Contract Review Handbook for Civil Contractors

Similar documents
Hobson Engineering Co Pty Ltd

The Toler Firm LLC A Construction Law Firm Timothy N. Toler September 23, 2015

Do your. homework. A contractor s guide to rights and obligations when contracting with homeowners

CUSTOMER CONTRACT. Introduction. Contract Terms. Dear Customer

Consumer means a consumer as that term is defined in Section 3 of the Australian Consumer Law;

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALE

FIDIC CONTRACTS A COMPARATIVE. Uttam Sengupta Sr. GM Contracts & Risk Management

Western Water Development Consultant Accreditation Deed

Application for commercial credit account

2 nd Edition September 2005 (Second Edition of CIDB document 1020)

Short Course on. Construction Law. with particular reference to the. JBCC 2000 Series of Contracts. in particular the application of

Subcontracting. Module 7

TERMS AND CONDITONS PARTIES

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF HIRE

CS ENERGY LIMITED SERVICE CONDITIONS

DOUKPSC04 Rev Feb 2013

Odessa Marine Pty Ltd ACN Terms & Conditions of Trade

Terms of Trade relating to Produce and Grocery acquired for sale

PRACTICE NOTE 1: COMMERCIAL CONTRACTS GUIDANCE. 16 August 2018

C O N T R A C T. between

Terms of Trade. 1 P a g e

Conditions of Contract

NFF Contract Template Labour Hire

Personal Loans Terms & Conditions

SHORT FORM STANDARD SUBCONTRACT. This Agreement is made this day of, 20, between

A Guide to the use of BIFA Standard Trading Conditions 2017 Incorporation and Key Aspects

General Insurance - Domestic Insurance - Motor Vehicle- Comprehensive - Service - Service quality

PURCHASE ORDER TERMS AND CONDITIONS

APPLICATION FOR COMMERCIAL CREDIT 30 DAY TRADING ACCOUNT Date:

CLAUSE AND EFFECT BASIC CONTRACT LAW PRINCIPLES AND KILLER CONTRACT CLAUSES

(1) In these sub-contract conditions of agreement, the following words and phrases shall have the following meanings:-

We are pleased to provide this Offer to carry out Energex Connection Services as requested in your application.

Electronic & Mechanical Calibrations Pty Ltd Terms & Conditions of Trade Definitions Acceptance Change in Control 4.

Terms & Conditions Supply of Goods or Services

Contractor and subcontractor insolvency January 2010

PROLONGATION COST CLAIMS THE BASIC PRINCIPLES

STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR THE COMMERCIAL HIRE OF GOODS AND EQUIPMENT

Implementing the Construction Supply Chain Payment Charter. January Guidance Note

APPLICATION FOR COMMERCIAL CREDIT 30 DAY TRADING ACCOUNT A.B.N

Basic Connection Service Connection of Micro Embedded Generator (less than or equal to 5kW)

Standard Trading Terms and Conditions


ETTORE ZANON S.p.A. GENERAL CONDITIONS OF PURCHASE

The 7 things you MUST ask BEFORE signing your Building Contract

Australian Independent Hire A.B.N

Australian Standard. Subcontract conditions for design and construct. AS (Incorporating Amendment No. 1) AS

Foreign Exchange SOLD VANILLA CALL OPTION PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

Calliden Home Warranty Insurance - New South Wales Insurance Policy

Foreign Exchange BOUGHT VANILLA CALL OPTION PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

Brandis Hire Pty Ltd Terms and Conditions of Hire

STANDARD TERMS OF BUSINESS TROTEC PRODUKTIONS- UND VERTRIEBS GMBH. 1. General Elements of the contract Conclusion of the contract...

CREDIT SALE AGREEMENT (PERSONAL)

Conditions for the Carriage of Goods by Road

Bulk Water Supply Contract LMA Scheme. Version 1

ASX interim guidance: Reporting scoping studies

Terms and Conditions. Doc ID /v3

Standard Form Project Agreement (hub DBFM Projects)

The definitions which shall apply to these Terms and Conditions are set out in paragraph 8.

[Based on or amended from] Australian Standard. Subcontract conditions for design and construct (QLD) Design and Construction of: PROJECT

EPC Contracts Key Issues to Consider. Ran Chakrabarti Partner May 2018

Professional Indemnity Initiative

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SUPPLY

Civil Design Consultants, Inc.

flexi loan Conditions of Use This booklet contains General conditions Things you should know about your credit contract

QBCC PERIOD MINOR WORKS SUBCONTRACT

Finance Terms and Conditions

Clause 17: Care of the Works and Indemnities

Section Fees and Other Types of Remuneration. (Applicable from 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2012)

HOSTMANN-STEINBERG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Company Number TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF TRADE

G A U D A L R IN A E G NTE O E E F S H ACI E L R ITE

A. Contracts considered in the context of construction projects. 3. Particular forms of agreement unit price, T&M, Design/Build.

Nutreco General Purchase Terms and Conditions

Welcome to. Dorchester Finance. Your Finance. Your Way

ANZ ASSURED & PERSONAL OVERDRAFT

1 In these Domestic Sub-Contract Conditions the following expressions and terms shall have the meanings given below:

Building & Construction Law all notes

INVITATION TO TENDER TENDER FORM

MASTER ECM TERMS. 7 March 2016

STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS

STANDARD FORM OF AGREEMENT GENERAL TERMS

TERMS OF BUSINESS 1. INTRODUCTION AND DEFINITIONS

Important Facts about this Lawpack Kit

ARCHITECTURAL CONSULTANCY AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS

Agreement for Supply of Goods and Services - Standard Terms & Conditions

Ethical Contract Negotiation

Standard Connection Service Connection Service for Unmetered Supply

CONSUMER LOAN & SECURITY AGREEMENT COMMERCIAL TERMS

to the DIRECTOR OF BUILDING CONTROL DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TASMANIA on the

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALE

Home Improvement Contract Contractor Any Notice of Cancellation can be sent to this address. Owner

ICT PROCUREMENT A PRACTICAL GUIDE

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF TRADE

Construction Contracts Issues and Practical Solutions. Shahram Safai Partner Afridi & Angell

Dear ^firstname ^lastname

Cosmos Projects - Standard Terms and Conditions of Sub-Contract

Australian Securities Exchange Notice

APPLICATION FOR CREDIT ACCOUNT, AND CONDITIONS OF SALE

Facility Agreement Continuing Credit Facility - Line of Credit Terms & Conditions

Terms and conditions of sale of material

Part 5. Default Purchasers Conditions of Contract. for

Transcription:

Contract Review Handbook for Civil Contractors Civil Contractors Federation - WA Branch P: (08) 9414 1486 www.ccfwa.com.au

LAVAN LEGAL S EXpERTISE Practical advice on construction contracts, tendering and strategies In-depth knowledge of the PPSA and Construction Contracts Act Specialists in dispute resolution and arbitration Shane Pentony Partner Construction and Infrastructure The Quadrant, 1 William Street, GPO Box F338, Perth WA 6841 T +61 8 9288 6000 F +61 8 9288 6001 www.lavanlegal.com.au

Contents Contract Approach, Documentation and Scope of Work 6 Contract Sum and Schedule of Rates 8 Contract Programme 10 Head Contract Clauses 10 Warranties 12 Security 12 Site Access and Possession 14 Practical Completion 14 Extensions of Time and Prolongation Costs 16 Liquidated Damages 18 Payment Claims 18 Variations 20 Latent Conditions 22 Information Disclaimers 22 Limiations of Liability 24 Indemnities and Insurance 26 Claim Bars and Time Bars 28 Termination Clauses 28 Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) Issues 30 Dispute Resolution Clauses 32 Specifications 32 PAGE 3

The purpose of this Booklet This booklet is intended to give Western Australian members of the Civil Contractors Federation a practical guide for use when considering whether to enter a construction contract. NOTE: this booklet is only a general guide and should not be treated as an exhaustive analysis of the risks that a particular contract may pose and should not be treated as a substitute for legal advice in respect of a contract. The information in the document is based on the law as at November 2014. PAGE 4

LAVAN LEGAL S COMMITMENT Understand WA s civil construction sector Draft clear and concise contracts Be commercial Resolve disputes efficiently This is our service commitment to you. Greg Nairn Senior Associate Construction and Infrastructure The Quadrant, 1 William Street, GPO Box F338, Perth WA 6841 T +61 8 9288 6000 F +61 8 9288 6001 www.lavanlegal.com.au

Issues Contract Approach, Documentation and Scope of Work There are a host of different contracting approaches that may be taken and the documentation will differ according to the type of project. Different types of contracting approaches include a simple construct only, a design and construct or an EPC (Engineer, Procure and Construct) contract. In a typical scenario a civil contractor will be performing only construction and the contract should reflect that (eg an AS2124). It is important to consider that your obligations are clearly set out in the contract and that the contract type is suitable for the job. Beware of contracts referring to design obligations unless that is what you are being asked to undertake. Usually a detailed scope of work is necessary, setting out what work is required, to what level that work is required and what work is not to be completed by you. The scope is also important as it will directly affect your ability to make a variation claim (and associated extension of time claim), or to be subjected to directions from the principal or superintendent. Beware of vague or broadly drawn scopes of work, as the contract will usually require you to perform all work incidental to the scope without any right to a variation claim. Make sure all important documents are listed as contract documents and in the correct order (think in particular of important tender qualifications which may be in a register or similar document). Be careful with costs-plus contracts as in practice they may give rise to significant disputes. PAGE 6

Checklist Contract Approach, Documentation and Scope of Work Is the type of contract appropriate for what you are being asked (eg if construct only, is it a construct only contract, or is it more in the nature of a design and construct?) Is the contract scope of work clearly expressed and any specific inclusions and exclusions noted? Have all the documents that you want to rely on been included as contract documents (eg scope exclusions, tender qualifications and clarifications)? Are the contract documents listed in the correct order of importance (in general terms, usually the documents listed first take precedence)? Are the contract documents (including drawings and specifications) clearly described and itemised in the contract itself? Are you are seeking to rely on your own set of terms and conditions? If so, does the principal have a competing set of terms and conditions? If so does the contract spell out which set of terms and conditions applies? PAGE 7

Issues Contract Sum and Schedule of Rates The importance of clearly setting out what and how you are going to be paid cannot be emphasised enough. A surprising number of contracts fail to set out the basics. Special care must be taken where you have set a contract price or rate on certain assumptions (eg a particular construction methodology that you wish to adopt). You should ensure that these assumptions are clearly stated in the contract and that you have a right to claim additional payment in the event that (for whatever reason) these assumptions do not come to pass (eg a superintendent s direction to re-sequence the works prevents you from using your preferred construction methodology). Special care must also be taken with schedule of rates contracts, to make it clear what your rights are where the stated quantities prove unreliable, or where the bill items are not sufficient to cover all the work necessary for the job. PAGE 8

Checklist Contract Sum and Schedule of Rates Is the contract sum clearly expressed? Are prices and rates inclusive or exclusive of GST? If it is a re-measure schedule of rates contract, does the contract clearly express that? If there is a schedule of rates: How are you to be paid - by actual quantities worked or are the quantities in the schedule guaranteed/fixed? Are the bill items sufficient to cover all of the necessary work? Is there a clause which deals with missing bill items and if so do you get to claim additional payment for items of work not expressed in the schedule? If there is a schedule of rates according to which you are to be paid according to actual quantities worked: Is the method by which those quantities are to be measured (methods of measurement) clearly set out? Is there a clear and understandable mechanism for what happens when the quantities are exceeded by a certain amount (eg 20% of estimated quantities)? If there is a schedule of rates and you have priced the works according to an assumed methodology for approaching the work: Have you included your methodology as part of the contract? To what extent can the principal or superintendent change your methodology (eg a direction to re-sequence the works)? Does the contract permit a re-price if your assumed methodology cannot be used? PAGE 9

Issues Contract Programme Contract programmes vary in importance depending on the contract used. The programme may be one that is created by the contractor or it may be set by the principal or superintendent. If the principal or superintendent have the power to give directions in relation to programming (and the sequence of the works), you should consider your entitlements to additional payment, particularly if changes to the programme are likely to upset your methodology of work. Make sure you have put in the necessary technical input to come up with a realistic programme, particularly if breach of the programme will put you in breach of the contract. Head Contract Clauses It is common for there to be clauses referring to, or incorporating, a head contract. Often, the clauses are poorly drafted and give rise to significant uncertainty as to the extent to which the head contract governs a subcontractor s obligations under a subcontract. These clauses need to be considered carefully and wherever they occur you should demand a full copy of the head contract and all applicable drawings and specifications before you sign a subcontract. PAGE 10

Checklist Contract Programme Is the programme a contract document and if so what are the consequences if you breach it? Does the principal or superintendent have the ability to direct the sequence of the works and, if so, are you entitled to claim an additional payment for having to follow a different sequence? Head Contract Clauses Are there terms incorporating all or part of a head contract and if so: Is the incorporation clause clear about the role of the head contract in relation to the contract and the extent to which it is incorporated? Have you actually read and considered the head contract? To what extent does the head contract impose further obligations on you? Are you deemed to be aware of anything under the head contract that the main contractor has not given you (eg scope inclusions or parts of the specification that have not been provided to you)? PAGE 11

Issues Warranties Generally civil contractors will be performing a construct-only role with no design obligations. It is vital that the contract warranties reflect that. Construction contracts usually have provisions which detail the standards or qualities that the contractor must achieve. Care must be taken to ensure that you are not warranting or guaranteeing the work of others which is outside your scope of work. For example, if you warrant that the works when complete will be fit for their purpose, you may be assuming responsibility for the design of the works which may have been set by others. Where possible, you should limit your obligation to carry out the work in a proper and workmanlike manner. It is also common for a contractor to be required to supply warranties from third parties (eg manufacturers, suppliers and subcontractors). These clauses are frequently onerous and you need to consider before entering a contract whether you will be able to comply in practical terms. Security The type of security that has to be provided needs to be considered from a practical perspective. You should also look at the rights that the principal has in respect of security it is increasingly common for contracts to give principals wide ranging rights to have recourse to security, even where there is no specific debt due under the contract. For instance, a clause may entitle a principal to have recourse to security where the principal merely believes that it may have a claim against a contractor (eg for defective work). Wherever possible, restrict the principal s rights to access security to circumstances where you have actually breached the contract and the principal has a liquidated claim in respect of that breach. Where cash retention is not held on trust for you in a separate account, that retention may stand exposed to being lost in the event that the principal becomes insolvent. PAGE 12

Checklist Warranties What results, standards and qualities are you promising to achieve by the contract? Are you being asked to assume responsibility for designs drawn up by others? Are there any warranties requiring you to warrant that the works when complete will be fit for their purpose (if so these may be inappropriate unless you are also assuming a design responsibility)? Are you obliged to provide separate third party warranties (eg manufacturer warranties, supplier warranties, subcontractors warranties) and, if so, will you actually be able to provide those warranties? Security What security has to be provided and is it reasonable having regard to the contract value? If security is in the form of retention, is it being held on trust for you or can the principal mix and/or use the monies itself? When are you entitled to a return of security? Is the principal entitled to have recourse to security in a broad range of circumstances, such as the mere assertion of a claim against you? What rights do you and the principal have in relation to the security if a dispute arises? PAGE 13

Issues Site Access and Possession As civil contractors, you may find yourselves impeded in carrying out your work because of problems with site access or because you have to co-ordinate your works with others. Carefully consider what the contract says about these issues, and look at your entitlements (or lack thereof) in the event that you run into problems. Many construction contracts these days will try to bar you from making any time/cost claims when your works are impeded by other contractors. Practical Completion Frequently, standard definitions of practical completion are being added to, so that a whole host of other requirements are added in. For example, there maybe a requirement that all third party warranties have to be supplied or that you have to provide some documentation or certification before practical completion can be reached. You need to factor in these additional requirements (and the potential for delays in meeting them) before you agree to a date for practical completion. PAGE 14

Checklist Site Access and Possession Do you have to share the site with others working the site (eg principal s other contractors or consultants) and if so: Are you given any control over those other persons? Are you entitled to make any extension of time claim or payment claim in the event that the others impede your work? Practical Completion What is the definition of practical completion and how easy will it be for you to achieve it? Have you thought about possible delays in meeting all the requirements of the definition when agreeing to the contract programme? PAGE 15

Issues Extensions of Time and Prolongation Costs The right to claim an extension of time (and seek associated damages or costs for delay) is a fundamental issue for any contractor. The clauses governing these provisions should be fair and reasonable. Beware of unduly narrow or strict provisions which may make an otherwise lucrative contract unviable, particularly where the contractor is being asked to shoulder most, if not all of the risk for delay events. Care should also be taken to consider the role of the superintendent (or other subcontract certifier) in relation to granting extensions of time. Occasionally, the contract will try to suggest that the superintendent can act as he or she pleases without regard to your interests. Such clauses should be a red flag. PAGE 16

Checklist Extensions of Time and Prolongation Costs In what circumstances will you be entitled to claim an extension of time? Is the superintendent or principal obliged to act fairly and reasonably in relation to granting extensions of time or is the superintendent or principal given wide powers which may be difficult, if not impossible, to challenge? Examples of such wide powers include: The superintendent may in his sole and absolute discretion determine an extension of time claim. The superintendent is not obliged to act in accordance with the interests of the contractor in determining whether to grant an extension of time. Is there provision for you to claim additional payment claim for an extension of time and if so: In what circumstances will you be able to make such a claim? What is your claim limited to (eg does it include a margin or is it direct costs only)? How onerous are any time limits applying to: Extension of time claims? Claims for additional payment for delays? Will you lose your entitlement to claim an extension of time/ prolongation costs if you do not lodge a claim within time? PAGE 17

Issues Liquidated Damages Liquidated damages clauses are commonplace but are not always clearly expressed. Make sure you understand how the liquidated damages provisions work and what your maximum exposure is going to be. Be particularly wary of contracts where different rates apply for missing a variety of milestone dates if all the milestones are missed the overall rate of liquidated damages may be far greater than anticipated. Where possible, negotiate a cap on liquidated damages. Where a liquidated damages clause strikes you as unusually high or onerous, consider negotiating the clause down or at least require the principal to justify the rate. Remember, to be valid, a liquidated damages rate must be a genuine pre-estimate of the principal s loss. Payment Claims Payment claim clauses are frequently convoluted and tortuously drafted, with extensive procedures made for an initial claim, assessment of that claim, issuing an invoice and making payment. It is critical for these clauses to be effective that they comprehensively set out a procedure for: when and how a payment claim is to be made; when and how a payment claim is to be assessed; and when payment is to be made. If the contract does not set out these matters clearly, the implied terms of the Construction Contracts Act 2004 (WA) may apply and override what the contract says and this can occur without the parties even realising that those provisions apply. Note also that the Construction Contracts Act 2004 (WA) will read down provisions which permit the principal to pay on greater than 50 day terms to 50 days. PAGE 18

Checklist Liquidated Damages If there is provision for liquidated damages, are the rates of liquidated damages clearly expressed and capable of application? If there are different rates of liquidated damages applicable to different milestone dates, do you understand what your maximum exposure to damages is going to be? If there is provision for liquidated damages, are the rates a reasonable pre-estimate of the loss that the principal will suffer by reason of delay? Payment Claims In relation to making a payment claim under the contract (not just for progress payments, but any contractual claim for payment including variations), does the contract clearly set out: When a payment claim is to be made? How to make a payment claim? When and how the payment claim will be assessed by the principal and superintendent? When the principal is obliged to pay each payment claim? What happens if something goes wrong in relation to a payment claim, including: failing to make a payment claim on time; and the principal or superintendent failing to assess a payment claim? Are the payment terms longer than 50 days (from the date a payment claim is made)? PAGE 19

Issues Variations Variation clauses control what changes can be made by the principal, whether you will get paid for making them and how much you will get paid. Check the definition of what constitutes varied work and have regard to any applicable scope of work document. Check the valuation method carefully to ensure you will receive fair compensation for varied work. Where the principal or superintendent is given sole or absolute discretion to value variations, you may find yourself unable to challenge such variations. Beware of restrictions on your right to claim where the variation direction is not in the prescribed format. Beware of claim bars where correct procedure for variations is not followed make sure your project management team can handle these. Beware of clauses which permit the principal to omit works from your scope and assign those works to others these clauses can be used as a device for a de facto termination of the contract. PAGE 20

Checklist Variations What variations are you obliged to carry out? How onerous are the procedures surrounding the direction of variations? Do you lose your claim if you do not strictly follow those procedures? Do variation directions have to be in a particular format and if so what happens if a variation direction is given in a different format (eg via an issued for construction drawing with no mention of a variation)? How are variations to be valued and in particular: By reference to what standards, rates or prices will the variation be valued? Are the valuation provisions fair to all parties? Are there clauses which purport to give the principal or superintendent the sole or absolute discretion to value variations (if so these may be difficult, if not impossible, to challenge)? Do you have a right to challenge an adverse valuation or are the principal and superintendent entitled to make a final certificate or assessment? Is the valuation process so drawn out that you are forced to carry the costs of performing the varied work in the meantime? Does the valuation of variation include delay and disruption costs as well? If so you may be restricted to a single claim for all costs/loss associated with the variation. PAGE 21

Issues Latent Conditions Be aware of exactly what constitutes a latent condition and what does not, and what your entitlements (to extensions of time and payment) are in the event you encounter a latent condition. Beware of any contractual procedures applicable to make a claim in respect of a latent condition. Beware of clauses which make you responsible to deal with any site contamination or other unforeseen site problems. Information Disclaimers Beware of information disclaimers where the principal excuses itself of responsibility for any errors in the information it has provided you. Where these clauses exist, you may not be able to make a claim where you relied on that information (eg a geotechnical report in relation to ground water conditions or the existence of rock). Accordingly you may have to undertake expensive site investigations yourself. PAGE 22

Checklist Latent Conditions Is there a latent condition clause and if not are you otherwise able to rely on unforeseen events to claim an extension of time and additional payment? If there is a clause: What is the definition of latent condition and is it appropriate? What are your entitlements to an extension of time in the event of a latent condition? What are your entitlements to additional payment in the event of a latent condition? What are the procedures for making a claim and are they fair and reasonable? Are there clauses which make you responsible for making your own site investigations no matter what information (however detailed) the principal has given you? If so have you carried out those investigations? Are you being asked to take on the risks pre-existing site contamination? Information Disclaimers Are you relying on information provided to you by the principal in planning the works (eg a geotechnical report)? Is there an information disclaimer clause that covers that report? If so, have you undertaken your own investigations? PAGE 23

Issues Limitations of Liability Subject to the contract s terms, damages for breach of contract are generally open ended and are payable in respect of consequential losses that the innocent party may incur. Exposure to a contract damages claim can be indeterminate and substantial, particularly in the context of mining or similar high value projects where breaches by you may cause significant knock on effects for the project. You will need to consider your exposure to such losses and whether that exposure is or can be limited in some way by the contract. You will also need to consider whether the principal has imposed a limit on the amount of damages that you can recover from it. It is common for construction contracts to exclude liability for consequential loss. This limitation can be for the benefit of both parties or may only allow for one party to rely upon it, in which case it will likely be in favour of the principal. Any limitation of liability clause should be clearly drafted and understood by you. You should also inform your insurance broker of any limitations of liability (particularly limits on the principal s liability) as these may impact whether your existing insurance policies will respond. PAGE 24

Checklist Limitations of Liability Should there be a limitation of liability to protect you (may be important where breaches by you could cause massive consequential loss - eg on a mine development)? If there is a limitation on liability: Is it clearly expressed and do you understand its scope and effect? Does the limitation work in both parties favour or just one party s favour? Has your insurance broker checked for any adverse insurance implications? PAGE 25

Issues Indemnities and Insurance Usually as a civil contractor you will be called upon to grant indemnities to the principal. Carefully consider indemnities before executing the contract and ensure that they are fair and reasonable and properly reflect the extent of the obligations you are assuming in taking the job on. It is vital that any indemnities and warranties that you are giving refer to matters within your knowledge and control and that you have an ability to influence the content covered by those indemnities and warranties. Closely allied with the indemnities will usually be a clause requiring you to secure insurance. You need to ensure that you can obtain this insurance (and get an idea of the cost of doing so) before you enter the contract. If (as is common) the proportionate liability provisions of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA) are excluded, you will be potentially liable to the principal for 100% of the loss it suffers by reason of a breach of contract, even if other parties may have contributed to that loss. You should also ensure that any insurance you obtain reflects any exclusion of the proportionate liability provisions. Give your broker the contract and make sure that appropriate policy extensions are in place. PAGE 26

Checklist Indemnities and Insurance What indemnities are you giving under the contract? Are they fair and reasonable? Do you have the ability to control whether the indemnity will be applied or are you being asked to guarantee the conduct of others beyond your control? Are (as is common) the proportionate liability provisions of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA) excluded (eg by an express provision or implicitly via the inclusion of an arbitration clause)? Have you had your broker review the provisions to make sure that the necessary insurance is available on the market and the cost of obtaining it? PAGE 27

Issues Claim Bars and Time Bars Many construction contracts contain bars on claims that the contractor can make against the principal. These frequently include onerous time limits and procedures for the lodging of claims and provision for the loss of a claim if those procedures are not strictly complied with. Make sure that your project management team will be able to comply with these limits and wherever possible negotiate relaxations of the clauses (eg get 30 days to lodge notice of a claim rather than five days). You should also consider whether there are any hidden bars for instance, in a termination clause a clause that says that if the principal repudiates the contract the contractor is not entitled to claim damages on a quantum meruit basis. Such clauses can potentially affect your ability to claim fair compensation when the principal wrongly repudiates a contract. Termination Clauses Many construction contracts allow the principal to terminate the contract for convenience and set out the extent of the contractor s entitlements in that event. Usually the clause will bar recovery of a loss of profit by the contractor on the job. Check these clauses carefully and make sure they provide for fair compensation, at least for the value of work done and other costs that you unavoidably incur in the event that the principal avails itself of this option. Early termination by a principal may have a significant adverse impact of your business cash flow. PAGE 28

Checklist Claim Bars and Time Bars Where there are claim and time bars, how onerous are these and do you have the resources (project managers etc) to ensure timely compliance? Are the timeframes for giving notice of claims reasonable and will your project management team be able to comply? Are there any bars that apply to you even where the principal is in default (eg a clause which precludes you from claiming damages on a quantum meruit basis in the event that the principal defaults)? What are the bars that apply to claims when a final certificate is issued and do those clauses give you a reasonable opportunity to put claims in before the issue of the final certificate? Termination Clauses What are the principal s rights of termination? Can the principal terminate at any time for convenience? If so, what are your rights and entitlements if this occurs and are they fair? Are there any limitations on your right to terminate or on your rights and entitlements if you choose to terminate (even if it is the principal s fault)? PAGE 29

Issues Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) Issues If your principal or client were to become insolvent, you need to consider how you will claw back loose goods, plant and equipment that may be on site and which may fall into the possession of an administrator and liquidator. This is particularly important where you may have valuable goods, plant and equipment on site for sustained periods of time, or where you are hiring any plant or equipment out. You can no longer assume that your ownership of goods, plant or equipment can be relied upon to get back possession of those things when a principal or client becomes insolvent. Rather, to protect your ownership rights, it may be necessary for you to register your interests on the Personal Property Securities Registrar (PPSR). For example, ordinarily, goods you supply under a civil works contract can be registered on the online PPSR as a purchase money security interest (PMSI). PMSIs generally take priority over any other secured claim. However, if you do not register and a principal becomes insolvent you may well lose your rights to those goods to an administrator or liquidator and your legal ownership will not count. If you decide to register, you should register on the PPSR as early and as frequently as possible as time limits apply. In general terms, to achieve the highest levels of protection, your interest must have been registered on the PPSR within 15 business days of supply of the good/ hire of the equipment. Further, it is now commonplace for construction contracts to contain Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA) clauses, especially those contracts involving the hire or supply of plant, equipment and goods. A reasonably and fairly worded PPSA clause in the agreement can assist you in ensuring that you are free to protect your ownership rights under the PPSA. PAGE 30

Checklist Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) Issues You should look to register on the PPSR where: you will be supplying valuable goods to site which may be sitting on site for a period before being incorporated into the works; you will be supplying plant or equipment that will be on site for a sustained period; you are hiring or lending any plant or equipment to a client. If you intend to register on the PPSR, have you done so correctly and within the relevant time limit? If you do not know what to do, have you taken specialist advice such as from a lawyer? Remember you may need to act quickly to properly protect your interests do not wait until there is a problem. Does your contract contain a PPSA clause? If so does it permit you to register on the PPSR or does it try to prevent you from doing so? PAGE 31

Issues Dispute Resolution Clauses Construction contracts usually have a dispute resolution procedure. Some work better than others. Be aware of clauses that are inappropriate (eg submitting all disputes to arbitration in a different place other than Perth or WA). Be aware of clauses which give an expert power to determine all disputes arising under the contract which may mean you are at the mercy of an expert for legal as well as technical disputes. Consider whether there is any restriction on your ability to recover legal costs in the event of a dispute. Specifications The specifications to a construction contract frequently include boilerplate clauses that sit uneasily with the general and/or special conditions. Check for any clashing terms. Understand your specifications fully and make sure you can comply with any particular standard or tolerance requirement set out. PAGE 32

Checklist Dispute Resolution Clauses Are disputes to be determined in Western Australia or is a different law of the contract or place for determining disputes nominated? If there is an arbitration or expert determination clause, are there provisions governing what types of disputes can be sent to the arbitrator or expert? If an expert determination clause is open-ended and applies to all disputes, are you prepared to have any dispute arising under the contract submitted to an expert for determination? Are you entitled to your legal costs of an arbitration or expert determination? Specifications Do the specifications have boilerplate clauses that supplement or even contradict the main contract general conditions? Have you checked the specifications carefully (including any applicable head contract specification) to ensure that you are aware of any specific tolerances that you are required to meet? PAGE 33

Issues Notes PAGE 34

CCF WA MEMBER OPPORTUNITY: FIXED PRICE CONTRACT REVIEWS WITH LAVAN LEGAL YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A LEGAL REVIEW OF YOUR CONTRACT FOR A FRACTION OF WHAT YOU THOUGHT IT MIGHT COST KEY BENEFITS OF WORKING WITH LAVAN LEGAL: Harness the expertise of Lavan Legal s team of construction lawyers, who are based in Western Australia and understand the civil contracting market. Have the certainty of a fixed price. Special rates for CCF members which are competitive and can save you valuable dollars by helping to manage project risk. Obtain pragmatic and commercial legal advice for the purposes of contract negotiations. Understand your legal risk and go into a project with your eyes open. Fast turnaround (generally within 24-48 hours). LAVAN LEGAL S FIXED PRICE CONTRACT REVIEW RATES FOR CCF WA MEMBERS: BAND 1 CONTRACT SUM UP TO $750,000 (excl GST) Fixed price review fee: $750.00 excl GST BAND 2 CONTRACT SUM $751,000 to $1,500,000 (excl GST) Fixed price review fee: $1,250.00 excl GST BAND 3 CONTRACT SUM $1,501,000 to $5,000,000 (excl GST) Fixed price review fee: $1,750.00 excl GST BAND 4 CONTRACT SUM $5,000,001 to $20,000,000 (excl GST) Fixed price review fee: $2,250.00 excl GST BAND 5 CONTRACT SUM >$20,000,000 Price on application Call today on (08) 9288 6000 and speak to one of our qualified team members! TERMS AND CONDITIONS Terms and conditions apply, namely: Applies to construction contract reviews only (other types of contract POA). A contract review includes provision of a letter or email identifying unusual or problematic terms. A contract review does not extend to drafting revised or reworded clauses, nor to negotiation of the contract. Additional legal services can be provided by separate agreement if required.

Civil Contractors Federation - WA Branch P: (08) 9414 1486 www.ccfwa.com.au