Fundamental Indexation Usually, but not always, a value play July Prepared by Aon Hewitt Retirement & Investment
|
|
- Alyson Thornton
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Fundamental Indexation Usually, but not always, a value play July 2017 Prepared by Aon Hewitt Retirement & Investment
2 Summary This paper is the third in a series on alternative indexation so called smart beta investing. The intention to develop a framework to provide medium term views on the major smart beta factors. Fundamental indexation, a term coined by Research Affiliates, is not strictly a way of creating a value biased portfolio of stocks at relatively low cost, but it tends to do this in practice. As with other alternative indices, the core idea is to break the index s weighting scheme from the stock price, in this case, using information on a company s balance sheet and earnings strength, as well as its value relative to assets on the books. Value is probably the first factor to be identified, and has a large body of empirical evidence to support its existence. But value has not provided a premium over the past decade. As with all factors, the performance of value and, hence of the fundamental indices, is highly cyclical, with very long periods of underperformance. Value, and the RAFI index, especially is higher beta than the market cap index. This means that the indices are higher risk and will tend to underperform in times of market stress. This is an important issue to consider when deciding on investing. Returns have been driven by a few specific sectors and countries, such as energy and materials stocks, meaning that the indices can be overly exposed to stock or country specific developments that are not related to the value factor. This is a risk with most alternative indices and should be kept in mind by investors. Our medium term economic and market outlook indicates a moderate preference for the value factor relative to low volatility and quality focused indices. The ride will not be smooth, however, with variable headwinds to contend with, hence the small tilt. Fundamental indices, such as RAFI, are also preferred for their value and cyclical exposures. 2
3 What is Fundamental Indexation? Fundamental indexation is commonly classified as an alternative indexation (or smart beta) approach, which uses a weighting scheme that breaks the link between past performance and index weight. In contrast to standard market cap indices, where the largest companies have the largest weight in the index, companies with the highest rank in terms of a selection of other company and balance sheet metrics get the biggest weight in these indices. The unifying theme across all smart beta approaches is that they focus on factors, such as low volatility, quality, momentum or small companies, that are thought to offer a long term premium relative to market cap indices. In other words, portfolios weighted towards these factors have proven to outperform the market cap index over long periods of time and across different markets. Fundamental indices are normally thought to be an effective way to invest in so-called value stocks or those companies whose stock prices are lower than is justified by their underlying value. However, this assertion is controversial. We will test this assumption on pages 8 and 9. As the name suggests, the weighting criteria are related to the fundamentals of companies. These can vary a little across the major providers but generally include strong earnings or sales, along with valuable balance sheets at a reasonable price. In terms of the last criterion, the most common metric is the book value to share price ratio. There are many different providers of fundamental indices, but this note will concentrate on easily the most well-known of these, the Research Affiliates Fundamental Index or RAFI. The note will also contrast this, where appropriate, with the MSCI Value Weighted index, which we use to represent a more explicit value tilted index. We will be using the most global versions of both. Fundamental indexation looks for profitable and valuable companies with low stock prices. The main criteria for selection 3
4 How are the indices constructed? RAFI They start with a parent index and use an average of four metrics or "fundamental factors" sales, cash flow, book value and dividends to rank all the companies in descending order of this averaged fundamental measure (see flow chart). Apart from book value, the other three metrics are 5 year averages. At this point, the bottom most stocks are excluded, depending on the version and the weights of the companies in this new index are linked to the fundamental measure. Each version has its own parent index FTSE Global All Cap for the RAFI All World 3000 or the FTSE US All Cap for the RAFI US 1000, for example and the number of excluded stocks varies according to the number in the title. MSCI Value Weighted Index The MSCI Value Weighted index uses the three year averages of sales, earnings and cash earnings, along with the latest book value reading to determine its weights. There is no exclusion of stocks relative to the parent, market cap index. This contrasts with the confusingly named MSCI Value index, in that the latter still uses price related ratios, such as Price to Book Value and Price to Sales. Both the Value Weighted index and RAFI break the link to stock price. There is substantial overlap between the construction criteria of RAFI and the MSCI Value Weighted index. At face value, this hints that RAFI might have a bias towards value stocks. As we will see, however, the small differences do add up over time. RAFI construction 4
5 Where does RAFI fit amongst the other smart beta strategies? Statistics for selected MSCI passive smart beta indices compared with the MSCI AC World index MSCI AC World Minimum Volatility Quality Momentum Value RAFI No. of stocks Beta yr Sharpe Ratio Tracking Error Turnover % Price/Earnings Ratio Price/Book Value Ratio Dividend Yield Source: MSCI and Research Affiliates. All indices are the All Country World index versions, except RAFI 3000, which is also the most global version of the index All figures correct as at end May 2017 As the above table shows, both the MSCI All Country Value Weighted index ( Value ) and the FTSE RAFI All World 3000 index ( RAFI ) contain a large amount of stocks and certainly suffer less from concentration problems in comparison with the other prominent smart beta indices. They also both have a beta, or sensitivity to the market, of greater than one. This means that upwards or downwards movements in the wider market would tend to translate into a greater movement in the same direction. The key implication is that investors will be taking on extra risk by switching from the market cap index to either RAFI or Value. At the same time, we can see that the 10 year risk adjusted monthly returns, or Sharpe ratio, are broadly in line with the market cap index there certainly does not seem to be a clear outperformance on this measure at least. As with all smart beta strategies that employ a method of altering allocations and excluding stocks, the portfolio turnover figures are higher versus the market cap index. Regular buying and selling of stocks (the indices rebalance every 6 months) incurs transactions costs, which will eat into the performance of these indices. This is not excessive relative to active managers with typical turnover rates of 85% or more, but investors should be aware that this cost must be paid before returns can be earned. Finally, we can see from the valuation measures that RAFI is currently invested in cheap stocks by Price/Earnings and Price/Book Value standards, thus further supporting the view that RAFI gains the investor exposure to value stocks. RAFI is value oriented but is riskier than the market cap index, as evidenced by a higher tracking error and a higher beta. 5
6 How has RAFI performed? Since 2002, the RAFI 3000 has outperformed relative to the market cap index (here the MSCI All Country World Index, but results are similar with the FTSE All World index). $100 invested in 2002 in the market cap index would be worth $279 now, whereas the equivalent in the RAFI All World 3000 index would be worth $402 (see top chart). By contrast, the MSCI Value Weighted index, whilst also an outperformer, has not performed quite as well as the RAFI the same $100 would be worth $315 now. However, outperformance has been much harder to come by since the global financial crisis (see bottom chart). Over this 9 year period, the FTSE RAFI All World 3000 index has outperformed the MSCI All Country World Index by 7% points, which translates into an annual outperformance of only 76bps, without also accounting for the extra risk inherent in the RAFI. The Value index has actually underperformed over this period. Since the start of the year, performance has been even worse, with marked underperformance of 2.6% and 3.7% for RAFI and Value respectively. Indeed, we can see from many measures that the past decade has seen the longest period of underperformance by value stocks since data collection began over a century ago. The degree of outperformance relative to market cap for both RAFI and Value has weakened markedly since the financial crisis. RAFI and Value are long term outperformers but have struggled since the financial crisis 6
7 What are the drivers of RAFI? Value and small cap recently As the top chart of a returns attributions analysis shows, RAFI is currently heavily weighted towards value stocks, where value stocks are defined as those with low price to book value ratios. There is also a weighting towards small companies but this is a little misleading because only 10% of the parent index can be classed as small companies. Large companies still dominate the RAFI and the parent FTSE index. The theoretical underpinnings of both the value and small cap premiums are strong, having been identified over very long periods of time and across different regional markets. The value factor premium was also the first to be identified and value investors are very prevalent in the active management industry (the appendix sets out the theory behind both factors). Furthermore, looking at the performance of the RAFI index relative to the Value weighted index since 2014, we can see a very close correlation, thus supporting the view that RAFI has been biased sharply towards value stocks over this period (see bottom chart). This is in contrast to the data on pages 6 and 7 that clearly show a differential in performance between the two over a 10 or 15 year time horizon. There is clearly more going on here and it would be incorrect to think that all value focused indices are the same. The next page delves deeper into this issue. RAFI performance has been driven by an exposure to value and small cap stocks in recent times but this does not explain performance over longer periods. RAFI is strongly weighted towards value currently and performance over the last few years indicate a value bias 7
8 What are the drivers of RAFI? Why do RAFI and Value weighted indices perform differently? The purveyors of RAFI often say that they are not strictly a value tilted index, but the evidence is quite clear that the value factor is the leading driver of returns, both recently and over the longer term. However, there is clearly a difference in returns between RAFI and other, more explicitly value focused indices, such as our choice of the MSCI Value Weighed Index. The key here is that there are small, but important differences in the degree to which indices lean into their selection criteria. We can see this by comparing the exposure to stocks with high book value to price ratios and high sales to price ratios of RAFI versus the Value weighted index. As the top chart shows, the difference over time between the exposure of RAFI and Value Weighted to stocks with high book value to price is very similar over the past 10 years. Remember that book value is a core metric to select value stocks. But, the bottom chart reveals that the RAFI has a consistently higher exposure to stocks with high company sales than the Value Weighted exposure. Of course, these relative exposures may well be different if we compare the RAFI with other value focused indices, but the point remains the same. No value index will be the same and small differences can make a material difference over time. RAFI selection criteria focuses more on sales than Value Weighted but has a similar exposure to book value. RAFI and Value Weighted have very similar exposures to book value to price over time but there is a small and material difference in terms of sales to price 8
9 What are the drivers of RAFI? Digging deeper is it worth it to be more exposed to high sales companies? Given that RAFI is more heavily weighted to companies with high sales to price ratios, we have to ask whether this approach really has been the underlying driver of returns compared with the Value Weighted index. Historical data compiled by Bank of America Merrill Lynch for the S&P 500 index certainly suggests that it has. To start with, the top chart shows clearly that stocks with high book value to price ratios (or conversely, low price to book value ratios) took a sharp dive during the global financial crisis and have been tracking sideways ever since. Most financial sector companies fall into the category of high book value to price stocks. In other words, value indices were hurt by being overweight in financial stocks during the financial crisis and have faced headwinds since then. In contrast, stocks with high sales to price ratios started to outperform strongly after the financial crisis and have continued to make progress up to around RAFI has benefitted more from this than the Value Weighted index and, given the structurally higher weighting to companies with higher sales (using 5 year averages helps), we can assume that this will continue to be an important driver of returns. RAFI s larger bias to high sales companies has supported returns in the past and is an important differentiator to other value focused indices. High book value to price stocks have not been helpful but high sales to price stocks have done well 9
10 What are the drivers of RAFI? Small differences add up over time Another way of showing the impact of slightly different selection criteria is by comparing the sector weightings of the RAFI and Value Weighted indices. As the top chart shows, the RAFI has a higher weighting to energy and materials sectors and a lower weighting to financials and IT stocks. This means that RAFI will be more closely linked to commodities than the Value Weighted index. This was not always the case, however. As the bottom chart shows, in 2010, the RAFI had a significantly higher weight to financials stocks than the Value Weighted index, and a lower weight to energy stocks. Back then, the RAFI would not have been driven by commodity cycle factors relative to the Value Weighted index Also note the behaviour of the value exposures during the financial crisis that we can see in the chart on the previous page. The RAFI remained much more exposed to both high book value and high sales companies than the Value Weighted index over This is due to the longer period used when averaging the selection criteria (5 years versus 3 years). This has an impact on performance differences too. So which should you pick? This depends on whether a pure exposure to value stocks is required, because all the evidence shows clearly that the RAFI might not be a reliable, long term way of achieving this. RAFI weights are different enough to other value indices to become material over time, which will require regular review by investors. Bigger overweights to energy and materials in RAFI compared with value weighted at the moment Relative stock weightings vary over time 10
11 The risks of RAFI investing long periods of underperformance The first risk is applicable to all alternative indexation or smart beta approaches. This is that the performance of the factors being used as weighting criteria are highly cyclical in nature. Furthermore, these cycles can be very long, so although it can mean that outperformance relative to the market cap index can endure, it also means that underperformance can last several years too. For example, RAFI has underperformed the market cap index for the past 3 years (see top chart). However, as the table shows, RAFI has both outperformed the market cap index and the other alternative indices considered here over the past 12 month period. The performance of the others has been poorer, with 3 of them quality, minimum volatility and momentum actually underperforming. The key implication is that the timing of initial investments can be highly important in terms of relative performance, even over quite long periods of time. It also means that tilts to a portfolio of differently focused smart beta indices (on value, quality, low volatility etc) can enhance returns further. The highly cyclical nature of the relative performance of alternative indices increases the importance of timing initial strategic investments and that of medium term asset allocation to dynamically tilt exposures over time. It also means that combining different factors in a portfolio of alternative indices has merit. Timing can matter even over long time horizons RAFI performance moves around a lot, as it does for all factor indices Total returns for selected alternative indices, % 1 year 5 year 10 year 15 year MSCI (market cap) RAFI Value Weighted Quality Minimum Volatility Momentum Source: DataStream Note: All indices are the All Country World versions, except RAFI, w hich is the All World 3000 version 11
12 The risks of RAFI investing unintended exposures A second risk is the issue of unintended exposures. When investing in smart beta products, such as RAFI, the investor is consciously investing in an altered weighting scheme to the market cap index. There is nothing inherently wrong with this. The problem is that particularly large weightings to specific sectors or countries can increase risks beyond those related directly to the factor. For example, the RAFI index has a large overweight to energy, materials and financial companies, and an underweight to IT and Healthcare (see top chart). This would naturally mean that performance will be driven by commodity prices, which could change due to things completely unrelated to value factor specific developments. Examples include geopolitical tensions and supply disruptions. The same argument applies to country exposures. The bottom chart shows a large underweight to US stocks (of over 12%), whilst the largest overweight relative to market cap is in Japan. Again, it may well be the case that there is an overabundance of stocks meeting the RAFI criteria in the Japanese market, but these are unlikely to be accounting for country specific risk. So, if there is a change in Japanese legislation that improves the prospects and stock prices of the country s financial sector, can we really say that this is due to the value factor? Probably not! Equally, a Japanese recession could disproportionately affect the RAFI, which would be unintentional. Beware large relative weights in RAFI that expose the investor to sector and country specific risk. RAFI is overweight in energy, materials and financials and overweight in Japanese, UK and Brazilian stocks 12
13 The medium term outlook conditions point to moderate RAFI outperformance but this may take some time to become apparent The stage of the macroeconomic cycle, along with relative valuations, provide the best indication of medium term outlook for value stocks and, by extension, RAFI. In terms of the cycle, RAFI tends to outperform the market cap index when longer term interest rates are rising (see top chart). This is because interest rates normally rise when economic growth is picking up and company earnings are rising, or future expectations are improving. Value stocks outperform in this environment as earnings improvement is greater for them relative to the average and investors notice. An improving cycle also tends to mean higher commodity prices, and energy stocks tend to be cheap as we have seen earlier. Our view is that developed interest rates are likely to trend higher from here, and oil prices have some moderate upside over the medium term, both of which are supportive for value stocks and RAFI at the current time. But we must remember that macro risks are especially high currently, so our view is tempered. As for valuations, the gap between measures for the cheapest and most expensive stocks can provide a useful guide to turning points in relative performance. When the gap between cheap stocks and expensive stocks is especially large, value tends to perform better (see bottom chart). The gap was very large 12 months ago, over which time value stocks outperformed, but we do not see a large valuation gap at the moment. This means that relative valuations are not particularly supportive. Bond yields and RAFI relative performance are closely linked Value stocks tend to outperform when the gap between the cheapest and most expensive sectors is very wide 13
14 Implementation advice While we think there is a clear benefit to applying Medium Term Views to dynamically alter allocations over time, the key starting point has to be the strategic positioning of alternative indices and the underlying aims of clients. A combination of factor (or alternative) indices could be used to replace part or all of a passive portfolio. This is in order to mitigate the burdensome cyclicality of the returns of individual factors, whilst still achieving superior returns to the market cap index. Remember that relative return patterns are not synchronised across the key factors, such as value, low volatility and quality. From this perspective, we believe that RAFI warrants a place within such a portfolio of factors. Of course, some clients may be considering replacing an active manager with alternative indices in order to lower costs while maintaining a broad exposure to certain factors. This is feasible but clients should be aware that no passive index will provide a completely pure exposure to a factor. For example, a mechanical weighting process would not account for the myriad of qualitative aspects involved in picking value stocks some stocks are cheap for a reason! Furthermore, one should not consider investing in value indices or RAFI with the view of reducing portfolio risk since these styles are actually riskier than the market cap index in market downturns, the underperformance would be greater, not smaller. Downside risk mitigation would more effectively be achieved through investments in low volatility factor focused indices, such as the MSCI Minimum Volatility index. Investment timing can also play an important role, given the fluctuating relative performance of smart beta indices. This applies to both the initial strategic investment and altering allocations over time using medium term views. Asset allocation views are a crucial element in this decision making process. Finally, it should be understood that the true benefit of alternative indices will be borne out over long periods of time and so investments should be undertaken with long time horizons in mind. Please speak to your Aon Hewitt consultant for more details. 14
15 Appendix The theory behind the value and small cap premiums Value The value premium was the first to be identified, back in 1928 by Ben Graham and David Dodd, and has been found across several decades and in many different country markets. It was further identified and applied in the context of passive investing by Eugene Fama and Kenneth French in More recently, however, this return premium has fallen into negative territory, implying that the market cap index has been a consistently better choice over the past 10 year (see chart on next page). There are two broad theories one which supports the investment industry orthodoxy that markets are efficient and that prices reflect all available information, and another that challenges that orthodoxy. The former theory is that cheaper stocks are inherently riskier than average and this higher risk is rewarded with higher returns. The heightened risk of value stocks comes from large fixed assets, for example, that cannot be sold quickly in an economic downturn and that put the company in financial risk. Conversely, when economic demand picks up, these previously struggling companies are the quickest to respond because previously unproductive capital, such as mothballed factories or offices, can be put back on line with little extra cost. This is also why value companies tend to perform better when economic activity starts to pick up after a downturn. This theory has merit but we do not think it is a sufficient explanation for a number of reasons. Firstly, returns seem to be greater than can be explained simply by risk or volatility because the returns adjusted for risk of value stocks are also higher than market cap stocks. Secondly, a phenomenon such as the superior risk adjusted returns of low volatility stocks runs contrary to the theory that higher risk is always rewarded with higher returns. This is also supported by the historical data that shows a long term underperformance of the highest volatility stocks. The second theory, which uses investor behaviour as the key explanation, is perhaps more convincing. Investors routinely overestimate the prospects of growth stocks companies that are forecast to grow strongly and attach too much weight on earnings forecasts as opposed to current earnings and balance sheet strength. This so-called "overreaction effect" is in evidence as stock prices adjust sharply when earnings miss forecasts. If markets were efficient and stock prices reflected all available information accurately, the change in prices would not be so great. This theory is controversial too and empirical evidence is hard to come by. 15
16 Appendix The theory behind the value and small cap premiums Small Cap The small cap premium was identified in the 1970s by Rolf Banz in his paper, The relationship between return and market value of common stocks, and empirical evidence has shown that a portfolio of the smallest companies in the stock market has delivered superior risk adjusted returns relative to the market cap index over the long term. But, along with value, this outperformance has declined markedly over the past decade (see chart). In terms of the theory, smaller stocks are generally less well researched, are more difficult to trade (less liquid) and sometimes have lower reporting responsibilities to the market. They are therefore considered riskier investments. More risk means better expected return, at least according to traditional theory. Smaller firms are also more likely to be able to respond to rapid changes in demand, normally as the economy recovers from a downturn, and their earnings may grow more sharply. However, recent performance hints that there has been a change, at least in terms of research coverage, meaning that there may be less of a premium. Where has the return premium gone? 16
17 Contact List Koray Yesildag CFA Principal, Asset Allocation Specialist Consulting Global Investment Practice +44 (0)
18 Disclaimer Investment advice and consulting services provided by Aon Hewitt Investment Consulting, Inc. ( AHIC ). The information contained herein is given as of the date hereof and does not purport to give information as of any other date. The delivery at any time shall not, under any circumstances, create any implication that there has been a change in the information set forth herein since the date hereof or any obligation to update or provide amendments hereto. This document is not intended to provide, and shall not be relied upon for, accounting, legal or tax advice or investment recommendations. Any accounting, legal, or taxation position described in this presentation is a general statement and shall only be used as a guide. It does not constitute accounting, legal, and tax advice and is based on AHIC s understanding of current laws and interpretation. This document is intended for general information purposes only and should not be construed as advice or opinions on any specific facts or circumstances. The comments in this summary are based upon AHIC s preliminary analysis of publicly available information. The content of this document is made available on an as is basis, without warranty of any kind. AHIC disclaims any legal liability to any person or organization for loss or damage caused by or resulting from any reliance placed on that content. AHIC. reserves all rights to the content of this document. No part of this document may be reproduced, stored, or transmitted by any means without the express written consent of AHIC. Aon Hewitt Investment Consulting, Inc. is a federally registered investment advisor with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. AHIC is also registered with the Commodity Futures Trade Commission as a commodity pool operator and a commodity trading advisor, and is a member of the National Futures Association. The AHIC ADV Form Part 2A disclosure statement is available upon written request to: Aon Hewitt Investment Consulting, Inc. 200 E. Randolph Street Suite 1500 Chicago, IL ATTN: AHIC Compliance Officer Aon plc All rights reserved 18
CIO Newsletter Q Monetary Tightening, Fiscal Easing
CIO Newsletter Q2 2018 Monetary Tightening, Fiscal Easing Q2 2018 Current Environment The second quarter of 2018 saw the continuation of several trends described in this newsletter in prior quarters. Fundamentals
More informationThe Rise of Factor Investing
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment A paper from Aon s UK Investment Committee The Rise of Factor Investing How clients should invest Table of contents Key conclusions.... 3 Factor investing a reminder...
More informationFactor Performance in Emerging Markets
Investment Research Factor Performance in Emerging Markets Taras Ivanenko, CFA, Director, Portfolio Manager/Analyst Alex Lai, CFA, Senior Vice President, Portfolio Manager/Analyst Factors can be defined
More informationINTERVIEW Rethink: Global Pension Risk Governance. A discussion with Aon colleagues Matt Clink, Jeff Clymer and Ian Hinton
INTERVIEW Rethink: Global Pension Risk Governance A discussion with Aon colleagues Matt Clink, Jeff Clymer and Ian Hinton How is pension risk management different for multinational companies than for those
More informationThe Rise of Factor Investing
Aon Retirement and Investment The Rise of Factor Investing Investing for DC savers Table of contents Key conclusions.... 3 Factor investing what is it?... 4 Where does factor investing fit in equity portfolios?....
More informationFactor Investing. Fundamentals for Investors. Not FDIC Insured May Lose Value No Bank Guarantee
Factor Investing Fundamentals for Investors Not FDIC Insured May Lose Value No Bank Guarantee As an investor, you have likely heard a lot about factors in recent years. But factor investing is not new.
More informationPERFORMANCE STUDY 2013
US EQUITY FUNDS PERFORMANCE STUDY 2013 US EQUITY FUNDS PERFORMANCE STUDY 2013 Introduction This article examines the performance characteristics of over 600 US equity funds during 2013. It is based on
More informationQEP Global Equity Team, Schroder Investment Management Australia Ltd
Schroders Smart Beta QEP Global Equity Team, Schroder Investment Management Australia Ltd Executive summary Smart beta may be the latest trend in the investment community but the concept is far from revolutionary.
More informationMSCI LOW SIZE INDEXES
MSCI LOW SIZE INDEXES msci.com Size-based investing has been an integral part of the investment process for decades. More recently, transparent and rules-based factor indexes have become widely used tools
More informationAdvisor Briefing Why Alternatives?
Advisor Briefing Why Alternatives? Key Ideas Alternative strategies generally seek to provide positive returns with low correlation to traditional assets, such as stocks and bonds By incorporating alternative
More information2018 Stock Market Outlook: Double-Digit Returns?
2018 Stock Market Outlook: Double-Digit Returns? January 4, 2018 by John Lynch of LPL Financial KEY TAKEAWAYS We forecast 8 10% returns for the S&P 500 in 2018. The S&P 500 is well positioned to generate
More informationUPDATE ON GROWTH AND VALUE STOCKS
LPL RESEARCH WEEKLY MARKET COMMENTARY September 18 2017 UPDATE ON GROWTH AND VALUE STOCKS Burt White Chief Investment Officer, LPL Financial Jeffrey Buchbinder, CFA Market Strategist, LPL Financial KEY
More informationTAKE CONTROL OF YOUR INVESTMENT DESTINY Increasing control over your investments.
TAKE CONTROL OF YOUR INVESTMENT DESTINY Increasing control over your investments. Challenge for Investors Case for Factor-based Investing What Next? The Real World Economic and Market Outlooks are Constrained
More informationCIO Newsletter Overlapping Cycles
CIO Newsletter Overlapping Cycles Q3 2018 Current Environment The CIO Newsletter warned a year ago that late cycle is a challenge for investors: We fear the next downturn, but we know there can be a steep
More informationFactor Investing: Smart Beta Pursuing Alpha TM
In the spectrum of investing from passive (index based) to active management there are no shortage of considerations. Passive tends to be cheaper and should deliver returns very close to the index it tracks,
More informationReturns on Small Cap Growth Stocks, or the Lack Thereof: What Risk Factor Exposures Can Tell Us
RESEARCH Returns on Small Cap Growth Stocks, or the Lack Thereof: What Risk Factor Exposures Can Tell Us The small cap growth space has been noted for its underperformance relative to other investment
More informationETF s Top 5 portfolio strategy considerations
ETF s Top 5 portfolio strategy considerations ETFs have grown substantially in size, range, complexity and popularity in recent years. This presentation and paper provide the key issues and portfolio strategy
More informationTAKE CONTROL OF YOUR INVESTMENT DESTINY Increasing control over your investments.
TAKE CONTROL OF YOUR INVESTMENT DESTINY Increasing control over your investments. To appreciate the power of Factors, consider this: Humankind is formed from just 23 Chromosome pairs CMINST-13427 2 1 Yet,
More informationSmart Beta and the Evolution of Factor-Based Investing
Smart Beta and the Evolution of Factor-Based Investing September 2016 Donald J. Hohman Managing Director, Product Management Hitesh C. Patel, Ph.D Managing Director Structured Equity Douglas J. Roman,
More informationPutting DC Members Front and Centre
Aon Retirement and Investment Putting DC Members Front and Centre Refocusing DC Investment Table of contents Intoduction.... 3 Discover the member focus.... 4 Develop your equity investments to help achieve
More informationSmart Beta and the Evolution of Factor-Based Investing
Smart Beta and the Evolution of Factor-Based Investing September 2017 Donald J. Hohman Managing Director, Product Management Hitesh C. Patel, Ph.D Managing Director Structured Equity Douglas J. Roman,
More informationQuarterly Investment Outlook January 2016
Quarterly Investment Outlook January 2016 January 29, 2016 Summary The struggle for return in asset markets in the past year is payback for the earlier multi-year period of performance far above normal.
More informationLazard Insights. Interpreting Active Share. Summary. Erianna Khusainova, CFA, Senior Vice President, Portfolio Analyst
Lazard Insights Interpreting Share Erianna Khusainova, CFA, Senior Vice President, Portfolio Analyst Summary While the value of active management has been called into question, the aggregate performance
More informationINSIGHTS. The Factor Landscape. August rocaton.com. 2017, Rocaton Investment Advisors, LLC
INSIGHTS The Factor Landscape August 2017 203.621.1700 2017, Rocaton Investment Advisors, LLC EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Institutional investors have shown an increased interest in factor investing. Much of the
More informationRisk Parity Looking at Risk Through a Different Lens
Risk Parity Looking at Risk Through a Different Lens December 2015 Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources. Key Points Assets under management for risk parity strategies continue to increase steadily Investors
More informationETF Research: Understanding Smart Beta KNOW Characteristics: Finding the Right Factors Research compiled by Michael Venuto, CIO
ETF Research: Understanding Smart Beta KNOW Characteristics: Finding the Right Factors Research compiled by Michael Venuto, CIO In this paper we will explore the evolution of smart beta investing through
More informationLazard Insights. Distilling the Risks of Smart Beta. Summary. What Is Smart Beta? Paul Moghtader, CFA, Managing Director, Portfolio Manager/Analyst
Lazard Insights Distilling the Risks of Smart Beta Paul Moghtader, CFA, Managing Director, Portfolio Manager/Analyst Summary Smart beta strategies have become increasingly popular over the past several
More informationDynamic Asset Allocation for Practitioners Part 1: Universe Selection
Dynamic Asset Allocation for Practitioners Part 1: Universe Selection July 26, 2017 by Adam Butler of ReSolve Asset Management In 2012 we published a whitepaper entitled Adaptive Asset Allocation: A Primer
More informationSeeking higher returns or lower risk through ETFs
Seeking higher returns or lower risk through ETFs BROUGHT TO YOU BY: Contents Seeking higher returns or lower risk through ETFs Factors and the rise of smart beta Reducing risk through smart beta strategies
More informationManaging Health Care Reserves: Aligning Operating Assets with Broader Organizational Goals
Managing Health Care Reserves: Aligning Operating Assets with Broader Organizational Goals Enterprise Risk Management for Health Care Organizations June 2017 Investment advice and consulting services provided
More informationTed Stover, Managing Director, Research and Analytics December FactOR Fiction?
Ted Stover, Managing Director, Research and Analytics December 2014 FactOR Fiction? Important Legal Information FTSE is not an investment firm and this presentation is not advice about any investment activity.
More informationThe Power of Mid-Caps: Investing in a Sweet Spot of the Market
Mid-Cap White Paper The Power of Mid-Caps: Investing in a Sweet Spot of the Market We believe U.S. mid-cap companies offer untapped potential for investors. In this paper, we discuss the merits of allocating
More informationFOCUS: SIZE. Factor Investing. msci.com
FOCUS: SIZE Factor Investing msci.com FACTOR INVESTING FACTOR FOCUS: SIZE IN THE REALM OF INVESTING, A FACTOR IS ANY CHARACTERISTIC THAT HELPS EXPLAIN THE LONG-TERM RISK AND RETURN PERFORMANCE OF AN ASSET.
More informationGet active with Vanguard factor ETFs
Get active with Vanguard factor ETFs Factor investing has gained attention in recent years, in part because of the rise of alternatively weighted indexes and smart-beta products. Yet factor investing has
More informationQEP Investment Team. Schroders. There s nothing smart about Smart Beta
Schroders QEP Investment Team January 2015 There s nothing smart about Smart Beta Smart Beta presents a beguiling prospect to investors: a set-and-forget investment approach that can regularly outperform
More informationFund Management Diary
Fund Management Diary Meeting held on 12 th March 2019 Earnings to weigh on emerging market equities A slowdown in both the United States and Chinese economies will weigh heavily on export growth in the
More informationA Performance Analysis of Risk Parity
Investment Research A Performance Analysis of Do Asset Allocations Outperform and What Are the Return Sources of Portfolios? Stephen Marra, CFA, Director, Portfolio Manager/Analyst¹ A risk parity model
More informationCan Active Management Make a Comeback? September 2015
Can Active Management Make a Comeback? September 2015 Executive Summary Recent underperformance by active U.S. managers can be easily explained and, in our view, is only temporary FACTORS MAKING FOR A
More informationBROAD COMMODITY INDEX
BROAD COMMODITY INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS JUNE 2017 80.00% CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% -20.00% -40.00% -60.00% -80.00% ABCERI S&P GSCI ER BCOMM ER
More informationIdentifying a defensive strategy
In our previous paper Defensive equity: A defensive strategy to Canadian equity investing, we discussed the merits of employing a defensive mandate within the Canadian equity portfolio for some institutional
More informationIndex Investing and the Factor Evolution
Topic Paper May 2017 Index Investing and the Factor Evolution Every financial website displays key barometers to track global stock performance around the world at a glance in the form of stock indexes.
More informationState Street Global Equity Fund Why Smart Equity Investors Continue to Look for Value
Market Commentary July 2018 State Street Global Equity Fund Why Smart Equity Investors Continue to Look for Value Ample evidence demonstrates the long-term efficacy of value investing. As with any investment,
More informationSPECIAL REPORT. TD Economics CANADIAN CORPORATE BALANCE SHEETS
SPECIAL REPORT TD Economics October 3, 212 CANADIAN CORPORATE BALANCE SHEETS solid as a rock Highlights If we compare the current standing of corporate balance sheets in the first half of 212 to what they
More informationDynamic Smart Beta Investing Relative Risk Control and Tactical Bets, Making the Most of Smart Betas
Dynamic Smart Beta Investing Relative Risk Control and Tactical Bets, Making the Most of Smart Betas Koris International June 2014 Emilien Audeguil Research & Development ORIAS n 13000579 (www.orias.fr).
More informationAsset Allocation Model March Update
The month of February was marked by a sell-off in global equity markets and a sudden increase in market volatility with the CBOE Volatility Index reaching its highest level since August 2015. The rout
More informationMANAGED FUTURES INDEX
MANAGED FUTURES INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS JULY 2017 CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) 120.00% 100.00% 80.00% 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% AMFERI BARCLAY BTOP50 CTA INDEX S&P 500 S&P
More informationDiversified Growth Funds (DGF)
Diversified Growth Funds (DGF) Stick or twist April 2017 kpmg.com/uk Diversified Growth Funds (DGF) 2 Executive summary Over the past 10 years Diversified Growth Fund (DGF) investing has grown in popularity,
More informationAdverse Active Alpha SM Manager Ranking Model
CONSULTING GROUP INVESTMENT ADVISOR RESEARCH DECEMBER 3, 2013 Adverse Active Alpha SM Manager Ranking Model MATTHEW RIZZO Vice President Matthew.Rizzo@ms.com +1 302 888-4105 Introduction Investment professionals
More informationLOW VOLATILITY: THE CASE FOR A STRATEGIC ALLOCATION IN A RISING RATE ENVIRONMENT
MFS White Capability Paper Series Focus Month February 212 217 Authors James C. Fallon Portfolio Manager Quantitative Solutions Christopher C. Callahan Regional Head North American Institutional R. Dino
More informationSeven-year asset class forecast returns
For professional investors and advisers only. Seven-year asset class forecast returns 2017 Update Seven-year asset class forecast returns 2017 update Introduction Our seven-year returns forecast largely
More informationHow Much Should We Invest in Emerging Markets?
How Much Should We Invest in Emerging Markets? May 28, 2015 by Dr. Burton Malkiel of WaveFront Capital Management Investors today are significantly underexposed to emerging markets; fortunately, the opportunity
More informationIndex Investing and the Factor Evolution
Topic Paper May 2017 Index Investing and the Factor Evolution Every financial website displays key barometers to track global stock performance around the world at a glance in the form of stock indexes.
More informationThe Case for Growth. Investment Research
Investment Research The Case for Growth Lazard Quantitative Equity Team Companies that generate meaningful earnings growth through their product mix and focus, business strategies, market opportunity,
More informationIn the Middle Lies Opportunity: The Case for Mid Caps
In the Middle Lies Opportunity: The Case for Mid Caps Despite their attractive risk and return characteristics, U.S. mid cap stocks are frequently overlooked by equity investors; that may be hurting their
More informationFrom Construction to Results: Fundamental Index Investing in the Emerging Markets
From Construction to Results: Fundamental Index Investing in the Emerging Markets BRENT LEADBETTER, CFA About the Author BRENT LEADBETTER, CFA Vice President Client Strategies Brent Leadbetter is a relationship
More informationOutlook & Perspective
Outlook & Perspective All data and information as of June 30, 2016 Approved for current clients. May be presented to prospective clients in a one-on-one setting only. Morningstar Investment Services LLC
More informationEquities: Enhancing the Core/Satellite Framework
Equities: Enhancing the Core/Satellite Framework March 13, 2015 by Sabrina Callin, Andrew Pyne of PIMCO In a lower-returning environment, investors may need to look beyond traditional active or passive
More informationSpecialist International Share Fund
Specialist International Share Fund Manager Profile January 2016 Adviser use only Specialist International Share Fund process process for this Fund is structured in the following steps: Step 1 Objectives:
More informationBROAD COMMODITY INDEX
BROAD COMMODITY INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS JULY 2018 100.00% 80.00% 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% -20.00% -40.00% -60.00% CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) -80.00% ABCERI S&P GSCI ER BCOMM
More informationSTRATEGY INSIGHT JAPAN LONG/SHORT
STRATEGY INSIGHT JAPAN LONG/SHORT FEBRUARY 2018 FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY In today s markets, investors are increasingly seeking greater stability in returns and managed volatility as well as a focus
More informationPerspectives FEB Value Underperformance in the Current Market Cycle
Perspectives FEB 2018 Underperformance in the Current Market Cycle With the value premium seemingly in decline, value investors have had a lot to complain about over the past ten years. Growth stocks continue
More informationEconomic Cycle model, Recession Probability model & Leading Indicators A Holistic Perspective
Economic Cycle model, Recession Probability model & Leading Indicators A Holistic Perspective White Paper RecessionProtect.com Whilst history doesn't repeat itself, it often rhymes, so the saying goes.
More informationEnhancing equity portfolio diversification with fundamentally weighted strategies.
Enhancing equity portfolio diversification with fundamentally weighted strategies. This is the second update to a paper originally published in October, 2014. In this second revision, we have included
More informationWhat We Can Learn by Going Back to School
What We Can Learn by Going Back to School August 13, 2015 by Burt White of LPL Financial KEY TAKEAWAYS Expectations for the back to school shopping season are low, and this season may only be flat versus
More informationKBC INVESTMENT STRATEGY PRESENTATION. Defensive August 2017
KBC INVESTMENT STRATEGY PRESENTATION August 2017 Investment climate Key rate trends and outlook 2,0 2,0 1,5 VS EMU 1,5 0,5 0,5 0,0 0,0-0,5-0,5 - - 07-2012 07-2013 07-2014 07-2015 07-2016 07-2017 07-2018
More informationThe Case for TD Low Volatility Equities
The Case for TD Low Volatility Equities By: Jean Masson, Ph.D., Managing Director April 05 Most investors like generating returns but dislike taking risks, which leads to a natural assumption that competition
More informationThe Benefits of a Diversified Precious-Metals Exposure
The Benefits of a Diversified Precious-Metals Exposure July 26, 2016 by Robert Huebscher ETF Securities provides accessible investment solutions, enabling investors to intelligently diversify their portfolios
More informationInvestment Insight. Are Risk Parity Managers Risk Parity (Continued) Summary Results of the Style Analysis
Investment Insight Are Risk Parity Managers Risk Parity (Continued) Edward Qian, PhD, CFA PanAgora Asset Management October 2013 In the November 2012 Investment Insight 1, I presented a style analysis
More informationHas Diversification Stopped Working?
Questions from the Field: During the course of teaching seminars, writing articles and newsletters, and meeting with clients we hear lots of questions. We will try to address some of the more timely and
More informationResearch Factor Indexes and Factor Exposure Matching: Like-for-Like Comparisons
Research Factor Indexes and Factor Exposure Matching: Like-for-Like Comparisons October 218 ftserussell.com Contents 1 Introduction... 3 2 The Mathematics of Exposure Matching... 4 3 Selection and Equal
More informationP-Solve Update By Marc Fandetti & Ryan McGlothlin
Target Date Funds: Three Things to Consider P-Solve Update By Marc Fandetti & Ryan McGlothlin February 2018 Target Date Funds (TDF) have become increasingly important to the retirement security of 401(k)
More informationINVESTMENT UPDATE. July 2017 PERFORMANCE UPDATE
INVESTMENT UPDATE July 2017 PERFORMANCE UPDATE ASSET CLASS REVIEW HAPPY BIRTHDAY WOODFORD WHAT RISK ARE YOU TAKING WITH YOUR MONEY? FINAL COMMENT PERFORMANCE UPDATE It is unusual to find most of the major
More informationBROAD COMMODITY INDEX
BROAD COMMODITY INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS JANUARY 2018 100.00% 80.00% 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% -20.00% -40.00% -60.00% CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) -80.00% ABCERI S&P GSCI ER
More informationBROAD COMMODITY INDEX
BROAD COMMODITY INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS APRIL 2017 80.00% CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% -20.00% -40.00% -60.00% -80.00% ABCERI S&P GSCI ER BCOMM ER
More informationCHAPTER 17 INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT. by Alistair Byrne, PhD, CFA
CHAPTER 17 INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT by Alistair Byrne, PhD, CFA LEARNING OUTCOMES After completing this chapter, you should be able to do the following: a Describe systematic risk and specific risk; b Describe
More informationNasdaq Chaikin Power US Small Cap Index
Nasdaq Chaikin Power US Small Cap Index A Multi-Factor Approach to Small Cap Introduction Multi-factor investing has become very popular in recent years. The term smart beta has been coined to categorize
More informationFinancial Market Outlook & Strategy: Stocks Bottoming On Track to Recovery. Near-term Risks
For Market Commentary Interviews Contact: Lisa Villareal, 973-367-2503/lisa.villareal@prudential.com Financial Market Outlook & Strategy: Stocks Bottoming On Track to Recovery. Near-term Risks John Praveen
More informationBEYOND SMART BETA: WHAT IS GLOBAL MULTI-FACTOR INVESTING AND HOW DOES IT WORK?
INVESTING INSIGHTS BEYOND SMART BETA: WHAT IS GLOBAL MULTI-FACTOR INVESTING AND HOW DOES IT WORK? Multi-Factor investing works by identifying characteristics, or factors, of stocks or other securities
More informationSTRATEGY OVERVIEW EMERGING MARKETS LOW VOLATILITY ACTIVE EQUITY STRATEGY
STRATEGY OVERVIEW EMERGING MARKETS LOW VOLATILITY ACTIVE EQUITY STRATEGY A COMPELLING OPPORTUNITY For many years, the favourable demographics and high economic growth in emerging markets (EM) have caught
More informationINVESTMENT UPDATE. 8th September 2014
INVESTMENT UPDATE 8th September 2014 PERFORMANCE UPDATE ASSET CLASS REVIEW MOMENTUM WHAT RISK ARE YOU TAKING WITH YOUR MONEY? FINAL COMMENT PERFORMANCE UPDATE Stock markets were all up over the month,
More informationMarket Insights. The Benefits of Integrating Fundamental and Quantitative Research to Deliver Outcome-Oriented Equity Solutions.
Market Insights The Benefits of Integrating Fundamental and Quantitative Research to Deliver Outcome-Oriented Equity Solutions Vincent Costa, CFA Head of Global Equities Peg DiOrio, CFA Head of Global
More informationZero Beta (Managed Account Mutual Funds/ETFs)
2016 Strategy Review Zero Beta (Managed Account Mutual Funds/ETFs) December 31, 2016 The following report provides in-depth analysis into the successes and challenges of the NorthCoast Zero Beta investment
More informationThe Emerging Market Conundrum
T H E M A G A Z I N E F O R E T F INVESTORS ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// MAY 2016 The Emerging Market Conundrum P U B L I S H E D BY SMART-BETA CORNER By Heather Bell
More informationFOCUS: YIELD. Factor Investing. msci.com
FOCUS: YIELD Factor Investing msci.com FACTOR FOCUS: YIELD FACTOR FOCUS: YIELD IN THE REALM OF INVESTING, A FACTOR IS ANY CHARACTERISTIC THAT HELPS EXPLAIN THE LONG-TERM RISK AND RETURN PERFORMANCE OF
More informationFactor investing Focus:
Focus: adding value Factoring in the best approach a rose by any other name In association with: Quoniam Asset Management s Thomas Kieselstein explains to European Pensions how best to implement factor
More informationSmart Beta: Unlocking New Investment Opportunities
Smart Beta: Unlocking New Investment Opportunities Ana Paula Harris State Street Global Advisors FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONAL USE ONLY. Not for use with the public. All the information contained in this
More informationActive vs. Passive Money Management
Active vs. Passive Money Management Exploring the costs and benefits of two alternative investment approaches By Baird s Advisory Services Research Synopsis Proponents of active and passive investment
More informationEARNINGS MOMENTUM STRATEGIES. Michael Tan, Ph.D., CFA
EARNINGS MOMENTUM STRATEGIES Michael Tan, Ph.D., CFA DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY AND COPYRIGHT NOTICE The material in this document is copyrighted by Michael Tan and Apothem Capital Management, LLC for which
More informationTHE VALUE FACTOR ISN'T DEAD, JUST MISAPPLIED
REPRINTED FROM POINT OF VIEW MAY 2018 THE VALUE FACTOR ISN'T DEAD, JUST MISAPPLIED CONTRARY TO POPULAR PERCEPTION, THE VALUE FACTOR HAS OUTPERFORMED OVER THE LAST DECADE. Investors are losing patience
More informationGrowth and Value Investing: A Complementary Approach
Growth and Value Investing: A Complementary Approach March 14, 2018 by Stephen Dover, Norman Boersma of Franklin Templeton Investments Growth and value investing are often seen as competing styles, with
More informationThe hedge fund sector has grown at a rapid pace over the last several years. There are a record number of hedge funds,
The hedge fund sector has grown at a rapid pace over the last several years. There are a record number of hedge funds, and hedge fund of funds in the marketplace. While investors have considerably more
More informationFactors have delivered similar risk-adjusted performance as asset classes, but may perform worse going forward
Are Factors Better and More Diversifying Than Asset Classes? (For the most part, we don t think so) February 2018 By: Maneesh Shanbhag, CFA Executive Summary - Factor investing promises outperformance
More informationRaising Your Corpus From the Dead
Raising Your Corpus From the Dead Effective Use of Spending Policy and Investment Strategy for Notfor-Profits in Today s Challenging Markets February 2016 Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources. Key Points
More informationWhy Decades-Old Quantitative Strategies Still Work Today
Why Decades-Old Quantitative Strategies Still Work Today June 2, 2015 by John Reese Advisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor
More informationETF Research January 2018 Buy and Adjust : Capturing a Structural Factor with PPLC
ETF Research Buy and Adjust : Capturing a Structural Factor with PPLC Research compiled by Michael Venuto, CIO The first US-listed ETF targeting the S&P 500 Index began trading in 1993. Today the US ETF
More informationBROAD COMMODITY INDEX
BROAD COMMODITY INDEX COMMENTARY + STRATEGY FACTS AUGUST 2018 120.00% 100.00% 80.00% 60.00% 40.00% 20.00% 0.00% -20.00% -40.00% -60.00% CUMULATIVE PERFORMANCE ( SINCE JANUARY 2007* ) -80.00% ABCERI S&P
More informationFidelity s Perspectives on Sector Investing
Fidelity s Perspectives on Sector Investing Hello, I m Denise Chisholm, a sector strategist here at Fidelity Investments. Welcome to our new video series, Fidelity s Perspectives on Sector Investing. Our
More informationInvestment. Insights. Emerging Markets. Invesco Global Equity. A 2012 outlook
Investment Insights Invesco Global Equity Emerging Markets A 2012 outlook Ingrid Baker Portfolio Manager Invesco Global Equity Many investors have watched from the sidelines as emerging market equities
More informationActive vs. Passive Money Management
Active vs. Passive Money Management Exploring the costs and benefits of two alternative investment approaches By Baird s Advisory Services Research Synopsis Proponents of active and passive investment
More informationSEATTLE S BEST COFFEE? Using ZRS and the Zacks Valuation Model to identify factors impacting equity valuations in 3 minutes or less
Using ZRS and the Zacks Valuation Model to identify factors impacting equity valuations in 3 minutes or less SEATTLE S BEST COFFEE? Starbucks: Can this International coffeehouse add value to your portfolio?
More information