Equity Risk Service Q3/2017. Estimating Betas for JSE-Listed Companies and Indices

Similar documents
Equity Risk Service Q1/2018. Estimating Betas for JSE-Listed Companies and Indices

Presented by Mike Adsetts

Weekly Technical Report 18 July 2016

Weekly Technical Report 26 September 2016

Weekly Technical Report 3 October 2016

Key market performance drivers

Key market performance drivers. Monthly charts to 30 September 2018

Key market performance drivers

Key market performance drivers

Key market performance drivers. Monthly charts to 31 March 2018

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

JSE LIMITED GEN- General Index Change Advice June 2015 Quarterly Review ICA

RISK AND MARKET VOLATILITY. Truly Understanding and Managing It

SII Changes. FF Changes. Large Cap ANH 3 6 ANH (0.29%) NPN (0.23%) NPN (22.71%) 0.91%

SPDR S&P Emerging Middle East & Africa ETF (GAF) Summary. Description. Historical prices (1 year) DIAMONDS* RATINGS* ETFG RISK RATING 6.

Notes from the FTSE/JSE Advisory Committee Meeting held on Thursday, 2 March 2017

BATSETA Durban Mark Davids Head of Pre-retirement Investments

FUND OF HEDGE FUNDS DO THEY REALLY ADD VALUE?

DRW Investment Research. Market Performances and Indicators

FTSE PAPER. Global Index Standards, Emerging Market Partnerships

DRW Investment Research. Market Performances and Indicators

Managed Futures managers look for intermediate involving the trading of futures contracts,

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

Dividend Growth as a Defensive Equity Strategy August 24, 2012

Companies we invest in

Fact Sheet User Guide

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series All Share Factor Indices Review

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

MONTHLY PORTFOLIO REPORT May 2015

Quarterly Strategy Note April THE CASE FOR SHORT SELLING IN HEDGE FUNDS by Richard Hasson

Asset Manager Performance Comparison

Asset Manager Performance Comparison

Short Extension (130/30) Fund Strategy

Portfolio Peer Review

Isle Of Wight half year business confidence report

PowerPoint. to accompany. Chapter 11. Systematic Risk and the Equity Risk Premium

Identifying a defensive strategy

Aspiriant Risk-Managed Equity Allocation Fund RMEAX Q4 2018

Stocks. Participant Workbook. Your Name: Member SIPC PAGE 1 OF 17

Improving equity diversification via industry-wide market segmentation

Foundations of Investing

The Case for TD Low Volatility Equities

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

Man AHL Diversified (Guernsey)

FTSE/ JSE Africa Index Series - Quarterly Review

Claim Segmentation, Valuation and Operational Modelling for Workers Compensation

NBIM Quarterly Performance Report Second quarter 2007

HSBC Global Asset Management, India Creating Wealth through Asset Allocation. March 2018

Quantitative Management vs. Traditional Management

Understanding your Accel Risk Profile

Do Indian Mutual funds with high risk adjusted returns show more stability during an Economic downturn?

STANLIB Balanced Cautious Fund

Manager Comparison Report June 28, Report Created on: July 25, 2013

Fund Size $ mil. November Fund Performance Summary Gross of Fees

Weekly Economic Highlights

RSA Retail Savings Bonds: Fixed or Inflation Linked Rates?

Weekly Economic Highlights

Asset Allocation vs Stock-Picking March 2011

MLC Horizon 1 - Bond Portfolio

Man AHL Diversified Futures

DAC Short Term: $10,000 Growth from Inception

CHAPTER 5 ANALYSIS OF RESULTS: PORTFOLIO PERFORMANCE

NL AIR France Analysis of 25-Jun-2016 Closing price of 24-Jun-2016 EUR Neutral. Risk Zone. Stars

RisCura - SAVCA South African Private Equity Performance Report. As at 31 December 2017

UCRP and GEP Quarterly Investment Risk Report

Cor Capital Fund MONTHLY REPORT & FACT SHEET 31 OCTOBER MTD: -3.7% 12M: -2.0% 3yr Ann: 4.7% 3yr Vol: 7.4% Description

Hedging Inflation with Equities

SECTOR. Gold Mining. Analysis and Synthesis - World. March 1, 2016

MANAGED FUTURES INDEX

A Review of the Historical Return-Volatility Relationship

Ground Rules. FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series v5.3

Low Correlation Strategy Investment update to 31 March 2018

Understanding fund factsheets

Sanlam Employee Benefits

Performance Measurement and Attribution in Asset Management

ALPHA GENERATION IDENTIFYING TALENT

Understanding Smart Beta Returns

Models of Asset Pricing

Answers to Concepts in Review

CORESHARES SCIENTIFIC BETA MULTI-FACTOR STRATEGY HARVESTING PROVEN SOURCES OF RETURN AT LOW COST: AN ACTIVE REPLACEMENT STRATEGY

Total

General Investor Report as at 30/09/2017

Statistically Speaking

Ground Rules. FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series v5.5

Indices WHITE PAPER SERIES # Value 50. Capturing the performance of select Value companies across market cap segments

August 2007 Quant Equity Turbulence:

DAC Wealth Builder: $10,000 Growth from Inception

Weekly Economic Highlights

Managed by ICICI Prudential Asset Management Company Ltd.

Kalyan Nalla Bala, Subramanyam.P, International Journal of Advance Research, Ideas and Innovations in Technology.

Investec Structured Return Note. 10 January 2019

Estimating Economic Capital for Private Equity Portfolios

Spheria Australian Smaller Companies Fund

Portfolio Management Services

Global Convertible Bonds Investment Rationale

Industry: Industrial Goods & Services Sector: Electronic Equipment. This report is just the appetizer! Free of charge, reports on :

2 Since 1999, the CalPERS has allocated 6% of its assets to. 3 Most hedge funds specify an initial lockup period of between 6

Weekly Economic Highlights

Transcription:

Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 Estimating Betas for JSE-Listed Companies and Indices prepared by The African Institute of Financial Markets and Risk Management (AIFMRM)

Contents 1 Introduction 4 2 The Basics of Risk Management 5 3 Use of the Service 8 4 Beta Tables 11 4.1 FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series.................................... 11 4.2 JSE-Listed Shares.......................................... 16 5 Questions and Answers 30 6 A Worked Example 32 7 Bibliography 37 8 Acknowledgements 39 9 Disclaimer 40 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 2

Executive Summary AIFMRM s Equity Risk Service AIFMRM s Equity Risk Service is a continuation of the same service previously offered by BNP Paribas Securities South Africa (Pty) Ltd (BNP). This service is aimed at providing up-to-date risk measures and associated statistics for the stocks and indices that are listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE). The Equity Risk Service is based not only on the American and the British experience but also on an ongoing research programme at the University of Cape Town (UCT). The estimates are based on a price and volume series database sourced from the JSE Ltd, Bloomberg L.P. and INET BFA - IRESS. Unique Estimation Features This service differs from others in that the estimation procedure is refined and enhanced to improve the accuracy of the risk estimates. Two adjustments have been effected to the standard estimation procedure - the first improves the sampling-theory beta estimate by reducing sampling error, while the second further improves this estimate by reducing estimation error. Firstly, a thin-trading correction procedure, known as the trade-to-trade procedure, is implemented to preclude biases in sample beta estimates caused by thin-trading. Secondly, a Bayesian adjustment is implemented which reduces estimation error by incorporating prior distributional information on sample beta estimates. Prior research by BNP has shown that this adjustment improves the predictability of betas by approximately 20%. Market Proxies The JSE is unique in the sense that it is composed of three distinctly different types of shares: resources, financial and industrial shares. Investors are often concerned with the behaviour of shares in these markets relative to an index which characterises these markets separately, rather than relative to an overall market index. For example, many investors prefer to measure the performance of an industrial share relative to an industrial market index and a gold share relative to a mining index. To accommodate these preferences for each listed share, risk statistics relative to each share s characteristic market index as well as relative to the overall market index have been included. Proxies for the three main sectors as well as the overall market are considered to be the following: FTSE/JSE All Share Index (J203); FTSE/JSE Top 40 Index (J200); FTSE/JSE Financials and Industrials Index (J250); FTSE/JSE Industrials Index (J257); and the FTSE/JSE Resources Index (J258). Therefore, the tables which follow provide risk statistics (primarily betas in this report, but other statistics are provided in the accompanying Excel workbook) for all JSE-listed shares and indices relative to the aforementioned market and sector proxies. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 3

1 Introduction The quantitative understanding of equity market risk has evolved significantly since the advent of Modern Portfolio Theory in 1952, see [Mar52], and the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) in the 1960 s, see [Tre61], [Tre62], [Sha64], [Lin65b], [Lin65a], [Mos66]. What has persisted is the fundamental understanding of equity risk as been decomposable into systematic and specific components, with the CAPMdefined beta providing the path to the first quantitative notion and measure of these risks. While more complex models have been advocated in academia and practice, the classical CAPM-defined beta is still widely used in the assessment of equity risk. As such, the estimation of the CAPM-defined beta is the focus of this report. AIFMRM s Equity Risk Service AIFMRM s Equity Risk Service is a continuation of the same service previously offered by BNP Paribas Securities South Africa (Pty) Ltd (BNP). This service is aimed at providing up-to-date risk measures and associated statistics for the stocks and indices that are listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE). The Equity Risk Service is based not only on the American and the British experience but also on an ongoing research programme at the University of Cape Town (UCT). The estimates are based on a price and volume series database sourced from the JSE Ltd, Bloomberg L.P. and INET BFA - IRESS. Unique Estimation Features This service differs from others in that the estimation procedure is refined and enhanced to improve the accuracy of the risk estimates. Two adjustments have been effected to the standard estimation procedure - the first improves the sampling-theory beta estimate by reducing sampling error, while the second further improves this estimate by reducing estimation error. Firstly, a thin-trading correction procedure, known as the trade-to-trade procedure, is implemented to preclude biases in sample beta estimates caused by thin-trading. Secondly, a Bayesian adjustment is implemented which reduces estimation error by incorporating prior distributional information on sample beta estimates. Prior research by BNP has shown that this adjustment improves the predictability of betas by approximately 20%. Due to the increased emphasis on professionalism, most investment managers no longer doubt the usefulness and the scientific merit of the tools of Modern Portfolio Theory. However, many investors have been daunted by the myths that the level of mathematics needed is unmanageable. Therefore some explanatory material is also included in Section 2, which shows that the crucial ideas are simple ones and are free from mathematical complexity. In Section 3, basic risk management ideas are expanded upon and suggestions for how the Equity Risk Service may be used are offered. In Section, 4 the risk and associated statistics for JSE-listed stocks and indices are tabled. In Section 5, some pertinent questions are answered; in Section 6, a worked example is included; and in Section 7, some references to pertinent literature on the subject of systematic risk measurement is provided. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 4

2 The Basics of Risk Management The major challenge facing investors has always been the maximisation of their wealth in a world of uncertainty. In the world of finance, the level of uncertainty, or risk, of a share has become associated with the degree to which the share price fluctuates over a specific horizon. The more variable the company s share price, the more risky the share. To get a better picture of the notion of risk, consider Figure 1, which demonstrates the price variability of Gold Fields, a high-risk gold share, and Woolworths, a low-risk general retail share since 1997. FIGURE 1: Gold Fields (GFI) and Woolworths (WHL) share prices since October 1997. It is also possible to attach a quantitative measure to the risk of a share by measuring its variability. This is done by computing the standard deviation of the percentage price changes (percentage returns). Standard deviation or volatility is a widely accepted statistical measure of a share s total risk. The higher the standard deviation, the riskier the share. (The annualised standard deviation or volatility estimates for each of the JSE-listed shares and indices may be found in tables in the accompanying Excel workbook.) As expected, Gold Fields had an annualised standard deviation of 49.19% over the entire period, while Woolworths has an annualised standard deviation of only 35.15% over the same period. It is important to note that a company s total risk can be split into two parts, namely, market risk and unique risk. Market/systematic risk reflects the fluctuations which are linked to factors which affect the market as a whole (e.g. political events, interest rate changes, etc.). Unique/non-systematic risk reflects the fluctuations which are linked to events which are unique to the company (e.g. bad management, worker strikes, operational issues, etc.). Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 5

Market/Systematic Risk All share prices are driven to some extent by market forces, some more than others. Beta measures the sensitivity of a share price to movements in the market as a whole. A share with a beta of 1.5 will move, on average, 15% for each 10% move in the market. Generally, such a share would prove aggressive, performing well in bull markets and poorly in bear markets. On the other hand, a share with a beta of 0.5 will move, on average, only 5% for every 10% move in the market. Generally, such a share would prove to be defensive, underperforming the market index in bull markets, but would do well, relative to other shares, in bear markets. Finally, a share with a beta of 1 will, on average, move in line with the market. We can determine what proportion of a share?s total risk is attributable to market risk by using the R 2 statistic. R 2 indicates the proportion of a share s total risk that is attributable to market movements. Unique/Specific Risk Unexpected price movements (those which are not market driven) are a result of a share s unique risk. It is also possible to determine what proportion of a share s total risk is unique risk by using the R 2 statistic. While R 2 indicates the proportion of a share s total risk that is attributable to market movements, 1 R 2 indicates the proportion of a share s total risk that is not attributable to market movements but rather to factors that are unique to the company, since 0 R 2 1. Systematic versus Specific Risk Firstly, the CAPM advocates that investors should not expect to be compensated (expect more profit) for taking on unique risk, but they can expect to receive higher returns for taking on market risk. This makes sense as most investors are concerned with holding a portfolio of investments rather than one individual share. The major reason for holding portfolios is an intuitive one - we don?t want to put all our eggs in one basket. Put simply, if portfolios are diversified, the unique risks of individual shares tend to cancel each other out. For example, while Gold Fields shares had periods of decline since 2000, Woolworths? shares increased in value over the same period. If an investor had been holding a portfolio of both shares, the bad news of Gold Fields would largely have been cancelled by the good news of Woolworths? success and so it would have diversified some of the unique risk of Gold Fields away. This reduction in unique risk is precisely what diversification is all about. In fact, a portfolio consisting of an investment divided equally between almost any 10 listed companies will have eliminated over 80% of the unique risk of the portfolio. And so empirical evidence is consistent with intuition - if one is not forced to take on unique risk (since it can be eliminated by diversification), then why should one be rewarded for it? However, no matter how Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 6

much one diversifies, one cannot eliminate market risk. One cannot escape the economy-wide perils that affect the entire market - each share in a portfolio will respond to the news affecting the economy as a whole. The market risk of any portfolio can be determined by computing the weighted average of the betas of the constituent shares of the portfolio. This is precisely why beta is such an important tool to professional investment management. Unique risk can easily be diversified away; leaving the beta of a welldiversified portfolio as the key risk measure which reveals all there is to know about the portfolio?s risk. The second reason why it is important to know the difference between market risk and unique risk concerns the way people approach investment analysis. Some investors are skilled at predicting which way the market will be moving, others attempt to identify which sectors they should be in, and perhaps analyse particular shares. One s skills in these areas are inextricably linked to the two components of total risk and have important implications for the composition of the portfolios you should hold. To capitalise on any skills one may have in forecasting the market, one will need to be concerned with shifting the beta of a portfolio - increasing it when a market is predicted/expected to rise and vice versa. That is, one will be altering the market risk exposure of a portfolio. On the other hand, if one is skilled at selecting sectors and shares, or have some information that the rest of the market does not, one may need to take on some unique risk. In summary, it is worth mentioning that, measured over long periods of time, high beta shares have given the highest returns. However, it is important to emphasise over long periods of time. Clearly, during bear markets, high beta shares are the worst performers. While many investors may be seeking high returns from high beta shares, there is absolutely no guarantee that this will be achieved. That is why beta is referred to as a measure of risk - high beta shares are genuinely more risky than low beta shares. Some useful references to academic literature are the following: [BB93b], [BB93a], [BB98], [BB97], [Bra91], [AB93], [Bra89], [BB89], [FF77], [Ber94], [GM96], [Bla93], [Gri93], [Dre92] and [Ber92]. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 7

3 Use of the Service The ERS is not about advising one on what shares he/she should buy; its aim is to supply back-up information to the astute investor or portfolio manager so that they may make sound, professional investment decisions. Below, some ideas are offered on how risk measures can be used. These ideas by no means cover all the uses as there exists a multitude of specific financial models which require these parameters. Monitoring a Portfolio s Risk Level The biggest concern for investment managers is that a so-called balanced portfolio realises a substantial loss during a market recession, or a so-called growth fund returns only 10% when the market goes up 20%. Whether one is a private investor or a professional portfolio manager, one needs to know how much risk a portfolio is exposed to and how to monitor the risk over time. Calculating a Portfolio s Risk By now it should be clear that, for portfolios, beta is the most important component of risk (since market risk is the dominant risk component for diversified portfolios). The beta of a portfolio tells us how sensitive it is to market movements. Calculating a portfolio s beta is straightforward: simply look up the individual betas of the constituent shares and weight each one by the proportion of the fund that is invested in that share. The sum of these weighted values will yield your portfolio s beta (to calculate the actual amount of market risk that a portfolio has, refer to the worked example in Section 6). The measurement of the unique risk of a portfolio is slightly more intricate. Naturally, if a portfolio is the market index or something very close to it, the unique risk of the portfolio will be virtually zero. However, if a portfolio is not diversified, one may need some data on the recent history of the portfolio?s performance. Alternatively, if a portfolio is reasonably diversified, one may calculate the portfolio?s unique risk from the unique risk figures of the constituent shares, analogous to the method employed in the worked example in Section 6. If a portfolio is fairly well diversified, this approach gives a good estimate of its unique risk. However, if many of the shares in a portfolio are clustered in one industry, then the true unique risk will be slightly higher than calculated. Once the two risk components of a portfolio have been quantified, these may be compared, for instance, your target levels. If either of the risk components is off target, the remedy is clear. Traditionally, the approaches to portfolio management have included: restricting selection choices to an eligible list of large companies; specifying a minimum yield level; restricting the proportion in a single share or sector; and even authorising every deal that is made. This can impose unnecessary constraints that fail to control the risks. The modern way to manage portfolios is to measure beta and unique risk on an ongoing basis and to track actual levels to target levels. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 8

Measuring a Portfolio s Performance In the past, many managers have compared their funds on the basis of returns alone. Performance figures that are unadjusted for risk indicate how much money the portfolio has earned, but provide no information about the risks that were taken. Managers may argue that it is profit that clients are concerned with and find it difficult to convince clients that their portfolios yield lower returns than their competitors simply because they are exposed to lower risks. But managers who take on unnecessarily high-risk portfolios in an attempt to gain a competitive edge on return are foolish and will be managers no more when the market turns bearish. Merit should always go to the managers who have achieved the highest risk-adjusted returns even if their unadjusted returns are lower. Adjusting for Risk A lot has been written about adjusting for risk. Some measures have been designed to compare portfolios on a one-off basis, and others have been designed to continually monitor the risk-adjusted performance of a portfolio. For example, to compare risk-adjusted performances of various portfolios at the year-end, one could simply divide the annual return on each portfolio by its beta (Treynor s measure). Clearly, the portfolio having the largest measure would be the best risk-adjusted performer. If however, the portfolios are not fully diversified, one should perhaps divide by their standard deviation (i.e. total risk) instead of beta and compare them on this basis (Sharpe s measure). Alternatively, one may want to monitor how well an individual portfolio is performing. In this case, one could compute the portfolio s abnormal return on an ongoing basis. The term abnormal return embodies the idea of having returns over and above (or below) what is expected, given the risk of a portfolio. The idea is to compute the return for a portfolio over and above the return you would expect for a portfolio having the same beta. For example, consider a portfolio having a beta of 1. Since this is the same beta as that of the market index, one would expect it to perform just as well as the market. What about an investment with a beta of zero? Zero beta means zero market risk. If one were to invest all their money in a fixed interest instrument, one would receive the interest rate as a return but the beta would be zero. So the interest rate can be used as a benchmark return for a portfolio with a beta equal to zero. Now suppose that a portfolio has a beta of 0.7. This can be viewed as having the same beta as a portfolio with 70% invested in the market index and 30% invested at a fixed interest rate. So to compare like-with-like, the benchmark return on this portfolio can be computed as 0.7 multiplied by the return of the market index (over the same period) plus 0.3 multiplied by the interest rate. Having obtained this benchmark return, subtract it from the portfolio s actual return realised over the same period. This is the portfolio s abnormal return. If the abnormal return is positive, the portfolio is doing well. If it is negative, the portfolio is underperforming the benchmark. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 9

Selection and Timing In this section, two issues that are of utmost importance to all portfolio managers are considered. Firstly, which shares to choose (selection), and secondly when to trade (timing). Considering selection, one should look for shares with high abnormal returns. By contrast, shares that consistently produce negative abnormal returns are the ones to sell. The abnormal return for a share can be calculated in the same way as that for a portfolio described above (see also Section 6 for a worked example). Abnormal returns can even be computed on a daily or weekly basis to closely monitor opportunities to trade in shares. Calculating abnormal returns of shares is well and good, but there are hundreds of shares. Which shares should one look for? Obviously, one should focus their efforts on the sectors and shares which one knows best. One may also want to focus on sectors where he/she hold much less than market proportions. But the shares which are most likely to yield significant abnormal returns are the ones having high unique risk. If a share had no unique risk, there would be no purpose in analysing its abnormal returns as its price movements would be determined entirely by its beta. Considering market timing, this depends very much on one s ability to forecast which way the market is moving. If one thinks the market is about to go up, more wealth should be moved into high-beta shares. On the other hand, if one thinks the market is about to fall, then it would be better to move into lowbeta shares or into liquid assets. Of the two, going liquid is easier and may be less costly, but one may be constrained to remain invested in liquid assets (e.g. fixed-term deposits). Whichever way one chooses, however, it will be better to sell the highest beta shares first. Confidence in forecasts should also impact the degree to which a portfolio is shifted. Clearly, the less confident one is about their forecasts, the more moderate should the shift be in the beta of their portfolio. The ability to make accurate forecasts and the ability to pick winners are clearly going to influence an investment strategy. Assuming that one is a fairly good analyst that is correct 6 times out of 10. Even with these moderate levels of forecasting skills one can produce useful profits. One may thus want to take on a slight amount of unique risk, although it would be wise to limit unique risk to a maximum of about 10% of a portfolio s total risk. If, however, one does not claim to be able to pick winners or if one has no particular forecasting prowess, then one should hold as diversified a portfolio as possible. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 10

4 Beta Tables Market Proxies The JSE is unique in the sense that it is composed of three distinctly different types of shares: resources, financial and industrial shares. Investors are often concerned with the behaviour of shares in these markets relative to an index which characterises these markets separately, rather than relative to an overall market index. For example, many investors prefer to measure the performance of an industrial share relative to an industrial market index and a gold share relative to a mining index. To accommodate these preferences for each listed share, risk statistics relative to each share s characteristic market index as well as relative to the overall market index have been included. Proxies for the three main sectors as well as the overall market are considered to be the following: FTSE/JSE All Share Index (J203); FTSE/JSE Top 40 Index (J200); FTSE/JSE Financials and Industrials Index (J250); FTSE/JSE Industrials Index (J257); and the FTSE/JSE Resources Index (J258). Therefore, the tables which follow provide risk statistics (primarily betas in this report, but other statistics are provided in the accompanying Excel workbook) for all JSE-listed shares and indices relative to the aforementioned market and sector proxies. 4.1 FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series About the Index Statistics Tables For the FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series, the tables are decomposed or split by index type with each column defined as follows: Code: The index code which identifies the respective FTSE/JSE index. Name: The name of the respective FTSE/JSE index. # Points: The number of months that the index has been in existence over the past 5-year period. Beta(x): This is the sensitivity of the respective index level to changes in the market proxy x, where x = J203, J200, J250, J257 or J258. A beta of 1 means that the index will, on average, move in line with the market proxy. A beta greater than 1 implies that the index will tend to move more in percentage terms than the market proxy and vice versa. If the value is depicted in: (i) red, then the beta value is negative; (ii) green, then the beta value is statistically significant with 95% confidence; or (iii) blue, then the beta value is statistically significant with 99% confidence. Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 11

TABLE 1: All Africa Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) JA00 All Africa 40 60 0.86876 0.87421 0.08647 0.86055 0.24929 JA0R ZAR All Africa 40 60 0.86891 0.87437 0.08653 0.86083 0.24921 TABLE 2: Dividend Forecast Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J259 Dividend Plus 60 0.81018 0.62314 0.08736 0.52827 0.30469 TABLE 3: Headline Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J200 Top 40 60 1.09518 1 0.11794 0.94444 0.31438 J201 Mid Cap 60 0.61159 0.41433 0.03831 0.33162 0.2344 J202 Small Cap 60 0.53791 0.39585 0.055 0.34246 0.19113 J203 All Share 60 1 0.88944 0.10517 0.8341 0.29663 J204 Fledgling 60 0.28359 0.19158 0.02162 0.07559 0.15151 J205 Large Cap 11 1.07609 0.99351 0.65422 0.89596 0.42138 J206 Large and Mid Cap 11 1.02972 0.93492 0.70954 0.85462 0.39497 TABLE 4: Headline Index Variants Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J2EQ Equally Weighted Top 40 60 0.97039 0.83121 0.0856 0.76795 0.28679 J300 Capped Top 40 60 1.07504 0.97147 0.11643 0.90928 0.31676 J303 Capped All Share 60 0.9864 0.87346 0.1043 0.81832 0.29482 JN00 Top 40 Net TRI 60 1.09518 1 0.11794 0.94444 0.31438 JN23 All Share Net TRI 46 1 0.90871 0.08877 0.78971 0.24542 TABLE 5: ICB Industry Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J500 Oil & Gas 60 0.89905 0.85405 0.1855 0.73126 0.4589 J510 Basic Materials 60 1.37582 1.24065 0.06456 0.67611 0.94936 J520 Industrials 60 0.63576 0.49528 0.05739 0.52594 0.1315 J530 Consumer Goods 60 0.89426 0.87324 0.13548 1.05548 0.11749 J540 Health Care 60 0.79726 0.65003 0.10813 0.79293 0.11289 J550 Consumer Services 60 1.00695 0.92716 0.11955 1.14168 0.11774 J560 Telecommunication 60 0.79379 0.66559 0.17211 0.6184 0.25878 J580 Financials 60 0.77669 0.62414 0.09589 0.63732 0.12946 J590 Technology 60 0.56285 0.4329 0.04141 0.32433 0.15304 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 12

TABLE 6: ICB Sector Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J055 Oil & Gas Producers 60 0.87014 0.84552 0.21866 0.71449 0.20555 J135 Chemicals 60 1.00609 0.91763 0.0994 0.86396 0.3748 J173 Forestry & Paper 60 1.07156 1.03882 0.08972 1.0237 0.28104 J175 Industrial Metals & Mining 60 0.96184 0.83231 0.13001 0.37278 1.22803 J177 Mining 60 1.33618 1.20121 0.05435 0.57646 1.15443 J235 Construction & Materials 60 0.54579 0.3908 0.05472 0.20058 0.2581 J272 General Industrials 60 0.70096 0.55993 0.07023 0.65741 0.08964 J273 Electronic & Electrical Equipment 60 0.49209 0.37333 0.01085 0.21807 0.21126 J275 Industrial Engineering 60 0.52295 0.36222 0.09732 0.16269 0.17867 J277 Industrial Transportation 60 0.81019 0.62556 0.03258 0.51944 0.30201 J279 Support Services 60 0.39895 0.30141 0.04078 0.25515 0.04545 J335 Automobiles & Parts 60 0.85792 0.74698 0.11092 0.52644 0.41729 J353 Beverages 60 0.7655 0.75539 0.13318 0.97502-0.02031 J357 Food Producers 60 0.58855 0.42384 0.02427 0.43212 0.15586 J372 Household Goods & Home Construction 60 0.89574 0.80249 0.0508 0.83565 0.13798 J376 Personal Goods 60 1.23785 1.2391 0.18844 1.33199 0.38261 J378 Tobacco 60 0.77728 0.76386 0.12789 0.93481 0.06177 J453 Health Care Equipment & Services 60 0.87156 0.72962 0.08768 0.90255 0.10946 J457 Pharmaceuticals & Biotechnology 60 0.75669 0.60312 0.13368 0.6643 0.14453 J533 Food & Drug Retailers 60 0.58605 0.40724 0.07742 0.4719 0.04899 J537 General Retailers 60 1.12857 1.04921 0.94099 1.18339 0.25377 J555 Media 60 1.21136 1.23281 0.15242 1.50293 0.20583 J575 Travel & Leisure 60 0.5076 0.38501 0.05279 0.38207 0.10251 J653 Fixed Line Telecommunications 60 1.05217 0.97028 0.06062 0.81539 0.42525 J657 Mobile Telecommunications 60 0.78357 0.65413 0.17677 0.60394 0.25721 J835 Banks 60 1.13134 1.05799 0.95227 1.09171 0.3043 J853 Non-life Insurance 60 0.60855 0.42768 0.04368 0.32444 0.19511 J857 Life Insurance 60 1.06902 0.90568 0.13024 0.94386 0.19324 J863 Real Estate Investment & Services 60 0.25904 0.19158 0.04109 0.28209-0.09581 J867 Real Estate Investment Trusts 60 0.50108 0.36974 0.04037 0.4379 0.04267 J877 General Financial 60 0.85132 0.72892 0.12022 0.72209 0.15039 J898 Equity Investment Instruments 60 0.7712 0.70794 0.10046 0.83169 0.11603 J953 Software & Computer Services 60 0.57881 0.44757 0.04394 0.33829 0.15821 J957 Technology Hardware & Equipment 60 0.51061 0.41722 0.01818 0.35141 0.09666 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 13

TABLE 7: ICB Sub-Sector Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J150 Gold Mining 60 0.96571 0.83104-0.11886 0.43911 0.91914 J151 Coal Mining 60 1.00607 0.85149 0.09903 0.36603 1.01231 J153 Platinum & Precious Metals 60 1.14459 0.97475-0.0129 0.54334 0.9787 J154 General Mining 60 1.38386 1.30462 0.08988 0.65702 1.18622 TABLE 8: Preference Share Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J251 Preference Share 60 0.13923 0.10751 0.03517 0.07767 0.03995 JN51 Preference Share Net TRI 46 0.20894 0.15888 0.03573 0.0805 0.06184 TABLE 9: RAFI Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J260 RAFI 40 60 1.05384 0.90821 0.09859 0.70456 0.43843 J263 RAFI All Share 60 1.02461 0.87506 0.09147 0.66585 0.43842 J283 Capped RAFI All Share 60 1.00981 0.8602 0.09197 0.66572 0.42211 JNR4 RAFI 40 Net TRI 60 1.04732 0.89552 0.09703 0.67224 0.45321 TABLE 10: Secondary Market Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J230 Development Capital 60 0.46139 0.275 0.02386 0.19991-0.01934 J231 Venture Capital 60 0.69624 0.61446 0.03315 0.3961 0.24929 J232 Alternative Exchange 60 0.23126 0.16414-0.04062 0.14916 0.01552 J233 Alternative Exchange 15 60 0.49575 0.4103-0.04427 0.3244 0.11665 TABLE 11: Shareholder Weighted (SWIX) Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J400 SWIX Top 40 60 1.00418 0.89875 0.11459 0.91187 0.23984 J403 SWIX All Share 60 0.90288 0.78327 0.09962 0.78713 0.22771 JN43 SWIX All Share Net TRI 46 0.94858 0.8422 0.0861 0.79237 0.18921 JNX4 SWIX Top 40 Net TRI 60 1.00153 0.89611 0.11442 0.90645 0.23886 TABLE 12: Shariah Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J140 Shariah Top 40 60 1.28256 1.16181 0.10654 0.82079 0.63166 J141 Capped Shariah Top 40 57 1.13781 0.99581 0.08132 0.71997 0.53506 J143 Shariah All Share 60 1.17077 1.02893 0.09098 0.71913 0.58228 JNS4 Shariah 40 Net TRI 60 1.27212 1.14236 0.10444 0.77686 0.65078 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 14

TABLE 13: Specialist Indices Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J250 Financials and Industrials 60 1.16362 1.14772 1 1.33218 0.2541 J257 Industrials 60 0.90715 0.83524 0.125 1 0.13607 J258 Resources 60 1.35782 1.22467 0.05623 0.65498 1 TABLE 14: Specialist Property Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J253 SA Listed Property 60 0.28574 0.12334 0.03491 0.1932-0.04445 J254 Capped Property 60 0.35317 0.23634 0.03593 0.34088-0.03328 J255 Property Unit Trust 60 0.03982-0.06222 0.01377 0.04602-0.11365 J256 Property Loan Stock 60-0.10666-0.17427 0.00038-0.0635-0.13375 TABLE 15: Style (Value and Growth) Index Series Code Name # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) J330 Value 60 0.92422 0.75779 0.09356 0.61991 0.37506 J331 Growth 60 1.02886 0.95212 0.11164 0.95213 0.24805 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 15

4.2 JSE-Listed Shares About the Share Statistics Tables For the FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series, the tables are decomposed or split by index type with each column defined as follows: Code: The share code which identifies the respective JSE-listed share. Cap: The market capitalisation segment to which the respective share belongs: L - for large capitlalisation shares; M - for mid capitalisation shares; S - for small capitalisation shares; F - for fledgling capitalisation shares; A - for AltX-lised shares; and - for unclassified shares. First Trade: The first day on which the share traded over the past 5-year period. Last Trade: The last day on which the share traded over the past 5-year period. % Traded: This quantity is the percentage of the business days traded between the first and last trade date. This provides an indication of the extent to which the security is thinly traded. # Points: The number of months that the share traded over the past 5-year period. Beta(x): This is the sensitivity of the respective share price to changes in the market proxy x, where x = J203, J200, J250, J257 or J258. A beta of 1 means that the share will, on average, move in line with the market proxy. A beta greater than 1 implies that the share will tend to move more in percentage terms than the market proxy and vice versa. If the value is depicted in: (i) red, then the beta value is negative; (ii) green, then the beta value is statistically significant with 95% confidence; or (iii) blue, then the beta value is statistically significant with 99% confidence. TABLE 16: Oil & Gas (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) ERN 28-Feb-14 20-Sep-17 24% 37 0.95837 0.89016 0.04273 0.85637 0.3505 MNK F 31-Dec-14 29-Sep-17 89% 33 0.92264 0.83977 0.23141 0.76091 0.1003 OAO 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 65% 60 0.92449 0.83767 0.06778 0.55101 0.63085 SCL 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 92% 56 1.21928 1.05854 0.03215 0.83404 0.68313 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 16

TABLE 17: Basic Materials (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) ACL S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.09594 0.88495 0.1846 0.54051 0.88434 AFE M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.65043 0.55074 0.09039 0.5296 0.25876 AFX S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.84692 0.72399 0.1118 0.58779 0.37047 AGL L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.2898 1.03958 0.0846 0.39947 1.41087 AMS L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.22585 0.96738-0.12526 0.48519 1.14677 ANG L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.1629 0.94678-0.1554 0.57464 1.01415 ARI M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.21462 0.95407 0.04794 0.41023 1.23714 ASR M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.18373 0.96508 0.01045 0.4591 1.1198 ATL 28-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 76% 60 1.11471 0.94457 0.12002 0.79401 0.7928 BAU F 20-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 66% 60 1.06336 0.94719 0.0836 0.86776 0.52057 BDM F 28-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 73% 60 0.89824 0.81668 0.17744 0.57697 0.50557 BIL L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.56039 1.39586 0.08353 0.86303 0.92248 BSS A 28-Sep-12 26-Sep-17 83% 60 0.54314 0.49386 0.0621 0.44009-0.04866 BUC A 06-Sep-12 18-Sep-17 8% 46 0.79489 0.73423 0.02729 0.56482 0.25164 CMO 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 61% 60 1.21012 1.02821 0.11446 0.86647 0.77832 CRD 27-Sep-12 11-May-17 59% 56 1.07867 0.92702 0.1231 0.90701 0.46019 CZA F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.897 0.83643 0.10479 0.7409 0.39585 DRD F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.63936 0.5604-0.01757 0.21375 0.43137 DTA F 27-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 61% 60 0.6702 0.6348 0.01965 0.49609 0.30015 EHS 27-Sep-12 13-Apr-15 38% 31 0.87389 0.77604 0.09027 0.67716 0.46698 EPS 28-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 70% 59 0.90605 0.84311 0.04123 0.66989 0.4413 EXX M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.13492 0.88658 0.08921 0.40316 1.05807 FCR F 01-Oct-12 28-Sep-17 44% 55 1.15754 1.00922 0.14177 0.84472 0.82031 FSE 28-Sep-12 16-Mar-15 42% 29 1.10066 0.94975 0.12322 0.85686 0.57693 GFI M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.85609 0.69921-0.10383 0.38947 0.60758 GLN L 29-Nov-13 29-Sep-17 100% 46 1.392 1.12899 0.25814 0.70902 1.16187 HAR M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.00811 0.84401 0.07235 0.59485 0.77408 HLM F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.97982 0.85739 0.16827 0.83751 0.33658 HWA F 10-Sep-12 22-Sep-17 13% 52 0.99379 0.87546 0.08969 0.73704 0.59479 IMP M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.3079 1.01445-0.01363 0.62213 0.99774 ISB F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 58% 60 0.55804 0.50235 0.0536 0.36168 0.10796 JBL A 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.88393 0.82272 0.0825 0.75903 0.18224 KBO A 13-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 43% 49 0.96098 0.848 0.05872 0.72523 0.50999 KIO L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.00994 0.81763 0.10938 0.35876 1.22004 LON S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.61946 1.28096 0.26165 1.12788 1.15076 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 17

TABLE 18: Basic Materials (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) MED 28-Sep-12 02-Dec-16 48% 51 0.92257 0.81603-0.47494 0.64996 0.64927 MMH 27-Sep-12 23-Sep-14 35% 24 0.91016 0.83176 0.08185 0.7263 0.50934 MND L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.19649 1.11243 0.11018 1.06755 0.34762 MNP L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.23254 1.15143 0.11503 1.10758 0.3642 MRF F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.85651 0.73082 0.01945 0.28494 0.5816 NHM M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.33049 1.0427-0.00711 0.68994 0.98155 OMN M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.86378 0.7286 0.07835 0.58582 0.41036 PAN S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.90543 0.77232-0.08645 0.51551 0.6605 RBP S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.96977 0.77534 0.09484 0.39052 0.83677 RDI 27-Sep-12 27-Mar-17 27% 54 1.1101 0.97841 0.11307 0.90019 0.78675 RLF F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.50442 0.44785 0.06823 0.29081 0.14338 RNG F 27-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 60% 60 0.71558 0.62305 0.08728 0.45483 0.2127 RSG F 28-Mar-14 29-Sep-17 18% 38 1.00921 0.90456 0.0593 0.74422 0.67461 S32 L 29-May-15 29-Sep-17 100% 28 1.20843 0.98939 0.14926 0.58527 0.91222 SAP L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.79057 0.70689 0.0537 0.74897 0.04707 SGL M 28-Feb-13 29-Sep-17 100% 55 1.36739 1.10397 0.14333 0.93481 0.93037 SOL L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.29689 1.16667 0.07853 0.99407 0.53915 SPA F 25-Sep-12 12-Sep-17 15% 57 0.29373 0.29971 0.18124 0.27894 0.06366 TAW 26-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 62% 60 1.09763 0.93358 0.09708 0.74176 0.79121 THA F 30-Apr-14 29-Sep-17 67% 41 0.65313 0.60324 0.08961 0.20434 0.53228 TSX F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 97% 60 0.8234 0.71136 0.20817 0.67454 0.20393 UCP F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 96% 60 0.56224 0.51837-0.21869 0.26986 0.43934 WCC 31-Oct-13 16-Mar-15 31% 17 1.06376 0.92046 0.10659 0.74857 0.57749 WEZ F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.03333 0.90514 0.08641 0.49034 0.75089 WSL F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.76441 0.68035 0.10719 0.59242 0.25236 YRK F 27-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 87% 60 0.62514 0.56013 0.10197 0.24586 0.42389 ZCI 27-Sep-12 28-Jul-15 11% 32 0.83803 0.76146 0.06846 0.59389 0.43674 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 18

TABLE 19: Industrials (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) ACE A 28-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 53% 60 0.36193 0.31714-0.3971 0.01067 0.24555 ADR F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.48365 0.44832 0.08771 0.30897 0.1181 AEG F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.89506 0.71521 0.16141 0.34809 0.66135 AEL S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 96% 60 0.93657 0.83227 0.16396 0.64636 0.54725 AFT S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.46716 0.44111 0.04539 0.27852 0.1091 ANS A 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 93% 60 1.08604 0.93928-0.03449 0.77804 0.5298 ARH F 28-Sep-12 21-Sep-17 79% 60 0.24776 0.22039-0.0113 0.19512 0.03108 ART F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 95% 60 0.46291 0.46213 0.18023 0.45327 0.00482 BAW M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.70305 0.53952 0.08129 0.21621 0.35519 BCF F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 92% 60 0.08007 0.14157-0.07374 0.06604-0.1379 BEL F 28-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 85% 60 0.4646 0.44925-0.02908 0.19895 0.22875 BIK 27-Sep-12 31-Jul-13 7% 10 1.16146 1.01393 0.12275 0.98723 0.72877 BSR F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 98% 60 1.07644 0.91069 0.1445 0.81878 0.36994 BVT L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.65993 0.54166 0.05832 0.53729 0.12643 CAC F 15-Feb-13 10-Mar-17 2% 15 1.19467 1.02669 0.20571 1.18997 0.50225 CGR F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.41751 0.43049 0.06786 0.50983-0.12537 CIL S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.68778 0.58577 0.01863 0.45897 0.19383 CRG F 17-Sep-12 30-Aug-17 29% 58 0.75957 0.70351 0.16214 0.79019 0.21811 CSG 27-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 86% 60 0.59184 0.57059 0.09766 0.3037 0.25132 CTK F 30-Dec-14 27-Sep-17 77% 33 0.27486 0.31348 0.03469 0.17267 0.05708 DAW F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 91% 60 0.27277 0.30806 0.04703 0.21155-0.14248 ELI F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.17769 1.0361 0.15476 1.01089 0.42263 ELR F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 69% 60 0.55725 0.46855 0.12988 0.29077 0.24865 ENX F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 83% 60 0.56464 0.52868 0.05402 0.37875 0.1911 ESR F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 96% 60 1.05043 0.94139 0.02872 0.79907 0.50637 EXG F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.84246 0.74372-0.06789 0.33346 0.63797 GND S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.98008 0.81464 0.0355 0.63458 0.45114 GRF F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.87577 0.72949 0.05515 0.42863 0.62511 HDC S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.58474 0.49002 0.09631 0.32872 0.23865 HWN F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 88% 60 0.45094 0.38198-0.04863 0.15669 0.34042 IPL M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.0359 0.7958-0.02287 0.6594 0.41247 IVT S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.63113 0.50999 0.12779 0.29295 0.27693 IWE F 25-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 87% 60 0.83596 0.7291 0.11494 0.56675 0.25033 KAP M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.65325 0.56518 0.04493 0.51048 0.15169 KDV 12-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 16% 56 0.85157 0.76965 0.15917 0.71127 0.2796 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 19

TABLE 20: Industrials (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) MAP A 31-May-17 29-Sep-17 87% 4 1.14588 0.97782 0.12572 0.90846 0.70191 MDI F 31-Dec-12 29-Sep-17 92% 57 0.37598 0.35195 0.03618 0.19985 0.1011 MFL F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 99% 60 0.32916 0.2808-0.01865 0.19827 0.085 MIX F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 93% 60 0.6407 0.6392 0.13046 0.31973 0.33036 MMG F 14-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 80% 60 0.9427 0.83024 0.088 0.66695 0.36035 MMP F 26-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 34% 60 0.47225 0.44601 0.09554 0.3259 0.16405 MPT S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.78362 0.64549 0.01316 0.58598 0.20847 MRI 28-Sep-12 26-Jul-16 49% 46 0.80309 0.7285-0.06788 0.6539 0.30937 MUR S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.66573 0.5196 0.01579 0.27967 0.36466 MZR F 27-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 37% 60 0.64543 0.58319 0.02954 0.4817 0.20953 NPK M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.06894 0.89085 0.12392 0.93166 0.24099 NT1 S 27-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 76% 60 0.52908 0.52683-0.07498 0.26477 0.25501 NVS S 31-Mar-15 29-Sep-17 93% 30 0.99585 0.86261 0.10974 0.70451 0.2898 OLG F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 98% 60 0.85153 0.72695 0.00533 0.86921 0.09462 PMV F 15-Oct-12 29-Sep-17 19% 58 0.62094 0.62694 0.03021 0.46886 0.04668 PPC S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.64146 0.57359 0.05149 0.37318 0.24187 PSV A 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 52% 60 0.89404 0.78942-0.35232 0.61876 0.47078 RBX S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.43527 0.39369 0.05778 0.2402 0.19342 REM L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.00169 0.81724 0.09636 0.92362 0.17766 RLO M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.36309 0.29253 0.03218 0.19659 0.07676 SEP F 25-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 98% 60 0.8475 0.72842 0.1521 0.74914 0.16249 SNV F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 98% 60 0.97885 0.85975 0.11824 0.82605 0.22151 SOH F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 58% 60 0.68592 0.61714 0.11915 0.46511 0.20063 SPG M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.59301 0.52111 0.13029 0.52298 0.06069 SSK F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 98% 60 1.06101 0.90231 0.22581 0.68574 0.60498 TOR F 31-Dec-12 29-Sep-17 97% 57 0.44622 0.44659 0.04628 0.21704 0.06471 TPC F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 69% 60 0.0594 0.09196-0.05521-0.12589 0.09498 TRE S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.12669 0.96507 0.14297 0.7737 0.52033 TRL F 30-Oct-15 29-Sep-17 79% 23 0.5968 0.44316 0.07261 0.09089 0.31554 VLE F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 89% 60 0.6635 0.60958 0.11618 0.50434 0.26256 WBO S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.48089 0.42424 0.02784 0.33258 0.22143 WEA A 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 63% 60 1.03602 0.92798 0.13615 0.82549 0.56181 WKF 20-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 22% 48 0.75486 0.68278 0.07128 0.49029 0.23109 WNH F 27-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 62% 60 0.40431 0.47481 0.04292 0.35611-0.03665 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 20

TABLE 21: Consumer Goods (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) AHL 27-Sep-12 11-Sep-17 15% 52 1.07339 0.92619 0.10368 0.92304 0.34563 ANH 29-Jan-16 29-Sep-17 100% 20 1.07941 1.08431 0.46157 1.27836 0.0448 ARL S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.7262 0.59763 0.00334 0.58354 0.27765 AVI M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.44748 0.34952 0.0521 0.44308 0.02116 AWT 28-Sep-12 29-Jan-15 25% 28 0.99503 0.89194 0.11515 0.80765 0.44421 BTI L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.71257 0.70627 0.11226 0.83792 0.07875 CFR L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.28575 1.21566 0.16285 1.28221 0.3787 CKS F 28-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 53% 60 0.59789 0.52105 0.0217 0.41874 0.24365 CLR S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.71445 0.59963 0.05057 0.43608 0.27448 CVH S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.48248 0.42085 0.07396 0.47968 0.05461 DST M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.58194 0.51462 0.06507 0.52907 0.16329 ILE A 21-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 40% 60 0.74359 0.67705 0.00052 0.4105 0.40714 MTA S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.80034 0.69763 0.11175 0.45915 0.38768 NWL F 21-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 53% 60 0.52298 0.46161-0.28056 0.3085 0.2673 OCE M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.72742 0.60681 0.03689 0.6191 0.09768 PFF F 31-Mar-17 29-Sep-17 83% 6 0.57092 0.58026 0.07982 0.46951 0.215 PFG M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.91862 0.75152 0.05353 0.7671 0.33169 QFH F 31-Oct-14 29-Sep-17 99% 35 0.9298 0.75057 0.065 0.62628 0.32369 RBA 28-Sep-12 09-Feb-16 60% 41 0.51565 0.41479-0.08707 0.2294 0.10348 RCL M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.59588 0.50275 0.10353 0.42639 0.20987 RFG S 31-Oct-14 29-Sep-17 100% 35 0.64911 0.56257-0.00785 0.43282 0.03485 SHG F 31-Mar-17 29-Sep-17 93% 6 0.16777 0.22267 0.03429 0.20533-0.22627 SNH L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.91742 0.80677 0.04688 0.83324 0.17154 SOV F 27-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 87% 60 0.6794 0.56332-0.00666 0.39896 0.32522 TBS L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.64898 0.50769 0.03524 0.51354 0.11792 TON M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.70642 0.5516 0.06558 0.33361 0.41415 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 21

TABLE 22: Health Care (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) ACT S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.68923 0.61787 0.07132 0.37098 0.34758 AIP S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.85699 0.74278 0.02897 0.62538 0.33346 APN L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.95927 0.78854 0.16014 0.86646 0.2332 ASC S 29-Nov-13 29-Sep-17 100% 46 1.06678 0.96977 0.16443 0.94509 0.19078 AVL A 30-Apr-14 29-Sep-17 99% 41 0.72828 0.69758 0.12109 0.76139 0.00515 GLI A 30-Nov-16 26-Sep-17 21% 9 0.9426 0.84485 0.09465 0.74009 0.4373 LHC M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.89438 0.71023 0.05004 0.76729 0.23072 MEI L 29-Feb-16 29-Sep-17 100% 19 1.12643 1.01191 0.32238 1.23453 0.24578 NTC M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.85596 0.68961 0.05793 0.7334 0.18743 NUT A 28-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 88% 60 1.03099 0.90784 0.13717 0.81919 0.52627 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 22

TABLE 23: Consumer Services (ICB Industry) Code Cap First Trade Last Trade % Traded # Points Beta(J203) Beta(J200) Beta(J250) Beta(J257) Beta(J258) ADH S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.11988 0.15327 0.00221 0.07078 0.01475 AET 28-Sep-12 03-Jul-14 25% 22 0.97638 0.86839 0.08032 0.68816 0.63153 AME F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 31% 60-0.07452-0.01824 0.05066-0.0204-0.12667 AON 28-Sep-12 22-Aug-17 6% 34 0.61507 0.59315 0.08934 0.50606 0.14786 AOO 26-Sep-12 14-Aug-17 2% 16 0.45824 0.4634 0.07774 0.14983 0.25171 BID L 31-May-16 29-Sep-17 100% 16 0.82359 0.75654 0.16936 0.68021 0.16171 CAT S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 92% 60 0.23759 0.24058 0.02953 0.13583 0.10182 CHP S 29-May-15 29-Sep-17 100% 28 0.75097 0.68977 0.04487 0.6438 0.11712 CLH S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.35669 0.27585 0.01818 0.36153-0.00642 CLS M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.69395 0.55934 0.11605 0.53828 0.14604 CMH F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 83% 60 0.45399 0.40842-0.02822 0.36447 0.14422 COH M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.67297 0.6301 0.01415 0.65849 0.07683 COM F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 97% 60 0.67477 0.52897 0.10249 0.29653 0.45425 CSB S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.46492 0.38517 0.02866 0.35131 0.06065 CUL F 13-Sep-12 30-Aug-17 31% 59 0.47736 0.48246-0.01129 0.05375 0.43029 DCP M 30-Nov-16 29-Sep-17 100% 10 0.81009 0.73322 0.1386 0.70612 0.25487 EMH F 27-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 49% 60 0.89586 0.82066-0.04562 0.69874 0.52392 EMN 28-Sep-12 27-Sep-17 47% 59 1.06312 0.97262 0.10022 1.01933 0.42812 FBR M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.24566 0.22243-0.02468 0.16672 0.00947 GBI A 29-Feb-16 28-Sep-17 58% 19 0.39504 0.44687-0.00692 0.17844 0.09389 HIL 22-Dec-14 19-Sep-17 35% 33 0.33552 0.37759 0.04242 0.37137 0.02346 HSP S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.00045 0.87174 0.04471 0.88041 0.31136 ITE M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 90% 60 0.58392 0.50132 0.0647 0.53252 0.11013 KAL F 30-Jun-17 29-Sep-17 90% 3 0.86806 0.80682 0.09702 0.73223 0.42014 LEW S 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.74897 0.61488-0.03241 0.60829 0.31173 MRP L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.03472 0.82244 0.13517 0.90116 0.25429 MSM M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.07043 0.80432 0.16692 0.75601 0.38332 NCS F 26-Sep-12 28-Sep-17 20% 58 0.42588 0.48728-0.03482 0.38263 0.11826 NPN L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 1.3868 1.28249 0.14985 1.49547 0.27261 PEM A 31-Mar-17 29-Sep-17 98% 6 1.08073 0.9875 0.18586 0.92933 0.60673 PHM F 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 91% 60 0.35175 0.37758 0.08859 0.23947 0.04062 PIK M 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.85117 0.66575 0.02017 0.60598 0.18254 RTN F 27-Sep-12 20-Sep-17 9% 42 1.04007 0.91856 0.10136 0.75052 0.62291 RTO F 27-Sep-12 05-Sep-17 5% 29 1.03979 0.94539 0.22078 0.74474 0.57312 SHP L 28-Sep-12 29-Sep-17 100% 60 0.55109 0.39291 0.06449 0.35894 0.11457 Equity Risk Service Q3/2017 23