COMMENTARY NUMBER 603 January Durable Goods Orders and Home Sales February 27, Durable Goods Orders in Downturn

Similar documents
COMMENTARY NUMBER 622 March Durable Goods Orders, New- and Existing-Home Sales April 24, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 594 December Existing-Home Sales January 23, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 776 November Durable Goods Orders, New-Home Sales December 23, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 601 January Housing Starts, PPI February 19, Unstable Housing Starts Showed a Corrective Plunge in January

COMMENTARY NUMBER 794 New Orders for Durable Good, New- and Existing-Home Sales March 24, 2016

COMMENTARY NUMBER 599 January Retail Sales, Liquidity, Late Detail from Jobs Revision February 13, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 652 July 2014 Durable Goods Orders, New- and Existing-Home Sales August 26, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 738 June Durable Goods Orders, New-Home Sales, Household Income July 27, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 415 Fourth-Quarter GDP, December Durable Goods and Home Sales. January 27, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 529 Retail Sales Benchmark Revision May 31, Annual Retail Sales Revised Lower by 0.43% in 2011 and 0.

COMMENTARY NUMBER 685 November Trade Deficit, Construction Spending January 7, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 650 July 2014 Industrial Production, Producer Price Index (PPI) August 18, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 632 April Trade Deficit and Benchmark, Construction Spending, Liquidity June 4, New Trade Data Indicate Weaker Recent Economy

SPECIAL COMMENTARY NUMBER 429 Consumer Liquidity Update, March Retail Sales April 16, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 637 GDP Revision, Durable Goods Orders, New- and Existing-Home Sales June 25, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 436 March Trade Balance, Consumer Credit, April PPI May 11, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 724 April Trade Deficit and Benchmark Revision, Construction Spending June 3, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 699 January CPI, Real-Retail Sales and Earnings, Durable Goods, Home Sales February 26, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 493 November Trade Deficit. January 11, Official Inflation-Adjusted Merchandise Trade Deficit Hit 4-1/2 Year High

COMMENTARY NUMBER 689 December Housing Starts, Special Comments on the Economy January 21, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 358 February CPI, PPI, Production, Housing Starts, Real Retail Sales, Real M3. March 17, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 654 July Median Household Income, Trade Deficit, Construction Spending September 4, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 623 First-Quarter 2014 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) April 30, Not Annualized, First-Quarter GDP Gained Just 0.

COMMENTARY NUMBER 451 GDP Revision, Unemployment Reporting Inconsistencies. June 28, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 363 Inflation, Retail Sales, Production. April 15, Real Monthly Retail Sales Fell by 0.2% in March

COMMENTARY NUMBER 386 GDP Revision, July Durable Goods Orders and New Home Sales. August 26, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 460 FOMC, June Construction, Disposable Income, PCE Deflator. August 1, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER Household Income, August Housing Starts September 18, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 462 June Trade Balance, Consumer Credit. August 9, Bernanke Bemoans GDP Not Reflecting Common Experience

COMMENTARY NUMBER 354 GDP Revision, Durable Goods Orders, Home Sales, Tax Receipts, Political Crises. February 25, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 331 Third-Quarter GDP, Quantitative-Easing Games, Homes Sales, New Orders. October 29, 2010

COMMENTARY NUMBER 417 December 2011 and Annual Trade Deficit. February 10, Trade Could Pressure GDP Revision to Downside

COMMENTARY NUMBER 551 July New Orders for Durable Goods, New- and Existing-Home Sales August 26, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 378 June Retail Sales, PPI, May Trade Deficit. July 14, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 391 August Housing Starts. September 20, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 349 Crisis in Economic Reporting, Systemic Liquidity. February 7, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 610 February CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings, Housing Starts March 18, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 592 December CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings January 16, Inflation Picks Up as the Economy Slows Down

COMMENTARY NUMBER 659 August CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings September 17, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 392 Benchmark Payroll and GDP Revisions, August Durable Goods and Home Sales. September 29, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 353 January Inflation. February 17, January Annual Inflation Rose to 1.6% (CPI-U), 1.8% (CPI-W), 9.

COMMENTARY NUMBER 535 Fed Jawboning, May Durable Goods, New- and Existing-Home Sales. June 25, 2013

ADVANCE COMMENTARY NUMBER 930-A. December Labor, Private Surveying and M3, November Trade Deficit and Construction Spending January 5, 2018

COMMENTARY NUMBER 528 First Revision to First-Quarter 2013 GDP May 30, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 405 October Trade Balance. December 9, October Trade Deficit Suggests Positive Contribution to Fourth-Quarter GDP

COMMENTARY NUMBER 743 Global Currency Instabilities, Oil Industry, July Retail Sales, Production and PPI August 17, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 459 Second-Quarter GDP, Annual GDP Revisions. July 28, GDP Revisions Showed a Later Full Recovery with Shifted Growth Patterns

COMMENTARY NUMBER 627 April CPI, PPI, Industrial Production, Real Retail Sales and Earnings May 15, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 569 Consumer Liquidity, September Retail Sales, PPI October 29, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER Federal Deficit Cash versus GAAP, Durable Goods Orders November 27, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 395 September CPI, PPI, Real Retail Sales, Housing Starts, Industrial Production. October 19, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 524 April Industrial Production, PPI. May 15, April Production Sinks Below First-Quarter 2013 Average

COMMENTARY NUMBER 772 Retail Sales, Liquidity, PPI, Federal Obligations, SDRs, FOMC December 11, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 345 December Inflation, Retail Sales, Production. January 14, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 411 December Employment and Unemployment. January 6, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 372 April Trade Deficit, Bernanke Shift. June 9, Earthquake-Diminished Imports of Auto Parts Narrowed April Deficit

COMMENTARY NUMBER 456 June CPI and Industrial Production. July 17, Headline Inflation Should Increase in Next Several Months

COMMENTARY NUMBER 494 December Retail Sales, PPI. January 15, Merrily We Roll Along, Towards Hyperinflation

COMMENTARY NUMBER 793 CPI, Real Retail Sales, Production, Housing Starts, GDP and U.S. Dollar March 17, 2016

COMMENTARY NUMBER 716 March Trade Deficit, Construction Spending, Retail Sales Benchmark Revision May 5, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 735 June Industrial Production, Producer Price Index (PPI) July 15, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 467 GDP Revision, Gold Standard. August 29, GDI at 0.6%, GDP at 1.7%, GNP at 2.2%, All Plus-or-Minus Three Percentage Points

COMMENTARY NUMBER 782 December Durable Goods Orders, New- and Existing-Home Sales January 28, 2016

COMMENTARY NUMBER 578 Trade Deficit, Construction Spending, New Home Sales December 4, No Signs of a Growing Economy

COMMENTARY NUMBER 482 October CPI, PPI, Retail Sales, Real Earnings. November 15, Official Real Retail Sales Signal Recession

COMMENTARY NUMBER 736 June CPI, Housing Starts, Real Retail Sales and Earnings July 17, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 508 Employment and Unemployment, Money Supply, Consumer Credit. March 8, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 651 July 2014 CPI, Housing Starts, Real Retail Sales and Earnings, Monetary Base August 19, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 686 December Employment and Unemployment, Money Supply M3 January 9, 2015

DEPRESSION SPECIAL REPORT. Number 52. August 1, Current Economic Downturn Is Worst Since Great Depression

COMMENTARY NUMBER 385 July CPI, PPI, Industrial Production and Housing Starts. August 18, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 473 September Employment and Unemployment, August Construction Spending, PCE Deflator. October 5, 2012

COMMENTARY NUMBER 400 Budget Deficit Reality, October CPI, Industrial Production. November 16, 2011

COMMENTARY NUMBER 533 May Industrial Production and PPI. June 14, Weakening Economy and Rising Inflation Should Become the Trend

COMMENTARY NUMBER 505 January CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings, Existing Home Sales, Fed Easing, Gold and U.S. Dollar.

COMMENTARY NUMBER 501 December 2012 and Annual Trade Balance, Consumer Credit. February 8, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 547 July Employment and Unemployment, M3, June Construction August 2, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 756 September Labor Conditions, Money Supply M3, August Construction Spending October 2, Expectations Shift Towards Recession

COMMENTARY NUMBER 694 January Payrolls, Employment and Revisions February 6, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 553 July Trade Deficit, Construction Spending September 4, July Trade Data Remain in State of Flux

COMMENTARY NUMBER 702 Trade, Labor, Construction-Spending, Household Income, M3, U.S. GAAP-Accounting March 6, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 573 October Industrial Production and Money Supply, September Trade Balance November 15, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 410 Special Commentary, GAAP-Based 2011 U.S. Financial Data. December 28, Actual 2011 Federal Deficit Topped $5.

COMMENTARY NUMBER Consumer Expenditures, August Retail Sales, Gold September 12, 2014

COMMENTARY NUMBER 519 First-Quarter 2013 GDP, Median Household Income. April 26, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 329 Inflation, Retail Sales, Trade Deficit and Debased Money. October 15, Dollar Debasement Fears Mount

COMMENTARY NUMBER 510 February 2013 CPI, PPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings, Production. March 15, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 574 October CPI, Retail Sales, Real Retail Sales and Earnings, Existing Home Sales November 20, Watch Out for the Dollar

ADVANCE SPECIAL COMMENTARY No. 858 Economic and Financial Review and Preview December 30, 2016

COMMENTARY NUMBER 580 November Labor Data and M3, October Household Income December 6, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 557 August CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings September 17, Liquidity Constraints Impair Consumption, Prevent Recovery

COMMENTARY NUMBER 725 May Employment and Unemployment, Money Supply M3 June 5, 2015

COMMENTARY NUMBER 549 July CPI, PPI, Nominal and Real Retail Sales, Industrial Production, Real Earnings August 15, No Economic Recovery Here

COMMENTARY NUMBER 572 October Employment and Unemployment November 8, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 548 June Trade Balance August 6, Unusually Large Reduction in June Trade Deficit Likely Reflected Port of New York Disruptions

COMMENTARY NUMBER 554 August Employment and Unemployment, M3 September 6, August Labor Conditions Showed a Deteriorating Economy

COMMENTARY NUMBER 583 November Consumer Price Index, Real Retail Sales and Earnings December 17, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 570 Economic Review, September CPI, Real Retail Sales and Earnings October 30, 2013

COMMENTARY NUMBER 479 Presidential Election, Hurricane Sandy, October Employment and Unemployment, September M3, Construction and PCE Deflator

COMMENTARY NUMBER 546 GDP and Revisions, Mounting Consumer- and Systemic-Liquidity Issues August 1, 2013

Transcription:

COMMENTARY NUMBER 603 January Durable Goods Orders and Home Sales February 27, 2014 Durable Goods Orders in Downturn Statistically Indistinguishable from January 2013, January 2014 5-1/2 Year High in New-Home Sales Still Was 65% Below Pre-Recession Peak At 1-1/2 Year Low, Existing-Home Sales Fell Sharply Month-to-Month and Year-to-Year 37% Below Pre-Recession High PLEASE NOTE: The next regular Commentary is scheduled for tomorrow, Friday, February 28th, covering the second estimate, first revision of fourth-quarter 2013 GDP. Where the U.S. Treasury has delayed further the GAAP-based 2013 financial statements for the U.S. government until sometime later today, February 27th, at least an initial ShadowStats analysis of the statements also should be published with tomorrow s missive. Best wishes to all John Williams OPENING COMMENTS AND EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Latest Economic Reporting Remained Consistent With Renewed Economic Downturn. This morning s (February 27th) Commentary focuses on the January reporting for new orders for durable goods and for new- and existing-home sales activity. Only the new-home sales data showed positive monthly results. Yet, with that series at 65% below its pre-recession highs, and with headline monthly Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 1

and annual gains well shy of approaching statistical significance, the best that can be said for the series is that it is highly unstable and unreliable. While the other two series also have stability and reliability issues, they also recently have been consistent with prior reporting, with other recent, related reporting and with underlying economic fundamentals. They are showing patterns of renewed downturn consistent with the onset of what likely will be viewed formally as a new or double-dip recession. More will follow in tomorrow s (February 28th) Commentary No. 604, on the GDP revision. January 2014 Durable Goods Weaker Orders Suggestive of New Downtrend. Although the headline 0.97% decline in January 2014 durable goods orders was more than accounted for by a decline in the extremely volatile orders for commercial aircraft, headline January reporting was in the context of a fair downward revision to December s new orders, with the result that January orders were down by 6.25% for the two months from November. Of that decline, 3.07% still was net of a drop in those aircraft orders, which usually dominate the aggregate durable goods growth numbers. Accordingly the twomonth drop in total orders tended to be based broadly across the economy. Aggregate January reporting and revisions not only reflected some corrective pullback in orders, but also some corrective downside revisions to the reporting of prior activity. Accordingly, the ongoing longerterm pattern of stagnation has remained in place for the series particularly when viewed net of inflation despite any short-term blips, and a recent slight uptrend in the pattern of stagnation now may have turned to a downtrend. The growth patterns in this series remain of a nature that commonly precedes or coincides with a recession or deepening business downturn. Nominal (Not-Adjusted-for-Inflation) January 2014 Reporting. The seasonally-adjusted nominal level of January 2014 new orders for durable goods fell by 0.97% for the month, following a revised 5.34% decline in December, and a revised November gain of 2.75%. Before the prior-period revisions, total new orders in January fell by 1.89%. The reporting of contractions and surges in commercial aircraft orders is seen in an irregularly-repeating process throughout the year and often dominates headline durable goods orders. These extremely volatile aircraft orders are booked well into the future and are indicative more of longer-term, rather than shorterterm prospects for manufacturing activity. In January, nondefense (or commercial) aircraft orders fell by 20.20% month-to-month, versus a revised 22.32% decline in December, and an unrevised 21.08% gain in November. Net of prior-period revisions, January commercial-aircraft orders fell by 24.88%. Net of the aircraft numbers, total new orders rose by 0.59% in January, versus a revised decline of 3.63% in December, and a revised 1.21% gain in November. What these numbers show over the last eight months is no meaningful change (down by 2.47%) effectively stagnation in new orders for durable goods, net of commercial-aircraft order activity and before any consideration for the effects of inflation. The eight-month change is down by 3.14% net of PPI-related inflation. Aircraft-order volatility also has impacted year-to-year change in seasonally-adjusted, total new orders. Total orders in January 2014 were up by 4.61% year-to-year, up by 1.17% ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised aggregate annual decline of 0.84% in December 2013, down by a revised 3.16% ex-commercial Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 2

aircraft; versus a revised November aggregate annual gain of 10.14%, up by a revised 5.64% excommercial aircraft. Further affected by aircraft-order activity were the seasonally-adjusted new orders for nondefense capital goods, which fell by 3.89% month-to-month in January 2014, were up by 0.41% ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised aggregate decline of 6.52% in December, down by a revised 1.22% ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised 8.24% gain in November, up by a revised 4.52% ex-commercial aircraft. Real (Inflation-Adjusted) Durable Goods Orders January 2014. ShadowStats still is in the process of developing a new inflation measure for deflating the PPI. With the complete revamping of the PPI series this month (see Commentary No. 601 and Commentary No. 591), the previously-used PPI finished goods, capital equipment measure disappeared. The closest new measure appears to be final goods machinery and equipment, and it was used here to estimate the relevant January inflation, reflecting a seasonallyadjusted 0.2% monthly inflation rate for January, an annual inflation rate of 1.2%. A new inflation series should be in place for the next durable goods reporting. Adjusted for that inflation, and as reflected in the accompanying graphs, real month-to-month aggregate orders fell by 1.16% in January, versus a revised decline of 5.45% in December, versus a revised 2.68% gain in November. Ex-commercial aircraft, orders rose for the month by 0.39%, following a revised 3.75% decline in December, and rose by a revised 1.15% in November. Real year-to-year aggregate orders rose by 3.32% in January, following a revised 1.86% decline in December, versus a revised 9.07% gain in November, and, ex-commercial aircraft, they rose by 1.17% in January, following a revised 3.16% decline in December, and a revised gain of 5.64% gain in November. Graphs of Inflation-Adjusted and Smoothed Durable Goods Orders. As usually shown and discussed in the Commentaries covering new orders for durable goods, the following two graphs plot the new orders for durable goods, adjusted for inflation. These graphs show monthly as well as a six-month moving average of the activity level. The first graph shows the aggregate new orders series. The second series is net of the unstable commercial-aircraft order sector, and, accordingly, it is somewhat smoother than the first graph. In terms of inflation-adjusted activity, both of these series have shown a slowing uptrend and flatteningout in the last two-to-three years with a dip and upside bouncing into 2013, and renewed downturn in recent reporting. Broadly, there has been a recent general pattern of stagnation or bottom-bouncing evident in the orders clearly not the booming recovery that is seen in official GDP reporting. The real (inflation-adjusted) level of orders in January 2014 remained at or below both the pre-2001 and pre-2007 recession highs. The pattern of recent stagnation in the inflation-adjusted series also is one that commonly precedes or is coincident with a recession. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 3

Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 4

New-Home Sales January 2014 Continued Unstable Monthly Reporting. Neither the headline 9.6% monthly gain nor the 2.2% annual gain in January new-home sales was close to being statisticallysignificant. Separately, where the popular press put out headlines of January home sales at a 5-1/2 Year High, the January 2014 headline number was not meaningfully different from the level of January 2013, and it still was down 65.0% from the pre-recession peak activity, seen in June 2005. The statistically-insignificant 9.6% headline gain in January 2014 was in the context of an unusual reshuffling of fourth-quarter activity. While December 2013 new-home sales revised higher, November and October activity revised lower. As a result, the fourth-quarter activity, in aggregate, virtually was unchanged on both a seasonally-adjusted and unadjusted basis. The best that can be said for these numbers is that they remain highly unstable. As discussed later in these Opening Comments, there has been no underlying improvement in fundamental consumer liquidity conditions, and most underlying economic numbers are showing a renewed economic downturn. There is no basis here for an imminent recovery in the housing market. January New-Home Sales Reflected a Return to Normal Instability. Headline new-home sales (counted based on contract signings) rose by a statistically-insignificant 9.6%, following a revised 3.8% decline in December, and a revised 1.7% decline in November. Before prior-period revisions, January sales rose by a still-statistically-insignificant 13.0% for the month. Year-to-year, January 2014 sales rose by a statistically-insignificant 2.2%, following a revised 7.8% annual gain in December, and an unrevised year-to-year increase of 11.8% in November. Again, the numbers here are unstable and not reliable. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 5

New-Home Sales Graph. The regular monthly graph of new-home sales activity is the first of the two graphs preceding, along with the second graph of January single- and multiple-unit housing starts (from Commentary No. 601) and a third graph of existing-home sales follows, for comparison purposes. Existing-Home Sales January 2014) Dropped 5.1% Both on a Monthly and Annual Basis. In the context of annual revisions to seasonal adjustments back through 2011, which shifted seasonally-adjusted growth from the second-half to the first-half of each year, the new seasonal-factors likely gave January 2014 sales more of boost than would have been seen otherwise with the prior seasonals. Nonetheless, headline January 2014 sales fell by 5.1% from December 2013, as well as by 5.1% from January 2013, to a 1-1/2 year low. Where these sales reflected actual closings on homes, and where the pattern of decline was seen across all regions, the sharp downturn likely reflected minimal impact from the unseasonably-bad weather in some areas. The year-to-year decline in January 2014 sales was the third such decline in a row. The level of January 2014 existing-home sales was 36.5% below the June 2005, pre-recession peak in the series. Again, as discussed in the next section, there has been no underlying improvement in consumer liquidity conditions, and most economic fundamentals are showing a renewed economic downturn. There is no economic basis here for an imminent recovery in the housing market. Headline Reporting. Existing-home sales (counted based on actual closings), showed a seasonallyadjusted 5.1% month-to-month drop, versus an unrevised 1.0% gain in December, and a revised 5.8% Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 6

headline monthly decline in November. On a year-to-year basis, January 2014 annual sales declined by 5.1%, versus a revised 0.2% decline in December and a revised 2.6% decline in November. The issuing National Association of Realtors (NAR) estimated the portion of total sales in distressed properties rose to 15% (11% foreclosures, 4% short sales) in January 2014, versus 14% (10% foreclosures, 4% short sales) in December 2013. Reflecting ongoing lending problems, related banking-industry and consumer solvency issues, and the continuing influx of speculative investment money into the existing housing market, the NAR also estimated that all-cash sales in January 2014 rose to 33%, up from 32% in December 2013, and from 28% in January 2013. Existing-Home Sales Graph. Smoothed for irregular distortions, the series has remained statistically consistent with a period of broad stagnation, turning into a faltering downtrend, as suggested by the following graph. Included for comparison purposes are January new-home sales activity and single- and multiple-unit housing starts (from Commentary No. 601) in the two graphs preceding. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 7

Underlying Liquidity Fundamentals Continue to Show No Relief for the Housing Market. The problem for the housing market, along with much of the broad economy, ties directly to the severe, structural liquidity problems impairing consumer spending and consumption. There have been no developments in underlying economic fundamentals, consumer conditions or otherwise, that would suggest a pending housing-industry turnaround or a rebound in broad business activity. Underlying reality favors a renewed downturn in general economic activity, as increasingly shown in the retail sales and housing series. Reemphasizing points in Commentary No. 599 on these liquidity issues are the three graphs that follow. The first graph is a repeated from the referenced Commentary, reflecting real (inflation-adjusted) median household income as of December 2013, as published by www.sentierresearch.com, based on monthly surveying by the Census Bureau. Median income has continued to hold near the cycle trough of the series. As the broad economy purportedly rebounded from June 2009, household income instead plunged into 2011, and it generally has been stagnant at a low level of activity, ever since. Along with the updated consumer confidence and sentiment, seen in the second and third graphs, household income has shown a broad pattern of plunge-and-stagnation in the current economic crisis, as opposed to the GDP s purported pattern of plunge, recovery and expansion. Those issues will be reviewed in tomorrow s Commentary No. 604 of February 28th, following the release of the second estimate of fourth-quarter 2013 GDP (see the Week Ahead section). Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 8

Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 9

The Conference Board s February 2014 reading of consumer confidence showed a small, monthly decline and prior-period downward revision, with the level of confidence remaining deep in historical recession territory, as also seen in the early-february estimate of consumer sentiment, well shy of levels perhaps 60% higher that tend to signal the type of booming economic recovery currently reported in the GDP, let alone any economic recovery at all. [For greater detail on January 2014 new orders for durable goods and existing- and new-home sales, see the Reporting Detail section.] HYPERINFLATION WATCH Hyperinflation Outlook. With the First Installment of Hyperinflation 2014 The End Game Begins published on January 7th, a new Hyperinflation Summary for this section will be added in conjunction with the publication of the Second Installment. The second and final installment will cover historical and prospective economic activity, as well as possible protective and preventative actions and reactions at both a personal and federal level, versus the unfolding circumstance. It will be published shortly, including the analysis of the much-delayed publication of the 2013 GAAP-based financial statements of the United States government, which are due for release later today (February 27th). The new material in the Second Installment will supplement and update the basic material already available to ShadowStats readers in Chapters 4, 5 and 9 of Hyperinflation 2012. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 10

REPORTING DETAIL NEW ORDERS FOR DURABLE GOODS (January 2014) Decline in January Durable Goods Orders Was in Context of December Downside Revision. The headline 0.97% decline in January 2014 durable goods orders was more than accounted for by a decline in the extremely volatile orders for commercial aircraft. The headline January reporting, however, was in the context of a good-sized downward revision to December s new orders, with the result that January orders were down by 6.25% for the two months from November. Of that decline, 3.07% still was net of declining commercial aircraft orders, which usually dominate the aggregate durable goods growth numbers. Accordingly the two-month drop in durable goods orders tended to be based broadly across the economy. Aggregate January reporting and revisions not only reflected some corrective pullback in orders, but also some corrective downside revisions to the reporting of prior activity. Accordingly, the ongoing longerterm pattern of stagnation has remained in place for the series particularly when viewed net of inflation despite any short-term blips, and a recent slight uptrend in the pattern of stagnation now may have turned to a downtrend. The growth patterns in this series remain of a nature that commonly precedes or coincides with a recession or deepening business downturn. Nominal (Not-Adjusted-for-Inflation) January 2014 Reporting. The Census Bureau reported today, February 27th, that the regularly-volatile, seasonally-adjusted nominal level of January 2014 new orders for durable goods fell by 0.97% for the month, following a revised 5.34% decline (previously down by 4.30%) in December, and a revised November gain of 2.75% (previously 2.60%, initially 3.50%). Before the prior-period revisions, total new orders in January fell by 1.89%. The reporting of contractions and surges in commercial aircraft orders is seen in an irregularly-repeating process throughout the year and often dominate headline durable goods orders. These extremely volatile aircraft orders are booked well into the future and are indicative more of longer-term, rather than shorterterm prospects for manufacturing activity. In January, nondefense (or commercial) aircraft orders fell by 20.20% month-to-month, versus a revised 22.32% (previously 17.51%) decline in December, and an unrevised 21.08% (initially 21.76%) gain in November. Net of prior-period revisions, January commercial-aircraft orders fell by 24.88%. Net of the aircraft numbers, total new orders rose by 0.59% in January, versus a revised decline of 3.63% (previously 2.98%) in December, and a revised 1.21% (previously 1.05%, initially 1.97%) gain in November. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 11

What these numbers show over the last eight months or so is no meaningful change (down by 2.47%) effectively stagnation in new orders for durable goods, net of commercial-aircraft order activity and before any consideration for the effects of inflation. The eight-month change is down by 3.14% net of PPI-related inflation. Aircraft-order volatility also has impacted year-to-year change in seasonally-adjusted, total new orders. Total orders in January 2014 were up by 4.61% year-to-year, up by 1.17% ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised aggregate annual decline of 0.84% (previously a gain of 0.10%) in December 2013, down by a revised 3.16% (previously 1.65%) ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised November aggregate annual gain of 10.14% (previously 9.98%, initially 10.90%), up by a revised 5.64% (previously 6.50%, initially 7.42%) ex-commercial aircraft. Further affected by aircraft-order activity were the seasonally-adjusted new orders for nondefense capital goods, which fell by 3.89% month-to-month in January 2014, were up by 0.41% ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised aggregate decline of 6.52% (previously 4.97%) in December, down by a revised 1.22% (previously 0.75%) ex-commercial aircraft; versus a revised 8.24% (previously 7.84%, initially 9.38%) gain in November, up by a revised 4.52% (previously 4.01%, initially 5.79%) ex-commercial aircraft. Caution: Current durable goods reporting remains subject to many of the same sampling and concurrentseasonal-adjustment problems that are seen with retail sales, payroll and unemployment reporting. Unusual seasonal-factor volatility raises issues as to the significance of reported seasonally-adjusted monthly and annual changes. While those issues are brought into balance, temporarily, with an annual benchmark revision to durable goods orders (usually in May), subsequent reporting makes all historical reporting prior to November 2013 inconsistent with the current headline numbers. Real (Inflation-Adjusted) Durable Goods Orders January 2014. ShadowStats still is in the process of developing a new inflation measure for deflating the PPI. With the complete revamping of the PPI series this month (see Commentary No. 601 and Commentary No. 591), the previously-used PPI finished goods, capital equipment measure disappeared. The closest new measure appears to be final goods machinery and equipment, and it was used here to estimate the relevant January inflation, reflecting a seasonallyadjusted 0.2% monthly inflation rate for the January, an annual inflation rate of 1.2%. A new inflation series should be in place for the next durable goods reporting. Adjusted for that inflation, and as reflected in the graphs of the Opening Comments section, real monthto-month aggregate orders fell by 1.16% in January, versus a revised decline of 5.45% (previously 4.42%) in December, versus a revised 2.68% (previously 2.54%, initially 3.44%) gain in November. Excommercial aircraft, orders rose for the month by 0.39%, following a revised 3.75% (previously 3.10%) decline in December, and rose by a revised 1.15% (previously 0.99%, initially 1.91%) in November. Real year-to-year aggregate orders rose by 3.32% in January, following a revised 1.86% (previously 0.93%) decline in December, versus a revised 9.07% (previously 8.91%, initially 9.83%) gain in November, and, ex-commercial aircraft, they rose by 1.17% in January, following a revised 3.16% (previously by 2.66%) decline in December, and a revised gain of 5.64% (previously 5.47%) gain in November. Graphs of Inflation-Adjusted and Smoothed Durable Goods Orders. The usual two inflation-adjusted graphs are found in the Opening Comments section. Those graphs show the monthly as well as a sixmonth moving-average activity for both the aggregate new orders series and the series net of the unstable Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 12

commercial-aircraft order sector. The moving-average levels in both series have been holding in a pattern of near-stagnation, with some recent upside trend having turned to the downside, recently. Real levels of the January 2014 orders remained at or below both the pre-2001 and pre-2007 recession highs. The pattern of recent stagnation in the inflation-adjusted series also is one that commonly precedes or is coincident with a recession. NEW-HOME SALES (January 2014). Continued Unstable Monthly Reporting. The statistically-insignificant 9.6% headline gain in January 2014 was in the context of an unusual reshuffling of fourth-quarter activity. While December 2013 newhome sales revised higher, November and October activity revised lower. As a result, the fourth-quarter activity, in aggregate, virtually was unchanged on both a seasonally-adjusted and unadjusted basis. The best than can be said for these numbers is that they remain highly unstable. Neither the headline 9.6% monthly gain nor the 2.2% annual gain was close to being statisticallysignificant. Separately, where the popular press put out headlines of January home sales at a 5-1/2 year high, that headline number was not meaningfully different from the level of January 2013, and it still was down 65.0% from the pre-recession peak activity, seen in June 2005. As discussed in the Opening Comments, there has been no underlying improvement in fundamental consumer liquidity conditions, and most underlying economic numbers are showing a renewed economic downturn. There is no basis here for an imminent recovery in the housing market. January New-Home Sales Reflected a Return to Normal Instability. As reported yesterday (February 26th) by the Census Bureau, January 2014 headline new-home sales (counted based on contract signings) rose by a statistically-insignificant 9.6% +/- 20.9% (all confidence intervals are at the 95% level), following a revised 3.8% (previously 7.0%) decline in December, and a revised 1.7% (previously 3.9%, initially 2.1%) decline in November. Before prior-period revisions, January sales rose by a stillstatistically-insignificant 13.0% for the month. Year-to-year, January 2014 sales rose by a statistically-insignificant 2.2% +/- 23.6%; following a revised 7.8% (previously 4.5%) annual gain in December, and an unrevised year-to-year increase of 11.8% (initially 16.6%) in November. Again, the numbers here are unstable and not reliable. New-Home Sales Graph. The regular monthly graph of new-home sales activity is included in the Opening Comments section, along with graphs of the latest existing-home sales and housing starts. Even with the recent unstable numbers, new-home sales activity appears to be stagnant, at best. EXISTING-HOME SALES (January 2014) January 2014 Existing-Home Sales Dropped 5.1% on Both a Monthly and Annual Basis. In the context of annual revisions to seasonal adjustments back through 2011, which shifted seasonally-adjusted Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 13

growth from the second-half to the first-half of each year, the new seasonal-factors likely gave January 2014 sales more of boost than would have been seen with the prior seasonals. Nonetheless, headline January 2014 sales fell by 5.1% from December 2013, as well as by 5.1% from January 2013, to a 1-1/2 year low. Where these sales reflect actual closings on homes, and where the pattern of decline was seen across all regions, the sharp downturn likely reflected minimal impact from the unseasonably-bad weather in some areas. The year-to-year decline in January 2014 sales was the third such decline in a row. The level of January 2014 existing-home sales was 36.5% below the June 2005, pre-recession peak in the series. Again, as discussed in the Opening Comments, there has been no underlying improvement in consumer liquidity conditions, and most economic fundamentals are showing a renewed economic downturn. There is no economic basis here for an imminent recovery in the housing market. Headline Reporting. The February 21st release of January 2014 existing-home sales (counted based on actual closings, National Association of Realtors [NAR]) showed a seasonally-adjusted 5.1% month-tomonth drop, versus an unrevised 1.0% gain in December, and a revised 5.8% (previously 5.9%, initially 4.3%) headline monthly decline in November. On a year-to-year basis, January 2014 annual sales declined by 5.1%, versus a revised 0.2% (previously 0.6%) decline in December and a revised 2.6% (previously 2.8%, initially 1.2%) decline in November. Smoothed for irregular distortions, the series remained statistically consistent with a period of broad stagnation, turning into a faltering downtrend, as suggested by the graph in the Opening Comments section. Again, the data quality remains questionable. The NAR estimated the portion of total sales in distressed properties rose to 15% (11% foreclosures, 4% short sales) in January 2014, versus 14% (10% foreclosures, 4% short sales) in December 2013. Reflecting ongoing lending problems, related banking-industry and consumer solvency issues, and the continuing influx of speculative investment money into the existing housing market, the NAR also estimated that all-cash sales in January 2014 rose to 33%, up from 32% in December 2013, and from 28% in January 2013. Existing-Home Sales Graph. The regular monthly graph of existing-home sales activity is included in the Opening Comments section, along with graphs of the latest new-home sales and housing starts. Existing home sales appear to be in a downtrend. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 14

WEEK AHEAD Much Weaker-Economic and Stronger-Inflation Reporting Likely in the Months and Year Ahead. Although shifting to the downside, market expectations generally still appear to be overly optimistic as to the economic outlook, based on data that likely were puffed-up in the process of going through the datagathering and reporting distortions of the October shutdown to the federal government, in addition to the regular seasonal-adjustment issues. Expectations should continue to soften, though, with an increasing number of corrective revisions and disappointing headline economic activity. The initial stages of that process have been seen in the recent reporting of December and January payroll, retail sales, housing and industrial production data, and in the December trade-balance detail. That corrective circumstance and underlying weak economic fundamentals remain highly suggestive of deteriorating business activity. Accordingly, weaker-than-consensus economic reporting should become the general trend until such time as an unfolding new recession receives general recognition. Stronger inflation reporting remains likely. Upside pressure on oil-related prices should reflect intensifying impact from a weakening U.S. dollar in the currency markets, and from ongoing political instabilities in the Middle East. The dollar faces pummeling from continuing QE3, the ongoing U.S. fiscal-crisis debacle, a weakening U.S. economy and deteriorating U.S. political conditions (see Hyperinflation 2014 The End Game Begins). Particularly in tandem with a weakened dollar, reporting in the year ahead generally should reflect much higher-than-expected inflation. A Note on Reporting-Quality Issues and Systemic Reporting Biases. Significant reporting-quality problems remain with most major economic series. Ongoing headline reporting issues are tied largely to systemic distortions of seasonal adjustments. The data instabilities were induced by the still-evolving economic turmoil of the last seven-to-eight years, which has been without precedent in the post-world War II era of modern economic reporting. These impaired reporting methodologies provide particularly unstable headline economic results, where concurrent seasonal adjustments are used (as with retail sales, durable goods orders, employment and unemployment data), and they have thrown into question the statistical-significance of the headline month-to-month reporting for many popular economic series. PENDING RELEASES: Gross Domestic Product GDP (Fourth-Quarter 2014, Second Estimate, First Revision). The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) will publish the second estimate of fourth-quarter 2013 GDP tomorrow, Friday, February 28th. Market expectations appear to be for a downside revision to the initial 3.2% headline estimate, by an order of magnitude somewhat shy of a full-percentage point. The official aggregate data still will lack enough meaning, though, for the first estimates of gross domestic product (GDP) and gross national product (GNP) to be published. The year-end and annual versions of those numbers usually are released with the third estimate of GDP. Underlying reality would tend to favor an even greater downside revision, disappointing the already negative market expectations. The most recent reporting of the trade deficit, retail sales, industrial Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 15

production and housing all suggest a significant downside adjustment to this heavily-overstated, annualized quarterly growth rate. Copyright 2014 American Business Analytics & Research, LLC, www.shadowstats.com 16