Jeff Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner TEI Richmond Chapter March 19, 2014
|
|
- Elisabeth Barrett
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Jeff Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner TEI Richmond Chapter March 19, 2014 State Tax Controversy Update
2 Agenda MTC Compact Election Filing Methodologies Insurance Companies 2
3 MTC Compact Litigation
4 Apportionment Under the MTC Election Background of issue Article IV of The Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act (UDITPA) within the Multistate Tax Compact (adopted by 23 states), provides an election for taxpayers to apportion multistate income pursuant to: State law; or The standard evenly-weighted three-factor formula provided within UDITPA As states strayed away from the standard formula by enacting more heavily sales-factor-weighted apportionment, taxpayers began to utilize this election 4
5 Apportionment Under the MTC Election Gillette Company v. Franchise Tax Board, No. A (Cal. Ct. App. 10/2/2012) Court invalidated the 1993 amendments (imposing 2X sales) attempt to repeal the MTC equally-weighted three-factor formula ( notwithstanding CRTC ). Three holdings: MTC is a valid compact: supersedes conflicting state law MTC is an enforceable contract: U.S. and CA Constitutions prohibit CA from passing laws impairing the obligations of contracts 1993 amendments did not validly repeal MTC three-factor election: violation of reenactment clause of CA Constitution The notwithstanding language in the 1993 amendments was not effective to repeal the MTC alternative California Supreme Court granted cert. the FTB filed its response to amicus briefs on January 22,
6 Apportionment Under the MTC Election California s reaction: On June 27, 2012, CA withdrew from the Compact (SB 1015) Bill also contains Doctrine of Election language aimed at possibly limiting elections on amended returns Two-thirds vote? Issues as to whether SB 1015 violates Prop. 26 FTB Notice provides procedural guidance on filing claims for refund Enacted mandatory single sales factor apportionment (for most taxpayers) beginning in
7 Apportionment Under the MTC Election IBM v. Dep t of Treasury, No (Mich. Ct. App. Nov. 20, 2012) Michigan Court of Appeals held that adoption of MBT repealed the Compact election MCL (1) and (2) state that single sales factor applies to MBT, unless otherwise provided by a provision of the MBT Act MCL was amended by 2011 PA 40, explicitly stating that the Compact election was unavailable to the MBT after 1/1/2011 Court viewed this as mere clarification of prior law rather than change in law to be applied prospectively But see Anheuser-Busch, Inc. v. Dep t Treasury, No MT (Mich. Ct. Cl. June 6, 2013) (holding that MTC is binding). Cert. application granted by Michigan Supreme Court on July 3,
8 Compact Activity in Texas Graphic Packaging Corp. v. Combs, No. D-1-GN (353rd Jud. Distr. Ct., Travis Cnty., Tex., Jan. 15, 2014) (Byrne, J.) Texas trial court denied a taxpayer s claim that it was entitled to use the Multistate Tax Compact s three-factor formula election for the Texas Margin Tax. The court s order did not specifically address either the availability of the election or whether the tax meets the MTC s definition of an income tax. The taxpayer s remaining claims an as-applied constitutional challenge to the single factor sales apportionment formula and tax rate structure and a challenge to the imposition of penalties and interest remain pending. 8
9 Compact Activity in Minnesota Kimberly-Clark Corporation & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner of Revenue; Docket No R Kimberly-Clark filed refund claims in Minnesota pursuant to an MTC Compact Election. Kimberly-Clark appealed the Department's denial of its refund claims in Minnesota Tax Court asserting it had the ability to elect to apportion its income under the Multistate Tax Compact's formula. The Department filed an answer on February 10 th and asserted no election was available under Minnesota law. 9
10 Repealing the MTC South Dakota SB 239 (signed 2/28/2013) Repeals the MTC in South Dakota Utah SB 247 (signed 4/1/2013) Repeals the MTC in Utah and then temporarily reenacts the Compact for one year, absent the following: Election provision Apportionment formula Some definitions Minnesota HF 677 (signed 5/23/2013) Repeals MTC in Minnesota but retains MTC audits Oregon SB 307 (signed 6/13/2013) Repeals the compact from the state code, but reenacts everything except the election and apportionment sections 10
11 Multistate Tax Commission MTC is still very active in developing model legislation However, viability of MTC has been questioned by many in light of MTC Compact litigation, state withdrawals from Compact, and potential decreases in funding 11
12 Filing Methodologies
13 Filing Methodologies Comcon Production Services I, Inc., vs. FTB (Los. Cty. Sup. Crt. Mar. 6, 2014) Court held that Comcast Corp. and QVC Inc. did not form a unitary business during 1998 and 1999 for California income tax purposes. Comcast argued that it was not in a unitary business group with QVC because each company was in a separate line of business: Comcast is a cable television provider, while QVC is a retailer. Comcast said the relationship between the companies lacked any centralization of management, functional integration, or economies of scale, thus failing the three-part unitary business test. FTB argued that because QVC was an integral component of Comcast's cable and cable-related infrastructure, they were engaged in a unitary enterprise. The FTB also Comcast was an active shareholder of QVC and benefited from the vertical integration of the two companies. 13
14 Filing Methodologies Comcon Production Services I, Inc., vs. FTB (Los. Cty. Sup. Crt. Mar. 6, 2014) Court also held that $1.5 billion merger termination fee received by Comcast in 1999 after Media One accepted a merger offer from AT&T was apportionable business income that should have been reported. Comcast asserted the fee did not meet the transactional test because the fee was not acquired in the normal course of Comcast's business and was a once-in-a-lifetime event. The fee did not meet the functional because the fee arose from contractual rights in its merger agreement with Media One - because those rights did not become a part of its unitary business operations, the fee fails the functional test for business income. The FTB said the transactional test for business income was met because Comcast regularly engaged in transactions and activity to grow its cable and cable-related businesses. The functional test was also met because the merger agreement represented intangible property rights that Comcast acquired, managed, and disposed of as part of its regular business activity. The FTB also argued that the termination fee represented lost profits that would have been earned had the deal not failed. 14
15 Filing Methodologies In re Matter of the Petitions of Knowledge Learning Corp. and Kindercare Learning Centers, Inc., Dkt. Nos & (N.Y. Div. of Tax. App. June 27, 2013) On appeal, the New York Division of Tax Appeals found that taxpayers failed to establish substantial intercorporate transactions existed between affiliates to permit a combined filing New York law provides that unitary corporations meeting certain stock ownership requirements must file a combined report if substantial intercorporate transactions exist between the related parties The taxpayers attempted to establish that substantial intercorporate transactions existed because 1) all of Kindercare s employees were paid and employed by KLC and 2) all of Kindercare s expenses were paid by KLC In rejecting those arguments, the ALJ noted that there was no written agreement documenting the employee transfers between the affiliates and that KLC s payments of Kindercare s expenses were on behalf of Kindercare, using Kindercare s own cash 15
16 Filing Methodologies: Unitary Group Tesoro Corp. et. al. v. Alaska, Dkt. No. S (Alaska Oct. 25, 2013) The Supreme Court of Alaska held that a taxpayer was a unitary business and thus its worldwide income was subject to Alaska s three-factor apportionment formula. The taxpayer, Tesoro Corporation, was a petroleum company headquartered in Texas, with 33 subsidiaries spread globally amongst 5 business segments. One of the business segments was located in Alaska. As a result of the taxpayer s acquisition of an oil pipeline, it became a taxpayer engaged in the transportation of oil or gas by pipeline in Alaska, subject to Alaska s alternative apportionment method. From the inception of the taxpayer s business in Alaska in 1969 until 1994, it filed its Alaska income tax returns as a unitary group. During which time the taxpayer s Alaska apportionment was based on Alaska s codification of the MTC s equally weighted three-factor apportionment formula. AS , article IV, section 9. The taxpayer challenged the Alaska Department of Revenue s income tax assessment for the 1994 through 1998 tax years, arguing that Alaska s tax scheme violated the Due Process Clause and the Commerce Clause, and thus only its Alaska-based subsidiaries should be subject to Alaska income tax. The court found that the taxpayer was a unitary business and therefore lacked standing to challenge Alaska s alternative apportionment method applied to taxpayers engaged in the transportation of oil or gas by pipeline. 16
17 Filing Methodologies: Unitary Group Tesoro Corp. continued The taxpayer challenged the Alaska Department of Revenue s income tax assessment for the 1994 through 1998 tax years, arguing that Alaska s tax scheme violated the Due Process Clause and the Commerce Clause, and thus only its Alaska-based subsidiaries should be subject to Alaska income tax. The court found that the taxpayer was a unitary business and therefore lacked standing to challenge Alaska s alternative apportionment method applied to taxpayers engaged in the transportation of oil or gas by pipeline. 17
18 Insurance Companies
19 State Taxation of Insurance Companies Ind. Dep t of Revenue v. United Parcel Serv., Inc., 969 N.E.2d 596 (Ind. June 21, 2012) The Indiana Supreme Court held that income from UPS s out-of-state captives was not exempt from the state s corporate income tax because reinsurance transactions taking place out of state did not subject the affiliates to the state s premium tax If the captives had nexus in Indiana, they would be subject to the premium tax and their income could not be included in the UPS combined corporate income tax return Illustrates the implications of defining subject to tax Hypothetical vs. actually paid 19
20 State Taxation of Insurance Companies United Parcel Serv., Inc. v. Ind. Dep t of State Rev., 995 N.E.2d 20 (Ind. Tax Ct. Sept. 16, 2013) On remand, the Indiana Tax Court determined that captive insurance companies must be physically present in the state to be doing business, and thus to qualify for a corporate income tax exemption Rejected Department s assertion that the Ind. Supreme Court intended for a lower economic presence standard Rejected Commerce Clause challenge to regime that taxed domestic insurance companies under premiums tax but outof-state insurance companies under the corporate income tax, because Commerce Clause challenges enjoy immunity under the federal McCarran-Ferguson Act 20
21 State Taxation of Insurance Companies Wendy s Int l, Inc. v. Hamer, No , 2013 IL App (4th) (Ill. App. Ct. Oct. 7, 2013) Illinois Appellate Court determined that state must treat the Wendy s captive insurance company as an insurance company for income tax purposes. Thus, taxpayer properly excluded the captive from its unitary group. Captive met definition of insurance company under federal law and, thus, properly recognizable as such under state law: Majority of captive s income derived from insurance business activities Formed for purpose of shifting and distributing risk 21
22 Questions? Jeff Friedman, Partner Sutherland Michele Borens, Partner Sutherland
23 Connect with us! The Sutherland SALT Shaker mobile app is now available in the itunes App store and on Google Play for Android! Visit us at Sutherland SALT Group
The Latest and Greatest in State Tax Litigation
Marc Simonetti Andrew Appleby TEI Upstate New York Tax Conference May 6, 2014 The Latest and Greatest in State Tax Litigation Agenda Group Composition / Unitary Disputes Apportionment Nexus MTC Election
More informationThe MTC Election Following Gillette vs. Franchise Tax Board
The MTC Election Following Gillette vs. Franchise Tax Board Thomas Cornett Senior Manager Deloitte Tax LLP Detroit, Michigan December 6, 2012 Agenda Background: The Multistate Tax Compact Gillette vs.
More informationState and Local Tax: Ten Cases to Watch
Prentiss Willson, Of Counsel Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Tax Executive Institute Houston Chapter State and Local Tax May 9, 2014 State and Local Tax: Ten Cases to Watch 1 Due Process and Commerce Clauses
More informationNationwide State Tax Case Developments
Carley Roberts, Partner Dan Schlueter, Partner Marc Simonetti, Partner TEI Detroit Dearborn, Michigan March 26, 2014 Nationwide State Tax Case Developments MULTISTATE TAX COMPACT LITIGATION 2 The Multistate
More informationJeffrey A. Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner Leah Robinson, Partner TEI/IPT SALT Day December 9, 2014
Jeffrey A. Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner Leah Robinson, Partner TEI/IPT SALT Day December 9, 2014 State Tax Litigation and Controversy Update Agenda Apportionment Income Tax Nexus Dormant Commerce
More informationDiscussion of State Tax Cases, Issues and Policy Matters to Watch in 2014
Discussion of State Tax Cases, Issues and Policy Matters to Watch in 2014 California & Pacific Southwest Regional State Tax Seminar August 7, 2014 Irvine, California 1 Presenters Wm. Gregory Turner COST
More informationState and Local Tax Update. Tuesday, November 28, 2017 Wichita Country Club Tim Hartley - Director
State and Local Tax Update Tuesday, November 28, 2017 Wichita Country Club Tim Hartley - Director Presenters Tim Hartley Director Tax tim.hartley@us.gt.com 316 636 6507 Grant Thornton LLP. All rights reserved.
More informationIndustry Specific Nexus Issues
Jeffrey A. Friedman Maria M. Todorova STARTUP Spring 2014 Conference May 15, 2014 Industry Specific Nexus Issues Agenda Jurisdiction to Tax Recent Nexus Developments Industry-Specific Issues Characterization
More informationState Tax Implications of Commodities Transactions
Scott Wright Andrew Appleby State Tax Implications of Commodities Transactions Sutherland SALT Financial Services Roundtable January 21, 2016 All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational
More informationEric Tresh Sutherland Jonathan Feldman Sutherland TEI Meeting Petroleum Club Ft. Worth, TX June 25, State Tax Litigation and Legislation Update
Eric Tresh Sutherland Jonathan Feldman Sutherland TEI Meeting Petroleum Club Ft. Worth, TX June 25, 2014 State Tax Litigation and Legislation Update Agenda Group Composition / Unitary Disputes Nexus MTC
More informationState Income Tax Litigation You Need to Know About
Michele Borens, Partner Amy Nogid, Counsel TEI New York State and Local Tax Seminar November 9, 2016 State Income Tax Litigation You Need to Know About All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general
More informationState and Local Taxation Update: Information Sharing and Transparency
Jeffrey A. Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner May 14, 2014 TEI Denver Chapter State and Local Taxation Update: Information Sharing and Transparency Agenda Transparency in State Taxation What Type
More informationConformity Issues in SALT
Carley Roberts, Partner Zachary Atkins, Associate TEI Nashville 2014 Spring Seminar Franklin, TN May 14, 2014 Conformity Issues in SALT Agenda Conformity and the State Income Tax Base Capital Gains Conformity
More informationSlicing the Pie Update on State Tax Apportionment Litigation TEI Denver
Slicing the Pie Update on State Tax Apportionment Litigation TEI Denver May 15, 2017 Maria Todorova Partner Ted Friedman Associate 2018 (US) LLP Agenda Introduction Key Issues Recent Developments Sales
More informationLitigation and Controversy Update
Jeff Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner TEI San Diego State and Local Tax Seminar September 29, 2016 Litigation and Controversy Update All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational
More informationNexus Assistant Results
Nexus Assistant Results Tax Type: Corporate Income Legend: N/A - Not Applicable Alabama --Company Business income includes income from intangible personal property, the acquisition, management, and disposition
More informationCALIFORNIA UPDATE. Financial Institutions State Tax Coalition Annual Meeting November 13, Jeffrey M. Vesely Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
CALIFORNIA UPDATE Financial Institutions State Tax Coalition Annual Meeting November 13, 2014 Jeffrey M. Vesely Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP 705554564 AGENDA APPORTIONMENT BUSINESS/NONBUSINESS DIVIDENDS/INTEREST
More informationCorporate Apportionment and Sourcing Rights in Multistate Tax Compact States Key Implications Triggered by California's Gillette Case
Presenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A Corporate Apportionment and Sourcing Rights in Multistate Tax Compact States Key Implications Triggered by California's Gillette Case WEDNESDAY,
More informationAlternative Apportionment - The Process and the Impact
Alternative Apportionment - The Process and the Impact Current Issues in State & Local Taxation TEI Philadelphia Chapter February 22, 2017 Maria Todorova Open Weaver Banks 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.
More information2018 Tax Executives Institute, Inc. Houston Texas May 11, 2018 ALL STATES UPDATE. Marilyn M. Wethekam (312)
2018 Tax Executives Institute, Inc. Houston Texas May 11, 2018 ALL STATES UPDATE Marilyn M. Wethekam (312) 606-3240 mwethekam@saltlawyers.com Horwood Marcus & Berk Chartered 500 W. Madison Street, Suite
More informationShifting Apportionment Landscape TEI Nevada Chapter
Shifting Apportionment Landscape TEI Nevada Chapter April 19, 2017 Jeff Friedman Partner Marc Simonetti Partner 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational purposes
More informationTop Ten Nonconformity Issues Between Federal and State
Top Ten Nonconformity Issues Between Federal and State Sixth Annual UW-TEI Tax Forum February 17, 2017 Jeff Friedman, Partner Michele Borens, Partner 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication
More informationUDITPA Section 18: The Changing Faces of Alternative Apportionment
UDITPA Section 18: The Changing Faces of Alternative Apportionment July 12, 2009 Presented by: Kelly W. Smith, LLP Jay Koren, LLP PwC This document was not written to be used, and it cannot be used, for
More informationCALIFORNIA UPDATE. Financial Institutions State Tax Coalition Annual Meeting November 12, Jeffrey M. Vesely Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
CALIFORNIA UPDATE Financial Institutions State Tax Coalition Annual Meeting November 12, 2018 Jeffrey M. Vesely Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP 4834-0357-6954v1 AGENDA FEDERAL TAX REFORM APPORTIONMENT
More informationOhio Tax. Workshop Q. Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Trends, Pitfalls & Opportunities. Tuesday, January 24, p.m. to 4 p.m.
26th Annual Tuesday & Wednesday, January 24 25, 2017 Hya Regency Columbus, Columbus, Ohio Ohio Tax Workshop Q Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Trends, Pitfalls & Opportunities Tuesday, January 24, 2017
More informationJUDICIAL DEVELOPMENTS IN THE INCOME AND SALES TAX WORLD: THE YEAR IN REVIEW
JUDICIAL DEVELOPMENTS IN THE INCOME AND SALES TAX WORLD: THE YEAR IN REVIEW 2017 Federation of Tax Administrators Annual Meeting Seattle, Washington 6/12/17 Presenters (the opinions expressed are personal
More informationMTC Apportionment Yes, No, Maybe? The National Ramifications of the Gillette Case, Recent Legislation and Cases Pending in Other States
2012 COST ANNUAL MEETING Orlando, Florida MTC Apportionment Yes, No, Maybe? The National Ramifications of the Gillette Case, Recent Legislation and Cases Pending in Other States Lynn Gandhi Honigman, Miller,
More informationADMINISTRATIVE DECISION
STATE OF ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE & ADMINISTRATION OFFICE OF HEARINGS & APPEALS ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION IN THE MATTER OF REFUND CLAIM DISALLOWANCES (ACCT. NO.: ) (Corporate Income Tax) DOCKET NOS.:
More informationCalifornia and Multistate
Chapter 7 California and Multistate 1 Topics California Income and Franchise Taxes Sales and Use Taxes Property Taxes Miscellaneous Multistate 2 Contacting FTB FTB Pub 1240 https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/misc/1240.pdf
More informationState income and franchise tax quarterly update
Third quarter 2014 State income tax developments State income and franchise tax quarterly update In this issue To our readers: Key developments The following provides a summary of the significant legislative,
More informationWhirlwind Review of New State Tax Laws
Todd Lard, Partner Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Carley Roberts, Partner Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP FTA Annual Conference June 10, 2014 Whirlwind Review of New State Tax Laws Agenda Factor Weighting
More informationThe Collision of Formulary Apportionment and Transfer Pricing COST Pacific Northwest Regional State Tax Seminar
The Collision of Formulary Apportionment and Transfer Pricing COST Pacific Northwest Regional State Tax Seminar December 7, 2017 Todd Lard Partner Ted Friedman Associate 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.
More informationOhio Tax. Workshop Q. Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Trends, Pitfalls & Opportunities. Tuesday, January 26 3 p.m. to 4 p.m.
25th Annual Tuesday & Wednesday, January 26 27, 2016 Hya Regency Columbus, Columbus, Ohio Ohio Tax Workshop Q Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Trends, Pitfalls & Opportunities Tuesday, January 26 3 p.m.
More informationPublication 9, Construction and Building Contractors, California State Board of Equalization, December 2015
January 2016 California Construction and Building Contractors Tax Guidance Issued The California State Board of Equalization has updated its publication on the sales and use tax treatment and responsibilities
More informationALABAMA COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS
REL: 02/17/2012 Notice: This opinion is subject to formal revision before publication in the advance sheets of Southern Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Reporter of Decisions, Alabama Appellate
More informationThe Most Important State And Local Tax Cases Of 2017
Portfolio Media. Inc. 111 West 19 th Street, 5th Floor New York, NY 10011 www.law360.com Phone: +1 646 783 7100 Fax: +1 646 783 7161 customerservice@law360.com The Most Important State And Local Tax Cases
More informationTWIST-Q Summary of developments
TWIST-Q Summary of developments Rate changes Impact The corporate income tax rate is increased to 7.0 percent effective July 1, 2017. Senate Bill 9 (veto overridden July 6, 2017). IL Because the state
More informationSales and Use Tax Audit Trends
TEI Audits and Appeals May 21, 2015 Michele Borens Todd Lard Sales and Use Tax Audit Trends Agenda Aggressive States and Auditors Locality Audits Third Party Auditors Class Action Concerns/Considerations
More informationLitigation Update for Texas Taxpayers and Research Association (TTARA) Annual Meeting
Litigation Update for Texas Taxpayers and Research Association (TTARA) Annual Meeting Don Neal Deputy General Counsel for Litigation & Taxation Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts October 22, 2014 Austin,
More informationHold the Intercompany Transactions State and Local Tax Considerations
Hold the Intercompany Transactions State and Local Tax Considerations Current Issues in State & Local Taxation TEI Philadelphia Chapter February 22, 2017 Open Weaver Banks Andrew Appleby 2017 (US) LLP
More informationState income and franchise tax quarterly update
First quarter 2014 State income tax developments State income and franchise tax quarterly update First-quarter 2014 state tax developments The following provides a summary of the legislative, administrative
More informationSALT 2017 Outlook Cases, Issues and Policies to Watch TEI Nevada Chapter
SALT 2017 Outlook Cases, Issues and Policies to Watch TEI Nevada Chapter April 19, 2017 Jeff Friedman Partner Michele Borens Partner 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general
More informationState income and franchise tax
Third quarter 2016 State income tax developments State income and franchise tax Quarterly update To our readers: The following provides a summary of the significant legislative, administrative and judicial
More informationState Tax Return. Kristi L. Stathopoulos Atlanta (404)
July 2006 Volume 13 Number 7 State Tax Return California Appellate Court Finds Return of Principal on Short- Term Investments Is Gross Receipts, But Excludes From the Taxpayer s Sales Factor Kristi L.
More informationSTATE TAX LITIGATION UPDATE
Federation of Tax Administrators Annual Meeting June 10, 2013 STATE TAX LITIGATION UPDATE I. NEXUS ISSUES 1. Ann Sacks Tile and Stone, Inc. v. Department of Revenue, Oregon Tax Court, No. TC 4879, November
More informationIMPORTANT INFORMATION
Advanced Income Tax Apportionment Issues Confronting Multi-State Companies Navigating States' Shift to Market-Based Sourcing, Utilizing Alternative Apportionment and Weighting Factors WEDNESDAY, JULY 22,
More informationClass Action Lawsuits and False Claims Act Suits: Protecting Your Company
Dan Schlueter, Partner Andrew Appleby, Associate TEI Los Angeles May 15, 2015 Class Action Lawsuits and False Claims Act Suits: Protecting Your Company 1 Overview What are False Claims Act (FCA) lawsuits?
More informationSTATE OF MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
This document is made available electronically by the Minnesota Legislative Reference Library as part of an ongoing digital archiving project. http://www.leg.state.mn.us/lrl/sonar/sonar.asp STATE OF MINNESOTA
More informationState Tax Controversy Update
Marc Simonetti, Partner Sutherland s Year-End Tax Seminar December 6, 2016 State Tax Controversy Update All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational purposes only and is not intended
More informationWhat Would Federal Tax Reform Mean for States?
Jeffrey A. Friedman March 31, 2016 What Would Federal Tax Reform Mean for States? Urban Institute Forum All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational purposes only and is not intended
More informationImplications of Wynne and Group Discussion
Jeff Friedman, Partner Jon Maddison, Associate June 12, 2015 Implications of Wynne and Group Discussion 1 Maryland s Tax Regime Maryland imposes state and county income taxes on its residents. Maryland
More informationTom Cornett, Deloitte Tax LLP Oct 31, 2015
Recent Developments in State and Local Tax DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES ONLY Tom Cornett, Deloitte Tax LLP Oct 31, 2015 Agenda Proposed Federal Legislation Trends in State Income Tax Economic Presence
More informationNew Directions for Indirect Taxes
W. Scott Wright Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Zachary T. Atkins Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP TEI Atlanta Half-Day SALT Seminar June 3, 2014 New Directions for Indirect Taxes 1 Overview An influx of
More informationLegislative, regulatory and. judicial income tax. developments: key states
Legislative, regulatory and judicial income tax developments: key states 14 May 2013 Disclaimer Ernst & Young refers to the global organization of member firms of Ernst & Young global limited, each of
More informationState Tax Implications of New (and Pending) Federal Rules
Todd A. Lard Andrew D. Appleby NESTOA September 27, 2016 State Tax Implications of New (and Pending) Federal Rules All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general informational purposes only and
More informationState and Local Tax 2017 Developments, Including Quill TEI Denver Chapter
State and Local Tax 2017 Developments, Including Quill TEI Denver Chapter May 24, 2017 Jeff Friedman Partner Michele Borens Partner 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general
More informationSB 28 Joyce to Finnigan
SB 28 Joyce to Finnigan Senate Committee on Finance and Revenue February 6, 2017 2 What is it? Joyce and Finnigan are references to two different ways of calculating a unitary group s sales factor numerator
More informationState Tax Return I. SUBSTANTIAL NEXUS LITIGATION IN THE STATE COURTS
September 2007 Volume 14 Number 9 State Tax Return NEXUS: UPDATE ON RECENT DEVELOPMENTS Maryann B. Gall Columbus (614) 469-3924 Laura A. Kulwicki Columbus (330) 656-0416 We keep track of nexus developments
More informationFair Reflection: Defending Against or Applying Alternative Apportionment
COST Pacific Northwest Regional State Tax Seminar San Francisco, California July 10, 2012 Fair Reflection: Defending Against or Applying Alternative Apportionment Kerne H. O. Matsubara, Esq. Michael J.
More informationTax Management. Allocation/Apportionment
Tax Management Weekly State Tax Report Reproduced with permission from Tax Management Weekly State Tax Report, WSTR 04/29/16, 04/29/2016. Copyright 2016 by The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. (800-372-1033)
More informationSTATE APPORTIONMENT UPDATE
STATE APPORTIONMENT UPDATE Sourcing of Services and Market-based Souring Laura Holmes Senior Director BDO USA February 16, 2016 TEI Houston Chapter Tax School Laura Holmes, CPA State and Local Tax Senior
More informationCurrent California "Strict Liability" Penalty Issues Under Revenue and Taxation Code Sections and 19138
Current California "Strict Liability" Penalty Issues Under Revenue and Taxation Code Sections 19777.5 and 19138 10/14/2009 State + Local Tax Client Alert While California s current $26 billion budget crisis
More informationTWIST-Q Summary of developments First Quarter 2019
TWIST-Q Summary of developments First Quarter 2019 This checklist includes developments for Quarter 1 of 2019 that have occurred prior to the date of publication. Please note that certain Quarter 1 items
More informationIPT 2016 Sales Tax Symposium Indianapolis, Indiana September Credit Card Bad Debts Is Anyone Entitled to Sales Tax Refunds?
IPT 2016 Sales Tax Symposium Indianapolis, Indiana September 18-21 Credit Card Bad Debts Is Anyone Entitled to Sales Tax Refunds? Presenters Tom Zessman, CMI Senior Tax Manager, U.S. Bank, N.A. 612-303-4361/thomas.zessman@usbank.com
More informationSALTY Talk: 2018 SALT Insurance Tax Update
SALTY Talk: 2018 SALT Insurance Tax Update DECEMBER 18, 2018 TO RECEIVE CPE CREDIT Individuals Participate in entire webinar Answer polls when they are provided Groups Group leader is the person who registered
More informationState & Local Tax Alert
State & Local Tax Alert Breaking state and local tax developments from Grant Thornton LLP U.S. Supreme Court Vacates and Remands Massachusetts Case for Further Consideration Based on Wynne On October 13,
More informationState Tax Return. Is There A Constitutional Standard for UDITPA 18 Alternative Apportionment?
April 2007 Volume 14 Number 4 State Tax Return Is There A Constitutional Standard for UDITPA 18 Alternative Apportionment? Charolette Noel Kristi L. Stathopoulos Dallas Atlanta (214) 969-4538 (404) 581-8512
More informationKathryn M. Jaques Summer Tax Institute June 2017
Kathryn M. Jaques Summer Tax Institute June 2017 } General partnership } Limited partnership } Limited liability partnership (LLP) } Limited liability company (LLC) Multiple member LLC Single member LLC
More informationSALT YEAR-END UPDATE PART 1 STATE INCOME TAX DEVELOPMENTS. November SALT Year-End Update Part 1: State Income Tax Developments
SALT YEAR-END UPDATE PART 1 STATE INCOME TAX DEVELOPMENTS November 2017 1 1 WITH YOU TODAY MARIANO SORI Partner State & Local Tax 312-616-4654 msori@bdo.com RICHARD SPENGLER Senior Director State & Local
More informationState Tax Return. Columbus
April 2007 Volume 14 Number 4 State Tax Return NEXUS: UPDATE ON RECENT DEVELOPMENTS Maryann B. Gall Columbus (614) 281-3924 Phyllis J. Shambaugh Columbus (614) 281-3824 Laura A. Kulwicki Columbus (330)
More informationThe 2018 National Multistate Tax Symposium Take the lead Tax reform and fortifying state positions. February 7-9, 2018
The 2018 National Multistate Tax Symposium Take the lead Tax reform and fortifying state positions February 7-9, 2018 State tax twists and turns: What s happened that surprised us Valerie Dickerson, Deloitte
More informationThe 2019 National Multistate Tax Symposium State tax reboot The age of Multistate. February 6-8, 2019
The 2019 National Multistate Tax Symposium State tax reboot The age of Multistate February 6-8, 2019 Sales factor deep dive Defining today s Market Sheelagh Beaulieu, CVS Caremark Corporation Craig B.
More informationSCOTUS, SALT & the Road Ahead St. Petersburg, FL June 10, 2014
SCOTUS, SALT & the Road Ahead St. Petersburg, FL June 10, 2014 Panelist: Bruce Fort, MTC Fred Nicely, COST Marshall Stranburg, FL DOR Greg Turner, COST 2008 Term Polar Tankers 1/83 cases 2009 Term Levin
More informationSelf Procurement taxes
Self Procurement taxes Daniel J. Kusaila, Tax Partner Crowe Horwath LLP Audit Tax Advisory Risk Performance 2015 Crowe Horwath LLP Agenda What is a procurement tax Nexus standards and Todd Shipyards Non
More informationSales/Use Tax Updates & Developments - Texas & Louisiana - Streamlined Sales Tax - Affiliate Nexus. IPT - San Antonio March 28, 2012
Sales/Use Tax Updates & Developments - Texas & Louisiana - Streamlined Sales Tax - Affiliate Nexus IPT - San Antonio March 28, 2012 Scott Steinbring David Somerville Tracy Watts Overview Updates & Developments
More informationSingle Sales Apportionment:
Presenting a live 110 minute teleconference with interactive Q&A Single Sales Apportionment: Crafting a Multi State Strategy Meeting Tax Compliance and Planning Demands Amid Significant Changes in Sales
More informationSALT 2017 Outlook Cases, Issues and Policies to Watch TEI Oklahoma City Chapter
SALT 2017 Outlook Cases, Issues and Policies to Watch TEI Oklahoma City Chapter May 11, 2017 Todd Lard Partner Christopher Lutz Associate 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication is for general
More informationAdvanced Income Tax Apportionment Issues Confronting Multi-State Companies
FOR LIVE PROGRAM ONLY Advanced Income Tax Apportionment Issues Confronting Multi-State Companies THURSDAY, JULY 20, 2017, 1:00-2:50 pm Eastern IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR THE LIVE PROGRAM This program is
More informationCurrent Trends in Alternative Apportionment. UDITPA Section 18
Current Trends in Alternative Apportionment UDITPA Section 18 Advanced State and Local Tax Institute August 6-7, 2012 Your Panel Panelists Kimberley M. Reeder Partner, Reeder Wilson LLP Redwood City, CA
More informationTWIST-Q 2017 Summary of developments
TWIST-Q 2017 Summary of developments This checklist includes the developments we reported in Quarters 1, 2, and 3, as well as new developments for Quarter 4. New developments from Quarter 4 are in bold
More informationBackground. Earlier Guidance
October 2017 California Guidance on Water s-edge Elections Expanded The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) extended earlier guidance addressing the treatment of a water's-edge election when the expansion
More informationState Tax Return. Geoffrey Bagged In Oklahoma: Tax Commission Sets Its Scopes on Geoffrey's Income From Intangible Property And Hit The Target
February 2006 Volume 13 Number 2 State Tax Return Geoffrey Bagged In Oklahoma: Tax Commission Sets Its Scopes on Geoffrey's Income From Intangible Property And Hit The Target Matthew J. Cristy Atlanta
More informationPresenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A. Today s faculty features:
Presenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A Advanced Apportionment Issues Confronting Multi-State Companies Reporting Accurately and Strategically, Preparing for Problematic States,
More informationBad Debts: How Contractual Terms and Sales Tax Intersect IPT Annual Conference Charlotte, North Carolina
Bad Debts: How Contractual Terms and Sales Tax Intersect Thomas Zessman Senior Tax Manager U.S. Bank Minneapolis, Minnesota thomas.zessman@usbank.com Kyle Brehm State and Local Tax Director PricewaterhouseCoopers
More informationThe Impact of Joyce & Finnigan on Multi-State Combined Groups with Intangible Sales
The Impact of Joyce & Finnigan on Multi-State Combined Groups with Intangible Sales By Selena Walker I. INTRODUCTION The California State Board of Equalization decisions of In the Matter of the Appeal
More informationOhio Tax. Workshop N. Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Sales Factor, Costs of Performance, Market-Based Sourcing & Alternative Apportionment
27th Annual Tuesday & Wednesday, January 23 24, 2018 Hya Regency Columbus, Columbus, Ohio Ohio Tax Workshop N Advanced: Multistate Apportionment Sales Factor, Costs of Performance, Market-Based Sourcing
More informationAbstract. Standard formulary apportionment, as currently adopted by states which impose a corporate level
Abstract Standard formulary apportionment, as currently adopted by states which impose a corporate level income tax on multistate corporations, may have a distortive effect in instances where the corporation
More informationNexus Under Fire: The Assault on Quill and Other Developments TEI Los Angeles Chapter
Nexus Under Fire: The Assault on Quill and Other Developments TEI Los Angeles Chapter May 19, 2017 Michele Borens Partner Tim Gustafson Counsel 2017 (US) LLP All Rights Reserved. This communication is
More information2003 Insurance Tax Year in Review: Part III - State and Local Tax Matters by Richard J. Burness and Rick Carlson
Page 1 of 8 2003 Insurance Tax Year in Review: Part III - State and Local Tax Matters by Richard J. Burness and Rick Carlson In the third installment of a four-part report, representatives from Deloitte
More informationCorporation Could Exclude Sale of U.S. Business from Sales Factor
```` December 2017 California Corporation Could Exclude Sale of U.S. Business from Sales Factor A corporation could exclude the sale of its U.S. business when determining the sales apportionment factor
More informationState income and franchise tax quarterly update
Fourth quarter 2015 State income tax developments State income and franchise tax quarterly update In this issue Key developments To our readers: The following provides a summary of the significant legislative,
More informationCalifornia and Multistate
California and Multistate Chapter 6 1 Conformity Conformity in General FTB Information Letter 2014-01 See text in outline. https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/updates/conformity.shtml 2 Conformity references
More informationApportionment Rules Evolve As Business Environment Changes
Apportionment Rules Evolve As Business Environment Changes September 2007 By Michael S. Schadewald Michael S. Schadewald examines apportionment rules with a focus on the sales factor. Introduction The
More informationAgenda. Income/franchise tax. Nexus Sourcing of Revenue for Services Uniformity and Simplicity Intercompany Transactions Update. Salt Lunch and Learn
Income/franchise tax Salt Lunch and Learn Agenda Nexus Sourcing of Revenue for Services Uniformity and Simplicity Intercompany Transactions Update Texas Louisiana 2 1 Multistate -Nexus Nexus Taxpayer s
More informationPresenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A. Today s faculty features:
Presenting a live 110-minute teleconference with interactive Q&A State Corporate Income Apportionment Key Fundamentals Understanding Trends and State Approaches to Factor Weighting, Service Revenue, Joyce
More informationIncome/Franchise: California FTB Now Permitting Taxpayers to Make Oral Presentations in Staff- Initiated Alternative Apportionment Proposals
State Tax Matters The power of knowing. In this issue: Income/Franchise: California FTB Now Permitting Taxpayers to Make Oral Presentations in Staff-Initiated Alternative Apportionment Proposals... 1 Income/Franchise:
More informationState Tax Matters The power of knowing. May 26, In this issue:
State Tax Matters The power of knowing. In this issue: Amnesty/Voluntary Disclosure: Oklahoma: New Law Provides for 2017 Tax Amnesty Program; Qualifying Criteria and Lookback Periods for Voluntary Disclosure
More informationDiscussion of State Tax Cases, Issues and Policy Matters to Watch in 2015
Discussion of State Tax Cases, Issues and Policy Matters to Watch in 2015 Pacific Southwest Regional State Tax Seminar February 19, 2015 Phoenix, Arizona 1 Agenda State of the States Business Tax Trends
More informationThe Supreme Court Should Accept A Nexus Case Part II
The Supreme Court Should Accept A Nexus Case Part II by Michele Borens and Scott Booth Back in Time What Is the Nexus Standard and How Has It Been Applied? Taxpayers have become accustomed to contending
More informationState income and franchise tax quarterly update
First quarter 2015 State income tax developments State income and franchise tax quarterly update In this issue Key developments To our readers: The following provides a summary of the significant legislative,
More information