How State Policies Impact Local Property Taxes Adam H. Langley 1
Pennsylvania Tax Swap Property Tax Independence Act (SB 67) Eliminate school property tax, except for debt service Income tax: 3.07% to 4.34% State sales tax: 6% to 7% Expanded tax base 2015 Senate Vote: 24-24 tie Lt. Gov. voted against bill Bill sponsors will try again Efforts in other states FL, TX, WA 2
Chicago Tax Increase (2015) $588m increase over four years Primarily for police/fire pensions 2016: Average residential bill 13% 60% of four year hike of city tax $250m increase for Chicago Schools expected this month Teachers pensions 3
Lincoln Institute of Land Policy Finding answers in land. Think tank focused on solving major challenges through creative approaches to use and taxation of land Property tax matters because it s the linchpin of municipal fiscal health 4
Outline Data on property tax rates Why property taxes vary across cities State policy options 5
Data on Property Taxes Effective tax rate ETR = (Tax Bill) / (Market Value) Accounts for: Differences in assessment ratios Exemptions and credits Accuracy of assessments All overlying governments Report Largest city, rural city in each state 4 property types (Homestead, commercial, industrial, apartments) 6
Homestead Property Tax Rate (2015) Effective Tax Rate on Median Valued Home CT: Bridgeport (1) MI: Detroit (2) IL: Aurora* (3) 3.88% 3.81% 3.72% NJ: Newark (4) WI: Milwaukee (5) 2.68% 3.05% U.S. Average 1.50% MA: Boston (49) CO: Denver (50) AL: Birmingham (51) WY: Cheyenne (52) HI: Honolulu (53) 0.67% 0.66% 0.66% 0.65% 0.30% *Report includes two cities in IL and NY, because tax systems for Chicago and New York City are very different than rest of state. 7
Property Taxes on Median Valued Home (2015) Rate Rank Bill Rank Effective Tax Rate Tax Bill 0 1,401 2,802 4,203 5,604 7,005 CT: Bridgeport ( 1, 2) 3.88% MI: Detroit ( 2, 42) IL: Aurora ( 3, 3) 3.81% 3.72% NJ: Newark ( 4, 4) WI: Milwaukee ( 5, 16) 2.68% 3.05% MA: Boston (49, 20) AL: Birmingham (50, 53) CO: Denver (51, 34) WY: Cheyenne (52, 48) HI: Honolulu (53, 37) 0.67% 0.66% 0.66% 0.65% 0.30% 0.5x ( $1,400) 1x ( $2,800) 1.5x ( $4,200) 2x ( $5,600) 0.00% 0.75% 1.50% 2.26% 3.01% 3.76% Tax Relative to U.S. Average 2.5x ( $7,000) 8
Commercial Property Tax Rate (2015) Effective Tax Rate on $1 Million Property MI: Detroit (1) NY: New York City (2) RI: Providence (3) IL: Chicago (4) CT: Bridgeport (5) 4.13% 3.96% 3.71% 3.60% 3.59% U.S. Average 2.11% DE: Wilmington (49) VA: Virginia Beach (50) HI: Honolulu (51) WA: Seattle (52) WY: Cheyenne (53) 1.04% 1.03% 0.91% 0.88% 0.64% 9
Commercial-Homestead Classification Ratio (2015) (Effective tax rate on $1-million commercial property vs. median valued home) NY: New York City (1) MA: Boston (2) SC: Columbia (3) HI: Honolulu (4) CO: Denver (5) IL: Chicago (6) IN: Indianapolis (7) LA: New Orleans (8) AL: Birmingham (9) KS: Wichita (10) DC: Washington (11) PA: Philadelphia (12) WV: Charleston (13) MN: Minneapolis (14) AZ: Phoenix (15) ID: Boise (16) U.S. Average 2.73 2.65 2.20 2.19 2.18 2.17 2.12 2.11 2.09 2.07 2.04 1.68 4.22 4.00 3.69 3.62 3.62 40 of 53 cities favor homesteads: -27 have lower assessment ratios and/or nominal tax rates -13 cities, classification solely the result of exemptions/credits 10
Why do Property Tax Rates Vary? 11
Key Factors that Explain Differences in Effective Tax Rates on Median Valued Homes Other 27% Home Values 31% Local Gov't Spending 7% Property Tax Classification 8% Property Tax Reliance 27% Source: 50-State Property Tax Comparison Study: For Taxes Paid in 2015 (Page 8). 12
Property Values Low property values > Need high tax rates High property values > Modest tax rates raise a lot of revenue Detroit Median home value: $42,000 Tax rate: 3.14% Tax bill $1,300 San Francisco Median home value: $847,000 Tax rate: 0.83% Tax bill $7,000 Average tax bill in our study: $3,039 Detroit would need a tax rate 20x higher than San Francisco 13
Property Tax Reliance High property tax reliance: Property tax rates High local sales/income taxes: Property tax rates Bridgeport (CT) Birmingham (AL) Property tax rate Highest 4 th Lowest Per capita taxes for local governments (2013) Property tax $1,891 $767 Sales tax 0 866 Income tax 0 353 Other taxes 23 443 Total Taxes $1,914 $2,429 Source: Per capita taxes from Fiscally Standardized Cities database (Lincoln Institute of Land Policy). 14
Classification Preferences built into property tax system for homesteads Tax rates for homesteads Tax rates for business properties New York City Commercial-homestead ratio: 4.2x Apartment-homestead ratio: 5.1x 7 th lowest tax rate on homes 2 nd highest commercial tax Highest tax on apartments 15
Local Government Spending Higher local gov t spending Property tax rates DC: Washington CA: San Francisco NY: New York City CA: Oakland CA: Los Angeles Average for Cities MS: Jackson OK: Oklahoma City MT: Billings ID: Boise HI: Honolulu Per Capita Expenditures by Local Governments (2013) 18,680 12,904 12,229 9,986 9,074 6,015 3,507 3,425 3,193 2,829 2,464 Source: Direct expenditures from Fiscally Standardized Cities database (Lincoln Institute of Land Policy). 16
Four Key Factors Driving Property Taxes Property Values State aid necessary to offset differences in property wealth across communities Property Tax Reliance Local tax options determined by state law State aid can substitute for local taxes Property Tax Classification Local gov t ability to impose higher tax rates on business and use homestead exemptions determined by state law Local Gov t Spending State mandates State vs. local service responsibilities 17
State Policy Options 18
Think Twice Moving Away from Property Tax Tax swaps are popular, but have serious downsides: Tax revenues more volatile Tax system more regressive (If sales taxes increased) 19
Revenue Changes During Great Recession (% Chg. in Real Per Capita State-Local Tax Revenues, Peak to Trough) Property Tax Sales Tax Income Tax -6.5% -11.2% -19.5% Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Annual Surveys of State and Local Government Finances. 20
8% State-Local Taxes as % Family Income Property Tax Sales & Excise Taxes 6% 4% 2% 0% Lowest 20% Second 20% Middle 20% Fourth 20% Next 15% Next 4% Top 1% Source: Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy. Who Pays (5 th Edition). 21
Tax Limits Assessment limits (CA Prop. 13) Constrains annual growth in assessed value of individual properties Severs connection between property values and taxes Large horizontal inequities Unpredictable winners and losers Create disincentive to move Levy limits (MA Prop. 2 ½) Constrains annual growth in tax levy for entire municipality But individual tax bills still based on market values Limits property taxes without as many unintended consequences 22
Circuit Breakers Circuit breakers prevent households from being overburdened by property taxes Targeted and cost-effective approach Focuses on households with heaviest tax burdens Seniors on fixed incomes; People who lost their job Classic approach sets a threshold percentage of income that property taxes must exceed before any tax relief is available Circuit breaker benefit offsets taxes above this point 23
Property Tax as % Income 10% 5% Threshold Circuit Breaker 8% 6% 4% 2% Circuit breaker kicks in above 5% Circuit breaker credit Property Tax Due 0% Home 1 Home 2 Home 3 Home 4 Home 5 24
Property Tax Escrow People pay tax monthly $ goes to account to pay off annual or bi-annual property tax installment Mortgage escrow (2014 American Community Survey) 44% of homeowners pay property tax as part of mortgage bill 20% have mortgage, but not property tax escrow 37% do not have mortgage 25
Property Tax Escrow 46% of Americans couldn t come up with $400 in emergency (Federal Reserve survey) $400 Median Property Tax Bill = $2,139 Monthly Bill = $178 Source: Federal Reserve Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2015; 2014 American Community Survey (U.S. Census Bureau). 26
Property Tax Escrow Local option programs where tax collectors manage property tax escrow systems a.k.a. Prepayment agreements, escrow plans, monthly payments Low participation, but big potential Monthly automated payments via credit/debit card, checking account Pay monthly via check States could help set-up billing system Indiana: Monthly Installment Plans (IC 6-1.1-22-9.7) Most widely used program Washington [RCW 84.56.020(11)] Passed in 2015; Spokane County has payment agreements 27
Conclusions Large differences in property taxes due to four factors Property values: Low values Tax Property tax reliance: Low sales/income tax Property Tax Local gov t spending: Higher spending Tax Property Tax Classification: Homestead tax, Business tax State options for cost-effective property tax relief Circuit breakers: Relief for those w/highest tax relative to income Property tax escrow: Break large lump-sum into monthly payments States should be cautious about Tax swaps: Make tax system more volatile and regressive Tax limits Assessment limits (CA Prop 13): Horizontal inequities, lock-in Levy limits (MA Prop 2 ½): Fewer unintended consequences 28
Thank You! Adam H. Langley ALangley@lincolninst.edu 617-503-2117 www.lincolninst.edu 113 BRATTLE STREET CAMBRIDGE MA 02138 LINCOLNINST.EDU @LANDPOLICY 29