington, DC 20552 Re: Docket No. CFPB-2013-0016: Telephone Survey Exploring Consumer Awareness
More informationCompetition Commission of Mauritius Guidelines: GENERAL PROVISIONS
CCM 7 Competition Commission of Mauritius Guidelines: GENERAL PROVISIONS November 2009 Competition Commission of Mauritius 2009 Guidelines General provisions 2 1. Introduction... 3 Guidelines... 3 Guidelines
More informationSUBJECT: DISCUSSION DRAFT ON THE TRANSFER PRICING ASPECTS OF CROSS-BORDER COMMODITY TRANSACTIONS
Dr. Andrew Hickman Head of Transfer Pricing Unit Centre for Tax Policy and Administration By email SUBJECT: DISCUSSION DRAFT ON THE TRANSFER PRICING ASPECTS OF CROSS-BORDER COMMODITY TRANSACTIONS 6 February
More information1. Purpose of regulating the petroleum industry
Petroleum Legislation and Regulations Overview Petroleum sector projects are complex, high-risk investments which require a carefully drafted regulatory framework that combines sustainable economic development
More informationICSA response to the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) consultation on Insolvency and Corporate Governance
Insolvency and Corporate Governance Business Frameworks Directorate Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy 1st Floor 1 Victoria Street London SW1P 0ET By email: insolvencyandcorporategovernance@beis.gov.uk
More informationChapter 16: National Economy Introduction
16 National Economy 16.1 Introduction This chapter considers the Simandou Project s impacts on the national economy. The chapter considers the Project as a whole and does not distinguish between mine,
More informationOverview of Selected Issues
Natural Resource Wealth & Economic Development Overview of Selected Issues Jan Gottschalk TAOLAM This training activity is funded with grants from Japan. Overview I. Some Basic Issues II. Key Factors for
More informationRecovering the costs of the Office for Professional Body Anti-Money Laundering Supervision (OPBAS): fees proposals
Recovering the costs of the Office for Professional Body Anti-Money Laundering Supervision (OPBAS): fees proposals Consultation paper CP17/35 Published by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) Comments
More information*******************************************
William Morris Chair, BIAC Tax Committee 13/15, Chaussée de la Muette, 75016 Paris France The Platform for Collaboration on Tax Submitted by email: GlobalTaxPlatform@worldbank.org October 20, 2017 Ref:
More informationPrinciples And Practice
Surrey Energy Economics Centre Mining And Petroleum Taxation: Principles And Practice Carole Nakhle Revenue Mobilization and Development IMF, DC, 2011 1 Economic Contribution in 52 Developing Countries
More informationExtractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) Improving EI: Emerging Lessons and Results from EITI implementation in the GAC context
Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) PREM Week 2008 Joint Event on Extractive Industries (EI): Legal / Fiscal Systems, Revenue Management and Good Governance Improving EI: Emerging Lessons
More informationLeslie Van den Branden Partner De Witte-Viselé Associates Kaasmarkt 24 B Brussels (Wemmel) Belgium 1 October 2013
Mr. Joseph Andrus Head, Transfer Pricing Unit OECD 2, rue andré pascal 75775 Paris Cedex 16 France Leslie Van den Branden Partner De Witte-Viselé Associates Kaasmarkt 24 B- 1780 Brussels (Wemmel) Belgium
More informationInternational Monetary and Financial Committee
International Monetary and Financial Committee Thirty-Third Meeting April 16, 2016 IMFC Statement by Angel Gurría Secretary-General The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) IMF
More informationNovember 28, FSB Policy Framework for Addressing Shadow Banking Risks in Securities Lending and Repos (29 August 2013) (the Policy Framework ) 1
- November 28, 2013 By email to fsb@bis.org Secretariat of the Financial Stability Board c/o Bank for International Settlements CH-4002, Basel Switzerland Re: FSB Policy Framework for Addressing Shadow
More informationBasel Committee on Banking Supervision. Consultative Document. Pillar 2 (Supervisory Review Process)
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision Consultative Document Pillar 2 (Supervisory Review Process) Supporting Document to the New Basel Capital Accord Issued for comment by 31 May 2001 January 2001 Table
More informationMining. Barry Irwin Allen & Overy LLP Peter Wilkes Allen & Overy
Barry Irwin Allen & Overy LLP Peter Wilkes Allen & Overy 1. Introduction Recent years have been challenging times for mining companies seeking to raise finance. Lower commodity prices have put equity values
More informationMining Development Framework
Mining Development Framework Cielo Magno, Ph.D. National Coordinator, Bantay Kita OUTLINE Discussion of the Mining for Development Framework Philippine Context Assessment Recommendations SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
More information1. Sunk Costs. Major Characteristics of exhaustible natural resource extraction:
Eytan Sheshinski 2 Major Characteristics of exhaustible natural resource extraction: 1. Sunk Costs Large sunk costs create, from a tax point of view, a Time-Consistency problem. Taxation of Variable profits,
More informationProject Information Document/ Identification/Concept Stage (PID)
Public Disclosure Authorized The World Bank Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Project Information Document/ Identification/Concept Stage (PID) Concept Stage Date Prepared/Updated:
More informationSotiris A. Pagdadis, Ph.D.
www.pwc.com Leveraging PPPs for Airport Management and Development ACI 21 st African Region Annual Assembly, Conference and Exhibition: Overcoming the challenges of Airport development in Africa 28 August,
More informationInvesting in Zimbabwe: An investor s experience
Investing in Zimbabwe: An investor s experience By Dr. Philip Kamau Senior Director (Finance) Presented at: ICAZ Investors Conference Polokwane, South Africa, October, 2014 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1Afreximbank
More informationRecent Experiences in Assessing Public Infrastructure Management in Sri Lanka
Recent Experiences in Assessing Public Infrastructure Management in Sri Lanka Session II: Enhanced Framework For Public Investment Public Investment Processes And Benchmarking Tokyo Fiscal Forum 2018 June
More informationEFAMA REPLY TO THE EBA / ESMA CONSULTATION PAPER FOR BENCHMARKS SETTING PROCESSES IN THE EU
EFAMA REPLY TO THE EBA / ESMA CONSULTATION PAPER FOR BENCHMARKS SETTING PROCESSES IN THE EU EFAMA 1 welcomes the opportunity to provide comments on the EBA / ESMA joint consultation paper on benchmarks
More informationFIDUCIARY ARRANGEMENTS FOR SECTORWIDE APPROACHES (SWAPS)
FIDUCIARY ARRANGEMENTS FOR SECTORWIDE APPROACHES (SWAPS) OPERATIONS POLICY AND COUNTRY SERVICES APRIL 2, 2002 FIDUCIARY ARRANGEMENTS FOR SECTORWIDE APPROACHES (SWAPS) CONTENTS Page I. Introduction..1 II.
More informationImmunization Planning and the Budget Cycle
Key Points Immunization Planning and the Budget Cycle * Domestic public funding is the most important source of immunization financing, and immunization planning and financing must be considered as a part
More informationComments on Liberia Petroleum Act and NOCAL Act Executive Summary December 12, 2013 Petroleum Advisory Group
Comments on Liberia Petroleum Act and NOCAL Act Executive Summary December 12, 2013 Petroleum Advisory Group This paper sets out the comments of the Petroleum Advisory Group ( PAG, comprising the Revenue
More informationTHE EBRD AS A PROBLEM-SOLVING PARTNERSHIP FOR RESPONSIBLE NATURAL RESOURCE INVESTORS
44 Eric Rasmussen THE EBRD AS A PROBLEM-SOLVING PARTNERSHIP FOR RESPONSIBLE NATURAL RESOURCE INVESTORS Through its practical involvement in the natural resources sector, the EBRD implements its institutional
More informationThe Roles of National Resource Companies and Regulators
NATURAL RESOURCE TAXATION IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC REGION AUGUST 11-13, 2015 JAKARTA, INDONESIA The Roles of National Resource Companies and Regulators Bryan Land Lead Extractives Specialist Introduction How
More informationRisk Based compliance Strategies for the Extractive industries
Risk Based compliance Strategies for the Extractive industries Scott Shelton Fiscal Affairs Department Challenges in determining the Tax Base for Extractive Industries Bogota, Columbia September 29 October
More information(DRAFT) EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA (DRAFT) EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM FOR THE MINERAL AND PETROLEUM RESOURCES ROYALTY BILL, 2007 06 December 2007 EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM FOR THE MINERAL AND PETROLUEM RESOURCES ROYALTY
More informationMINISTRY OF MINING REPORTING OF MINING AND MINERAL RELATED ACTIVITIES 2016 MEMORANDUM
MINISTRY OF MINING REPORTING OF MINING AND MINERAL RELATED ACTIVITIES 2016 MEMORANDUM Introduction Mineral resource development involves a complex web of relationships among mining companies, government
More informationPeople s Republic of China TA 8940: Municipality-Level Public Private Partnership (PPP) Operational Framework for Chongqing
Consultant s Report Project Number: 49166-001 People s Republic of China TA 8940: Municipality-Level Public Private Partnership (PPP) Operational Framework for Chongqing Public Private Partnerships: Management
More informationManaging Risk in PPP Projects through Legal Documentation
Managing Risk in PPP Projects through Legal Documentation P R E P A R E D F O R P R E S E N T A T I O N A T T H E E X P E R T R O U N D T A B L E O N P R I V A T E - P U B L I C P A R T N E R S H I P S
More informationThe Contribution of the Mining Sector to Socioeconomic and Human Development
The Contribution of the Mining Sector to Socioeconomic and Human Development Paulo de Sa Practice Manager Energy & Extractives Global Practice The World Bank Group January 13, 2015 Agenda The World Bank
More informationThe Tax Treatment of the Mining Sector: An IMF Perspective. Emil M. Sunley and Thomas Baunsgaard 1
The Tax Treatment of the Mining Sector: An IMF Perspective Emil M. Sunley and Thomas Baunsgaard 1 This session of the workshop addresses the question of whether the development of the mining sector requires
More informationEMERGING ISSUES IN INTERNATIONAL TAXATION CHALLENGES AND WAY FORWARD PATIENCE T. RUBAGUMYA COMMISSIONER LEGAL SERVICES AND BOARD AFFAIRS
EMERGING ISSUES IN INTERNATIONAL TAXATION CHALLENGES AND WAY FORWARD By PATIENCE T. RUBAGUMYA COMMISSIONER LEGAL SERVICES AND BOARD AFFAIRS OUTLINE L 1 Introduction taxation 3 2 Challenges in international
More informationGLOBAL ENTERPRISE SURVEY REPORT 2009 PROVIDING A UNIQUE PICTURE OF THE OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FACING BUSINESSES ACROSS THE GLOBE
GLOBAL ENTERPRISE SURVEY REPORT 2009 PROVIDING A UNIQUE PICTURE OF THE OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FACING BUSINESSES ACROSS THE GLOBE WELCOME TO THE 2009 GLOBAL ENTERPRISE SURVEY REPORT The ICAEW annual
More informationClassification of Contracts under International Financial Reporting Standards IFRS [2005]
IAN 3 Classification of Contracts under International Financial Reporting Standards IFRS [2005] Prepared by the Subcommittee on Education and Practice of the Committee on Insurance Accounting Published
More informationSovereign Rating Methodology Overview November 2009
Sovereign Rating Methodology Overview November 2009 Maria Cannata Director General of Public Debt Management Treasury Department - Ministry of Economy and Finance Italy Republic of Italy Credit ratings
More informationDomestic Resource Mobilization in Africa
Domestic Resource Mobilization in Africa Yiagadeesen (Teddy) Samy Associate Professor Norman Paterson School of International Affairs and Institute of African Studies Carleton University March 12, 2015
More informationStrengths (+) and weaknesses ( )
Country Report Australia Country Report Marcel Weernink Economic growth in Australia decelerates due to lower mining investments. The outlook depends heavily on demand from China for its commodities and
More informationIssue Paper: Linking revenue to expenditure
Issue Paper: Linking revenue to expenditure Introduction Mobilising domestic resources through taxation is crucial in helping developing countries to finance their development, relieve poverty, reduce
More informationOPEN BUDGET INITIATIVE, EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE (EITI) and OPEN GOVERNMENT PARTNERSHIP
OPEN BUDGET INITIATIVE, EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE (EITI) and OPEN GOVERNMENT PARTNERSHIP Paul Barker - CIMC National Development Forum, 2 July 2015 Holiday Inn The Function of the State:
More informationEvaluating and Comparing Fiscal Regimes for EI
Evaluating and Comparing Fiscal Regimes for EI NATURAL RESOURCE TAXATION IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC REGION A forum on the design, implementation and evaluation of fiscal regimes for extractive industries Jakarta,
More informationTHE TAXATION SYSTEM IN ZAMBIA
A report for the Jesuit Centre for Theological Reflection THE TAXATION SYSTEM IN ZAMBIA Executive Summary Final Report January 2011 This study was prepared by Messrs Alfred Mwila, David Manley, Patrick
More informationValidation of Zambia Validation Report Adam Smith International Independent Validator 10 August 2017
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Validation of Zambia Validation Report Adam Smith International Independent Validator 10 August 2017 The Government of Zambia committed to implementing the EITI in 2008 and a multi-stakeholder
More information