Additional Insured Endorsements The topic of additional insured status is a difficult one at best. Many misconceptions result when adding contracting parties to one another s insurance policies as additional insureds. There is also the tug-of-war between insurers and indemnitors that want to limit the scope of additional insured coverage under their policies and the indemnitees who want to maximize coverage under the policies of the indemnitors. Added to this, the interaction of additional insured status with indemnity clauses, insurance requirements, and other contract provisions is unique and complex. This session will examine the reasons for requiring, methods of achieving, and problems associated with additional insured status under various policies. Copyright 2016 International Risk Management Institute, Inc. 1 www.irmi.com
Notes This file is set up for duplexed printing. Therefore, there are pages that are intentionally left blank. If you print this file, we suggest that you set your printer to duplex. 2
Additional Insured Endorsements WHY MUST THEY TORTURE ME? How One Little Piece of Paper Changed an Industry 2 3
E&O The ultimate additional insured endorsement 3 What Is(n t) A Certificate Of Insurance? Informational snapshot only Cannot modify a policy Is not a contract (or is it?) 4 4
Three Types Of Certificate Desires I have a dream Here s what I ll settle for Deal-breaker 5 Four Types Of Certificate Requests Uninsurable Any Acts, errors, omissions Any and all liabilities Claims, costs, expenses, liabilities, penalties, fines Primary and Non-contributory What does non-contributory mean? Non-CGL policies Equivalent or comparable 6 5
Four Types Of Certificate Requests Illegal Non-existent coverage Withdrawn endorsements Transfer of sole negligence Certificate modifications Striking through / amending language / disclaimers ACORD copyright violation Statute, regulation or DOI directive violation 7 Four Types Of Certificate Requests Inappropriate Cancellation notice No longer provided Endeavor to was a pipe dream Non-ACORD Certificates Usually require company approval Improper request or copyright infringement 8 6
Four Types Of Certificate Requests Inappropriate Comprehensive General Liability Comprehensive Automobile Liability Agent attestation ( in the opinion of the agent, the policy contains the required insurance coverages/indemnifications required by the contract with the insured ) 9 Four Types Of Certificate Requests Impractical Unavailable or expensive Completed operations, EIFS, pollution, subsidence, mold, etc. No time to search market before certificate is due 10 7
Weird Requests Ongoing operations XYZ Corporation and its officers, directors, partners, members, and employees coverage to continue for (5) (10) years x, c and u exclusions removed Blanket contractual liability Broad form property damage 11 Other Issues Certificate limit v. policy limit Impaired aggregates Deductibles and SIRs Defense within limits Known loss or damage Umbrella and excess policies Copyright issues Carrier agreements Your authority extends to issuance of standard, unaltered Certificates of Insurance (ACORD 24 or 25) 12 8
Use The Proper Form ACORD Certificates 20 Certificate of Aviation Liability Insurance 21 Certificate of Aircraft Insurance 22 Intermodal Interchange Certificate of Insurance 23 Vehicle or Equipment Certificate of Insurance 24 Certificate of Property Insurance 25 Certificate of Liability Insurance 27 Evidence of Property Insurance 28 Evidence of Commercial Property Insurance 29 Evidence of Flood Insurance 30 Certificate of Garage Insurance 31 Certificate of Marine/Energy Insurance 13 What You Should (and Should Not) Do DO provide a disclaimer to the insured and certificateholder DO NOT exceed your legal or contractual authority DO work with the insured s attorney or minimize contract review DO NOT modify an ACORD certificate DO proof-read all certificates and perform periodic audits DO establish a procedure for handling certificates DO always send the entire certificate (both pages) DO be judicious with the big white box the FIG indicates you should put any exclusion endorsement or special policy condition 14 9
What You Should (and Should Not) Do DO send copies of certificates to all insurers/mgas/wholesalers DO use the correct form DO NOT use proprietary or non-acord forms without company approval DO NOT certify coverages that don t exist DO NOT indicate limits on a certificate that satisfy the request when actual policy limits are higher DO NOT sign any certification or attestation without management approval 15 10
Additional Insured Changes 16 2013 Changes 24 revised forms Many changes are due to state anti-indemnity statutes Coverage for AI is only to the extent provided by law Coverage for the AI cannot be more broad than that provided to the Named Insured New forms CG 20 01 Primary and Non-Contributory Other Insurance Endorsement Requires AI to be an NI on other available insurance Written contract must state that our insured s policy be primary and not seek contribution from other insurance of the AI CG 20 38 Additional Insured Owners, Lessees or Contractors Automatic Status for Other Parties When Required in Written Construction Contract Agreement 17 11
2013 Changes 18 2013 Changes 45 states have anti-indemnification statutes that restrict, modify, or invalidate indemnification agreements in construction and other contracts These statutes frequently prohibit the transfer of an indemnitee s sole (or concurrent) negligence through an indemnification agreement ISO may be attempting to genericize the endorsement to conform to the various state laws without the need to create state-specific endorsements The ultimate impact of this change will remain unknown until ISO issues clarification or there are judicial decisions 19 12
2013 Changes 20 2013 Changes 21 13
Other Issues Contractual Liability 22 Blanket Additional Insured Endorsements The use of blanket AI endorsements restricts the ability to provide notice of cancellation. When blanket endorsements are used, the insurer does not have a list of additional insureds or addresses. They are not aware of additional insureds' identities until a claim is made. Obviously insurers can't provide notice of cancellation to unidentified parties. 23 14
Blanket Additional Insured Endorsements 24 Resources Statutes and Regulation www.iiaba.net/vu/nonmember/wilsoncertlawsregs.htm Court Cases www.iiaba.net/vu/nonmember/wilsoncertcourtcases.htm 25 15
Notes This file is set up for duplexed printing. Therefore, there are pages that are intentionally left blank. If you print this file, we suggest that you set your printer to duplex. 16