REPORT OF THE CONSULTATIVE COMMITTEE ON SUPERANNUATION TO THE MINISTER OF FINANCE
|
|
- Camron Newton
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 REPORT OF THE CONSULTATIVE COMMITTEE ON SUPERANNUATION TO THE MINISTER OF FINANCE CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY 1.1 Announcement of Government Policy and Formation of Consultative Committee On 17 December 1987, the Government announced a series of far reaching economic policy changes, one of which related to the tax treatment of superannuation. The 17 December statement was further amplified by a ministerial statement on 10 February 1988, and at that point most of the features of the proposed treatment of superannuation were outlined. Essentially, the Government proposed to ensure that contributions to superannuation schemes would henceforth be from tax-paid income, and that the income generated within such schemes would be taxed at a rate approximating the marginal rate of contributors, while on the other hand providing that all benefits paid out by superannuation schemes would be exempt from taxation. Early in March 1988, the Government issued the "Consultative Document on Superannuation and Life Insurance: Volume 1", setting out the proposed changes in detail. The Consultative Document was critical of the previous tax regime as it applied to superannuation, and noted that under that regime savings channelled into superannuation received a markedly more concessionary tax treatment than savings channelled into other areas, such as banks. Section 5.1 of the Consultative Document argued that past tax concessions provided to superannuation have "been expensive in terms of tax revenue lost, created distortions in investment patterns and in employment behaviour, created the need for tight regulatory control of superannuation funds, led to tax planning, and have made the tax system unfair by favouring the high over the low income earner. Arguments for retaining tax preferences - the desirability of encouraging savings and the desirability of encouraging private, as opposed to public, provision for retirement - do not, in the end, stand up to close analysis". Following a pattern adopted on several previous occasions, the Government invited public submissions "on matters concerning the implementation and operation of the measures proposed" in the Consultative Document, and established a Consultative Committee to receive those submissions. The Committee was charged with reporting to the Minister of Finance on matters raised in the submissions concerning "the implementation and administration" of the proposed changes, as well as to suggest possible amendments to the detailed changes set out in the document "consistent with the Government's policy announcements and policy objectives". 2/...
2 Submissions Received In response to that invitation, a total of 225 submissions were received: Employers and employer-related superannuation schemes 72 Private individuals 88 Superannuation professionals (actuaries, life insurance companies, fund managers, etc) 33 Trade and professional associations, accountants, trade unions, and other 32 Total 225 Of the submissions from private individuals, 46 took the form of two or three essentially standard letters, obviously reflecting an organised lobbying campaign in some areas. It was not possible to meet personally with most of the parties who had made submissions. But we were able to meet with the following: AMP Society Association of Consulting Actuaries of New Zealand Association of Superannuation Funds of New Zealand Government Life Life Offices' Association National Mutual National Provident Fund New Zealand Council of Trade Unions New Zealand Society of Actuaries In comparison to the 1067 written submissions made to the Advisory Panel on the Goods and Services Tax, and the 1084 submissions made to the Consultative Committee on Primary Sector Taxation, the 225 submissions made on the proposed changes to superannuation taxation seem modest in number, particularly in the light of the number of form letters. On the other hand, the submissions on superannuation frequently argued on behalf of many hundreds, indeed sometimes many thousands, of superannuation scheme members, and were reflective of a very widespread public interest in the Government's proposals. As noted above, the Government charged us with the responsibility of receiving public submissions, and reporting to the Minister of Finance, on matters concerning "the implementation and administration" of the proposed changes. Our terms of reference did not, therefore, extend to a comprehensive analysis of the merits or demerits of the Government's proposals. 3/...
3 3 - We would be failing in our duty, however, if we did not report to the Minister that the overwhelming majority of submissions received were very strongly opposed to the policy which Government has announced in this area. In a few cases, the anger was directed at the Committee itself, in the mistaken belief that the Committee had initiated the policy proposals. 1.3 The Criticisms Summarised There were seven major areas of concern mentioned frequently: A. Lack of consultation - Many of those professionally involved in providing superannuation services recalled frequent Government promises of "consultation" with the industry before any major changes were announced. Those parties resented Government's policy announcements as a fait accompli. Two submissions actually called upon the Committee to resign immediately, on the grounds that the whole consultation process was a farce, particularly in view of the fact that several of the key features of the proposal had already been enacted into legislation. B. Retrospectivity - A number of submissions expressed concern that the proposals would effectively abrogate existing contractual rights, and give little or no time to adjust financial plans. Several submissions described the proposals as having retrospective effect, and argued that the existing tax treatment should apply to all superannuation schemes, or at least all existing members of existing schemes, as at 17 December The Committee recognises that this is a very difficult area. If it is accepted that the present multiplicity of tax regimes applying to different superannuation schemes is undesirable, and that the present situation is both open to manipulation for tax planning purposes and inefficient as a means of providing retirement income to the majority of the population, as many submissions did, then it follows that some fundamental change is required. It also follows that, unless arrangements existing at 17 December 1987 are to be preserved until the death of those concerned, in perhaps years' time, some element of "retrospectivity" is inevitably involved in that change. It was for this reason that the Consultative Document proposed concessionary arrangements to smooth the transition from the previous regime to the proposed one. 4/...
4 - 4 - The Committee believes that it would be quite unreasonable to expect any Government to tie its hands for a period of up to 50 or 60 years. This is particularly true in a situation where many other parts of the New Zealand economy are being forced to face up to radical change, with tariffs, import controls, and export incentives, for example, being reduced or phased out "retrospectively" after investments have been made. Moreover, no submissions complained that the proposals would "retrospectively" provide benefits to many people, by making tax-free benefits which under the previous regime would have been taxable. (In at least some cases, it seems virtually certain that the benefit of receiving payments from superannuation schemes in a tax-exempt form would more than offset any possible reduction in the size of those payments.) In complaining about the "retrospectivity" ot the proposals, however, a small number of submissions did acknowledge the very important point that the proposed changes to the taxation of superannuation were only one aspect of a larger tax reform programme, some parts of which involved significant reductions in both corporate and personal tax rates. C. Distribution of benefits - Section 5.7 of the Consultative Document argued that the previous superannuation tax regime provided substantially greater benefits to high income earners than low income earners. A great many submissions questioned this argument, most simply noting that most of the members of employee superannuation schemes were low or middle income earners. 5/... There is no doubt that a large number of New Zealanders earning quite modest levels of income are members of superannuation schemes. The Committee was not persuaded, however, that the benefits of the previous tax regime were distributed on the same basis as the membership of schemes. High income earners typically save more in tax (because of their higher marginal tax rates) for any given level of superannuation exemption than do low income earners; high income earners are able to save a higher proportion of their income, and shelter the income on that savings through superannuation schemes, than can low income earners; and, particularly in defined benefit superannuation schemes, it is the high income earners who receive overwhelmingly the largest part of the employer subsidies. (This last point is frequently overlooked. The reality, however, is that a great many of the contributors to defined benefit superannuation schemes receive little or nothing of the employer subsidies
5 - 5 - notionally made on their behalf, with these subsidies effectively appropriated for the benefit of long-term, and therefore frequently higher income earning, employees.) Lack of neutrality - One of the main arguments advanced by the Consultative Document for the proposed changes is that the changes would make the tax system more neutral, in that savings in the form of contributions to superannuation schemes would be treated in the same way as savings in all other forms. Most submissions questioned the desirability of neutrality as a goal, but even those submissions that accepted neutrality as a desirable objective argued that the proposed system fell well short of that objective. It was noted, for example, that in proposing to tax the income of superannuation schemes at 33% the Government's policy would act as a significant deterrent to those low income earners paying a marginal tax rate of less than 33%. The Committee recognises that this particular aspect of neutrality will be very difficult to avoid with anything other than a single personal tax rate. Another point raised by a large number of submissions was the proposal to tax capital gains in superannuation schemes. Interestingly, a great many submissions accepted the desirability of having a comprehensive capital gains tax, and the Committee addresses this question later. But there was a virtually unanimous view on the part of the many submissions which raised the subject that, as long as capital gains are not subject to tax in the hands of private individuals, they should not be subject to tax within a superannuation scheme if neutrality is an important objective. Security of private retirement plans - In large measure because the personal tax rate is now above the corporate tax rate, there was a widespread recognition on the part of many of those who made submissions that the proposed policy would create a quite considerable financial incentive for companies not to fund superannuation schemes, but rather simply to promise to provide retirement income to long serving employees on retirement. Such a move to unfunded "superannuationcould have a most undesirable effect on the security of the provision for retirement in the private sector because employees would be entirely dependent upon the long-term financial viability of their employers for retirement security. Effect of proposals on level of savings - The great majority of those who made submissions expressed serious concern about the effect which the proposals would have on the level of savings for retirement. This concern was expressed in many different ways, but the common thread was that many employers would cease
6 - 6 - providing superannuation schemes to their employees, that employees would cease to provide for their own retirement, and that as a consequence dependence on state-provided income would increase markedly over the next 10 to 20 years. A number of submissions pointed out that, because this would be the result of the Government's proposals, it was imperative that the whole issue of the provision of retirement income, both state and private, should be addressed at the same time. This issue is of such fundamental importance to the matter under consideration that it is discussed further in Chapter 2. G. Need for long-term stability - Many submissions expressed grave concern at the number of changes which had afflicted superannuation arrangements over the years since More than one submission claimed that there had been five major changes in the policy framework relevant to superannuation during that 13 year period. It was noted that the introduction of National Superannuation was itself a distinct discouragement to undertaking long-term retirement-orientated savings. The introduction of the National Superannuation surcharge increased that disincentive, by sharply reducing the return from private provision for retirement. Many submissions suggested that the December 1987 package, as it related to superannuation, was the final nail in the coffin of private provision for retirement. Yet at the same time there was also widespread recognition that there is little prospect of National Superannuation surviving in its present form, given the demographic trends which we face. A considerable number of submissions argued in favour of there being some form of compulsion to belong to a funded superannuation scheme, rather along the lines proposed by the Hon. Mr Trevor de Cleene. And there was a widespread feeling that a bipartisan approach was crucially important in order to provide some form of certainty to those planning for their retirement. One individual submission wrote that "if ever there was a case for a common approach by the two major political parties then it must be over superannuation. If the Committee can give a lead to some consensus on this, if nothing else, then the effort will be totally worthwhile." The sentiment was expressed by many others, and the Committee comments further on this issue in Chapter 2. 7/...
7 - 7 - Despite the criticism of Government's proposals, there was also, in many submissions, a recognition that the previous regime had some serious deficiencies as a way of encouraging provision of retirement income. It was recognised, for example, that much of the money that goes into superannuation schemes is withdrawn well before retirement. It was pointed out that, as a consequence, savings in this form is both enormously concessional from a tax point of view and quite ineffective as a means of providing for retirement income. Some submissions recognised also that most of the employer contributions in some defined benefit schemes went to high income participants only. It was pointed out, however, that these difficulties could in large measure be dealt with by appropriate legislative change relating to vesting, portability, and "preservation." Commenting on the fairly wide range of tax treatments of superannuation schemes under the previous regime, several submissions favoured standardising on the exempt/exempt/taxed approach, ie. allowing contributions into superannuation schemes to be deducted from taxable income, allowing income to accrue within superannuation schemes on an exempt basis, but taxing the payments out of superannuation schemes. It was suggested that this was the internationally typical arrangement, and that it would retain a substantial incentive for the private provision of retirement income while avoiding the worst abuses possible under the present situation. A very small number of submissions fully accepted Government's desire to move to a tax neutral situation, but argued that this objective would be much better achieved by moving to an exempt/taxed/taxed (E/T/T) regime, ie. allowing deductibility of contributions into superannuation schemes, while taxing both the income in those schemes and the payments from those schemes. It was claimed that, whereas no other country in the world had moved to the taxed/taxed/exempt (T/T/E) regime proposed in the Consultative Document, four countries had moved to an E/T/T regime, namely Denmark, Finland, Norway, and Spain. 1.4 Brief Summary of Key Recommendations Much of this report is devoted to a commentary on the implementation and administration of the proposals contained in the Government's Consultative Document, as requested in our terms of reference. But the Committee was sufficiently impressed by the arguments of those who claimed that the Government's proposals would lead to both a significant reduction in aggregate savings, and a substantial disruption of capital markets in the short-term, to recommend to the Government that the proposals themselves should be fully reviewed in a wider context. 8/...
8 - 8 - We recognise that, at this stage, with some of the proposed tax changes already in place, there is little prospect of any fundamental change in the proposed regime for 1988/89. In any event, the Committee recommends that this regime (subject to modifications outlined in Chapter 4) should be adopted for lump sum superannuation schemes. But it was also the unanimous view of the Committee that - a) Every effort should be made to ensure a bipartisan approach to the whole question of the provision of retirement income in New Zealand. b) The Government should urgently review the feasibility of continuing National Superannuation on the present basis and, if found appropriate, make it clear at the earliest opportunity that present levels of state-provided retirement income will not be available in future. (The Committee's reason for this recommendation is that the proposed non-concessional tax regime to apply to the private provision of retirement income provides a substantial disincentive for such private provision, when there remains access to a generous, but income-tested, state-provided retirement income.) c) In this context, the Government should give serious consideration to the adoption of a "modified E/T/T" regime for pension schemes (Retirement Income Funds, or RIFs). 9/...
CHAPTER 3 - NON-CONCESSIONARY OPTIONS. 3.1 Taxed/Taxed/Exempt
- 17 - CHAPTER 3 - NON-CONCESSIONARY OPTIONS 3.1 Taxed/Taxed/Exempt The Consultative Document proposed that contributions to superannuation schemes should be from tax paid income, rather than being deductible
More informationTAX TREATMENT SUPERANNUATION REPORT OF THE CONSULTATIVE COMMITTEE
TAX TREATMENT SUPERANNUATION REPORT OF THE CONSULTATIVE COMMITTEE JULY 1988 26 July 1988 STATEMENT BY Minister of Finance, Hon R 0 Douglas RELEASE OF THE REPORT ON SUPERANNUATION The Government is pleased
More informationCHAPTER 6 - HOW SUPERANNUATION AND LIFE INSURANCE SAVINGS ARE TO BE TAXED
87 CHAPTER 6 - HOW SUPERANNUATION AND LIFE INSURANCE SAVINGS ARE TO BE TAXED 6.1 Introduction For the reasons given in Chapter 5, the preferential tax treatment of superannuation cannot be justified on
More information2.2 Superannuation and Life Insurance in the New Zealand Financial System
15 CHAPTER 2 - SUPERANNUATION AND LIFE INSURANCE 2.1 Introduction As both repositories for savings, and as sources of loanable funds, superannuation schemes and life offices play a significant role in
More informationBlack hole R&D expenditure
Black hole R&D expenditure A government discussion document Hon Steven Joyce Minister of Science and Innovation Hon Todd McClay Minister of Revenue First published in November 2013 by Policy and Strategy,
More informationDEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY OFFICE OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY OFFICE OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS Embargoed Until 12:30 EST Contact: Brookly McLaughlin November 18, 2004 202-622-1996 Samuel W. Bodman, Deputy Secretary of the Treasury Remarks before
More informationThe tax implications of pay, salary sacrifice, KiwiSaver and PIEs
The tax implications of pay, salary sacrifice, KiwiSaver and PIEs RPRC Briefing Paper 06/2007 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction
More informationRECOGNITION OF GOVERNMENT PENSION OBLIGATIONS
RECOGNITION OF GOVERNMENT PENSION OBLIGATIONS Preface By Brian Donaghue 1 This paper addresses the recognition of obligations arising from retirement pension schemes, other than those relating to employee
More informationNew Zealand s International Tax Review
New Zealand s International Tax Review Extending the active income exemption to non-portfolio FIFs An officials issues paper March 2010 Prepared by the Policy Advice Division of Inland Revenue and the
More informationImplementation - Sustaining the Superannuation Contribution Concession
27 September 2013 The Hon. Joe Hockey MP Treasurer The Treasury Langton Crescent PARKES ACT 2600 AUSTRALIA Email: J.Hockey.MP@aph.gov.au Dear Mr Hockey Implementation - Sustaining the Superannuation Contribution
More informationPENSION SCHEMES ACT 1993, PART X DETERMINATION BY THE DEPUTY PENSIONS OMBUDSMAN
PENSION SCHEMES ACT 1993, PART X DETERMINATION BY THE DEPUTY PENSIONS OMBUDSMAN Applicant Scheme Respondent(s) Mr S Travis Lloyds Bank Offshore Pension Scheme Pension Investment Plan (PIP) Section (the
More informationH M Treasury: Business Rates Review
H M Treasury: Business Rates Review Submission from the Chief Economic Development Officers Society (CEDOS) and the Association of Directors of Environment, Economy, Planning & Transport (ADEPT) May 2015
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION Internal Market and Services DG FREE MOVEMENT OF CAPITAL, COMPANY LAW AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Internal Market and Services DG FREE MOVEMENT OF CAPITAL, COMPANY LAW AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE Accounting Brussels, 27 June 2008 MARKT F3 D(2008) Endorsement of the Amendments to IAS
More informationTAX TREATMENT OF PENSION PROVISION BY F. R. LANGHAM, F.I.A., A.S.A., F.S.S. AND J. D. SPARKS, B.A., F.I.A.
TAX TREATMENT OF PENSION PROVISION BY F. R. LANGHAM, F.I.A., A.S.A., F.S.S. AND J. D. SPARKS, B.A., F.I.A. 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1. The present authors, with G. T. Humphrey and R. E. Snelson, were associated
More informationIn Confidence. Opportunity to Clarify KiwiSaver First Home Withdrawal Provisions
In Confidence OFFICE OF THE MINISTER OF COMMERCE AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS The Chair Cabinet Economic Growth and Infrastructure Committee Opportunity to Clarify KiwiSaver First Home Withdrawal Provisions Proposal
More informationTRANSITION TO RETIREMENT INCOME STREAMS: THE STATE OF PLAY
www.fsadvice.com.au 1 Chris Chow, Rainmaker Information Chris is the Technical Services Manager at Rainmaker. He is responsible for researching and producing educational content regarding all areas of
More informationThe tax status of credit unions
The tax status of credit unions An issues paper 6 September 2000 Prepared by: The Treasury Ministry of Economic Development Policy Advice Division of Inland Revenue The tax status of credit unions: an
More informationStrengthening the Legislative and Regulatory Framework for Defined Benefit Pension Plans Registered under the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985
Strengthening the Legislative and Regulatory Framework for Defined Benefit Pension Plans Registered under the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 Financial Sector Division Department of Finance Consultation
More informationOmbudsman s Determination
PO-149 Ombudsman s Determination Applicant Scheme Respondent Mrs Christine Harris NHS Pension Scheme (the Scheme) NHS Pensions Subject Mrs Harris complains that: She was not informed that she should have
More informationA Guide to Segregation
A Guide to Segregation 1 / Introduction In theory the tax rules surrounding superannuation balances that support pensions are very simple : no tax is paid on the investment income they generate. This income
More informationHMRC Consultation: Large Business compliance enhancing our risk assessment approach Response by the Chartered Institute of Taxation
HMRC Consultation: Large Business compliance enhancing our risk assessment approach Response by the Chartered Institute of Taxation 1 Introduction 1.1 This consultation document is examining how HM Revenue
More informationRe: Adoption of the amended IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement
Dr. Alexander Schaub Director General European Commission Directorate General for the Internal Market 1049 Brussels 26 September 2004 Dear Dr. Schaub, Re: Adoption of the amended IAS 39 Financial Instruments:
More informationRe: Position Paper Means Test Rules for Lifetime Retirement Income Streams
Means Test Policy Department of Social Services By email: retirementincomestreams@dss.gov.au 16 February 2018 Re: Position Paper Means Test Rules for Lifetime Retirement Income Streams Dear Sir or Madam,
More informationTax Brief. 9 April Changes to Superannuation. Background. Earnings on assets set aside to meet pension liabilities
Tax Brief 9 April 2013 Changes to Superannuation The Treasurer has put an end to the frenzied pre-budget speculation by announcing the government s plans for changing superannuation. This Tax Brief examines
More informationSuperannuation reform package
Superannuation reform package Submission by UniSuper About UniSuper UniSuper 1 is the superannuation fund dedicated to people working in Australia's higher education and research sector. With approximately
More informationEFAMA s comments on the European Commission s proposal for a Regulation on a pan-european personal pension product (PEPP)
EFAMA s comments on the European Commission s proposal for a Regulation on a pan-european personal pension product (PEPP) Introduction EFAMA welcomes the European Commission s proposed Regulation for the
More informationAccident Compensation Corporation
Submission by to the Accident Compensation Corporation on the Levy Consultation 2017-19 October 2016 ACC LEVY CONSULTATION 2017-19 SUBMISSION BY BUSINESSNZ 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 BusinessNZ welcomes the
More informationThe European approach to pensions and its impact on small self-administered schemes Received: 5th June, 2004
The European approach to pensions and its impact on small self-administered schemes Received: 5th June, 2004 John Murray is a law graduate from Leeds University. He has been a partner at Nabarro Nathanson
More informationOmbudsman s Determination
Ombudsman s Determination Applicant Scheme Respondents Mr A Scargill National Union of Mineworkers Officials' and Permanent Employees' Superannuation Fund National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) The Trustees
More informationAssociation of Accounting Technicians response to HM Treasury Call for Evidence on the Value Added Tax (VAT) Registration Threshold
Association of Accounting Technicians response to HM Treasury Call for Evidence on the Value Added Tax (VAT) Registration Threshold 1 Association of Accounting Technicians response to HM Treasury Call
More informationSubmission in response to the Governments proposals to simplify and streamline superannuation (May 2006)
Avenue Capital Management Ltd Australian Financial Services License #232406 Suite 1, 20 Bundaroo St Bowral NSW 2576 General Manager Superannuation, Retirement and Savings Division The Treasury Langton
More informationFinancial Review: Banking & Wealth Summit A World-leading Superannuation System
A World-leading Superannuation System The Financial System Inquiry chaired by David Murray was established in 2013 following an election commitment made by the incoming Coalition Government. It was tasked
More informationLABOR PARTY RESPONSE TO THE FEDERAL PRE-ELECTION SUBMISSION FROM AIR
LABOR PARTY RESPONSE TO THE FEDERAL PRE-ELECTION SUBMISSION FROM AIR Recommendation 1 That the 50 per cent mandatory draw down requirement for Account Based Pension, Allocated Annuities and Market Linked
More informationAge Discrimination in Superannuation. Submission to. The Hon Susan Ryan AO Age Discrimination Commissioner
Association of Independent Retirees (A.I.R.) Ltd ACN 102 164 385 Age Discrimination in Superannuation Submission to The Hon Susan Ryan AO Age Discrimination Commissioner December 2011 Summary The Association
More informationshortfalls in perpetuity. 3 The 2003 Trustees report, for example, pushes the insolvency date back by assuming that older
Dr. Dave. I ve read that the President s proposal to create personal savings accounts within the Social Security system will do nothing to reduce the system s projected revenue shortfall. Is that true?
More informationCoversheet: Business tax
Coversheet: Business tax Discussion Paper for Sessions 6 and 7 of the Tax Working Group April 2018 Purpose of paper This paper discusses New Zealand s system of taxing business income, and seeks the Group
More informationNational Insurance and Self-employed Entertainers Response by the Chartered Institute of Taxation
National Insurance and Self-employed Entertainers Response by the Chartered Institute of Taxation 1 Introduction 1.1 The Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) is pleased to comment on the proposals to
More informationSubmission. Finance & Expenditure Select Committee. Taxation (Base Maintenance and Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill
Submission By To Finance & Expenditure Select Committee On Taxation (Base Maintenance and Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 28 February 2005 PO Box 1925 Wellington Ph: 04 496 6555 Fax: 04 496 6550 1 TAXATION
More informationAssociation of Accounting Technicians response to the Office of Tax Simplification:
Association of Accounting Technicians response to the Office of Tax Simplification: OTS Depreciation and Capital Allowances review call for evidence 1 Association of Accounting Technicians response to
More informationOmbudsman s Determination
Ombudsman s Determination Applicant Scheme Respondents Mr Y Ulster Bank Pension Scheme (the Scheme) Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) Ulster Bank Pension Trustees Ltd (the Trustees) Outcome 1. I do not uphold
More informationFSA Consultation Paper 176. Bundling and Softing. Response from The UK Society of Investment Professionals
UKSIP is a member society of FSA Consultation Paper 176 Bundling and Softing Response from The UK Society of Investment Professionals About UKSIP The UK Society of Investment Professionals ( UKSIP ) is
More informationFUNDING FAIRNESS: A REPORT ON ONTARIO S WORKPLACE SAFETY AND INSURANCE SYSTEM
FUNDING FAIRNESS: A REPORT ON ONTARIO S WORKPLACE SAFETY AND INSURANCE SYSTEM SUMMARY AND HIGHLIGHTS The Funding Review The Funding Review, chaired by Professor Harry Arthurs, was established in September
More informationRestricting pensions tax relief Government policy decisions on the reduced annual and lifetime allowances. slaughter and may.
Restricting pensions tax relief Government policy decisions on the reduced annual and lifetime allowances slaughter and may October 2010 Contents A. Summary of key Government decisions 01 B. How accurate
More informationTaxation of Retirement Savings. Lee Burns Graduate School of Government University of Sydney
Taxation of Retirement Savings Lee Burns Graduate School of Government University of Sydney Taxation of Retirement Savings Common for developed countries to use the tax system to encourage citizens to
More information1 Introduction. 2 Executive summary
HMRC Consultation Document Strengthening Sanctions for Tax Avoidance a Consultation on Detailed Proposals Response by the Chartered Institute of Taxation 1 Introduction 1.1 This consultation follows the
More informationtop strap New Pension Scheme 2015 Government s Final Offer Members Ballot
top strap New Pension Scheme 2015 Government s Final Offer Members Ballot 1 top strap Contents 1. Introduction the choice for members 3 2. An outline of the new scheme 5 3. How does a career-average scheme
More information1 Payrolling of benefits
1 Payrolling of benefits Recommendation 1.1 Our recommendation is that a legislative framework is introduced specifically to permit employers to payroll some or all of their employee benefits (including
More informationPENSION SCHEMES ACT 1993, PART X DETERMINATION BY THE PENSIONS OMBUDSMAN
PENSION SCHEMES ACT 1993, PART X DETERMINATION BY THE PENSIONS OMBUDSMAN Applicant Schemes Respondent(s) Mr D Jones Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) Lambert Smith Hampton Group Pension Scheme (LSH
More informationThe Danish Experience With A Financial Activities Tax
The Danish Experience With A Financial Activities Tax Presentation to the Brussels Tax Forum 28-29 March 2011 by Peter Birch Sørensen Assistant Governor Danmarks Nationalbank Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and
More informationA GUIDE TO PENSION WITHDRAWAL TAKING BENEFITS UNDER NEW PENSION FREEDOM RULES
A GUIDE TO PENSION WITHDRAWAL TAKING BENEFITS UNDER NEW PENSION FREEDOM RULES OPTIONS AND CONSIDERATIONS FOR ACCESSING PENSION BENEFITS The aim of this guide is to provide a basic overview of the options
More informationSCHEDULE 1 FUNDING AND ESTABLISHMENT OF OPENING BALANCES FOR TRANSFERRING MEMBERS FOR THE PURPOSES OF CLAUSES AND 4.2.
SCHEDULE 1 FUNDING AND ESTABLISHMENT OF OPENING BALANCES FOR TRANSFERRING MEMBERS FOR THE PURPOSES OF CLAUSES 3.1.1 AND 4.2.3 OF THE DEED S1.1 Interpretation S1.1.1 In this Schedule: Allocated Pension
More informationTAX TREATY ISSUES ARISING FROM CROSS-BORDER PENSIONS PUBLIC DISCUSSION DRAFT
DISCUSSION DRAFT 14 November 2003 TAX TREATY ISSUES ARISING FROM CROSS-BORDER PENSIONS PUBLIC DISCUSSION DRAFT Important differences exist between the retirement pension arrangements found in countries
More informationJUDICIAL PENSIONS AND SUPERANNUATION. The Hon Justice Alan Blow Supreme Court of Tasmania
JUDICIAL PENSIONS AND SUPERANNUATION The Significance of Judicial Pensions The Hon Justice Alan Blow Supreme Court of Tasmania Remuneration packages and recruitment A pension entitlement forms a significant
More informationCanadian Budget Delivers Outbound Tax Relief
Volume 53, Number 5 February 2, 2009 Canadian Budget Delivers Outbound Tax Relief by Steve Suarez Canadian Budget Delivers Outbound Tax Relief by Steve Suarez Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty on
More informationBrian G. Tough (New Zealand) SUPERANNUATION AND BEYOND
SUPERANNUATION - 1990 AND BEYOND Brian G. Tough (New Zealand) As it plays host to the 12th Conference of the International Association of Consulting Actuaries, New Zealand enters the last decade of the
More informationInformation Note: Simpler Super - Notional Taxed Contributions
Information Note: Simpler Super - Notional Taxed Contributions March 2008 Purpose The purpose of this Information Note is to advise members of the outcome of Institute consultations with the Treasury and
More informationSingapore Institute of Management and its Subsidiaries. Contents. Financial Report 2017
Singapore of Management and its Subsidiaries Financial Report 2017 Contents 2 Governing Council s statement 3 Independent auditor s report 5 Statements of comprehensive income 6 Statements of financial
More information17. Social Security. Congress should allow workers to privately invest at least half their Social Security payroll taxes through individual accounts.
17. Social Security Congress should allow workers to privately invest at least half their Social Security payroll taxes through individual accounts. Although President Bush failed in his efforts to reform
More informationOur commentary focuses on five main issues. Supplementary comments relating to specific paragraphs or issues are provided in the appendix.
Comments on the Revised Discussion Draft on Transfer Pricing Aspects of Intangibles by the Confederation of Netherlands Industry and Employers (VNO-NCW) We are pleased to see the significant progress which
More informationThe names and identifying details of the parties in this decision have been changed.
LCRO 261/2014 CONCERNING an application for review pursuant to section 193 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006 AND CONCERNING a determination of the Standards Committee BETWEEN OL Applicant AND MR
More informationMEMBERS RETIRING ALLOWANCES PLAN AND MEMBERS SUPPLEMENTARY RETIRING ALLOWANCES PLAN
Financial Statements of MEMBERS RETIRING ALLOWANCES PLAN AND MEMBERS SUPPLEMENTARY RETIRING ALLOWANCES PLAN Financial Statements Financial Statements Independent Auditor s Report 1 Statements of Financial
More informationCFA Society of the UK response to consultation questions on Revenue Recognition IASB/FASB Exposure Draft
Henry Rees Senior Project Manager International Accounting Standards Board 30 Cannon Street London EC4M 6XH 1 November 2010 CFA Society of the UK response to consultation questions on Revenue Recognition
More informationPrivate sector contractors in a public service pension scheme Received: 6th March, 2000
Private sector contractors in a public service pension scheme Received: 6th March, 2000 Mike Ratcliffe, a Public Finance Accountant and Fellow of the Pensions Management Institute, is the Managing Director
More informationThe Economics of Taxing Pensions Tax Relief, Efficiency and Equity
The Economics of Taxing Pensions Tax Relief, Efficiency and Equity Moore McDowell Economist Issues: Introduction of a radical universal pension scheme to replace current three tier system. Not being considered
More informationCompetition Commission of Mauritius Guidelines: GENERAL PROVISIONS
CCM 7 Competition Commission of Mauritius Guidelines: GENERAL PROVISIONS November 2009 Competition Commission of Mauritius 2009 Guidelines General provisions 2 1. Introduction... 3 Guidelines... 3 Guidelines
More informationFINAL NOTICE. i. imposes on Peter Thomas Carron ( Mr Carron ) a financial penalty of 300,000; and
FINAL NOTICE To: Peter Thomas Carron Date of 15 September 1968 Birth: IRN: PTC00001 (inactive) Date: 16 September 2014 ACTION 1. For the reasons given in this Notice, the Authority hereby: i. imposes on
More informationAssessing alternative approaches to design tax and financial incentives for retirement savings
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development DAF/AS/PEN/WD(2017)11 English - Or. English DIRECTORATE FOR FINANCIAL AND ENTERPRISE AFFAIRS INSURANCE AND PRIVATE PENSIONS COMMITTEE 10 November
More informationRESPONSE TO CONSULTATION
RESPONSE TO CONSULTATION CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL: TRAM DEVELOPER CONTRIBUTIONS Introduction is the representative body of the house-building industry in Scotland. Its members build over 90% of the new
More informationSpecial feature: Current issues on reporting tax revenues
Revenue Statistics 2016 Statistiques des recettes publiques 2016 OECD/OCDE 2016 Chapter 2 Special feature: Current issues on reporting tax revenues 61 2.1. Introduction The release of the final version
More informationSubmission. Discussion Paper to inform the development of a Food Standard
Submission By to Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) on the Discussion Paper to inform the development of a Food Standard September 2005 PO Box 1925 Wellington Ph: 04 496 6555 Fax: 04 496 6550
More informationI issued a provisional decision in September 2013 concluding that Mr A s complaint should be upheld.
complaint Mr A s complaint, in summary, is that Lighthouse Advisory Services Limited advised him to invest in a carbon trading partnership scheme (CTP) that was unsuitable for him. background I issued
More informationNHS Trade Union response to HMT consultation on reforms to public sector exit payments.
NHS Trade Union response to HMT consultation on reforms to public sector exit payments. Introduction & general comments We are unclear from the consultation the extent to which Government wishes to impose
More informationCOMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES
COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES Brussels, 26.01.2006 COM(2006) 22 final REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE
More informationProposals for the New Zealand Accounting Standards Framework
Proposals for the New Zealand Accounting Standards Framework Incorporating the Draft Tier Strategy and Presented to the Minister of Commerce in accordance with Section 34A of the Financial Reporting Act
More informationPOLICY BRIEF. A Stronger Foundation. Pension Reform and Old Age Security. By Monica Townson. November 2009
POLICY BRIEF November 2009 A Stronger Foundation Pension Reform and Old Age Security By Monica Townson The current economic and financial situation has brought Canada s retirement income system into sharp
More informationICAEW REPRESENTATION 166/16 TAX REPRESENTATION
ICAEW REPRESENTATION 166/16 TAX REPRESENTATION Lease Accounting Changes: Tax Response ICAEW welcomes the opportunity to comment on the discussion draft Lease Accounting Changes: Tax Response published
More informationTreasury Laws Amendment (Protecting Your Superannuation Package) Bill 2018
File Name: 2018/21 9 July 2018 Committee Secretary Senate Economics Legislation Committee PO Box 6100 Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 Via email to: economics.sen@aph.gov.au Dear Committee Secretary
More informationIncome products for the post-retirement market in Australia Received 28th May, 2004
Income products for the post-retirement market in Australia Received 28th May, 2004 Graham Bird is a consultant, based in Sydney. He advises clients on a broad range of strategic issues relating to efficient
More informationOmbudsman s Determination
Ombudsman s Determination Applicant Scheme Respondent Mr O ICL Group Pension Plan (the Plan) The Trustees of the ICL Group Pension Plan (the Trustee) Outcome 1. I do not uphold Mr O s complaint and no
More informationPosition Paper on the Taxation of Private Pension Provision
Position Paper on the Taxation of Private Pension Provision Paper issued in November 2011 Supplementary Note issued in November 2017 Supplementary note to the Position Paper on Taxation of Private Pension
More informationCOMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES. Proposal for a COUNCIL DIRECTIVE
COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES Brussels, 17.10.2003 COM(2003) 613 final 2003/0239 (CNS) Proposal for a COUNCIL DIRECTIVE amending Directive 90/434/EEC of 23 July 1990 on the common system of taxation
More informationINTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS: DISCUSSION
INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS: DISCUSSION William R. Cline* I welcome the contribution that Sebastian Edwards s sharp, lucid paper has made to the literature and to deepening our understanding of the Chilean
More informationREVISED COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 7 OF THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT REVISED COMMENTARY ON ARTICLE 7 OF THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION 10 April 2007 CENTRE FOR TAX POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION 10 April 2007 REVISED COMMENTARY
More information7 July to 31 December 2008
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Discussion draft on a new Article 7 (Business Profits) of the OECD Model Tax Convention 7 July to 31 December 2008 CENTRE FOR TAX POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION
More information*******************************************
William Morris Chair, BIAC Tax Committee 13/15, Chaussée de la Muette, 75016 Paris France The Platform for Collaboration on Tax Submitted by email: GlobalTaxPlatform@worldbank.org October 20, 2017 Ref:
More informationResponse to submissions received on proposed implementation of Basel III capital adequacy requirements in New Zealand.
Response to submissions received on proposed implementation of Basel III capital adequacy requirements in New Zealand. September 2012 This document sets out the to the main issues raised in submissions
More informationMPFA submission to the Commission on Poverty s public consultation on retirement protection Media briefing 8 June 2016 Key points
MPFA submission to the Commission on Poverty s public consultation on retirement protection Media briefing 8 June 2016 Key points Introduction 1. The Commission on Poverty (CoP) launched a six-month public
More informationREVIEW OF PENSION SCHEME WIND-UP PRIORITIES A REPORT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL PROTECTION 4 TH JANUARY 2013
REVIEW OF PENSION SCHEME WIND-UP PRIORITIES A REPORT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL PROTECTION 4 TH JANUARY 2013 CONTENTS 1. Introduction... 1 2. Approach and methodology... 8 3. Current priority order...
More informationCHANGES IN STAMP DUTY ADMINISTRATION
CHANGES IN STAMP DUTY ADMINISTRATION Recent Finance Acts have introduced far-reaching changes in the operation of the stamp system. In this presentation I propose to focus principally on the changes introduced
More informationOmbudsman s Determination
Ombudsman s Determination Applicant Scheme Respondents Mr T Principal Civil Service Pension Scheme (CSPS) / Widow's Pension Scheme (WPS) Cabinet Office (CO), My Civil Service Pensions (MyCSP), HM Revenue
More informationChristiaan Hendrik Muller. Sharon Gail Yerman DECISION
BEFORE THE IMMIGRATION ADVISERS COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL Decision No: [2015] NZIACDT 77 Reference No: IACDT 045/14 IN THE MATTER of a referral under s 48 of the Immigration Advisers Licensing
More informationResponse to HM Treasury s Consultation Document Cm 9102 STRENGTHENING THE INCENTIVE TO SAVE: A CONSULTATION ON PENSIONS TAX
Response to HM Treasury s Consultation Document Cm 9102 STRENGTHENING THE INCENTIVE TO SAVE: A CONSULTATION ON PENSIONS TAX RELIEF By Dr Hugh Pemberton and Professor Roger Middleton, Department of History,
More information24 NOVEMBER 2009 TO 21 JANUARY 2010
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT REVISED DISCUSSION DRAFT OF A NEW ARTICLE 7 OF THE OECD MODEL TAX CONVENTION 24 NOVEMBER 2009 TO 21 JANUARY 2010 CENTRE FOR TAX POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION
More informationProposed Changes to the Pension Benefits Act. Presentation to The Pension Commission of Manitoba
Proposed Changes to the Pension Benefits Act Presentation to The Pension Commission of Manitoba JANUARY 14, 2003 Summary Pension Plan legislation has, as its primary purpose, the protection of benefits
More informationThere are three pressing reasons why we need a significant and sustained increase in home building:
National Planning Policy Framework: House of Commons Debate BRIEFING Budget 2013 11 March 2013 INTRODUCTION There are three pressing reasons why we need a significant and sustained increase in home building:
More informationConseil national de la comptabilité. Téléphone Télécopie / Internet
Conseil National de la Comptabilité 3, Boulevard Diderot 75572 PARIS CEDEX 12 Paris, 07 January 2008 Téléphone 01.53.44.52.01 Télécopie 01 53 18 99 43 / 01 53 44 52 33 Internet http://www.cnc.minefi.gouv.fr/
More informationSession three: Revenue Raising and Base Broadening 16 September 2009
VICTORIA UNIVERSITY TAX WORKING GROUP Session three: Revenue Raising and Base Broadening 16 September 2009 The day: The framework in which to consider tax reform; Presentations from Len Burman, Arthur
More informationCHAPTER 17 INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT. by Alistair Byrne, PhD, CFA
CHAPTER 17 INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT by Alistair Byrne, PhD, CFA LEARNING OUTCOMES After completing this chapter, you should be able to do the following: a Describe systematic risk and specific risk; b Describe
More informationSri Lanka Accounting Standard-LKAS 19. Employee Benefits
Sri Lanka Accounting Standard-LKAS 19 Employee Benefits CONTENTS SRI LANKA ACCOUNTING STANDARD-LKAS19 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS from paragraph OBJECTIVE 1 SCOPE 2 DEFINITIONS 8 SHORT-TERM EMPLOYEE BENEFITS 9 Recognition
More informationBefore C Hughes Judge and Henry Fitzhugh and Andrew Whetnall Tribunal Members
IN THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL Appeal No: EA/2012/0136,0166,0167 GENERAL REGULATORY CHAMBER (INFORMATION RIGHTS) ON APPEAL FROM: The Information Commissioner s Decision Notices Nos: FS50427672, FS50426626,
More information