Similar documents
Insolvency Statistics in Canada. September 2015

Mackenzie's Canadian Federal / Provincial Marginal Tax Rates

Insolvency Statistics in Canada. April 2013

Alberta Labour Force Profiles

Alberta Minimum Wage Profile April March 2018

2016 Alberta Labour Force Profiles Women

Alberta Minimum Wage Profile April March 2017

2017 Alberta Labour Force Profiles Youth

Highlights. For the purpose of this profile, the population is defined as women 15+ years.

TAX FACTS What s Inside. Quick Estimates. RRSP, RPP and DPSP Limits. Top Personal Rates for CPP, EI and QPIP Rates

Investing in Canada s Future. Prosperity: An Economic Opportunity. for Canadian Industries

Post-Secondary Education, Training and Labour August New Brunswick Minimum Wage Factsheet 2017

The Nova Scotia Minimum Wage Review Committee Report

Federal and Provincial/Territorial Tax Rates for Income Earned

STATISTICS CANADA RELEASES 2016 GDP DATA

Appendix A Jurisdiction-Specific Requirements General Insurance Agents And Brokers

Post-Secondary Education, Training and Labour Prepared May New Brunswick Minimum Wage Report

The Nova Scotia Minimum Wage Review Committee

Information on the Form T2203, Provincial and Territorial Taxes for 2017 Multiple Jurisdictions

2019 New Years Tax Changes

Post-Secondary Education, Training and Labour Prepared November New Brunswick Minimum Wage Report

CCAA Statistics in Canada. Third Quarter of 2017

Net interest income on average assets and liabilities Table 66

Net interest income on average assets and liabilities Table 75

Canadian School Board Structure and Trustee Profile

Minimum Wage. This will make the minimum wage in the NWT one of the highest in Canada.

Individual Taxation Tax Planning Guide

BC JOBS PLAN ECONOMY BACKGROUNDER. Current statistics show that the BC Jobs Plan is working: The economy is growing and creating jobs.

Information on Form T2203, Provincial and Territorial Taxes for 2018 Multiple Jurisdictions

CANTAX T1Plus 2007 versions December 2007

August 2015 Aboriginal Population Off-Reserve Package

October 2016 Aboriginal Population Off-Reserve Package

2013 Payroll Guide. This is how we work.

April 2017 Alberta Indigenous People Living Off-Reserve Package

November 2017 Alberta Indigenous People Living Off-Reserve Package

December 2017 Alberta Indigenous People Living Off-Reserve Package

January 2018 Alberta Indigenous People Living Off-Reserve Package

Sprott Flow-Through Limited Partnerships

2014 MINIMUM WAGE RATE ANNUAL REPORT

Saskatchewan Labour Force Statistics

2017 Annual Alberta Labour Market Review

Canada Education Savings Program Annual Statistical Review Canada Education Savings Program LC E

Business Barometer Newfoundland & Labrador

Yukon Bureau of Statistics

Workers Compensation Act Committee of Review

2012 Annual Alberta Labour Market Review

Canada Education Savings Program Annual Statistical Review. December 2008

CANADIAN MANUFACTURERS & EXPORTERS BUSINESS CONDITIONS SURVEY

MULTILATERAL INSTRUMENT LISTING REPRESENTATION AND STATUTORY RIGHTS OF ACTION DISCLOSURE EXEMPTIONS

GOVERNMENT BENEFITS UPDATE 2017

2. Full-time staffing intentions, next 3 months 3. General state of business health. 20 Bad 5 10 Down

2019 Canadian Rates and Limits

2. Full-time staffing intentions, next 3 months 3. General state of business health. * 12-month moving averages. * 12-month moving averages.

Household Food Insecurity in Canada: Time for Action!

GOVERNMENT BENEFITS UPDATE 2018

CCAA Statistics in Canada. Second Quarter of 2017

TAX INITIATIVES TAX OPTION GRADUATED FLAT COMPETITIVE

How it works. for Newfoundland & Labrador. Labour s Plan for an improved Canada Pension Plan. Get the job done! canadianlabour.ca

Yukon Bureau of Statistics

June Decentralization, Provincial Tax Autonomy and Equalization in Canada

Canada Education Savings Program Annual Statistical Review Canada Education Savings Program Annual Statistical Review 2014 LC E

Business Barometer Newfoundland & Labrador

Access to Basic Banking Services

2017 Report of the Auditor General of New Brunswick. Volume I

96 Centrepointe Dr., Ottawa, Ontario K2G 6B National Dental Hygiene Labour Survey

National Sector Results. First Quarter 2018

Provincial and National Employment, Alberta and Canada Employment Rates 1, % 62.7% 62.7% 63.0% 63.5%

December 8, Minimum Wage Review Committee Report

Service Request Requirements for Form 1042-S Tax Year 2008

National Sector Results. Fourth Quarter 2018

January 2013 Canadian Payroll Tax Update. Sage BusinessVision

What s new. Release

January 12, Minimum Wage Review Committee Report

National System Results. Fourth Quarter 2016

2008 ANNUAL ALBERTA LABOUR MARKET REVIEW

Electronic Filers Manual

Status Report on Phase 1 of the New Infrastructure Plan

About the Canadian Taxpayers Federation

Trends in Labour Productivity in Alberta

EI parental benefits changes and amendments to federal and provincial maternity/pregnancy and parental leaves

Comparing Ontario s Fiscal Position with Other Provinces

Prince Edward Island Labour Force Survey 2017 Annual Report. Highlights:

Labour Force Statistics for the 10 largest communities in Nunavut

Consumer Price Index. Highlights. Manitoba second highest among provinces. MBS Reports C o n s u m e r P r i c e I n d e x, M a r c h

ALBERTA PROFILE: YOUTH

Yukon Bureau of Statistics

TAX CALCULATION SUPPLEMENTARY CORPORATIONS (2007 and later tax years)

Riding the Commodity Price Roller-Coaster

SPECIMEN Application for Registration of a Pension Plan (Application)

2010 CSA Survey on Retirement and Investing

Consumer Price Index. Highlights. Manitoba second highest among provinces. Consumer Price Index (CPI), Manitoba and Canada, February 2019

How Investment Income is Taxed

Fiscal Coordination in Canada

Canadians Celebrate Tax Freedom Day on June 14

How Investment Income is Taxed

Consumer Price Index. Highlights. Manitoba third highest among provinces. Consumer Price Index (CPI), Manitoba and Canada, December 2018

Consumer Price Index. Highlights. Manitoba third highest among provinces. Consumer Price Index (CPI), Manitoba and Canada, September 2018

The Current and Future Contribution of the Aboriginal Community to the Economy of Saskatchewan

THE HOME STRETCH. A Review of Debt and Home Ownership Among Canadian Seniors

Electronic filers manual for 2014 income tax returns. Chapter 2 Error messages

Transcription:

Estimated total job losses from 10% minimum wage increase across all provinces Upper Bound 321,300 Lower Bound 92,300 Source: CFIB calculations from Statistic Canada s 2009 Labour Force Survey data. iv

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 1 Table 1 rates by province, 2010 Province General Rate Planned Increases Ontario $10.25 Newfoundland & Labrador $10.00 Nunavut $10.00 Jan 1, 2011:$11.00 Nova Scotia $9.65 Manitoba $9.50 Quebec $9.50 Saskatchewan $9.25 New Brunswick $9.00 Apr 1, 2011: $9.50 Sep 1, 2011: $10.00 Prince Edward Island $9.00 Northwest Territories $9.00 Apr 1, 2011: $10.00 Yukon $8.93 Alberta $8.80 British Columbia $8.00 Source: Provincial and Territorial Government websites.

2 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure 1 earners, by province (% total employed) Newfoundland and Labrador Ontario Nova Scotia Quebec New Brunswick Prince Edward Island Manitoba Saskatchewan British Columbia Alberta Canada 1.3 2.3 6.8 6.1 5.3 5.2 4.6 3.9 5.8 8.1 9.3 Number of Employees: 14.1 million Source: Statistics Canada, Perspectives on Labour and Income, March 2010. Figure 2 By age group (% total minimum wage earners) 45 to 54, 10.0% 55 and over, 8.8% 35 to 44, 10.4% 25 to 34, 11.5% 15 to 24, 59.3% Number of Minimum Wage Earners: 817,000 Source: Statistics Canada, Perspectives on Labour and Income, March 2010.

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 3 Figure 3 By level of education completed (% total minimum wage earners) High school graduate, 23.0% At least some postsecondary, 42.7% Less than high school completion, 34.3% Number of Minimum Wage Earners: 817,000 Source: Statistics Canada, Perspectives on Labour and Income, March 2010. Figure 4 By employment status (% total minimum wage earners) Part-time, 59.1% Full-time, 40.9% Number of Minimum Wage Earners: 817,000 Source: Statistics Canada, Perspectives on Labour and Income, March 2010.

4 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure 5 By industry sector (% total employed) Accommodation and food Agriculture Trade Information, cultural, arts and recreation Management, administrative and other support Transportation and warehousing Finance, insurance, real estate and leasing Education Manufacturing Health care and social assistance Professional, scientific and technical Forestry, fishing, mining, oil and gas Public administration Construction and utilities 14.3 12.3 6.7 6.0 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.1 1.9 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.1 Number of Employees: 14.1 million 22.5 Source: Statistics Canada, Perspectives on Labour and Income, March 2010.

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 5

6 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 7 Figure 6 elasticity

8 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure 7 Job loss estimates from 10 % minimum wage increase, by province Canada Ontario Quebec British Columbia Alberta Manitoba Saskatchewan Nova Scotia New Brunswick Newfoundland and Labrador Prince Edward Island 22,300 11,700 10,700 3,000 2,400 2,300 1,900 1,200 300 36,400 92,300 Estimated Lower Bound Job Losses Canada Ontario Quebec British Columbia Alberta Manitoba Saskatchewan Nova Scotia New Brunswick Newfoundland and Labrador Prince Edward Island 73,500 42,700 39,000 11,800 10,100 8,600 7,000 4,100 1,300 123,300 321,300 Estimated Upper Bound Job Losses Source: CFIB analysis of Statistics Canada s 2009 Labour Force Survey data.

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 9 Table 2 Lower bound estimated job losses from 10% minimum wage increase, by province and age group 1 British Columbia Alberta Saskatchewan Manitoba Ontario Quebec New Brunswick Nova Scotia Prince Edward Island Newfoundland and Labrador Canada Source: CFIB analysis of Statistics Canada s 2009 Labour Force Survey data. 15-24 25-54 55+ Net Loss 2,200 16,900-7,400 11,700 1,800 14,900-6,000 10,700 500 3,700-1,800 2,400 600 4,400-2,000 3,000 6,500 50,200-20,300 36,400 3,900 29,800-11,300 22,300 300 2,800-1,200 1,900 400 3,400-1,500 2,300 100 500-200 300 200 1,700-600 1,200 16,500 128,300-52,400 92,300 Table 3 Upper bound estimated job losses from 10% minimum wage increase, by province and age group 1 British Columbia Alberta Saskatchewan Manitoba Ontario Quebec New Brunswick Nova Scotia Prince Edward Island Newfoundland and Labrador Canada Source: CFIB analysis of Statistics Canada s 2009 Labour Force Survey data. 15-24 25-54 55+ Net Loss 13,500 29,200 0.0 42,700 13,200 25,800 0.0 39,000 3,700 6,400 0.0 10,100 4,200 7,600 0.0 11,800 36,600 86,700 0.0 123,300 22,000 51,400 0.0 73,500 2,200 4,800 0.0 7,000 2,800 5,800 0.0 8,600 500 900 0.0 1,300 1,100 3,000 0.0 4,100 99,800 221,500 0.0 321,300 1 Subtotals may not add up to totals due to rounding.

10 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure 8 Provincial income tax deductions, 2010 (% of minimum wage earner s gross income) Manitoba Prince Edward Island Nova Scotia Quebec Newfoundland and Labrador New Brunswick Ontario Saskatchewan Yukon Nunavut Northwest Territories Alberta British Columbia 0.2 0.0 1.5 1.5 3.0 2.7 2.3 5.7 5.2 4.7 4.5 4.4 4.4 Source: CFIB calculations.

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 11 Table 4 Annual payroll deductions per employee, 2007 vs 2010 by province/territory Minimum Wage 2007 Minimum Wage 2010 % change Net income 2007 Net income 2010 % change Deductions as a % of net income 2007 Deductions as a % of net income 2010 BC $8.00 $8.00 0 $14,769.04 $15,061.28 2 12.7 10.5 AB $8.00 $8.80 10 $14,771,64 $16,338.40 11 12.6 12.0 SK $7.95 $9.25 16 $13,965.38 $16,597.88 19 18.4 15.9 MB $8.00 $9.50 19 $13,999.44 $16,404.44 17 18.9 20.5 ON $8.00 $10.25 28 $14,365.26 $18,132.40 26 15.8 17.6 QC $8.00 $9.50 19 $15,179.61 $17,970.62 17 13.7 15.0 NB $7.25 $9.00 24 $12,987.52 $15,886.78 22 16.1 17.8 NS $7.60 $9.65 27 $13,488.28 $16,845.66 25 17.2 19.2 PEI $7.50 $9.00 20 $13,261.30 $15,737.54 19 17.6 19.0 NL $7.50 $10.00 33 $13,204.88 $17,456.40 32 18.1 19.2 NT $8.25 $9.00 9 $14,967.68 $16,421.86 8 14.6 14.0 YT $8.37 $8.93 7 $15,016.56 $16,168.10 10 15.9 14.9 NU $8.50 $10.00 18 $15,395.90 $18,046.34 17 14.8 15.3 Source: Provincial/territorial websites, CFIB calculations based on full-time (2,080 hours) employee. Deductions include federal income tax, provincial income tax, CPP and EI. Note 1: The results above are independent of job loss effects examined in the previous section.the effect on total wage costs to the employer is uncertain depending on the number of jobs cut or fewer jobs being created. However, on a per employee cost basis, it can be seen that payroll deductions as a percentage of net income have increased in 2010 compared to 2007 even with increases in the minimum wage across most provinces. Note 2: Increased income through minimum wage increases could also result in lost benefits delivered through the tax system due to ineligibility to qualify (e.g. GST tax credit) but this effect is excluded from the analysis. Table 5 earner s annual CPP/QPP deductions: 2010 vs proposed British Columbia Alberta Saskatchewan Manitoba Ontario Quebec New Brunswick Nova Scotia Prince Edward Island Newfoundland and Labrador Northwest Territories Yukon Nunavut 2010 Proposed $650.52 $1,040.83 $732.68 $1,172.29 $779.22 $1,246.75 $804.96 $1,287.94 $882.18 $1,411.49 $804.96 $1,287.94 $753.48 $1,205.57 $820.30 $1,312.48 $753.48 $1,205.57 $856.44 $1,370.30 $753.48 $1,205.57 $746.20 $1,193.92 $856.44 $1,370.30 Source: CFIB calculations based on Canadian Labour Congress recommendations

12 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Table 6 earner s annual EI deductions: 2010 vs 2015 British Columbia Alberta Saskatchewan Manitoba Ontario Quebec New Brunswick Nova Scotia Prince Edward Island Newfoundland and Labrador Northwest Territories Yukon Nunavut 2010 2015 $287.82 $316.68 $332.80 $341.90 $368.94 $368.84 $323.96 $347.36 $323.96 $359.84 $323.96 $321.36 $359.84 $347.78 $382.55 $402.12 $412.98 $445.59 $412.98 $391.25 $419.50 $391.25 $434.72 $391.25 $388.20 $434.72 Source: Employment Insurance Whipsaw. www.cfib-fcei.ca/english/research/canada/113-tax_policy/1680- employment_insurance_whipsaw.html. 2 WCB contribution example refers to Accommodation, Food and Beverage, Restaurant industry classification. Due to Manitoba s experience rating system, the new firm rate is utilized. Source: Association of Workers Compensation Boards of Canada (AWCBC).

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 13 Table 7 Annual cost of hiring minimum wage earner (2010) Annual Wages Annual CPP, EI, WCB British Columbia $16,640.00 $1,224.86 Alberta $18,304.00 $1,375.55 Saskatchewan $19,240.00 $1,431.77 Manitoba $19,760.00 $1,471.34 Ontario $21,320.00 $1,750.48 Quebec $19,760.00 $1,789.38 New Brunswick $18,720.00 $1,557.09 Nova Scotia $20,072.00 $1,655.86 Prince Edward Island $18,720.00 $1,448.51 Newfoundland $20,800.00 $1,878.14 Northwest Territories $18,732.00 $1,635.71 Yukon $18,574.40 $1,601.03 Nunavut $20,800.00 $1,836.54 Source: CFIB calculations based on full-time (2,080 hours) employee. Total $17,864.86 $19,679.55 $20,671.77 $21,231.34 $23,070.48 $21,549.38 $20,277.09 $21,727.86 $20,168.51 $22,678.14 $20,355.71 $20,175.43 $22,636.54 Contribution percentage 6.9% 7.0% 6.9% 6.9% 7.6% 8.3% 7.7% 7.6% 7.2% 8.3% 8.0% 7.9% 8.0% Note: Other provincial payroll taxes and health premiums are excluded from the analysis, but would add to employer payroll costs.

14 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 15 Table 8 Comparison of minimum wage rates (% increase from 2005) BC AB SK MB ON 2005 Rate $8.00 $7.00 $7.05 $7.25 $7.45 2010 Mandated $8.00 $8.80 $9.25 $9.50 $10.25 (0%) (26%) (31%) (31%) (38%) 2010 Indexed to CPI $8.63 $8.04 $7.89 $7.97 $8.10 2010 Indexed to Average Hourly Wage (8%) $9.36 (17%) (15%) $9.33 33%) (12%) $8.96 (27%) (10%) $8.61 (19%) (9%) $8.72 (17%) QC NS NB PEI NL 2005 Rate $7.60 $6.80 $6.30 $6.80 $6.25 2010 Mandated $9.50 $9.65 $9.00 $9.00 $10.00 (25%) (42%) (43%) (32%) (60%) 2010 Indexed to CPI $8.25 $7.48 $6.82 $7.50 $6.85 (9%) (10%) (8%) (11%) (10%) 2010 Indexed to Average Hourly Wage $8.79 $8.18 $7.73 $7.98 $7.92 (16%) (20%) (23%) (17%) (27%) Source: Statistics Canada, The Consumer Price Index, 2010; Statistics Canada, The Labour Force Historical Review 2009; Human Resources and Skills Development Canada, Minimum Wage Database, 2010.

16 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure 9 2010 Basic Personal Exemption, by province ($) Alberta Saskatchewan Northwest Territories British Columbia Quebec Nunavut Yukon Ontario New Brunswick Nova Scotia Manitoba Newfoundland and Labrador Prince Edward Island 16,825 13,348 12,740 11,000 10,505 10,382 10,382 8,943 8,777 8,231 8,134 7,833 7,708 Source: Federal and Provincial government websites

3 Canada s Training Grounds: SME s $18 Billion Dollar Investment in the Nation s Workforce. www.cfibfcei.ca/english/research/canada/112-labour_policy/368-canada_s_training_ground.html Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 17

18 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 19 4 Ineffective is the term used by Human Resources and Skills Development Canada to describe a number of their own training initiatives implemented under the EI program, as presented in their 2008 Monitoring and Assessment Report.

20 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 21

22 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 23

24 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 25

26 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Figure A1 Annual change in average hourly wage, minimum wage, and consumer price index (CPI), by province 5 180 British Columbia 160 140 120 100 Average Hourly Wage Change, 119 CPI Change, 112 Minimum Wage Change, 100 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Alberta Minimum Wage Change, 147 Average Hourly Wage Change, 137 CPI Change, 122 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 5 Sources: Statistics Canada, The Consumer Price Index, 2010. Statistics Canada, The Labour Force Historical Review 2009. Human Resources and Skills Development Canada, Minimum Wage Database, 2010. Note: The base year used for prices and wages is 2002 (2002=100). Index above 100 means that price/wage/minimum wage levels in particular year are above 2002. (E.g. Price index of 120 in 2009 means that prices are 120% of levels in 2002).

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 27 180 Saskatchewan 160 140 120 100 Minimum Wage Change, 144 Average Hourly Wage Change, 136 CPI Change, 117 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Manitoba Minimum Wage Change, 136 Average Hourly Wage Change, 126 CPI Change, 114 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Ontario Minimum Wage Change, 136 Average Hourly Wage Change, 123 CPI Change, 114 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Quebec Average Hourly Wage Change, 123 Minimum Wage Change, 121 CPI Change, 113 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

28 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 180 160 140 120 100 New Brunswick Minimum Wage Change, 138 Average Hourly Wage Change, 129 CPI Change, 114 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 Nova Scotia 160 140 120 100 Minimum Wage Change, 145 Average Hourly Wage Change, 128 CPI Change, 116 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Prince Edward Island Minimum Wage Change, 136 Average Hourly Wage Change, 130 CPI Change, 117 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 180 160 140 120 100 Newfoundland and Labrador Minimum Wage Change, 153 Average Hourly Wage Change, 132 CPI Change, 115 80 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 29 Table A1 Annual Minimum Wage Earnings and Deductions: 2007, 2010 British Columbia 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.00 $16,640.00 $892.84 $28.08 $650.52 $299.52 $1,870.96 $14,769.04 12.7% $8.00 $16,640.00 $640.38 $0.00 $650.52 $287.82 $1,578.72 $15,061.28 10.5% Alberta 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.00 $16,640.00 $892.84 $25.48 $650.52 $299.52 $1,868.36 $14,771.64 12.6% $8.80 $18,304.00 $873.34 $42.90 $732.68 $316.68 $1,965.60 $16,338.40 12.0% Saskatchewan 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $7.95 $16,536.00 $878.02 $749.58 $645.32 $297.70 $2,570.62 $13,965.38 18.4% $9.25 $19,240.00 $1,004.38 $525.72 $779.22 $332.80 $2,642.12 $16,597.88 15.9% Manitoba 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.00 $16,640.00 $892.84 $797.68 $650.52 $299.52 $2,640.56 $13,999.44 18.9% $9.50 $19,760.00 $1,076.92 $1,131.78 $804.96 $341.90 $3,355.56 $16,404.44 20.5% Ontario 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.00 $16,640.00 $892.84 $431.86 $650.52 $299.52 $2,274.74 $14,365.26 15.8% $10.25 $21,320.00 $1,295.32 $641.16 $882.18 $368.94 $3,187.60 $18,132.40 17.6% Quebec 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions QPP deductions EI/QPIP deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.00 $16,640.00 $743.86 $573.30 $650.52 $312.17 $2,279.85 $14,360.15 13.7% $9.50 $19,760.00 $895.96 $895.70 $804.96 $368.84 $2,965.46 $16,794.54 15.0% New Brunswick 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $7.25 $15,080.00 $667.42 $580.32 $573.30 $271.44 $2,092.48 $12,987.52 16.1% $9.00 $18,720.00 $931.32 $824.46 $753.48 $323.96 $2,833.22 $15,886.78 17.8% Nova Scotia 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $7.60 $15,808.00 $772.72 $653.38 $609.18 $284.44 $2,319.72 $13,488.28 17.2% $9.65 $20,072.00 $1,120.60 $938.08 $820.30 $347.36 $3,226.34 $16,845.66 19.2% Prince Edward Island 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $7.50 $15,600.00 $742.56 $716.30 $599.04 $280.80 $2,338.70 $13,261.30 17.6% $9.00 $18,720.00 $931.32 $973.70 $753.48 $323.96 $2,982.46 $15,737.54 19.0% Newfoundland and Labrador 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Prov. tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $7.50 $15,600.00 $742.56 $772.72 $599.04 $280.80 $2,395.12 $13,204.88 18.1% $10.00 $20,800.00 $1,222.52 $904.80 $856.44 $359.84 $3,343.60 $17,456.40 19.2%

30 Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate Northwest Territories 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Territory tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.25 $17,160.00 $968.24 $238.94 $676.26 $308.88 $2,192.32 $14,967.68 14.6% $9.00 $18,720.00 $931.32 $289.38 $753.48 $323.96 $2,298.14 $16,421.86 14.0% Yukon 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Territory tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.37 $17,409.60 $1,004.12 $456.04 $688.48 $313.30 $2,461.94 $14,947.66 16.5% $8.93 $18,574.40 $911.04 $427.70 $746.20 $321.36 $2,406.30 $16,168.10 14.9% Nunavut 2007 2010 Gross income Federal tax deductions Territory tax deductions CPP deductions EI deductions Total deductions Net income Deductions as % of net income $8.50 $17,680.00 $1,043.38 $220.48 $702.00 $318.24 $2,284.10 $15,395.90 14.8% $10.00 $20,800.00 $1,222.52 $314.86 $856.44 $359.84 $2,753.66 $18,046.34 15.3% Source: CFIB calculations based on a full-time (2,080 hours) employee.

Minimum Wage: Reframing the Debate 31 Table A2 Annual Impact of Minimum Wage Increases on Employers: 2007, 2010 British Columbia 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $419.33 $141.44 $1,211.29 $17,851.29 $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $402.95 $171.39 $1,224.86 $17,864.86 Alberta 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $419.33 $198.02 $1,267.86 $17,907.86 $8.80 $18,304.00 $732.68 $443.35 $199.51 $1,375.55 $19,679.55 Saskatchewan 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $7.95 $16,536.00 $645.32 $416.78 $188.51 $1,250.61 $17,786.61 $9.25 $19,240.00 $779.22 $465.92 $186.63 $1,431.77 $20,671.77 Manitoba 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $419.33 $151.42 $1,221.27 $17,861.27 $9.50 $19,760.00 $804.96 $478.66 $187.72 $1,471.34 $21,231.34 Ontario 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $419.33 $274.56 $1,344.41 $17,984.41 $10.25 $21,320.00 $882.18 $516.52 $351.78 $1,750.48 $23,070.48 Quebec 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.00 $16,640.00 $650.52 $437.13 $372.74 $1460.39 $18,100.39 $9.50 $19,760.00 $804.96 $516.11 $468.31 $1,789.38 $21,549.38 New Brunswick 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $7.25 $15,080.00 $573.30 $380.02 $241.28 $1,194.60 $16,274.60 $9.00 $18,720.00 $753.48 $453.54 $350.06 $1,557.09 $20,277.09 Nova Scotia 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $7.60 $15,808.00 $609.18 $398.22 $273.48 $1,280.87 $17,088.87 $9.65 $20,072.00 $820.30 $486.30 $349.25 $1,655.86 $21,727.86 Prince Edward Island 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $7.50 $15,600.00 $599.04 $393.12 $260.52 $1,252.68 $16,852.68 $9.00 $18,720.00 $753.48 $453.54 $241.49 $1,448.51 $20,168.51 Newfoundland and Labrador 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $7.50 $15,600.00 $599.04 $393.12 $414.96 $1,407.12 $17,007.12 $10.00 $20,800.00 $856.44 $503.78 $517.92 $1,878.14 $22,678.14 Northwest Territories 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.25 $17,160.00 $676.26 $432.43 $502.79 $1,611.48 $18,771.48 $9.00 $18,720.00 $753.48 $453.54 $428.69 $1,635.71 $20,355.71 Yukon 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.37 $17,409.60 $688.48 $438.62 $502.79 $1,629.89 $19,039.49 $8.93 $18,574.00 $746.20 $449.90 $404.92 $1,601.03 $20,175.43 Nunavut 2007 2010 Annual wages CPP contribution EI contribution WCB contribution Total contributions Total cost to employer $8.50 $17,680.00 $702.00 $445.54 $518.02 $1,665.56 $19,345.56 $10.00 $20,800.00 $856.44 $503.78 $476.32 $1,836.54 $22,636.54 Source: CFIB calculations based on full-time (2080 hours) employee.