Monetary Policy and the Stability of the Banking Systems in the Countries of the Region - A Decade After the Lehman Brothers Bankruptcy Maja Kadievska Vojnovikj Vice Governor Sector of Financial Market Operations and Payment Systems National Bank of the Republic of Macedonia Summit of National Bank Governors, Finance Ministers and Tax Administration Directors of the Region Becici, Montenegro, June 14-16, 218
25 26 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 26 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 Economic developments Growth is strengthening and broadening across Europe 217 marked by widest dispersed growth between countries since 21 Region is following gradual recovery after the crisis Slowdown in growth in 217 due to weaker growth in Macedonia (prolonged political crisis) and Serbia (extreme weather conditions severe winter and summer drought) 8 6 4 2-2 Real GDP growth, y-o-y, in % 16 14 12 1 8 6 4 2 1 8 6 Real GDP, 217 (as compared to pre-crisis GDP level, 27=1) Region average ALB BiH HRV KOS MKD MNE SRB Real GDP growth y-o-y, in % -4 4 2-6 -2 EU World Region - average -4-6 -8-1 Source: IMF WEO, April 218 Region average ALB BiH HRV KOS MKD MNE SRB
26 27 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 I.28 I.29 I.21 I.211 I.212 I.213 I.214 I.215 I.216 I.217 I.218 Monetary policy and inflation Headline inflation has picked up, reflecting stronger fuel prices, but core inflation remains soft Inflation rose in most of the region led by food and energy prices Monetary policy remains accommodative in support to economic growth......as currencies appreciate in inflation targeting countries 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 Headline inflation y-o-y average, in % 2 18 16 14 12 1 8 6 Policy rates (in %) MKD ECB ALB SRB 1 4 2-1 EU World Region average Source: IMF WEO, April 218 Source: central banks web sites.
External sector developments...supported by shrinking external imbalances following GFC, with some economies replacing large CA deficit with small surpluses Capital inflows continued, albeit at decelerated pace across the region Low yields in EA enable capital inflows in 216-217 5 Current account balance (in % of GDP) 7 6 Financing gap (in % of GDP) positive: financing >CA deficit 5-5 4-1 3-15 2-2 -25-3 -35-4 ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB 1-1 -2-3 ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB 217 25-28 29-212 213-216 217 25-28 29-212 213-216 Source: central banks web sites.
28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 Capital flows Financial inflows mainly in the form of FDIs as more stable component Incurrence of portfolio liabilities supported by Government financing abroad 3 25 Net financial flows, in % of GDP 2 15 1 5-5 -1-15 ALB HRV KOS MKD MNE SRB FDI PI Other invs. Source: central banks web sites.
Capital flows By creditor, significant reliance on EU developments, as EU creditors are largest Significant share of external liabilities denominated in euros, which posses risk when ECB starts to reduce the extent of monetary accommodation Composition of external liabilities (% of GDP, end 215) 14 By instrument 14 By creditor 14 By currency 12 1 8 6 4 2 11 11 32 68 16 8 11 7 11 11 6 62 12 1 8 6 4 2 26 6 18 72 16 3 17 62 29 4 13 42 12 1 8 6 4 2 15 4 8 59 5 2 42 42 11 9 4 35 CEE SEE EU SEE non EU CEE SEE EU SEE non EU CEE SEE EU SEE non EU Cross border lending to non-banks Cross border interbank funding Euro area other EU US RoW Euro US dollar domestic Other Portfolio investment FDI and intercompany lending Source: IMF, CESEE REI Spring 217
1/216 3/216 5/216 7/216 9/216 11/216 1/217 3/217 5/217 7/217 9/217 11/217 1/218 3/218 5/218 Fiscal sector developments Ultra loose monetary policy of major central banks enabled favorable conditions for Government borrowing on international markets 6 Yield spreads on Eurobonds* (in p.p.) Country Eurobonds issued beginning from 29 Maturity Coupon Albania 215-45 EUR mil. 22 5.75% Serbia 211-2. USD mil. 221 7.25% 213-1. USD mil. and 1.5 USD mil. 218 and 22, respectively 5.875% and 4.875%, respectively 29-1.5 USD mil. 219 6.75% 21-1.25 USD mil. 22 6.625% 5 4 3 2 Croatia 211-75 EUR mil. and 1.15 USD mil. 213-1.5 USD mil. and 1.75 USD mil. 218 and 221, respectively 223 and 224, respectively 5.875% and 6.375%, respectively 5.5% and 6.%, respectively 214-1.25 EUR mil. 222 3.875% 215-1.15 EUR mil. 225 3.% 1 217-1.25 EUR mil. and 1.275 EUR mil. 227 and 23, respectively 3.% and 2.75%, respectively ALB SRB CRO MNE MKD * Spreads are calculated in regard to German government bonds with similar maturity, except for Serbia that issues securities in US dollar, so spread is made in regard to US government securities Montenegro Macedonia Source: Bloomberg 218-75 EUR mil. 228 2.7% 214-28 EUR mil. 219 5.375% 215-5 EUR mil. 22 3.875% 216-3 EUR mil. 221 5.75% 218-5 EUR mil. 225 3.375% 214-5 EUR mil. 221 3.975% 215-27 EUR mil. 22 4.875% 216-45 EUR mil. 223 5.625% 218-5 EUR mil. 225 2.75%
Fiscal sector developments Fiscal consolidation is broadly on the way across the region Gradual winding down of fiscal stimulus as economies recover Public debt growth sustained at a slower pace in recent period Still, the level of public debt remains elevated in some countries 4. Fiscal balance, in % of GDP 1 Gross public debt, change in pp of GDP 3. 8 2. 1. 6. 4-1. 2-2. -3. -2-4. -5. -4 ALB BiH HRV KOS MKD MNE SRB -6. ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB 217- Stock of GPD, in % of GDP 28/25 212/28 216/212 25-28 29-212 213-216 217 Source: IMF WEO data base, April 218, MoF s and central banks web sites.
Banking sector developments Banking systems broadly stable across the region, but still reeling from the boombust cycle Ample foreign parent banks financing pre crisis that fueled credit boom Sudden stop in foreign financing post crisis with credit entering a bust cycle To Peak Foreign bank funding to all sectors (% of GDP) Post crisis 25 Leveraging and Deleveraging episodes 2 15 1 5-5 -1-15 -2 NMS (21-28- 214) WB (21-28- 214) Crisis Asia (1989-1997- 25) Latam (1977-1982- 1995) Source: IMF, Regional Economic Outlook: Europe, Nov. 217 Decrease in foregin bank funding, all sectors, % of GDP) Increase in foregin bank funding, all sectors, % of GDP) *Western Balkans refers to: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, Macedonia, Montenegro and Serbia.
28 29 21 211 212 213 214 215 Banking sector developments EU-owned banks experienced the sharpest falls Gradual stabilization in foreign funding flows in recent years, but still far below pre-crisis levels 35 3 Western Balkans: Bank credit growth by ownership (in %) External bank claims on WB (% of GDP, all sectors) 25 2 15 1 5-5 Domestic Foreign-EU Foreign-non EU Source: IMF, Regional Economic Outlook: Europe, Nov. 217
Banking sector developments NPL ratios are declining and NPL coverage ratios are improving All countries in the region are witnessing drop in NPL in recent years In 217 no country recorded NPL ratio above 15% NPL ratio, coverage ratio and volume (%, EUR bn, September 217) Source: NPL Monitor for the CESEE region H1 218
Banking sector developments NPLs improvement comes after the peak in the burst of the crisis GFC resulted in drop in profitability, which is also improving in recent times Capital positions remained sound and broadly stable NPLs in % of total credit ROA, in % CAR, in % 25 2.5 25 2 2 1.5 2 15 1.5 15 1 -.5 1 5-1 5-1.5 ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB -2 ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB ALB BiH HRV MKD MNE SRB 217 25-28 217 25-28 217 25-28 29-212 213-216 29-212 213-216 29-212 213-216 Source: central bank web sites.
Banking sector developments Reduction in NPLs was supported by NPL resolution measures and strategies implemented in the region Albania and Serbia implemented comprehensive strategies covering banking supervision, tax issues, court procedures and legal aspects Macedonia with relatively lower NPLs in regional comparison measure for mandatory write-off of loans that were fully provisioned for more than 2 years; Draft NPL resolution strategy Albania- NPL, in % of total loans Serbia- NPL, in % of total loans Macedonia - NPL, in % of total loans Source: IMF, Regional Economic Outlook: Europe, Nov. 217
Banking sector developments Credit growth has improved in recent years, but still remains timid across the region Credit to GDP ratios still below levels predicted by fundamentals Financial intermediation levels in the region are relatively low compared to other CESEE countries Estimated credit gaps in 216 (Actual minus fundamentals consistent level of private credit in % of GDP) Source: IMF, Regional Economic Outlook: Europe, Nov. 217 and central bank web sites. Emerging Europe: Financial Depth, in % of GDP, 216 Bank credit to the private sector Bank assets
Banking sector developments Going forward, expanding the funding base is important factor for bolstering credit intermediation Foreign banks see limited prospects in the region Region is under significant indirect effects from EU regulatory changes via dominance of foreign subsidiaries Stable deposit growth has mitigated decline in foreign funding post crisis however, further growth is constrained by region s low savings level and low interest rates Group level response of long term strategies in CESEE (in %) Source: CESEE deleveraging and credit monitor, June 218, IMF WEO data base, April 218 and central banks web sites..
Banking sector developments The latest EIB Survey points to some positive developments Total exposure to the region is trending positively over the past six months, for the first time since starting the survey (213) - fifth of banking groups have reduced their exposure and 3% have increased their exposure to CESEE resulting in positive aggregate net balance Groups total exposure to CESEE : Cross border operations involving CESEE countries Comprehensive NPL strategies in countries with still high NPL levels and structural reforms (sound bankruptcy and insolvency regimes, strengthening property rights protection and judiciary systems) could also support faster recovery in credit growth in the period ahead
IMF role in the region Supporting structural reforming programs Shielding against potential risks and vulnerabilities Safeguarding macroeconomic and financial stability IMF Supporting economic growth Improving fiscal health and public debt sustainability
IMF arrangements in the region following GFC IMF role in the region
Regional cooperation among central banks MoU for cooperation and exchange of information Study visits in the area of accounting- IFRS, numismatic collections acquisitions, curating Study visits in the area of payment systems, statistics, banking regulation, supervision and research MoU for business cooperation Study visits in the area of supervision, IT, library and archiving, public procurement, security Study visits in the area of FX reserves management and SAA MoU for cooperation Study visits in the area of IT, public relations and EU financed projects MoU for business cooperation Study visits in the area of monetary operations and FX reserves management, accounting, documenting and archiving, public procurement and security
Going forward Regional Outlook Generally positive growth outlook Externally, main risks related to EU recovery and developments with rising protectionism Domestically, political uncertainty may cloud growth prospects if upcoming elections in several countries lead to a slower pace of structural reforms Low and stagnant productivity may hamper region s growth potential Productivity Source: World Bank Western Balkans RER, Spring 218. Fiscal consolidations will reduce fiscal risks and ensure fiscal space to support growth enhancing reforms and investments Advancement in structural reforms to reduce labor market rigidities and promote private sector development
Going forward main challenges and uncertainties GEO-POLITICAL ECONOMICS GLOBAL FINANCIAL MARKETS FINTECH ADOPTION EU AND EURO AREA Geo-political development Global banking landscape and FDI Payment systems evolution EU enlargement appetite Economic growth path Capital markets Financial service innovation EU and EA consolidation Centers of gravity for the global economy Trade patterns and rising protectionism Banking regulation Monetary dynamics ECB MP normalization Energy commodity markets/prices Sovereign debt markets
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION! http://www.nbrm.mk https://www.facebook.com/nbrmkd https://twitter.com/narodna_banka