Operating Budget Fiscal Year 2016 17 Council Work Session March 22, 2016 Topics for Review City Council s Guiding Principles Budget Process Improvements in Revenue Reserve Requirements Budgetary Savings Employee Benefits Budget recommendations State Budget Update Remaining Action 2 1
City Council s Guiding Principles No increase in the real estate tax rate No new fees No supplanting of losses in state or federal funds with local revenue Review all vacant positions for possible elimination Identify operating efficiencies and reduce spending accordingly Identify non core services for possible consolidation, curtailment or elimination 3 Budget Process Revenue forecast completed by budget office 3 year budget plans prepared by departments Analytical inquiry and review by budget office Budget Review Committee Includes City Manager, Deputy City Manager, City Attorney, Chief Information Officer, Purchasing Officer, and Directors of Budget, Finance, and Human Resources Reconcile budget plans with available resources City Manager Recommendation Council Appropriations 4 2
Improvements in Revenue Entity wide revenue increases by $49.6 million (5.2%) General Fund revenue increases by $17.3 million (3.3%) Property tax revenues increase 3.4% No change in tax rates recommended Real estate assessments increased 1.5% Net new construction increases revenue by 1.6% Current real estate taxes contribute to preponderance of increase Increase in collections of delinquent taxes, especially personal property Current personal property taxes very small increase Other local tax revenues increase 5.6% Strength in consumer taxes: sales taxes up 6.8%; restaurant taxes up 8.2% Improvements in business licenses (BPOL) and recordation taxes No changes recommended in tax rates 5 Improvements in Revenue, continued Permits up 12.7% Relatively small source of revenue ($2.5 million in FY 2017) Most of the increases are related to construction activity Charges for services up 13.0% General Fund increase primarily EMS collections Public Utilities 4.9% increase in water and sewer rates Opening of Dominion Boulevard Increased service billings CIBH Chesapeake Public Schools increases 5% Primarily state revenue Rebenchmarking New composite index 6 3
Revenue Trends ( in millions) General Fund All Funds FY 2009 $ 518.8 $ 940.1 FY 2010 $ 509.0 1.9% $ 925.3 1.6% FY 2011 $ 499.0 2.0% $ 902.8 2.4% FY 2012 $ 502.2 0.6% $ 910.2 0.8% FY 2013 $ 501.9 0.0% $ 896.0 1.6% FY 2014 $ 507.6 1.1% $ 913.5 2.0% FY 2015 $ 523.9 3.2% $ 937.5 2.6% FY 2016* $ 526.1 0.4% $ 947.2 1.0% FY 2017* $ 543.4 3.3% $ 996.8 5.2% FY 2018** $ 555.4 2.2% FY 2019** $ 567.7 2.2% *Budgeted Revenue **Revenue Projections 7 Revenue All Funds Revenue (in millions) FY 2015 Actual FY 2016 Budget FY 2017 Budget Increase from FY 2016 Local Revenue General Property Taxes $ 307.21 $ 311.09 $ 321.66 $ 10.57 3.4% Other Local Taxes 132.71 131.49 138.81 7.32 5.6% Charges for Services 116.27 119.14 134.62 15.48 13.0% Other Local Revenue 20.51 16.37 17.29 0.92 5.6% Local Revenue $ 576.70 $ 578.09 $ 612.38 $ 34.29 5.9% State Revenue 317.59 327.03 342.47 15.44 4.7% Federal Revenue 43.23 42.09 41.96 (0.13) 0.3% Total Revenue $ 937.52 $ 947.21 $ 996.81 $ 49.60 5.2% 8 4
Reserve Requirements Charter and Policy Reserve Add $1.04 million of GF revenue to reserve required by Charter (6%) Add $2.08 million of GF revenue to unassigned fund balance (policy 12%) Add $188,000 of TIF revenue to reserves (18%) Locked Revenue for Capital Schools $26.2 million of locked revenue Debt service and cash funding of capital $20.3 million City $20.1 million of locked revenue Debt service and cash funding of capital $13.7 million Up to $8.5 million of capital locked revenue is needed for Spring 2016 debt issuances Excess locked revenue is added to Fund Balance as a commitment 9 Budgetary Savings Employee Benefits Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB) FY 2016 Budget based on estimates of Annual Required Contributions $10.7 million FY 2017 Budget based on estimates of Annual Required Contributions $2.9 million Savings for FY 2017 $7.8 million (73% reduction) Primary factor Medicare eligible retirees Future risk investment returns Virginia Retirement System Employee retirement costs FY 2016 Budget $18.5 million FY 2017 Budget based on estimates of Annual Required Contributions $16.6 million Savings for FY 2017 $1.9 million (10% reduction) Primary factors positive investment returns, hybrid program Future risk investment returns 10 5
Other Employee Benefits Employee healthcare increases $534,500 Moderate largely because FY 2016 budget understated non participants Health care budget based on December 2015 employee selections with 6% increase starting December 2016 6% of Employer s annual subsidy = $1.5 million Disability benefits increase $187,300 Most of increase ($150,000) provides new coverage to Plan 1 and 2 employees Most of remainder is for new hybrid participants Group life insurance increases $97,800 (increased rates) Worker compensation increases $586,600 Prior year trends Increased funding of Risk Fund to address fund deficit 11 Expenditures and Transfers All Funds Expenditures (in millions) FY 2015 Actual FY 2016 Budget FY 2017 Budget Increase from FY 2016 Governance/Management $ 23.78 $ 26.77 $ 26.21 $ (0.56) 2.1% Quality Community of Life 78.71 88.07 89.37 1.30 1.5% Economic/Environmental Vitality 139.60 161.04 171.71 10.67 6.6% Public Safety and Justice 137.81 148.90 150.18 1.28 0.9% Education 446.37 453.47 467.99 14.52 3.2% Debt Service Fund 52.93 39.40 42.30 2.90 7.4% Non Departmental 13.91 20.16 19.69 (0.47) 2.3% Total Expenditures $ 893.11 $ 937.81 $ 967.45 $ 29.64 3.2% Capital/Grant Transfers 46.92 25.66 45.55 19.89 77.5% Expenditures + Transfers $ 940.03 $ 963.47 $ 1,013.0 $ 49.53 5.1% 12 6
BUDGET RECOMMENDATIONS FY 2016 2017 13 City Portion of Operating Budget Net Increases (Decreases) in Budget Chesapeake Public Schools (revenue sharing formula adds) Employee compensation Across board general wage increase 2.5% effective July 1, 2016 Recognition of superior performance Public Safety Career Path added funds to cover full year Compression adjustment part time/seasonal/substitute employees Estimates include adjusting all pay scales by 1.5% Payroll efficiencies Convert to arrears pay for all employees New positions added (44.8 FTE net), including reclassifications Debt service for Spring 2016 borrowings (city and schools) Regional jail commitment $ 7.4 million $ 5.8 million $ 0.5 million $ 0.4 million $ 0.1 million $ 3.5 million $ 3.2 million $ 8.5 million $ 1.6 million 14 7
New Positions Recommended CIBH new and expanded services 17.5 FTE $1.12 million City Attorney attorney(pt offset) 0.4 FTE $ 88,500 City Manager records manager (citywide) 1.0 FTE $ 64,300 Develop & Permits reorganization 1.0 FTE $ 1,200 Finance continue spec. project (payroll) 1.0 FTE $ 64,200 Fire fiscal administrator (with offset) 0.0 FTE $ 26,800 Human Resources continue spec project 1.0 FTE $ 59,900 IT reorganization/mainframe transition 0.0 FTE $ 74,700 PRT recreational specialists and leaders 6.2 FTE $225,200 Housekeeping new PS Operations Bldg. (part year) 2.0 FTE $ 17,300 Public Utilities service gaps/productivity 10.0 FTE $536,850 15 New Positions Recommended, continued Police Animal Services Outreach 0.6 FTE $ 22,700 Police FOIA office spec, video technician 2.0 FTE $ cost offset Police additional police officers (incl. equipment) 3.0 FTE $ 339,600 PW Stormwater office asst. compliance reports 1.0 FTE $ 40,400 PW Traffic traffic signal technician 1.0 FTE $ 51,700 Sheriff reclassification data control techs 0.0 FTE $ 87,500 Central Fleet add PT drivers for vehicle delivery 1.3 FTE $ 34,000 Mosquito Control reactivate mechanic tech 1.0 FTE $ 31,600 Other reclassifications/part time citywide 4.8 FTE $ 57,500 Removed from Complement: Agriculture transferred to state payroll 4.0 FTE cost offset Development & Permits temporary positions 4.0 FTE CIP funding 16 8
Dominion Boulevard Completion Capital project must be complete by April 2017 Considerable incentives are available for early completion Current estimates indicate completion between September and December 2016 CTS Budget Increased for Dominion Boulevard: Dominion Boulevard tolls $ 6.55 million Interest expenses on outstanding debt $ 8.97 million * Toll system service contract $ 4.37 million CTS Budget Increased for Chesapeake Expressway: Additional tolls increase by (rate and traffic) $ 1.03 million Renewal and replacements (FY 16 omission) $ 0.77 million Interest on outstanding debt (FY 16 omission) $ 1.36 million * * Includes interest accruals on outstanding loans that will be paid in future years. 17 Public Utilities Revenue Estimates: Actual for FY 2015 was $70.2 million Budget for FY 2016 was $69.4 million (even with 4.9% rate increase) Budget for FY 2017 is $76.5 million (also includes 4.9% rate increase) Average annual increase assumed in FY 2017 forecast is 4.5% Recommended increases (decreases) in spending: Capital outlays, including small improvements and repairs $ 2,196,700 9 added positions incl. operations, meter reading, customer service 510,000 Other wage/benefit changes (savings) (691,300) Reimburse General Fund for overhead 250,000 Water contracts with neighboring localities (savings) (314,000) Interest and payments on utility debt (savings) (817,900) Increase transfers to Capital Projects Fund $ 5,996,700 18 9
3 Year Projection (Excludes School Revenue) Revenue (in millions) FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018 FY 2019 General Property Taxes $ 307.21 $ 311.09 $ 321.66 $ 330.29 $ 338.70 Other Local Taxes $ 132.71 $ 131.49 $ 138.81 $ 141.98 $ 145.51 Charges for Services 111.94 113.75 130.66 130.76 130.97 Other Local Revenue 5.32 14.10 14.96 14.95 15.01 Subtotal $ 557.18 $ 570.43 $ 606.09 $ 617.98 $ 630.19 State Revenue 117.01 106.13 107.06 107.56 108.10 Federal Revenue 12.67 10.80 10.86 10.86 10.86 Total Revenue $ 686.86 $ 687.36 $ 724.01 $ 736.40 $ 749.15 19 3 Year Projection (Excludes School Revenue) Expenditures (in millions) FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018 FY 2019 Governance/Management $ 23.78 $ 26.97 $ 26.41 $ 27.11 $ 27.43 Quality Community of Life 78.71 88.07 89.37 91.02 92.73 Economic/Environmental Vitality 139.60 161.04 171.71 172.93 174.47 Public Safety and Justice 138.43 149.75 151.03 155.13 158.96 Education City Transfers 177.77 183.22 190.32 194.65 200.27 Debt Service Fund 52.93 39.40 42.30 41.80 34.46 Non Departmental 13.29 19.11 19.49 17.00 17.98 Total Expenditures $ 624.51 $ 667.56 $ 690.63 $ 699.64 $ 706.30 Capital/Grant Transfers 46.93 25.66 45.55 35.68 30.01 Expenditures + Transfers $ 671.44 $ 693.22 $ 736.18 $ 735.32 $ 736.31 20 10
Chesapeake Public Schools Additional funding from revenue sharing formula Additional state funding Rebenchmarking cost of education Change in local composite index (relative ability to fund) Programmatic changes Other net reductions (reliance on fund balances, grants, etc.) Net increase in school operating budget $ 7.4 million $ 6.4 million $ 4.7 million $ 1.2 million $ 5.2 million $14.5 million Note that superintendent s budget recommendation for annual city funding is $12,000 greater than final revenue sharing formula. 21 School Board Action of School Budget School Board approved budget proposal on March 14 largely as recommended by superintendent with several modifications: Increased projected student enrollment by 150 students and state funding accordingly adds $749,000 (not included in city budget) Recommended appropriation of $1,691,834 to Textbook Fund from FY 2014 15 reversion (included in city budget) Recommended appropriation of $2,382,235 to School Capital Fund for Full Day Kindergarten Program from FY 2014 15 revenue sharing settlement or true up (not included in city capital budget) With exception of small difference in final revenue sharing projection for FY 2017, city staff is in agreement with modifications. 22 11
State Budget Update General Assembly approved budget March 11 Governor may sign, veto, or recommend amendments Lawmakers return in April to consider Governor s amendments or vetoes Anticipate additional funding that is not in the budget proposal: School budget amendments include eliminating additional instructional personnel recommended by Governor, restoring Lottery funding, and accelerating teacher pay raises Constitutional officers anticipate additional funds from State Comp Board for staff pay raises Anticipate amendments to revenue and school budget based on final state budget 23 Recap of What s in the Budget Solid growth in City revenue with no increase in tax property tax rates Address school funding issues and teachers receive raises Add police officers over next three years Address public safety career path Invest in city and school facilities Strengthen city s financial reserves as required Realize huge reduction in cost of employee retirement benefits Provide 2.5% pay raise to all city employees 24 12
Remaining Action Council work sessions April 12, 19 and 26 As requested by Council Public hearings April 26 and May 10 Charter requires public hearing at least one public hearing Adoption of budget and appropriations ordinances May 10 City Charter requires adoption 45 days before year begins Technical amendments and corrections June 14 First day of new fiscal year July 1 25 13