New York Efficiency & Competitiveness: Findings Presentation to the New York State Commission on Local Government Efficiency & Competitiveness By Wendell Cox - 18 February 2008 State Capital Albany
ASSUMPTIONS Larger local governments are more efficient Consolidated local governments are more efficient High property taxes are local government s fault Larger governments encourage greater economic growth Smart growth & regional planning improve competitiveness
Domestic Migration Losses: New York EXCEEDS KATRINA HIT LOUISIANA: 2000-2007 20% Domestic Migration/2000 Population 15% 10% 5% 0% -5% -10% PER IRS: Net Personal Income Loss $27 Billion (2006)
New York Competitiveness 2 PRINCIPAL ISSUES (PROBLEMS) High Taxes High Cost of Living Albany
New York City (from NJ) Local Government Consolidation: Actual, not Theoretical Experience
Toronto s Costly Consolidation HIGHER COSTS, PROMISED SAVINGS NOT ACHIEVED the harmonization of wages and service levels has resulted in higher costs for the new City. We will all continue to feel these higher costs in the future. Toronto City Summit Alliance 2003
Toronto s Costly Consolidation HIGHEST AND WORST IMPACTS OF CONSOLIDATION Leveling up of service levels Leveling up of labor contracts ( highest and worst )
Power Shift: People to Special Interests LARGER GOVERNMENTS. V. LOCAL DEMOCRACY IMPACTS OF CONSOLIDATION Loss of local democracy Voter control is diluted Economies of scale for special interests
Average Local Jurisdiction Population NEW YORK AND ALL STATES 70,000 Average Jurisdiction Population 60,000 50,000 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0
Per Capita Taxation & Jurisdiction Size NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $7,000 $6,000 Taxation per Capita $5,000 $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 Average Jurisdiction Population
Per Capita Taxation & Jurisdiction Size NEW YORK & 10 LARGEST STATES 7,000 6,000 Taxation per Capita 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 Average Jurisdiction Population
Government Efficiency in New York Alfred E. Smith State Office Building Albany
$6,000 $5,000 NY: Highest State & Local Taxes NEW YORK & OTHER STATES Taxation per Capita $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0
NY: Higher Taxes NEW YORK &10 LARGEST STATES $6,000 $5,000 Taxation per Capita $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0 CA FL GA IL MI NC NY OH PA TX
NY: High Federal Revenue per Capita NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $6,000 Revenue per Capita $5,000 $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0
NY: High State & Local Debt per Capita NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $14,000 $12,000 Debt per Capita $10,000 $8,000 $6,000 $4,000 $2,000 $0
NY: High Wages & Salaries per Capita NEW YORK & OTHER STATES Wages & Salaries per Capita $4,000 $3,500 $3,000 $2,500 $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0 Note: New York fringe benefits average 39% more than national average (not shown here)
$4,000 Government Wages & Salaries 10 LARGEST STATES Wages & Salaries per Capita $3,500 $3,000 $2,500 $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0 CA FL GA IL MI NC NY OH PA TX
NY: High Education Expenditures NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $16,000 $14,000 Spending per Pupil $12,000 $10,000 $8,000 $6,000 $4,000 $2,000 $0
$16,000 NY: High Education Expenditures NEW YORK & 10 LARGEST STATES Spending per Pupil $14,000 $12,000 $10,000 $8,000 $6,000 $4,000 $2,000 $0 CA FL GA IL MI NY NC OH PA TX
NY: High Public Welfare Spending NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $2,500 Spending per Capita $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0
$2,500 NY: High Public Welfare Spending NEW YORK & 10 LARGEST STATES Spending per Capita $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0 CA FL GA IL MI NC NY OH PA TX
Reconciling New York s Spending COMPARED TO AVERGE OF OTHER STATES State & Local Expenditures per Capita $10,000 $9,000 $8,000 $7,000 $6,000 $5,000 $4,000 $3,000 $2,000 $1,000 $0 New York Other State Average NY Excess: Interest NY Excess: Welfare NY Excess: Education NY Excess: Personnel Other Spending Note: Personnel Expense excludes Education & Welfare
Local Government Efficiency in New York City Hall Albany
Local Government Efficiency Analysis DATA FROM STATE COMPTROLLER All Local Governments: Cities, Towns Villages & Fire Districts by City by Town Areas: (Towns, Villages & Fire Districts) SERVICES INCLUDED General Government Police Fire Other Public Safety Health Transportation Culture & Recreation (More than 90% of non-utility spending) Per capita spending: 2005 All fully reporting governments Analyzed by average jurisdiction size
Spending Lower in Smaller Jurisdictions MUNICIPAL SPENDING PER CAPITA $1,500 Local Expenditures per Capita $1,250 $1,000 $750 $500 $250 $0 Over 100,000 50,000-100,000 25,000-50,000 10,000-25,000 5,000-10,000 Average Jurisdiction Population 2,500-5,000 1,000-2,500 Under 1,000
Spending Lower in Smaller Jurisdictions MUNICIPAL SPENDING IN METROPOLITAN AREAS $1,500 Local Expenditures per Capita $1,250 $1,000 $750 $500 $250 $0 Over 100,000 50,000-100,000 25,000-50,000 10,000-25,000 5,000-10,000 Average Jurisdiction Population 2,500-5,000 1,000-2,500 Under 1,000
Town/Village/Fire Spending Lower IN ALL METROPOLITAN AREAS Local Expenditures per Capita $1,600 $1,400 $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $0 Albany Binghamton Buffalo Elmira Glens Falls Ithaca Kingston New York Poughkeepsie Rochester Syracuse Utica
Debt Lower in Smaller Jurisdictions MUNICIPAL DEBT PER CAPITA $2,250 $2,000 $1,750 Debt per Capita $1,500 $1,250 $1,000 $750 $500 $250 $0 Over 100,000 50,000-100,000 25,000-50,000 10,000-25,000 5,000-10,000 Average Jurisdiction Population 2,500-5,000 1,000-2,500 Under 1,000
Spending Lower in Smaller Jurisdictions FIRE SPENDING PER CAPITA $300 Local Expenditures per Capita $250 $200 $150 $100 $50 $0 Over 100,000 50,000-100,000 25,000-50,000 10,000-25,000 5,000-10,000 2,500-5,000 Average Jurisdiction Population 1,000-2,500 Under 1,000
Smaller Units of Govt. More Efficient SUMMARY OF FINDINGS Average Jurisdiction Population Factor Over 100,000 50,000-100,000 25,000-50,000 10,000-25,000 5,000-10,000 2,500-5,000 1,000-2,500 Under 1,000 Expenditures per Capita $1,323 $1,213 $944 $806 $709 $602 $545 $773 Expenditures per Capita: Metropolitan Areas $1,323 $1,213 $1,044 $794 $677 $562 $514 $697 Debt per Capita $2,001 $1,054 $1,060 $815 $736 $652 $483 $416 Fire Expenditures per Capita $295 $263 $167 $120 $52 $35 $31 $37
Employment Growth & Jurisdiction Size FROST BELT METROPOLITAN AREAS 70% 60% Employment Growth 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 Average General Government Population
Concern about Property Taxes New York Suburbs
NY: High Property Taxes NEW YORK & OTHER STATES $2,500 $2,000 Per Capita $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0
NY: High Property Taxes NEW YORK & 10 LARGEST STATES $2,000 $1,500 Per Capita $1,000 $500 $0 CA FL GA IL MI NC NY OH PA TX
New York: Relies Most on Local Govt. LOCAL SHARE OF STATE & LOCAL TAXATION 60% Local Share of State & Local Taxation 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
NY: High Local Public Welfare Spending PER CAPITA BY STATE $600 Local Expenditures per Capita $500 $400 $300 $200 $100 $0
Government Employee Compensation NEW YORK & OTHER STATES: CHANGE 1965-2005 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% PERSONNEL EXPENSE 71.7% New York Other States 0% Compensation per Employee: Inflation Adjusted 1965 2005
Long Island & Northern Virginia Study THE DIFFERENCE IS PERSONNEL $5,000 Local Expenditures per Capita $4,500 $4,000 $3,500 $3,000 $2,500 $2,000 $1,500 $1,000 $500 $0 Long Island Northern Virginia Personnel Other Spending Note: Assumes national fringe benefit rate (understates New York personnel costs) Center for Governmental Research study
Expenditures per Capita in Context TOWNS/VILLAGES & NY STATE & LOCAL Index 2.00 1.80 1.60 1.40 1.20 1.00 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 0.00 NATIONAL AVERAGE NEW YORK State & Local NATIONAL LOCAL GOVT. NEW YORK TOWNS/ VILLAGES Local Core Services
Prospects: Proposed Consolidations BUFFALO SYRACUSE - BINGHAMTON Leveling up of employee wages and benefits is likely to raise costs and taxes. Leveling up of service levels is likely to raise spending and taxes. The likely outcome: Less competitive urban areas.
Smart Growth, Competitiveness and the Cost of Living Hudson Valley
Democratization of Prosperity ASSOCIATED WITH HOME OWNERSHIP Levittown 70% 40% 2005 1940 THE AMERICAN DREAM Nassau County Roots
Smart Growth & Housing Affordability TYPICAL CONTEXT: REGIONAL PLANNING Strategy Potential to Increase Housing Prices 1 Regional Urban Growth Boundaries YES 2 Local Urban Growth Boundaries YES 3 Regional Urban Service Districts YES 4 Local Urban Service Districts YES 5 Large-Lot Zoning in Rural Areas YES 6 High Development Fees & Exactions YES 7 Restrictions on Physically Developable Land YES 8 State Aid Contingent on Local Growth Zones 9 Transferable Development Rights 10 Adequacy of Facilities Requirements From Table 15.4, Costs of Sprawl---2000 Potential to Increase Housing Prices from Costs of Sprawl---2000
Paul Krugman: New York Times THE ZONED ZONE
Unprecedented Affordability Loss 10 LARGEST US MARKETS: 2000 & 2006 12.0 10.5 9.0 7.5 6.0 4.5 3.0 1.5 0.0 PRESCRIPTIVE (SMART GROWTH) MEDIAN MULTIPLE: Median House Price Divided by Median Household Income MIXED RESPONSIVE NY LA MIA WDC CHI PHI HOU DFW ATL DET
80% Home Ownership by Ethnicity: 2005 LARGE GAP: 45 YEARS AFTER MLK I HAVE A DREAM 60% 40% 20% 0% White-Non-Hispanic African-American Hispanic 48
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Median Multiple: New York MAJOR METROPOLITAN AREAS New York Buffalo Rochester Albany Syracuse
House Cost & Financing Trend MAJOR NEW YORK MARKETS: 2000-2006 $500,000 $450,000 $400,000 $350,000 $300,000 $250,000 $200,000 $150,000 $100,000 $50,000 $0 Change in Median House Price & Mortgage Cost NY Metro Buffalo Rochester Albany Syracuse
Net Domestic Migration: 2000-2006 RUST BELT & POST-WAR COMPETITIVE AREAS 2% 0% -2% DET PGH CLV BUF ROC ALB SYR NY SD LA SF SJose -4% -6% -8% -10% -12% -14%
Conclusions Empire State Plaza Albany
Conclusions Local government consolidation is likely to lead to a less competitive New York, by raising taxes. Smart growth is likely to lead to a less competitive New York, by raising housing costs and the cost of living.