BOARD OF TRUSTEES BUFFALO & ERIE COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY MEETING DATE: June 12, 2014

Similar documents
CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY OF THE NEW YORK STATE WEST YOUTH SOCCER ASSOCIATION, INC. (ADOPTED ON THE 17th DAY OF February, 2016)

RAMAPO CATSKILL LIBRARY SYSTEM BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING MARCH 16, 2015 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR S SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT

Conflict of Interest Policy

( CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

Conflict of Interest Policy for Trustees, Officers and Key Employees

Conflict of Interest Policy

Conflict of Interest Policy

Conflict of Interest Policy. Institute for Middle East Understanding (the Organization ) Article One Purpose

, INC. Conflict of Interest Policy

Delaware State University

Article I - Purpose. Article II - Definitions

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

YMCA OF GREATER TRI-VALLEY CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

NOTE REGARDING THE SAMPLE DOCUMENTS: This sample document is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or counsel.

Washington Youth Soccer. Conflict of Interest Policy. Article I Purpose

Policy and Procedure. McMinnville Free Clinic

CUSTER AREA ARTS COUNCIL. CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY 1 and ANNUAL STATEMENT

Maple Valley-Anthon Oto Foundation Conflict of Interest Policy. Article I Purpose

Durango Arts Center Conflict of Interest Policy and Annual Statement

The Louisiana Chapter American Institute of Architects Conflict of Interest Policy (Adopted )

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY MEN S HEALTH ARKIVE, INC. ARTICLE I PURPOSE ARTICLE II DEFINITIONS

Conflict of Interest Policy

For Directors and Officers and Members of a Committee with Board Delegated Powers

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY OF THE UNITED STATES LACTATION CONSULTANT ASSOCIATION, INC.

Conflict of interest. Addendum to Bylaws of the Pro-Life Action League

Conflict of Interest Policy

THE D.C. CENTRAL KITCHEN, INC. CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

The GOD S CHILD Project Conflict of Interest Policy For Directors and Officers and Members of a Committee with Board-Delegated Powers

Conflict of Interest Policy. And. Annual Statement

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY OF BOROUGH OF MANHATTAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION, INC.

CONFLICT-OF-INTEREST POLICIES: DISCLOSURE, MONITORING, AND ENFORCEMENT

Mountain Song Community School Conflict of Interest Policy

Community Foundation of St. Clair County Conflict of Interest Policy

Nonprofit Governance and Management, Third Edition

Forever Young Foundation (FYF) Conflict of Interest Policy And Annual Statement

Conflict of Interest Policy The Cooperative Foundation

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

Constitution Review Committee 07/06/2011

Pine-Richland Unified Booster Organization Conflict of Interest

BUTLER HEALTH SYSTEM CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

MOUNT SINAI JEWISH CENTER CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

Conflict of Interest Statement For American Baptist Homes of the West And its Affiliated Entities

Conflict of Interest Policy of the Blair Historic Preservation Alliance

FORENSIC SPECIALTIES ACCREDITATION BOARD

Conflict of Interest Policy: Utah Council for Citizen Diplomacy (UCCD)

Conflict of Interest Policy and Procedures of the Columbus Family YMCA

YMCA OF DELAWARE CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY AND PROCEDURES

WASHINGTON STATE RECYCLING ASSOCIATION CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY ARTICLE 1. PURPOSE

Conflict of Interest Policy for Officers and Trustees

YALE CHINA ASSOCIATION, INC. Conflict of Interest Policy

MISSOURI EVERGREEN A MISSOURI NONPROFIT CORPORATION RESOLUTION ADOPTING CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

American Platform Tennis Association, Inc. Conflict of Interest Policy

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

THE DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION OF THE NORTH CAROLINA CENTER FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF TEACHING CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

Conflict of Interest Policy

I. Purpose. Policy Definitions

Wounded Warrior Project, Inc. Conflict of Interest and Related Party Transaction Policy

Conflict of Interest Policy Revised Effective: July 23, 2011 Page 1 of 5

SAMPLE POLICY [NAME OF ORGANIZATION] CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AND DOCUMENTATION POLICY. Scope. Purpose. Policy

SAMPLE Board Member Conflict of Interests Disclosure Form

SAMPLE Org. Conflict of Interest Policy & Annual Form

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY F O R GRA YHA WK EL E ME NT A RY S CHO OL PTO

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY ARTICLE I PURPOSE AND POLICY

WSA Conflict of Interest Policy

[NAME OF CHARTER SCHOOL] CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY ARTICLE I PURPOSE

Publishers International Linking Association, Inc. (PILA) Conflict of Interest Policy for Directors, Officers and Key Employees

XYZ Health System Policy

UNANIMOUS WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF NAPA VALLEY COLLEGE VITICULTURE AND WINERY TECHNOLOGY FOUNDATION

Section 1: Name: The name of the organization is Long Beach ALIVE (ALIVE is an acronym for Alternatives to Living In a Violent Environment).

DeWitt Community Library Association (DCLA) Conflicts of Interest Policy

Riverwood Healthcare Center Policy and Procedure

SAFARI CLUB INTERNATIONAL

ST. CLAIR COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES Minutes of Regular Meeting Held August 13, 2015

Conflict of Interest Policy Packet

NEW YORK EHEALTH COLLABORATIVE, Inc. POLICY ON CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND DISCLOSURE

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

disability Law Center of Virginia

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY. Article I: Purpose. Article II: Definitions

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY updated 10/15/2015

UMass Amherst Alumni Association

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY OF THE CORDAID FOUNDATION

New York Battery and Energy Storage Technology Consortium CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY FOR THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE AMERICAN NATIONAL STANDARDS INSTITUTE ( ANSI )

Unitarian Universalist Church of Annapolis Conflict of Interest Policy

EAST OF HUDSON WATERSHED CORPORATION CODE OF ETHICS January 9, 2018

PHA Policy on Conflict of Interest

The Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, Inc.

ANAHEIM RESORT TRANSPORTATION CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY

Board of Directors Nomination and Application. Class of 2022

Last Revised Next Review

CHAPTER XI FINANCE. Approvals required for making investment decisions, other than those stated in the investment policy statements, are as follows:

Conflicts of Interests and Charter Schools By Eric V. Hall

RADFORD UNIVERSITY FOUNDATION, INCORPORATED. Conflicts of Interests Policy

Resolution to adopt Conflicts of Interest Policy for the GCOOS-RA Corporation

Conflict of Interest Policy

Foundation for the National Institutes of Health CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY for THE BIOMARKERS CONSORTIUM

CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY COMPASSPOINT

Transcription:

BOARD OF TRUSTEES BUFFALO & ERIE COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY MEETING DATE: June 12, 2014 AGENDA ITEM NUMBER: E.4.b. Resolution: 2014-14 B&ECPL Conflict of Interest Policy (to supersede current Conflict of Interest & Ethics Policy) BACKGROUND: The Buffalo & Erie County Public Library s (B&ECPL) Board of Trustees adopted a Conflict of Interest & Ethics Policy on September 16, 2010 which had superseded the Code of Ethics adopted on March 16, 2006. B&ECPL legal counsel Patrick Martin was asked to review and update the current policy to be in compliance with the provisions required by the New York State Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013 (Act). Counsel recommended the current policy be separated and become two stand-alone policies (separate Conflict of Interest Policy and separate Ethics Policy) and has included all the provisions required by the Act in the two proposed policies. The NYS Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013 requires all New York State Not-for- Profit Corporations to adopt a written Conflict of Interest Policy. The Act also revises the concept of "interested directors/trustees" and replaces this concept with "related party transactions." The purpose of these changes is to enhance transparency and accountability in non-profits by ensuring that boards and/or board committees undertake an independent review of the transactions between the organization and persons affiliated with the organization. A draft of the new Conflict of Interest Policy, along with a summary document of required changes, was included with the agenda items for review. In addition, to comply with the New York State Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013, the proposed Governance Committee (formerly the Bylaws Committee) shall oversee the Conflict of Interest Policy. This policy affects the Central Library and Buffalo branch libraries, over which the B&ECPL Board of Trustees exercises statutory authority. Contract Libraries will be instructed to adopt their own Conflict of Interest Policy to comply with the Act. The Policy Committee and the Bylaws Committee have reviewed the changes and recommend the proposed Conflict of Interest Policy for approval by the full Board. ACTION REQUIRED: Motion to adopt Resolution 2014-14.

PROPOSED RESOLUTION 2014-14 WHEREAS, Buffalo & Erie County Public Library (B&ECPL) legal counsel Patrick Martin has reviewed and updated the current Conflict of Interest & Ethics Policy to be in compliance with the provisions required by the New York State Non- Profit Revitalization Act of 2013 (Act), and WHEREAS, legal counsel recommends the current policy becomes two separate stand-alone policies (separate Conflict of Interest Policy and separate Ethics Policy) which include all the provisions required by the New York State Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013, now therefore be it RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library adopts the proposed Conflict of Interest Policy (attached) to supersede and replace the prevailing Conflict of Interest and Ethics Policy last adopted September 16, 2014, and be it further RESOLVED, the Conflict of Interest Policy be overseen by the Governance (formerly Bylaws) Committee, and be it finally RESOLVED, that each Contracting Library Board be instructed to adopt their own Conflict of Interest Policy that is in compliance with the New York State Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013.

To: Mary Jean Jakubowski, Library Director From: Attorneys Patrick Martin, Nicole Tzetzo and Lauren Fish Date: May 20, 2014 Pursuant to our discussions, attached please find a copy of the revised proposed amendments to the Bylaws, a draft Conflict of Interest Policy and draft Whistleblower Policy, and proposed amendments to the Ethics Policy. For your convenience, we have also included a markup version of each which illustrates the provisions removed and inserted. Below is a brief explanation of each proposed substantive change to the Bylaws and each proposed policy. Except as otherwise stated, each change should be made effective no later than July 1, 2014. We would be happy to discuss any additional questions, comments, or concerns you have regarding the proposed amendments. 1. Amended and Restated Bylaws. As you are aware, the NYS Non-Profit Revitalization Act of 2013 has permitted some new provisions and has provided clarification on some issues. Since the Library is a unique entity governed by its enabling statute, we have included only those provisions that are applicable/permissible for the Library. In addition, the Non-Profit Revitalization Act requires all organizations to have a Conflict of Interest Policy, while your Bylaws referenced some provisions, we removed these clauses and have included all of the necessary language in a separate policy, which is attached. We did include reference in the Bylaws that all Trustees must abide by the Policy. The amended changes are as follows: a) Article III, Paragraph 3. The Non-Profit Revitalization Act enacted a provision prohibiting any employee of a non-profit from serving as Chairperson of the Board or any similarly equivalent position, effective July 1, 2015. The purpose for this amendment was to promote clear lines of accountability between management and the Board and to ensure independent Board leadership. b) Article V. Committees/Composition & Authority. (i.) (ii.) The current Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (NFPCL) distinguishes between standing and special committees. The Non-Profit Revitalization Act seeks to simplify the classification of board committees by eliminating this distinction and clarifying what committees can bind the board. Therefore, you will see that we have removed reference to "standing committees." The Non-Profit Revitalization Act made significant changes to the NFPCL by requiring an Audit Committee for certain organizations. The Act also requires that the Audit Committee consist of directors or trustees who qualify as "independent directors/trustees," as defined in the Act. The Act specifies the

responsibilities of the Audit Committee, including various aspects of the annual audit of the organization's financial statements. The purpose of this new requirement was to ensure that independent persons are aware of, and respond to, issues and risks identified by auditors and are monitoring the organization's internal controls (Conflict of Interest Policy and Whistleblower Policy). While the Library is not technically required to include an Audit Committee, a committee of independent directors/trustees is required to oversee the Conflict of Interest and Whistleblower Policies; therefore, we have included a Governance Committee to fulfill these requirements. Although the Library does not technically meet the requirements which would mandate an Audit Committee, these provisions of the Non-Profit Revitalization Act are best practices that should be considered and incorporated to the extent feasible and consideration should be given to including additional duties for the Budget and Finance Committee. c) Article V, Paragraph 6. Governance Committee. As discussed above, the Non-Profit Revitalization Act requires all New York not-for-profit organizations to have a Conflict of Interest Policy and certain larger organizations such as the Library must have a Whistleblower Policy. The Act specifies that the Audit Committee or a committee of "independent directors/trustees" as defined in the Act must oversee these policies. The independence requirement is relevant just for committee composition, not for full Board membership, and independent trustees are still full Board members. We include the explicit requirement that each Committee member, including the Chairperson, qualifies as an "Independent Trustee." The definition of "Independent Trustee" and related definitions are also included, mirroring the definitions set forth in the Non-Profit Revitalization Act. Note that the Act does not define "Substantial Financial Interest." However, we have included a definition in the proposed amendments which gives the Board the discretion to determine what constitutes a "Substantial Financial Interest." We have included these definitions directly within the Bylaws to ensure awareness and transparency as to the criteria required and the expectations of the Governance & Compliance Committee. 2. Conflict of Interest Policy. The Non-Profit Revitalization Act requires all New York not-for-profit corporations to adopt a written Conflict of Interest Policy. The Act also revises the concept of "interested directors/trustees" and replaces this concept with "related party transactions." The purpose of these changes is to enhance transparency and accountability in non-profits by ensuring that boards and/or board committees undertake an independent review of the transactions between the organization and persons affiliated with the organization. The Act sets forth certain particular requirements for the Policy, including the following: a) A definition of conflicts; 2

b) Procedures for disclosure to an Audit Committee, or if no Audit Committee exists, to the board; c) A requirement that any conflicted person be recused from deliberations and voting on the subject; d) Prohibition against the conflicted person attempting to improperly influence deliberations or voting on the subject; e) Documentation of conflict situations, including in minutes of any meetings where discussed; f) Special procedures for disclosing and handling related-party transactions; g) Written disclosure of potential conflicts, including involvement with any entity with which the corporation has a relationship and interest in any transaction in which the corporation is a participant, by all directors prior to election and annually thereafter; and h) Written disclosures are to be submitted to the secretary, who must provide copies to the Chair of the Audit Committee, or if none exists, the Chair of the Board. In addition, the Conflict of Interest Policy must include procedures for disclosing, addressing, and documenting related party transactions. A related party is defined as any director, officer or key employee of the organization or an affiliate, any relative of such individual, and any entity in which any such individual or relative has a 35% or greater ownership or beneficial interest or, in the case of a partnership or professional corporation, a direct or indirect ownership interest in excess of 5%. A related party transaction means any transaction, agreement or any other arrangement in which a related party has an interest and in which the Library or affiliate is a participant. Ultimately, the Board may enter into a related party transaction only if the Board determines and documents that the transaction is fair, reasonable, and in the Library's best interest. For any related party transactions involving a substantial financial interest, additional procedures will be required. The document the Library provided with respect to the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Policy does not meet a lot of the provisions required by the Act. We have deleted the conflict language from your policy and left that as a stand-alone Ethics Policy and have provided a comprehensive Conflict of Interest Policy, which includes all of the provisions required by the Act. 3. Ethics Policy. As discussed above, we have deleted the conflict of interest language from this policy and left it as a stand-alone Ethics Policy. Please note that we have replaced the term "officials" and "Senior level employees" with the term "Key Employees" as defined in the proposed Bylaws. The terms "officials" and "Senior level employees" are not defined elsewhere, 3

but seem to be intended to encompass those persons which would qualify as "Key Employees." Therefore, we propose this change so that the governing documents of the Library are consistent. Additionally, because the Library Director constitutes a "Key Employee" just as senior level employees likely do, we have proposed that the Governance Committee consult with the Library Director regarding discipline or termination of Key Employees who are not acting in accordance with the Ethics Policy as appropriate. 4. Whistleblower Policy The Non-Profit Revitalization Act requires non-profits with more than 20 employees and more than $1 million in annual revenue to adopt and implement a Whistleblower Policy and requires the policy include certain procedures. You have provided us with a draft Whistleblower Policy under consideration by the Board and this draft Policy generally satisfies the requirements imposed by the Act. As with the Conflict of Interest Policy, a committee of independent trustees must oversee the adoption and implementation of the Whistleblower Policy. Therefore, we have modified the draft policy to provide that the proposed Governance Committee oversee the policy and investigation, rather than the Executive Committee. Additionally we have added a few provisions to enhance the procedural aspects of the draft policy. We have included a Reporting Form as Appendix A. This is substantially similar to the draft form previously provided. However, in accordance with the proposed changes to the Policy & the Bylaws, we removed reference to the System Director and indicate that the form should be submitted to the Chair of the Governance Committee. 4

DRAFT CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY ARTICLE I Purpose The purpose of this Conflict of Interest Policy is to protect the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library when it is contemplating entering into a transaction or arrangement that might benefit the private interest of an officer, trustee, or Key Employee of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library. It provides guidelines for handling perceived, potential or actual Conflicts of Interest and addresses procedures and disclosures of Related Party Transactions. This policy is intended to supplement but not replace any applicable state and federal laws governing Conflict of Interest applicable to nonprofit and charitable organizations. ARTICLE II Definitions Section 2.1. Interested Person. An Interested Person is any trustee, officer, employee or member of a committee with powers delegated by the Board of Trustees, who (1) has a direct or indirect Financial Interest, as defined below, and/or (2) is a Related Party, as defined below. Section 2.2. Disinterested Trustee. A Disinterested Trustee is any trustee who is not an Interested Person. Section 2.3. Relative. A Relative of an individual means his or her spouse or domestic partner, ancestors, brothers and sisters (whether whole or half blood), children (whether natural or adopted), grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and spouses of brothers, sisters, children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren. Section 2.4. Financial Interest. A person has a Financial Interest if the person has, directly or indirectly, through business, investment, or a Relative: (A) An ownership or investment interest in any entity with which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library has a transaction or arrangement; (B) A compensation arrangement with the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library or with any entity or individual with which the Buffalo & Erie County

Public Library has a transaction or arrangement; or (C) A potential ownership or investment interest in, or compensation arrangement with, any entity or individual with which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is negotiating a transaction or arrangement. Compensation includes direct and indirect remuneration as well as gifts or favors that are not insubstantial. Section 2.5. Substantial Financial Interest. A Financial Interest in a Related Party Transaction is a "Substantial Financial Interest" if, in the discretion of the Board after giving due consideration to the material facts and circumstances of the Financial Interest as presented, the Board determines that such Financial Interest is substantial. Section 2.6. Related Party. A Related Party includes: (A) any trustee, officer or Key Employee of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library or any Affiliate of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library; (B) any Relative of any officer or Key Employee of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library or any Affiliate of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library; or (C) any entity in which any individual described in clauses (A) and (B) of this section has a thirty-five percent or greater ownership or beneficial interest or, in the case of a partnership or professional corporation, a direct or indirect ownership interest in excess of five percent. Section 2.7. Key Employee. A Key Employee is any person who is in a position to exercise substantial influence over the affairs of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library. Section 2.8. Affiliate of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library. An Affiliate of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library means any entity controlled by, in control of, or under common control with the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library. Section 2.9. Related Party Transaction. A Related Party Transaction means any transaction, agreement or any other arrangement in which a Related Party has a Financial Interest and in which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library or any Affiliate of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is a participant. Section 2.10. Conflict of Interest. A Conflict of Interest exists if an outside interest or activity influences or appears to influence the ability of an individual to exercise objectivity or impair the individual's ability to perform his or her responsibility in the best interests of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library. 2

ARTICLE III Disclosure Section 3.1. Initial Disclosure. Prior to the initial election of any trustee, officer, or member of a committee with powers delegated by the Board or hiring of any Key Employee, the prospective trustee, officer, committee member, or Key Employee shall complete, sign and submit to the Chair of the Governance Committee a written Disclosure Statement, attached as Appendix A, identifying, to the best of his or her knowledge, the following information: (A) any entity of which such prospective trustee, officer, committee member, or Key Employee is an officer, trustee, member, owner (either as a sole proprietor or a partner), or employee and with which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library has a relationship; and (B) any transaction in which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is a participant and in which the prospective trustee, officer, committee member, or Key Employee might have a Financial Interest that may give rise to a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction. Section 3.2 Annual Disclosure. Each trustee officer, member of a committee with powers delegated by the Board of Trustees, and Key Employee shall annually submit to the Chair of the Governance Committee the written Disclosure Statement, attached as Appendix A, in which such person: (A) identifies, to the best of his or her knowledge, the information specified in Paragraphs (A) and (B) of Section 3.1 of this Article; (B) affirms that he or she has received a copy of the Conflict of Interest Policy, read and understands the policy, agrees to comply with the policy, and understands the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is charitable and in order to maintain its federal tax exemption it must engage primarily in activities which accomplish one or more of its tax-exempt purposes. Section 3.3 Continuing Duty to Disclose. In connection with any actual or possible Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction which may arise in the ordinary course of the year and within Board or committee meetings, an Interested Person must disclose the existence of the Financial Interest and be given the opportunity to disclose all material facts to the Board of Trustees or the Governance Committee. Such disclosure may be made in a written statement or orally at a meeting of the Board, provided that such oral disclosure must be documented in the minutes of the meeting at which such disclosure is made and given to the Governance Committee for review in accordance with Article IV, Section 4.2. 3

ARTICLE IV General Procedures Section 4.1. General Prohibitions. (A) An Interested Person is precluded from being present at or participating in any Board or committee deliberation or vote related to the transaction or arrangement giving rise to a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Board of Trustees or the Governance Committee, may request that an Interested Person present information to the Board or Governance Committee prior to the commencement of deliberations or voting relating thereto. (B) An Interested Person shall not directly or indirectly attempt to influence improperly the deliberation or voting on the transaction or arrangement giving rise to the conflict. Section 4.2. Determining Whether a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction Exists. (A) After the Interested Person's disclosure of the existence of and all material facts relating to his or her Financial Interest as required under Article III, and after any discussion among the remaining members of the Board of Trustees or the Governance Committee and the Interested Person regarding the facts and circumstances of the Financial Interest, the Governance Committee shall discuss and make a recommendation to the Board as to each of the determinations required by Paragraphs (C) and (D) of this Section 4.2. Alternatively, if the existence of the Financial Interest initially arises at a meeting of the Board of Trustees, then the Board of Trustees can directly make the determinations required without seeking recommendations from the Governance Committee, provided the Interested Person leaves the meeting while the remaining members of the Board of Trustees discusses the information disclosed. (B) Upon due discussion and consideration of the Governance Committee recommendations, the Board shall make each of the determinations required by Paragraphs (C) and (D) of this Section 4.2. (C) Upon discussion, the remaining Board members shall decide and document in the meeting minutes if the transaction or arrangement constitutes a Related Party Transaction as defined in Article II, Section 2.9. If so, then the Board of Trustees must also determine and document in the meeting minutes whether the Related Party has a Substantial Financial Interest, as defined in Article II, Section 2.5, in the proposed Related Party Transaction. Regardless of whether or not the Financial Interest is a Substantial Financial Interest, a Related Party Transaction is subject to the procedures set forth in Article V. 4

(D) If the transaction or arrangement does not constitute a Related Party Transaction as defined in Article II, Section 2.9, then the remaining Board members in their discretion shall decide if a Conflict of Interest, as defined in Article II, Section 2.10, exists nonetheless, after giving due consideration to the material facts and circumstances presented. If the Board determines that the transaction or arrangement involves a Conflict of Interest, then such transaction or arrangement is subject to the procedures set forth in Article V. ARTICLE V Procedures for Addressing Conflicts of Interest & Related Party Transactions. Section 5.1. Consideration of Alternatives. (A) If the transaction or arrangement is a Related Party Transaction in which the Related Party has a Substantial Financial Interest, then consideration of alternatives in accordance with this section is mandatory. For Conflicts of Interest, consideration of alternatives is within the discretion of the Board of Trustees. (B) After disclosure and discussions with the Interested Person, the Board of Trustees may appoint a Disinterested Trustee or committee of Disinterested Directors to investigate alternatives to the proposed transaction or arrangement. Alternatives must be presented to the Board of Trustees and must be documented in the minutes of the meeting at which the determination is made. (C) If alternatives are investigated and presented to the Board, then after exercising due diligence and giving due consideration for any such alternative transactions presented, the Board of Trustees shall determine whether the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library can obtain with reasonable efforts a more advantageous transaction or arrangement from a person or entity that would not give rise to a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction. Section 5.2. Board Decision. (A) If alternatives are considered, whether mandatory or discretionary, and if the Board of Trustees determines that a more advantageous transaction or arrangement is not reasonably possible under circumstances not producing a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction, the Board of Trustees shall determine by a majority vote of the Board whether the transaction or arrangement is in the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's best interest, for the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's own benefit, and whether it is fair and reasonable. (B) In conformity with the above determination, in accordance with the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's Bylaws, the Board of Trustees shall make its decision as to whether to enter into the transaction or arrangement. 5

(C) If the transaction or arrangement involves a Related Party Transaction in which the Related Party has a Substantial Financial Interest, then a majority of the Board members present at the meeting is required to approve such transaction. Section 5.3. Documentation Required. In connection with all actual or possible Conflicts of Interest and Related Party Transactions, the Board of Trustees shall document in the minutes of the meeting at which such determinations are made the following: (A) The names of the persons who disclosed or otherwise were found to have a Financial Interest in connection with an actual or possible Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction, the nature of the Financial Interest, any action taken to determine whether a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction was present, and the Board's decision as to whether a Conflict of Interest, Related Party Transaction or Substantial Financial Interest in a Related Party Transaction in fact existed. (B) The names of the persons who were present for discussions and votes relating to the transaction or arrangement, the content of the discussions at the meeting regarding the proposed transaction or arrangement, including the alternatives to the proposed transaction or arrangement considered, if any. (C) The determination as to whether the transaction or arrangement is fair, reasonable and in the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's best interest. (D) The determination as to whether to enter into the transaction or arrangement which gives rise to the Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction. If the Board of Trustees approves a Related Party Transaction in which the Related Party has a Substantial Financial Interest, then the minutes must also include the basis for such approval. (E) A record of any votes taken in connection with the proceedings. ARTICLE VI Oversight & Reviews Section 6.1. Oversight Responsibility. The designated Governance Committee of the Board, as defined in the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's Bylaws, shall oversee the adoption of, implementation of, and compliance with this Conflict of Interest Policy in accordance with the procedures contained herein and within the process and authority granted under the Bylaws. Section 6.2. Violation of the Conflict of Interest Policy. (A) If the Governance Committee has reasonable cause to believe a 6

trustee, officer or Key Employee has failed to disclose an actual or possible Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction, it shall inform such person of the basis for such belief and afford such person an opportunity to explain the alleged failure to disclose. (B) If, after hearing the response of the trustee, officer or Key Employee and after making further investigation as warranted by the circumstances, the Governance Committee determines that the trustee, officer or Key Employee has failed to disclose an actual or possible Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction, it shall recommend to the Board appropriate disciplinary and corrective action, up to and including dismissal or termination, and referral to the New York State Board of Regents for possible removal of a trustee, pursuant to New York State Education Law Section 226. Section 6.3. Periodic Reviews. To ensure the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library operates in a manner consistent with its charitable purposes and does not engage in activities that could jeopardize its tax-exempt status, the Board shall conduct periodic reviews. The periodic reviews shall, at a minimum, include the following subjects: (A) Whether compensation arrangements and benefits are reasonable, based on competent survey information, and the result of arm's length bargaining. (B) Whether partnerships, joint ventures, and arrangements with management organizations conform to the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's written policies, are properly recorded, reflect reasonable investment or payments for goods and services, further charitable purposes and do not result in impermissible or excessive benefit. Section 6.4. Use of Outside Experts. When conducting the periodic reviews as provided for in Article VI, Section 6.3, the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library may, but need not, use outside advisors. If outside experts are used, their use shall not relieve the Board of Trustees of its responsibility for ensuring periodic reviews are conducted. Adopted by Buffalo & Erie County Public Library Board of Trustees at a public meeting June 12, 2014. (Supersedes B&ECPL Conflict of Interest and Ethics Policy adopted in public session September 16, 2010.) 7

Appendix A DISCLOSURE STATEMENT OF THE BUFFALO & ERIE COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY The undersigned, being a trustee, officer, and/or Key Employee of the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library, hereby acknowledges and confirms the following: (1) I have received, read and understand the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library's Conflict of Interest Policy in effect as of the date written below, and I agree to comply with the Conflict of Interest Policy. (2) I understand that the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is charitable and in order to maintain its federal tax exemption it must engage primarily in activities which accomplish one or more of its tax-exempt purposes. (3) Personal Interests & Relationships. I am an officer, director, trustee, member, owner (either as a sole proprietor or a partner), or an employee of the following entities with which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library has a relationship: [If none, please write "None." If such interests exist, please specify the capacity in which you hold such an interest (for example, employee, director, or owner). If an owner, please specify your percentage ownership).] (4) Interests & Relationships of Relatives. A Relative (spouse or domestic partner, ancestors, brothers and sisters (whether whole or half blood), children (whether natural or adopted), grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and spouses of brothers, sisters, children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren) of mine is an officer, director, trustee, member, owner (either as a sole proprietor or a partner), or an employee of the following entities with which the Buffalo & Erie County Public Library has a relationship: [If none, please write "None." If such interests exist, please specify the Relative (for example, sibling or spouse) and the Relative's position (for example, employee, director, or owner). If an owner, please specify the percentage ownership).]

Appendix A (5) Transactions. The Buffalo & Erie County Public Library is a participant in the following transactions in which I or my Relative may have a Financial Interest that may give rise to a Conflict of Interest or Related Party Transaction, as defined in the Conflict of Interest Policy. [If none, please write "None." If such transaction(s) exists, please specify the transaction and the potential financial interest involved and whether you or a Relative has such an interest for any such transaction(s). Please specify the Relative and their position, if applicable.] I certify that the above statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. Name: Position: Signature: Date: 2