Errors in Estimating Accruals: Implications for Empirical Research. Daniel W. Collins a *, Paul Hribar b
|
|
- Alaina Page
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Errors in Estimating Accruals: Implications for Empirical Research Daniel W. Collins a *, Paul Hribar b a Henry B. Tippie Research Chair in Accounting Tippie College of Business, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA b Johnson Graduate School of Management, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY Current Version: September 10, 2000 *Corresponding Author. Phone (319) ; Fax: (319) ; danielcollins@uiowa.edu. We gratefully acknowledge the helpful comments and suggestions made by Kevin Den Adel, Mary Barth, Bill Beaver, Mike Cipriano, S.P. Kothari, Nicole Jenkins, Maureen McNichols, Mort Pincus, Scott Vandervelde, Charles Wasley, Hong Xie and workshop participants at the University of Iowa, Tulane University, and the Stanford Summer Research Camp.
2 Abstract This paper examines the impact of measuring accruals as the change in successive balance sheet accounts, as opposed to measuring accruals directly from the statement of cash flows. Our primary finding is that studies using a balance sheet approach to test for earnings management are potentially contaminated by measurement error in accruals estimates. In particular, if the partitioning variable used to indicate the presence of earnings management is correlated with the occurrence of mergers and acquisitions or discontinued operations, tests are biased and researchers are likely to erroneously conclude that earnings management exists when there is none. Additional results show that the errors in balance sheet accruals estimation can confound returns regressions where discretionary and non-discretionary accruals are used as explanatory variables. Moreover, we demonstrate that tests of market mispricing of accruals will be understated due to erroneous classification of extreme accruals firms. 1
3 Errors in Estimating Accruals: Implications for Empirical Research I. Introduction The measurement of accruals plays a central role in a wide body of literature in accounting. This literature includes studies on the relative informativeness or value relevance of cash flows versus accruals [Rayburn (1986), Wilson (1987), Dechow (1994)], tests of earnings management and income smoothing [e.g. Healy (1985), DeAngelo (1986, 1988), Jones (1991), Dechow, Sloan and Sweeney (1995), Rees, Gill and Gore (1996), DeFond and Subramanyam (1998), Teoh, Welch, Wong (1998), Rangan (1998)], the pricing of discretionary versus nondiscretionary accruals [Subramanyan (1996), Guay, Kothari and Watts (1996), Xie (1999)], and the market's mispricing of accruals [Sloan (1996), Xie (1999), Collins and Hribar (2000)]. Despite the availability of accurate accruals data in the statement of cash flows since 1988, the majority of these studies use an indirect balance sheet approach to calculate accruals. The balance sheet approach relies on the presumed articulation between changes in working capital balance sheet accounts and accrual components of revenues and expenses on the income statement. This presumed articulation breaks down when nonoperating events such as reclassifications, acquisitions, divestitures, accounting changes and foreign currency translations occur [Drtina and Largay (1985), Huefner, Ketz and Largay (1989), Bahnson, Miller and Budge (1996) and Revsine, Collins and Johnson (1999)]. Using actual accruals taken from cash flow statements subsequent to SFAS No. 95, Bahnson et al. (1996) estimate that approximately 75% of Compustat firms present nonarticulated changes in current accounts. The purposes of this paper are to assess the error introduced by the indirect balance sheet approach to accruals estimation and demonstrate the implications for empirical studies that have 2
4 relied on this approach. The severity of the mismeasurement of accruals and/or operating cash flows is evaluated for samples comprised of a broad cross section of NYSE and AMEX firms and for samples of firms involved in mergers and acquisitions, divestitures and foreign operations through subsidiaries. We demonstrate the effect of using balance sheet accruals estimates relative to accruals taken directly from the statement of cash flows in three popular applied settings: (1) estimating the discretionary and nondiscretionary component of accruals and tests of earnings management; (2) the relation between security returns and accruals, discretionary accruals, nondiscretionary accruals, and cash flow from operations; and (3) testing for market mispricing of accruals. Our major finding is that the error induced by using a balance sheet estimation approach contaminates computations of so-called discretionary or abnormal accruals, and can lead to erroneously concluding that earnings management exists when no such opportunistic activity is present. We demonstrate that balance sheet accruals estimates are predictably biased in studies where the partitioning event is correlated with either mergers and acquisitions or discontinued operations. To illustrate how this bias can lead to unwarranted inferences, we replicate sections of two prior studies that test for earnings management using a balance sheet approach. Additionally, we document the probability of making a type I error as the percent of the sample that is contaminated by these non-articulation events increases. Other findings show that when discretionary and non-discretionary balance sheet accruals estimates are used as regressors in a second stage regression of returns on earnings components, the resulting coefficient bias can yield incorrect statistical inferences about the equality of parameter estimates. Finally, we demonstrate that tests of market mispricing of accruals calculated under the balance sheet 3
5 approach tend to understate the true extent of the mispricing by roughly 35% due to misclassification of extreme accruals firms. The remainder of the paper proceeds as follows. Section two explains the balance sheet approach to estimating accruals and how the presumed articulation between changes in balance sheet working capital accounts and income statement accruals breaks down when nonoperating events like mergers and acquisitions, divestitures and foreign currency translations are present. This section also documents the frequency and magnitude of accrual estimation errors by comparing total accruals taken directly from the cash flow statement to estimates derived using the indirect balance sheet method. In section three we use the modified Jones model to evaluate the effect of non-articulation on estimates of discretionary and nondiscretionary accruals and tests of earnings management. We compare results for two samples of firms: (a) a broad crosssection of NYSE/AMEX firms; and (b) samples of firms affected by one or more of the nonoperating events that contribute to non-articulation. We also investigate the potential bias in selected studies on earnings management that are confounded by non-articulation events. Section four investigates the relation between returns, discretionary and non-discretionary accruals, and operating cash flows determined using the balance sheet approach versus the cash flow statement approach. Section five demonstrates the effect of measurement error on tests of market mispricing of accruals using the approach outlined in Sloan (1996). Section six summarizes our findings and discusses the implications for prior and future research. 4
6 II. The Non-articulation Problem: Its Frequency, Magnitude and Contributing Factors 2.1 An example of the non-articulation problem Much of the literature to date that focuses on accruals uses a balance sheet approach to determine the accruals component of earnings. Specifically, accruals (ACC bs ) are typically calculated as follows (firm and time subscripts omitted for convenience): ACC bs = ( CA - CL - Cash + STDEBT DEPTN) (1) where CA = the change in current assets during period t (Compustat #4); CL = the change in current liabilities during period t (Compustat #5); Cash = the change in cash and cash equivalents during period t (Compustat #1); STDEBT = the current maturities of long-term debt and other short-term debt included in current liabilities during period t (Compustat #34); and DEPTN = depreciation and amortization expense during period t (Compustat #14). All variables are deflated by lagged total assets (TA t-1 ) to control for scale differences. The H.J. Heinz 1997 annual report demonstrates the magnitude of the accrual estimation problem caused by non-articulation between the balance sheet and the cash flow statement and the kinds of events that contribute to this problem. 1 The first column of numbers in Exhibit 1 shows the operating section of Heinz s cash flow statement for the year ended, April 30, 1997 and the implied directional changes in the working capital accounts after excluding the effects of acquisitions and divestitures. Note that the net change in working capital and its corresponding effect on earnings is + $253.3 million (i.e., income increasing accruals). The directional changes in the individual working capital accounts taken from Heinz s comparative balance sheets for are presented as the second column of numbers. 2 1 This illustration is adapted from Revsine, Collins and Johnson (1999, Chapter 16). 2 These amounts exclude (in $ millions) a reduction of short-term debt of $404.7, an increase in the current portion of long-term debt of $486.0 and an increase in accrued restructuring costs of $210.8 which are captured elsewhere in Heinz s cash flow statement. Also omitted is $324,418 of depreciation and amortization expense. 5
7 These numbers are presented analogous to the statement of cash flows in that they represent the adjustment to net income to arrive at cash from operations. Notice that the net change in these working capital accounts is only + $13.1 million. Thus, the indirect approach to calculating accruals based on using comparative balance sheets understates Heinz s working capital accruals by approximately $240.2 million, or 79.6% of Heinz s 1997 reported net income of $301.9 million. The main reason for the understatement of Heinz s accruals (and associated overstatement of operating cash flows) stems form two major divestitures that Heinz made in fiscal 1997 related to its Project Millenia reorganization and restructuring program. As shown on the cash flow statement and detailed in footnotes to their annual report, Heinz divested of its New Zealand ice cream business and its U.K. real estate business in Accordingly, a portion of the decrease in the working capital balance sheet accounts relates to these divestitures that would erroneously be shown as income decreasing accruals under the balance sheet approach to estimating accruals. In contrast to divestitures of on-going businesses that introduce a negative bias to estimated accruals, mergers and acquisitions introduce a positive bias to estimated accruals using the approach in eqn. (1). Heinz reported cash outflows (net of cash acquired) of $208.4 million in 1997 for acquisitions of several businesses accounted for under the purchase method. A portion of this Investing Activity cash outflow would most likely contribute to a positive increase in working capital accounts that did not have a corresponding positive effect on accrual earnings. Finally, Heinz has numerous foreign subsidiaries whose statements are translated using the current rate approach specified in SFAS No. 52. If the dollar falls (rises) in relation to the 6
8 functional currencies of these subsidiaries, this change would result in increases (decreases) in balance sheet accounts that would not have a corresponding effect on accruals [Huefner et al.(1989)]. Unlike divestitures and acquisitions where one can reliably sign the direction of the bias in accruals estimated via eqn. (1), the direction of the bias due to foreign currency adjustments is indeterminate and, hence, is more akin to error or noise. The bias in estimated accruals under the balance sheet approach would depend on whether the dollar strengthened or weakened relative to the local currency of the countries in which a company operates. While there are no doubt other reasons for non-articulation (e.g., accounting changes and reclassifications that affect current accounts), we believe that mergers and acquisitions, divestitures and foreign currency translation of foreign subsidiary account balances are likely to be the most important and most pervasive factors contributing to the non-articulation problem. Accordingly, the remainder of the paper focuses on understanding how these transactions affect the estimation of accruals and cash flows using the balance sheet approach reflected in eqn. (1) and (2) above, which has been the dominant approach used in the literature to date. 2.2 Estimating the severity of the non-articulation problem Our sample is comprised of all NYSE/AMEX firms on the Compustat Primary, Supplementary and Tertiary Annual Industrial File and Research File with requisite balance sheet and earnings data to compute accruals according to eqn. (1). 3 Accruals are determined for each year over the ten-year period from resulting in a total sample of 14,558 firmyears. 3 The primary tests are also replicated including all NASDAQ firms in the sample as well, with no qualitative change in results. The NYSE/AMEX sample is used for comparability with prior accruals research which focuses primarily on this subsample of firms. 7
9 To provide some evidence on the severity of the non-articulation problem, we first calculate accruals using the balance sheet approach (ACC bs ) as shown in eqn. (1). We next compute two alternative definitions of accruals directly from the cash flow statement. The first measure captures total accruals and is computed as follows (firm and time subscripts are suppressed for convenience): TACC cf = EBXI CFO cf (2) where TACC cf = the total accrual adjustments provided on the cash flow statement under the indirect method; EBXI = earnings before extraordinary items and discontinued operations (Compustat #123); and CFO cf = operating cash flows (from continuing operations) taken directly from the statement of cash flows (Compustat #308 - Compustat #124). 4 The second measure of accruals includes only the changes in the working capital accounts plus depreciation expense and, hence, is more directly comparable to the balance sheet definition of accruals commonly used in prior research. 5 This definition of accruals is computed as follows: ACC cf = - (CHGAR cf + CHGINV cf + CHGAP cf + CHGTAX cf + CHGOTH cf + DEP cf ) (3) where CHGAR cf is the decrease (increase) in accounts receivable (Compustat #302); CHGINV cf is the decrease (increase) in inventory (Compustat #303); CHGAP cf is the increase (decrease) in accounts payable (Compustat #304); CHGTAX cf is the increase (decrease) in taxes payable (Compustat #305); CHGOTH cf is the net change in other current assets (Compustat #307); and 4 The cash portion of discontinued operations and extraordinary items (Compustat #124) is subtracted from total cash from operations to provide a cash flow from continuing operations. This is consistent with our definition of net income. Alternatively, one could include bottom line net income (Compustat #172) instead of net income before extraordinary items, which is consistent with including cash from discontinued operations in the measure of operating cash flow. 5 An alternative approach is to include a funds from operations variable in the balance sheet definition of accruals to arrive at a measure of total accruals using the balance sheet. This metric, however, can only be computed prior to
10 DEP cf is depreciation expense (Compustat #125). All of these variables are taken from the operating section of the statement of cash flows and, hence, are not affected by non-operating changes in these accounts. Because this second measure approximates the balance sheet definition more closely, we calculate the difference in accruals estimated under the balance sheet approach given in eqn. (1) and the accrual amount from the statement of cash flows given in eqn. (3) for each firm and scale by alternative deflators as follows: DIFF = ACC bs - ACC cf / Deflator (4) where ACC bs the alternative deflators are the absolute value of EBXI, ACC bs, or total assets at the beginning of the year (TA t-1 ). 6 Table 1 presents descriptive statistics for the error or bias in balance sheet accruals induced by the three non-articulation events noted earlier. Panel A presents results for firmyears where the firm is involved in a merger or acquisition, Panel B presents results for firmyears where the firm is involved in divestitures (discontinued operations), Panel C presents results for firms with foreign operations, and Panel D presents results for firms without any of the three non-articulation events. To determine observations that are affected by one of the three non-articulation events, we use proxies that are available on Compustat. Mergers and acquisitions are determined by examining annual footnote code #1, which reflects whether a merger or acquisition impacts current sales. A firm is considered to have discontinued operations if the absolute value of discontinued operations (Compustat #66) exceeds $10, It should be emphasized that all predictions regarding error and bias in balance sheet estimation will carry over regardless of which measure of accruals is used, as it is the non-operating changes in working capital accounts from the balance sheet that lead to the non-articulation problem. 9
11 Similarly, a firm is considered to have foreign operations if the absolute value of the foreign currency adjustment account (Compustat #150) exceeds $10,000. Consistent with our priors, the mean, median and inter-quartile range of ACC bs values for the merger and acquisition sample are less negative than the ACC cf amounts (i.e., positively biased). For example, the median DIFF in estimated accruals under the balance sheet approach is 16.95% of EBXI, indicating a positive and significant bias in balance sheet accruals estimates. For one-quarter of the firms in this sample, the accruals error exceeds 64.3% of EBXI. Similarly, the results for the discontinued operations sample (Panel B) reveal the expected negative bias in estimated accruals under the balance sheet approach. The mean, median and inter-quartile range values for the scaled ACC bs values are consistently more negative than for the ACC cf amounts. For example, the median DIFF is % of EBXI, demonstrating a negative and significant bias in balance sheet accruals estimates in this subset of firms. For the lower quartile of the firms in this sample, the negative bias is substantial, measuring -96.3% of EBXI. The results for the foreign operations subsample in Panel C are less dramatic. The median difference is 0.12% of TA t-1 or 1.65% of EBXI. This is expected, however, as foreign currency translations can cause positive or negative differences in balance sheet accruals estimates depending on the fluctuations of the local (foreign) currency relative to the U.S. dollar. Hence, unlike the case of mergers and acquisitions or discontinued operations, foreign currency translations do not induce an ex-ante predictable bias in balance sheet accruals estimates. Thus, the resulting difference between accruals measured using the balance sheet and cash flow approaches is more akin to error or noise. Finally, Panel D reports the difference for firms that do not have any of these three events. Similar to the case of foreign currency translations, the 10
12 median difference is quite small, equaling 0.11% of total assets, or 1.85% of EBXI. Additionally, the interquartile range is smaller, indicating that there is less noise in these firms balance sheet accruals estimates than in the foreign operations subsample. The univariate results presented in Table 1 do not control for the fact that in any given year, firms might have more than one of the three events affecting the articulation between the balance sheet, income statement and the statement of cash flows. To account for this potential overlap, Table 2 provides multivariate estimates of the average bias in estimated accruals induced by each of the three events noted above. The first model regresses DIFF/TA t-1 on three indicator variables, D MERGER, D DISC-OP, and D FC, each of which equals one in firm-years in which mergers and acquisitions, discontinued operations, or foreign currency translations occur, respectively, and zero otherwise. The benefit to this approach is that the average bias can be examined after controlling for the other non-articulation events. Model 2 is similar to the first model, but also adds an indicator variable for significant mergers and acquisitions. 7 Results in Table 2 show first that there is a significantly positive intercept. Thus the balance sheet estimation method tends to induce a positive bias across all firms, before considering non-articulation events. This is likely due to the omission of non-current accruals other than deprecation and amortization when computing total accruals using the balance sheet approach. 8 Turning to the non-articulation events, mergers and acquisitions induce an upward bias in balance sheet accruals estimates of approximately 1.48% of total assets. In contrast, discontinued operations induce a downward bias of approximately -1.54% of total assets, and 7 A merger or acquisition is classified by Compustat as significant when the impact on current sales is greater than 50% of the prior year s sales. 8 Bahnson et al. (1996) use a more precise measure of accruals from the balance sheet that might resolve this overall positive bias. Instead of using Bahnson et al.'s approach, we opted to use the balance sheet estimation approach most commonly used in prior empirical accrual studies. 11
13 foreign currency translations have a smaller negative bias of approximately -0.49% of total assets. Moreover, Model 2 demonstrates that large mergers and acquisitions induce an incremental bias (relative to small mergers and acquisitions) of 0.91% of total assets, for a total bias of approximately 2.39% of total assets. Because of the small number of large merger firms relative to the total merger subsample (56 larger merger firms compared to 2991 merger firms in total), the coefficient on the small mergers decreases only slightly in the expanded model (from 1.48% to 1.44%). Finally, to provide some sense of the pervasiveness of the non-articulation problem caused by the three events noted above, Figure 1 plots the percentage of Compustat firms affected by each of these events over the ten-year period from 1988 to The percentage of Compustat firms involved in a merger or acquisition has increased steadily from a low of roughly 14% in 1991 to slightly over 27% in The percentage of firms with material foreign subsidiaries has remained fairly steady throughout the sample period ranging from 18% to 21% of Compustat firms. Firms reporting divestitures (discontinued operations) ranges from just over 15% in 1988 to around 9% in The percentage of Compustat firms having one or more of the three events that introduce error in ACC bs estimates is shown in the top line of Figure 1a. Clearly, a significant portion of Compustat firms are affected, with the proportion ranging from a low of 38.6% in 1991 to 46.5% in Figure 1b depicts a time series plot of the absolute value of the difference (deflated by total accruals) between accruals measured using the balance sheet and the cash flow statement approach. A cursory examination of the plot reveals that the average error resulting from a balance sheet approach appears to follow the same pattern as the relative frequency of nonarticulation events presented in Figure 1a. Specifically, both the frequency of non-articulation 12
14 events in Figure 1a and the degree of measurement error in balance sheet accruals estimates plotted in Figure 1b decrease from , and then follow more of a gradual upward trend until Collectively, the results reported in this section suggest that non-operating events or transactions (i.e., mergers and acquisitions, divestitures and foreign operations) can cause significant error and bias in accrual estimates using the balance sheet approach. Moreover, the number of firms affected by one or more of these activities represents a nontrivial proportion of the firms that comprise the Compustat files. Thus, a considerable body of literature to date that utilizes balance sheet-based accruals estimates suffers from a potentially large measurement error problem. The following sections evaluate how the errors embedded in ACC bs estimates affect inferences in studies where accruals are the major object of interest. III. Estimating Discretionary and Nondiscretionary Accruals and Detecting Earnings Management 3.1 Bias in discretionary accrual calculations McNichols and Wilson (1988) outline a general discretionary accruals framework that is the foundation for most earnings management studies in accounting. In the model, accruals are partitioned into a discretionary (DACC*) and non-discretionary (NDACC*) component, such that: ACC* = NDACC* + DACC* (5) Since DACC* is unobservable, it is typically estimated using one of several alternative empirical models. 9 The estimate of discretionary accruals (DACC) that emerges from the empirical model inevitably measures the true and unknowable discretionary accruals (DACC*) with error: 9 Examples of discretionary accruals models include the Healy model, the DeAngelo model, the Jones model, the modified Jones model, and the Kang and Sivaramakrishnan model. Because of their prevalence in accounting research, most of the analysis in this section focuses on the Jones and modified Jones models. 13
15 DACC = DACC* + η (6) where η is the measurement error associated with the estimate. Ultimately, the researcher uses this estimate of discretionary accruals to test for earnings management surrounding a particular event. Examples of these events are numerous, but include such diverse events as seasoned equity offerings, proxy contests, stock-for-stock mergers, management buyouts, asset writedowns, and management forecasts. Typically, the test is conducted by regressing discretionary accruals on a partitioning variable (PART), which is a dummy variable equaling one in the period(s) in which earnings management is hypothesized to occur. Thus, a theoretical model to test for earnings management can be represented as follows: DACC* = α + β PART + ε (7) Where α estimates average discretionary accruals across all firms, and α + β estimates the average discretionary accruals for the experimental group. The significance of β is used to draw inferences about the presence of earnings management (or lack thereof). However, because a discretionary accrual proxy, DACC, is used instead of DACC*, McNichols and Wilson (1988) demonstrate that equation (7) can be rewritten as follows: DACC = α + γ PART + ν, (8) where γ = β + ρ PART, η * σ η /σ PART = β + bias in γ Hence, as noted in McNichols and Wilson (1988), given measurement error in DACC, the coefficient used to test for the presence of earnings management will be biased. Moreover, this bias will be (1) increasing in the correlation between η and PART, (2) increasing in the variance of η, and (3) decreasing in the variance of PART. More importantly, with a significant bias in the discretionary accrual estimate, one could erroneously conclude there is earnings management 14
16 (i.e. observe non-zero values of γ) when, in fact, earnings may not be managed at all (i.e. β = 0). Alternatively, accruals estimates biased in the opposite direction of the hypothesized earnings management could yield insignificant results when, in fact, accruals were used to manage earnings. 3.2 Empirically estimating bias in tests of earnings management As shown in equation (8), empirically assessing the degree of bias in a test of earnings management requires an estimate of η, the measurement error in the estimate of discretionary accruals. As argued earlier, using a balance sheet approach to estimating accruals will induce error if the balance sheet working capital changes do not articulate with accruals from the income statement that are reflected in the statement of cash flows. The fact that in the post- SFAS 95 period we are able to measure both ACC bs and ACC cf allows us to estimate the resulting error in estimated discretionary accruals using the balance sheet approach. Because we only have ten years of post-sfas 95 data available, however, a cross-sectional version of the modified Jones model is used to estimate discretionary accruals. 10 Thus, the following models are estimated by year and industry: 11 ACC bs = α + β 1 ( Rev) + β 2 PPE + ε bs ACC cf = α + β 1 ( Rev) + β 2 PPE + ε cf (10a) (10b) Where Rev is the change in revenue, and PPE is the level of gross property, plant, and equipment. The parameters in equations (10a) and (10b) are estimated over sub-samples of firmyears without a specific non-articulation event (for example, all firm-years without a merger or 10 This estimation procedure is a cross-sectional adaptation of the modified-jones model introduced by Dechow, Sloan, Sweeney (1995). It is similar to the cross-sectional Jones model used in Teoh, Welch, Wong (1998). 11 The industry classifications are those used in Barth, Beaver, Hand, and Landsman (1999). 15
17 acquisition or divestiture). The proxies for non-discretionary accruals under the balance sheet and cash flow approach are then computed as follows: NDACC NDACC bs cf = α + β ( Re v AR) + β 1 = α + β ( Rev AR) + β PPE PPE (11a) (11b) Where Rev - AR represents the change in revenue less the change in accounts receivable, and PPE is the level of gross property, plant, and equipment. 12 Discretionary accruals are computed as total accruals less non-discretionary accruals under both the balance sheet (DACC bs ) and cash flow (DACC cf ) approaches. By comparing the estimates of discretionary accruals under the balance sheet and cash flow approaches, we can estimate the error in discretionary accruals that results from using a balance sheet approach. 13 Specifically, η = DACC bs - DACC cf (12) If the error in ACC bs (i.e. DIFF) is uncorrelated with the regressors, the majority of this error will be captured by the residual, DACC bs (Greene, 1991). Empirically, this turns out to be the case as there is a 0.94 correlation between η and DIFF. Thus, much of the error from a balance sheet approach to estimating accruals, which is induced by non-articulation events, transfers to the discretionary accrual proxy in tests of earnings management. Equation (8) demonstrates that the magnitude and direction of the bias in a test of earnings management depends on the correlation between PART and η. However, we have already identified at least three non-articulation events that contribute to η : mergers and 12 Using the cash flow approach, AR is taken from the statement of cash flows, while under the balance sheet approach it is measured as the difference in subsequent balance sheets. 13 Clearly this is not the only source of measurement error. The discussion in McNichols and Wilson is geared towards the measurement error induced by the choice of an empirical model used to measure discretionary accruals. Our analysis, however, examines a source of measurement error that is knowable and hence allows us to empirically evaluate the impact that the resulting coefficient bias can have on inferences made about earnings management. 16
18 acquisitions, divestitures, and foreign currency translations. Table 3 presents evidence of the bias in tests of earnings management that arises when PART (the dummy variable used to identify periods of expected earnings management) coincides with each of these three nonarticulation events. Panel A displays the standard deviations of the measurement error proxy, η, and the three partitioning variables, PART merger, PART disc-op, and PART fc, as well as the correlations between η and each of these partitions. Using equation (8), the magnitude of the bias associated with the three non-articulation events can be estimated. This is shown in the right-most column of Panel A. The bias associated with PART merger is 1.65% of total assets, which is both statistically and economically significant, given accruals are, on average, approximately 4.5% percent of total assets. The bias associated with discontinued operations is similarly large but in the opposite direction, averaging -1.64% of total assets. The bias associated with foreign currency translations also tends to be negative, but is not as large averaging only -0.25% of total assets. While Panel A shows evidence of a significant bias entering the calculation of discretionary accruals when using DACC bs, it does not provide direct evidence of the potential impact on statistical inferences in tests of earnings management. To address this issue, Panel B of Table 3 provides results of tests of earnings management (see eqn.(8)) using the three previously identified partitions and discretionary accruals computed under both the balance sheet approach and from the statement of cash flows. By testing for significant discretionary accruals under both approaches, we can examine if any statistical inferences change due to measurement error in discretionary accruals under the balance sheet approach. A priori, we have no reason to believe that there will be significant earnings management associated with any of the three nonarticulation events used as partitioning variables. Therefore, when accruals are measured 17
19 correctly from the statement of cash flows, we expect the coefficient on PART to be insignificantly different from zero. Discretionary accruals are regressed on each of the three partitioning variables on an annual basis. Additionally, the significance across all years is reported by taking the average of the sampling distribution of the ten individual-year parameter estimates. From Panel A, we expect that the balance sheet estimation method biases the coefficient on PART, especially for merger/acquisition firms and discontinued operation firms. More importantly, however, Panel B demonstrates that the researcher s inference of whether or not earnings management exists can change depending on how the accruals are measured. Specifically, the second column of Panel B demonstrates that a partition on mergers and acquisitions yields evidence of significant income increasing earnings management (in 10 of 10 individual years and across all years) when balance sheet accruals estimates are used. However, the same partition using accruals from the statement of cash flows (column 3 of Panel B) yields no evidence of earnings management. The next two columns in Panel B demonstrate that a partition on discontinued operations yields evidence of significant income decreasing earnings management (in 8 of 10 individual years and across all years) when using accruals under the balance sheet approach, while a similar partition using accruals from the statement of cash flows yields evidence of earnings management in only one year. Finally, the last two columns of panel B demonstrate that a partition on foreign currency translation does not appear to be directionally biased, with insignificant results across all years under both the balance sheet and cash flow approaches. The results in Table 3 assume a 100% overlap between the partitioning variable used to test for the existence of earnings management and the three non-articulation events considered in this study. In general, however, the partitioning variable chosen by the researcher will rarely 18
20 coincide perfectly with these non-articulation events. Rather, the sample will often be only partially contaminated by the non-articulation events, and the degree of contamination will vary depending on the event chosen. For example, studies examining financially distressed firms might contain a higher proportion of firms with discontinued operations than the population in general, while studies examining rapidly growing firms might contain a higher proportion of merger and acquisition firms than the population in general. Therefore, this section attempts to estimate the potential bias in tests of earnings management where the partitioning variable is imperfectly correlated with the non-articulation events. The procedure we use is described only for the mergers and acquisitions subsample of firms, but the identical procedure is used for the discontinued operations subsample. We start by taking a random sample of 250 firms from the subsample of firms that do not have a non-articulation event in a given year. This is our 0% contamination sample. 14 Using 1000 iterations of this procedure, we then measure the amount of the bias in discretionary accruals as a percent of total assets (η in equation 12), and the probability of committing a type I error if there is no earnings management present. Based on 1000 trials, the rejection frequencies (i.e. type I error rates) are reported at the 1% and 5% significance levels using a one tailed t-test. Next, we increase the percent contaminated to 10% by taking a random sample of 25 firms from the merger and acquisition subsample and a random sample of 225 from the subsample of firms without a non-articulation event, repeat this procedure 1000 times, and measure the magnitude of the bias and the rejection frequency at this level of contamination. We continue this procedure until the percent of the sample contaminated by mergers and acquisitions is 100%. 14 A sample size of N=250 is arbitrarily chosen to approximate a typical sample size in a study of earnings management. As N is increased (decreased), the rejection rate frequencies will increase (decrease), although the magnitude of the bias will not be affected. 19
21 Results of this procedure for mergers and acquisitions are depicted in Figure 2 and the results for discontinued operations are depicted in Figure 3. Examining the merger and acquisition subsample in Figure 2, the first point to note is that at a 0% contamination level, the bias in panel A is minimal (0.03% of total assets) and the test statistics in panel B are relatively well specified (3.4% and 1.8% relative to the expected 5% and 1% levels). As the percent of the sample contaminated increases, however, the bias increases and the probability of committing a type I error increases significantly. For example, even when the sample is only 30% contaminated, the probabilities of committing type I errors in the absence of earnings management are approximately 45% and 33%, relative to the expected levels of 5% and 1%. Moreover, as the percent of the sample contaminated by mergers and acquisitions rises above 50%, the type I error rates increase to 90% and greater. Thus, at these levels of contamination, even if no earnings management were present, the researcher would almost certainly conclude that earnings had indeed been managed. Results for the discontinued operations in Figure 3 are similar. At the 0% contamination level, the bias in panel A is 0.05% of total assets and the probabilities of committing a type I error in panel B are 6.5% and 3.6% relative to the expected 5% and 1% levels. As the percent of the sample contaminated increases, however, the bias for discontinued operation firms decreases from approximately -0.19% of total assets at the 10% contamination level, to 1.33% of total assets at the 100% contamination level. Additionally, although the rejection frequencies do not rise as quickly for the discontinued operations subsample as they do for the mergers and acquisitions subsample, at 30% contamination the rejection frequencies are still 36% and 25%, relative to the expected 5% and 1% levels. Thus, it is obvious that even a relatively modest level of contamination by non-articulation events can have a potentially large impact on both the 20
22 magnitude of the estimated accruals that are managed, as well as the inferences that the researcher draws from these results. 3.3 Implications for extant earnings management literature. The results of the previous section have significant implications for extant earnings management studies using a balance sheet approach to estimating accruals. Specifically, the measurement error in total accruals and the resulting coefficient bias for various partitions could lead the researcher to conclude that significant earnings management exists, when in fact there is none. Given the results of the previous section, this is most problematic for partitions that are correlated with either mergers and acquisitions or discontinued operations. For example, Rees, Gill and Gore (1996) investigate the potential for earnings management associated with asset write-downs using a balance sheet approach to measuring accruals (p. 159, equation 1). The authors hypothesize that if the primary motive for an asset write-down is opportunistic, firms are likely to concurrently manage operating accruals downwards. Accordingly, they test for income decreasing discretionary accruals. Yet, as noted by the authors, the majority of write-downs in their sample are part of an overall firm restructuring. Thus, the partition chosen by Rees, Gill, and Gore (i.e. asset write-downs) is likely to be positively correlated with the presence of discontinued operations. Furthermore, as shown above, discretionary accruals determined under the balance sheet approach are negatively biased for firms with discontinued operations. Therefore, it is predicted that this combination will induce a negative bias to their test of earnings management, which is exactly the predicted direction of the alleged earnings management. To empirically assess the impact of this potential bias, we collect a sample of asset writedowns from using the same data source (NAARS), search string, and selection 21
23 criteria as Rees et al. (1996, pp ). 15 This procedure results in a sample of 307 firm-year observations. Operating accruals are as defined as in Rees et al. (1996) whereby the definition only encompasses working capital accruals and depreciation expense. Additionally, accruals are adjusted for the impact of the restructuring charge on current liabilities. Finally, the control sample consists of all firms within the same two-digit SIC code in the year of the write-down. The test for abnormal accruals is then conducted using a separate regression for each sub-sample of observations, where the sub-sample consists of a sample and a control group, as follows: 16 ACC t = α 0 + α 1 ( Rev t ) + α 2 (PPE t ) +α 3 (CFO t ) +β 1 (PART t ) + ε t (13) where PART equals one for firms with an asset write-down, and zero otherwise. The original results from the Rees et al. (1996) study are shown in Table 4, Panel A. Abnormal operating accruals in the year of the write-down (i.e. the average coefficient on PART) are -3.05% of total assets. Additionally, in their 120 separate cross-sectional regressions estimated using equation (13), the coefficient on PART is negative 67.5% of the time. Using the balance sheet approach and sample we collected from , we first replicate the Rees et al. finding using a balance sheet estimation approach (Panel B) and then repeat the tests using a cash flow statement approach (Panel C). Using the balance sheet approach in Panel B, we find results that are qualitatively similar to those reported in Rees et al. (1996). There appears to be significant income-decreasing abnormal accruals of approximately 2.24% of total assets, and negative abnormal accruals in 62.3% of our 125 cross-sectional regressions. In Panel C, however, when operating accruals are taken directly from the statement of cash flows, the results are dramatically different. In the year of the asset write-down, abnormal operating accruals are 15 Rees et al. (1996) examine data from However, to ensure that all cash flow statement data are available to correctly determine accruals, we use data from This estimation procedure differs slightly from the procedure outlined in equations (10) and (11), but is used to maintain consistency with the original Rees et al. (1996) study. 22
24 only 0.40% of total assets, which is not significantly different from zero at conventional significance levels. Moreover, abnormal accruals are negative only 52.8% of the time, which is not significantly different from 50% using a binomial test. Thus, the presence of discontinued operations has a significant impact on the magnitude of income-decreasing discretionary accruals estimated via the balance sheet approach. As shown, this can readily lead the researcher to conclude that accruals are being managed downward when, in fact, properly measured accruals indicate otherwise. Other studies of earnings management subject to similar concerns about negative bias would include studies that test for income decreasing earnings management in a sample that contains a disproportionate number of financially distressed firms (e.g. Perry and Williams 1994). In this case, the firms hypothesized to be engaged in earnings management are also likely to be divesting of unprofitable segments or divisions. As we have shown, this divestiture activity induces a negative bias to ACC bs estimates that is in the same direction as the hypothesized earnings management, thus confounding their hypothesis tests. Moreover, as shown earlier, the probability of committing a type I error increases substantially, even if the sample is only 30-40% contaminated by discontinued operations. Similar concerns can be raised about studies that test for income-increasing earnings management around events that are positively correlated with mergers and acquisitions. For example, Teoh, Welch, and Wong (1998) and Rangan (1998) examine earnings management in anticipation of seasoned equity offerings (SEOs). These studies investigate whether earnings management might contribute to the long-run underperformance of SEOs previously identified in the finance literature (e.g. Loughran and Ritter 1995). While on the surface, there is no obvious relation between mergers and acquisitions and SEOs, we find that firms listed by Securities Data 23
25 Corporation as participating in SEOs are 55.1% (64.7%) more likely to be involved in a merger or acquisition in the year prior to (in the year of) an SEO than the population in general. Thus, an estimate of discretionary accruals in this sub-sample of firms is more likely to be upward biased relative to the population in general, due to the fact that there is a higher proportion of merger and acquisition firms in this sub-sample. To investigate whether this bias impacts any inferences, Table 5 examines the impact of the balance sheet estimation approach for 775 firms conducting seasoned equity offerings from Teoh, Welch, and Wong (1998) find that, on average, accruals are managed upwards in the year prior to and in the year of a seasoned equity offering. Panel A re-examines this issue by comparing the discretionary accruals of the SEO sample to discretionary accruals of a control sample in the year prior to a seasoned equity offering. 17 Because of our requirements for cash flow statement data availability, our sample periods are largely non-overlapping, with our period covering , and their period covering The first line of Panel A reveals that under the balance sheet approach, discretionary accruals are significantly larger in period t-1 for the firms that issue a seasoned equity offering in period t as compared to a set of control firms (DACC bs,seo DACC bs,control = 0.73%, t=2.90). Using the cash flow approach to measuring accruals, however, we find no significant difference in discretionary accruals between the SEO firms and the control firms (DACC cf,seo DACC cf,control = 0.22%, t=1.13). Thus, the inference as to whether firms manage earnings upward in the year prior to a seasoned equity 17 The control sample is matched on the basis of net income in the year prior to the seasoned equity offering. Discretionary accruals are computed using the cross-sectional version of the modified Jones model, as outlined in equations (10) and (11). 18 Another issue is that their balance sheet accrual measure cannot be replicated during our sample period because total funds from operations (Compustat #110) is only reported prior to the issuance of the statement of cash flows. Thus, we use the ACC bs and ACC cf measures discussed earlier when replicating the study. 24
26 offering changes depending on whether the balance sheet or cash flow approach is used to estimate accruals. 19 Panel B demonstrates that within the sample of SEO firms, it is those with mergers and acquisitions that cause the measure of discretionary accruals to be significantly positive under the balance sheet approach. For the 251 firms involved in a merger or acquisition, mean abnormal accruals are 1.69% of total assets. Conversely, for the 524 firms not involved in a merger or acquisition, discretionary accruals are 0.03% of total assets. Note that the magnitude of estimated discretionary accruals for the non-merger firms in Panel B is comparable to the discretionary accruals of 0.04% reported in Panel A for the SEO sample as a whole when the cash flow approach is used. Thus, one important implication of this result is that when cash flow statement data are not available to determine accruals (e.g. prior to 1988), a viable alternative is to separately analyze those firms involved in non-articulation events. Comparison of results for these firms with those not impacted by non-articulation events can be used to determine the potential contamination caused by balance sheet accrual estimation. In summary, our results suggest that inferences regarding the existence and magnitude of earnings management in anticipation of SEOs can change when the balance sheet approach is used to estimate accruals and the sample contains a significant number of firms involved in mergers and acquisitions. Moreover, the underperformance of SEO stocks that Teoh et al. (1998) and Rangan (1998) attribute to the market corrections related to earnings management is likely to be confounded by the well-documented long-run underperformance of firms involved in mergers and acquisitions (see, for example, Agrawal and Jaffe 1999). 19 Additional findings not reported in Table 5 show that in the year of the SEO, discretionary accruals as a percent of total assets are 138% larger when estimated using the balance sheet approach ( vs , p<.01). 25
Errors in Estimating Unexpected Accruals in the Presence of. Large Changes in Net External Financing
Errors in Estimating Unexpected Accruals in the Presence of Large Changes in Net External Financing Yaowen Shan (University of Technology, Sydney) Stephen Taylor* (University of Technology, Sydney) Terry
More informationA Synthesis of Accrual Quality and Abnormal Accrual Models: An Empirical Implementation
A Synthesis of Accrual Quality and Abnormal Accrual Models: An Empirical Implementation Jinhan Pae a* a Korea University Abstract Dechow and Dichev s (2002) accrual quality model suggests that the Jones
More informationComparison of Abnormal Accrual Estimation Procedures in the Context of Investor Mispricing
Comparison of Abnormal Accrual Estimation Procedures in the Context of Investor Mispricing C.S. Agnes Cheng* University of Houston Securities and Exchange Commission chenga@sec.gov Wayne Thomas School
More informationThe Effects of Firm Growth and Model Specification Choices on Tests of Earnings Management in Quarterly Settings
The Effects of Firm Growth and Model Specification Choices on Tests of Earnings Management in Quarterly Settings Daniel W. Collins, Raunaq S. Pungaliya, and Anand M. Vijh * Abstract Commonly used Jones-type
More informationDiscretionary Accrual Models and the Accounting Process
Discretionary Accrual Models and the Accounting Process by Xavier Garza-Gómez 1, Masashi Okumura 2 and Michio Kunimura 3 Nagoya City University Working Paper No. 259 October 1999 1 Research assistant at
More informationPerformance Matched Discretionary Accrual Measures
Performance Matched Discretionary Accrual Measures S.P. Kothari Sloan School of Management Massachusetts Institute of Technology 50 Memorial Drive, E52-325 Cambridge, MA 02142 kothari@mit.edu 617-253-0994
More informationACCRUALS MANAGEMENT, INVESTOR SOPHISTICATION, AND EQUITY VALUATION: EVIDENCE FROM 10-Q FILINGS
ACCRUALS MANAGEMENT, INVESTOR SOPHISTICATION, AND EQUITY VALUATION: EVIDENCE FROM 10-Q FILINGS Steven Balsam Fox School of Business and Management Temple University Philadelphia, PA 19122 Eli Bartov and
More informationErrors in Estimating Unexpected Accruals in the Presence of Large Net External Financing THINK.CHANGE.DO
Errors in Estimating Unexpected Accruals in the Presence of Large Net External Financing THINK.CHANGE.DO Yaowen Shan Stephen Taylor Terry Walter University of Technology, Sydney UEXAC = β PART + ε Motivations
More informationIdentifying unexpected accruals: a comparison of current approaches
Identifying unexpected accruals: a comparison of current approaches Jacob Thomas and Xiao-jun Zhang Journal of Accounting and Public Policy (Winter 2000): 347-376 Jacob Thomas is Ernst & Young Professor
More informationAccrual determinants, sales changes and their impact on empirical accrual models
Accrual determinants, sales changes and their impact on empirical accrual models Nicholas Dopuch Dopuch@wustl.edu Raj Mashruwala Mashruwala@wustl.edu Chandra Seethamraju Seethamraju@wustl.edu Tzachi Zach
More informationOnline Appendix to. The Value of Crowdsourced Earnings Forecasts
Online Appendix to The Value of Crowdsourced Earnings Forecasts This online appendix tabulates and discusses the results of robustness checks and supplementary analyses mentioned in the paper. A1. Estimating
More informationCauses or Consequences? Earnings Management around Seasoned Equity Offerings *
Causes or Consequences? Earnings Management around Seasoned Equity Offerings * JIE CHEN Tepper School of Business Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh, PA 15213 jiec1@andrew.cmu.edu ZHAOYANG GU Tepper
More informationAnalysis on accrual-based models in detecting earnings management
Lingnan Journal of Banking, Finance and Economics Volume 2 2010/2011 Academic Year Issue Article 5 January 2010 Analysis on accrual-based models in detecting earnings management Tianran CHEN tianranchen@ln.edu.hk
More informationOn Diversification Discount the Effect of Leverage
On Diversification Discount the Effect of Leverage Jin-Chuan Duan * and Yun Li (First draft: April 12, 2006) (This version: May 16, 2006) Abstract This paper identifies a key cause for the documented diversification
More informationIPO s Long-Run Performance: Hot Market vs. Earnings Management
IPO s Long-Run Performance: Hot Market vs. Earnings Management Tsai-Yin Lin Department of Financial Management National Kaohsiung First University of Science and Technology Jerry Yu * Department of Finance
More informationManagerial compensation and the threat of takeover
Journal of Financial Economics 47 (1998) 219 239 Managerial compensation and the threat of takeover Anup Agrawal*, Charles R. Knoeber College of Management, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC
More informationThe Journal of Applied Business Research Fourth Quarter 2007 Volume 23, Number 4 SYNOPSIS
The Incremental Usefulness Of Income Tax Allocations In Predicting One-Year-Ahead Future Cash Flows Benjamin P. Foster, (E-mail: ben.foster@louisville.edu), University of Louisville Terry J. Ward, (E-mail:
More informationThe Accrual Effect on Future Earnings
Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 22: 97 121, 2004 c 2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Manufactured in The Netherlands. The Accrual Effect on Future Earnings KONAN CHAN Department of Finance,
More informationInvestor Sophistication and the Mispricing of Accruals
Review of Accounting Studies, 8, 251 276, 2003 # 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Manufactured in The Netherlands. Investor Sophistication and the Mispricing of Accruals DANIEL W. COLLINS* Tippie College
More informationManagement of the loss reserve accrual and the distribution of earnings in the property-casualty insurance industry $
Journal of Accounting and Economics 35 (2003) 347 376 Management of the loss reserve accrual and the distribution of earnings in the property-casualty insurance industry $ William H. Beaver, Maureen F.
More informationAccrued Earnings and Growth: Implications for Earnings Persistence and Market Mispricing
Accrued Earnings and Growth: Implications for Earnings Persistence and Market Mispricing by Patricia M. Fairfield a Scott Whisenant b Teri Lombardi Yohn a November 2001 Corresponding author Teri Lombardi
More informationThe Separate Valuation Relevance of Earnings, Book Value and their Components in Profit and Loss Making Firms: UK Evidence
MPRA Munich Personal RePEc Archive The Separate Valuation Relevance of Earnings, Book Value and their Components in Profit and Loss Making Firms: UK Evidence S Akbar The University of Liverpool 2007 Online
More informationEssays on IPO-Firm Earnings Management
University of Tennessee, Knoxville Trace: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 8-2006 Essays on IPO-Firm Earnings Management Scott N. Bronson University of Tennessee
More informationThree essays on earnings management, financial irregularities, and capital structure
University of Iowa Iowa Research Online Theses and Dissertations Spring 2010 Three essays on earnings management, financial irregularities, and capital structure Raunaq Sushil Pungaliya University of Iowa
More informationClassification Shifting in the Income-Decreasing Discretionary Accrual Firms
Classification Shifting in the Income-Decreasing Discretionary Accrual Firms 1 Bahçeşehir University, Turkey Hümeyra Adıgüzel 1 Correspondence: Hümeyra Adıgüzel, Bahçeşehir University, Turkey. Received:
More informationThe Persistence of Cash Flow Components into Future Cash Flows
The Persistence of Cash Flow Components into Future Cash Flows C. S. Agnes Cheng * Securities Exchange Commission, Washington, DC University of Houston, Houston, Texas 77204-4852 CHENGA@SEC.GOV Dana Hollie
More informationThe Implications of Accounting Distortions and Growth for Accruals and Profitability
THE ACCOUNTING REVIEW Vol. 81, No. 3 2006 pp. 713 743 The Implications of Accounting Distortions and Growth for Accruals and Profitability Scott A. Richardson University of Pennsylvania Richard G. Sloan
More informationEarnings quality and earnings management : the role of accounting accruals Bissessur, S.W.
UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Earnings quality and earnings management : the role of accounting accruals Bissessur, S.W. Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Bissessur, S.
More informationThe Effect of Matching on Firm Earnings Components
Scientific Annals of Economics and Business 64 (4), 2017, 513-524 DOI: 10.1515/saeb-2017-0033 The Effect of Matching on Firm Earnings Components Joong-Seok Cho *, Hyung Ju Park ** Abstract Using a sample
More informationCorporate Life Cycle and the Accrual Model: An Empirical Study Based on Chinese Listed Companies
Front. Bus. Res. China 2010, 4(3): 580 607 DOI 10.1007/s11782-010-0112-1 RESEARCH ARTICLE Xudong Chen, Wendong Yang, Dengshi Huang Corporate Life Cycle and the Accrual Model: An Empirical Study Based on
More informationDividend Changes and Future Profitability
THE JOURNAL OF FINANCE VOL. LVI, NO. 6 DEC. 2001 Dividend Changes and Future Profitability DORON NISSIM and AMIR ZIV* ABSTRACT We investigate the relation between dividend changes and future profitability,
More informationThe Effects of Firm Growth and Model Specification Choices on Tests of Earnings Management in Quarterly Settings
THE ACCOUNTING REVIEW Vol. 92, No. 2 March 2017 pp. 69 100 American Accounting Association DOI: 10.2308/accr-51551 The Effects of Firm Growth and Model Specification Choices on Tests of Earnings Management
More informationInformation in Accruals about the Quality of Earnings*
Information in Accruals about the Quality of Earnings* Scott Richardson a Richard G. Sloan a Mark Soliman a and Irem Tuna a First Version: July 2001 * We acknowledge the helpful comments of Patricia Dechow.
More informationPropensity of Australian firms to manage their earnings around recognised benchmarks
Propensity of Australian firms to manage their earnings around recognised benchmarks Presented By Richard Anthony Kent Submitted in total fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Philosophy
More informationPerformance Measures, Discretionary Accruals, and CEO Cash Compensation
Performance Measures, Discretionary Accruals, and CEO Cash Compensation Simon S.M. Yang School of Business, Adelphi University Phone: (516) 877-4618 Fax: (516) 877-4607 Email address: yang@adelphi.edu
More informationEarnings Management and Earnings Surprises: Stock Price Reactions to Earnings Components * Larry L. DuCharme. Yang Liu. Paul H.
Earnings Management and Earnings Surprises: Stock Price Reactions to Earnings Components * Larry L. DuCharme Yang Liu Paul H. Malatesta University of Washington School of Business Box 353200 Seattle, WA
More informationHow Does Earnings Management Affect Innovation Strategies of Firms?
How Does Earnings Management Affect Innovation Strategies of Firms? Abstract This paper examines how earnings quality affects innovation strategies and their economic consequences. Previous literatures
More informationDoes Income Smoothing Make Stock Prices More Informative? June, 2002
Does Income Smoothing Make Stock Prices More Informative? June, 2002 Paul Zarowin New York University Stern School of Business Ph: 212-998-0015 Fax: 212-995-4004 e-mail: pzarowin@stern.nyu.edu I thank
More informationForecasting Cash Flows: A Comparison of Prediction Models Within and Between Industries
Brooke N. Young, William Stammerjohan, and Laurie Swinney Forecasting Cash Flows: A Comparison of Prediction Models Within and Between Industries Brooke N. Young, Deloitte & Touché, Omaha, NE 68102 William
More informationEarnings quality and earnings management : the role of accounting accruals Bissessur, S.W.
UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Earnings quality and earnings management : the role of accounting accruals Bissessur, S.W. Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Bissessur, S.
More informationDoes Calendar Time Portfolio Approach Really Lack Power?
International Journal of Business and Management; Vol. 9, No. 9; 2014 ISSN 1833-3850 E-ISSN 1833-8119 Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education Does Calendar Time Portfolio Approach Really
More informationThe Reconciling Role of Earnings in Equity Valuation
The Reconciling Role of Earnings in Equity Valuation Bixia Xu Assistant Professor School of Business Wilfrid Laurier University Waterloo, Ontario, N2L 3C5 (519) 884-0710 ext. 2659; Fax: (519) 884.0201;
More informationEvaluating the accrual-fixation hypothesis as an explanation for the accrual anomaly
Evaluating the accrual-fixation hypothesis as an explanation for the accrual anomaly Tzachi Zach * Olin School of Business Washington University in St. Louis St. Louis, MO 63130 Tel: (314)-9354528 zach@olin.wustl.edu
More informationCAN WE BOOST STOCK VALUE USING INCOME-INCREASING STRATEGY? THE CASE OF INDONESIA
I J A B E R, Vol. 13, No. 7 (2015): 6093-6103 CAN WE BOOST STOCK VALUE USING INCOME-INCREASING STRATEGY? THE CASE OF INDONESIA Felizia Arni 1 and Dedhy Sulistiawan 2 Abstract: The main purpose of this
More informationThe Information Content of Commercial Banks Fair Value Disclosures of Loans under SFAS 107. Seungmin Chee
The Information Content of Commercial Banks Fair Value Disclosures of Loans under SFAS 107 By Seungmin Chee A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor
More informationA Study of the Factors Affecting Earnings Management: Iranian Overview
A Study of the Factors Affecting Earnings Management: Iranian Overview Farzaneh Nassirzadeh Assistant professor, Accounting Department, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran Mahdi salehi (Corresponding
More informationEarnings Management: New Evidence. Based on Deferred Tax Expense
Earnings Management: New Evidence Based on Deferred Tax Expense John Phillips Universy of Connecticut Morton Pincus * Universy of Iowa Sonja Olhoft Rego Universy of Iowa July 2001 * Corresponding author:
More informationAccounting Conservatism and the Relation Between Returns and Accounting Data
Review of Accounting Studies, 9, 495 521, 2004 Ó 2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Manufactured in The Netherlands. Accounting Conservatism and the Relation Between Returns and Accounting Data PETER EASTON*
More informationThe cross section of expected stock returns
The cross section of expected stock returns Jonathan Lewellen Dartmouth College and NBER This version: March 2013 First draft: October 2010 Tel: 603-646-8650; email: jon.lewellen@dartmouth.edu. I am grateful
More informationDetecting Earnings Management Using Discontinuity Evidence*
Detecting Earnings Management Using Discontinuity Evidence* David Burgstahler Julius A. Roller Professor of Accounting University of Washington/Seattle Elizabeth Chuk Assistant Professor University of
More informationEvidence of conditional conservatism: fact or artifact? Panos N. Patatoukas Yale University
Evidence of conditional conservatism: fact or artifact? Panos N. Patatoukas Yale University panagiotis.patatoukas@yale.edu Jacob Thomas Yale University jake.thomas@yale.edu Current Version: October 5,
More informationLiquidity skewness premium
Liquidity skewness premium Giho Jeong, Jangkoo Kang, and Kyung Yoon Kwon * Abstract Risk-averse investors may dislike decrease of liquidity rather than increase of liquidity, and thus there can be asymmetric
More informationFUNDAÇÃO INSTITUTO CAPIXABA DE PESQUISAS EM CONTABILIDADE, ECONOMIA E FINANÇAS (FUCAPE) RAFAELA MÓDOLO DE PINHO
FUNDAÇÃO INSTITUTO CAPIXABA DE PESQUISAS EM CONTABILIDADE, ECONOMIA E FINANÇAS (FUCAPE) RAFAELA MÓDOLO DE PINHO ACCRUALS QUALITY: net income perspective and comprehensive income perspective VITÓRIA 2011
More informationAdjusting for earnings volatility in earnings forecast models
Uppsala University Department of Business Studies Spring 14 Bachelor thesis Supervisor: Joachim Landström Authors: Sandy Samour & Fabian Söderdahl Adjusting for earnings volatility in earnings forecast
More informationJ. Account. Public Policy
J. Account. Public Policy 28 (2009) 16 32 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect J. Account. Public Policy journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jaccpubpol The value relevance of R&D across profit
More informationResearch Methods in Accounting
01130591 Research Methods in Accounting Capital Markets Research in Accounting Dr Polwat Lerskullawat: fbuspwl@ku.ac.th Dr Suthawan Prukumpai: fbusswp@ku.ac.th Assoc Prof Tipparat Laohavichien: fbustrl@ku.ac.th
More informationThe predictive power of investment and accruals
The predictive power of investment and accruals Jonathan Lewellen Dartmouth College and NBER jon.lewellen@dartmouth.edu Robert J. Resutek Dartmouth College robert.j.resutek@dartmouth.edu This version:
More informationServicing Assets and Gain-On-Securitization under SFAS 156. Abstract
Servicing Assets and Gain-On-Securitization under SFAS 156 Abstract SFAS No. 156 was issued in 2006 to amend SFAS No.140 which addresses the accounting for servicing of financial assets and requires fair
More informationDetecting Earnings Management: A New Approach *
Detecting Earnings Management: A New Approach * Patricia M. Dechow The Haas School of Business University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94705 Patricia_dechow@haas.berkeley.edu Amy P. Hutton Carroll
More informationFinancing Decisions and Discretionary Accruals: Managerial Manipulation or Managerial Overoptimism
Financing Decisions and Discretionary Accruals: Managerial Manipulation or Managerial Overoptimism Dalia Marciukaityte Louisiana Tech University Samuel H. Szewczyk Drexel University December 3, 2007 Address
More informationThe accrual anomaly focus on changes in specific unexpected accruals results in new evidence
WORKING PAPER R-2006-03 Finn Schøler The accrual anomaly focus on changes in specific unexpected accruals results in new evidence Financial Reporting Research Group The accrual anomaly focus on changes
More informationEarnings Management and Excess Investment: Accrual-Based versus Real Activities. Daniel Cohen and Paul Zarowin
Earnings Management and Excess Investment: Accrual-Based versus Real Activities Daniel Cohen and Paul Zarowin New York University Leonard N. Stern School of Business December, 2009 Abstract We examine
More informationReal Estate Ownership by Non-Real Estate Firms: The Impact on Firm Returns
Real Estate Ownership by Non-Real Estate Firms: The Impact on Firm Returns Yongheng Deng and Joseph Gyourko 1 Zell/Lurie Real Estate Center at Wharton University of Pennsylvania Prepared for the Corporate
More informationImproving the estimation of discretionary accruals the cycle approach
ABSTRACT Improving the estimation of discretionary accruals the cycle approach Che-Wei Chiu, PhD Winona State University Po-Chang Chen, PhD Miami University Yuqian Wang, PhD Winona State University The
More informationConservatism and Accruals: Are They Interactive? Evidence from the Greek Capital Market
Conservatism and Accruals: Are They Interactive? Evidence from the Greek Capital Market Panagiotis E. Dimitropoulos University of Peloponnese Department of Sport Management 3-5 Lysandrou Str P.C.23100,
More informationInformation asymmetry and the FASB s multi-period adoption policy: the case of SFAS no. 115
OC13090 FASB s multi-period adoption policy: the case of SFAS no. 115 Daniel R. Brickner Eastern Michigan University Abstract This paper examines Financial Accounting Standard No. 115 with respect to the
More informationAccrual reversals and cash conversion
Accrual reversals and cash conversion Matt Bloomfield 1, Joseph Gerakos 1 and Andrei Kovrijnykh 2 1 University of Chicago Booth School of Business 2 W. P. Carey School of Business, Arizona State University
More informationMarket Reaction to Earnings Management: The Incremental Contribution of Analysts
International Research Journal of Finance and Economics ISSN 1450-2887 Issue 8 (2007) EuroJournals Publishing, Inc. 2007 http://www.eurojournals.com/finance.htm Market Reaction to Earnings Management:
More informationEmpirical Methods in Corporate Finance
Uses of Accounting Data Josh Lerner Empirical Methods in Corporate Finance Accounting-based Research Why examine? Close ties between accounting research and corporate finance. Numbers important to both.
More informationAbnormal accruals and external financing
Abnormal accruals and external financing Theodore H. Goodman Eller College of Management University of Arizona McClelland Hall Tucson, AZ 85721-0108 tgoodman@email.arizona.edu August 2007 ABSTRACT In this
More informationDisclosure Quality and Earnings Management
Farsiarticles.com Iran-article.ir Iranarticles.com Disclosure Quality and Earnings Management Gerald J. Lobo Arthur Andersen Professor of Accounting Department of Accountancy & Taxation Bauer College of
More informationLancaster University Management School Working Paper 2002/018. Earnings Management and the Distribution of Earnings Relative to Targets: UK Evidence
Lancaster University Management School Working Paper 22/18 Earnings Management and the Distribution of Earnings Relative to Targets: UK Evidence Pelham Gore, Peter Pope and Ashni Singh The Department of
More informationMIT Sloan School of Management
MIT Sloan School of Management Working Paper 4262-02 September 2002 Reporting Conservatism, Loss Reversals, and Earnings-based Valuation Peter R. Joos, George A. Plesko 2002 by Peter R. Joos, George A.
More informationThe Classification and Market Pricing of the Cash Flows and Accruals on Trading Positions. June, 2005
The Classification and Market Pricing of the Cash Flows and Accruals on Trading Positions June, 2005 Stephen G. Ryan* X. Jenny Tucker** Paul A. Zarowin* * Stern School of Business, New York University.
More informationExternal Financing and Future Stock Returns
The Rodney L. White Center for Financial Research External Financing and Future Stock Returns Scott A. Richardson Richard G. Sloan 03-03 External Financing and Future Stock Returns * Scott A. Richardson
More informationThe Associations of Cash Flows and Earnings with Firm. Performance: An International Comparison
The Associations of Cash Flows and Earnings with Firm Performance: An International Comparison Shin-Rong Shiah-Hou * Chin-Wen Hsiao ** Department of Finance, Yuan Ze University, Taiwan Abstract This paper
More informationACCOUNTING QUALITY MODELS: A COMPREHENSIVE LITERATURE REVIEW
International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management United Kingdom Vol. III, Issue 5, May 2015 http://ijecm.co.uk/ ISSN 2348 0386 ACCOUNTING QUALITY MODELS: A COMPREHENSIVE LITERATURE REVIEW Cetin
More informationThe Usefulness of Direct and Indirect Cash Flow Disclosures
The Usefulness of Direct and Indirect Cash Flow Disclosures Greg Clinch Australian Graduate School of Management University of New South Wales Baljit Sidhu Australian Graduate School of Management University
More informationThe Implications of Using Stock-Split Adjusted I/B/E/S Data in Empirical Research
The Implications of Using Stock-Split Adjusted I/B/E/S Data in Empirical Research Jeff L. Payne Gatton College of Business and Economics University of Kentucky Lexington, KY 40507, USA and Wayne B. Thomas
More informationThe IPO Derby: Are there Consistent Losers and Winners on this Track?
The IPO Derby: Are there Consistent Losers and Winners on this Track? Konan Chan *, John W. Cooney, Jr. **, Joonghyuk Kim ***, and Ajai K. Singh **** This version: June, 2007 Abstract We examine the individual
More informationEARNINGS MANAGEMENT AND ACCOUNTING STANDARDS IN EUROPE
EARNINGS MANAGEMENT AND ACCOUNTING STANDARDS IN EUROPE Wolfgang Aussenegg 1, Vienna University of Technology Petra Inwinkl 2, Vienna University of Technology Georg Schneider 3, University of Paderborn
More informationThe Usefulness of Core and Non-Core Cash Flows in Predicting Future Cash Flows
The Usefulness of Core and Non-Core Cash Flows in Predicting Future Cash Flows by C. S. Agnes Cheng University of Houston Houston, Texas 77204-4852 Dana Hollie* University of Houston Houston, Texas 77204-4852
More informationDividend Policy and Earnings Management: Based on Discretionary Accruals and Real Earnings Management
, pp.137-150 http://dx.doi.org/10.14257/ijunesst.2016.9.2.15 Dividend Policy and Earnings Management: Based on Discretionary Accruals and Real Earnings Management 1 Chae Chang Im (1 st Author), 2 Jeong
More informationAppendix. In this Appendix, we present the construction of variables, data source, and some empirical procedures.
Appendix In this Appendix, we present the construction of variables, data source, and some empirical procedures. A.1. Variable Definition and Data Source Variable B/M CAPX/A Cash/A Cash flow volatility
More informationElisabetta Basilico and Tommi Johnsen. Disentangling the Accruals Mispricing in Europe: Is It an Industry Effect? Working Paper n.
Elisabetta Basilico and Tommi Johnsen Disentangling the Accruals Mispricing in Europe: Is It an Industry Effect? Working Paper n. 5/2014 April 2014 ISSN: 2239-2734 This Working Paper is published under
More informationDetecting Earnings Management Using Discontinuity Evidence*
Detecting Earnings Management Using Discontinuity Evidence* David Burgstahler Julius A. Roller Professor of Accounting University of Washington/Seattle Elizabeth Chuk Assistant Professor University of
More informationValuation of tax expense
Valuation of tax expense Jacob Thomas Yale University School of Management (203) 432-5977 jake.thomas@yale.edu Frank Zhang Yale University School of Management (203) 432-7938 frank.zhang@yale.edu August
More informationYale ICF Working Paper No March 2003
Yale ICF Working Paper No. 03-07 March 2003 CONSERVATISM AND CROSS-SECTIONAL VARIATION IN THE POST-EARNINGS- ANNOUNCEMENT-DRAFT Ganapathi Narayanamoorthy Yale School of Management This paper can be downloaded
More informationEarnings Management and Underpricing of Initial Public Offerings (IPO), Evidence from Iran
International Business Research; Vol. 7, No. 7; 2014 ISSN 1913-9004 E-ISSN 1913-9012 Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education Earnings Management and Underpricing of Initial Public Offerings
More informationDoes R&D Influence Revisions in Earnings Forecasts as it does with Forecast Errors?: Evidence from the UK. Seraina C.
Does R&D Influence Revisions in Earnings Forecasts as it does with Forecast Errors?: Evidence from the UK Seraina C. Anagnostopoulou Athens University of Economics and Business Department of Accounting
More informationManagerial Insider Trading and Opportunism
Managerial Insider Trading and Opportunism Mehmet E. Akbulut 1 Department of Finance College of Business and Economics California State University Fullerton Abstract This paper examines whether managers
More informationAccounting Anomalies and Information Uncertainty
Accounting Anomalies and Information Uncertainty Jennifer Francis (Duke University) Ryan LaFond (University of Wisconsin) Per Olsson (Duke University) Katherine Schipper (Financial Accounting Standards
More informationAndrzej Krystian Piosik, Małgorzata Rówińska DETERMINANTS OF LONG-LIVED ASSET IMPAIRMENTS. EVIDENCE FROM POLAND
Andrzej Krystian Piosik, Małgorzata Rówińska DETERMINANTS OF LONG-LIVED ASSET IMPAIRMENTS. EVIDENCE FROM POLAND ANDRZEJ KRYSTIAN PIOSIK, MAŁGORZATA RÓWIŃSKA Introduction * The objective of the paper is
More informationThe Earnings Persistence and the Market Pricing of Cash Flows, Normal and Abnormal Accruals: Thailand's Capital Markets
The Earnings Persistence and the Market Pricing of Cash Flows, Normal and Abnormal Accruals: Thailand's Capital Markets Somchai Supattarakul, Ph.D.* Thammasat Business School, Thammasat University 2 Prachan
More informationEarnings Management in Initial Public Offering. and Post-Issue Stock Performance
Erasmus School of Economics Earnings Management in Initial Public Offering and Post-Issue Stock Performance Author: Sha Xu, 424970 424970sx@student.eur.nl Supervisor: Dr. Yun Dai dai@ese.eur.nl Program:
More informationThis document is downloaded from DR-NTU, Nanyang Technological University Library, Singapore.
This document is downloaded from DR-NTU, Nanyang Technological University Library, Singapore. Title Rounding-up in reported EPS, behavioral thresholds, and earnings management Author(s) Das, Somnath; Zhang,
More informationDIVIDEND POLICY AND THE LIFE CYCLE HYPOTHESIS: EVIDENCE FROM TAIWAN
The International Journal of Business and Finance Research Volume 5 Number 1 2011 DIVIDEND POLICY AND THE LIFE CYCLE HYPOTHESIS: EVIDENCE FROM TAIWAN Ming-Hui Wang, Taiwan University of Science and Technology
More informationTHE IMPACT OF AUDIT QUALITY ON EARNINGS CONSERVATISM: AUSTRALIAN EVIDENCE
THE IMPACT OF AUDIT QUALITY ON EARNINGS CONSERVATISM: AUSTRALIAN EVIDENCE Sarah Taylor* University of Melbourne FIRST DRAFT October 2003 Comments Welcome As this is a preliminary draft, please do not quote.
More informationOnline Appendix (Not For Publication)
A Online Appendix (Not For Publication) Contents of the Appendix 1. The Village Democracy Survey (VDS) sample Figure A1: A map of counties where sample villages are located 2. Robustness checks for the
More informationTrends in Earnings Management and Informativeness of Earnings Announcements in the Pre- and Post-Sarbanes Oxley Periods *
Trends in Earnings Management and Informativeness of Earnings Announcements in the Pre- and Post-Sarbanes Oxley Periods * Daniel A. Cohen Aiyesha Dey Thomas Z. Lys ** Kellogg School of Management Northwestern
More information