Trend Macrolytics, LLC Donald Luskin, Chief Investment Officer Thomas Demas, Managing Director Michael Warren, Energy Strategist Data Insights: Global Equity Risk Premia Monday, November 5, 2018 NOTE: Standard & Poor s conversion of the Telecom sector to Communications Services, and related membership changes in the Info Tech and Consumer Discretionary sectors in October 2018, distort metrics for those sectors throughout this report. The overall S&P 500 is not affected. Global leader-board: by equity risk premium, value, and growth Best Worst Rank Equity risk premium Forward PE ratio Fwd earnings upgrade rate Fwd sales upgrade rate By SD from crisis era mean Trailing 90 days, AR Trailing 90 days, AR By country By country By country By country 1 Brazil: Bovespa +1.60 Russia: MICEX 5.4 Russia: MICEX +4 Turkey: Istanbul +9 2 Korea: KOSPI +1.52 Turkey: Istanbul 6.3 Brazil: Bovespa +3 China: Shanghai SE +30% 3 Italy: MIB +1.46 Korea: KOSPI 8.3 Turkey: Istanbul +1 Canada:TSX +2 4 Turkey: Istanbul +1.36 Italy: MIB 9.5 Indonesia:JCI +1 Brazil: Bovespa +2 5 Taiwan:TWSA +1.22 China: Shanghai SE 9.9 Japan: Nikkei +1 India: SENSEX +1 6 Spain: IBEX +1.15 HK: Hang Seng 10.1 Italy: MIB +1 Korea: KOSPI +1 7 Japan: Nikkei +0.97 Brazil: Bovespa 11.0 Netherlands: AEX +1 Indonesia:JCI +11% 8 Germany: DAX +0.90 Spain: IBEX 11.2 Canada:TSX + France: CAC + 9 France: CAC +0.83 Germany: DAX 11.7 UK: FTSE + Australia: ASE +9% 10 Russia: MICEX +0.79 UK: FTSE 11.9 India: SENSEX + US: S&P 500 + 11 UK: FTSE +0.73 Taiwan:TWSA 12.6 France: CAC +9% Japan: Nikkei + 12 China: Shanghai SE +0.71 France: CAC 12.6 US: S&P 500 + Italy: MIB + 13 Australia: ASE +0.65 Netherlands: AEX 13.0 Australia: ASE + UK: FTSE + 14 Netherlands: AEX +0.42 Canada:TSX 13.3 China: Shanghai SE -1% Spain: IBEX + 15 Canada:TSX +0.40 Indonesia:JCI 13.9 HK: Hang Seng -1% HK: Hang Seng -0% 16 HK: Hang Seng +0.38 Australia: ASE 14.6 Spain: IBEX - Russia: MICEX - 17 Indonesia:JCI -0.22 Japan: Nikkei 14.7 Taiwan:TWSA - Germany: DAX - 18 US: S&P 500-0.55 US: S&P 500 15.6 Germany: DAX - Netherlands: AEX -1 19 India: SENSEX -0.67 India: SENSEX 17.1 Korea: KOSPI -1 Taiwan:TWSA -40% US, by style US, by style US, by style US, by style 1 S&P Smallcap +0.32 S&P 500 Value 13.4 S&P Midcap +11% S&P Midcap +1 2 S&P Midcap +0.30 S&P 500 15.6 S&P Smallcap + S&P 500 Growth +9% 3 S&P 500 Value -0.06 S&P Midcap 15.7 S&P 500 Value + S&P 500 + 4 S&P 500-0.55 S&P Smallcap 16.6 S&P 500 + S&P 500 Value + 5 S&P 500 Growth -0.94 S&P 500 Growth 18.3 S&P 500 Growth + S&P Smallcap - US, by sector US, by sector US, by sector US, by sector 1 Financial +0.51 Financial 11.6 Energy +4 Info Tech +4 2 Materials +0.08 Energy 14.0 Info Tech +1 Energy +3 3 Energy +0.06 Materials 14.7 Financial + Consumer Disc +3 4 Industrial -0.10 Industrial 15.0 Health Care + Industrial + 5 Info Tech -0.64 Health Care 15.5 Industrial + Financial + 6 Health Care -0.73 Communications 16.0 Utilities + Consumer Stap + 7 Consumer Stap -0.80 Info Tech 16.5 Consumer Stap + Health Care + 8 Communications -0.86 Utilities 16.6 Consumer Disc - Utilities + 9 Utilities -0.86 Consumer Stap 18.3 Materials -1 Materials - 10 Consumer Disc -0.89 Consumer Disc 19.5 Communications -8 Communications -9 Copyright 2018 Trend Macrolytics LLC. All rights reserved. This document is not to be forwarded to individuals or organizations not authorized by Trend Macrolytics LLC to receive it. For information purposes only; not to be deemed to be recommendations for buying or selling specific securities or to constitute personalized investment advice. Derived from sources deemed to be reliable, but no warranty is made as to accuracy.
Equity risk premium: forward earnings yield minus bond yield, July 2007 to current Standard deviations from crisis-era mean First, High, Low, Last US by style (vs 30y Treasury) US by S&P 500 sector Canada, Europe (vs 10y gov) Pacific/EM (vs 10y gov) S&P 500-0.54 Consumer Disc -0.89 Canada TSX 0.4 Japan: Nikkei 0.96 S&P 500 (vs 10Y) -0.94 Consumer Stap -0.79 UK: FTSE 0.72 Australia: ASE 0.65 S&P 500 (vs. Corp) -0.31 Energy 0.06 Germany: DAX 0.89 China: Shanghai SE 0.7 S&P 500 Growth -0.94 Financial 0.51 France: CAC 0.83 Hong Kong: Hang Seng 0.37 S&P 500 Value -0.05 Health Care -0.72 Netherlands: AEX 0.41 Korea: KOSPI 1.51 S&P Midcap 0.3 Industrial -0.1 Italy: MIB 1.45 Taiwan: TWSE 1.22 S&P Smallcap 0.32 Info Tech -0.63 Spain: IBEX 1.15 Indonesia: JCI -0.22 Snapple-0.54 Materials 0.08 EABank: STOXX FR10Y 1 India: SENSEX -0.66 Brazil: Bovespa (v. 3yr) 1.59 Turkey: Istanbul (v 7yr) 1.36 Russia: MICEX 0.78 2
EPS: forward consensus, bottom-up, July 2007 to current First, High, Low, Last US by style US by S&P 500 sector Canada, Europe Pacific/EM S&P 500 Consumer Discretionary Canada: TSX Japan: Nikkei Consumer Staples UK: FTSE Australia: ASE Energy Germany: DAX China: Shanghai SE S&P 500 Growth Financial France: CAC Hong Kong: Hang Seng S&P 500 Value Health Care Netherlands: AEX Korea: KOSPI S&P Midcap Industrial Italy: MIB Taiwan: TWSE S&P Smallcap Information Technology Spain: IBEX Indonesia: JCI Snapple Materials EA Banks: STOXX India: SENSEX Brazil: Bovespa Turkey: Istanbul Russia: MICEX 3
P/E ratio: forward consensus, bottom-up, July 2007 to current First, High, Low, Last US by style US by S&P 500 sector Canada, Europe Pacific/EM S&P 500 Consumer Discretionary Canada: TSX Japan: Nikkei Consumer Staples UK: FTSE Australia: ASE Energy Germany: DAX China: Shanghai SE S&P 500 Growth Financial France: CAC Hong Kong: Hang Seng S&P 500 Value Health Care Netherlands: AEX Korea: KOSPI S&P Midcap Industrial Italy: MIB Taiwan: TWSE S&P Smallcap Information Technology Spain: IBEX Indonesia: JCI Snapple Materials EA Banks: STOXX India: SENSEX Brazil: Bovespa Turkey: Istanbul Russia: MICEX 4
Benchmark bond yields, July 2007 to current First, High, Low, Last US Canada, Europe Pacific/EM 30-year Treasury Canada 10-year govt Japan: 10-year govt 10-year Treasury UK: 10-year govt Australia: 10-year govt Moody's Corporate Avg Germany: 10-year govt China: 10-year govt France: 10-year govt Hong Kong: 10-year govt Netherlands: 10-year govt Korea: 10-year govt Italy: 10-year govt Taiwan: 10-year govt Spain: 10-year govt Indonesia: 10-year govt India: 10-year govt Brazil: 3-year govt Turkey: 7-year govt Russia: 10-year govt 5
Daily S&P 500 equity risk premium in the crisis era Draghi "whatever it takes", July 2012 Equity risk premium 2.9 Crisis-era mean 3.7 Aftermath mean 3.0 Pre-crisis mean 1.5 Ebola 10/15/2014 3.9 Oil $26 RMB devalue 2/11/2016Brexit 8/24/2015 4.19% 6/27/2016 3.99% 3.8 China tariffs 4/2/2018 3.2 1% JPM margin call on Bear Stearns, July 2007 Versus 30-year Treasury Post-crisis tight 3/13/2017 2.40% Source: Bloomberg, NBER, TrendMacro calculations A century-plus of the monthly S&P 500 equity risk premium 1 Yield-cap era Jun 27, 2016 Feb 11 2016 Aug 24 2015 Oct 15 2014 S&P 500 Equity Risk Premium Oct 3 2011 Apr 2 2018 Decade mean 10-year moving average Jun 1 2012 MA from 1900 Mar 9 2009 Crisis mean BushObama years Pre-crisis mean 0% QE era March 13, 2017 ReaganClinton years JohnsonNixonCarter years - 1900 1906 1913 1920 1927 1934 1941 1948 1955 1962 1969 1976 1983 1990 1997 2004 2011 2018 Versus 30-year Treasury Source: Various, TrendMacro calculations 6
Close-up: Global equity risk premia in the crisis, and its aftermath July-to-July range (left panel), daily from July 2013 (right panel) 9% 1% 11% 9% Draghi "whatever it takes", July 2012 JPM margin call on Bear Stearns, July 2007 '07 '08 '10 '11 '12 Equity risk premium 6.69% Crisis-era mean 5.1 Aftermath mean 5.7 Japan Nikkei 225 Equity risk premium 6.90% Crisis era mean Aftermath mean 5.39% UK FTSE 100 1 Equity risk premium 8.1 Crisis-era mean 6.8 Aftermath mean 7.21% Germany DAX 7
Close-up: Global equity risk premia in the crisis, and its aftermath July-to-July range (left panel), daily form July 2013 (right panel) 9% 1% Draghi "whatever it takes", July 2012 JPM margin call on Bear Stearns, July 2007 Equity risk premium 5.00% Crisis-era mean 4.5 Aftermath mean 4.5 Canada TSE China Shanghai 0% - 1 11% 9% '07 '08 '10 '11 '12 Equity risk premium 6.5 Crisis era mean Aftermath mean 5.39% Equity risk premium 7.2 Crisis-era mean 5.5 Aftermath mean 5.31% Italy MIB 8