Asset Acquisition and Disposal Procedures

Similar documents
WPG Holdings Limited Procedure for the Acquisition and Disposal of Assets

Major Internal Policies of Walsin Lihwa

Major Internal Policies of Walsin Lihwa

Walsin Lihwa Corporation

Procedure for Granting Loans. Records of Document Approval & Modification Date Contents of Modification Issuing Dept.

Purpose II. Scope III. Recipients of Endorsements and Guarantees

Operational Procedures for Loaning Funds to Others

Q & A for Listing in Taiwan by Foreign Issuers Compiled by Taiwan Stock Exchange

2014 Annual General Shareholders Meeting MEETING AGENDA. (Translation)

Pacific Hospital Supply Co., Ltd. Minutes of Regular Meeting of Shareholders 2017

Procedures for Lending Funds to Other Parties of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Limited (The "Company")

STATEMENT OF POLICY REGARDING CORPORATE SECURITIES DEFINITIONS Adopted April 27, 1997; Amended September 28, 1999, March 31, 2008 and May 6, 2018

Sunspring Metal Corporation

ATTORNEY LETTER AGREEMENT

Walsin Lihwa Corporation Minutes from the 2015 Annual Shareholders Meeting

Main Laws and Regulations for Foreign Investment in China Foreign investments in China are subject to a series of laws and regulations.

DEBT MANAGEMENT POLICY

1.1 Please give a brief outline of the legal system in Taiwan. Is it based on common law, civil law, or some other system?

STARWOOD REAL ESTATE INCOME TRUST, INC. ARTICLES OF AMENDMENT AND RESTATEMENT

Powertech Technology Inc. Procedures for Financial Derivatives Transactions

Chailease Holding Company Limited Operational Procedures for Loaning Funds to Others

(Draft for Comment) Contents. Chapter I General Provisions Chapter II Listing of CDRs... 4

Kino Biotech Co., Ltd. and Subsidiaries

National Instrument Mutual Funds. Table of Contents

RESTRICTED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT

Chailease Holdings Co., Ltd. Procedures for Engaging in Derivatives Trading

Gintech Energy Corporation and Subsidiaries

Page 1 of 61. DTE Energy Company Series F 6.00% Junior Subordinated Debentures due 2076

CHARTER OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF FS CREDIT INCOME FUND ADOPTED AS OF SEPTEMBER 2017

tender date. (4) The historical performance of the mandate type that the manager applies for shall not be less than three years. (5) The manager must

ENFORCEMENT RULE OF THE FINANCIAL INVESTMENT SERVICES AND CAPITAL MARKETS ACT

TAX COMPLIANCE AGREEMENT. Dated as of January 1, Among CITY OF WESTWOOD, KANSAS, MIDWEST TRANSPLANT NETWORK, INC., And

EXECUTION VERSION. between. and. U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, as Trustee NORTHSTAR EDUCATION FINANCE, INC. SEVENTH SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE OF TRUST

National Instrument Mutual Funds. Table of Contents

Articles of Incorporation of Investment Corporation

RULES CONCERNING FOREIGN SECURITIES TRANSACTIONS

ORDINANCE NO

The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.

Regulations 14D and 14E

National Instrument Mutual Funds. Table of Contents

Contents. Application. Summary INCOME TAX INTERPRETATION BULLETIN. INCOME TAX ACT Meaning of Eligible Capital Expenditure

Articles of Incorporation of Investment Corporation

Gintech Energy Corporation and Subsidiaries

Enforcement Rules for Securities Listing Regulations [Rule 1 through Rule 822] (As of June 3, 2016)

Title 35-A: PUBLIC UTILITIES

THE SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM Independence - Freedom - Happiness No. 20/2017/ND-CP Hanoi, February 24, 2017 DECREE

CHAILEASE HOLDING COMPANY LIMITED

Bank Finance and Regulation Survey. Taiwan

The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.

Capital Market Authority

GIGA-BYTE TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. UNCONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND REPORT OF INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANTS 31st DECEMBER 2010 AND 2011

Authorizing Statutes Document 1 of 34

Delta Electronics, Inc. ("Company") Minutes of 2017 Annual General Shareholders' Meeting (Translation)

CHINATRUST FINANCIAL HOLDING COMPANY, LTD

Articles of Incorporation of Investment Corporation

Brogent Technologies Inc Annual Meeting of Shareholders. Proceedings Manual

VESTEL BEYAZ EŞYA SANAYİ VE TİCARET ANONİM ŞİRKETİ ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION

Notification. Collection, Process and Use of Personal Information. by Citibank

C&G ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION HOLDINGS LIMITED (Incorporated in Bermuda on 24 September 2004) (Registration Number 35842)

NAN YA PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS MARCH 31, 2014 AND 2015 (With Independent Accountants

VESTEL BEYAZ EŞYA SANAYİ VE TİCARET ANONİM ŞİRKETİ ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION

RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION THE CLOROX COMPANY. This corporation was originally incorporated on September 5, 1986.

CMS Energy Corporation % Junior Subordinated Notes due 20

KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA. Capital Market Authority

June 30, 2011 June 30, June 30, 2011 June 30, 2010 ASSETS Amount % Amount % LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY Amount % Amount %

Fair Trade Commission. FTC Newsletter

PROMOS TECHNOLOGIES INC. NON-CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND REPORT OF INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANTS

NYSTRS Code of Ethics Revision Date 7/7/15

ANNEX A. Proposed Amendment to National Instrument Mutual Funds. 1. National Instrument is amended by this Instrument.

PHILLIPS EDISON GROCERY CENTER REIT II, INC.

Securities and Exchange Commission Rules 144 and 144A

Law No. 116 of 2013 Regarding the Promotion of Direct Investment in the State of Kuwait

Walsin Lihwa Corporation

NATIONAL INSTRUMENT THE MULTIJURISDICTIONAL DISCLOSURE SYSTEM TABLE OF CONTENTS

ADOPTED AS OF MARCH 30, 2017

LAW ON THE MARKET OF SECURITIES AND OTHER FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS

County Of Sacramento Master Swap Policy

Sporton International Inc.

Share Trading Policy. LifeHealthcare Group Limited ACN

COMPULSORY AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICY

58,000,000 Depositary Shares. Each Representing a 1/1,000th Interest in a Share of 6.5% Non-Cumulative Convertible Preferred Stock, Series T

GIGA-BYTE TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. UNCONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND REPORT OF INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANTS 31st DECEMBER 2009 AND 2010

AND REGULATORY PROVISIONS

ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION BANK OF CHINA LIMITED

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Limited

AMENDED AND RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION DELTA AIR LINES, INC. *

Acquisition and Disposition of Assets

Consolidated Statement of Financial Condition. Piper Jaffray & Co. (A Wholly-Owned Subsidiary of Piper Jaffray Companies)

Prospectus Supplement (To Prospectus dated September 1, 2005)

Pricing Supplement No to the Offering Circular dated June 10, 2016, as supplemented The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.

Chunghwa Telecom Co., Ltd.

Financial Statements

MEDIATEK INC. PARENT COMPANY ONLY BALANCE SHEETS

NC General Statutes - Chapter 142 Article 9 1

CPA/ORD/29 February 2004/64

QUANTA COMPUTER INC.

STATEMENT OF POLICY REGARDING CORPORATE SECURITIES DEFINITIONS Adopted April 27, 1997; Amended September 28, 1999

Financial Consumer Protection Act. Article 2 The competent authority for this Act is the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC), Executive Yuan.

Public Act No

OPERATING AGREEMENT ARTICLE 1. Formation

Transcription:

Asset Acquisition and Disposal Procedures General Principles Article 1 Objective The Asset Acquisition and Disposal Procedures (the Procedures) set forth herein serve as the guidelines for Walsin Lihwa (the Company) to acquire or dispose assets. Article 2 Legal Basis These operating procedures have been promulgated in accordance with Article 36-1 of the Securities and Exchange Act and shall be abided by the letter no. TFS (1) 1010004588 from the Securities and Futures Commission, Ministry of Finance on February 13, 2012. Article 3 Applicability 1. The Procedures shall be applicable to the Company and its subsidiaries, including non-public subsidiaries. 2. The assets referred to herein include: a) Long-term and short-term investment in stocks, government bonds, corporate bonds, financial bonds, domestic beneficiary certificates, overseas mutual funds. depositary receipts, call (put) warrants, beneficial interest securities, and asset-backed securities b) Real property (including inventories of construction enterprises) and other fixed assets c) Memberships d) Patents, copyrights, trademarks, franchise rights, and other intangible assets e) Claims of financial institutions (including receivables, bills purchased and discounted, loans, and overdue receivables) f) Derivatives g) Assets acquired or disposed of in connection with mergers, demergers, acquisitions, or transfer of shares in accordance with acts of law h) Other important assets Article 4 Definition 1. Derivatives: Derivatives include forward contracts, options contracts, futures contracts, leverage contracts, swap contracts, and compound contracts combining the above products, whose value is derived from assets, interest rates, foreign

exchange rates, indexes or other interests. Forward contracts do not include insurance contracts, performance contracts, after-sales service contracts, long-term leasing contracts, or long-term purchase (sales) agreements. 2. Assets acquired or disposed through mergers, demergers, acquisitions, or transfer of shares in accordance with acts of law: Such assets refer to those acquired or disposed through mergers, demergers, or acquisitions conducted under the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act, Financial Holding Company Act, Financial Institution Merger Act and other acts, or refer to transfer of shares from another company or new shares issued by the Company under Article 156, paragraph 6 of the Company Act. 3. Related parties As defined in Regulations Governing the Preparation of Financial Reports by Securities Issuers Article 18. When determining whether transaction counterparty is a related party, the Company shall take into consideration of the substance of the relationship with the transaction party in addition to legal formalities. 4. Subsidiaries As defined in International Financial Reporting Standards No. 27 5. Professional appraiser: A professional appraiser refers to a real property appraiser or another party duly authorized by an act of law to engage in the value appraisal of real property or other fixed assets. 6. Date of occurrence: A date of occurrence refers to the date of contract signing, date of payment, consignment trade, transfer, resolutions made by directors of the board, or any other date that can confirm the counterpart and monetary amount of the transaction, whichever date is earlier; provided, for investment for which approval of the competent authority is required, the earlier of the above date or the date of receipt of approval by the competent authority shall apply. 7. Mainland area investment Mainland area investment refers to the investment in China approved by the Ministry of Economic Affairs Investment Commission or conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Regulations Governing Permission for Investment or Technical Cooperation in the Mainland Area. Contents

Article 5 Appraisal 1. When acquiring or disposing the negotiable securities that are not traded at stock exchanges or securities dealers, the Company shall factor in the net value per share, profitability, and future potential of such securities as well as the market interest rate, coupon rate, debt credit rating, and transaction price upon acquisition or disposal. 2. When acquiring or disposing the negotiable securities that are traded at stock exchanges or securities dealers, the Company shall factor in the equity or bond price upon acquisition or disposal. 3. When acquiring or disposing the assets not covered by Article 5-1 and Article 5-2, the Company shall resort to price inquiry, comparison, negotiation, or an open invitation to bid. 4. For any real property transaction, the Company shall factor in the publicly announced value and the appraised value of the property as well as property transaction prices in the vicinity of the property. The Company shall refer to professional appraisal reports if any transaction should be disclosed and announced as prescribed by the Procedures. Article 6 Acquisition, custody, and disposal of fixed assets 1. Acquisition, custody, and disposal of fixed assets shall abide by the Capital Expenditure Management Procedures and the Procedures for Procurement and Sale of Fixed Assets of the Company. 2. Acquisition, custody, and disposal of equity investment shall abide by the Long-term Investment Management Procedures and the Negotiable Securities Management Procedures of the Company. 3. Acquisition and disposal of derivatives shall bide by the Derivatives Transaction Procedures of the Company. 4. Acquisition, custody, and disposal of intangible assets such as patent rights and other intangible assets shall abide by the R&D Management Procedures of the Company as well as other relevant rules and regulations. 5. The Company shall not engage in the transaction of claims of financial institutions (including receivables, bills purchased and discounted, loans, and overdue receivables) as set forth in e) of Article 2-2. 6. Relevant personnel in charge of acquisition, custody, and disposal of fixed assets shall be subject to disciplinary action -- in accordance with the reward and punishment policy of the Company -- for any violation of the Procedures. 7. When any acquisition, custody, or disposal of intangible assets is subject to passage by the board of directors, any objection expressed by any director of the board shall be minuted or provided in writing and reported to supervisors of

the board. Pursuant to the articles of incorporation of the Company relevant to independent directors, when the procedures for acquisition and disposal of assets are submitted for discussion by the board of directors, the board of directors shall take into full consideration each independent director's opinions. If any independent director objects to or expresses reservations about any matter, it shall be recorded in the minutes of the board of directors meeting. Article 7 Limits of authority 1. Asset acquisition and disposal shall be made in accordance with the Company s Regulations of Hierarchy of Decision Making (as provided in appendix one). 2. Approval by the board of directors shall be required for acquisition of fixed assets from related parties as set forth in Article 10 and Mainland area investment as set forth in Article 4-7. Article 8 Investment limits 1. Limits on real property and securities acquired by the Company for non-operating use provided in the consolidated financial statements are: a) Real property shall not exceed 40% of shareholders equity. b) Long- and short-term investment in negotiable securities shall not exceed 100% of shareholders equity. c) Long-term investment in individual negotiable securities shall not exceed 50% of shareholders equity. d) Short-term investment in individual negotiable securities shall not exceed 4% of shareholders equity. 2. When engaging in derivatives transaction, the Company shall abide by its Derivatives Transaction Procedures, which impose the following restrictions: a) Hedge trading: On an ad hoc basis b) Non-hedge trading: 1. Foreign exchange trading prohibited 2. Non-iron metals: Cooper limited to 80,000 tons in total Nickel limited to 6,000 tons in total 3. Amounts of other non-iron metals: Written approval by the chairman of the board of the Company required

Article 9 Reports from disinterested, impartial, and objective experts 1. Before acquiring or disposing negotiable securities, the Company shall, prior to the date of occurrence, evaluate the transaction price by referring to exemplary companies financial statements recently audited or reviewed by CPA. Under any of the following circumstances and when a transaction reaches 20 percent of the paid-in capital of the Company or more than NT$300 million, the Company shall, prior to the date of occurrence, appoint an accountant to render an opinion on the reasonableness of the transaction price. If the accountant needs to use an expert s report, the accountant shall do so in accordance with the provisions of the Statement of Auditing Standards No. 20 published by the Accounting Research and Development Foundation. This requirement, however, does not apply to publicly quoted prices of securities that have an active market, or where otherwise provided by regulations of the Financial Supervisory Commission. 2. When a membership or intangible asset transaction reaches 20 percent of the paid-in capital of the Company or more than NT$300 million, the Company shall, prior to the date of occurrence, seek CPA opinions as to whether the transaction price is reasonable based on the Statements of Auditing Standards No. 20 promulgated by the Accounting Research and Development Foundation. 3. When acquiring or disposing real property or other fixed assets, if the transaction amount reaches 20% of the Company s paid-in capital or more than NT$300 million, except for transacting with a governmental agency, engaging others to build on its own land, engaging others to build on rented land, or acquiring machinery and equipment for business use, the Company shall, prior to the date of occurrence of the event, obtain an appraisal report from a professional appraiser to abide by Section 9 of the No. 1010004588 amendment by the Securities and Futures Commission. This paragraph shall be accordingly amended upon any change to the amendment. 4. The calculation of the transaction value as referred to in the preceding three paragraphs shall be made in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 30 of the No. 1010004588 amendment by the Securities and Futures Commission, while within the preceding year as used herein refers to the year preceding the date of occurrence of the current transaction. Items for which an appraisal report from a professional appraiser or an accountant s opinion is obtained in accordance with these operating procedures need not be counted toward the transaction amount. 5. When the Company acquires or disposes assets from any court auction

procedures, the evidentiary documentation issued by the court may be substituted for the appraisal report or CPA opinion. 6. Professional appraisers and their officers, certified public accountants, attorneys, and securities underwriters that provide the Company with appraisal reports, certified public accountant's opinions, attorney's opinions, or underwriter's opinions shall not be a related party of any party to the transaction. 7. If the transaction price of any asset acquisition or disposal reaches a level that requires expert opinions, the Company shall abide by Section 2 of the letter no. TFS (1) 1010004588 from the Securities and Futures Commission, Ministry of Finance. This article shall be amended accordingly upon any change to the letter. Article 10 Acquisition of fixed assets from related parties 1. When the Company engages in any acquisition or disposal of assets from or to a related party, in addition to complying with the requirements as set forth in Article 9 as well as the procedures of this Article to ensure the transaction terms are reasonable, if the transaction amount reaches 10% of the Company s total assets, the Company shall also obtain an appraisal report from a professional appraiser or an accountant s opinion in accordance with Article 9. When determining whether transaction counterparty is a related party, the Company shall take into consideration of the substance of the relationship with the transaction party in addition to legal formalities. 2. When the Company engages in any acquisition or disposal of assets from or to a related party, or any acquisition or disposal of assets other than real property from or to a related party, and the transaction amount reaches 20% of the Company s paid-in capital, 10% of the Company s total assets, or more than NT$300 million, the Company shall not proceed to enter into any transaction contract or make any payment until the following information has been submitted to the board of directors and approved by the board of directors. a) The purpose, necessity and estimated benefits of the acquisition or disposal of assets. b) The reason for choosing the related party as the transaction counterparty. c) Information on appraisal of the reasonableness of the preliminary transaction terms regarding the acquisition of real property from a related party in accordance with the Article 15 and Article 16 of the No. 1010004588 amendment by the Securities and Futures Commission d) The date and price at which the related party originally acquired the real

property, the original transaction counterparty, and that transaction counterparty s relationship to the Company and the related party e) Monthly cash flow forecasts for the year beginning from the anticipated month of signing of the contract, and evaluation of the necessity of the transaction, and reasonableness of the use of funds f) An appraisal report from a professional appraiser or an accountant s opinion obtained in accordance with the preceding Article g) Restrictive covenants and other important stipulations associated with the transaction The calculation of the transaction amount as referred to in this Article shall be made in accordance with Paragraph 2 of Article 30 of the No. 1010004588 amendment by the Securities and Futures Commission, while within the preceding year as used herein refers to the year preceding the date of occurrence of the current transaction. Items that have been submitted to and approved by the board of directors and supervisors need not be counted toward the transaction amount. With respect to the acquisition or disposal of machinery and equipment for business use between the Company and its subsidiaries, the board of directors of the Company may authorize the Chairman to first decide such matters when the transaction is within a certain amount and subsequently submit the aforesaid decision to the next meeting of the board of directors for ratification. 3. When the Company acquires real property from a related party, the Company shall evaluate whether the transaction cost is reasonable in accordance with the Article 15 of the letter no. TFS (1) 1010004588 from the Securities and Futures Commission, and shall seek review by the CPA and CPA opinions when there is any exception to the following circumstances: a) The related party acquired the real property through inheritance or as a gift b) More than five years will have elapsed from the time the related party signed the contract to obtain the real property to the signing date for the current transaction c) The real property is acquired through signing of a joint development contract with the related party 4. When the Company acquires real property from a related party and the results of appraisals conducted in accordance with relevant regulations are uniformly lower than the transaction price, the following steps shall be taken: a) A special reserve shall be accordingly set aside against the difference between the real property transaction price and the appraised cost, and may not be distributed or used for capital increase or issuance of bonus

shares. When the Company uses the equity method to account for its investment in another public company, the special reserve shall be set aside pro rata in a proportion consistent with the share of the Company's equity stake in that company. b) Supervisors shall comply with the provisions of Article 218 of the Company Act. c) Actions taken pursuant to Article 10-1 and Article 10-2 shall be reported to the shareholders meeting, and the details of the transaction shall be disclosed in the annual report and any investment prospectus. If the Company has set aside a special reserve in accordance with the preceding paragraph, it shall not utilize the special reserve until it has recognized a loss on decline in market value of the assets it purchased at a premium, or they have been disposed of, or adequate compensation has been made, or the status quo ante has been restored, or there is other evidence confirming that there was nothing unreasonable about the transaction, and the Financial Supervisory Commission has given its consent. When the Company obtains real property from a related party, it shall also comply with the provisions of the preceding two paragraphs if there is other evidence indicating that the acquisition is not an arms length transaction. 4. For real property acquisition or disposal from any related party, the Company shall abide by Section 3 of the letter no. TFS (1) 0910006105 from the Securities and Futures Commission. This article shall be amended accordingly upon any change to the letter. Article 11 Acquisition and disposal of derivatives Acquisition and disposal of derivatives shall bide by the Derivatives Transaction Procedures of the Company (as provided in appendix two), and attention shall be given to risk management and audit for effective internal control. Article 12 Merger, demerger, acquisition, and transfer of shares Any merger, separation, demerger, and transfer of shares shall abide by the Company Act, Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act, Statue for Upgrading Industry, and Section 5 of the letter no. TFS (1) 1010004588 (as provided in appendix three) from the Securities and Futures Commission. This article shall be amended accordingly upon any change to the letter.

Article 13 Disclosure 1. Under any of the following circumstances, the Company shall publicly announce and report relevant information on the Securities and Futures Commission's designated website within two days of the occurrence in accordance with Section 30 and 31 of TFS (1) 1010004588 (as provided in appendix four) from the Securities and Futures Commission: a) Asset acquisition or disposal reaching NT$300 million, b) Acquisition of real estate from any related party, c) Derivatives trading, d) Investment in Mainland China, and/or e) Merger, demerger, acquisition, and transfer of shares This article shall be amended accordingly upon any change to the letter. 2. The Company shall abide by the Taiwan Stock Exchange Corporation Procedures for Verification and Disclosure of Material Information of Companies with Listed Securities (as provided in appendix five) to input any asset acquisition or disposal reaching NT$300 million, investment in Mainland China, and/or merger, demerger, and transfer of shares onto the designated Market Observation Post System website prior to securities trading on the next day of the occurrence. This article shall be amended accordingly upon any change to the letter. 3. Whenever the requirement for public disclosure of asset acquisition and disposal is applicable to the Company and its subsidiaries, the Company and its subsidiaries shall inform the accounting department of the Company of such acquisition and disposal on the day of the occurrence in accordance with the preceding two paragraphs of this article. Article 14 Asset acquisition or disposal by subsidiaries 1. The Company shall require its subsidiaries to establish their asset acquisition and disposal procedures, which shall become effective after approval by the Company. The subsidiaries without their asset acquisition and disposal procedures shall abide by relevant procedures and regulations of the Company and seek approval in accordance with the Company s Regulations of Hierarchy of Decision Making. 2. The Company shall disclose on behalf of any subsidiary subject to the public disclosure requirements of Article 13-1 and Article 13-2 that is not a Taiwan public company, With regard to requirement of public announcement and reporting, the provisions regarding exceeding 20% of the Company s paid-in capital or 10% of the total assets shall refer to the parent company s

paid-in capital or total assets. 3. The Company shall disclose on behalf of any subsidiary subject to Article13-2. Article 15 Enforcement and amendment The Procedures and any amendment to the Procedures shall be approved by the meeting of the board of directors and submitted to supervisors of the board as well as the shareholders meeting for approval. If any director has any objection that has been minuted or included into any written announcement, the Company shall inform each supervisor of the board of the objection. Pursuant to the articles of incorporation of the Company relevant to independent directors, when the procedures for acquisition and disposal of assets are submitted for discussion by the board of directors, the board of directors shall take into full consideration each independent director's opinions. If any independent director objects to or expresses reservations about any matter, it shall be recorded in the minutes of the board of directors meeting.