Auction of Coal Mines for Production of Iron & Steel 5 th Tranche. SCOPE Complex, New Delhi April 24, 2017

Similar documents
[Insert Name]Coal Mine

Corrigendum No. 2 to Standard Tender Document (Schedule III Coal Mines) (For iron and steel, cement and captive power plant sector)

[Insert Name]Coal Mine

COAL INDIA LIMITED. Auction of Coal Linkage of Coking Coal in the Steel sub-sector. Date: April 18, 2017

Auction of Schedule II Coal Mines

COAL INDIA LIMITED. Auction of Coal Linkage for Non-Regulated Sector Tranche II

Auction of Coal Linkage for Non-Regulated Sector Tranche III

Coal India Limited. Auction of Coal Linkages in the Steel Sub-Sector Coking Coal Auction for Steel Sub-sector. Pre Bid Presentation

The Singareni Collieries Company Limited

Coal India Limited. Pre Bid Presentation

The Singareni Collieries Company Limited (A Government Company) Auction of Coal Linkages for Non-Regulated Sector Tranche II

Coal India Limited. Pre Bid Presentation

Coal India Limited. Auction of Coking Coal Linkages in the Others Sub-Sector- Coking Coal Auction. Pre Bid Presentation

The Singareni Collieries Company Limited

No.CBA / 1/2017-CBA2-Part(1) Government of India Ministry of Coal ORDER

Corrigendum No. 2 to Scheme Document uploaded on June 22, 2016 For Auction of Coal Linkages in the Captive Power Plant Sub-sector

Coal Production, Marketing & Distribution

COAL PRODUCTION, MARKETING & DISTRIBUTION

Coal India Limited. Auction of Coal Linkages to Power Producers/IPP(s) having already concluded long term PPAs under Clause B(ii) of SHAKTI Policy

COAL DISTRIBUTION AND MARKETING

MADHYA PRADESH ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION BHOPAL

SPOT E-AUCTION SCHEME,2007 FOR SALE OF COAL IN MCL FOR THE MONTH OF MAY, 2009

Date: Feb 19, Reference to Model. As appearing in original Model Tender Document/ mine specific Tender Document. insertions

Limestone Mineral Auction

GMR Chhattisgarh Energy Limited

STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED COLLIERIES DIVISION 1, STADIUM ROAD, KULTI (WEST BENGAL)

TENDER DOCUMENT FOR PSDF SUPPORT TO STRANDED GAS BASED PLANTS (PHASE 1)

MADHYA PRADESH ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION

PRESS RELEASE FINANCIAL RESULTS FOR Q4 & FULL YEAR 14-15

PPP in Coal: The Next Big Thing!

Sub : E-auction Forward for Rolling year Apr. 14 Mar. 15.

Steel In The News. A compilation of leading news items on Indian steel industry as reported in major national dailies. Highlights.

Q4 FY 17. Industry Update & Key Performance Highlights. 23 rd May, 2017

Jharkhand State Electricity Regulatory Commission

- 1 - WEST BENGAL MINERAL DEVELOPMENT AND TRADING CORPORATION LIMITED (WBMDTCL) (Govt. of West Bengal Undertaking)

Overview of the framework

Q1 FY 2010 Net Sales at Rs. 2,541 million Operating profit stands at Rs. 336 million Net Profit stands at Rs. 101 million EPS at Rs. 0.

FORM A. [See rule 7 (2)(b) and 13(1)] ALLOTMENT ORDER IN CASE THE ALLOTTEE IS NOT THE PRIOR ALLOTTEE

Uttar Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission

Bihar Sponge Iron Ltd

REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL (RfP) ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD

New and Renewable Energy Department Vallabh Bhavan, Bhopal

Company Overview. Performance Highlights. Major Developments. Status of Projects

Q2 FY 19. Industry Update & Key Performance Highlights. 13 th November, 2018

Jharkhand State Electricity Regulatory Commission

Tender No. COCONTS/00032D/PSCB/MDO/2016, Dt

New and Renewable Energy Department Vallabh Bhavan, Bhopal

(INTERNATIONAL COMPETITIVE BIDDING)

Summary of Rated Instruments

Sub : Tender for sale of Furniture, Computers, UPS and Racks as scrap on As is where is Basis.

Steel In The News. A compilation of leading news items on Indian steel industry as reported in major national dailies. Highlight of the Week

Trading of ESCerts on IEX

e-auction Schedule Version Number : 1 Date of Hoisting : Apr 23, 2014 Catalog Name:- Spot e-auction of CCL-RAIL Dt: Qty offered 20RAKE

NOTICE INVITING BID FOR

WEST BENGAL MINERAL DEVELOPMENT AND TRADING CORPORATION LIMITED (WBMDTCL)

Steel In The News. A compilation of leading news items on Indian steel industry as reported in major national dailies. Raw Materials 2.

Captive Coal: Blocked?

Q1 FY 19. Industry Update & Key Performance Highlights. 9 th August, 2018

P.K.Bhardwaj Executive Director and CFO DIN AUDITORS

TENDER DETAILS OF NOTICE INVITING TENDER NIT NO.: MDI/GURUGRAM/PROJECT/PGPM//2017

Bharat Diamond Bourse (BDB): Policies and Rules for the Manual Auction of DTC Cabins at BDB complex on Tuesday, 7th April 2015.

Bihar Sponge Iron Ltd Sector Industry

DELHI METRO RAIL CORPORATION LTD. Contract-NC-05

SMP-10/2016 M.P. Electricity Regulatory Commission Bhopal

OFFICE OF THE GENERAL MANAGER / CONTRACTS CORPORATE OFFICE, NEYVELI NOTICE INVITING BID INTERNATIONAL COMPETITIVE BIDDING

PRESS RELEASE FINANCIAL RESULTS FOR FIRST QUARTER - FY16. Enhanced capacities Pushing up Production & Sales Volumes

PRAKASH INDUSTRIES LIMITED

AUCTION NOTICE. The sealed offer should be submitted in the office of SBTE. No offer will be accepted beyond the date and time mentioned as below.

KARNATAKA FISHERIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD.,

To [Name & Address of the Assured] Dear Mr./Ms.[ ] Subject: Letter of Assurance

Case No.39 of 2012 IN THE MATTER OF. Shri V. P. Raja, Chairman Shri Vijay L. Sonavane, Member ORDER

REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL FOR SELECTION OF MINE

CASE No. 73 of hours for a period of six months from 1 April, 2019 to 30 September, Coram. I. M. Bohari, Member Mukesh Khullar, Member

Steel In The News. A compilation of leading news items on Indian steel industry as reported in major national dailies. Highlight of the Week 2

A Bucket wheel excavator ANNUAL REPORT

THE MYSORE PAPER MILLS LTD (A Government of Karnataka Undertaking)

RInfra-G Multi Year Tariff Petition for FY to FY Executive Summary 1

Steel In The News. A compilation of leading news items on Indian steel industry as reported in major national dailies. Highlight of the Week

(1) Any buyer can participate in the e-auction for procurement of coal.

KIOCL Limited Tel : (080)

Monnet Ispat. CMP: INR449 TP: INR518 Neutral

Valuation & Recommendation. planning to increase its capacity from the current 6.8mtpa to

GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH A B S T R A C T

Case No. 27 of In the matter of

The general terms and conditions of last Sale, e- auction held on are as under. The terms and conditions in future sales may be changed.

REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL (RFP) for. Appointment of Portfolio Managers for managing

THE BISRA STONE LIME COMPANY LIMITED [A GOVT OF INDIA ENTERPRISE] REGD. OFFICE: SOURAV ABASAN, AG-104, SECTOR-II, SALTLAKE, KOLKATA

Shri Arnab Mahalanabis, Dy.General.Manager (Coal Sale Divn), M.S.T.C. Ltd., 225-C, Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose Road, Kolkata

PTC INDIA LIMITED NEW DELHI

CHAPTER II - INITIAL PUBLIC OFFER ON MAIN BOARD

GUJARAT NRE SAILING AHEAD AMID TURBULENT TIMES

Knowledge Sharing Platform

Name of the Issue: Coal India Limited (the Company ) 1. Type of Issue (IPO/FPO) Initial Public Offering (IPO)

Prakash Industries Limited

GAIL (INDIA) LIMITED

Mines and Mineral Development and Regulation (MMDR) Amendment Act, 2015

SECTOR UPDATE KEY HIGHLIGHTS: FY 2011 FINANCIAL RESULTS SITE PHOTOGRAPHS

GMDC/BX/SALE/001/14-15

Implementation of Solar Based Projects in MP Dated 20 July, 2012

KARNATAKA POWER CORPORATION LIMITED YELAHANKA COMBINED CYCLE POWER PLANT (CIN: U85110KA1970SGC001919)

Transcription:

Auction of Coal Mines for Production of Iron & Steel 5 th Tranche SCOPE Complex, New Delhi April 24, 2017

Background Apr 17 Sep 14 Cancellation of allocation of 204 coal blocks by Hon ble Supreme Court Oct 14 The Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Ordinance, 2014 Dec 14 The Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Rules, 2014 Dec 14-Mar 17 Issuance of Vesting Orders for 29 coal mines Issuance of Allotment Orders for 51 coal mines Start of the auction process for 6 Schedule III coal mines for production of iron & steel 5 th Tranche 2

5 th Tranche of Coal Mines Auction List of Coal Mines S. No. Coal Mine Sch Location PRC (MTPA) 1 Brahmadiha III Jharkhand 0.15 2 Choritand Tiliaya III Jharkhand 0.78 3 Jogeshwar & Khas Jogeshwar III Jharkhand 0.60 4 Rabodih OCP III Jharkhand 2.50 5 Rohne III Jharkhand 8.00 6 Urtan North III Madhya Pradesh 0.60 Abovementioned coal mines are earmarked for the specified end use of production of Iron & Steel 3

5 th Tranche of Coal Mines Auction Important Dates Event Description Estimated Date Last date of receiving request for site visit Friday, May 12, 2017 Bid Due Date (last date for Technical Bid submission) Friday, May 19, 2017 Opening of the Technical Bids Monday, May 22, 2017 End date for examination of the Technical Bid(s). Monday, June 12, 2017 Conduct of electronic auction (Financial Bid) for the Qualified Bidders Tuesday, June 13, 2017 to Monday, June 19, 2017 Recommendation of Successful Bidder to GoI by the Wednesday, June 21, 2017 Nominated Authority Intimation to the Successful Bidder (subject to GoI Monday, July 03, 2017 clearance) Execution of the Agreement between the Successful Wednesday, July 05, 2017 Bidder and the Nominated Authority Last date for furnishing of PBG and payment of one-time Friday, August 04, 2017 payments by the Successful Bidder Issuance of Vesting Order by Nominated Authority Tuesday, August 08, 2017 4

Tender Process

Online Electronic Auction Process Method of Bidding Ascending Forward Auction 2-Stage Online Electronic Auction Tender Doc to be purchased upon payment of Rs. 5 lakh per Bid Technical Bid Compliance with Eligibility Conditions Financial Bid > Floor Price Initial Price Offer To be submitted along with Technical Bid Final Price Offer To be submitted against Qualified Bids 6

Technical Bid Eligibility Conditions Eligible Bidder: A Company engaged in the specified end use or A JV Company formed by two or more Companies each having a common specified end use If the Bidder is a prior allottee, should have paid the applicable Additional Levy within prescribed time period should not have been convicted for an offence relating to coal mine allocation and sentenced with imprisonment for more than three years If the Bidder is a JV Company, hold at least 20% of voting rights off-take and utilise at least 20% of the coal reckoned on an annual basis independently meet the qualifying requirements regarding Specified End Use and specified expenditure of the Total Project Cost coal requirement of Specified EUP belonging to each of the JV Partners shall be considered collectively 7

Technical Bid Eligibility Conditions..2 Coal Entitlement - Coking Coal Extractable coking coal reserves of a specific coal mine should not exceed 150% of 30-year coal requirement of a Specified EUP engaged in the production of hot metal i.e. blast furnace less the coal requirement of such EUP met from any other coal mine allocated to the Bidder thro auction or allotment by the Nominated Authority Coal Entitlement - Non-Coking Coal Extractable non-coking coal reserves of a specific coal mine should not exceed 150% of 30-year coal requirement of a Specified EUP engaged in the production of DRI and captive power less the coal requirement of such EUP met from any other coal mine allocated to the Bidder thro auction or allotment by the Nominated Authority Not applicable for Brahmadiha, Rohne and Urtan North coal mines Annual coal requirement of the specified EUP to be determined at 85% PLF or capacity utilization, as the case may be, in conformity with the consumption norms provided in the Tender Document 8

Technical Bid Eligibility Conditions..3 Total Project Cost & Expenditure Incurred Bidder should have incurred an expenditure of at least 60% of the Total Project Cost of a unit or phase of the specified EUP(s) If EUP is being commissioned in units or phases and one or more units or phases are eligible under above provision, then at least 30% expenditure of the cost should already have been incurred on such other units or phases for Schedule III Coal Mines Bidders with Coal Linkage or MoU In case the Bidder becomes the Successful Bidder, then the entitlement to receive coal pursuant to such coal linkage or MoU for supply of coal executed by a coal producing Government company shall stand proportionately reduced on the basis of the requirement of coal being met from the Coal Mine Existing coal linkage or MoU shall be tapered off as per extant policy Limitation on Total No. of Bids With respect to 1 (one) Specified End Use Plant only 1 (one) Bid may be submitted for the Coal Mine, either individually or as a part of joint-venture, either directly or indirectly 9

Technical Bid Documents to be Submitted Certification of Total Project Cost & Expenditure Total Project Cost To be certified by lead secured creditor if the EUP is lender financed To be certified by statutory auditor of the Bidder or JV Partner, as the case may be, if the EUP is not financed by lenders Expenditure Incurred To be certified by statutory auditor of the Bidder or JV Partner, as the case may be Operational EUP Certificate from statutory auditor of the Bidder (or JV Partner, as the case may be), confirming that the EUP is operational Capacity of the Specified EUP as mentioned in the total project cost/ expenditure certificate issued by the secured creditors or statutory auditor of the Bidder, as the case may be, shall be considered 10

Technical Bid Documents to be Submitted 2 Online Submission Scanned Copies Offline Submission Original Documents Technical Bid Bid Security Letter Comprising Technical Bid Transaction Fee Security Supporting Certificates Scanned Copy of Documents to be submitted offline (Optional) Board Resolution Power of Attorney Board Resolution should pre-date Power of Attorney Power of Attorney should pre-date the documents submitted as part of the Technical Bid Affidavit 11

Determination of Qualified Bids Evaluation of Technical Bids Technical Evaluation Committee will evaluate Technical Bids Technically Qualified Bids will be shortlisted Bidders who have submitted Technically Qualified Bids shall be Technically Qualified Bidders (TQBs) Ranking of Technically Qualified Bids IPOs of only Technically Qualified Bids will be opened Technically Qualified Bids shall be ranked in a descending order on the basis of the IPO IPOs which are equal shall be assigned the same rank Cluster Determination of Qualified Bids Rank Bids submitted by TQBs who are Group Companies Rank Bids submitted by the same TQB If (No. of ranks -1) >= 5, then except for the TQ Bid(s) which occupy the last rank, each of the remaining TQ Bid(s) shall be considered to be the Qualified Bids Else, all TQ Bid(s) shall be considered to be the Qualified Bids However, if (No. of TQ Bid(s) none of which is a Cluster + No. of Clusters) < 3, no TQ Bid shall be considered to be the Qualified Bid Technically Qualified Bidders which submitted the respective Qualified Bids shall be the Qualified Bidders (QBs) 12

Selection of Successful Bidder Submission of Final Price Offer (FPO) Applicable Floor Price for the e-auction will be the highest IPO offered by a QB Minimum 1 FPO should be placed on MSTC e-auction platform by any of the QB for successful auction; otherwise, the auction process for that particular mine will be annulled Determination of Preferred Bidder The QB who offers the highest FPO in e-auction will be declared as a Preferred Bidder Determination of Successful Bidder Nominated Authority will recommend the name of the Preferred Bidder to the Central Government When Central Government directs the Nominated Authority to issue Vesting Order, the Preferred Bidder will become the Successful Bidder Execution of CMDPA Successful Bidder shall execute the CMDPA with the Nominated Authority and within the prescribed time period, the Successful Bidder shall o o furnish the Performance Security pay Fixed Amount & first instalment of Upfront Amount Issuance of Vesting Order Vesting Order will be issued to the Successful Bidder by the Nominated Authority 13

Payments/ Guarantees

Bid Security & Transaction Fee Security To be submitted in the form of a Bank Guarantee as part of Technical Bid, for an amount mentioned in the Tender Document Bid Security and Transaction Fee Security of unsuccessful Bidders will be returned by the Nominated Authority, without any interest on issuance of Vesting Order or when the tender process is cancelled by the Nominated Authority Bid Security of Successful Bidder will be returned, without any interest, on signing of CMDPA and furnishing Performance Security Transaction Fee Security of Successful Bidder will be returned, without any interest, upon issuance of Vesting Order The Nominated Authority shall be entitled to forfeit and appropriate the Bid Security and Transaction Fee Security as damages as specified in the Tender Document 15

Payments by the Successful Bidder Fixed Amount Value of land Value of mine infrastructure Cost of consents Cost of GR Transaction Expense To be paid prior to issuance of Vesting Order Upfront Amount 50% to be paid prior to issuance of Vesting Order 25% to be paid upon execution of Mining Lease or, notification under CBA Act, 1957, as the case may be 25% to be paid upon grant of mine opening permission Monthly Payments Payment towards the coal extracted @FPO; to be made within 20 calendar days of expiry of each month Statutory royalty shall be payable additionally as per extant law Payments shall be subject to a yearly adjustment (upward or downward) on the basis of a Reference Index i.e. WPI Prevailing Reference Index at the time of Vesting Order will be considered as the base In case the revised FPO on account of above mentioned adjustment becomes lower than the FPO pursuant to which the Successful Bidder has received the Vesting Order, then the revised FPO for that year shall be equal to the FPO pursuant to which the Successful Bidder has received the Vesting Order 16

Performance Security Successful Bidder shall provide an irrevocable and unconditional PBG for the performance of its obligations Amount 1 year royalty on the basis of PRC of the mine as per the approved Mine Plan PRC x FPO Revision in amount Validity Annual adjustment in FPO Upward revision in Mine Plan Revision in rate of royalty Revision in CIL notified price Earlier of, expiry of the period for which Mining Lease (including renewed Mining Lease) has been granted or will be granted extractable reserves are remaining in the Coal Mine Appropriation May be appropriated by the Nominated Authority in the manner specified in CMDPA 17

Other Terms

Change in Control and Composition of Bidder Prior to Determination of Successful Bidder No change in control shall be permitted without prior approval of Nominated Authority Approval shall be granted only in case such change in control does not make the Bidder non-compliant with any of the eligibility criteria Subsequent to Determination of Successful Bidder Permissible with prior intimation to the Nominated Authority and the Central Government if Successful Bidder/ Transferee is compliant with Eligibility Conditions Such change does not require any NOC If NOC is required, then such approval shall be granted only if the Successful Bidder/ Transferee meets all the Eligibility Conditions If Bidder is a JV company No change in shareholding shall be permitted without the approval of GoI If one of the JV Partner becomes ineligible or ceases to operate the specified EUP or ceases to be a JV Partner the JV Company may supply coal to the remaining JV Partners subject to the condition that each such remaining JV Partners shall not be entitled to receive coal in excess of the eligibility conditions coal extracted in excess of the abovementioned limit shall be supplied to CIL at CIL Notified Price 19

Utilization of Coal Successful Bidder is required to wash the coking coal obtained from the coal mine in a pit-head washery before utilising the same Successful Bidder may set up the washery itself; or Successful Bidder may engage a third party to set up the washery on its behalf Successful Bidder shall not be permitted to use the coal extracted from the coal mine for any purposes other than utilization in EUP Any middling or washery rejects generated from the coal mine should not exceed the normative limits may be utilised in any captive power plant of the Successful Bidder balance middling, if any may be sold by the Successful Bidder to CIL at the CIL Notified Price less 15 per cent of such CIL Notified Price balance washery rejects, if any may be sold by the Successful Bidder only with the prior approval of CCO 20

Utilization of Coal 2 Excess coal extracted beyond the requirement of the Bidder shall be supplied to Coal India Limited (CIL) at CIL Notified Price less 15 per cent of such CIL Notified Price In case of Rohne Coal Mine, Successful Bidder shall be permitted to use non-coking coal extracted from the Coal Mine in its sponge iron unit and/or CPP Excess non-coking coal shall be required to be supplied to CIL at the CIL Notified Price. Successful Bidder shall be required to make monthly payments with respect to coal extracted from the coal mine on the basis of Final Price Offer for all grades of coal (i.e. including non-coking coal) Utilization of coal for any other EUP of the Successful Bidder or its subsidiary shall also be permitted in accordance with Rule 20 of the notified Rules Successful Bidder shall also be permitted to enter into arrangements for optimal utilization of the Coal Mine in accordance with Rule 19 of the notified Rules 21

Thank You

Consumption Norms Grade of Coking Coal Coking Coal Requirement per tonne of hot metal (kg of coal/tonne of hot metal)* Steel I 410 Steel II 330 Washery I 365 Washery II 470 Washery III 600 Washery IV 820 Grade of Non- Coking Coal Non-Coking Coal Requirement per tonne of DRI (kg of coal/tonne of DRI)* G3, G4 1150 G5, G6 1300 G7, G8 1400 G9, G10 1700 G11, G12 2100 *To be estimated at 85% capacity utilization 23

Consumption Norms..2 Grade Below 100 MW Captive Power (tonnes of coal/mw/annum) Sub Critical Technology 100 MW - 200 MW 200 MW - 250 MW @ Above 250 MW $ Unit Heat Rate (kcal / kwh)# Note: Coal consumption norm given is on per annum basis at 85% PLF. # In case of power projects where approved heat rate by the Regulator is higher than above considered values, the Heat Rate approved by the Regulator would be considered for the purpose of working out annual coal requirement. @ In case of main steam pressure 150 ata or above the Unit Heat rate shall be reduced by 100 kcal/kwh. Super Critical $ 2770 2615 2500 2375 2250 G9 4484 4233 4047 3844 3642 $ In case of units having Motor Driven Boiler Feed Pump (MDBFP) of 500 MW and above size units including super critical units the Unit Heat Rate shall be reduced by 50 kcal/kwh. 24

Illustration Eligibility on the Basis of Coal Entitlement 3 MTPA Blast Furnace 1 MTPA DRI + 100 MW Annual Coal Requirement 30-year Coal Requirement Eligible to bid for Coal Mine with Reserves of 2.1 MTPA 63 MT 94.5 MT @85% Plant Load Factor or Capacity Utilization @150% of 30-year requirement 1.87 MTPA 56 MT 84 MT @85% Plant Load Factor or Capacity Utilization @150% of 30-year requirement Mine Extractable Reserves Coking (MT) Eligible Status Coking Coal Extractable Reserves Non-Coking (MT) Eligibility Status Non-Coking Coal Overall Eligibility Status X 90 60 Y 100 60 Z 90 120 *Not applicable in case of Brahmadiha, Rohne and Urtan North coal mines 25

Illustration Eligibility on the Basis of Coal Entitlement 3 MTPA Blast Furnace Annual Coal Requirement 30-year Coal Requirement Eligible to bid for Coal Mine with Reserves of 2.1 MTPA 63 MT 94.5 MT @85% Plant Load Factor or Capacity Utilization @150% of 30-year requirement Mine Extractable Reserves Coking (MT) Eligible Status X 90 Y 100 *Applicable in case of Brahmadiha, Rohne and Urtan North coal mines 26

Illustration Eligibility on the Basis of Coal Entitlement 1 MTPA DRI + 100 MW Annual Coal Requirement 30-year Coal Requirement Eligible to bid for Coal Mine with Reserves of 1.87 MTPA 56 MT 84 MT @85% Plant Load Factor or Capacity Utilization @150% of 30-year requirement Mine Extractable Reserves Coking (MT) Eligible Status Coking Coal Extractable Reserves Non-Coking (MT) Eligibility Status Non-Coking Coal Overall Eligibility Status X 90 60 Y 100 60 Z 90 120 27

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case I TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A - 1200 1 q B - 1150 2 r C - 1100 3 s D - 1070 4 t E - 1050 5 u F - 1030 6 v G - 1020 7 28

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case II TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A - 1200 1 q B - 1150 2 r C - 1100 3 s D - 1070 4 t E - 1050 5 u F - 1030 6 v G - 1030 6 29

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case III TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A - 1200 1 q B - 1150 2 r C - 1150 2 s D - 1070 3 t E - 1050 4 u F - 1050 4 v G - 1050 4 30

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case IV TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A 1200 1 1: A, B q B 1150 2 r C - 1150 2 s D 1070 3 t E 2: D, E, F, 1050 4 u F G 1050 4 v G 1050 4 31

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case V TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A 1200 1 q B 1: A, B, C 1150 2 r C 1150 2 s D 1070 3 t E 2: D, E, F, 1050 4 u F G 1050 4 v G 1050 4 32

Illustration Selection of Qualified Bidders Case VI TQ Bid TQ Bidder Cluster? IPO Rank Qualified Bid? p A - 1200 1 q B - 1150 2 r C - 1150 2 33